They could have dived into the strategic mind of Sir Manekshaw and his conflicts with the PM. Sir Manekshaw was more than the clever replies that he gave.
People will always find something to criticise. If it was all strategic planning... then people would be like where is the war.... where is the war....
Screenplay doesn't show the real antagonist of that time i.e. Congress govt. If Sam Manikshaw was alive he wouldn't have liked the film. Meghna Gulzar is good at sugarcoating, earlier Pakistan with Raazi and now Congress with Sam Bahadur.
Yes, you're right, this movie shouldn't have been clashed with overhyped Animal. I still remember the clash between SRK's Raees and Hrithik's Kaabil where a good film like Kaabil was unfortunately undermined due to overhype of Raees at that time. 😏
Animal ain't overhyped by any means...just accept the fact that both r great films...if we r talking about an overhyped film then it is none other than Pathan which was only bearable due to SRK
@@menaceyt-ud8hoif you have seen good Hollywood and South Indian action movies then it would be really hard to appreciate movies like pathaan, jawan, bla bla...And Its A Fact !
Aisa kuch bhi nhi h ott is niche platform aur achi movie hamesa se ban rahi h jese ki satya,salam bombey but aise movie ko pahle art house movie bola jata tha aur Indian cinema action,scfi,horror movie m bhut piche h
@@tmj8623 ahinsawadi party hai ya nahi? Lage raho Munna Bhai was a lie? Jyada se jyada protest hote aur usaka benefit ho jata movie ko Aur kya series of events ho jate.. They should have shown a biopic as it is
kuch nahi hota. aajkal no1 cares much about congress. its cause meghna gulzar is a sickular/woke director. thats it. even in raazi she painted indian army in negative light.@@tmj8623
I eagerly anticipate your review Shan Tomorrow, I'll be watching this film with my family. Let's refrain from comparing "Animal" and "Sam Bahadur" - they're distinctly unique movies. Instead of pitting them against each other, let's appreciate the rarity of witnessing quality Bollywood films. Vicky Kaushal has long been acknowledged as a talented actor, but his portrayal in "Sardar Udham" elevated my respect for him. His chameleon-like ability in roles like these is commendable. Just as Ranbir Kapoor carried an entire movie, despite other commendable performances, people will undoubtedly praise Vicky for his portrayal of Sam Maneckshaw. Cheers to the joy of experiencing such cinematic brilliance after a considerable time! 🔥
Sam Bahadur was slated to release on 1 December since the very beginning. It was Animal that was postponed to clash with Sam Bahadur. Animal was originally slated to release on 11 August but was postponed so as to not clash with Gadar 2.
They should have released it next year, maybe on January 15th ie apparently Army Day as well. But idk what urge was there to release it with Animal. 🤦🏻♂️
Animal vs Sam Bahadur- I’ll watch Sam Bahadur. I personally prefer movies based on real life characters and the best way to honour his memory is to spend my hard earned cash on watching his story be inspired by his values, morals and valour. Again only my opinion🙏
It felt like meghna Gulzar sir manekshaw ke kisse sunaa rahi hai. Ek kissa khatam hota toh scene abruptly end ho jaata. There was no particular flow to the story. War mai kabhi elevate kiya nahi ki why is the war important, what is at stake. Toh woh jeetne ki urgency feel ho nahi hui. This movie felt like sir manekshaw had a very smooth life which was not the case at all. Kudos to Vicky kaushal and costume and set designers. They nailed their jobs
इसे कहते हैं बहती गंगा मे हात धोना । राष्ट्रभक्ती वाली मूवी बनावो पर आधे मन से और मूल विषय को विकृत करो अथवा व्हाइट वॉश करो। और भी हात धोने वाले है अक्षय कुमार, कंगना...
@mukulsingh3083 i completely agree with your assessment. There was no coherent flow to the narrative. Wasted opportunity for such a potentially great story.
Excellent review and you have made an excellent point about trying to release this movie along with Animal. It boggles the mind who in the industry thought it does not matter in releasing this movie with Animal.
