It’s nice that the fandom is more chill now than it was in the spring. It sucks that Welcome Home lost some of its fans and some of the traction it had, but it’s good that the people who stuck around are much more chill. The fandom vibes have gotten so much less chaotic and toxic.
Hey Matpat! I wanted to draw some attention to some info about the apple situation. There’s some old information (that the canon state of is up in the air) that Wally eats things through his eyes! He canonically greatly enjoys apples and I believe that the darkening of the screen may be him blinking to bite! Thank you for continuing to look at this!
That's what I think too because we've seen Wally eat till now if that was him. But this also begs the question of if the others know this is how Wally eats. Because if they do then Barnaby's line wouldn't make sense unless he was just teasing.
Fr like I’ll just listen to music half listening to their conversation. One second I’ll be listening to music zoning out and they are chatting about math two seconds later I hear “I eat children” and I just question everything 💀
I think it's just that Eddie is trying to stay professional but gets comfortable to use a first name for Frank Yknow since the creator draws them kissing all the time on tumblr lol. they're boyfriends your honor, I doubt a stuttered name goes deeper than that
I also want to add is that if you listen to Franks tone of voice with Eddie, it's diffrent then with the others. AS so far we really only ever heard him use a strict or upset tone with them. Eddie is the only one I beileve we've heard him use a playful/loving tone with.
I really like Clown's approach to puzzles. They are like baby's first ARG and are a great way to introduce people to this type of media! Unfortunately our brains have been so rotten by FNAF and such that we overcomplicate the puzzles
Overcomplicating indeed, I'd point to Mat immediately going "what other kid, who could this other kid be" when Barnaby addresses Wally as "kid" all the time.
@@babulbi Clown even tried to account for it once, remember? The puzzle where the first letter of each answer to the quiz was the password? The hint not was like "no l33t speak, no capitalization, no special characters, maybe it has to do with the quizz" and MatPat was legit mad about how simple it ended up being lol
I really appreciate that Clown makes the puzzles simple enough for the average viewer. You still have to work for the answers sometimes, but you don't need specialized knowledge to complete them.
31:24 a thing I noticed with the way Frank interacts with Wally at that moment feels kinda... defiant? Like he says "they're like you or me" and then calls on Wally. If we follow on "Frank is a guy in a disguise", is he calling on Wally like "You are in a disguise too, aren't you?"
I have 3 theories I'd care to share: 38:10 the fact that the narrator says we are "peering through the window" of Poppy's home seems like an extremely important detail, especially when compared to real-life children's shows. Viewers are often active members of the community or acknowledged/welcomed tourists. Here, however, the viewers are like spies. I can't remember if you've mentioned that before, but it seemed important to me. 39:20 Going off the idea that the narrator *is* Wally, maybe that was Wally's original role--until he got jealous and lonely and Home offered to make him real, to give him a name and a face and make him part of the neighborhood. 41:09 The "monsters in the woods" that come out to "view them" at night are us. This can tie back to my first theory in this comment. I think the statement at 42:39 that the noises can be heard "especially if you wait next to your window" confirms this.
@@ShadowPhoenix82maybe consuming like how we consume media, we click on whatever bugs we see on the website absorbing their knowledge wanting to absorb the knowledge of the characters
Ah, I was thinking that it would be the human backstage cast that would be the monster. Given that bugs disappearing, bushes being moved and house exteriors being messed with could be the human workers touching up the set between episodes. Plus if neighbours have gone missing overnight in the past, it could be the characters being retired from the show. Of course, given what it is, being retired would be a little more sinister than a character being dropped normally.
If I remember correctly in the apartment- hallway one the birds name is "the greeter" then a yellow one called "the waiter" then "the follower" is like a blue goat or ram thing
Between all the well written dialogue and the incredible art style, I honestly kind of just want an actual welcome home show. Not a creepy pseudo-horror thing, just like an actual tv show with these characters. I love the ARG stuff, but it almost makes me sad that we’ll likely never see these characters outside that context. All that to say that ClownIllustrations is an absolute master of design for coming up with all this, and even though I know this ended up being stressful for them I hope they feel proud of what they’ve made.
Considering how passionate some fans are nowadays, you bet there will be someone out there crazy enough to make a whole episode with the vibrant style of this lost show
@@Valentina-ng4hhclown himself, he does have a puppet of his own, but also, to put, quote on quote, would be a lot to deal with, especially with the fans and their problematic issues. Honestly would love to watch a few episodes but, it's also the risk they take cause, remember: copy right claims.
Wally is known to eat with his eyes! He was taking a bite out of the candy apple. Also in the art for the Halloween episode he was holding a bitten caramel apple!
Glad someone else noticed the apple in the poster, I was going crazy with Matpat not noticing it. That and him not remembering playfellow is the television company associated with the show being spelled out on the very first page
@@alexisfox9206agree, and some others that are in clowns twitter too. But also, let's not forget Julie is a rainbow monster with siblings of her own, also to point out the whole neighbourhood, the one that stands out is Frank and yet, we barely know much then what his character catalogue says.
@@average-art3222 oh no Frank is def important. Either he'll be the first to figure out whatever is happening or already knows and is trying to help (both work honestly)..
@@alexisfox9206plus, his name doesn't end with an e sound like the others, like Wally, Sally, Julie, poppy, they all end with an "E" sound while Frank ends with a "K" ... he is definitely important cause he's the colorless character around, along the fact he has a garden and eats, while the others, not sure if so cause of Wally, can eat with his eyes. But a lot of people have head theories that, it either the puppets of their puppeteers but, that's honestly where it goes ngl.
Eddie Dear being a suspect is interesting, especially since he is forgetful. In which I mean he forgets things. Maybe he could be the creature that lurks around at night.
@@lukacunningham342well they technically aren’t married by this point yet. Also if I remember correctly (so please correct me if I’m wrong) but didn’t clown say that was only a scrapped concept for the show
I also think it’s interesting because Sally has always held some kind of disdain towards him. She doesn’t like Eddie much, which would make sense if she hears this monster in the town every night and knows (or at least suspects) it’s him.
I think the thing we've not touched on yet is the orientation of Wally's eyes. His eyes are either "content" or "alert" at any moment. I think this is either the separation of when he's in his "surveillance" mode versus being in control. Perhaps it indicates that there's two different Wally's entirely, but the direction his eyes are tilted seems to have some sort of importance.
Yes, Clown revealed this on their Tumblr and Twitter. Though, fun fact, if he were to see an apple pie he wouldn't know what to do with it (he'd be like 'this isn't an apple' and just not eat it).
I like how the other characters don’t know/realize Wally eats with his eyes so, in this case, Barnaby doesn’t realize Wally bit the apple. Also I imagine Wally is looking from barnaby to the apple making sure he isn’t looking so he can take a bite.
I would just like to point out that Frank dressed up as a vampire for the Halloween update so that would specify why he calls out the teeth marks. Hope this helps
So like when Barnaby points them out and Frank specifically says that it’s fake, that could mean that he’s just saying that it couldn’t have been him if there fake
Wally isn't brought into the conversation at its end, rather the conversation continues with Wally included. We only get to see the parts of conversation when Wally is just listening in and doesn't need to talk, and I can confirm that people listening to conversations without being brought in is a thing that can happen.
I have to admit, Ash's project was definitely a help for me in trying to finish my own. And I've not actually gotten to the end of the book, but I did pass 50,000 words about four and a half hours before the deadline, so I think it was a month well spent. Thanks, Ash!
Eddie has the bitten apple package, but...Eddie's a mailman. That doesn't belong to him. He's simply about to deliver it and as others have called out, Wally canonically loves apples. I didn't know about the lore floating around that says he eats with his eyes but he absolutely is able to reach out and absorb energies and brainwash people with them so I think it makes more sense that Home "took a bite" of the candy apple through Wally's eyes and that Eddie is delivering that package to Wally.
