आप दोनों महानुभावों से पद्मावत पर चर्चा सुनकर मैं अपने आपको पद्मावत के बारे में अपनी जानकारी को और समृद्ध कर पाया । इसके लिए मैं आप दोनों का आभारी हूं। विशेष कर आदरणीय प्रो अग्रवाल साहब को सादर नमन।
प्रो,अग्रवाल जी का साक्षात्कार सुन मेरे लिये एक उपलब्धि है इसमें आपके व्यक्तिव की ऊंचाई का भी पता चलता है ।आप हमेशा अच्छे विषय को इमानदारी से उठाते है कुछ तो jnu का कमाल और कुछ आपके संस्कार का ।आपको शुभकामनायें।
मां सरस्वती ,कि कृपा से एक अत्यन्त ज्ञानवर्धक वार्ता गुरु शिष्या के मध्य सुनने का अवसर मिला। धन्यवाद सौरभ ।लगा कि भारतेन्दु हरिश्चन्द्र, मैथलीशरण गुप्त कि परम्परा के अग्रवाल विद्वान आज भी हमारे मध्य मौजूद हैं।
U were rightly nervous about interviewing Dr. Puroshottam agarwal, and iam very thankful that u interviewed him, rather didnnot interview him and let him be himself , amazing to listen to him.
I just found this randomly while going through your channel since I follow it from long time. I was playing it on speakers and suddenly my dad exclaimes "Oh, he's my batchmate.", about Mr. Aggarwal. "It feels good to see people you know, being up there", was what my dad said then.
Thank you for a brilliant discussion. I thought this will be about khiljee and the horrors of deceit and war. Instead I learned to understand another viewpoint. An enjoyable serious experience
Saurav, our society need people and reporter like you... You are making a real change that is needed at this moment.... Proud of you buddy... Big time fan of yours...
Sir this was wonderful . Though I am not a student of literature but I enjoy the novel idea of padmavat. This has open my eyes also, that is, how to read a classical text . Many new ideas i have earned . Thank you sir so much
suravi ji Literature is a reflection of the time it has been written. and thouth of writer nothing else It is up to you whether you are inpress it or not
Sourabh, many many thanks to you from the core of my heart not only for this awesome program but also for the role you're playing as a journalist. My best wishes to you and your team.
I have stopped the clip so as to remark as I can't hold myself any longer. Iam deeply deeply impressed by the beautiful teacher- son relationship that both you and Prof Sahib enjoy. I must say you have gladdened my heart by your humble attitude and exhibition of deep and genuine love and respect that you have for the august personality of dear Prof. Agrawal. Prof Sahib is on the dot ( as he always is) that the most a teacher can wish for is to see his wards doing well in life and living by the principles taught to him by his teacher. Bravo! You have cemented my belief in humanity and in the strength of human values Sir. As you would have guessed, Iam also a teacher ( an atrocious one, the only such specimen in history!) and recently one of my former students came to me, touched my knees and told me that he has been selected as college lecturer. It delighted me and ever since I am on an entirely different universe! That's what teachers feel when they see their students. Prof Sahib is an asset. I have listened to him on different channels and what a brilliant human being he is! Do me a favour , when you meet him pay my most respectful regards to him. He is right, we need more than tolerance. What we need in this region is empathy for others. This message should be clamoured from house tops throughout South Asia. I don't think Iam that old ( I think, others do not necessarily agree) but I want to say to you Sir: Salamat rahein Hamesha. You made me happy. Now to the discussion.
Phew! I had no idea what a learned person Prof. Purshottam Agarwal is - it is an honor to hear him speak. Thank you for introducing us to him. Also please show the book cover clearly.
महर्षि वाल्मीकि ने रावण के माध्यम से सीता के सौन्दर्य के प्रति जैसी अभिव्यक्ति दी है , वह सदा सुखांतकारी और कालजयी भी है। कौन ऐसा नहीं है ! धन्यवाद दोनों को। ऐसी प्रस्तुति के लिये!
