진짜 찐 어른들의 이별인듯. 단순히 싸우거나 누군가 잘못을 저지르고 감정이 상해서 헤어지는 게 아니라, 어느 순간부터 점점 사랑이 식어가며 이별을 직감하고 자신들의 인연이 이젠 서로를 구속하는 족쇄가 돼갈 것을 알기에 행복을 빌며 인연의 끈을 잘라버리는 거... 너무 아프지만 누구의 잘못도 아니라는 게 슬프면서도 가장 깔끔하고 좋은 이별이 아닐까 싶다ㅠㅠ
딱 지금 제 상황입니다..서로의 행복을 빌며 인연의 끈을 잘라버리는거.. 이런이별을 저도 했는데, 사실 이게 찐 어른들의 이별인지 뭔지도 모르겠고.. 이게 가장 깔끔한 이별인지도 잘 모르겠어요.. 심하게 싸우면서 서로에게 심한말을 하고 큰 상처를 주고 끝나는 그런 이별은 아니고 서로 앞으로 좋은 일만 있길 응원하면서 헤어졌기 때문에 틀림없이 좋은면도 있긴 하지만.. 두사람이 만나면서 똑같이 사랑하고 똑같이 식는게 아니다보니 둘중 한사람은 헤어지고 싶어하고.. 나머지 한사람은 그 모습을 보면서 힘든 상황을 지속하다 결국 놓아주는 그림이 되는 경우가 많거든요.. 결국 아직 끈을 놓고싶지 않았던 사람은 그냥 그렇게 남겨진채로 있는거에요. 아마 뮤비에서는 마지막에 아이유가 끈을 자르는 모습이 안나왔는데.. 그런걸 뜻하지 않았을까 싶어요.. 끈을 자르고싶지만 한번에 못잘라요... 남겨진 사람 입장에선.. 전혀 깔끔하지 않아요..ㅜ
어른들의 이별이 아니죠. 차라리 싸우고 헤어진게 낫다고 생각해요. 감정적으로 준비가 안되었는데 모든걸 앗아가는 상대를 보는것도, 싸울 가치도 없는 사람이었다 생각되는 나를 다독이는것도 너무 힘들었거든요. 상대의 행복을 비는건 거의 '내가 널 버리지만 그게 너한테 별일이 아니었음 좋겠다' 하는 자기위안이라고 생각해요 그냥 전부 다 위선같아요 저는
I think so. She’ve been loving by South Korea’s about more than 10 years. She has various capacity to become more talanted person. We can say that she is ‘treasure’.
@@ssbb7989 tbh she shd be called the nations treasure hahah tho the nations little sister name still fits her cuz she looks like under 20 while her 27th (or in Korea 28th) birthday is coming in 3 days!!! IU is just so amazing
뮤비가 진짜 연애부터 이별하는 과정 모두를 다 드러내주는거같아요. 채널로 사귀는 날짜를 묘사하는 것부터 시작해서, 남녀가 서로 좋게 기억하는게 다르듯 서로 다른 장면에서 웃는것도 그렇고, 줄에 메달린게 서로에 대한 기대라고 한다면 마지막에 스스로 가위로 끈을 자르듯 스스로 상대를 향한 기대를 져버려야한다는 슬픔과 비참함, 끊어도 끊어지지않는 지독한 미련.. 뮤비가 대단한거같아요 ..
He always choose IU over and over again 😭 Kim Soo Hyun's: last movie before enlisting - Real (IU as a cameo) Last drama before enlisting - The Producers (w/ IU) Last mv before enlisting - Ending Scene (IU’s mv) First drama cameo after enlistment - Hotel Del Luna (IU as main lead)
영상을 배우는 사람으로서 마지막 장면의 연출은 정말 본받고 싶습니다. 머리카락을 잘라주려던, 애틋하고 다정한 연인의 모습을 표현할 때 썼던 도구를 순식간에 두사람의 마음을 정리하고, 이별로 다가가는 도구로 전환시킬 생각을 어떻게 하셨는지 정말 대단한거 같습니다. 영상을 보면서 막 감동 받아서 눈물이 난다는건 과장 섞인 말이라고 생각했는데 저 장면을 볼 때 정말 소름돋고 눈물도 나네요.....
IU is really an artist she can make people think so deep whether they are a common person or an artist too regardless if who you are she can make you realize things through her song and relate it to your own life. She basically just wrote about what she is going through with love, family, career and her feelings but it can touch your heart how honest those words are. Like when she wrote Graduation Day, Voicemail, Bad Day, 23, Pallet, 25 and the rest of her song it reflect who she is and what she felt in those years and situation she went through. I've been a fan for 7 years but she never fail to amaze me every-time i thought i already know everything about her. I'm looking forward on what she will do again. I don't like her to be pressured by the expectation of others for me as long as she stay true to herself and love what she does i will continue to support her no matter what will happen. IU will always be precious in my heart. She made me realize that music doesn't have boundaries.
IU is such a gem in the k-pop industry. She can tell a story with her music and that is not something you can see in a lot of successful singers whether kpop or just pop. I really love her and her music. It's such a pleasure to anticipate her music and hope to enjoy it for many many years to come. Love IU !
I'm tearing up like I just went through a break. IU knows how to write a song that, even if you can't relate to the subject, you can still feel the emotions.
I just want to give IU a proper credits for the song and the music video. She just executes everything perfectly. I would say that during a break up, no song can ever describe how you truly feels but IU made it in this video. From the warm beginning, the conversation, the flashback of the break up, the words that the guy said, to the very end. Break up is like this. You basically cut off each others string in order to be happy, to just let go once you know it is not meant to be, again - this is not easy. The metaphor of the strings describes the attachment of being in a relationship. We cut off the strings, but - we have to cut off our own string in order to completely let go and move on. IU describes it painfully beautiful.
Indeed. I hope people do come back to this song of they needed healing during a tough period of time and hopefully, people would be able to see comments like this again and feel that they are not alone in this.
This is about someone with avoidant attachment style that abruptly left the relationship. It's heartbreaking but IU is trying to remember him in the best light possible. It is an issue of attachment style - psychological issue. The scene of them both cutting cords for each other is literally spot on. That's what I just had to do with someone. Crazy she went through this at that age.
the most heartbreaking thing about this song, is that everybody can relate to it in one way or another. the meaning is not limited to a romantic relationship, it applies to all.
IU is honestly one of the most amazing artists that i have ever heard, her voice is just pure perfection, filled with such provoking emotion- Im at a loss for words (sorry I'm a new fan :) )
Maybe it's just me but... from the hesitancy, words, and contrasting expressions between the girl and the boy... I get the feeling that the guy is cheerful, lighthearted, easily liked and accepted by others but the girl is more reserved, slow to trust, and hides her true emotions/facial expressions/depth of love because she is afraid of being vulnerable and takes longer to open up to others. She is thoughtful and internalizes everything, but often protects her inner self from the outside world unless she is sure that person can truly understand and accept her and will not try to tie her down or change her. But the guy mistakes this as hesitancy/lack of commitment... her reserved nature and need to protect herself before she can open up to her loved ones is mistaken as selfishness and loving herself more than anyone else when in actuality she just doesn't know how to show the depth of her feelings for the guy. Before she can even properly process the storm of emotions inside of her he starts misunderstanding her and saying things like ("maybe one day you can find someone who loves you more than you love yourself"), it makes it even more difficult to open up and be honest, "Oh... this whole time I was quietly beside him, he couldn't even see... could he even understand or believe my feelings? What if they have grown too much, what if it pushes him away? How can he show his love so easily, why can't he see what I cannot say...?" He mistakes her reserved nature for coldness... yet she is the one who floats easier than him and does not fall as hard in the moments that they fall a little. I think this means her feelings ran deeper and her internal commitment was actually stronger, she just couldn't express it in a way he could recognize (she says herself he'll never know the feelings he made her feel), which is why he much more easily cut his strings in the end. Funny how she was in essence blamed for being the "selfish" one when it was he who gave up first. It looks like truly, in the end, he really wasn't someone she could trust to show her true self to because he gave up before she even had the chance... he basically proved her fears right, which would make it even more difficult to open up in the future. I love the palpable pain you can feel in her voice and in the lyrics but how her facial expressions look cold and detached and misunderstood/alone. It shows the contrast/battle between her inner world and what she shows on the surface. In the end she just looks tired and alone, sort of like she expected him to give up on her but it still hurts anyway.
Crystal and Noel I can somehow relate this to MLSHR also.. Wang So has the personality of the girl (singing in this song) and Hae Soo has the boy's personality.. so melancholic..
