Best Cordless Vacuum? $99 HART vs $250 Ryobi, $300 LG, $349 SHARK, $439 Tineco, $750 Dyson
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ย. 2022
- Brands: Dyson V15, Samsung Jet 90, Tineco Pure ONE S12, SHARK Vertex, Roborock H7, LG A9, Ryobi One+, HART. Cordless vacuums tested on carpet for deep cleaning, small and large debris pickup and hair. Vacuums also tested for small and large debris pickup on hard flooring and crevice performance. Vacuums compared for CFM performance at the vacuum’s head, both sealed and unsealed, brush velocity, maximum run time on medium pile carpet, vacuum noise level, vacuum weight, and handle weight at 32 inches. I purchased all of the vacuums and supplies used to test the vacuums. So, thank you for supporting the channel.
➡ Thank you for supporting the channel through memberships:
/ @projectfarm
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel through Patreon: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: project-farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Dyson V15: amzn.to/3qV6Utj
Samsung Jet 90: amzn.to/3DJLBmg
Tineco Pure ONE S12: amzn.to/3xG96sk
Shark Vertex: amzn.to/3Utc7WD
Roborock H7: amzn.to/3Bv70wJ
LG A9: amzn.to/3Uurtdy
Ryobi One+ HP: Available at Home Depot
HART: Available at Walmart
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/3Ca0ZVN
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Finding a reviewer who works so hard at objectively testing things is just such a godsend in this day and age. You are a force working for the good of consumers everywhere. Thank you
You are welcome!
@@ProjectFarm I like how you apply scientific method when testing. Good show!
@@ProjectFarm Would it be possible in future to get a geometric mean score vs the cost? Based on this video the Tineco should come out best (its only two weak points being hard floor and battery life)
@@adrew9042 what's a dial indicator?
You got that right!! Good to see his test-equipment TOYBOX is getting much more hardcore. I always loved Instrumentation class. When I was younger I always thought, the more complicated the toys, the better, but 34yrs after getting my first industrial-maintenance job, I still love my analog Amprobe and "Wiggy" the most. 😎👍
As a research scientist, I just have to say- your methodology is top notch. I have been watching your videos for years. Thanks for all the hard work!
I'm an R&D Chemist and I really love his methodology. His videos are really entertaining.
Thank you!
What work have you (co-)published Brian?
@@louis-philippemaurice1607 his ability to focus and attend to detail is legendary
As a biologist, I have determined he is a man.
Would definitely love a round 2! Some good competitors to Dyson were absent from this one such as Numatic (HEN.100), Miele (HX1), Karcher (VC 4s), as well as some established brands such as Hoover & Bissell. The category seems to be getting more popular every year and its hard to keep up with all the new models on the market!
Thanks for the suggestion.
Would be great if you did round 2
@@ProjectFarm Jimmy H9 pro
you think dyson is a competitor to miele and kenmore? dyson would be utterly obliterated by those two, it wouldn't even be a contest, it would be pest control lmao
@@dummynodepanda in terms of cordless stick vacuums, I've seen feedback that the Miele stick is overpriced and not any better than Dyson. Not sure about Kenmore sticks. Obviously if you're talking bagged canisters that's a different story, for a different use case.
lol, I was thinking about buying the Dyson V15 and I thought to myself "I wonder if project farm made a video on it" ... and you did hahah. seriously one of the best and most helpful youtube channels! I wish you the best :)
Thanks!
He didn't even show the part where you can pick between suction modes on the head. Seriously, buy it. It's worth it.
@@James_DeanII I love it!! Bought it the same day I made that comment
This testing is so marvelous. I can't imagine a more comprehensive way to benchmark the everyday performance of a sweeper. You're doing a better job of benchmarking tools than many dedicated committees. And you somehow release one of these every week!Very impressive, as always!
@@BiggMo whoa that looks like a fascinating rabbit hole. Thanks for the recommendation
@@BiggMo My thoughts exactly; PF is following a good formula at least.
There's also an entire channel dedicated to this called "vacuum wars"
He's better than consumer reports and we all benefit with quicker free results, It's a win-win!!
I just learned that the HART brand sucks.
This channel just gets better and better, i swear. Im not even in the market for a cordless vacuum yet here i am unable to look away. Please keep up the amazing work, we need this kind of independent testing more than ever with so many retailers and resellers buying and hiding reviews!
I don't even trust consumer reports anymore. This guy is one of the very few people I actually listen to and he's helped me in a few decisions.
I'd be curious if Todd liaised / consulted with the bloke who runs the Vacuum wars channel. The tests were very similar.
Whatever you do... Don't watch vacuum wars :D
As much as I love this channel, there is already a channel that does all vacuums.
I totally agree. some of the other tools I may not need, but this one has me looking as well. lol
I have the Shark and it’s fantastic. One thing that I never realized how much I needed was the light. I have dark hardwood and dogs that shed. Without the light, the floor looks clean…but illuminated, and it shows all the hidden hair…it’s crazy!