कवि का अलंकरण और काव्य रस के प्रति उसका आकर्षण ही कई बार इतिहास का शत्रु बन जाता है और अनजाने में वो इतिहास के साथ अन्याय कर बैठता है | उदाहरण के लिए हम अगर तुलसीदास की रामचरित्र मानस को लें तो इसमें ऐसे अनेक प्रसंग हैं जो की वाल्मीकि की रामायण (जो की इतिहास है) से बहुत अलग है, जैसे की सीता स्वयंवर में राम का जाना, जो की वाल्मीकि रामायण में नहीं है, और चूँकि वर्तमान रामचरित्र मानस को भी वास्तविकता मानता है इसलिए भ्रम की स्थिति बनती। ये अत्यंत आवश्यक है की काव्य रचनाकार वास्तविकता और भ्रम के बीच की रेखा का ध्यान रखे अन्यथा भविष्य के दिग्भ्रमित होने का भय रहता है.
Recently I read and Rancharit Manas as translation of valmiki Ramadan. I am a Muslim woman deeply interested in religion so I know a little about different versions of Ramadan since my knowledge is not deep I did not question but felt very confused. What little I knew refused to believe ramcharit Manas as translation. Today I felt very happy to know that Mr agarwal endorsed my view. Feeling very confident sir, thanks a lot
Waise toh mai lalantop ke lagbhag videos dekhta hi hu but es interview ko dekhne ke baad mujhe aisa lga ki mujhe ek baar phir se lalantop ke saare videos ko phir se dekhna chahiye kuki khi koi important video mujhse miss na ho jaaye.. Now I am very thankful to saurabh bhaiya for this great video.. Ek ar important baat ki jb bhi professor Mr. Agarwaal saurabh bolte the to jaise mujhe lgta tha jaise unke samne mai baitha hu, because my name is also saurabh.
Very good Saurabh Ji giving so much respect to your teacher, he is fountain of knowledge. I occasionally come across him in tv discussion, his thoughts and comments are clear. I remember my teacher sh. J.c. Gupta who was teaching geography in higher secondary in govt higher secondary school No 2 Shakti Nagar, n. d. 110007. He was also a fountain of knowledge. I can't forget him even today after 36- 37 years.
अपने जीवन के बत्तीस वर्ष एक किताब लिखने में लगाए, क्या बात है, यूं ही नहीं कोई स्कालर बन जाता। ऐसे ही एक और स्कालर वी.एस सुकथांकर थे जिन्होंने सैंतालीस वर्ष लगा कर महाभारत का क्रिटीकल एडिशन तैयार किया था।
प्रो. पुरुषोत्तम अग्रवाल को पढ़ना और सुनना दोनों ही आनन्ददायक और ज्ञानवर्द्धक होता है। इनके साथ मध्यकालीन साहित्य और रचनाकारों पर एक श्रृंखला शुरू करें तो बहुत अच्छा रहेगा।
don't judge people especially if they are really intellectuals. I did my Ph.D. from History and this episode was more than an excellent lecture on Padmavat. thank u Saurabh for every topic that you introduced through the lallantop. unlogo k liye jo JNU ko leke likh rhe hain....''Gyan batoro itna ki pura pare jivan nhi, fir bhi jyada ho jaye to critical bano trollers nhi''
purushottam sir ka toh main bahut samman krta hi hun lekin aj pata chala saurav ji ki ap jnu se hain....sun ke ek ajeeb sa ehsas man me aya ki...yes..I knew ittt !! gajab ki pratibha hai ap me saurav ji...dil khush ho jata hai apko sun ke..itna karn priya bolte ho ki bus anand a jata...bhagwan apko khub safalta de aur ap bus aage hi badhte jao...
Please start a series on Indian literature with him 👍🏼
i concur that
Please write for us about the books Professor Sahib has mentioned in the discourse for we are not lucky enough to have encountered that literature.
I second it
Totally agree with Prashant Mishra ji
Very nice !