Shan bhai i loved your reviews. I love your Animal review. If such movies are made by Quentin Torentino or Holywood directors, Critics would have praised it left and right.
This movie is made from congress version and it didn't show everything about great Sam Manekshaw. He didn't like political involvement in Army and it hurt Indira Gandhi a lot and because of it congress took revenge by not paying his salary and pension for 30 years which is not shown in movie. After 30 years president Abdul Kalam give him check of 1.25 crores(which was not given to him when he need it more) but in 2008 he passed away. This movie had not shown how congress treat him in reality but given clean chit to congress.
I watched the movie today only, honestly I liked the movie but I had higher expectations, in one word if I have to describe Vicky Kaushal I will say us bande ne jiya hai yeh character play nhi kiya he is fantabulous ,, being from army fraternity myself , I could relate to each n every details, be it the ranks, places , army terminology and protocols everything was well taken care of.. they did a lot of home work.. in fact we met Vicky Kaushal too when he came to our unit.. this film just refreshen our memories of the places where we were posted , through this movie, but movie mein fir bhi bahut kamiyan hain, it lacks in emotions, realism, connection of audience with the film, it lacks in impact which a movie like this could do.. for eg Milkha singh, Uri, border , you can watch 100 times but I must say this movie is just one time watch , bas dekho aur khatam, that’s it.. usse zyada umeed mat rakho isse, achi hai but aur achi ho sakti Thi if they had gone into more details … 3/5 stars
I watched Sam Bahadur today and the movie is Okay as a film. I personally do not think that it has not performed very well only due to the release of Animal. The best thing is Vicky Kaushal's acting. I went to watch expecting it to be a spectacular movie about Sam sir. War movies are very popular in India. However, Sam Bahadur lacked on following points: 1. The movie needed a voiceover narration. It would have been best if they would have used the old radio broadcast style voiceover. As the movie seemed to be made for people like me, who already know about the history of india and Sam Sir. People around me even had no idea about who Sam bahadur was. Hence, it was necessary to establish through narration in the beginning who he was. 2. The movie is very linear. It should have started from the east pakistan liberation preparation scenes and then the backstory should have been unfolded. 3. It was unable to make full use many points. Ex: it could have shown the rise of Sam in India and rise of his friend Yahia in Pakistan, the pain and betrayal east pakistan's general Niyazi felt when he had to surrender on the command of his higher officials in Pakistan, the pain army wives and families feel when their spouses/parents are on the front lines. Also the lack of equipment in the army and the difficulties due to it etc. All these were not fully established and utilised. It is necessary to build the story of the supporting characters to build a spectacular movie. 4. To make a movie that will do good at the box office you have to do some exaggeration and dramatisation. They showed how the army fights actually are (which are painful but not dramatic) rather they should have made them a bit more intense. 5. For the liberation of Bangladesh they should have shot the scenes rather than using only real footage of that time. As an army kid and someone who really respects Sam sir I was left unsatisfied.
Sana Fatima is definitely a miscast, She makes Indira look like a child PM. And about the comparison, i love movies like Sam Bahadur, but when i think of my budget prefer to spend it on movies like Animal and enjoy Sam Bahadur at home in OTT platform.
Honestly when you make a biopic on a true patriot of our country,it should cover his entire life,not just end half way... what was done with field marshal in later days by a particular political party by stopping his full military pension..no government officials attending his funeral should also be shown.. otherwise it doesn't portray a good picture..
Nothing to watch except Vicky Kaushal. I knew most of the facts about Sam. They just made a film on it. More of a documentary than a movie. No screenplay nothing.
Don’t u guys research even a bit. Meghna Gulzar has directed Raati, Talvar and Chapaak. It’s not her debut. There might be issues in the movie but plz do some research before speaking as many people see your videos and will then believe this info
This isn't Meghna Gulzar's directorial debut film. She has directed Raazi, Chhapak, Talwar and a couple of more. Thodi reserch director par bhi kar liya karo yaar.