The haunting video is basically a scary story related to the town/Home. I find it interesting how it’s Sally that tells this story since she hasn’t been in the forefront thus far. Not to mention, near the end, Sally’s voice sounds very close to the recording. She obviously knows something. I wonder what it all means.
if anyone is looking for some deep dive stuff on welcome home and a lot of analog horror i highly recommend night mind! their voiceovers are awesome and i personally love their voice and expressions!
Seconded! And they specialize in ARGs so it's very in-depth analysis. As much as I love MatPat, I agree more with NightMind's interpretation of WH so far.
i think the bitten apple is connected to Frank. we already think hes different, trying to figure out what's going on. i think he gets called out for the apple, not bc he actually ate it, but to connect the apple symbolism to him. for the box, eddie is a mailman. those boxes aren't his. the box is green and yellow, so is frank's house and sweater. giving frank more connection to the bitten apple
This might just be me, and I also noticed everyone's names end in an 'E' sound, except Frank. Sally, Wally, Julie, Eddie, Barnaby, Howdy, Poppy...then Frank. That also sets him apart. The only thing with that is there's also Home, who doesn't have an 'E' sound at the end of their name either. I dunno, could be me overthinking, just food for thought! 😊
@@little_to_no_opinion6788 Well Frank makes up by being Frank Frankly but yeah with his name as is he just keeps showing how much of the outlier he is in the neighborhood.
@@Songal18 that's also very true! I wasn't even taking into consideration their last names. If we're to take it that way then that completely throws the idea out the window, so if anything it's just kinda a fun lil coincidence 😊
MatPat at 46:00 a speech bubble shows up next to Wally and the word "Hello" is written out. I can't say this information is 100% correct because I didn't see the posts myself, but I've seen a lot of people say that Frank and Eddie are canonically a couple. If Frank is already suspicious it's not a stretch to think their (Frank is nonbinary) partner would be too.
Clown has confirmed on their tumblr that Frank and Eddie are 100% a couple. Also, Frank is non-binary and goes by "they/them" (also canon). Hope this helps!
Slightly unrelated to your comment, but I didn't see anyone in the comments mention it, save for you. That hello bubble becomes a clickable link with an audio file from Wally.
That's really interesting that they're a couple. Might explain why Frank is teasing and Eddie called him frank. The neighborhood could want them to just be neighbors which would be interesting
Just a bit more about apples connected to Halloween - apples were traditionally buried at Halloween to feed the dead. They also contain a star, or pentagram, in the centre, symbolic of protection and often used in occult settings. Perhaps I’ve jumped too far into things there, but the focus on apples and them being used to feed the dead is particularly interesting.
I think the closed captions and audio descriptions are genius. I feel like by making it a character in and of itself not only does it add to the average viewer but it helps encapsulate the vibe better for people actually who need it. Like it adds an element of mystery that would probably get lost in a literal transcription.
Something that frustrates me is that he went for the secret stuff and it caused him to completely miss things that he would have gotten if he had done things in the right order.
Between the fangs and Sally’s monster that’s two vampire references (with it not breaking into homes but just wandering the streets at night) and Eddie is a mailman. So naturally he has to interact with everyone and know where they live even if this wasn’t a small community. Maybe this was supposed to give him more opportunities to be invited in?
The "fang" reference was towards Frank's costume during Halloween. He was dressed as a Vampire for the Halloween special, and Barnaby messes with Frank often, so I took it as Barnaby knowing Wally took a bite, but used it as an opportunity to say that Frank bit it because he "sees fang marks" (targeting Frank by alluding to his costume).
Matpat is the embodiment of the beard makes the man. With beard, he oozes daddy vibes. Without, he looks like he drank the water from the fountain of youth.
I know this might be a stretch, but when she says "I forget how many eyes my brother has... At least two. Or was it three? No, no two..." I was thinking about Home's windows being eyes. Then saw that Frank's house has 3 windows - as though there were three eyes - and wondered if there might be a connection there. Probably not, but regardless, it's weird that Barnaby's place doesn't show ANY windows.
So grateful for youtubers like NightMind and yourself for continuing to break down these updates. My ADHD would never let me find everything they've worked so well to include into the story. I continue to get so excited every time there happens to be an update. It's one of the only things thats so interesting, it'll be the one thing I give atttention to until I've watched you give your opinions. And kudos to the team behind Welcome Home in general. Keeping my brain and soul well-fed. EDIT: Wait.... I just noticed that the road surrounding Home seems to be star-shaped..... Interesting......
What I got from the Halloween video was that, we (the camera or pov) are wally. But not just Wally, it’s house looking trough Wally. Wally isn’t there, that’s why he isn’t talking, his just observing for house. When his “call to action” happens, house lets go and lets Wally take over. All the videos, are house watching through Wally. (The person writing the translation is probably just some worker watching the video, given a job.) But that’s just a theory!
To be honest I love the chaos of GTLive and it's probably my favorite of all the channels. :) It would be so cool if Matt played Cult Of The Lamb to be honest!!! It's such a cozy game. :D
Wally: *exists* MatPat: Everyone but Wally is sus and are evil. >.> I genuinely love Matt's thought process sometimes. xD Also Matty O'Patty I'm waiting on that Pinkie Pie theory.
I don’t know that you guys are talking about, I love it when may pauses the videos to talk about it!!! I’m autistic and personal do this with my friends, it annoys them so much. But to see a creator that I look up to do it, makes me happy knowing that I’m not alone :)
I have no idea about the Welcome Home fanbase being smaller but I've been chilling with it so yea, sure. The character designs and everything else really has their own charm. Cool stuff
The site had recently updated and the little tasks like move Barnaby aren't for us! They're for Wally from someone running the site! So they can confirm that he as an entity exists
With the sudden notice that there is an unknown entity who is transcribing events going on but not necessarily knowing what is going on and having an opinion, plus then the inclusion of a mysterious narrator who listens in on the characters out of sight. . . That sounds like the monster in Sally's story to me. I think this is another character we just haven't been aware of until now
Better late than never, thanks for covering this Matpat, and going over the newest update. Barnaby is a comedian so he fits into the role of Pedrolino. Which in French Pedrolino is known as Pierrot, but that fact it is Sally specifically who is. Wally is possibly the Conduit for this Entity that Home is infested with(or is if Home is the Entity taken on physical form to blend in). Eddie shows in this update that like Wally and possibly Frank knows much, much more than we realize. Now the "fang marks" I think is just Barnaby being silly because so far we've yet to see anybody with "fangs" outside of costumes. Also Barnaby CALLS Wally Kid, because Wally is younger than him, and as a term of endearment. Now we know Wally eats with his eyes, but does anybody in the Neighborhood know about this about Wally, because if they don't then they wouldn't suspect Wally eating the apple. I don't think Eddie is evil, but I do think he is not as he seems, I think he is playing two roles-The friendly neighborhood mailman and the man who knows what is really going on and knows he needs to play his role or his friends and him will pay the price. The Narrator I think was just made for this audio recording, but maybe they were also in the show? We'll have to see in more updates if they return. Sally's story definitely cuts out and she talks directly to us the people listening to this very recording because the record distortion goes away. Which shows that maybe more or all the Neighbors know what is going on and are all looking for our help and not just Wally, they're all doing it in their unique ways-Wally with his phone calls, Eddie with letters, Frank with Bugs, and Sally with stories. Sorry for the long comment I just have a lot to say on this Project. Ash I hope we all get to see your story published.