Yeh when i heard of songsong couple's divorce i remember this song speacially that songsong couple are fans of IU i can imagine they listen to this song and cry (SORRy for my bad english)good day for every one 😍😍💜💜💜
watching this now while also watching QOT this song and mv suits the drama so well… the mv looks like lovers’ memories slowly fading away just like Haein slowly forgeting hyunwoo
The most of the singers makes songs about couple breaking, based on a hate relation thing, but IU takes the side of when both still loves each other but at the same time realize that is not healthy to stay, just something warm and precious to heard and cry here.
OMG this hit way to close to home. As soon as I read your comment I started crying... Me and my ex have being dating this last few weeks, and I still love I try I really try to make everything work but it is just not the same... It just doesn't work and I'm getting crazy I have improved myself, changed a lot of toxic things about myself but it doesn't work.... Fuck I hate all of this, I really love her but it just doesn't work...
I really dont understand bcoz bse on this MV they still love each other,i was thinking bout relationship is all about love but this mv show us that even how much u cared for each other or you loved each other there are certain things that also needed to fullfill the heart of both of you.It seems uneasy to understand this situation but for me love is not enough to stay in a relationship if it is not healthy and hve no spArk anymore better to stop and ask yourself if you are willing to stay.
@@adeletonggal5285 Indeed. And caring for someone and being worried for their well-being doesn't make it valid for one to ignore the fact that they've fallen out of love or just can't love the other as much as to be in a proper romantic relationship. At times like these, letting go may be painful but it's better than dragging on what's going to be inevitable and spoiling the feelings both have for each other.
I think she's overshadowing her self. This could have had more views, if it hadn't been released a few days after Palette. To me, it's the best song of the three singles!
IU’s voice literally reaches out and touches your soul. She’s my fav female Kpop artist, i find her so different from other kpop artists smhow and her voice is so soothing, the lyrics are amazing 💜
IU is perfect idol. She can sing, rap, dance. Produce her own songs. Can act. She is also so good model. Natural pretty. Have kind and sweet personality. Strongest idol. How can people hate her? I love you IU, so much. You are best solist ever
The saddest part of this MV for me is the last 10 seconds. While we watched him let go…we didn’t actually see her let go too. So while he’s gone, the possibility of her still being hung up on him remains. Sad tbh.
Ikr. I started listening to IU only recently, after watching them in Producers and when I saw the thumbnail for this video, I was so happy thinking I could see them be a happy couple here. What I got was heartbreak.
her chat-shire album came out around when i started university. i had trouble making friends and those songs became my friend. years have passed and i feel gloomy and even though i made friends i can't talk to them. so her songs will be my company again. thank you for coming back IU.
this will always be my favourite song from IU. When i first listened to this i was so innocent, though it was sad i didn’t understand the depth and meaning of this song and mv.. and yet now ironically im going through the exact same thing in this mv.. almost as if i am IU. My first love, my first breakup and first heartbreak.. we kept hurting each other, he said the exact same words, that someday i will find someone better to love me the way i needed to be loved.. it hurt even more hearing that. This song explains every feeling and thought that im going through right now.. “You told me that you’ll love me.. what is this?” hits me so bad I’d never thought that this would happen to me but here we are.. everytime i hear this i get so emotional but yet so comforted. 💔
I never experienced a painful breakup before but this song gave me such raw, heartbreaking emotions every time I listen to it. IU really is a genius when it comes to delivering feels to her singing
The song is a masterpiece. The MV is powerful. IU spoke to our hearts through this ballad. There are a lot of sad songs out there but this particular song was arranged & interpreted with much emotions, that's why even if someone doesn't know the exact lyrics, he/she can still feel the sadness, hurt or even the pain. Some even said that this song made them miss their non-existent ex-boyfriend. The magic of the song doesn't simply rely on its relatability, its magic comes from the universal concept of "goodbyes" and letting go. The most powerful part of the MV is the cutting of strings. So, even if you haven't experienced a break-up or being dumped, you will still get affected because in this life, we have all experienced a loss & a rejection that pushed us to move on or accept the things we can't change. You can listen to this song while thinking of the saying "all good things come to an end" which makes this song an anthem for things or people you need to cut strings with because life wants you to. This can be a song for your bias (someone so distant to you) but at some point decided to change his/her direction so you must move on too. This can also be a song for a group/band that disbanded for personal reasons, no matter how attached you are to them, you'll need to let go. This can also be a song for a Kdrama you deeply loved but after 16-20 episodes has to end or for a TV series which has to end after several seasons. This can also be your song for your fangirl/fanboy life in general because you can't stay like that forever. Youth passes and priorities change. That's how powerful the song is, "Ending Scene" will always make us cry for it will always remind us of the things we had to let go for us to go on and begin a new chapter. IU & Kim Soo Hyun did a good job. The expressions & gestures they did were on-point. Palette album is my album of the year! :)
Indeed, everyone who worked on this video, from those involved in the music like Sam Kim and IU, to the directors, actors and staff who helped made this amazing. And your comment is indeed magical. My heart is all warm and fuzzy now thanks to you!
the verses where Kim Soo Hyun lip sing are from the guy's perspective. So he was telling the girl those words. It's not just mere lip singing. IU wrote this song from both the girl's and guy's perspective. Like a conversation. Similar to what she did with Peach. Pure genius!!! And that jam jam insert is also so well-played. Jam Jam is like the prelude to the relationship.
Everytime the girl hold the remote, it's like everything in the past has appeared again, so vividly. She is happy, but is painful at the same time. The lyrics is like from both of them; it's the message from the boy for her when he leave her, and also her hope that he should not be painful, because she don't want to see him suffering everyday. The ending is so hurt, but it's not miserable. Both of them always want the other to be happy. They just want to help the other to escape from the pain. As you can see at the ending, the girl also cut the strings, because she would like her love to be truly relieve and be away from all the pain, and finally the boy cut it himself to be truly escape himself from such a scenario. The ending scene is sad but not miserable, because we know that they always keep the image of the other deep in their heart. I love this music video so much, from the lyrics to the content and effects of the MV. Thank you IU for her excellent product this time, and long time no see but congratulation Kim Soo Hyun because you have done a good job
I kept coming to this song for the past 5 years and yet everytime I listen my eyes fill up with tears...every time I come, I find a new meaning to the lyrics and it is only now that I've fully understood it. I relate so much to it...I can see myself in the girl's position. Someone else in the comment section has already analysed it perfectly so I'm not gonna repeat the same thing. I love it no matter how much it makes me cry....legendary song. Does IU know how many people are touched by this?...she made a masterpiece🌟
I agree! until now im still into this. And I'm still crying every time i hear this song 🥺 I remember the encore part when IU sung this during her concert here in Manila. Im so touch with the phone lights swaying while singing this.
@@火百合-z9q 아이유는 한국을 대표하는 가수이면서 배우입니다. 아티스트입니다. 그리고 개인적인 인생도 그 누구보다 잘 삽니다. 앞으로도 그럴겁니다. 팬들도 함께 잘 삽니다. 함께 잘 사실꺼구요. 알면 알수록 매력있는 가수를 만나기는 쉽지 않습니다. 아이유가 그런 가수라서 진심으로 행복합니다. 나와 너(I-U)이기에 오늘과 미래의 우리들의 마음을 대표하는 멋진 사람입니다. 멋진 예술인입니다. 우리는 이런 사람들을 아티스트라고 합니다. 아무나 아티스트일 수는 없는겁니다.
다시보니까 너무 슬픈 뮤비네요. 왼쪽위에 CH01 이렇게 남녀 둘의 첫날부터를 채널처럼 돌려보는 아이유 시점인것같아요. 그러고 애인과의 옛채널 즉 과거를 돌려보면서도 남자친구가 최근에 헤어지자고 하면서 "잘먹고 다녀, 주는게 쉽지가 않아 등등" 라고 했던 말이 생각나는 형식이네요.키스하던 애인이 같은 옷을 입고 헤어졌을때의 말을 하는거 보면 CH10 에서의 추억을 떠올리면서도 이랬던남자가 결국엔 이런엔딩으로 이런 말을 하는구나를 비교하는것같구요. 너무 슬프네여 ㅠㅠ 나 자신도 행복하게 연애할때 언젠가 지금의 애인이 헤어지자고 하는 모습이 미래에있을까라며 슬퍼한적이있는데 그걸 음악으로 만들구 심리를 잘 표현한 뮤비 👍
4년이 지난 지금에서야 온전히 알 거만 같다 나온 순간에도 앨범 수록곡 중 가장 마음에 들었던 곡이라 뮤비해석도 많이 찾아보았음에도 불구하고 지금 또 다시보니 이제서야 정말로 알 거만 같은 이 느낌… 스트로베리문에서 사랑에 빠진 상황을 무중력으로 표현했는데 여기서도 마찬가지네 아이유가 표현하는 사랑을 알 거만 같다 나두 스스로 잘라낼 수 있을까?