This is not her directorial debut she have been directing since 2002 Filhaal movie and after that almost 5 films are directed … The most recent was Chaapak
Haven't seen SamBahadur, but Animal was such a bad movie.. had high hopes that finally bollywood will come over nonsensical movies like Pathan, Jawan, Gadar 2, but this one created new bad.. 3 hours 20 mins of torture.. pathetic especially 2nd half
Its unfortunate that this movie whitewash all the iltreatment of Field Marshall Sam Manekshaw. Did she show how Sam was not given his pension? So what's the point of making movie which doesn't make justice with his sacrifice ? 😑😑
Dono hi movies bohot different hai.. Mai Animal islea nahi dekh rahi.. kyuki muje already anger issues hai.. ise dekh k trigger ho jaaungi or 🤣🤣 baaki Movie is great.. Sam Bahadur is also very good movie... I would say... watch both.
Calling a Defense Personnel without his rank is considered as an insult for him and his rank. So address him as Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw not Manekshaw Saheb. It's a request to you Sir Peace out
Shan bhai....I was a bit disappointed by your animal review....It was like seeing as if an MLM guy (The filmmaker) has influenced a poor fellow.....There were problematic narratives around the film.....I though maybe you'll call it out...but unfortunately you too got influenced.....this shows the extent to which filmmaker has been successful in doing what he wanted.........There is nothing wrong about showing problematic, psychologically ill...or even misogynistic characters....but putting such characters in such a screenplay where the filmmakers makes us root, cheer and sympathize with the broken yet strong character...then it is a problem...a big problem.......There is no issue with showing violence....i enjoy the rawness and the gory too...with films like KILL, John wick, Scarface...but this one had made me truly believe the lack of sensibilities amount the youth....(believe me i am not being a narcissist)
so you can stand to watch men blown to bits but can't handle a woman being slapped in a movie, which is tame compared to whole mutilation of men. what the fuck is this selective outrage. it's a movie, everything about action movies are problematic if you view like this. If you can see men killing each other in raid and john wick they why are you seething seeing such tame scenes in movie. No man is gonna get influenced to hit his wife by seeing this movie.
Ranbir should have been killed at last not hero or protoganist should have been made then i would ve liked this movie ,there was no content its just like family rivalry shown in many telugu movies,like aravinda samitha also,only the barbaric attitude of ranbir i think would be criticised and hmare yaha ka kya kehna pictures main itna chain smoking laundigiri kyun batate hai ki aadhe chapri wohi karne mein lag jayege
Sir trust me.. Kal. Main advance booking ke liye visit ki inox. Gai thi animal ke liye 1 hour tak confused ho ke Sam Bahadur ka ticket liya. Main decide nahi kar pa rahi. Thi ki dekhu kya.. CLASH became Huge Cause of 1 Movie success
For every Sam Bahadur ,Shershah has Bhuj and Satyamev Jayate . Movie should have focused on one particular part of his life instead of putting so many parts in just 2 Hr movie
I have watched both the films and this is the kind of cinema we want to see. I am 100% in support that both the movies cannot be compared as both are poles apart in content & it's not fair to compare both. Both the actors did their fantastic job in their respective roles. Vicky kaushal's entry scene OMG, he will take the national award for sure. Animal will get hate from pseudo and woke feminist, which may hamper it's chances in national awards. But honestly I liked how the director showed the violence unuppologitaclly and rubbed salt on pseudo feminism .
Were British Indian soldiers really patriotic? If they were so patriotic then why did they serve for Britishers and helped British rule in India? Many of British Indian soldiers committed atrocities against Indians. Should we really respect them for helping Britishers? What do you think about them guys?
They could have dived into the strategic mind of Sir Manekshaw and his conflicts with the PM. Sir Manekshaw was more than the clever replies that he gave.
People will always find something to criticise. If it was all strategic planning... then people would be like where is the war.... where is the war....