Not sure if this was thought of but the "kid" Barnaby refers to could still be Wally. Someone older (Barnaby) may refer to someone younger (Wally) as kid, kiddo, etc. Not that there is another separate person who is the kid. Plus I think I recall Wally likes apples?
I think it would be cool if Matpat did a video on "The Man in the Suit" I recently came across it and thought it would be good since it fits in with the whole Analog Horror.
25:48 based on delivery I think “kid” is Wally. Plus, he references his “little devil” watching his Apple, Wally is dressed as a devil. Not sure who bit the Apple, but Wally is the only one there (as far as we know) 24:04 I think if he was talking to someone and then turned to Wally there would’ve been more emphasis on “you” like if the interior is: “Ah don’t worry about it, there’s plenty to eat here. What about you Wally? What are you craving?” Then I think the delivery would’ve been more along the lines of “what are *you* feel hungry for, Wally?” As a way to say “hey, what about you?”
I love all of Mats thoughts here. But with his thought of Eddie being, potentially, evil because of the apple on one of the boxes he’s carrying connecting to the glitch apple in the video…. I think he’s missing a HUGE detail there with the fact that Eddie is the mail man and each thing he’s carrying is for another character and not him. The top is a bow shaped present for Julie, the bottom is Barnaby’s, and I think the middle looks the most like it represents Howdy. I think this because of its green coloring but also because Howdy is literally holding an apple in his own imagery and the box he holds is an apple with a caterpillar in it. Do I know why that distinction could matter or what it means? Absouletly not. Do I think Howdy might have fangs? Or that he even ate the apple? No! I’ve got no idea. But I feel that detail could be important if who the apple “connects to” ends up mattering at all. And for Howdy not being in the video I’m not sure if that matters either. Just a thought I had and wanted to share. Potentially it could also be tying Howdy to Eddie? With the other video we got showing Eddie being afraid of a bug and Howdy having a lot of ties to potentially being a caterpillar. Maybe Eddie is scarred of Howdy? Idk anyway I love welcome home so much and I’m glad Mat is covering it.
I'm pretty sure the audio transcriptions are coming from the restoration team and not from Wally. They are restoring the pieces of media from a lost state and not all of the footage is in tact so they're putting their best guess in the transcription, that's why it said "I think".
Hey Matt and crew. I think I might have an idea on how to uncover the website command things. Although I'm not entirely certain it may work as I'm no expert, I feel Matt was on the right track. I feel you may need some website coding knowledge perhaps, so like he said, copy the website into your own version of the website that way you have access to editing the code itself. From there you can add text, alter the formatting of text etc. Another thing for you Matt, you mentioned wishing there was a way you could see what something is exactly? There kind of is. If you right click a website you can "inspect element", this is the page's source code. You can also press Control, Shift and C to get here. Once this opens, there's a dotted box with an arrow, or you can press Control, Shift and C again to be able to highlight an object on the page, and it will jump to that area of code. I hope this can help in any sort of way, and best of luck👍
I didn’t even know he was still paying attention to welcome home. I’m so excited he finally saw the October update and I can’t wait for 2024 for the new update. Love the team at gt ❤️❤️❤️ also it looks like there wasn’t another update but some notes got released I think this may be a mistake
i feel like the implication for poppy, the whole "reverse this image", is that shes much more deeply connected to wally than we think because the moment that matpat reversed the image, i immediately noticed that she has the same color palette as wally. it could be because i just had this on the bg while i was drawing and art and colors was on the mind, but it is something-- i could also be completely wrong but hey, thats theorizing
the bite if the apple could also represent one of the characters gaining more knowledge about their situation if you connect it to the apple of knowledge
In my opinion, the asks or commands that MatPat discussed at the end of the video is home or wally seeing if they could add you, the viewer/player into their "cult" or make you a puppet. Or something like that. Also, im not sure, but maybe when you reverse sally and imagine the reverse picture where the picture usually is, it may look like she's pointing or praising home. Idk tho
Also, MatPat if you're reading this, I want you to know something. My mom, who is an English teacher, watched this video with me and she was very impressed with how you dissected the information and your use of words. She said that she would bring you up in her next class to show her students how she wanted them to search for information in books and stuff. :D
Here's a compilation of Ash's book clues: -There's 3 of them (The Rainman) -Not a trilogy -Not a Bible Sequel -Numerous (DON'T SCREAM) -Not about numbers or the populous -No chapters no clue(FnaF Quiz) -Criticism (Smiling Critteer Cartoon) -Amy guessed Anthropocene Review, which Ash said was the closest anyone's gotten -Alignments (Outcore: Desktop Adventure) -It is about Tension but not about being a Chiropractor -You have to think about these words like you think about Connections -Memory (Fears to Fathom: Ironbark Lookout) -Not about Cats Amy guessed fictional dairy entires, not quite, but in the ballpark -Amy guesses Multimedia (Ergodic) Ash says no but also yes? -Hiatus (Five Nights At Freddy's Help Wanted 2) -Perspective Shift ("Spectacle" The Walten Files Minisode) no clue? (Fears to Fathom: Ironbark Lookout) -History (Cool Math Games ARG) -Contains Pieces -They guessed Period piece and Ash said a doubtful 'Mm?' -Writing (Welcome Home Website Update) -Inspired by the Theorist community. It's a Puzzle book -The book is about the lore of the character(s) within
if you look at the website now, sally's image has been reversed, playfellow turned upside down, ok and hello have been written, and barnaby has been moved
I would like to recommend playing a nancy drew game. Especialy now that they are making a small arg for their next game. They are detective point and click games. I would specifically recommend the ghost of Thornton hall. It's an amazing game, and I would love to see your reaction to it.😊
the bit apple in eddie's art is a gift, there is a Barnelby themed one directly under it. its most likely a gift for Wally, as he is known to like apples, as well as holding a bitten one in the halloween art.
Hey MatPat, in the guestbook when you scroll all the way down you see all the neighbors signatures. If you look at Howdy's signature it has a bitten apple. Don't know if that's important I just think it's something to put a lil thought into🤭💕
It should also be noted that in the “happy haunting to boo and yours” picture that Wally has an candy apple and it has a bite taken out of it. It correlates with what Matt was saying about a bite out of an apple being a representation of a villain or of evil. Definitely something to think about.
"Inspect Element," or some other thing depending on your browser probably, can be used to edit the html of a page you are looking at. By using the one tool that selects the element you click on and pressing delete, you can remove elements.
46:00 I don’t know if anyone else commented on this already, but when you were in the guestbook, Wally was drawn a speech bubble. It seems to me someone was writing hello in it, could the “write hello” thing be related to that? Edit: I know there is a code to flip an image, I think it was “flip box”. I’m not good at programming stuff though, so I am not able to get it to work with the code sadly.
A couple things to point out: First off, I’m not sure if this is canon or fanon, but I’m pretty sure it’s been said that Wally can eat with his eyes, and I’m also pretty sure Clown said that apples are Wally’s favorite food. Second, about the Boo and Yours audio and the whole idea of this monster at night, remember that drawing of Julie Clown put on their website before you click the link to Welcome home? I know they said it’s not canon/related to WH but I do think it’s worth considering that Julie is depicted as this cursed monster type thing in that one.
Someone has probably noticed this but I just wanna point out how Wally was holding a candy apple with a bite in it in the Halloween picture of all the characters. I also think that the box with apples on it could be for Wally because there seemed to be a package for Barnaby( probably didn’t spell that right) it had paw marks and bones so maybe apples hold a strong connection with Wally like how bones and paw marks correlate with Barnaby. Idk just a thought
Why didn't Mat point out that the captioning said "It sounds like Barnaby pats the camera." To me that's clearly indicating that Wally is the camera and Barnaby was like patting his shoulder or something.
