Great analysis Joe! You were right that as a debut album, Jay Chou was lacking in funds and resources but he made up for it with his music talent! He was actually writing music for others back then but it was not well received by the superstars as ballads were more popular in Chinese music. Mr JR Yang spotted his music talent and recommended that he sang his own compositions instead... and so his debut album was launched and a music legend was born! 💖
Hey, Joe! Great stuff! There was a big music show called the big band (乐队的夏天) in China. It was a phenomenal show two years ago. It got some interesting band and music in it. Maybe you can watch it yourself or with your friends give your thoughts on Chinese bands. I think it would be great and fun.
He's a composer who sings his own songs and also raps. A rapper is different. Rappers specialize in freestyle, rap battles, clever rhyme schemes, lyricism, etc. Jay Chou is a musician who is really good at rapping in his songs, but he's technically not a rapper. It would be like calling Jason Mraz or Ed Sheeran rappers. They're songwriters.
我至今仍珍藏着这张专辑，这首歌是我心中周杰伦最优秀作品，辨识度太高了，在一堆情情爱爱的歌里显得特别有意思
这简直就是教父级的启蒙，我们很幸运中文流行歌有这样的艺术存在
Jay的唱片在當年就是少數一張專輯中每一首歌都很好聽的，不像其他歌手只有主打歌好聽剩下的都像是充數
不能再赞同！周杰伦每张专辑，每首歌都是非常认真非常精心制作的。不过别的歌手也不是不愿意去精心制作每首歌，只是因为他们都没有像周杰伦一样的创作天赋，他们只能收歌，收歌的质量参差不齐是没办法的事。
第一张专辑，最让我惊喜又好玩的就是这首歌。他真的是个好玩的音乐天才。
周杰倫的第一張 專輯全都超好聽的
超級喜歡他的第一張專輯
風格非常多元。娘子 相反時間的鐘
完美主義。印地安老斑鳩。黑色幽默，龍捲風幾乎整張專輯都很喜歡。那時後第一次聽到就發現和當時的音樂風格完全不同等級，當然很像國外音樂風格很重背景音樂和旋律經典啊
第一次听到《娘子》的时候我是震惊的。因为之前所有江湖或者说武侠题材的歌，都硬要去迎合所谓古风，无论是作曲编曲还是歌词的遣词造句，都有些矫揉造作。《娘子》完全是另一种产物，却反而让人觉得更像是一个江湖人的心声。
反方向的钟
@@dionydonny 娘子真的超神
我當時反而最喜歡這首歌。。。但是唱不了
@@MGTmonkey 不好聽
Wow thank you Joe for reacting on this one!! This really is my favourite song in Jay’s debut album!!!
superb debut album by Jay
當年那張專輯，我其實最喜歡的就是這首歌，可惜鮮少有共鳴的夥伴。
那是周杰倫第一張專輯（有點試水溫的感覺），有時候不是精不精緻的問題，而是本身創意和態度非常吸引人。
然後，在台灣歌壇造成轟動。
現在的周杰倫我不多評論，但是當年的周杰倫真的像是一個奇異點，而且是真正土生土長受台灣教育文化長大的創作者所端出來的作品（畢竟同時也有王力宏和陶喆在前），然後也被主流市場接受了，這真的是不可思議呀！
boombap的beat加上jazz的編曲，到現在還是很讓人驚豔的前衛做法
編曲就是吊打黃雨熏
this is definitely one of his hidden/overlooked gems. It's so ahead of its time in terms of the arrangement and harmony.
Bizarre songs like this are among my favorites of Jay's music! Thank you for another great review!
Didn’t expect u review this.!
反方向的钟 is an interesting song also. Thanks for your review.
這也是我在這張專輯最愛的歌
周杰伦歌里真的什么主题都有，爱情，亲情，友情，无厘头，环保，反战，国风，真的是非常有才华的人，编曲也真的令人意想不到，早期他的歌真的没首都好听，他真的很难被超越！！！！！
我希望聽到更多關於周杰倫的歌曲專業分析，周杰倫的好歌實在太多，影響大部份人的青春
二十年来华语流行乐坛第一天才。
這首歌 其實是洪敬堯老師 編的
曲風跟編排 你完全看的出來
是，隨時都能聽得出大師的編曲。還有jay自己喜歡的dup 和聲。
弦樂就聽鐘興民。
現在？黃雨熏真的。。。。。。無話可說
这首歌虽然没有特别红 但真的好好听😊
不知道他知不知道？這張專輯的和聲混音配樂幾乎是周董一人包到底，還有專輯的歌多數都是寫給自己未出名的當紅歌星被打槍的歌曲，會有怎樣的驚訝之類的反應！？😅😅
原來這麼多外國人對周杰倫的歌曲那麼讚賞
謝謝你們 因為杰倫真的是華語樂壇的驕傲
流量密碼 別太當真
@@Rooboofish 同意，但如果没有实质的内容也无法吸引流量，周杰伦的音乐造诣确实高于其他歌手一个层次所以才能被review。
Great analysis Joe! You were right that as a debut album, Jay Chou was lacking in funds and resources but he made up for it with his music talent!