Screenplay doesn't show the real antagonist of that time i.e. Congress govt. If Sam Manikshaw was alive he wouldn't have liked the film. Meghna Gulzar is good at sugarcoating, earlier Pakistan with Raazi and now Congress with Sam Bahadur.
Bro, could you explain me a little bit more how congress is the real antagonist. I honestly do not know.
Congress made him the army chief and field marshall.
@@hardy2175 यही तो पॉलिटिक्स है जो अच्छे भले लोगोको अंधभक्त और चमचे बनाती है।
@@siddu7549 Bro no offence but Congress ignore Sam Manekshaw After 1971 War . They don't even give real Pension to his work .
@@souravkumar6698 Bro, but why ? Like any particular reason. I never heard this side of the story.
I'm glad u reviewed sam bahadur. I'm so disappointed to see that no big reviewer has reviewed Sam bahadur till now 😢
Yes, you're right, this movie shouldn't have been clashed with overhyped Animal. I still remember the clash between SRK's Raees and Hrithik's Kaabil where a good film like Kaabil was unfortunately undermined due to overhype of Raees at that time. 😏
Still Kaabil was a hit movie though
Bro if you compare their collections and budgets , then kaabil earned more profit than raees.
Animal ain't overhyped by any means...just accept the fact that both r great films...if we r talking about an overhyped film then it is none other than Pathan which was only bearable due to SRK
I watched Kaabil and it was too good..
@@menaceyt-ud8hoif you have seen good Hollywood and South Indian action movies then it would be really hard to appreciate movies like pathaan, jawan, bla bla...And Its A Fact !
Actually OTT has forced bollywood to make better content..but still a long long long long way to go
Dunki jawan pathan animal omg 😂😂😂
@@scarfallzgamer2515000000
@@scarfallzgamer2515dunki tune dekh bhi liya? 😮
@@scarfallzgamer2515pathan was mid at best
Aisa kuch bhi nhi h ott is niche platform aur achi movie hamesa se ban rahi h jese ki satya,salam bombey but aise movie ko pahle art house movie bola jata tha
aur Indian cinema action,scfi,horror movie m bhut piche h
Why most important part of Sam Bahadurs's life omitted..that Congress harassed him till his death
Coz then it will get into controversies and screens won't be reserved...the movie come under unnecessary tsunami of events...
@@tmj8623 ahinsawadi party hai ya nahi? Lage raho Munna Bhai was a lie?
Jyada se jyada protest hote aur usaka benefit ho jata movie ko
Aur kya series of events ho jate..
They should have shown a biopic as it is
kuch nahi hota. aajkal no1 cares much about congress.
its cause meghna gulzar is a sickular/woke director. thats it. even in raazi she painted indian army in negative light.@@tmj8623
I eagerly anticipate your review Shan
Tomorrow, I'll be watching this film with my family. Let's refrain from comparing "Animal" and "Sam Bahadur" - they're distinctly unique movies. Instead of pitting them against each other, let's appreciate the rarity of witnessing quality Bollywood films. Vicky Kaushal has long been acknowledged as a talented actor, but his portrayal in "Sardar Udham" elevated my respect for him. His chameleon-like ability in roles like these is commendable. Just as Ranbir Kapoor carried an entire movie, despite other commendable performances, people will undoubtedly praise Vicky for his portrayal of Sam Maneckshaw. Cheers to the joy of experiencing such cinematic brilliance after a considerable time! 🔥
Couldn’t agree more. Animal aaj dekhi kal sam bahadur dekhne jaunga
Sam Bahadur was slated to release on 1 December since the very beginning. It was Animal that was postponed to clash with Sam Bahadur. Animal was originally slated to release on 11 August but was postponed so as to not clash with Gadar 2.
So clever
Shan touching his ears to pay respect to the legend Sam Manikshaw Sir while saying his name ❤❤
They should have released it next year, maybe on January 15th ie apparently Army Day as well. But idk what urge was there to release it with Animal. 🤦🏻♂️
26 Jan hritik roshan ki fighter release hogi
bhai dec 1 bsf raising day hai and 4 dec Navy Day hai (remembering 1972 war) toh animal idhar aaya clash karne.