41:35 The sound reminds me of the huge "clack" sound effect they normally use when someone is flipping a large switch (normally it is like, to a stage production light, shining down on the stage from above)
Hey there! So I saw in the Welcome Home ARG Subreddit that Clown apparently said that these commands (write hello, write "ok", etc.) were an accident and he didn't mean to publish them yet. I haven't been able to find the source where he says this, but it would explain why nobody has been able to figure out how to act on the commands yet.
I love welcoming home a lot. Im not always looking at its contents looking at others things. When i see that video telling there is more i always come right back to see more welcome home
One thing I wonder is how filming was supposed to happen when the show was being made. The neighbors seems very much alive, and don’t seem to know about the audience. (Though I could be wrong about that). On the other hand we always view the world through Wally’s eyes, so it makes me wonder if somehow the Wally pov is supposed to be how the show is filmed??? Idk, I’d love to hear other thoughts Edit: also I’d like to mention that the “narrator” sounds like Frank imo
Ash. Have you ever read The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime? cuz the formatting clues are making me think of this book (not so much the context clues)
Hi! i dont know tons about this ARG, but when you go to the guestbook page and click on the "hello." that is written out in the speech bubble next to wally, it takes you to a voice memo on a separate page. It may be an old thing but thats all i could find that was connected to the word Hello in that way
My headcanon is that the name "Welcome Home" is the biggest clue of all. It's more like "Welcome, Home." As in, Wally is the harbinger of the arrival of Home in new worlds.
Interestingly, there is a Biblical reference in the Halloween/fall party video. After the apple is bitten, Barnaby comes over and says Wally was guarding it. He refers to Wally as a little devil. In the Bible Satan or the devil is hiding in the tree with the apple, when he convinces Eve to take a bite. When she does, Eve gains knowledge from the forbidden fruit. Barnaby then calls out Frank, accusing him of biting the apple. Could this scene confirm the idea that Frank knows what is going on here? That maybe after this moment, Frank gains the knowledge that the neighborhood is not just a simple place. I am also not saying that Wally convinces Frank to eat it, or that Barnaby is God. Just an interesting idea to play with. We all know how much ARGs love Biblical references.
Frank and Eddie being Adam and Eve could be a thing if we have the Biblical side of this Project still part of it. Because Frank and Eddie are going to be a couple but it's just going to be a slow burn type of story for them, then maybe Frank helps Eddie see the truth of the neighborhood.
@@Songal18 That would make sense. I have seen theories that they are in love with each other, but because this show takes place in a time when that would not be okay, Frank and Eddie may hide this fact. If it were the case that they are in love, then the references towards the bitten apple for both of them make a lot of sense.
It sounds the most plausible, as the 'beta' for the ARG had a lot of satanic/religious references (i.e. the picture of Wally doing that 'as above so below' pose). And Wally does love apples, he is a character who is initially ignorant but desires knowledge and apples in Christian mythology are symbols of 'forbidden knowledge'. Which, in this context, would mean the characters (so far only Wally and Frank) know full well they are puppets and are trying to communicate with us. Though, I have a new theory brewing in my head. What if Eddie is some kind of 'vampire' like monster? The evidence for this is - he is the mailman so he knows where everyone lives (and can go to their houses under the guise of 'delivering mail' to them), he often 'forgets' a lot of things (he could be lying but if he isn't then he would be going into 'monster mode' quite often), and he is the only character who has no real backstory of where he came from (he remembers he came from somewhere outside the town but that's it). And it would be ironic, as he is dressed like a scarecrow/frankenstein while Frank is the one dressed like a vampire (in my opinion if my theory is true their costumes reflect the role/nature of the other - both are in sense a 'fake', Eddie being a legit monster while Frank isn't even a real puppet). In fact, the halloween costumes may just reflect the roles of the characters as well...Wally is an easy one, but the others I'll have to figure out.
I’ve never been obsessed with an ARG like this before and ITS JUST HAD AN UPDATE, I’m so excited to see what Matpat and crew are going to discover !! V excite !!!
It’s nice that the fandom is more chill now than it was in the spring. It sucks that Welcome Home lost some of its fans and some of the traction it had, but it’s good that the people who stuck around are much more chill. The fandom vibes have gotten so much less chaotic and toxic.
I think they moved on to Amazing Digital Circus now
@@ezraprisclikely
@@ezrapriscThat’s why I’m staying far away from ADC lol
@@ezrapriscLike animals, they will find food, but find even bigger pile of food.
So, what happened that shrunk the fandom?
Hey Matpat!
I wanted to draw some attention to some info about the apple situation. There’s some old information (that the canon state of is up in the air) that Wally eats things through his eyes! He canonically greatly enjoys apples and I believe that the darkening of the screen may be him blinking to bite! Thank you for continuing to look at this!
A lot of gif out there of it and I love it
That's what I think too because we've seen Wally eat till now if that was him. But this also begs the question of if the others know this is how Wally eats. Because if they do then Barnaby's line wouldn't make sense unless he was just teasing.
Yes! And with the captions not being neutral, remember that everything is being given by the Welcome Home Restoration Society! THEY’RE the captions!
@@Songal18 they probably don't, or the bite is different depending on who's in control of wally's body.
@@sabertoothno34 Yeah.
Wally feels like the friend of the group that just zones out and dissociates a bunch and I feel so seen!
Fr like I’ll just listen to music half listening to their conversation. One second I’ll be listening to music zoning out and they are chatting about math two seconds later I hear “I eat children” and I just question everything 💀
The true reality is just Wally dissociating and zoning out when everyone is talking. Poor sod just spaces out.
Relatable
I think it's note worthy that during the bug conversation Eddie first says "Frank" and then corrects himself and says "Mr Frankly"
Yes I also thought this was weird and should be called out!
I think it's just that Eddie is trying to stay professional but gets comfortable to use a first name for Frank
Yknow since the creator draws them kissing all the time on tumblr lol. they're boyfriends your honor, I doubt a stuttered name goes deeper than that
I also want to add is that if you listen to Franks tone of voice with Eddie, it's diffrent then with the others. AS so far we really only ever heard him use a strict or upset tone with them. Eddie is the only one I beileve we've heard him use a playful/loving tone with.
@@purrpletiger2159I believe even husbands
I really like Clown's approach to puzzles. They are like baby's first ARG and are a great way to introduce people to this type of media! Unfortunately our brains have been so rotten by FNAF and such that we overcomplicate the puzzles
Overcomplicating indeed, I'd point to Mat immediately going "what other kid, who could this other kid be" when Barnaby addresses Wally as "kid" all the time.
It's so straight forward that it has people looking way too deep out of habit.
@@babulbi Clown even tried to account for it once, remember? The puzzle where the first letter of each answer to the quiz was the password? The hint not was like "no l33t speak, no capitalization, no special characters, maybe it has to do with the quizz" and MatPat was legit mad about how simple it ended up being lol
I’m not quite sure why they thought that it would be straight after the brain melting popular inscription arg
I really appreciate that Clown makes the puzzles simple enough for the average viewer. You still have to work for the answers sometimes, but you don't need specialized knowledge to complete them.
31:24 a thing I noticed with the way Frank interacts with Wally at that moment feels kinda... defiant? Like he says "they're like you or me" and then calls on Wally. If we follow on "Frank is a guy in a disguise", is he calling on Wally like "You are in a disguise too, aren't you?"
smart suggestion😮sounds right
I have 3 theories I'd care to share:
38:10 the fact that the narrator says we are "peering through the window" of Poppy's home seems like an extremely important detail, especially when compared to real-life children's shows. Viewers are often active members of the community or acknowledged/welcomed tourists. Here, however, the viewers are like spies. I can't remember if you've mentioned that before, but it seemed important to me.