आप दोनों महानुभावों से पद्मावत पर चर्चा सुनकर मैं अपने आपको पद्मावत के बारे में अपनी जानकारी को और समृद्ध कर पाया । इसके लिए मैं आप दोनों का आभारी हूं। विशेष कर आदरणीय प्रो अग्रवाल साहब को सादर नमन।
Kashinath ji, humare channel pe Prof Agrawal ke saath aise hi jwalant muddo pe charcha ki hai. Humare channel pe join kare. Dhanyawaad :)
प्रो,अग्रवाल जी का साक्षात्कार सुन मेरे लिये एक उपलब्धि है इसमें आपके व्यक्तिव की ऊंचाई का भी पता चलता है ।आप हमेशा अच्छे विषय को इमानदारी से उठाते है कुछ तो jnu का कमाल और कुछ आपके संस्कार का ।आपको शुभकामनायें।
Bhagwan ji,
humare channel pe bhi Prof Agrawal ke saath aisi hi baatcheet hai. Join kare, sir. :)
Have you ever wondered what perfection is? This interaction between two wonderful human beings is perfection!
Ali, please join us on our channel for more such discussions with Prof Agrawal.
मां सरस्वती ,कि कृपा से एक अत्यन्त ज्ञानवर्धक वार्ता गुरु शिष्या के मध्य सुनने का अवसर मिला। धन्यवाद सौरभ ।लगा कि भारतेन्दु हरिश्चन्द्र, मैथलीशरण गुप्त कि परम्परा के अग्रवाल विद्वान आज भी हमारे मध्य मौजूद हैं।
Sitaram Goyal ji ko na bhuliyega .
Possibly the best episode of LallanTop. Great going Saurabh.
We have more such interesting conversation with Prof Agrawal on our channel. Please join us there. Thank you :)
बहुत सुंदर डिस्कसन जायसी हमने भी पढ़ा है पद्मावत मेरा प्रिय काव्य है ऐसे ही साहित्य का डिस्कसन हो
Please tell me sufi kon hai ?
@@anshuljain2158 सूफी वो होते हैं जो अपने भगवान से ही प्रेम करते हैं उन्हीं में अपनी लौ लगए रहते हैं
@@madhugirraj wow.. sufi ko manne wale aur padhne wale dono
कभी कभी यह महसूस होता है कि नकारात्मकता फ़ैलाने वाले इसलिए भी सफल हो पाते हैं क्योंकि वो अधिकतर जनभाषा में अपनी बात कहते हैं
U were rightly nervous about interviewing Dr. Puroshottam agarwal, and iam very thankful that u interviewed him, rather didnnot interview him and let him be himself , amazing to listen to him.
Prasoon ji,
We have many such conversations with Prof Agrawal on our channel. Please join us.
I just found this randomly while going through your channel since I follow it from long time. I was playing it on speakers and suddenly my dad exclaimes "Oh, he's my batchmate.", about Mr. Aggarwal.
"It feels good to see people you know, being up there", was what my dad said then.
Wow..... amazing
Thank you for a brilliant discussion. I thought this will be about khiljee and the horrors of deceit and war. Instead I learned to understand another viewpoint. An enjoyable serious experience
Saurav, our society need people and reporter like you... You are making a real change that is needed at this moment.... Proud of you buddy... Big time fan of yours...
Loved this interview..Will read this book
आप दोनो का ढेरों आभार इतने रोचक जानकारी पद्मावत से समबंधित देने के लिए। हिरामन तोता और प्रेम की उद्दातता से जुड़ी बातें जानकर ख़ुशी हुई।
At what cost! Not at the cost of integrity! Wah, Wah! Parnam Prof. Sahib. You have encapsulated the total concept of life. A truly lived life.
Really this conversation is spiritual and valuable for youth as well #thankyou
सौरभ जी, शुक्रिया। इस एपिसोड की ओपनिंग बहुत ही मार्मिक और हृदयस्पर्शी है। एक बहुत ही मर्यादित गुरु-शिष्य परम्परा का प्रदर्शन देखने को मिला।
Very interesting, knowledgeable
My both favrat come together i can't tell how much I happy........ Watching this at 4 am....... Majedaar.... love u lallantop......
Lala Ji, please join us on our channel for more such conversations with Prof Agrawal. Thank you :)
Happy to see two great educators of this era....thank you for everything.
Thanks, In the present to bring out such ideas are very important
बेहतरीन पोस्ट के लिए हार्दिक बधाई और भविष्य की कोटि-कोटि शुभकामनाऐ
🙏 Thank You 🙏
Thanks
आनंदप्रद मुलाकात........ एक बार फिर भौतिक जगत दूर ले जाकर पद्मावत का आत्मिक चित्रण करवाने का the lallantop का आभार!