I'm not sure if my translator was wrong to translate your comment, but if you're having a hard time, fighting. Even if the pain doesn't seem to end, over time everything will get better.
It hurts more when people say "You deserve better" or "You deserve to be happy w someone else" it's easier when the person cheats or hurts you because you're angry. But when they still show some kind of affection it's harder to move on because you can't hate them.
This is why I'm breaking up with my boyfriend, because he honestly deserves someone who loves him as much as he loves her. I just can't be the one. But this song is making me cry,. I wish relationships weren't so complicated...
from my experience i don't think it shows affection but yes it hurts even more,way more. he said exactly this to me when I decided to break up with him. I was angry that he doubted my choice to be with him coz he was supposed to be the "better one". I chose him. then I knew I was completely wrong right at the moment he said this to me. It hurt so much when it came from a person you loved. I realised he didn't love me enough to say anything better than that, to save our relationship. It hurt but also I knew I made the right choice, I really deserve better.
“For the times you were lonely, I hope you can find someone who can love you more than the love you’re giving me…. I’m sorry that person isn’t me” -- IU 💚🍀
the part "geureon mareun haji ma jebal (please dont say those words)" really broke my heart into pieces. there's so much emotion in her voice. That sadness,suffering,disappointed...sorrowful...OMG IU-ah,u make me cry without a reason~😭😭😭
I absolutely love IU and V's duet that I came to listen to the original song...V always introduces me to great songs. I'm so Thankful! Seriously I can't get over Taehyung's different color of voice in this duet.
번역 좋다는 댓글이 꽤 보여서 영어 자막 틀어봤는데 “어떤 마음을 준 건지 너는 모를 거야” 부분이 상대방이 나에게 어떤 슬픔을 느끼게 한 건지 쪽으로 번역되었네요. 그동안 “내가 너에게 어떤 마음(사랑)을 줘왔던 건지 넌 모를 거야” 쪽으로 들어왔었는데 이것도 중의적으로 들을 수 있는 가사였던 거겠죠… 새롭게 아름답다…
this is such a sad song and i relate to this song so much. Personally, I think the most heartbreaking part was "I hope you found someone that can love you more than you love yourself". its like somehow, those of us who love ourselves too much are seen as a threat? inconvenient? hard to handle or love? and it is such a sad thing. i hope those that have experienced this or are the type of person people always consider hard to love, will find love so big, so selfless, and so encompassing that you end up being more in love with yourself for being the way you are :) (it can come from anyone, doesnt necessarily have to be from special someone)
To me the line "I hope you find someone who will love you more than you love yourself" means that she has *very little* love for herself, so he wants her to find someone who can appreciate and cherish her because she doesn't. Or maybe that's just what I understood because I hate myself lol
@@junehoneycrisp It certainly can be interpreted in that way and I personally feel that's the meaning for me especially since I know of so many people who are able to love others and are so giving. And yet they can't seem to love themselves as much, deeming themselves as less important or unworthy of love compared to everyone else. The lyrics are written to be quite vague so it can be either the girl being too selfless/loving while the boy being more unwilling/"selfish" or the other way round so basically the girl being unwilling/"selfish" and the boy being more selfless/loving. Like how 2:23 "It's not easy to give my heart to you" from the boy's perceptive is likely to seem like he can't really open up/trust the girl but it can also be interpreted as the boy trying to trust the girl but he finds it difficult if she doesn't trust him. And 3:26 "Like you said, one day can I be loved by someone like me?" seems to be implying that the girl is either 1. Unwilling to open up and can't seem to love anyone other than herself for now so how can she find someone like her that matches with her if they both love/appreciate themselves more before loving each other Or 2. How the girl can find that someone just as selfless/loving as her and would love the girl even more than themselves just like how she initially loved the boy? So what do you guys think? :3
@@uwuangel1998 this actually happened to me recelty. It was that ..we were both selfish? He left me bcuz he didnt want to see me anymore, whom he had hurt rly bad cuz it would be too painful to see some1 u love that was really hurt by u. And i was also selfish for wanting to still wanting to be together despite the fact that him seeing me would sting his heart. I guess thats the opening heart to some1 in the lyrics was that he didnt want to become vunerable n thus left. And i think that the number 2, last one was really accurate, at least on my part.
@@ayurax People fall in and out of love for various reasons and everyone is different in how they interact with people, how they love each other or even feel loved by people. Unfortunately it does not always end up in a happy ending, especially if people work and feel differently about certain things. But that's all the more reasons why don't you worry! Because every connection you have ever made is a step closer to getting to know who is the right one for you. And I'm sure there's more people who will be by your side, loving you just the way you are as friends, family and even more than all that: that special someone out there who's also wondering about you, waiting for you to come into their lives! I wish you all the best and stay strong~ 💕💖💜💜
Awwww watching this made me remember all their dramas together: 1. Dream High 2. The Producers 3. Hotel Del Luna 😭😭😭 It's really good to hear that they're really close friends
@@humanb5090 umm...so does that mean that if I'm a BLINK, I can't be an IU stan? That's just messed up BRUH! I love all kinds of K-pop and that doesn't mean that if u stan another idol or group, you can't stan another one😤
Playing ending scene after IU got dating news. Before everything, I really love their friendship and low-key expecting for dating news soon. But yeah I just hope they continue being such a good friend even uri IU's got her bf. And continue sending food cart on drama set, Soohyun's continue doing IU song challenge, and attending one another movie premiere night. Congrats Jieunahh u found love. I hope you become even more happy everyday now.
![[MV] IU(아이유) _ Through the Night(밤편지)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BzYnNdJhZQw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MV] IU(아이유) _ Through the Night(밤편지)](/img/tr.png)
개인적으로 이런엔딩 뮤비가 아이유 뮤비 중에서 제일 잘 만들어졌다고 생각함.. 연인의 이별과정을 표현한 방식도 독특하고 그냥 뭔가 보고있으면 아련함.. 주기적으로 보게 돼
저는 밤편지
스트로베리 문 뮤비 보고 이거 생각나서 보러옴
갠적으로 아이유 남주랑 뮤비 찍는 거 넘 좋은듯
전 개인적으로 이런엔딩이랑,밤편지,러브포엠이 젤 좋은거 같아요
@I57P 네 ㅎㅎ 발라드는 아니고 기리보이,다운 느낌 노래 좋아해서
이 노래도 어지간한 기억조작곡 중 하나임,, 나 분명 이렇게 마음 찢어질듯한 이별까진 안 해봤는데, “네말대로 언젠가 나도 나같은 누군가에게 사랑받게 될까.” 이 클라이맥스 부분은 너무 사기야 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 안 울 수가 없어 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
ka ka 맞아오ㅜㅠ
와... 이 댓 보자마자 그 부분 나옴 ㄷㄷ
ka ka 헐 슬프게 왜그러세요
진짜 찐 어른들의 이별인듯. 단순히 싸우거나 누군가 잘못을 저지르고 감정이 상해서 헤어지는 게 아니라, 어느 순간부터 점점 사랑이 식어가며 이별을 직감하고 자신들의 인연이 이젠 서로를 구속하는 족쇄가 돼갈 것을 알기에 행복을 빌며 인연의 끈을 잘라버리는 거... 너무 아프지만 누구의 잘못도 아니라는 게 슬프면서도 가장 깔끔하고 좋은 이별이 아닐까 싶다ㅠㅠ
맞아요.. 너무 깔끔해서 더 슬픈
하지만 여자가 확실하게 잘랐을지는 모릅니다 ㅠ 열린 결말이 더 슬프네요
딱 지금 제 상황입니다..서로의 행복을 빌며 인연의 끈을 잘라버리는거.. 이런이별을 저도 했는데, 사실 이게 찐 어른들의 이별인지 뭔지도 모르겠고.. 이게 가장 깔끔한 이별인지도 잘 모르겠어요.. 심하게 싸우면서 서로에게 심한말을 하고 큰 상처를 주고 끝나는 그런 이별은 아니고 서로 앞으로 좋은 일만 있길 응원하면서 헤어졌기 때문에 틀림없이 좋은면도 있긴 하지만.. 두사람이 만나면서 똑같이 사랑하고 똑같이 식는게 아니다보니 둘중 한사람은 헤어지고 싶어하고.. 나머지 한사람은 그 모습을 보면서 힘든 상황을 지속하다 결국 놓아주는 그림이 되는 경우가 많거든요.. 결국 아직 끈을 놓고싶지 않았던 사람은 그냥 그렇게 남겨진채로 있는거에요. 아마 뮤비에서는 마지막에 아이유가 끈을 자르는 모습이 안나왔는데.. 그런걸 뜻하지 않았을까 싶어요.. 끈을 자르고싶지만 한번에 못잘라요... 남겨진 사람 입장에선.. 전혀 깔끔하지 않아요..ㅜ
어른들의 이별이 아니죠. 차라리 싸우고 헤어진게 낫다고 생각해요. 감정적으로 준비가 안되었는데 모든걸 앗아가는 상대를 보는것도, 싸울 가치도 없는 사람이었다 생각되는 나를 다독이는것도 너무 힘들었거든요. 상대의 행복을 비는건 거의 '내가 널 버리지만 그게 너한테 별일이 아니었음 좋겠다' 하는 자기위안이라고 생각해요 그냥 전부 다 위선같아요 저는
ㅠㅠ..