Animal vs Sam Bahadur- I’ll watch Sam Bahadur. I personally prefer movies based on real life characters and the best way to honour his memory is to spend my hard earned cash on watching his story be inspired by his values, morals and valour. Again only my opinion🙏
It felt like meghna Gulzar sir manekshaw ke kisse sunaa rahi hai. Ek kissa khatam hota toh scene abruptly end ho jaata. There was no particular flow to the story. War mai kabhi elevate kiya nahi ki why is the war important, what is at stake. Toh woh jeetne ki urgency feel ho nahi hui. This movie felt like sir manekshaw had a very smooth life which was not the case at all. Kudos to Vicky kaushal and costume and set designers. They nailed their jobs
इसे कहते हैं बहती गंगा मे हात धोना । राष्ट्रभक्ती वाली मूवी बनावो पर आधे मन से और मूल विषय को विकृत करो अथवा व्हाइट वॉश करो। और भी हात धोने वाले है अक्षय कुमार, कंगना...
Bhi or Congress Kaisa Sam Manekshaw ko ignore kya or Unki pension rok deya Director ki Hypocrisy ke chakkar me nahi Dekhya
@mukulsingh3083 i completely agree with your assessment. There was no coherent flow to the narrative. Wasted opportunity for such a potentially great story.
I completely agree movie mein kisi scene mein connection built hi nhi huya.. movie kab shuru huyi kab khatam pta hi nhi chala
2:49 loved how he touched his ears after saying the name of Field-marshal Sam Manikshaw sir
Never miss any video of you. One of the honest channel on TH-cam.
This movie is love letter to Sam. people who have been obsessed with this man will definitely enjoy it more then other
No . Director is A is shit . She Ignored Congress sin
Excellent review and you have made an excellent point about trying to release this movie along with Animal. It boggles the mind who in the industry thought it does not matter in releasing this movie with Animal.
HE WAS A HEARTTHROB IN MOM'S TIME 😊
This is her 6th or 7th film as a director, not her debut
Video without research😂
Yess
Shan bhai i loved your reviews. I love your Animal review. If such movies are made by Quentin Torentino or Holywood directors, Critics would have praised it left and right.
4:33 How is it her directorial debut though? She has directed many movies before. Talvar, Raazi etc
4:32 Meghna Gulzar directorial debut is Filhaal back in 2002 i guess
Sam has proved Vicky is a brilliant actor .just amazing .
Bhai this is not the Directorial debu of Meghna Gulzar, she has directed Talwar, Raazi, and Chappak also.🙂
Sam bahadur was suppose to release on 1dec only, Animal got postpone from 11 aug to 1dec.
Why they choose date to clash? Why cant they release a gap of 1 or 2 weeks? That would have been beneficial for both
Tab fir dunkey se clash ho jayega.
This movie is made from congress version and it didn't show everything about great Sam Manekshaw. He didn't like political involvement in Army and it hurt Indira Gandhi a lot and because of it congress took revenge by not paying his salary and pension for 30 years which is not shown in movie. After 30 years president Abdul Kalam give him check of 1.25 crores(which was not given to him when he need it more) but in 2008 he passed away. This movie had not shown how congress treat him in reality but given clean chit to congress.
Major is also a great example of 2nd intention.🙌🏾
So good review. Love your content sir 👍🏻
This isn't a Meghana Gulzar's debute film. She has directed films such as Filhaal, Just married, Dus Kahaniyaan, Talwar and Raazi.
thats why screenplay and editing matters 4hrs of animal i never feel bored but in this i was exhausting although vicky killed it
animal me mai bore ho gayaa interval ke baad i was waiting ki jldi aage badhe story.
Hi Shan, this movie isn't Meghna's Directorial debut... She has worked on films like Raazi before this 😮
She directed films since 2002.
Talvar as well
chapak as well
Her debut movie was filhal with tabu and sushmita
Didn't she make her debut with Tabu and Sushmita Sen starer Filhaal ?
