World's Biggest Referee Whistle Sound Test - Molten, Fox 40, Acme, HyperWhistle… dB Comparision
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ค. 2024
- Many of these whistles are available at my Amazon storefront: amzn.to/41FRcUv
How to blow a whistle as heard in this video: • How to blow a whistle ...
This is the world's biggest whistle test video. It took several months of planning to get all these whistles and special permission to be in Gamla Ullevi in Gothenburg, Sweden.
While the loudest whistle doesn't necessarily mean the best, it's an important factor depending on the intended use. Practicality and sound consistency are also important to consider. In this video, I blew the whistles with full force to ensure fairness and I created a race chart to show how they compare in sound level.
Most whistle companies do not specify the distance or measurment type when stating the decibel levels of their whistles, resulting in a lack of standardized measurement practices. Some companies use A-weighting while others use C-weighting. I chose to measure the decibel levels from a distance of 0.5 meters with C-weighting. This decision was made considering that some companies measure from closer distances, while others choose 1-2 meters. C-weighting is particularly useful for measuring short bursts of sounds, such as whistle sounds.
The sound levels were measured using a professional class 1 sound level meter, the B&K 2245: www.bksv.com/en/instruments/h...
The race chart was created with Flourish: flourish.studio
The gauges were created with Microsoft Powerpoint.
Recording information:
Time at the stadium: 2:50:30
Total video material time: 2:52:32
Total video material file size: 79,38 GB
Video editing time: 100+ hours
00:00 - All whistles shown
0:05 - Gamla Ullevi stadium
0:15 - How the sounds were measured
0:30 - Acme Slimline Tornado 636
0:37 - Molten Deluxe
0:41 - Fox 40 Fuziun
0:45 - Acme Thunderer 670
0:49 - Fox 80 Classic
0:52 - Acme Tornado 622
0:56 - Fox 40 Mini Electronic
1:00 - Molten Vorca
1:04 - Naysir N1-B
1:08 - Fox 40 Sharx
1:11 - Motus Sybil
1:15 - Acme Thunderer 558
1:19 - No brand
1:23 - Acme Tornado 622 reduced
1:26 - Finegood stainless steel
1:30 - Best Sporting Hand Whistle
1:37 - Molten Dolfin B
1:41 - Fox 40 Rechargeable Electronic
1:45 - Hipat plastic
1:48 - Fox 40 Titan
1:52 - Acme Cyclone 888
1:56 - Fox 40 Electronic
2:00 - Savita stainless steel
2:03 - Molten Blazza
2:07 - Acme Thunderer 560
2:11 - HyperWhistle
2:15 - Acme Thunderer 63
2:18 - Pro Match Unique
2:21 - Hipat stainless steel
2:25 - Acme Tornado 623
2:29 - Fox 40 Classic
2:32 - Acme Thunderer 58
2:36 - Fox 40 Pearl
2:40 - Lifesystems Hurricane
2:44 - Ovtai Emergency
2:48 - Acme Thunderer 559
2:52 - Molten Deevo
2:55 - Fox 40 Epik
2:59 - Acme Thunderer 577
3:03 - Fox 40 Micro
3:06 - Acme Thunderer 59.5
3:10 - Molten Dolfin F
3:14 - All Weather Safety Whistle Windstorm
3:18 - Fox 40 Super Force
3:22 - Acme Tornado T2000
3:25 - Fox 40 Caul
3:29 - HRS
3:33 - Molten Standard
3:36 - Acme Thunderer 58.5
3:40 - Fox 40 Eclipse
3:44 - Pro Match Viking Taifun
3:47 - Acme Thunderer 658
3:51 - Molten Valkeen
3:55 - All Weather Safety Whistle Storm
3:58 - Fox 40 Mini
4:02 - Acme Thunderer 660
4:06 - Molten Dolfin Pro
4:09 - Acme Thunderer 60.5
4:13 - Fox 40 Sonik Blast
4:17 - Acme Tornado 635
4:25 - Complete list - กีฬา
![[TH]FFWS SEA Spring 2024 Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TK2mu-8yBFU/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for watching. Information is available in the description.
Many of these whistles are available at my Amazon storefront: amzn.to/41FRcUv
How to blow a whistle as heard in this video: th-cam.com/video/q2gl87GGb6Y/w-d-xo.htmlsi=r4M1YdBUppqdAmPH
Alphabetical order:
1:52 Acme Cyclone 888
0:30 Acme Slimline Tornado 636
1:15 Acme Thunderer 558
2:48 Acme Thunderer 559
2:07 Acme Thunderer 560
2:59 Acme Thunderer 577
2:32 Acme Thunderer 58
3:36 Acme Thunderer 58.5
3:06 Acme Thunderer 59.5
4:09Acme Thunderer 60.5
2:15 Acme Thunderer 63
3:47 Acme Thunderer 658
4:02 Acme Thunderer 660
0:45 Acme Thunderer 670
0:52 Acme Tornado 622
1:23 Acme Tornado 622 reduced
2:25 Acme Tornado 623
4:17 Acme Tornado 635
3:22 Acme Tornado T2000
3:55 All Weather Safety Whistle Storm
3:14 All Weather Safety Whistle Windstorm
1:30 Best Sporting Hand
1:26 Finegood stainless steel
3:25 Fox 40 Caul
2:29 Fox 40 Classic
3:40 Fox 40 Eclipse
1:56 Fox 40 Electronic
1:41 Fox 40 Rechargeable Electronic
2:55 Fox 40 Epik
0:41 Fox 40 Fuziun
3:03 Fox 40 Micro
3:58 Fox 40 Mini
0:56 Fox 40 Mini Electronic
2:36 Fox 40 Pearl
1:08 Fox 40 Sharx
4:13 Fox 40 Sonik Blast
3:18 Fox 40 Super Force
1:48 Fox 40 Titan
0:49 Fox 80 Classic
1:45 Hipat plastic
2:21 Hipat stainless steel
3:29 HRS
2:11 HyperWhistle
2:40 Lifesystems Hurricane
2:03 Molten Blazza
2:52 Molten Deevo
0:37 Molten Deluxe
1:37 Molten Dolfin B
3:10 Molten Dolfin F
4:06 Molten Dolfin Pro
3:33 Molten Standard
3:51 Molten Valkeen
1:00 Molten Vorca
1:11 Motus Sybil
1:03 Naysir N1-B
1:19 No brand
2:44 Ovtai Emergency
2:18 Pro Match Unique
3:44 Pro Match Viking Taifun
2:00 Savita stainless steel
I remember that a few years ago their Electronic Whistle was rated at 120 dB, and recently they have corrected it - now they claim 'only' 100 dB or so.