더 사랑하는 사람이 헤어짐을 당했을 때 그 감정을 너무 잘 표현한 가사와 뮤비..
1:36 I see that the owners of Hotel Del Luna and Hotel Blue Moon are getting along so well.
Your comment deserves thousand likes ❤
Huwah, i just realized. Look at what they wearing, it give so much hotel del luna vibe
thats what i've been saying!😂 the outfits give out that Hotel Del Luna vibes😂
Omg u're right
SAME!!!
South Korea is soo lucky to have IU. She's a gem. Amazing singer, actress, variety show guest, humanitarian activist, etc 😭
I think so. She’ve been loving by South Korea’s about more than 10 years. She has various capacity to become more talanted person. We can say that she is ‘treasure’.
@@ssbb7989 tbh she shd be called the nations treasure hahah
tho the nations little sister name still fits her cuz she looks like under 20 while her 27th (or in Korea 28th) birthday is coming in 3 days!!!
IU is just so amazing
@@ssbb7989 Not in the start...
이게 정말 연인이다. 서로 그렇게 좋아하다가 결국엔 끝나버리는 거. 마음이 찢어질 듯이 아파도 서로 담담한 척 괜찮은 척 혼자 앓다 잊어버리는 거.
😊
남겨진 사람은 결국 남은 감정을 스스로 끊어내야된다는 거 너무 잘 표현했다ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
명언을 남기시네요…😭😭
아이유는 진짜로 스펙트럼이 너무 넓다 동화면동화 판타지면판타지 감성이면감성
이런가수는 언제또 다른사람으로 어디서볼까
히트곡만몇개야...타이틀말고도 수록곡까지 기대하게만드는 찾아듣게만드는 아이유라 가능한일이 너무많다... 진짜 대단해 이런존재너무 한국에서 돋보적이야
ㅇㅈ
마! 아라 드러씀 대따 아이가?
앞으로 100년 안에 우리나라에서 아이유만큼의 인재가 나올거란 보장이 없음
우리나라에서 아이유정도의 여솔이 나올 수 있을까가 의문임 왠만한 그룹보다 히트곡이 많음ㅋㅋ
내가 지금 몇 번째 이 걸 보고있는지... 사랑해줄 꺼라며 다 뭐야...어떤 맘을 준건지 너는 모를꺼야.. 가사가 너무 아프다 ㅠ
인정
3:29 에 혹시 다칠까봐 바들바들 떨면서 앞머리를 잘라주던 가위로 바로 다음장면에 인연의 끈을 서로가 잘라주고 끝내 자기 스스로 잘라버리는 장면에서 울어버림..
눈물의여왕 보다가 여기까지 와버렸네..?
나두
저도!
이하동문
저도
알고리즘이 요즘 내 관심사를 잘 아네요.
뮤비가 진짜 연애부터 이별하는 과정 모두를 다 드러내주는거같아요. 채널로 사귀는 날짜를 묘사하는 것부터 시작해서, 남녀가 서로 좋게 기억하는게 다르듯 서로 다른 장면에서 웃는것도 그렇고, 줄에 메달린게 서로에 대한 기대라고 한다면 마지막에 스스로 가위로 끈을 자르듯 스스로 상대를 향한 기대를 져버려야한다는 슬픔과 비참함, 끊어도 끊어지지않는 지독한 미련.. 뮤비가 대단한거같아요 ..
He always choose IU over and over again 😭
Kim Soo Hyun's:
last movie before enlisting - Real (IU as a cameo)
Last drama before enlisting - The Producers (w/ IU)
Last mv before enlisting - Ending Scene (IU’s mv)
First drama cameo after enlistment - Hotel Del Luna (IU as main lead)
True... They are really close friends. I want to ship them so bad but I feel like them being close friends is better. 😀
Lousil Mae Paguta 2 days after discharged from military he came himself with food truck to hotel del luna staff and have a picture with IU
@@andreamarie685 "close friends" ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Dream high??
@@andreamarie685 I agree, I don't want them to have an ending scene in real life
How did she manage to translate a heartbreak so beautifully and painfully. This hits home. I really love her art.
Yes, but that song is so sad!
이거 진짜 헤어지고 들으면 다 공감이라 눈물 줄줄줄줄 정도가 아니라 그냥 오열하게 됨....... 특히 '사랑해줄거라며 다 뭐야' 이 부분
내먈이
내말이
내말이..
슬프다....ㅠㅠ
내말이
영상을 배우는 사람으로서 마지막 장면의 연출은 정말 본받고 싶습니다. 머리카락을 잘라주려던, 애틋하고 다정한 연인의 모습을 표현할 때 썼던 도구를 순식간에 두사람의 마음을 정리하고, 이별로 다가가는 도구로 전환시킬 생각을 어떻게 하셨는지 정말 대단한거 같습니다. 영상을 보면서 막 감동 받아서 눈물이 난다는건 과장 섞인 말이라고 생각했는데 저 장면을 볼 때 정말 소름돋고 눈물도 나네요.....
이세빈 진짜공감이요...뮤비한편본게 마치영화하나본듯하네요.. 아이유 목소리 너무 아련해요ㅠㅠ.. 이별한후에 들으면 진짜 펑펑울거같음ㅠㅠ
이세빈 5
뮤비찍으라니까 영화를 찍어놈..
맞아용 ㅠ.ㅜ
배워야 이렇게 보는구나 그냥 아이유이쁘다..이러면서봤는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
IU is really an artist she can make people think so deep whether they are a common person or an artist too regardless if who you are she can make you realize things through her song and relate it to your own life. She basically just wrote about what she is going through with love, family, career and her feelings but it can touch your heart how honest those words are. Like when she wrote Graduation Day, Voicemail, Bad Day, 23, Pallet, 25 and the rest of her song it reflect who she is and what she felt in those years and situation she went through. I've been a fan for 7 years but she never fail to amaze me every-time i thought i already know everything about her. I'm looking forward on what she will do again. I don't like her to be pressured by the expectation of others for me as long as she stay true to herself and love what she does i will continue to support her no matter what will happen. IU will always be precious in my heart. She made me realize that music doesn't have boundaries.
itsmenob2x she composed Graduation Day too? I never knew but I like that song a lot. I once wished it would be our highschool graduation song
itsmenob2x nc8thig9ti9digh
My boyfriend passed away 2 years ago. Before he go, he told me this too. The same what this song lyrics. it makes me cry :") miss him so much
Stay strong wish the best 💜
💖💝💋
I love you and you are not alone
Be strong girl🤍 You are not alone in this world🤍
You know he's in the better place love💓 Stay Strong 💖💖
첫사랑이 헤어질때 나한테 했던 말들과 그때 그 친구의 감정이 노래 가사랑 정말 많이 닮아서 더 아련한 노래.. 나 걱정하고 잘 되길 바라면서도 사랑은 식어있던 그 아이의 처연한 느낌이 아직도 느껴지는듯 하네요
IU is such a gem in the k-pop industry. She can tell a story with her music and that is not something you can see in a lot of successful singers whether kpop or just pop. I really love her and her music. It's such a pleasure to anticipate her music and hope to enjoy it for many many years to come. Love IU !