He was actually writing music for others back then but it was not well received by the superstars as ballads were more popular in Chinese music. Mr JR Yang spotted his music talent and recommended that he sang his own compositions instead... and so his debut album was launched and a music legend was born! 💖
也許你可以聽聽紐約地鐵，這首未發行的神曲Demo
親愛的：Joe Creator
感觉这首歌对杰伦很特别，他第一次上内地节目快乐大本营就是先唱这一首的。小时候我不觉得这首歌好听，现在简直觉得编曲制作太神了，第一第一！！
For this song, although Im chinesem I still same with you all. Can't understand any single word without subtitle. Just enjoy the music.
love your accent...this is so much fun
One of his craziest song😂
And the most craziest review ever
that is so awesome
威廉古堡，歌詞實在超酷
你講解的很詳細,讓不懂音樂的我,多少也能瞭解曲調
hi Favorite Jay Chou song is Fragrant Paddy
is a really nice nice nice song
推荐你听一下我喜欢的歌手陶喆的歌，David Tao
暗號的現場真的超級推薦
I feel Joe has loved Jay Zhou
2008 he did TWO albums
Absolutely crazy!!!
希望可以多聊聊他的歌！
黑色幽默 you will be super impressed
不懂為何這老外念不出老斑鳩的鳩，阿不就跟joe差不多...
這時候就聽的很出來他的特色唱腔很傷喉嚨，沒幾歲聲音就爆了，而動力火車到現在還能繼續唱下去
希望可以點評 米蘭小鐵匠 我超愛這首 我覺得這是首被低估的歌
一首很有故事很有畫面感的歌
這首歌 ~ 手機MP3 必備的歌曲
I recommend 床邊故事 by Jay Chou
nice！！！！！😊
Is Jay watching this? Come on! 👏👏👏
覺得後面有穿插那個：[你笑屁呀]才是精髓😂😂😂可惜只有懂中文的才懂這個笑點😂😂
❤❤❤❤❤
杰倫永遠的神
all of them
他的出現 就震撼了華語歌壇
Not only an album per year but also writing songs for others...lol😂
Mate, Jay also write songs to other,,and very good
this is concert version mv
❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
有聽過張敬軒的（不吐不快和最卑微的愿望）嗎？
Hey, Joe! Great stuff! There was a big music show called the big band (乐队的夏天) in China. It was a phenomenal show two years ago. It got some interesting band and music in it. Maybe you can watch it yourself or with your friends give your thoughts on Chinese bands. I think it would be great and fun.
😍😍
6:42 连歪果仁都听出口齿不清了🤣🤣🤣🤣
居然沒聽過這首歌
回忆起了读书的光阴
这个就9.8万次播放量，隔壁蜘蛛手也就几千人看，比较想只要，要怎么舔，才会看得人多？
老师，下次可以聊聊“李志”嘛？
You’ve gotta listen to 威廉古堡 if you like this one. Please please please!!!
哪怕经过20年后，那句歌词仍然听起来就是“包括TMD狗”，小学的时候还和同学争论过，我说这句话骂人了，同学坚持说不可能。
看看MayDay
很快~ ：）
No such Jay anymore :(((
you should have listen to 夜曲 ye qu
Please review GEM new album :D
简直一副生无可恋的表情(灬°ω°灬)
紐約地鐵也很讚
Joe想认识Jay吗？？
goos vidwo
He is more likely a rapper imo
He's a composer who sings his own songs and also raps. A rapper is different. Rappers specialize in freestyle, rap battles, clever rhyme schemes, lyricism, etc. Jay Chou is a musician who is really good at rapping in his songs, but he's technically not a rapper. It would be like calling Jason Mraz or Ed Sheeran rappers. They're songwriters.
這首咬字怎麼那麼清楚😂
blues 华语模板
32
I recommend another singer, David Tao, earlier than Jaychou. His first album in 1997 established him as the godfather of China's rnb
Hell no, Tao Zhe is overrated.
陶喆没意思
Can't wait to you react to some Hua Chenyu performances!
法师？！No，THANK YOU 😅😂
没有荷兰中间商赚差价
周董前3張真的很強，後來中國風不是很對我胃口，卻在中國打開市場，然後就被狂吹猛吹
不，周董并不是什么中国风才打开市场，而是从那几首中国风的歌他才进入更多人的视野。在年轻人群体，从他第一张专辑就已经很红了。2000年我大学广播站播《可爱女人》是直接推，根本不需要介绍歌手或者专辑，大家都知道他。
相反，中國風在大陸不是他最紅的歌曲，早期愛在西元前，開不了口，可愛女人，龍捲風，走紅之後的擱淺，一路向北，晴天等，都不是中國風但是大陸人超愛的
可以点评中国潮音么
JAY 'S MUSIC JUST SOSO
爵士我还是只喜欢听乐器，加了声乐总觉得怪怪的，不管中文还是英文。
這算有點混嘻哈
国外专业评论人评论国外歌手😂
听一下比较冷门的对不起吧。
我真不懂欣賞。。。
yequ qinyian yindianlaobanjiu
繼續吹，訂閱就會上來了
谁tm不爱杰伦啊
实话实说这首歌是周杰伦唯一一首我欣赏不来的歌。摸不着调也听不明白这首歌在唱什么。
厚話
我很喜歡杰倫 但真的別在吹他了
還要看這種自衛片嗎
印第安，你自己好好想想。
正统英国人是吧？
魔怔人？
W Your Poiiiiint?
抄袭 红烧狮子头！
我台灣人，從不聽他的歌
娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子
娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子
娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子
娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子 娘子
没有字幕，根本听不懂他在唱什么？
英文歌 韓文歌 日文歌 巴拉巴拉 你都聽得懂在唱甚麼嗎?? 音樂不分國界 重要的是旋律
方文山大神写的词就是不一样