39:20 Going off the idea that the narrator *is* Wally, maybe that was Wally's original role--until he got jealous and lonely and Home offered to make him real, to give him a name and a face and make him part of the neighborhood.
41:09 The "monsters in the woods" that come out to "view them" at night are us. This can tie back to my first theory in this comment. I think the statement at 42:39 that the noises can be heard "especially if you wait next to your window" confirms this.
Then how are we consuming neighbors? Even occasional insects that cross our path as we watch the show?
That's actually very interesting
@@ShadowPhoenix82maybe consuming like how we consume media, we click on whatever bugs we see on the website absorbing their knowledge wanting to absorb the knowledge of the characters
Ah, I was thinking that it would be the human backstage cast that would be the monster.
Given that bugs disappearing, bushes being moved and house exteriors being messed with could be the human workers touching up the set between episodes.
Plus if neighbours have gone missing overnight in the past, it could be the characters being retired from the show.
Of course, given what it is, being retired would be a little more sinister than a character being dropped normally.
Goes well with the culty vibe
It was quite sad the WH Fandom has gotten smaller, but I am glad some people still love this as much as I do!
Yeah- Kinda like the 123 slaughter me street Fandom that was smaller than welcomw home, now practically dead- but im glad this one's still Goin! ^^
@-WAS-THAT-THE-BITE-OF-87 I have heard of that Fandom, it has puppet things right? Like a pink bird puppet?
@maddieneko5778 yeah- I think it's a emu- I'm not quite sure- but I think the fandom was popular because of a fnf mod- that's how I found it atleast-
If I remember correctly in the apartment- hallway one the birds name is "the greeter" then a yellow one called "the waiter" then "the follower" is like a blue goat or ram thing
@@-WAS-THAT-THE-BITE-OF-87 I see, I might look into it
Between all the well written dialogue and the incredible art style, I honestly kind of just want an actual welcome home show. Not a creepy pseudo-horror thing, just like an actual tv show with these characters. I love the ARG stuff, but it almost makes me sad that we’ll likely never see these characters outside that context. All that to say that ClownIllustrations is an absolute master of design for coming up with all this, and even though I know this ended up being stressful for them I hope they feel proud of what they’ve made.
Considering how passionate some fans are nowadays, you bet there will be someone out there crazy enough to make a whole episode with the vibrant style of this lost show
you mean like dhmis?
@@AltKaxREAL Yeah but it would be better if it was made by the original creator.
@@Valentina-ng4hhclown himself, he does have a puppet of his own, but also, to put, quote on quote, would be a lot to deal with, especially with the fans and their problematic issues. Honestly would love to watch a few episodes but, it's also the risk they take cause, remember: copy right claims.
Wally is known to eat with his eyes! He was taking a bite out of the candy apple. Also in the art for the Halloween episode he was holding a bitten caramel apple!
Glad someone else noticed the apple in the poster, I was going crazy with Matpat not noticing it. That and him not remembering playfellow is the television company associated with the show being spelled out on the very first page
@@EarthquakerI think it could be cause he hasn't checked the Tumblr page.. like at all.. which he should do, cause a lot of extra info is there
@@alexisfox9206agree, and some others that are in clowns twitter too. But also, let's not forget Julie is a rainbow monster with siblings of her own, also to point out the whole neighbourhood, the one that stands out is Frank and yet, we barely know much then what his character catalogue says.
@@average-art3222 oh no Frank is def important. Either he'll be the first to figure out whatever is happening or already knows and is trying to help (both work honestly)..
@@alexisfox9206plus, his name doesn't end with an e sound like the others, like Wally, Sally, Julie, poppy, they all end with an "E" sound while Frank ends with a "K" ... he is definitely important cause he's the colorless character around, along the fact he has a garden and eats, while the others, not sure if so cause of Wally, can eat with his eyes. But a lot of people have head theories that, it either the puppets of their puppeteers but, that's honestly where it goes ngl.
Eddie Dear being a suspect is interesting, especially since he is forgetful. In which I mean he forgets things. Maybe he could be the creature that lurks around at night.
Well he *IS* Frank’s husband, if the theory about Frank being a spy on the inside is true, what better person to be his accomplice?
@@lukacunningham342well they technically aren’t married by this point yet. Also if I remember correctly (so please correct me if I’m wrong) but didn’t clown say that was only a scrapped concept for the show
@@fluffywhompus Isn't that like how every show is? deleted any scene that has gayness in it and not mention, that there are some country that ban LGBT
I also think it’s interesting because Sally has always held some kind of disdain towards him. She doesn’t like Eddie much, which would make sense if she hears this monster in the town every night and knows (or at least suspects) it’s him.
@@lacrossestick132 i think some of the Neighbors, namely Howdy Sally and Barnaby, have something against him.
You guys should totally do a GTnotLive over solving Ash’s novel!
Clap and a Half to you Ash!! Slayyyy!
Thanks for the likes!
the word "slay" just makes me want to die
Sorry, the person you are trying to reach is unavailable, please call back when you have something better to say. Thank you, have a FANTASTIC Day! 😀
@@ebrucan7161same 😭
Ash's novel is the mistery I needed for the end of the year, I'm excited to get to their december 1st to know more about it😢
Mystery right
I think the thing we've not touched on yet is the orientation of Wally's eyes. His eyes are either "content" or "alert" at any moment. I think this is either the separation of when he's in his "surveillance" mode versus being in control. Perhaps it indicates that there's two different Wally's entirely, but the direction his eyes are tilted seems to have some sort of importance.
19:30 Isn't it a part of the cannon lore that Wally can eat just by looking at things, And aren't apples his favorite food?
Yes, Clown revealed this on their Tumblr and Twitter. Though, fun fact, if he were to see an apple pie he wouldn't know what to do with it (he'd be like 'this isn't an apple' and just not eat it).
@@SoftySenpaii But didn't Clown also say Wally doesn't eat apples? He just loves to look at them.
@@katarinacarrico7887 He eats with his eyes, all he has to do is blink and the food vanishes. Which is also canon.
@@SoftySenpaiiIn the video example of Wally eating, he never blinks! He just looks at it, albeit with more focus(?). Like, 👁️👁️
I like how the other characters don’t know/realize Wally eats with his eyes so, in this case, Barnaby doesn’t realize Wally bit the apple. Also I imagine Wally is looking from barnaby to the apple making sure he isn’t looking so he can take a bite.
Games you should definitely play next.
1. In sound mind
2. Killer frequency
3. Cult of the lamb
4. Darkwood
5. Scp containment breach
Dark Deception as well
and When the Darkness Comes
Killer in purple 1/2
Wow you're committed. lol
OMG YES killer frequency is too good
I would just like to point out that Frank dressed up as a vampire for the Halloween update so that would specify why he calls out the teeth marks. Hope this helps
So like when Barnaby points them out and Frank specifically says that it’s fake, that could mean that he’s just saying that it couldn’t have been him if there fake
Wally isn't brought into the conversation at its end, rather the conversation continues with Wally included. We only get to see the parts of conversation when Wally is just listening in and doesn't need to talk, and I can confirm that people listening to conversations without being brought in is a thing that can happen.
I have to admit, Ash's project was definitely a help for me in trying to finish my own. And I've not actually gotten to the end of the book, but I did pass 50,000 words about four and a half hours before the deadline, so I think it was a month well spent. Thanks, Ash!