I watched the movie today only, honestly I liked the movie but I had higher expectations, in one word if I have to describe Vicky Kaushal I will say us bande ne jiya hai yeh character play nhi kiya he is fantabulous ,, being from army fraternity myself , I could relate to each n every details, be it the ranks, places , army terminology and protocols everything was well taken care of.. they did a lot of home work.. in fact we met Vicky Kaushal too when he came to our unit.. this film just refreshen our memories of the places where we were posted , through this movie, but movie mein fir bhi bahut kamiyan hain, it lacks in emotions, realism, connection of audience with the film, it lacks in impact which a movie like this could do.. for eg Milkha singh, Uri, border , you can watch 100 times but I must say this movie is just one time watch , bas dekho aur khatam, that’s it.. usse zyada umeed mat rakho isse, achi hai but aur achi ho sakti Thi if they had gone into more details … 3/5 stars
Shan, i loved the way you paid respect to Him by that small gesture of yours...thank you
I watched Sam Bahadur today and the movie is Okay as a film. I personally do not think that it has not performed very well only due to the release of Animal.
The best thing is Vicky Kaushal's acting. I went to watch expecting it to be a spectacular movie about Sam sir.
War movies are very popular in India. However, Sam Bahadur lacked on following points:
1. The movie needed a voiceover narration. It would have been best if they would have used the old radio broadcast style voiceover. As the movie seemed to be made for people like me, who already know about the history of india and Sam Sir.
People around me even had no idea about who Sam bahadur was. Hence, it was necessary to establish through narration in the beginning who he was.
2. The movie is very linear. It should have started from the east pakistan liberation preparation scenes and then the backstory should have been unfolded.
3. It was unable to make full use many points. Ex: it could have shown the rise of Sam in India and rise of his friend Yahia in Pakistan, the pain and betrayal east pakistan's general Niyazi felt when he had to surrender on the command of his higher officials in Pakistan, the pain army wives and families feel when their spouses/parents are on the front lines. Also the lack of equipment in the army and the difficulties due to it etc. All these were not fully established and utilised. It is necessary to build the story of the supporting characters to build a spectacular movie.
4. To make a movie that will do good at the box office you have to do some exaggeration and dramatisation. They showed how the army fights actually are (which are painful but not dramatic) rather they should have made them a bit more intense.
5. For the liberation of Bangladesh they should have shot the scenes rather than using only real footage of that time.
As an army kid and someone who really respects Sam sir I was left unsatisfied.
Any scenes were there in movie about his ill-treatment post retirement? If not, then just say 'Selective history film' or 'Distorted history' film..
Sana Fatima is definitely a miscast, She makes Indira look like a child PM. And about the comparison, i love movies like Sam Bahadur, but when i think of my budget prefer to spend it on movies like Animal and enjoy Sam Bahadur at home in OTT platform.
they just helped her by giving her a job
Same thing happened back in the day with Ranbir Kapoor's Rocket Singh when it clashed with 3 Idiots. Massy vs. Classy
Shan bhaiya ❤❤❤❤ always good reviews
Vicky Kaushal is a Very Very Very Very Talented Brilliant Actor.He perfectly suits in the role of Sam Bahadur ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍👍👍👍👍👍
Yeh tha review. Animal movie ke time par shan review nahi de raha tha woh bus excited tha.
Honestly when you make a biopic on a true patriot of our country,it should cover his entire life,not just end half way... what was done with field marshal in later days by a particular political party by stopping his full military pension..no government officials attending his funeral should also be shown.. otherwise it doesn't portray a good picture..
Already watched Sam Bahadur it’s a nice movie .. Fabulous acting by Vicky .. Should watch ..
Bhai Salaar ke trailer review bhi krdo😂Goosebumps agaye Goosebumps 🤡🤣
I wasted my 3.30 hrs watching Animal. Ab next one year I won’t go to theatre.😢
First comment bro....