Thanks for sharing.
Same with my cat. This thing is perfect for the multiple kitty litter cleanups needed everyday and that light is great. I had a cheap $100.00 cordless and the Shark is like night and day and is worth the extra money.
Totally agree on the light thing. Thanks to my vac light I have to vacuum daily now. LOL!
I used to have the Shark, because I wasn't willing to pay the ridiculous price for the Dyson. I have two dogs and two cats, and the Shark was OK at picking up the fur, but eventually I saved enough to pay the extra and bought the Dyson. It does a better job, and cleans up much faster than the Shark ever did. If you can afford it, or are able to save up, it really is worth the extra expense in terms of how much time it will save you and how much cleaner it leaves your floors.
@@AnthonyLauder Dyson's renewed products are a great deal. After returning a Tineco that died in under a month, I got a Dyson V10 Animal + for $250. It looked and worked like new. Way better than the Tineco. Unfortunately none of these test longevity.
When I look up reviews for an item this is the only quality and level of detail I will accept from anywhere now on! You’ve raised the bar sky high and I love it!
Please keep up the great work :)
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarm Here's an idea, can you do a review on carpet shampoos and hard floor cleaners?
This seems to be one of the more rare "you get what you pay for" tests on this channel!
It would be interesting to see some more European brands in a second test like Electrolux, Bosch and Philips
I thought the same thing... almost across the board with few exceptions, price dictated how it came out.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I agree, Miele would’ve been a good addition as well. I’ve never used their vacuums, but I’ve heard great things about them. They’re priced comparatively to Dyson. Maybe he could do a high end vacuum comparison.
@@christopherkortlever from my experience Miele produce the best vacuums, and that is said as someone who owns a couple of dysons!
And Miele's TriFlex line. I have a Dyson V12, but I have always preferred Miele's build quality to Dyson (just feels more solid overall) and have a traditional corded Miele.
The average family that still enjoys a bit of DIY owes you a debt of gratitude. I hope more people stumble across your channel and that you have many more years of sharing these in-depth reviews with the world.
Thanks!
Before I watch this , I feel like mr. Dyson might kill you before this video ends. Haha okay carry on. I’ll watch it now.
Boy how good can your tests get !! I can't ever imagine myself having the patience for vacuuming the same floor over and over for 15 minuts straight, 4 times in a row with a vacuum in each hand
Thanks!
We have the Samsung Jet 90. The Costco version came with a charging stand and an extra battery. After a year of use, it still works excellent. Two things: the deciding factor was the self emptying station and the superior filtration. The self empty station really makes the process easier. One minus is that the small wheels under the unit get clogged fairly easy but not a big deal. Parts: parts are cheap except the main roller is hard to find.
Thanks for sharing.
I have it and a dyson thats one model older and the Samsung is so so much better. The empty station is great, it works wonders on my laminate flooring and carpeted areas. It's solid!
As an R&D scientist, I must say that you're impressive in your methodology since you are both thorough and manage to reduce bias while keeping your reviews enjoyable. As a homeowner, I'm still waiting for that SDS-plus rotary hammer drill review. Can't buy a new one before you have made a review 😜
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Pretty sure Todd was an R&D scientist at one point.
Agree on both counts. An SDS-plus rotary hammer comparison would be great... and expensive.
I've bought a good number of products because of his reviews, even some products I've bought ended up being rated high once he came out with a video on it. Best product reviewer on TH-cam.
Metabo has one very cute UHEV--2860-2 Quick in 3+J territory. Bought it 3 years ago and never regret.
Interesting that while the Shark didn't score great in the objective tests, it was the only one to score A+ in all subjective categories. Considering that and it's decent objective scores (including #2 in run time), I think it might be the best bang for buck in this test.
Thanks for the feedback.
In reality those vacuum power etc doesn't really mean much. It's all about those subjective test. But you know it's projectfarm he loves to get into those technical details.
Like you can't just say you have a 1000 horse power car you are the fastest, anything below 1000 horse power is slower than you
It's all about the best design to serve it's purpose.
Like the test "sand extracted from crevice" is very unrealistic. In a regular house you don't have big deep crevice like that, mostly you are talking about slide door gap or door gap etc.
That's why the accessory comes into place to help you, you don't just use that same head and expect it to work in literally everything, there's no perfect head for everything.
You can argue say Dyson V15 is the best, but does it worth two sharks? I don't think so
According to Vacuum wars review, hepa filter performance Dyson V15 is best. It releases most cleaner air than others
That seems right. If you can afford it, go for the Dyson. But if you are on a low budget then the Shark looks like a good compromise.