Eddie has the bitten apple package, but...Eddie's a mailman. That doesn't belong to him. He's simply about to deliver it and as others have called out, Wally canonically loves apples. I didn't know about the lore floating around that says he eats with his eyes but he absolutely is able to reach out and absorb energies and brainwash people with them so I think it makes more sense that Home "took a bite" of the candy apple through Wally's eyes and that Eddie is delivering that package to Wally.
The haunting video is basically a scary story related to the town/Home. I find it interesting how it’s Sally that tells this story since she hasn’t been in the forefront thus far. Not to mention, near the end, Sally’s voice sounds very close to the recording. She obviously knows something. I wonder what it all means.
if anyone is looking for some deep dive stuff on welcome home and a lot of analog horror i highly recommend night mind! their voiceovers are awesome and i personally love their voice and expressions!
Seconded! And they specialize in ARGs so it's very in-depth analysis. As much as I love MatPat, I agree more with NightMind's interpretation of WH so far.
i think the bitten apple is connected to Frank. we already think hes different, trying to figure out what's going on. i think he gets called out for the apple, not bc he actually ate it, but to connect the apple symbolism to him. for the box, eddie is a mailman. those boxes aren't his. the box is green and yellow, so is frank's house and sweater. giving frank more connection to the bitten apple
That's a really smart connection.
This might just be me, and I also noticed everyone's names end in an 'E' sound, except Frank. Sally, Wally, Julie, Eddie, Barnaby, Howdy, Poppy...then Frank. That also sets him apart. The only thing with that is there's also Home, who doesn't have an 'E' sound at the end of their name either. I dunno, could be me overthinking, just food for thought! 😊
@@little_to_no_opinion6788 Well Frank makes up by being Frank Frankly but yeah with his name as is he just keeps showing how much of the outlier he is in the neighborhood.
@@Songal18 that's also very true! I wasn't even taking into consideration their last names. If we're to take it that way then that completely throws the idea out the window, so if anything it's just kinda a fun lil coincidence 😊
@@little_to_no_opinion6788 I mean it still holds merit as a potential theory. All theories are right until the canon comes out.
I love the time stamp saying “poppy from trolls is the ultimate poppy, sorry not sorry” and I so agree with them 😂💜
MatPat at 46:00 a speech bubble shows up next to Wally and the word "Hello" is written out. I can't say this information is 100% correct because I didn't see the posts myself, but I've seen a lot of people say that Frank and Eddie are canonically a couple. If Frank is already suspicious it's not a stretch to think their (Frank is nonbinary) partner would be too.
Clown has confirmed on their tumblr that Frank and Eddie are 100% a couple. Also, Frank is non-binary and goes by "they/them" (also canon). Hope this helps!
Slightly unrelated to your comment, but I didn't see anyone in the comments mention it, save for you. That hello bubble becomes a clickable link with an audio file from Wally.
@@iontruth A few others mention it if you look through the comments enough, but yeah. Pretty cool.
On the website if you click the word hello (on the guestbook tab) it takes you to another tab and it’s an audio file
That's really interesting that they're a couple. Might explain why Frank is teasing and Eddie called him frank. The neighborhood could want them to just be neighbors which would be interesting
So excited for this!!! I cosplayed wally to con and had so much fun so thanks matpat for showing me this series!
Just a bit more about apples connected to Halloween - apples were traditionally buried at Halloween to feed the dead. They also contain a star, or pentagram, in the centre, symbolic of protection and often used in occult settings. Perhaps I’ve jumped too far into things there, but the focus on apples and them being used to feed the dead is particularly interesting.
Ash's book is exactly the type of book I would expect Mat's figment of his brain would write. A mystery puzzle book you have to lore out lol
I think the closed captions and audio descriptions are genius. I feel like by making it a character in and of itself not only does it add to the average viewer but it helps encapsulate the vibe better for people actually who need it. Like it adds an element of mystery that would probably get lost in a literal transcription.
Something that frustrates me is that he went for the secret stuff and it caused him to completely miss things that he would have gotten if he had done things in the right order.
Can relate
For real! He has good theories but they're going in a wrong directions
@@tisa37bokun57thats mattpatt for ya
Between the fangs and Sally’s monster that’s two vampire references (with it not breaking into homes but just wandering the streets at night) and Eddie is a mailman. So naturally he has to interact with everyone and know where they live even if this wasn’t a small community. Maybe this was supposed to give him more opportunities to be invited in?
The "fang" reference was towards Frank's costume during Halloween. He was dressed as a Vampire for the Halloween special, and Barnaby messes with Frank often, so I took it as Barnaby knowing Wally took a bite, but used it as an opportunity to say that Frank bit it because he "sees fang marks" (targeting Frank by alluding to his costume).
Matpat is the embodiment of the beard makes the man.
With beard, he oozes daddy vibes.
Without, he looks like he drank the water from the fountain of youth.
but he looks great etherway 😊
@@nayfinch9165 i call it very good looking in the average way
I know this might be a stretch, but when she says "I forget how many eyes my brother has... At least two. Or was it three? No, no two..." I was thinking about Home's windows being eyes. Then saw that Frank's house has 3 windows - as though there were three eyes - and wondered if there might be a connection there. Probably not, but regardless, it's weird that Barnaby's place doesn't show ANY windows.
So grateful for youtubers like NightMind and yourself for continuing to break down these updates. My ADHD would never let me find everything they've worked so well to include into the story. I continue to get so excited every time there happens to be an update. It's one of the only things thats so interesting, it'll be the one thing I give atttention to until I've watched you give your opinions. And kudos to the team behind Welcome Home in general. Keeping my brain and soul well-fed.
EDIT: Wait.... I just noticed that the road surrounding Home seems to be star-shaped..... Interesting......
What I got from the Halloween video was that, we (the camera or pov) are wally. But not just Wally, it’s house looking trough Wally. Wally isn’t there, that’s why he isn’t talking, his just observing for house. When his “call to action” happens, house lets go and lets Wally take over. All the videos, are house watching through Wally.
(The person writing the translation is probably just some worker watching the video, given a job.)
But that’s just a theory!
To be honest I love the chaos of GTLive and it's probably my favorite of all the channels. :)
It would be so cool if Matt played Cult Of The Lamb to be honest!!! It's such a cozy game. :D
Wally: *exists*
MatPat: Everyone but Wally is sus and are evil. >.>
I genuinely love Matt's thought process sometimes. xD Also Matty O'Patty I'm waiting on that Pinkie Pie theory.
How happy he always is makes me a lot happier .
I don’t know that you guys are talking about, I love it when may pauses the videos to talk about it!!! I’m autistic and personal do this with my friends, it annoys them so much. But to see a creator that I look up to do it, makes me happy knowing that I’m not alone :)
I have no idea about the Welcome Home fanbase being smaller but I've been chilling with it so yea, sure. The character designs and everything else really has their own charm. Cool stuff
Prop to all of the voice actors for the amazing cast. I’m sure recording it was so fun!