Amazing review
You may hate Kangana Ranaut for her statements, but when it comes to Indira Gandhi's portrayal, I am keeping high hopes on Emergency movie.
Sam Manekshaw is not the first field marshal of India
It’s Cariappa
Gen Cariappa was second to get it
You should've reviewed Salaar's trailer as well.
Mere to kuch samajh hi nhi aaya or logo ko Goosebumps bhi aa Gaye😕😕
It's very good to see that Shan did proper research before making any video....
Nothing to watch except Vicky Kaushal. I knew most of the facts about Sam. They just made a film on it. More of a documentary than a movie. No screenplay nothing.
Tum Jo Sam Manekshaw "saab" bole na dil Jeet liye bhaiya ji.
Yes, I saw both the movies. 🙂
Bhai ye jacket kis brand ka hai aur kaha se liya hai
Don’t u guys research even a bit. Meghna Gulzar has directed Raati, Talvar and Chapaak. It’s not her debut. There might be issues in the movie but plz do some research before speaking as many people see your videos and will then believe this info
I wanted to watch sam bahadur but because of hype and peer pressure I had to go for animal (regretting)
Bhai bs ek baat puchni hai tuj se ki tune koi course kiya hua hai filme se related? Just a question.
correction.- this is NOT a director debut of Mehna Gulzar. She have made gems like Talvar, Raazi, Chhapaak previously.
OTT पे देख लेंगे... अभी तो back to back ANIMAL देखने में व्यस्त हूं जी
Sam Bahadur is a Must Watch Film for Every Indian with the Entire Family ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍👍👍👍👍👍
Both Sam Bahadur, Mission Raniganj Equally Deserve Oscar, National Award
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍👍👍👍👍👍
This isn't Meghna Gulzar's directorial debut film. She has directed Raazi, Chhapak, Talwar and a couple of more. Thodi reserch director par bhi kar liya karo yaar.
This is not her directorial debut she have been directing since 2002 Filhaal movie and after that almost 5 films are directed … The most recent was Chaapak
Bro till the date Animal trailer was not released... I was eagerly waiting for SamBahadur.
After Animal trailer release things changed 360 degree
360 degrees means full circle, no change.
Haven't seen SamBahadur, but Animal was such a bad movie.. had high hopes that finally bollywood will come over nonsensical movies like Pathan, Jawan, Gadar 2, but this one created new bad.. 3 hours 20 mins of torture.. pathetic especially 2nd half
You're looking dashing in this attire.
Its unfortunate that this movie whitewash all the iltreatment of Field Marshall Sam Manekshaw. Did she show how Sam was not given his pension? So what's the point of making movie which doesn't make justice with his sacrifice ? 😑😑
going for sam Bahadur rather than Animal !! will watch animal too but sam Bahadur is first priority !! ✌
Bhai aapki jacket bohot sahi lag rhi hai konsi hai aur kaha se li
Sach to ye hai ki animal sambahadur ki shows kha raha hai
Bhaii shirt kaha se Li??
Meghna Gulzar had made films earlier of Chappak and Raazi.
Dono hi movies bohot different hai.. Mai Animal islea nahi dekh rahi.. kyuki muje already anger issues hai.. ise dekh k trigger ho jaaungi or 🤣🤣 baaki Movie is great.. Sam Bahadur is also very good movie... I would say... watch both.
Sam Bahadur Excellent
Vicky Kaushal Excellent
Saniya,Fatima,Meghna Gulzar Excellent
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍👍👍👍👍
Sam Bahadur is a masterpiece.
Sam Bahadur is a perfect movie for OTT.
Calling a Defense Personnel without his rank is considered as an insult for him and his rank.
So address him as Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw not Manekshaw Saheb. It's a request to you Sir Peace out
I think this isn't the directorial debut of Meghna Gulzar, she has directed movies prior to this.