I feel so happy when there are many people can understand IU's music!! Thanks for your comments!!
yes her song always meaningful unlike others
really glad to know that i'm not alone in feeling/thinking like this.. !
i always love her music since the first time i discover kpop like 8 years ago
JK_blossom well i hope you knew Taylor Swift, Adele and Mariah Carey
OMG, I just melted when Kim Soo Hyun covered IU's forehead so that she won't get hurt when he opened the cupboard. 😍 So much kilig!
Ayuyuyuyu pilipino siya
Yup! and I'm proud to be one!
Ryo Mateo kilig overload. 😍
Me is so so kilig kilig yong umabot na sa point na nangingisay na ako
hahaha LOL. Okay k naman?
남겨진 사람은 먼저 떠나간 사람보다 끊어내기 더 힘든 감정까지 .....
배경은 비현실적 동화같은 예쁜 뮤비지만
담은 내용은 지극히 현실적인 뮤비네요 ....
IU's song is her story, I cry when I think of her story
2024년에 눈물의여왕보고 김수현광팬되서 여기왓어요 김수현❤
Same here💙
아직도 보러 오는 사람... 노래도 노래지만 뮤비도 여운이 오짐..
기분 안좋을때마다 보러와요... 최소 50번은 넘게본듯요
아 진짜 작성자님 말씀이 맞는 듯..
또 왔다 갑니다..
ㅜㅠ
ㄹㅇ... 노래 처음 들었을 땐 아 슬프다... 하고 말았는데 뮤비 보고 진짜 개처울엇음
I'm tearing up like I just went through a break. IU knows how to write a song that, even if you can't relate to the subject, you can still feel the emotions.
I came here once a month just to remember the tragic breakup that I never had.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
😂
LMAOO
OMG same!!
sounds like a good ritual.
이게 벌써 7년 전이라니😢 예뻤다 둘이
I just want to give IU a proper credits for the song and the music video. She just executes everything perfectly. I would say that during a break up, no song can ever describe how you truly feels but IU made it in this video. From the warm beginning, the conversation, the flashback of the break up, the words that the guy said, to the very end. Break up is like this. You basically cut off each others string in order to be happy, to just let go once you know it is not meant to be, again - this is not easy. The metaphor of the strings describes the attachment of being in a relationship. We cut off the strings, but - we have to cut off our own string in order to completely let go and move on. IU describes it painfully beautiful.
mina mina I am really amaze on how you explain everything 💓
Now I understand it
Okay, now I understand this mv..
Indeed. I hope people do come back to this song of they needed healing during a tough period of time and hopefully, people would be able to see comments like this again and feel that they are not alone in this.
이 뮤비에서 아이유 진짜 이쁘다.... 원래도 이쁘지만 특히 이 뮤비랑 잠못드는밤 비는내리고 뮤비에서..
아이유도 넘 이쁘고 그 매력 그대로 잘 살려주시는 코디?? 디자이너분들도 대박인듯
This song is so sad to the point of devastating and heartbreaking... and I feel it deep to the core.
iLLiya Nasir I can't understand Korean can you tell me what the song is about and why is it sad?
You can click the CC at the bottom right of the video to turn on the English caption.
한쿸말 좋아요~
iLLiya Nasir please go check my cover of this song and give me ur opinion
Hmm yeah it's definitely a song to add to a breakup playlist :""")
This is about someone with avoidant attachment style that abruptly left the relationship. It's heartbreaking but IU is trying to remember him in the best light possible. It is an issue of attachment style - psychological issue. The scene of them both cutting cords for each other is literally spot on. That's what I just had to do with someone. Crazy she went through this at that age.
마지막 김수현이 마지막 남은 끈 자를 때 아이유 표정이 다했다 ㅠ 저 표정이 젤 슬픔 눈물 흘리는것도 아닌데도 애절하다
이 댓글보고 다시 돌려봤는데... 정말 정말 마음 아프네요..
힘들 때마다 '제대로 잘 먹어. 다 지나가니까. 예전처럼 잠도 잘 자게 될 거야. 진심으로 빌게. 너는 더 행복할 자격이 있어 ' 이 부분 들으려고 이 노래 찾아들음
나도..
100일남았다.. 매일매일이 지치지만 조금만 더... 버티자
@@DoWhatYouLoveDan 정말로 정말로.. 화이팅이예요
100일후의 우리를 생각하고 열심히해요🌙🙇🏻♀️
sisi obvio todos los dias claro clarisimo concuerdo xd
프사도 참 힘든것 같네요
the most heartbreaking thing about this song, is that everybody can relate to it in one way or another. the meaning is not limited to a romantic relationship, it applies to all.
Amy Cross this comment hits the spot 🥺
5년전 헤어질때 이노래 듣고 얼마나 많이 울었는지, 그만큼 많이 울고나니 정화가 되더라. 나도 언젠간 나같은 사람을 만나 또다시 좋은 사랑할 수 있길
그후로 사귀셨나요??
@@박선영-j8r 안타깝게도 그 뒤로 연애 안하고 있어요. 소개팅도 한번도 안받아봤고요~ 근데 올해는 개인적으로 좀 노력해서 다시 좋은사람 만나려고 시도해보려고 합니다!
IU is honestly one of the most amazing artists that i have ever heard, her voice is just pure perfection, filled with such provoking emotion- Im at a loss for words (sorry I'm a new fan :) )
Her fandom name is Uaena. As a fan of 7 years...let me tell you that its worth every moment to be her fan.
Maybe it's just me but... from the hesitancy, words, and contrasting expressions between the girl and the boy... I get the feeling that the guy is cheerful, lighthearted, easily liked and accepted by others but the girl is more reserved, slow to trust, and hides her true emotions/facial expressions/depth of love because she is afraid of being vulnerable and takes longer to open up to others. She is thoughtful and internalizes everything, but often protects her inner self from the outside world unless she is sure that person can truly understand and accept her and will not try to tie her down or change her. But the guy mistakes this as hesitancy/lack of commitment... her reserved nature and need to protect herself before she can open up to her loved ones is mistaken as selfishness and loving herself more than anyone else when in actuality she just doesn't know how to show the depth of her feelings for the guy. Before she can even properly process the storm of emotions inside of her he starts misunderstanding her and saying things like ("maybe one day you can find someone who loves you more than you love yourself"), it makes it even more difficult to open up and be honest, "Oh... this whole time I was quietly beside him, he couldn't even see... could he even understand or believe my feelings? What if they have grown too much, what if it pushes him away? How can he show his love so easily, why can't he see what I cannot say...?" He mistakes her reserved nature for coldness... yet she is the one who floats easier than him and does not fall as hard in the moments that they fall a little. I think this means her feelings ran deeper and her internal commitment was actually stronger, she just couldn't express it in a way he could recognize (she says herself he'll never know the feelings he made her feel), which is why he much more easily cut his strings in the end. Funny how she was in essence blamed for being the "selfish" one when it was he who gave up first. It looks like truly, in the end, he really wasn't someone she could trust to show her true self to because he gave up before she even had the chance... he basically proved her fears right, which would make it even more difficult to open up in the future. I love the palpable pain you can feel in her voice and in the lyrics but how her facial expressions look cold and detached and misunderstood/alone. It shows the contrast/battle between her inner world and what she shows on the surface. In the end she just looks tired and alone, sort of like she expected him to give up on her but it still hurts anyway.
Additionally, at the beginning, you can count the strings tied to each person, and IU (representing the girl) has more.
Crystal and Noel your explanations gave me goosebumps... it's so sad... :(
Crystal and Noel
I can somehow relate this to MLSHR also.. Wang So has the personality of the girl (singing in this song) and Hae Soo has the boy's personality..
so melancholic..
ohmygod you explained everything so well.....i'm sad
this is the explanation i didn't know i needed til now omygod this is so on point
“You told me you’ll love me...what is this?” This line hit me so hard💔
Moon Yoongi me too 😭😭
same T_T
Yesss... Perfect song for divorcing celeb couples right now
Yeh when i heard of songsong couple's divorce i remember this song speacially that songsong couple are fans of IU i can imagine they listen to this song and cry (SORRy for my bad english)good day for every one 😍😍💜💜💜
Same😭💔
watching this now while also watching QOT this song and mv suits the drama so well… the mv looks like lovers’ memories slowly fading away just like Haein slowly forgeting hyunwoo
IU lyrics are always best 💛
The most of the singers makes songs about couple breaking, based on a hate relation thing, but IU takes the side of when both still loves each other but at the same time realize that is not healthy to stay, just something warm and precious to heard and cry here.
I think of it also..were same,actually this song i think for her and his x-bf jang kiha.