@@genrr2361 I don't see it as just the price of the vacuum cleaner, but also as the price of my time. I had a cheaper brand for a while, but bought the Dyson to speed up my cleaning time. Sure, it is $300 more than the Shark, but it saves me about 20 minutes a day, which over a 5 year lifespan of the cleaner works out at more than 600 hours save. In other words, it costs me less than 50 cent to save an hour of cleaning time, which I think is great value.
That was without a doubt the best and most detailed testing video I've ever seen for ANY product. The amount of time, effort, and detail you put into this is incredible! Thanks for your hard work!
Thanks and you are welcome!
"NO SPONSORS" I love it !
Yeah, but he gets a cut if you buy through the links in the description.
@@Bigtim2you whats the problem with that?
Goldfish and Cheerios sponsored him clearly. /s
No Sponsors and no bias. Love this channel.
@@Bigtim2you nothing wrong with profit if you create value.
A big yes for round two with other brands. The level of the testing you do is amazing!!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm Lupe is better than everything you tested, but also near the top of the price tier.
@@ProjectFarm is it also possible to get hair measurement on hard surface heads, or do they recommend the carpet head for hair on hard surfaces?
Xiaomi G10 please
@@ProjectFarm Please add a test to see how much carpet fiber is torn out by the vacuum brushes. I've bought various vacuums and some have abrasive brushes while others have soft brushes and a "beater bar". A beater bar is basically a smooth ridge on the roller that thumps the top of the carpet nap to shake the gritty sand loose at the bottom so that the vacuum airflow can then have a chance to suck up the dirt from deep in the carpet where the brush doesn't reach or make the carpet vibrate enough.
Thank you for one of the best reviews on our everyday items.
Not just tools but the things we use everyday and it's very hard to know when you are shopping which one should I buy! Problem solved, you have shown us what they can and cannot do and which one fits our budget/performance needs.
Hope you look into more of these appliance tests as nobody does such a thorough job as you do.
Looking forward to see what you test next..
My husband has been subscribed to you for over a year, but this video made me subscribe on my account, as well! Thank you so much for these amazing, thoughtful, thorough, and unbiased reviews. It is so incredibly helpful to those of us who really try to research things before we buy them.
Thanks for watching and subscribing!
All testing ever done in the world doesn’t hold a candle to you. Absolutely rigorous integrity. You’d make one hell of an R&D engineer. Thank you for making this video!
Thanks and you are welcome!
As always this channel proves to be the gold standard of unbiased test & evaluation. Thank you.
You're welcome!
This is the most biased test out there.
Project Farm, I am completely in awe of your videos. You are one of the most amazing reviewers and it makes shopping easier. You’re a Godsend to Product Reviewing and your unbiased testing perfects your amazing results.
Thanks so much!
I am amazed at the ingenuity and work you put into ALL of your testing. You are one in a million for sure. Thanks so much for doing this. Still the MOST useful TH-cam channel.
Thank you!
Thank you for what you do, as always! You’re the real Consumer Reports.
Thank you very much! This means a lot to me!!
@@ProjectFarm You are WAY better than consumer reports.
@@anthonyduncan5920 And more affordable to boot! 👍🏼😎✌🏼
And without CRs garbage political viewpoint they've had from the '70s on! 👍👍
@@RustyOpel - Plus, CR subscirbers who "aren't in the market for a brand new car, get stuck with the annual "car review" which is useless for most and reduces the number of actual product reviews. The annual car report (imho) should be offered as an extra "add-on" for those who are actually in the market for a new car.
There are some excellent youtube product reviews out there but this tops them all. You didn't waste a second of the viewers time. This video is the gold standard hands down. And NO annoying background music. Thank you.
Thanks!
His vids do have bg music sometimes, but it's not loud or intrusive and the songs are good. It's good to have balanced music volume bc some viewers have sensory processing disabilities where it's difficult to hear someone talk with music playing.
Yes, he did by not including two major mainstream consumer brands Bissell and Hoover. Let's be real, no one is putting Ryobi or Hart on their shopping list for a vacuum.
Great video. The hair vs. brushes test was VERY interesting. I think dollar for pounds the LG A9 comes out on top being significantly less expensive than the ones close to it and only marginally falling behind the top end of each category.
Great video as usual.
Thanks!
Also, the Costco variant of the LG comes with extra battery and more accessories, including an extra head with soft roller for hard floors. Plus the LG has a 10 year warranty.
I think if you exclude the first two tests the seal and unseal air tests, Lg will be a winner other than cavities, all other jobs for cleaning carpet and hair it was a great as the top + low noise
Best comparison video I've seen... You really did all of the real world testing I need to make a decision... Thank you
I love when you cover things that literally any of us could and probably do own. I would love to see more vacuum brands tested maybe battery vs corded?
Thank you for the video idea!
I haven’t watched the whole video yet but seeing notifications from testing the vacs that i so much wanted. Hope my favorite tool brand wins
I would also like to see self standing cordless vacumes in the mix, like Electrolux Q9.
@@ProjectFarm bosch 18v cordless please!