Shan bhai....I was a bit disappointed by your animal review....It was like seeing as if an MLM guy (The filmmaker) has influenced a poor fellow.....There were problematic narratives around the film.....I though maybe you'll call it out...but unfortunately you too got influenced.....this shows the extent to which filmmaker has been successful in doing what he wanted.........There is nothing wrong about showing problematic, psychologically ill...or even misogynistic characters....but putting such characters in such a screenplay where the filmmakers makes us root, cheer and sympathize with the broken yet strong character...then it is a problem...a big problem.......There is no issue with showing violence....i enjoy the rawness and the gory too...with films like KILL, John wick, Scarface...but this one had made me truly believe the lack of sensibilities amount the youth....(believe me i am not being a narcissist)
so you can stand to watch men blown to bits but can't handle a woman being slapped in a movie, which is tame compared to whole mutilation of men. what the fuck is this selective outrage. it's a movie, everything about action movies are problematic if you view like this. If you can see men killing each other in raid and john wick they why are you seething seeing such tame scenes in movie. No man is gonna get influenced to hit his wife by seeing this movie.
Same!
Same thought bro, same.
Bhai sach m itna violence h because mene bhut foreign action dekha h
Ranbir should have been killed at last not hero or protoganist should have been made then i would ve liked this movie ,there was no content its just like family rivalry shown in many telugu movies,like aravinda samitha also,only the barbaric attitude of ranbir i think would be criticised and hmare yaha ka kya kehna pictures main itna chain smoking laundigiri kyun batate hai ki aadhe chapri wohi karne mein lag jayege
Sir trust me.. Kal. Main advance booking ke liye visit ki inox. Gai thi animal ke liye 1 hour tak confused ho ke Sam Bahadur ka ticket liya. Main decide nahi kar pa rahi. Thi ki dekhu kya.. CLASH became Huge Cause of 1 Movie success
For every Sam Bahadur ,Shershah has Bhuj and Satyamev Jayate .
Movie should have focused on one particular part of his life instead of putting so many parts in just 2 Hr movie
Laptop 💻💻💻💻💻 kidhar hai
I have watched both the films and this is the kind of cinema we want to see. I am 100% in support that both the movies cannot be compared as both are poles apart in content & it's not fair to compare both.
Both the actors did their fantastic job in their respective roles.
Vicky kaushal's entry scene OMG, he will take the national award for sure.
Animal will get hate from pseudo and woke feminist, which may hamper it's chances in national awards. But honestly I liked how the director showed the violence unuppologitaclly and rubbed salt on pseudo feminism .
Sambhadur screen paly soo good and I love Indian army 🪖🇮🇳💪🚩🚩 Jai hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳💪🚩🚩
I will go for sam bahaadur. And I have 0 interest for animal movie.
Filhaal, Talvar, Raazi, Chapaak....tthis is atleast M.Gulzar's fifth film
'SamBahadur' makers have announced film date much before, so Animal makers did so (Same date launch)
Sam bahadur should have released on 26th January.
Not a directorial debut. She directed Raazi, Chappaak and Talvar also
Were British Indian soldiers really patriotic? If they were so patriotic then why did they serve for Britishers and helped British rule in India? Many of British Indian soldiers committed atrocities against Indians. Should we really respect them for helping Britishers?
What do you think about them guys?
Hamare local theatre ne Sam bahadur lagai hi ni sirf animal lagai maybe next week
this movie showed how indian thinks the 1971 was their war .Which was actually the liberation war for Bengalis.
This is not Directorial debut of Meghna Gulzar ,She has Directed Raazi,Chapaak & best one Talvar
Sam Bahadur is a Very Very Very Very Very Good Film
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍👍👍👍👍👍
It is meghana's 4th Film As Director
bhai meghna Gulzar ney Talvar and Raazi Direct ki hain!!
Well Meghna Gulzar's directorial debut was Raazi, not Sam Bahadur
They honestly should have released this movie around Jan 26. It would have easily crossed 100crore mark.
Sam bhai ke aage koi bol sakta hai kya?
how is it Sam Bahadur's fault in clashing???? They announced the date first, so why are you expecting them to move away from Animal?
SAM MAKEKSHAW didn't got his salary in his last days 😢