OMG this hit way to close to home. As soon as I read your comment I started crying... Me and my ex have being dating this last few weeks, and I still love I try I really try to make everything work but it is just not the same... It just doesn't work and I'm getting crazy I have improved myself, changed a lot of toxic things about myself but it doesn't work.... Fuck I hate all of this, I really love her but it just doesn't work...
I really dont understand bcoz bse on this MV they still love each other,i was thinking bout relationship is all about love but this mv show us that even how much u cared for each other or you loved each other there are certain things that also needed to fullfill the heart of both of you.It seems uneasy to understand this situation but for me love is not enough to stay in a relationship if it is not healthy and hve no spArk anymore better to stop and ask yourself if you are willing to stay.
@@adeletonggal5285 Indeed. And caring for someone and being worried for their well-being doesn't make it valid for one to ignore the fact that they've fallen out of love or just can't love the other as much as to be in a proper romantic relationship.
At times like these, letting go may be painful but it's better than dragging on what's going to be inevitable and spoiling the feelings both have for each other.
이런엔딩.. 뮤비는 정말... 모든 연인들의 이별 과정을 보여주는거 같아요 먹먹해지는 뮤비..
IU is basically just competing with herself on the charts. She did that. Legend.
yeah :)
I think she's overshadowing her self. This could have had more views, if it hadn't been released a few days after Palette. To me, it's the best song of the three singles!
Yup
can anyone please listen to choi youngjae ft. j.praize - call button. you're welcome
bulan sabit merah malaysia wilayah ?? :)
지금도 보러오는사람 나만있는거아니지? 정말 개인적으로 아이유뮤비중에서 원탑이다...
아이유 노래 중에서 제일 좋다고 할 수 없지만 이별 노래 중 최고라고 생각합니다.
저요~~ 듣고있어요
저도 듣고있습니다 😂
I am here to feel the pain of my non existent break up..
Lol same
🤣🤣😭🤣🤣
Hmm samee😂😂
Same :)
me too... Lol
IU is my girl crush. You are strong but you have soft side too. You are calm like lake but you are brave.
IU’s voice literally reaches out and touches your soul. She’s my fav female Kpop artist, i find her so different from other kpop artists smhow and her voice is so soothing, the lyrics are amazing 💜
Riri Spellman jungkooks cover touched my freakin soul
same
IU is SO ugly so just because you’re talking about I U DONT MEAN I HAVE TOO I CAME HERE FROM JK AND ITS MY OPINION that his cover was better
jolie aranda now saying that is outright rude on the artist’s mv..maybe not say sht that gives bad image of our fandom :/
IU is perfect idol. She can sing, rap, dance. Produce her own songs. Can act. She is also so good model. Natural pretty. Have kind and sweet personality. Strongest idol. How can people hate her? I love you IU, so much. You are best solist ever
The saddest part of this MV for me is the last 10 seconds. While we watched him let go…we didn’t actually see her let go too. So while he’s gone, the possibility of her still being hung up on him remains. Sad tbh.
연극같은 독특한 구성에 담담한 표정과 상징으로 가득한 표현들. 거기에다 아픈 가사가 내 심장을 후벼파....ㅠㅠ
I kind of want IU and Kim Soo Hyun to pair up in a new drama again. I miss them. They have chemistry. I think y'all could see it just from this MV.
Ikr. I started listening to IU only recently, after watching them in Producers and when I saw the thumbnail for this video, I was so happy thinking I could see them be a happy couple here. What I got was heartbreak.
And second lead man goes to Lee Hyun Woo. That's mean complete.
Where can I watch these dramas? And other kdramas as well?
MOARMY xoxo Viki and Netflix
@@makaylagrant873 thanks! Is Viki a website?
눈물의여왕에 미쳐서 여기까지왔네..
김수현에 미쳐서 여기까지..
@@Sooman-e9v 저도요ㅎㅎ
이번 뮤비는 진짜 성공적이고 의미가 애틋하고 좋은 것 같다ㅠㅠㅠ거기에 갓이유 목소리는 환상적...☆
her chat-shire album came out around when i started university. i had trouble making friends and those songs became my friend. years have passed and i feel gloomy and even though i made friends i can't talk to them. so her songs will be my company again. thank you for coming back IU.
I just cried. This song has such a beutiful and heartbreaking meaning. The vido Is even more heartbreaking.
Same I was also😭😭😭
this will always be my favourite song from IU. When i first listened to this i was so innocent, though it was sad i didn’t understand the depth and meaning of this song and mv.. and yet now ironically im going through the exact same thing in this mv.. almost as if i am IU. My first love, my first breakup and first heartbreak.. we kept hurting each other, he said the exact same words, that someday i will find someone better to love me the way i needed to be loved.. it hurt even more hearing that. This song explains every feeling and thought that im going through right now.. “You told me that you’ll love me.. what is this?” hits me so bad I’d never thought that this would happen to me but here we are.. everytime i hear this i get so emotional but yet so comforted. 💔
I never experienced a painful breakup before but this song gave me such raw, heartbreaking emotions every time I listen to it. IU really is a genius when it comes to delivering feels to her singing
girl be ready cuz that sh!t is painful than getting all of your tooth removed without anesthesia xD
@@gfdchugh really, come on
@@gfdchugh😢 exactly
The song is a masterpiece. The MV is powerful.
IU spoke to our hearts through this ballad. There are a lot of sad songs out there but this particular song was arranged & interpreted with much emotions, that's why even if someone doesn't know the exact lyrics, he/she can still feel the sadness, hurt or even the pain. Some even said that this song made them miss their non-existent ex-boyfriend. The magic of the song doesn't simply rely on its relatability, its magic comes from the universal concept of "goodbyes" and letting go. The most powerful part of the MV is the cutting of strings. So, even if you haven't experienced a break-up or being dumped, you will still get affected because in this life, we have all experienced a loss & a rejection that pushed us to move on or accept the things we can't change.
You can listen to this song while thinking of the saying "all good things come to an end" which makes this song an anthem for things or people you need to cut strings with because life wants you to.
This can be a song for your bias (someone so distant to you) but at some point decided to change his/her direction so you must move on too. This can also be a song for a group/band that disbanded for personal reasons, no matter how attached you are to them, you'll need to let go. This can also be a song for a Kdrama you deeply loved but after 16-20 episodes has to end or for a TV series which has to end after several seasons. This can also be your song for your fangirl/fanboy life in general because you can't stay like that forever. Youth passes and priorities change. That's how powerful the song is, "Ending Scene" will always make us cry for it will always remind us of the things we had to let go for us to go on and begin a new chapter.
IU & Kim Soo Hyun did a good job. The expressions & gestures they did were on-point. Palette album is my album of the year! :)
Beautiful comment :)
The MV was already emotional. But reading this beautiful comment got me more into my feels
now im crying even more cuz of this amazing comment
Well said. Wow
Indeed, everyone who worked on this video, from those involved in the music like Sam Kim and IU, to the directors, actors and staff who helped made this amazing.
And your comment is indeed magical. My heart is all warm and fuzzy now thanks to you!
the verses where Kim Soo Hyun lip sing are from the guy's perspective. So he was telling the girl those words. It's not just mere lip singing.
IU wrote this song from both the girl's and guy's perspective. Like a conversation. Similar to what she did with Peach.
Pure genius!!!
And that jam jam insert is also so well-played. Jam Jam is like the prelude to the relationship.
Sotong_Q I thought so too and it's making it more heartbreaking for me. 😭😭
I agree, it is. 👍
areum Sam Kim composed it but IU wrote the lyrics
IU Lee Jieun is such inspiring musician T_T
I absolutely love IU's lyrics TT
Precious Kidoh no iu wrote it.
2024 TH-cam recomend this mv when i watch drama "queen of tears"
Me too 😅😅
same
Everytime the girl hold the remote, it's like everything in the past has appeared again, so vividly. She is happy, but is painful at the same time. The lyrics is like from both of them; it's the message from the boy for her when he leave her, and also her hope that he should not be painful, because she don't want to see him suffering everyday. The ending is so hurt, but it's not miserable. Both of them always want the other to be happy. They just want to help the other to escape from the pain. As you can see at the ending, the girl also cut the strings, because she would like her love to be truly relieve and be away from all the pain, and finally the boy cut it himself to be truly escape himself from such a scenario.
The ending scene is sad but not miserable, because we know that they always keep the image of the other deep in their heart. I love this music video so much, from the lyrics to the content and effects of the MV. Thank you IU for her excellent product this time, and long time no see but congratulation Kim Soo Hyun because you have done a good job
Huy Nhat this comment need to risee T_T 👍👍👍
Huy Nhat crying
Huy Nhat huhuhuu
Huy Nhat thank you a lot coz
.....i ws almost blank abt the mv's meaning...so thank you a lot
Huy Nhat, Feeling every bit of it... Thx
Don't worry. You are not the only one listening to this masterpiece on May 2022.