Vacuum wars is where to go for that. They have been doing this exact same testing for years on hundreds of vacuums.
I'm constantly in awe of the engineering which goes in to his testing.
Thank you very much!
@@ProjectFarm Have you thought about testing chainsaw bars? It's always been something I've wondered, whether the manufacturer hype around durability and low friction are true. You could test frictional loss, particle ingress, oil-ability, resistance to bending or forming burrs etc. Cheers
There is no problem solving, thus no engineering. Using accepted methods and tools to compare performance is not engineering.
What engineering? lol
Amazing video! Impressed with the level dedication and attention to detail! Thank you!
Wow, this is by far the most comprehensive and unbiased review I’ve seen for any product group. Thank you! You helped me avoid a mistake and find the best option.
You are so welcome!
I really love that you test all your products in a format the average person can understand. Any time I'm thinking of buying a power tool I come searching through your videos. You deserve all the TH-cam success you have and I hope to see more great content for years to come.
Thanks and you are welcome!
As a machinist I would be really interested in seeing a comparison of calipers, some say they are rated to be coolant proof, I wonder about how much play there is in the jaws in different brands, also the durability if they are dropped on the measuring ends. I have seen a super wide range in prices and also wonder if I would get more precise reliability out of an analog pair vs a digital. Impressive testing and I look forward to the next video!
Thank you for sharing!
Machinist here too, I second this! Excellent suggestion
VINCA and NEIKO digital calipers from Amazon, both under $25 and 4.5 stars with 9,000 and 16,000 reviews respectively.
+1
@@sethsevaroth their home gamer calipers and their probably fine for that but no machinist would trust them.. starret or mititoyo (spelling) are the only ones I've ever seen other machinists use and their the only ones I'd ever use in my machine shop.. my current set is starret and their accurate to 5/10,000" (if used properly) all day, every day
Thanks for always giving an honest review! Being a first time home buyer, you've helped me pick out countless items. Keep it up, you're awesome!
Glad to help!
i see a lot of comments mentioning Robotnox. this robot just changed our minds. it has a lot of great features tbh
Thanks for sharing.
You are to TH-cam, what Consumer Reports is to print. Very comprehensive, unbiased, and practical testing.
Thank you so much for all the hard work you put into your content. It helps me a lot. Keep up the great work👍👍👍
Thanks, will do!
This was one genius. Definitely one of the most useful videos as almost everybody buys a vacuum at some point. I recently got the Dyson and I was glad to see I haven’t wasted my money in just marketing and branding.
Thanks!
Dyson vacuums (depending on the model, they do have some bad ones) are generally really good and their customer service has usually always been on point.
Whenever I'm looking to buy something and I come across your videos it's pretty much a slam dunk. Can't thank you enough for going in deep on all these product reviews.
Thanks for sharing!
Been watching you for years. You're videos are so well thought out, non biased, informative, and yet extremely entertaining everytime. You've helped me a lot as I've became an adult to not waste money on things I don't research and that the big brand isn't always the best.
Thanks for sharing!
As a full time vacuum reviewer, I can say this test was great. A+ job.
Thank you very much!
@@ProjectFarm No problem Your fantastic!
Your job really sucks eh?
@@WestcoastAudiGuy mine? It's fantastic.
@@VacMaster1991Since you are a vacuum tester, I believe that last comment was a pun. i.e. - You're job really "sucks". And a good one. LOL.
Nice! This one I feel like it’s long overdue. I happen to have a craftsman one I’m super happy with. A ton of power, yet, doesn’t chug batteries like other vacuums
Thank you!!
The 20v stick vacuum?
If that's the one. I can give it a instant pass.
I use it in a school with a 6.0ah battery and the only con I can give it is the hose size gets clogged with heavy dust.
It sucked up dirt,food crumbs, small paper, and orchestra strings and bow strings.
I was looking for a cordless vacuum awhile back and came across the Craftsman at Lowes. Figured I’d try it out and return it if it was a pos. Glad I bough it as it exceeded my expectations. They go on sale periodically so I picked mine up for $149.99. Included a decent charger and 2.0 battery, +another free 2.0 with purchase. Later, I picked up two 4.0 and “faster” charger for $99.00. Improved performance and run time;however, larger battery will make it top heavy and prone to falling over if you try and leave it in the upright position, unsupported.
@@BigHoss-dk4qj Absolutely, I generally store mine without the battery on anyway. That’s a really good deal, I’ve heard of people buying the bare vacuum for $199.
@@DUBMANS Yes that one. I haven’t had that issue but I also haven’t used it outside of my house
The quality of this product test video is so high you deserve the thumbs up and subscription. Much respect for your work and thoroughness.
Thanks! Thanks for watching and subscribing!
