Yes. They shoulda traded him if they weren’t gon pay him. Personally I think you keep talented young players especially when they are your entire offense. He was our best player I woulda paid him tagged Jones and moved on. Saquon woulda made a great weapon for a young QB
Giants offerd Saquan 3 contracts. He rejected all of them. The last one would have paid him just short of McCaffery but with some other perks. He didn't want to be a Giant. He grew up in PA near Philly, went to Penn St. He's playing at his home stadium with a much better franchise.
We all saw what happened. The Eagles offered him a deal, the agent called the Giants owner and gave them a chance to match. And the GM said "we're out". And just because someone offers you a contract, doesn't mean it's a good one. Obviously it wasn't good enough according to him and his agent. So cut the sht.
It's going to define Joe Schoen's legacy as the one who let our super star get away. I told my son, Saquon might challenge the rushing record behind that O-line.
I am happy for Barkley, because he would have never experienced the success with the Giants that he has with the Eagles. THE is a talented Running back, but he was never the type of running back, best suited for the poor Giant Roster. The Giants needed a generation power running back, able to run over lineman and linebackers, more or a north-south runner, that is not Barkley. Watching some of the Barkley high-light runs with the Eagles, running through huge gaping holes, I cannot remember him benefiting from that kind of blocking and space as a Giant.
The roster is better but the other teams got better as well so the results I’m seeing are expected. I want us to get the number one pick in the draft at this point!
If you are building inside out, Giants did the right thing by not giving Barkley the contract - need to focus on the OL. Should have traded Saquon. He wasn't going to put them into SB contention by himself.
If they got Baker as QB, 2 very good Olinemen, and kept Saquon, they would've had enough money to get a good CB as well, and they would've been in good shape.
lol at 3:00. Im sure the 8-2 and 7-3 teams are seeking out such stellar teams like the Giants’ and Jets’ fanbase/media for their thoughts on how to win games.
Of course they did but they wanted to keep the good ole boy Wish app Eli Manning. They paid him a ton for that record 😂😂😂. Giants got exactly what they deserved.
Did the Giants make a mistake? everybody already knows the answer to that question management and ownership Daniel Jones over Saquon Barkley enough said
No the giant didn’t make a mistake. They don’t have a offensive line and they don’t have a QB that can throw the ball saqoun wouldn’t have that good of a season and the Giants found a starting running back in the 7th round so it’s a win for both teams
No its not! Barkley is one of the best players in the NFL! A team leader! Your best player on offense last year! You just can't let him walk to a division rival
@@pariswilson6365 Yeah the Giants been losing so much over the years! Winning is not the objective anymore! There victories are now just not being blown out! While they wait for the next Peyton Manning or Lamar Jackson to fall in there lap!!!
Of course, we would not be putting up the numbers BUT he takes pressure off Jones they are better than they are & then you get a young player to pair with Saquon. He doesn't just run but catches the ball well. No freaking brainer to keep him.
@@richardcranium5801 Yes!! But respectful you miss the bigger picture. Get rid of Jones and have Saquon help be the foundation of the re-build. Experience, talent & leadership matters
If the Eagles win the Superbowl because we gave our best player to our arch enemy, Schoen needs to be fired
We didn’t give him to anyway. He went there on his own.
@@blazinrounds230WRONG. The Giants didn't want him.
@@thespy7795 sounds like you don’t know what you’re talking about.
Schoen should be fired now.
@ no. He shouldn’t.
Yes. They shoulda traded him if they weren’t gon pay him. Personally I think you keep talented young players especially when they are your entire offense. He was our best player I woulda paid him tagged Jones and moved on. Saquon woulda made a great weapon for a young QB
Giants offerd Saquan 3 contracts. He rejected all of them. The last one would have paid him just short of McCaffery but with some other perks. He didn't want to be a Giant.
He grew up in PA near Philly, went to Penn St. He's playing at his home stadium with a much better franchise.
You use the term "just short" like my wife when she tells me she's left "plenty" of fuel in the tank.
@@deaddropholidayit was the same exact overall money with a million less in guaranteed money.
Finally someone who knows what they’re fucking talking about.
Well the Giants is trash 😂😂😂
We all saw what happened. The Eagles offered him a deal, the agent called the Giants owner and gave them a chance to match. And the GM said "we're out".
And just because someone offers you a contract, doesn't mean it's a good one. Obviously it wasn't good enough according to him and his agent.
So cut the sht.
How come the titans don’t get blame for giving up King Henry
Bc they're not in NY
No one cares about titans, they are usually crap every season.
A mistake of what? He wouldn’t be great as he is in Philly. Come on man. Philly has a good OL.
He was the best player on the Giants by far. What are you talking about??
The mistake was signing jones long term and franchise tagging qoun
@@sojumedicyall don’t blame the titans for letting Henry go
It’s not that they let him go it’s that they paid the qb how much? That’s the true crime.
Giants did absolutely the right thing in believing that Daniel Jones was the best player on the team. ... HAHAHAHAHA!!