🥺💜
Ooppsss HAHA
It will never get old 🥳
April 😩✊
@@hyunjinsdinosaur4553 april 8
세상에나... 수현아 리얼말고 이런 말끔하고 말끔한 로맨틱만 찍자 ㅠㅠ 넘 이뿌다 아이유랑 김수현 ㅠㅠ
I kept coming to this song for the past 5 years and yet everytime I listen my eyes fill up with tears...every time I come, I find a new meaning to the lyrics and it is only now that I've fully understood it. I relate so much to it...I can see myself in the girl's position. Someone else in the comment section has already analysed it perfectly so I'm not gonna repeat the same thing. I love it no matter how much it makes me cry....legendary song. Does IU know how many people are touched by this?...she made a masterpiece🌟
I agree! I’ve loved this song for years 🤍
I totally agree with you. :( whenever someone breaks my heart I will listen to This and cry like mad.
I agree! until now im still into this. And I'm still crying every time i hear this song 🥺 I remember the encore part when IU sung this during her concert here in Manila. Im so touch with the phone lights swaying while singing this.
你知道IU的故事
@@火百合-z9q
아이유는
한국을 대표하는 가수이면서 배우입니다.
아티스트입니다.
그리고
개인적인 인생도
그 누구보다 잘 삽니다.
앞으로도 그럴겁니다.
팬들도 함께 잘 삽니다.
함께 잘 사실꺼구요.
알면 알수록 매력있는 가수를 만나기는 쉽지 않습니다.
아이유가
그런 가수라서
진심으로 행복합니다.
나와 너(I-U)이기에
오늘과 미래의
우리들의 마음을
대표하는
멋진 사람입니다.
멋진 예술인입니다.
우리는
이런 사람들을
아티스트라고 합니다.
아무나
아티스트일 수는 없는겁니다.
다시보니까 너무 슬픈 뮤비네요. 왼쪽위에 CH01 이렇게 남녀 둘의 첫날부터를 채널처럼 돌려보는 아이유 시점인것같아요. 그러고 애인과의 옛채널 즉 과거를 돌려보면서도 남자친구가 최근에 헤어지자고 하면서 "잘먹고 다녀, 주는게 쉽지가 않아 등등" 라고 했던 말이 생각나는 형식이네요.키스하던 애인이 같은 옷을 입고 헤어졌을때의 말을 하는거 보면 CH10 에서의 추억을 떠올리면서도 이랬던남자가 결국엔 이런엔딩으로 이런 말을 하는구나를 비교하는것같구요. 너무 슬프네여 ㅠㅠ 나 자신도 행복하게 연애할때 언젠가 지금의 애인이 헤어지자고 하는 모습이 미래에있을까라며 슬퍼한적이있는데 그걸 음악으로 만들구 심리를 잘 표현한 뮤비 👍
맞아여
Jess Park 그 와중에 한국인을 드디어 찾았네 ㅎㅎ
4년이 지난 지금에서야 온전히 알 거만 같다 나온 순간에도 앨범 수록곡 중 가장 마음에 들었던 곡이라 뮤비해석도 많이 찾아보았음에도 불구하고 지금 또 다시보니 이제서야 정말로 알 거만 같은 이 느낌… 스트로베리문에서 사랑에 빠진 상황을 무중력으로 표현했는데 여기서도 마찬가지네 아이유가 표현하는 사랑을 알 거만 같다
나두 스스로 잘라낼 수 있을까?
I'm not sure if my translator was wrong to translate your comment, but if you're having a hard time, fighting. Even if the pain doesn't seem to end, over time everything will get better.
It hurts more when people say "You deserve better" or "You deserve to be happy w someone else" it's easier when the person cheats or hurts you because you're angry. But when they still show some kind of affection it's harder to move on because you can't hate them.
girlgroup stan ㅔ1ㅃㅃ1
This is why I'm breaking up with my boyfriend, because he honestly deserves someone who loves him as much as he loves her. I just can't be the one. But this song is making me cry,. I wish relationships weren't so complicated...
Why can't you be the one? You just don't love him? For no reason?
J Kay 뀨뀨ㅅㅅㅆㅆㄲㄱㄱㄱㅆㄲㄲ666777료ㅅ66ㅅㅇ
from my experience i don't think it shows affection but yes it hurts even more,way more.
he said exactly this to me when I decided to break up with him.
I was angry that he doubted my choice to be with him coz he was supposed to be the "better one". I chose him.
then I knew I was completely wrong right at the moment he said this to me.
It hurt so much when it came from a person you loved.
I realised he didn't love me enough to say anything better than that, to save our relationship.
It hurt but also I knew I made the right choice, I really deserve better.
Ending Scene 🤝🏻 Love Wins All
김수현 아이유 껴안기전 표정봐ㅋㅋㅋ아 씹덕사하겠다ㅋㅋㅋ 둘이 넘 설렌다ㅠㅠ 캐미 오진다 승찬이랑 신디 생각나 둘이 주연인 드라마 한편 더 찍어주세요 이곡 들을수록 명곡이네 뮤비도 명작
J MJ 아 이 뮤비보면서 왜케 둘이 잘어울리지? 했는데 프로듀사였어 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 둘이 너무 좋다 ㅠㅠ
@@user-eunyeong + 학교배경으로 1개 더찍음
고런데 이름이 생각이 안나네...
수정)아 맞다 드림하이
드림하이부터인가 김수현하고 아이유하고 친한것 같아요 드라마나 영화에 가장 많이 나온 배우 탤런트 아닐까 싶음 ㅋㅋ 이것까지 다섯번임 드림하이 프로듀사 호텔델루나 리얼 이런엔딩
YOU'RE TELLING ME ENDING SCENE HAS AN MV AND I NEVER KNEW
WHERE THE HECK HAVE YOU BEEN ALL THIS TIME SON
Omg
Damn what this was years ago??? Skskskssk
Highkey same I didn’t know this exist either and now I’m crying 😭
same lol i didn't even know that this mv exist
우는 장면 하나없이 슬프네요..
2022년 3월 아직도 보러옵니다.. 내 인생 뮤비 중에 가장 최고의 뮤비
“For the times you were lonely, I hope you can find someone who can love you more than the love you’re giving me…. I’m sorry that person isn’t me”
-- IU 💚🍀
Actually that is what the partner said, not IU
@@dangchauanh what i meant was it was written by iu 🙂
The guy said that to her 😢
So is this the ost in their series THE PRODUCTION?
I think this was something her ex bf told her 😭😭
Let’s be honest, you came here to cry
I cry every damn time :(
Claire Ngo it’s good to release the sadness ;) take care
@@exoscalmfan191 thank you
just came to thi mv and had a heavy sob. you see right through me
meredith f make sure you let ppl see through you sometimes, makes it easier for them to understand and be there for you. 🤗
솔직히 아이유 노래는 다 좋지만 개인적으로 이름에게랑 이런엔딩이 제일 심금 울리고 좋은거 같다,,
뮤비 그렇게 찾아보는 사람아닌데
이 뮤비는 진짜 잊히지가 않아
悲傷的mv , 最後真的離開這個人
뮤비가 너무 슬픔
the part "geureon mareun haji ma jebal (please dont say those words)" really broke my heart into pieces. there's so much emotion in her voice. That sadness,suffering,disappointed...sorrowful...OMG IU-ah,u make me cry without a reason~😭😭😭
ive never even been in a proper relationship and now I feel all heartbroken
me too. I thought my career life was bad but my love life is even worse. :(
I was never in a relationship but I feel heartbroken.
Relatable 😂👌🏻
same
Janice Han feellllll you girl
Came here after Kim Soo-hyun posted his version of IU's Celebrity. I'm so glad we have content like this. They're so good together!!!
SooU
WAITING FOR A KDRAMA
What did he posted??
눈물의 여왕이 나를 여기까지 오게 만드네
하... 아이유 이번 앨범 모든 노래가 너무나도 완벽하게 좋다 ㅠㅠㅠ
아이유가 헤어지는 두 사람이 대화하는 내용으로 작사했다고 하네요. 이걸 몰랐을 때는 아이유가 혼자 다 불러서, 뭔가 가사가 약간 연결되지 않는 느낌이 들었는데, 두 사람이 헤어지면서 주고 받는 대화라는 걸 알고 들으면 자연스러움
Fumble Dog 그걸 모르고 가사를 봐도 대화형태로 보이지 않나요? 신기하네..