I love how intricate and creative his testing is. I'm actually considering getting a handheld vacumn and this was really helpful. Would love to see a round 2 and the top 3 or 4 come back against some new competitors.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I've had the Shark Vertex for over 2 years and I'm so happy with it. For the price, a house full of girls and kids with hardwood floors, couldn't be more satisfied. The thing with the shark is that it doesn't skatter material all over the hardwood floor when you make passes which cuts down the time you spend cleaning.
I like the vertex a lot
I thought the cheerio test was a clear over the top moment for the shark. I'd buy another shark.
@@independentsoul7396 , shark has the best floor to floor cleaning because of there dual brush rolls.
Certain Dyson kits come with a bush roll attachment similar to the Shark Vertex, but knowing which Dyson is the one is confusing because they have goofy names like “Fluffy,” “Animal,” etc. Given the price, the Shark Vertex is a good value for all around performance.
@@wtmayhew yes indeed
I bought the Shark Vertex based on Vacuum Wars' recommendation and I've been really pleased with it, especially on hard floors. No need to change heads and it's half the price of the Dyson.
Crazy how just 10 years ago, Shark's cordless vacs were awful.
I’m thinking I want one of those. The ability to pick up Cheerios, Goldfish, pet food, etc is a big deal.
The shark used in that video was the vertex pro. It's better than the one in this video.
I have a shark vertex and I use it all the time in our kitchen for picking up Cheerios and dried cereal that our baby drops all the time. It does a great job. I have a different vacuum for cleaning carpets.
Thanks for the feedback.
That was by far the absolute best vacuum review I've ever seen, unbiased, every test I could think of was done. THANK YOU! That was so so so informative. I own a residential cleaning company and have bought over 10 (Shark) vacuums over the years. I am so so so surprised LG and Samsung make better versions. Wow thank you again - you didn't waste any time and you have a follower for life
Thanks and you are welcome!
As an engineer, I really appreciate the testing and the detailed review.... I think you have done the best review of Cordless Vacuums with explaining each step.... Just WOW.
Thanks!
Coolers would be a awesome thing to review. With all the new coolers on the market some of them being upwards of $200-300 it would be nice to see a full test on brands.
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm I would like to see coolers too!
Just curious - what product exatly you call 'cooler'? Air conditioner? Insulation box for picnic beers? Water-cooler?
@@SandroSmith Probably what most of us call a cooler. One that keeps food cold. Duh.
@@SandroSmith Insulated boxes that you usually fill with ice and drinks, in order too keep drinks / food cold on beach days or when camping.
I have been considering a Dustbuster style vacuum for my garage recently and would love to see a similar comparison with small cordless vacuums. Great testing as always
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm Likewise. I have a Milwaukee hand held and I love its utility, however I’d love to see how it stacks up to the other brands! That would be awesome if you happened to do one of those!
@@ProjectFarm Small cordless vacuums would be good - also, how about robot vacuum cleaners? This would provide the opportunity to also test their navigation capabilities.
Same here, I bought the Ryobi One+ handheld cordless vacuum and was never really satisfied with it.
I have the new ryobi brushless wet dry and like it so far
This is the best TH-cam channel ever created to find out what to buy.
Thanks so much!
I really love how closely the test results line up with my own real world experience with these brands on the shop floor
Thanks for the feedback.
I love your reviews!
Something you may want to consider adding to your comparisons when there is variance is warranty periods. In this case warranties across these can be 1, 2, 3, 5, or even 10 years. When I recently purchased a cordless vacuum that was one of my consideration points.
Thank you for the feedback!
And cost of new filters, batteries, etc.
And on top of that you should have someone call each of the brands and make a warranty claim and see how much of a hastle they are to deal with because some companies like to offer super long warranties but void it for everything
While I know you primarily test tools, I think testing certain building materials would make for some interesting videos as well. For example: testing strength, flexibility, ease of sanding, etc of different commonly used woods. Many materials are known for being very good for certain purposes, but it could prove quite interesting to see those traits quantified. Just a random thought, great videos as always!
Thank you for the video idea!
Great job as always, I love the graph comparisons and final overall comparisons. I would be really interested to see the comparison of how the top three performers do at normal speed vs. their highest speed. Especially the suction and runtime.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
The way you can make all these and straight to the point is impressive. Amazing job
Thanks!
Amazing breakdown. I'm sure I speak for everyone who watches this channel that we appreciate how much time and effort you put into all your testing
Thanks so much!
This was phenomenal. If you ever do a standing vacuum roundup,, I'd love to see how a Kirby does against a Dyson
Kirby vs Dyson would be really interesting to see. Those Kirbys are $$$$$$$$$ though lol
Kirby is the GOAT expensive yes, but 20 years later it's still going strong and literally pulls the carpet up 😂🤣
Check out the "Vacuum Wars" TH-cam channel.
He is brilliant, and the OG in Vacuum testing.
He has several very well done videos of Dyson vs Kirby.