Yes ,the Giants made a huge mistake. Paying Jones and not Barkley is mind-blowing.
I don't agree. The Giants were better off not paying Barkely.
The real crime, is that in SIX YEARS, the giants couldn’t put a good enough offensive line/team around him to justify keeping him.
Giants have looked bad for about a decade or so now 😂
The NFL In New York City is the armpit of football
Laughable disgrace. Playoffs in 2023 and then It all goes to the dumpster
It's going to define Joe Schoen's legacy as the one who let our super star get away. I told my son, Saquon might challenge the rushing record behind that O-line.
This is what happens when a GM fails to resign their playmakers on their team. The team becomes bad and sloppy.
GM Joe Schoen made this "Mess"!
But the other gm picked him in the draft.
schoen needs to be fired anyways
I am happy for Barkley, because he would have never experienced the success with the Giants that he has with the Eagles. THE is a talented Running back, but he was never the type of running back, best suited for the poor Giant Roster. The Giants needed a generation power running back, able to run over lineman and linebackers, more or a north-south runner, that is not Barkley. Watching some of the Barkley high-light runs with the Eagles, running through huge gaping holes, I cannot remember him benefiting from that kind of blocking and space as a Giant.
Yes the Giants made a mistake. This team has been mis-managed for years.
Started with firing Mcadoo, all went into the dumpster since, with one fluke playoff appearance.
The roster is better but the other teams got better as well so the results I’m seeing are expected. I want us to get the number one pick in the draft at this point!
That’s good I think they are no1 pick right now
If you are building inside out, Giants did the right thing by not giving Barkley the contract - need to focus on the OL. Should have traded Saquon. He wasn't going to put them into SB contention by himself.
If they got Baker as QB, 2 very good Olinemen, and kept Saquon, they would've had enough money to get a good CB as well, and they would've been in good shape.
Nope. Got them better o-linemen and Brian Burns. They also found Tyrone Tracy. I don’t think about Saquon at all.
Nobody wanted to tackle this game?
Did these dudes turn the game on in the 4th quarter or something?
They had him for years and they sucked
I hope Saquan run 250 yards next game against the Gaints i never bets but I will bet Saquan runs over 200 yards on the sorry Gaints
When you draft like trash. You don't deserve Saquan Barkley.
lol at 3:00. Im sure the 8-2 and 7-3 teams are seeking out such stellar teams like the Giants’ and Jets’ fanbase/media for their thoughts on how to win games.
Mara will never pay a black quarterback or a black running back because Mara is prejudice
GM Joe Schoen has "screwed" the NY Giants by not giving Saquon Barkley a franchise contract and ends up with the Philadelphia Eagles.
Is that GM still with the Giants? Or are they waiting for the season to end?
Washington aint all that barely beat a sorry new York Gaints team
Of course they did but they wanted to keep the good ole boy Wish app Eli Manning. They paid him a ton for that record 😂😂😂. Giants got exactly what they deserved.
Did the Giants make a mistake? everybody already knows the answer to that question management and ownership Daniel Jones over Saquon Barkley enough said
he has a better team around him then with the Giants.
No the giant didn’t make a mistake. They don’t have a offensive line and they don’t have a QB that can throw the ball saqoun wouldn’t have that good of a season and the Giants found a starting running back in the 7th round so it’s a win for both teams
No its not! Barkley is one of the best players in the NFL! A team leader! Your best player on offense last year! You just can't let him walk to a division rival
@@kale2149he's just another fan trying to convince himself the giants did the right thing 😂😂😂
@@pariswilson6365 Yeah the Giants been losing so much over the years! Winning is not the objective anymore! There victories are now just not being blown out! While they wait for the next Peyton Manning or Lamar Jackson to fall in there lap!!!
Is the title of this video meant to be rhetorical?
THE GIANTS PAID THE WRONG GUY! WE ALL KNEW IT 😁😁😁😁😁😁 😁😁😁
The Giants run game is not the issue!
Fumbles from running backs have been back breakers
Look it’s not mistake it was right business decision
Was it also a good decision! To let Xavier go as well! And then turn around and sign burns to a massive contract?
HLL Yeah we made a mistake. You’re hardheaded if you can’t admit it.
@JayHughes-d1s he would not be putting up the numbers he’s putting up in Philly with the giants. Philly’s OL is light years ahead of the giants OL.
Of course, we would not be putting up the numbers BUT he takes pressure off Jones they are better than they are & then you get a young player to pair with Saquon. He doesn't just run but catches the ball well. No freaking brainer to keep him.
They stunk with him and the stink without him. Was resigning Saquon magically gonna give Jones the ability to spot open receivers? 🙄
@@richardcranium5801 Yes!! But respectful you miss the bigger picture. Get rid of Jones and have Saquon help be the foundation of the re-build. Experience, talent & leadership matters
Isn't that joe Schoen fault our roster isn't that good????
Mara reap what u sow
The Redkins haven't beaten a good team yet...very overrated.
One Giant mistake.