भारतीय साहित्य पर इस प्रकार की श्रंखला शुरू करें।
thank you for share with us use full knowledge thank you for teach us what is love
Sir this was wonderful . Though I am not a student of literature but I enjoy the novel idea of padmavat. This has open my eyes also, that is, how to read a classical text . Many new ideas i have earned . Thank you sir so much
I never realized that literature is that important. Thanks Lallantop
suravi ji Literature is a reflection of the time it has been written. and thouth of writer nothing else It is up to you whether you are inpress it or not
kafi sukoon dene vala video.
Marvellous literary talk on a epic love story. Thanks Prof. Agarawal , Saurabh and Lallantop
इसमें बात सिर्फ पद्मावत की नहीं, समकालीन दुनिया और साहित्य की भी है।
बहुत समझदार इंसान लगे, इनकी बाकी किताबें भी पढ़ी जाएंगी।
Such beautiful conversation and so good comments
Itni beautiful discussion ke leye 80 k view only.....Share kro bhai logon.
Hello, humare channel pe bhi Prof Agrawal ke saath aise hi discussions hai. Please join kare. Thank you :)
@@MillennialMonkPodcast bilkul.
It gave me profound knowledge and pleasre.
Sourabh, many many thanks to you from the core of my heart not only for this awesome program but also for the role you're playing as a journalist. My best wishes to you and your team.
I have stopped the clip so as to remark as I can't hold myself any longer. Iam deeply deeply impressed by the beautiful teacher- son relationship that both you and Prof Sahib enjoy. I must say you have gladdened my heart by your humble attitude and exhibition of deep and genuine love and respect that you have for the august personality of dear Prof. Agrawal. Prof Sahib is on the dot ( as he always is) that the most a teacher can wish for is to see his wards doing well in life and living by the principles taught to him by his teacher. Bravo! You have cemented my belief in humanity and in the strength of human values Sir. As you would have guessed, Iam also a teacher ( an atrocious one, the only such specimen in history!) and recently one of my former students came to me, touched my knees and told me that he has been selected as college lecturer. It delighted me and ever since I am on an entirely different universe! That's what teachers feel when they see their students. Prof Sahib is an asset. I have listened to him on different channels and what a brilliant human being he is! Do me a favour , when you meet him pay my most respectful regards to him. He is right, we need more than tolerance. What we need in this region is empathy for others. This message should be clamoured from house tops throughout South Asia. I don't think Iam that old ( I think, others do not necessarily agree) but I want to say to you Sir: Salamat rahein Hamesha. You made me happy. Now to the discussion.
Asad ji, we have more such conversations with Prof Agrawal on our channel. Please join us there. Your comments will be awaited. Thank you :)
Phew! I had no idea what a learned person Prof. Purshottam Agarwal is - it is an honor to hear him speak. Thank you for introducing us to him. Also please show the book cover clearly.
Poonam ji, please join us on our channel for more such intense and interesting conversations with Prof Agrawal. He is in full form here ;)
Best ever interview on Lallantop ... Always admire professor purshuttam
Munawar ji, please join us on our channel for more such engaging conversations with Prof Agrawal.
@@MillennialMonkPodcast yes sure
श्री पुरुषोत्तम जी के वैचारिक विष्णेशन के लिए आभार।
What a talk❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing
Waah Bahut Sundar
Bahut sundar great running co running commentary.
बहुत अच्छा, हिन्दी में प्रकाशन पर...
महर्षि वाल्मीकि ने रावण के माध्यम से सीता के सौन्दर्य के प्रति जैसी अभिव्यक्ति दी है , वह सदा सुखांतकारी और कालजयी भी है। कौन ऐसा नहीं है ! धन्यवाद दोनों को। ऐसी प्रस्तुति के लिये!