Kirby wont stand a chance, they only sell when a salesman pushes it on you
@@markimonki4017 You would be surprised.
these experiments are so well designed.. and that summary chart at the end! *chefs kiss* you are a wonderful human making the world a better place🙏🙏🙏
Thanks so much!
Man I love your testing scenarios, whatever products you test. Weighing dust containers is brilliant.
Thanks!
Love my Dyson V8. Been using it for 4.5 years, and it’s just one of those “it just works” type of tools. It was our only vacuum for most of that time, only recently being joined by a roomba to make life a little easier. It’s also great how Dyson actually supports self repair. Since we are moving again, I took the time to order new beater bars for the soft and hard surface heads, got new pre and post filters, and replaced the battery. All easily orderable from Dyson directly and made the vacuum like new.
good to hear, sounds like a very repairable vacuum... I may look around at used ones and see if I can get a deal. I like fixing up stuff like that.
my current cordless vac is just too weak, it's a basic 8.4v Electrolux. not even good enough to grab all the cat litter without it getting flung around the floor, and it eats hair instead of sucking it up. have to cut hair out of the brush roll after every week...
@@volvo09 it’s definitely a repairable vacuum. There are videos on how to take the heads completely apart, so even if there is lint and hair in beyond the roller area it’s easy to get it totally fresh. It makes it a lot more cost conscious option when you can buy used and fix up for an afternoon’s time.
Your testing is way better then Consumer Report. It’s great seeing the tests actually taking place.👍
I stopped getting Consumer Reports after many years. I find Project Farm’s reviews to be clearly superior. Sometimes Consumer Reports tests products that I am extremely familiar with and often test the most frivolous of factors that hardly factor into an intelligent and informed purchase. Thank you Project Farm for impartiality, relevance, interpretation of results, and, overall, fast moving and entertaining as well videos.
@@staberdearth3130 ..yes, as I have often stated, Consumer Reports are a sham...to me, they have zero credibility...
Thanks!
Would like to see a round 2 video. I am very interested in understanding how good batteries are as this is pretty important for longevity
This is by the far the most useful resource for comparing vacuums that I have seen!
Dude you are so awesome. I am looking for a cordless vac and have not chosen one before this video. But after this video I know. I have been hemming hawing for the past year. I don’t watch all of your videos, but enough to know. Your are the master of objective and impartial testing. Also impressed at how fast and clear you can speak.
Thanks!
My favorite utilitarian review channel on TH-cam.
Wow, thanks!
Your testing for this video is truly remarkable and a testament to your diligence in making sure that we know which vacuum performs the best. Great job as always.
Thank you!
You have nothing but respect for the efforts you put into these videos. Thank you.
You are welcome!
Bless you for this work/video. Exactly what I was after. Please don’t stop this service for us all!!!
Thanks! Glad to hear!
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. The tests you conduct are incredible. The amount of time and money you put into these videos is amazing. This is by far the absolute best product testing channel on TH-cam bar none.
I have seen this exact same comment on many of his older videos.
@@V3ntilator I think a lot of people say similar things. I've said something along those lines before and I stand by it. More test themed channels pop up all the time, but this is the best one!
Braised beef is brilliant.
Thanks so much!
Well, I am not surprised there are many RobotNox recommendations.
Thanks for the feedback.
Amazing test! I had a dyson for 5 years now and its still going strong, while its the most expensive one it was a good investment! I will always get a Dyson! thank you for the video, subscribed!
Thanks! Thanks for watching and subscribing!
A joy to watch your videos.
Your workshop makes a great backdrop in the videos as well.
Always inspiring and I admire your imagination to keep coming up with great ideas.
Well done.
One Handed Maker - Australia
Thanks!
Would definitely like to see a round two. Also, what about comparing different brands of carpet steam cleaners? I'd love to watch how those stack up.
Thanks for the suggestion. Thanks for the feedback.
YES! Can you also do dry paint in carpet when you do this review?
Bissel , better belt system $60 to $80
As a former professional carpet cleaner I'd be interested in this test but I wouldn't have much hope. I'd bet a rented Rug Doctor would beat anything you would buy in a store. I've used a Rug Dr multiple times myself since I quite cleaning carpet professionally and I was pretty impressed with the results.
I'd hope the Dreo cordless vac is tested if there's a round 2. The DC motor on their fan seems to be good. Might be a good value.
Best channel, best reviewer I've found anywhere. Thanks for helping so many folks with valuable information and testing!!!
You are welcome!
What an amazing tour de force of testing. Great job!
Would love to see a round 2. I like our little Makita (though it doesn’t have a rotating brush), and it’s always interesting to see how Miele performs in vacuum comparisons.
Thanks!!
Would be interested to see how the Wyze cordless vacuum performs as well.
Thank you for the video idea!
And the Miele TriFlex
Same here. Also suggesting the bosch unlimited 8 :)
Very interested in Makita to. A lot of cleaning companies are using it as a go vacuum. Huge difference with cyclonic attachment - is it true?