ㅇㅈ 딱히 몰라도 딱 들으면 바로 알겠던데
만약에 몰랐더라도 김수현이 아이유가 부르는 가사를 입모양으로 전하고 있으니 뮤비를 보면 알았겠네요!
Still crying every time I hear this song it’s heartbreaking
I absolutely love IU and V's duet that I came to listen to the original song...V always introduces me to great songs. I'm so Thankful!
Seriously I can't get over Taehyung's different color of voice in this duet.
Taehyung is in this song or u talking about love wins all ?!
새벽 감성 터트리네 진짜 사람 서럽게 수 십번을 들어도 계속 슬퍼진다 그 만큼 소중하고 고맙고 해줄 수 있는게 앨범 사는 거 밖에 없어서 미안해요
kelly kim 죄송하지만 띄어쓰기 제대로 해주세요
박지원 당사자 분께서 가만히 계신데 별걸다 트집잡으시네ㅎㅎ 그리고 좀 틀린게 아니라 많이 틀리셔서 말한거에요ㅎㅎ 저 보라고 댓 단게 아니여도 띄어쓰기 같은건 지켜야죵
박지원 일부러 두세번씩 띄웁니까?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그리고 제 댓글이 어디가 불편했죠?ㅋㅋㅋ 그냥 띄어쓰기 제대로 해달라고 부.탁 한건데^^
박지원 그리고 저도 님 보라고 댓단게 아니에요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 님은 그렇게 말하면서 오만가지 다 신경쓰시네요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
박지원 댓다는거 자유인거 아시는 분이 제가 댓단거 왜 뭐라하세요?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
지은아 노래해줘서 고마워 위로해줘서 고마워 너를 처음 만난 몇 년 전, 매년 그리고 지금 현재까지도 네 음악을 들을 수 있어서 감사하고 행복해 이지은 사랑해
이수빈 ㅇㅈ
Who's here admiring IU's beautiful voice and Kim Soo Hyun's beautiful face?? ME!
QUEEN IU!!!
Ivy Chan also IU's beautiful face.
salle choi yeah~ remember his song DREAMING?
진짜 뮤비 최고… 노래 들으면 뮤비 자동 재생돼서 오랜만에 보러 옴ㅜ
번역 좋다는 댓글이 꽤 보여서 영어 자막 틀어봤는데 “어떤 마음을 준 건지 너는 모를 거야” 부분이 상대방이 나에게 어떤 슬픔을 느끼게 한 건지 쪽으로 번역되었네요. 그동안 “내가 너에게 어떤 마음(사랑)을 줘왔던 건지 넌 모를 거야” 쪽으로 들어왔었는데 이것도 중의적으로 들을 수 있는 가사였던 거겠죠… 새롭게 아름답다…
뮤비 진짜 잘찍었다 스토리 다 맞고 안에 의미도 다 너무 슬프고
this is such a sad song and i relate to this song so much. Personally, I think the most heartbreaking part was "I hope you found someone that can love you more than you love yourself". its like somehow, those of us who love ourselves too much are seen as a threat? inconvenient? hard to handle or love? and it is such a sad thing. i hope those that have experienced this or are the type of person people always consider hard to love, will find love so big, so selfless, and so encompassing that you end up being more in love with yourself for being the way you are :) (it can come from anyone, doesnt necessarily have to be from special someone)
To me the line "I hope you find someone who will love you more than you love yourself" means that she has *very little* love for herself, so he wants her to find someone who can appreciate and cherish her because she doesn't.
Or maybe that's just what I understood because I hate myself lol
@@junehoneycrisp It certainly can be interpreted in that way and I personally feel that's the meaning for me especially since I know of so many people who are able to love others and are so giving. And yet they can't seem to love themselves as much, deeming themselves as less important or unworthy of love compared to everyone else.
The lyrics are written to be quite vague so it can be either the girl being too selfless/loving while the boy being more unwilling/"selfish" or the other way round so basically the girl being unwilling/"selfish" and the boy being more selfless/loving.
Like how 2:23 "It's not easy to give my heart to you" from the boy's perceptive is likely to seem like he can't really open up/trust the girl but it can also be interpreted as the boy trying to trust the girl but he finds it difficult if she doesn't trust him.
And 3:26 "Like you said, one day can I be loved by someone like me?" seems to be implying that the girl is either
1. Unwilling to open up and can't seem to love anyone other than herself for now so how can she find someone like her that matches with her if they both love/appreciate themselves more before loving each other
Or
2. How the girl can find that someone just as selfless/loving as her and would love the girl even more than themselves just like how she initially loved the boy?
So what do you guys think? :3
@@uwuangel1998 this actually happened to me recelty. It was that ..we were both selfish? He left me bcuz he didnt want to see me anymore, whom he had hurt rly bad cuz it would be too painful to see some1 u love that was really hurt by u. And i was also selfish for wanting to still wanting to be together despite the fact that him seeing me would sting his heart.
I guess thats the opening heart to some1 in the lyrics was that he didnt want to become vunerable n thus left.
And i think that the number 2, last one was really accurate, at least on my part.
@@ayurax People fall in and out of love for various reasons and everyone is different in how they interact with people, how they love each other or even feel loved by people. Unfortunately it does not always end up in a happy ending, especially if people work and feel differently about certain things.
But that's all the more reasons why don't you worry! Because every connection you have ever made is a step closer to getting to know who is the right one for you. And I'm sure there's more people who will be by your side, loving you just the way you are as friends, family and even more than all that: that special someone out there who's also wondering about you, waiting for you to come into their lives!
I wish you all the best and stay strong~ 💕💖💜💜
@@uwuangel1998 tysm uwu
둘다 존예존잘...아이유목소리꿀성대 미친ㅠㅜㅜㅠㅜㅠㅜㅜㅠ 요즘 아이유때문에 시험공뷰가안ㅢ대......ㅜㅠㅜㅜㅜ누ㅜㅠㅠㅜㅠㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠㅠㅜ
이효정 효종이당
미친 ㄲㅋㅋㄱㅋ
뮤비 졵나슬퍼미친ㅠ
효정이 시험잘쳐
당장 오늘 시험인데...... 아이유 넘 이쁘다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아이유 노래는 내가 어떤 일이 있어도 다른사람들이 날 상처내고 떠날때에도 항상 내 옆을 지켜준것 같아 ❤️🩹
아이유 언니 고마워💖
1.37-1.42 they're looks like CEO hotel del luna & CEO hotel blue moon
Hahaha I think so too
I was about to write comment like this tho 😂
that's because they are
ahh the memories:(
Lol 😅🤣🤣🤣
Awwww watching this made me remember all their dramas together:
1. Dream High
2. The Producers
3. Hotel Del Luna
😭😭😭 It's really good to hear that they're really close friends
Why did BlackPink Fan came here??!!
Are You going to be IU Fan Now??!!
@@humanb5090 umm...so does that mean that if I'm a BLINK, I can't be an IU stan? That's just messed up BRUH! I love all kinds of K-pop and that doesn't mean that if u stan another idol or group, you can't stan another one😤
@@blinkiesugar7476 lmao i agree also i might rewatch Dream high it's the series that made me find IU and fall for her
Does IU appear in Dream High?
If that's so, I'll definitely watch it but I have a lot of kdramas to watch
2021? Who’s still can’t move on with this MV?🥺🥺🥺
Me ✋
here
Bruh,I still listen to this song like everyday😀
Still wiping some tears
@@quianaquinanola1107 lol I was about to say that 😳
2024년에 보고 있는 사람 손~👏
냉동인간인가요ㅠㅠ 멋져요ㅠ
🙋
전 2032년 입니다
I'm so glad Kim Soo Hyun agreed to take part in the music video because their chemistry is amazing!
Who needs a bias when you have BTS
YOUR USER IS THE TRUTH OF LIFE PREACH 🙌🙌
Trangela Yo thank you 💜
지금까지 들었던 그 어떤 이별노래보다 슬프다.
천사 ㅇ응
This is probably the most beautiful MV I've ever watched.
the motherfucking truth has been spoken
Stone Cold Steve Austi
Pallette by IU overcame this MV already Aline Souza
Aline Souza agree
Playing ending scene after IU got dating news. Before everything, I really love their friendship and low-key expecting for dating news soon. But yeah I just hope they continue being such a good friend even uri IU's got her bf. And continue sending food cart on drama set, Soohyun's continue doing IU song challenge, and attending one another movie premiere night.
Congrats Jieunahh u found love. I hope you become even more happy everyday now.