The site had recently updated and the little tasks like move Barnaby aren't for us! They're for Wally from someone running the site! So they can confirm that he as an entity exists
With the sudden notice that there is an unknown entity who is transcribing events going on but not necessarily knowing what is going on and having an opinion, plus then the inclusion of a mysterious narrator who listens in on the characters out of sight. . . That sounds like the monster in Sally's story to me. I think this is another character we just haven't been aware of until now
Better late than never, thanks for covering this Matpat, and going over the newest update. Barnaby is a comedian so he fits into the role of Pedrolino. Which in French Pedrolino is known as Pierrot, but that fact it is Sally specifically who is. Wally is possibly the Conduit for this Entity that Home is infested with(or is if Home is the Entity taken on physical form to blend in). Eddie shows in this update that like Wally and possibly Frank knows much, much more than we realize. Now the "fang marks" I think is just Barnaby being silly because so far we've yet to see anybody with "fangs" outside of costumes. Also Barnaby CALLS Wally Kid, because Wally is younger than him, and as a term of endearment. Now we know Wally eats with his eyes, but does anybody in the Neighborhood know about this about Wally, because if they don't then they wouldn't suspect Wally eating the apple. I don't think Eddie is evil, but I do think he is not as he seems, I think he is playing two roles-The friendly neighborhood mailman and the man who knows what is really going on and knows he needs to play his role or his friends and him will pay the price. The Narrator I think was just made for this audio recording, but maybe they were also in the show? We'll have to see in more updates if they return. Sally's story definitely cuts out and she talks directly to us the people listening to this very recording because the record distortion goes away. Which shows that maybe more or all the Neighbors know what is going on and are all looking for our help and not just Wally, they're all doing it in their unique ways-Wally with his phone calls, Eddie with letters, Frank with Bugs, and Sally with stories. Sorry for the long comment I just have a lot to say on this Project. Ash I hope we all get to see your story published.
Not sure if this was thought of but the "kid" Barnaby refers to could still be Wally. Someone older (Barnaby) may refer to someone younger (Wally) as kid, kiddo, etc. Not that there is another separate person who is the kid. Plus I think I recall Wally likes apples?
I think it would be cool if Matpat did a video on "The Man in the Suit" I recently came across it and thought it would be good since it fits in with the whole Analog Horror.
Omg! I stubbled onto it and it was so good!
He did! Check it out!
@@bummysalt2221 I literally watched it the moment it came out 😂
@@bummysalt2221 I saw it, I was happy to see that he made that video it was really good
25:48 based on delivery I think “kid” is Wally. Plus, he references his “little devil” watching his Apple, Wally is dressed as a devil. Not sure who bit the Apple, but Wally is the only one there (as far as we know)
24:04 I think if he was talking to someone and then turned to Wally there would’ve been more emphasis on “you” like if the interior is: “Ah don’t worry about it, there’s plenty to eat here. What about you Wally? What are you craving?” Then I think the delivery would’ve been more along the lines of “what are *you* feel hungry for, Wally?” As a way to say “hey, what about you?”
I love all of Mats thoughts here. But with his thought of Eddie being, potentially, evil because of the apple on one of the boxes he’s carrying connecting to the glitch apple in the video…. I think he’s missing a HUGE detail there with the fact that Eddie is the mail man and each thing he’s carrying is for another character and not him.
The top is a bow shaped present for Julie, the bottom is Barnaby’s, and I think the middle looks the most like it represents Howdy. I think this because of its green coloring but also because Howdy is literally holding an apple in his own imagery and the box he holds is an apple with a caterpillar in it.
Do I know why that distinction could matter or what it means? Absouletly not.
Do I think Howdy might have fangs? Or that he even ate the apple? No! I’ve got no idea.
But I feel that detail could be important if who the apple “connects to” ends up mattering at all.
And for Howdy not being in the video I’m not sure if that matters either. Just a thought I had and wanted to share.
Potentially it could also be tying Howdy to Eddie? With the other video we got showing Eddie being afraid of a bug and Howdy having a lot of ties to potentially being a caterpillar. Maybe Eddie is scarred of Howdy? Idk anyway I love welcome home so much and I’m glad Mat is covering it.
I'm pretty sure the audio transcriptions are coming from the restoration team and not from Wally. They are restoring the pieces of media from a lost state and not all of the footage is in tact so they're putting their best guess in the transcription, that's why it said "I think".
Hey Matt and crew. I think I might have an idea on how to uncover the website command things. Although I'm not entirely certain it may work as I'm no expert, I feel Matt was on the right track. I feel you may need some website coding knowledge perhaps, so like he said, copy the website into your own version of the website that way you have access to editing the code itself. From there you can add text, alter the formatting of text etc.
Another thing for you Matt, you mentioned wishing there was a way you could see what something is exactly? There kind of is. If you right click a website you can "inspect element", this is the page's source code. You can also press Control, Shift and C to get here. Once this opens, there's a dotted box with an arrow, or you can press Control, Shift and C again to be able to highlight an object on the page, and it will jump to that area of code.
I hope this can help in any sort of way, and best of luck👍
I didn’t even know he was still paying attention to welcome home. I’m so excited he finally saw the October update and I can’t wait for 2024 for the new update. Love the team at gt ❤️❤️❤️ also it looks like there wasn’t another update but some notes got released I think this may be a mistake
i feel like the implication for poppy, the whole "reverse this image", is that shes much more deeply connected to wally than we think because the moment that matpat reversed the image, i immediately noticed that she has the same color palette as wally. it could be because i just had this on the bg while i was drawing and art and colors was on the mind, but it is something-- i could also be completely wrong but hey, thats theorizing
barnaby also has fangs in the Happy Haunting art and wally has a bitten apple
the bite if the apple could also represent one of the characters gaining more knowledge about their situation
if you connect it to the apple of knowledge
In my opinion, the asks or commands that MatPat discussed at the end of the video is home or wally seeing if they could add you, the viewer/player into their "cult" or make you a puppet. Or something like that. Also, im not sure, but maybe when you reverse sally and imagine the reverse picture where the picture usually is, it may look like she's pointing or praising home. Idk tho
Also, MatPat if you're reading this, I want you to know something. My mom, who is an English teacher, watched this video with me and she was very impressed with how you dissected the information and your use of words. She said that she would bring you up in her next class to show her students how she wanted them to search for information in books and stuff. :D
Here's a compilation of Ash's book clues:
-There's 3 of them (The Rainman)
-Not a trilogy
-Not a Bible Sequel
-Numerous (DON'T SCREAM)
-Not about numbers or the populous
-No chapters
no clue(FnaF Quiz)
-Criticism (Smiling Critteer Cartoon)
-Amy guessed Anthropocene Review, which Ash said was the closest anyone's gotten
-Alignments (Outcore: Desktop Adventure)
-It is about Tension but not about being a Chiropractor
-You have to think about these words like you think about Connections
-Memory (Fears to Fathom: Ironbark Lookout)
-Not about Cats
Amy guessed fictional dairy entires, not quite, but in the ballpark
-Amy guesses Multimedia (Ergodic) Ash says no but also yes?
-Hiatus (Five Nights At Freddy's Help Wanted 2)
-Perspective Shift ("Spectacle" The Walten Files Minisode)
no clue? (Fears to Fathom: Ironbark Lookout)
-History (Cool Math Games ARG)
-Contains Pieces
-They guessed Period piece and Ash said a doubtful 'Mm?'
-Writing (Welcome Home Website Update)
-Inspired by the Theorist community. It's a Puzzle book
-The book is about the lore of the character(s) within
Hi matpat i rlly appreciate the work you and your team do for us to entertain us!❤
When you know that this is going to be amazing. Thank you for producing these videos, they're amazing 👏
The people who make this should do an audio horror thing
if you look at the website now, sally's image has been reversed, playfellow turned upside down, ok and hello have been written, and barnaby has been moved
Mna I love this series so much. I can't wait to learn what it's about! There aren't that many ARGs/games that can keep us guessing like this!
Cant wait for him to get into the new things that are coming this December
I would like to recommend playing a nancy drew game. Especialy now that they are making a small arg for their next game. They are detective point and click games. I would specifically recommend the ghost of Thornton hall. It's an amazing game, and I would love to see your reaction to it.😊
That’s awesome they are making a small ARG.
Yesss, a Nancy Drew game would be amazing to see them play
Wally is not a observer because wally is known to eat by just looking at the object as shown on one of clowns pages
the bit apple in eddie's art is a gift, there is a Barnelby themed one directly under it. its most likely a gift for Wally, as he is known to like apples, as well as holding a bitten one in the halloween art.