I literally just bought the LG A9, I’ve been really pleased with it. Super quiet. It works well for dust and pet hair on my hard floors. I chose it over the dyson because it has replaceable batteries, came with a stand, and you don’t have to keep the button pressed for suction. Awesome video!
My initial thought at the end was that with the LG purchase, you could spend the saved $ on more batteries or accessories / attachments... Or buy 2 and have a vacuum ballet with your SO or trick your kids to a cleaning contest, "which ever one of you gets the most done gets an extra scoop of ice cream / 1st choice of pie slice etc". LOL
For the money, it performed quite well in these tests. Hope it lasts you a long time :)
Did you manage to find it for $300?
I've had the LG A9 for a yr and half and use it daily. It's been a great vacuum. Mine came from Costco, and came with 2 batteries. The brush head really does a great job of resisting hair wraps and it does a great job in carpet even on low power mode. With both batteries it can also run a long time. The stand will charge both batteries too, but one one at a time. The battery in the vacuum charges 1st, then the spare in the stand. It's really cool, every time you need it both batteries are full.
At its price point in don't think it can be beat. With the saving a small shop vac can handle the big junk and you are atill money ahead of the Samsung or Dyson.
I've got 2 Dyson's (V7 and V8) and i absolutely hate them. I've heard the V10+ are very good, but i hate the cheap feel and non repairablity of them. I can't even use the V7 on max suction anymore.
Wouldn't mind trying the LG one.. though I've had a fair few LG issues in my life too.
Maybe I'll get one from the tool brands - just for the battery
Without a doubt, the best objective, honest, thorough testing on the Internet! Excellent video!
Thanks so much!
You beat every vacuum review channel, this amazing.
THANK YOU Todd
Thank you very much!
@@ProjectFarm agreed! Would love to see a “robo/AI” vacuum challenge. Would be a fun test and building a n “Arena” to have them battle it out like battle bots 😂
Even the exclusive channel for vacuum
Vacuum Wars is equally unbiased and informative - and that's high praise for both channels!
I was about to purchase a cordless vacuum and this is exactly what I needed. Thank you as always.
Perfect!
You should also watch Vacuum Wars on TH-cam. His testing quality is as top tier as Todd’s but all he really does is vacuums. Great channel😊
your better off getting a 6.5 gallon shop vac with the proper attachments
My wife owns a small cleaning buisness(10 years)..she uses the Shark cordless ..its a very well built vacume.
EDIT: Hers are NOT cordless. She said the cordless vacs are just not worth it
Loved the goldfish and cheerios test, that is so very applicable to my life right now...
Thank you for the thought and time that you put into your videos. I found this video and it is super helpful to me. Again, thank you for all the effort you put in and god bless!
Thanks! Glad to hear the video was super helpful! Thanks for supporting the channel! I really appreciate it!
I would not have thought it would be possible to not have hair wrapped around a roller brush.
I use a hook tool to clean mine before every use.
Wish i could afford a better vacuum now.
this was an excellent review
Thanks!
That was an eye opener for me as well
@@gro_skunk Same with the dyson, they both have a great head design for hair removal, whilst using different methods
Go get yourself a new boyfriend josh
@@AG-en5y Was that supposed to be funny?
What are you doing here that's different than what I'm doing?
When you are on the market to buy one and magically project farm reads your mind!
😀
Thank you very much!!
I appreciate ProjectFarm - the transparency of the testing methodology (as well as explaining the logic behind it) and being clear to express objective/subjective is refreshing to see.
This video is educating me on what vacuum I want to buy. Great work and thank you!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I will never get tired of watching your videos. Thank you so much for helping us, the consumers, to make better decisions on product we should buy.
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
Crazy how linear this testing is as far as “you get what you pay for”
true, peronally i’d get a shark or lg, maybe lg cuz of the brand
Great Point!
@@tomektomek9836 I would also look for a discounted Dyson if you happen across one. You can sometimes find some great prices on older models or during holidays. Was happy to see that the high price was backed up by the best overall performance.
@@tomektomek9836 LG is a brilliant middle of the road option. Haven't had any annoyances with it at all.
I was looking into a cordless stick vacuum for a while but ended up going with a canister vacuum instead. My house is mostly hard floors and nothing beats the maneuverability of a canister head and having a bagged vacuum is really nice since I don't need to empty it often and it creates less of a dust plume when emptying. Definitely worth checking out canisters if you don't need cordless.
The surging on the higher end models is heat protection. They spin so fast they can overheat super quick, so if a complete clog is detected, they cut power. So it's likely it would have gone higher, though it would need some air passing through, tough to test.
or just cool the motors.
I'm always amazed by how this man reviews tools. This man is one of my favorites. Thank you for amazing reviews! 🙏
You are welcome!