This was very illuminating
Woww. its so interesting. It forced me not to get-up from my seat. I am fan of Saurav Dwivedi :)
Good discussion
दोनों गुरु चेला को हार्दिक नमस्कार
कवि का अलंकरण और काव्य रस के प्रति उसका आकर्षण ही कई बार इतिहास का शत्रु बन जाता है और अनजाने में वो इतिहास के साथ अन्याय कर बैठता है | उदाहरण के लिए हम अगर तुलसीदास की रामचरित्र मानस को लें तो इसमें ऐसे अनेक प्रसंग हैं जो की वाल्मीकि की रामायण (जो की इतिहास है) से बहुत अलग है, जैसे की सीता स्वयंवर में राम का जाना, जो की वाल्मीकि रामायण में नहीं है, और चूँकि वर्तमान रामचरित्र मानस को भी वास्तविकता मानता है इसलिए भ्रम की स्थिति बनती। ये अत्यंत आवश्यक है की काव्य रचनाकार वास्तविकता और भ्रम के बीच की रेखा का ध्यान रखे अन्यथा भविष्य के दिग्भ्रमित होने का भय रहता है.
bhai ji साहित्य अलंकृत इतिहास है उसको वैसे ही देखा जाना चाहिए
Recently I read and Rancharit Manas as translation of valmiki Ramadan. I am a Muslim woman deeply interested in religion so I know a little about different versions of Ramadan since my knowledge is not deep I did not question but felt very confused. What little I knew refused to believe ramcharit Manas as translation. Today I felt very happy to know that Mr agarwal endorsed my view.
Feeling very confident sir, thanks a lot
Maza aa gya simply outstanding
Best episode.
What a guesture to proffessor. Sir .. from saurabh sir .... good to see student giving soo much respect to Professor sir
Love is divine . True.
very nice
Great student by great interview for great teacher salute u sir
Waise toh mai lalantop ke lagbhag videos dekhta hi hu but es interview ko dekhne ke baad mujhe aisa lga ki mujhe ek baar phir se lalantop ke saare videos ko phir se dekhna chahiye kuki khi koi important video mujhse miss na ho jaaye.. Now I am very thankful to saurabh bhaiya for this great video.. Ek ar important baat ki jb bhi professor Mr. Agarwaal saurabh bolte the to jaise mujhe lgta tha jaise unke samne mai baitha hu, because my name is also saurabh.
Its the first time I am able to give some meaning to the existence of JNU in this country.
Bahut umda prastuti ! Rajendra chandrakant Rai
Sourabh bhai, you are doing great job, go ahead, congratulations
बहुत सार्थक और प्रेरक डॉक्ट र पुरुषोत्तम अग्रवाल साहब को सुनना अपने आप में एक आनंद दायक अनुभव है
I would do anything to learn from you. Mr purshottam aggrawal.
Ishan ji, your wish has come true. Please join us on our podcast for more such conversations with Prof Agrawal. Thank you :)
Bahut hi sunder saurav ji .padmawat par pro.purusottam Agrawal ke sath charcha sun kar abhibhut ho gaya.
Hi Saurav, eager to hear more amd more kitabwala kisse. In this chaotic and busy life, please encourage us more towards reading.
प्रोफेसर पुरुषोत्तम अग्रवाल का
2023 जुलाई में नया इंटरव्यू देखा तो लगा
कोई पुराना इंटरव्यू भी प्रोफेसर का देखा जाए
Man of wisdom and knowledge
बहुत खूब ।।
बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिला
26:55.... Teacher ki dhoons
Maa k baad Guru ka hi Shreshth sthaan hai...#Respect Sir...Sahi me apne Hindustan me sab kuch hai...
bahut badiya
Very good Saurabh Ji giving so much respect to your teacher, he is fountain of knowledge. I occasionally come across him in tv discussion, his thoughts and comments are clear. I remember my teacher sh. J.c. Gupta who was teaching geography in higher secondary in govt higher secondary school No 2 Shakti Nagar, n. d. 110007. He was also a fountain of knowledge. I can't forget him even today after 36- 37 years.
Ishwar ji, we have many such conversations with Prof Agrawal on our channel. Please join us there. Thank you :)
@@MillennialMonkPodcast OK sir.
Your style and neutrality are perfect Saurabh. Keep it up. Best wishes and Regards. Rajeev
something nice on lallantop after long time
Nice & knowledgeable interview regarding Padmavat.