OMG THANK YOU FOR COMING BACK TO THIS IM SO HAPPY YOU COVERED WELCOME HOME AGAIN
clown said on I believe tumblr that Wally can eat by eating with his eyes and that he likes looking at apples
im so glad they finally added some new things I think it’s such a great game thing
I found it funny how deep he was going into the video about the fangs- when their just talking about a halloween costume lol.
Yesssss this is one of my favorite horror things I enjoy matpat talking about
Hey MatPat, in the guestbook when you scroll all the way down you see all the neighbors signatures. If you look at Howdy's signature it has a bitten apple. Don't know if that's important I just think it's something to put a lil thought into🤭💕
It should also be noted that in the “happy haunting to boo and yours” picture that Wally has an candy apple and it has a bite taken out of it. It correlates with what Matt was saying about a bite out of an apple being a representation of a villain or of evil. Definitely something to think about.
So excited for this update!
Fr
SAME
"Inspect Element," or some other thing depending on your browser probably, can be used to edit the html of a page you are looking at.
By using the one tool that selects the element you click on and pressing delete, you can remove elements.
46:00 I don’t know if anyone else commented on this already, but when you were in the guestbook, Wally was drawn a speech bubble. It seems to me someone was writing hello in it, could the “write hello” thing be related to that?
Edit: I know there is a code to flip an image, I think it was “flip box”. I’m not good at programming stuff though, so I am not able to get it to work with the code sadly.
A couple things to point out:
First off, I’m not sure if this is canon or fanon, but I’m pretty sure it’s been said that Wally can eat with his eyes, and I’m also pretty sure Clown said that apples are Wally’s favorite food.
Second, about the Boo and Yours audio and the whole idea of this monster at night, remember that drawing of Julie Clown put on their website before you click the link to Welcome home? I know they said it’s not canon/related to WH but I do think it’s worth considering that Julie is depicted as this cursed monster type thing in that one.
Someone has probably noticed this but I just wanna point out how Wally was holding a candy apple with a bite in it in the Halloween picture of all the characters. I also think that the box with apples on it could be for Wally because there seemed to be a package for Barnaby( probably didn’t spell that right) it had paw marks and bones so maybe apples hold a strong connection with Wally like how bones and paw marks correlate with Barnaby. Idk just a thought
I am really curious to see where Mat's next theory video will take all this new, fractured information. This is continuing to intrigue! :D
Why didn't Mat point out that the captioning said "It sounds like Barnaby pats the camera." To me that's clearly indicating that Wally is the camera and Barnaby was like patting his shoulder or something.
41:35
The sound reminds me of the huge "clack" sound effect they normally use when someone is flipping a large switch (normally it is like, to a stage production light, shining down on the stage from above)
I got so excited when I saw this! I missed the Welcome Home content
Awe, we love you to MatPat, and the theorist team.
When you realize that in the group picture Wally is holding the bitten apple and as the devil, maybe he has fangs?
Hey there! So I saw in the Welcome Home ARG Subreddit that Clown apparently said that these commands (write hello, write "ok", etc.) were an accident and he didn't mean to publish them yet. I haven't been able to find the source where he says this, but it would explain why nobody has been able to figure out how to act on the commands yet.
I love welcoming home a lot. Im not always looking at its contents looking at others things. When i see that video telling there is more i always come right back to see more welcome home
So so so excited for Ash's novel/puzzle book!!! I'm ready to figure out that lore 😼
They talk to Wally like children's shows talk to children... >_>
One thing I wonder is how filming was supposed to happen when the show was being made. The neighbors seems very much alive, and don’t seem to know about the audience. (Though I could be wrong about that). On the other hand we always view the world through Wally’s eyes, so it makes me wonder if somehow the Wally pov is supposed to be how the show is filmed??? Idk, I’d love to hear other thoughts
Edit: also I’d like to mention that the “narrator” sounds like Frank imo
what if the fangs are symbolic of house "sinking its teeth into another" presumably the "kid" that Barnaby mentions
Also in the picture with Wally smiling while everyone else is scared he is also holding a candy apple
I also think you should look at what the package with the bitten Apple is going to
Ash. Have you ever read The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime? cuz the formatting clues are making me think of this book (not so much the context clues)
39:20 That is SO NOT Wally, doesn't even sound remotely like him!
You really dropped the ball there.
I just watched all the welcome home videos and wanted more so I’m excited for this
Dear Matpat, at 45:51 there is that image of Wally writing and a text balloon that might say hello
Hi! i dont know tons about this ARG, but when you go to the guestbook page and click on the "hello." that is written out in the speech bubble next to wally, it takes you to a voice memo on a separate page. It may be an old thing but thats all i could find that was connected to the word Hello in that way
My headcanon is that the name "Welcome Home" is the biggest clue of all.
It's more like "Welcome, Home." As in, Wally is the harbinger of the arrival of Home in new worlds.
Interestingly, there is a Biblical reference in the Halloween/fall party video. After the apple is bitten, Barnaby comes over and says Wally was guarding it. He refers to Wally as a little devil. In the Bible Satan or the devil is hiding in the tree with the apple, when he convinces Eve to take a bite. When she does, Eve gains knowledge from the forbidden fruit. Barnaby then calls out Frank, accusing him of biting the apple. Could this scene confirm the idea that Frank knows what is going on here? That maybe after this moment, Frank gains the knowledge that the neighborhood is not just a simple place. I am also not saying that Wally convinces Frank to eat it, or that Barnaby is God. Just an interesting idea to play with.
We all know how much ARGs love Biblical references.
Frank and Eddie being Adam and Eve could be a thing if we have the Biblical side of this Project still part of it. Because Frank and Eddie are going to be a couple but it's just going to be a slow burn type of story for them, then maybe Frank helps Eddie see the truth of the neighborhood.
@@Songal18 That would make sense. I have seen theories that they are in love with each other, but because this show takes place in a time when that would not be okay, Frank and Eddie may hide this fact. If it were the case that they are in love, then the references towards the bitten apple for both of them make a lot of sense.
@@superpanda_girl6505 Mmhm that's the idea. Again only if the biblical stuff is relevant still, which we will have to wait and see.
It sounds the most plausible, as the 'beta' for the ARG had a lot of satanic/religious references (i.e. the picture of Wally doing that 'as above so below' pose). And Wally does love apples, he is a character who is initially ignorant but desires knowledge and apples in Christian mythology are symbols of 'forbidden knowledge'. Which, in this context, would mean the characters (so far only Wally and Frank) know full well they are puppets and are trying to communicate with us.
Though, I have a new theory brewing in my head. What if Eddie is some kind of 'vampire' like monster? The evidence for this is - he is the mailman so he knows where everyone lives (and can go to their houses under the guise of 'delivering mail' to them), he often 'forgets' a lot of things (he could be lying but if he isn't then he would be going into 'monster mode' quite often), and he is the only character who has no real backstory of where he came from (he remembers he came from somewhere outside the town but that's it). And it would be ironic, as he is dressed like a scarecrow/frankenstein while Frank is the one dressed like a vampire (in my opinion if my theory is true their costumes reflect the role/nature of the other - both are in sense a 'fake', Eddie being a legit monster while Frank isn't even a real puppet).
In fact, the halloween costumes may just reflect the roles of the characters as well...Wally is an easy one, but the others I'll have to figure out.
@@SoftySenpaii That's an interesting theory, though if Eddie is the "fanged creature" then I would think he'd either be an Entity or it'd be symbolic.
I’ve never been obsessed with an ARG like this before and ITS JUST HAD AN UPDATE, I’m so excited to see what Matpat and crew are going to discover !!
V excite !!!