Great review! I was on my way to Home Depot to buy the Ryobi, but thought I should check out your channel first. Glad I did! Think I'm going to buy a Shark or Dyson!
I think there’s one key factor you’re missing on the cheerios and goldfish test. The Dyson has an adjustable brush head to tackle different levels of carpet. Had that been all the way retracted it may have done better in that test. Just something I noticed as a Dyson owner
Agreed, there are two "gates" that can be opened at the front of the brush head for larger objects-it is ultimately the compromise one must make. A head that has a better seal will pull up small dust and dirt more effectively, but exclude larger bits like cereal, and a brush that can take on larger bits like cereal will not have as performant a seal because of the larger openings. A manual selection is not a perfect solution, but is at least one that allows the user to determine which use case they are optimizing for.
Thanks for the feedback.
Personally I would take the better seal over being able to pick up cheerios and gold fish. In my day to day life I have never had that issue.
@@lejoshmont2093 Even if you dont it is very easy to adjust the Dyson for it. Also usually for large objects I just use the brush tool or even just the tube alone. Not like we have cheerios just sitting around till vacuum day lol thats a spot clean.
@@lejoshmont2093 that's funny cause thet exactly why got the shark cause the food like cheerios from two young children needing to be vacuumed up and having one head that does everything quickly and efficiently is just easier than switching heads.
You need to do more comparisons like this. I know you put a lot of effort into this channel and people appreciate it.😊
Thank you!
Thanks for you videos. They are well done and very informative.
Best honest channel hands down. I’ve made many purchases based on your data. Thanks.
Thanks! Thanks fore sharing!
I definitely would like to see the roomba type vacuums! There is a huge price difference! I find myself usually rewatching all of these multiple times
Thanks for the suggestion.
That would be awesome! If he did that, he should compare their performance to the results of this video as well
Best robot vacuum is Roborock, roomba is overpriced
@@monicav4986 WERE GONNA TEST THAT!!! 🤓🤠….. hopefully 😅
@@L44tsmasher735 Nah, I heard that channel sucks… 😆
That crevice test was absolutely diabolical and super practical! Thank you for putting out such amazing content! I now check your channel before I make a home/tool purchase to see if you have reviewed it. I followed your suggestion on pliers and went with the Tsundoa brand 8".
Thanks and you are welcome!
I have a Dyson V15, and you nailed it wrt large particles. The small conical brush (not demonstrated) is absolutely incredible for removing hairs and fibres from couches, car seats etc. Even better than the demonstrated brush. As always a great test. Thank you for sharing!
Thanks!
You paid $800 😂😂
@@ayo9057 not quite but worth every penny. It's a joy to use, it's very efficient, and there's plenty of power for my apartment. The laser for the floors is brilliant for hardwood floors!
@@ayo9057its easily the best vacuum out there, the cyclone tech in most of the vacuums was inspired by dyson
@@PovlKvolsDon’t worry about them clowns. I have the 15 and it’s amazing. Worth every penny…. People are just jealous!
Probably the best comprehensive reviewer I have ever had the pleasure of watching. I do notice though on the Dyson sand sweep the front vents were left open. Not sure if it would have helped the total grams, but you do get quite a bit more suction to the floor for little particles.
Thanks!
I have a Dyson V15 and I think it is 100% worth the price. The laser head alone reveals dust on my hardwood floors that I would never see otherwise. I can certainly feel it, going barefoot. It's expensive, but it's definitely the best vacuum I have ever owned.
I do agree on every points. It costs a Kidney, but it works like a charm.
I love the laser head so much that I clean my flat in the dark 🤫
@@KenoBeatZ i also clean my room in the dark...
As a V11 owner I agree, Dyson has the best performance and thanks to using their cyclones for primary filtration instead of a filter it will also perform more consistently.
Great job on the testing, as usual, Todd! I own the Dyson V15 after owning a corded Shark handheld for 4 years, and although the price tag is painful, it is definitely worth every penny (a corded vs. cordless comparison would be interesting). It picks up dust we never thought existed. That said, the Tineco does sound like a great buy if you're not willing to pay $800+ with taxes for a vacuum. I did get tired of cleaning hair out of my Shark's brush every week, so that test right there was probably the most important one...haha
Thanks, great comments. See my , MAY work on my DYSON DC-15, etc.. love it except HOSE, AWKWARD, BROKEV OUT of bottom, etc,)….WEIGHT, ETC..
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I think the “hair test” was the the most important one (from my pov), as firstly I thought “hey, I already have some ryobi, maybe let’s buy another tool”, but then - nah, it’s exactly the same as my Philips pro aqua (well - Philips has much more battery), BUT I’d still have to create some adapter to go from square to tube for sucking air from vacuum bags
This channel literally has everything you need, looking to buy a cordless vacuum, this channel has scientific testing for the most random of things and explains it better than literally anywhere on the internet. This is where you go to see if hardware performs well. lol
Thanks!