Hope Dr Purushottam Agrawal ji and Sourabh both are opened the mind of the frog of well and religious robots to evolve to 21 century.
verry nice
Sandar batchit. ....aise hi aur poets writer ko bulaya kriye. ...lallantop sabse alg to kam bhi alg be continue. .....★★★★★
ham rajneta aur samajik logo ki bat sunte h...
hmlog samajh ka bhala karege ...yadi sahitykaro ko samman se padhna sikh jaye👌👌best line
वाह वाह वाह 👏👏👏👏 इतना विस्तृत सुनना मेरा सौभाग्य है पुरुषोत्तम जी 🙏🙏🙏🙏💐💐
Shanadar
*I am Addicted To LALANTOP* 💞💞😍💞💞
Prime Movie hum bhi ese hi he☺☺
Prime movie tm pdmavati hm ..ratan singh...and plz ye comment krne wale alauddin ke chkkar me n pdo
Prime Movie cobrapost episode ke bad bhi???
वाह वाह ! !!
It is an impressive discussion. Dr Surender Bhutani in Warsaw (Poland)
Wow
हम सभी सौभाग्यशाली हैं।सौरभ को सहृदय धन्यवाद !
काश की लोग जेएनयू का विरोध करने से पहले जेएनयू के बौद्धिक योगदान को समझ या जान लेते !
श्री सौरभ जी
आप इतना बता दो
की ये किताब हिंदी में उपलब्ध है क्या?
आप और आपके गुरूजी ने पद्मावत और प्यार के इतिहास को
सिर्फ 52 मिंटो में समझा दिए।
Best content 👌👌
अपने जीवन के बत्तीस वर्ष एक किताब लिखने में लगाए, क्या बात है, यूं ही नहीं कोई स्कालर बन जाता। ऐसे ही एक और स्कालर वी.एस सुकथांकर थे जिन्होंने सैंतालीस वर्ष लगा कर महाभारत का क्रिटीकल एडिशन तैयार किया था।
Purshottam Agarwal Sir is one of the gem of India. Salute to him.
Brij mohan ji, please join us on our channel for more such conversations with Prof Agrawal. Thank you :)
Very good interview
मैंने पद्मावत का अनुशीलन,इंद्रचंद्रनारग,लोकभारती प्रकाशन पढ़ा है पर यह पुस्तक कई नए आयाम खोलती है ऐसा आपकी बातचीत जो लेखक महोदय से हुई से लगता है।
Brilliant interview. Pleased to know the genius Prof. Purushottam.
Ziaul Hussain ji, please join us on our channel for more such incredible conversations with Prof Agrawal. Thank you :)
Ji ha, itane gyani guruji ke saath dusari kitabo ya topic par bhi charcha honi chahie jisase ham logbhi labhanvit ho sake🙏
प्रो. पुरुषोत्तम अग्रवाल को पढ़ना और सुनना दोनों ही आनन्ददायक और ज्ञानवर्द्धक होता है। इनके साथ मध्यकालीन साहित्य और रचनाकारों पर एक श्रृंखला शुरू करें तो बहुत अच्छा रहेगा।
Mithilesh ji, humare channel pe humne yahi karne ki koshish ki hai Prof Agrawal ke saath. Please unhe wahaan sune. Aapke comments ka intezaar rahega.
My fav professor
Rahul ji, we have more such conversations with your favourite Prof Agrawal on our channel. Please join us there. Thank you :)
don't judge people especially if they are really intellectuals. I did my Ph.D. from History and this episode was more than an excellent lecture on Padmavat. thank u Saurabh for every topic that you introduced through the lallantop. unlogo k liye jo JNU ko leke likh rhe hain....''Gyan batoro itna ki pura pare jivan nhi, fir bhi jyada ho jaye to critical bano trollers nhi''
Pranjali ji, we have many such interesting conversations with Prof Agrawal. Please join us there. Thank you :)
👍👍
purushottam sir ka toh main bahut samman krta hi hun lekin aj pata chala saurav ji ki ap jnu se hain....sun ke ek ajeeb sa ehsas man me aya ki...yes..I knew ittt !! gajab ki pratibha hai ap me saurav ji...dil khush ho jata hai apko sun ke..itna karn priya bolte ho ki bus anand a jata...bhagwan apko khub safalta de aur ap bus aage hi badhte jao...
Is this book on Amazon?