Yes.
The most valuable clip for the referees! Brilliant !!
I have to say compared to the last whistle comparison, a leap from 16 to 60 whistles is astounding! With so many choices available, it's safe to say this is truly the biggest whistle comparison yet. Very interesting to see that most Molten whistles are on the higher end of the dB scale. I might have to look into a new secondary whistle option! (Main being the Valkeen of course :D)
One thing I'd like to know is if you have done whistle signals from different positions (further away, while running, etc.) this time as well, and if so, can we expect another video with them included?
Anyway, great video and thank you again! Happy new year and good luck with the upcoming season/matches!
Thank you. Yes. I have done all whistle signal variations and also a 50 meter test for every whistle in this video. A lot more videos are coming. I didn’t add those in this one because I wanted the video to be under 5 minutes.
Excellent.! 👏
Great job 👏
Great video, thank you! I enjoy using Sonic Blast, it is somewhat underrated whistle imo.
Thank you. It’s used in La Liga and in South America mainly.
The slimline tornado 636 is my go to. Its my edc whistle, vehicle emergency whistle, sports refereeing whistle, because its just so light and small yet packs a punch! And easy to blow
Yes, it’s a nice whistle.
Thanks
Satisfying 🤩👏
Excellent!
Thank you.
I LOVE IT
Você gosta do Fox 40 sharx é meu preferido saudações do Brasil
Can you remember original Fox 40 Sonik, produced before ca. 2007? It was advertised as '4-chamber, Multi-directional Whistle' with exactly 125 dB sound power - the loudest in Fox 40 history. Later they re-designed it into Sonik Blast, which has 'only' 120 claimed. I strongly wonder how it sounded like. It's very rare today and hard to find.
I wasn’t a referee in 2007 so I don’t know.
I heard for the Valkeen there’s a secret way to use it I was gonna ask if you know it and if you do can you do a video on how to do it
There is no secret way of using any whistle. Just tilt the Valkeen up a little if you want a little darker tone.
valkeen is still my favourite, didn't know it was that loud though!
Qual você recomenda mais o fox 40 classic ou o HRS eu tenho um HRS tava pensando em trocar para um classic é uma boa escolha ou continuo com o HRS?
They have different sounds so it depends on what you like. HRS is clearly louder but Fox 40 Classic has a different sound that you can hear in NBA, Premier League and more.
If you had to referee a Champions League match, what would you use from these 3? HRS ,Acme Tornado 2000 or FOX 40 classic? I appreciate your answer
T2000. It’s a bit louder than the Classic and has a unique tone.
I have a few questions about the whistles in this video.
1. I thought the Dolfin Pro was for volleyball but you claimed as outdoor sports. Is it because it is one of the loudest whistles?
2. What is HRS? Is it ripoff of Valkeen or some other brand that became same design as Valkeen?
3. Can I use Valkeen in any sports?(Outdoor, Indoor, Futsal, etc) because I'm too lazy to having a other whistles for indoors.
Lastly I am glad that you are still here to make a whistle comparison. Happy new year!
1: I see that they claim it’s tuned for volleyball but it’s very similar to the Valkeen and suitable for outdoors. It’s way too loud for indoors.
2: Yes, a complete copy but it’s a brand called HRS.
3: You can use it indoors but I don’t recommend it. It’s too loud and it will be uncomfortable for you and everyone in there. For indoors I recommend darker tones and/or less than 125 dB. Valkeen doesn’t sound good if you use less force to make it quiet. You can use the Vorca or Blazza for that.
I use valkeen in futsal too, and I know many top refs, including fifas who use it too. A Whistle can never be too loud
@jambow8469 Disagree. A whistle can be too loud. If people are uncomfortable by it then it’s too loud. From experience the Valkeen is too much for indoors. But it’s my recommendation.
@@RefereeChannel Well I guess a Whistle can be too loud, but I just have not found one that loud yet in my opinion. The louder the Whistle the better the decisions look. Even Classic fox sounds too whiny to me, not convincing at all. Also speaking as a high-level player; when the Whistle hurts their ears they do not want to start arguing. It gives you more power. But there is a reason Why almost all futsal referees carry 2 Whistles compared to usually just one in football.
@@RefereeChannel One more extra question, if I ask you that you can use all of these whistles in the video but for Valkeen, Fox classic and T2000(3 whistles that you use in real matches), what whistle would you use?
Can you rank top 3 whistle that are good to use indoor?
I am not an indoors referee but I would say Molten Blazza, Fox 40 Classic and Fox 40 Pearl.
The Dholpin Pro whistle that I use is bigger than the Molten Valken😂
Dolfin Pro is noticeably smaller than the Valkeen.
Do you know where the Pro Match Unique horn is sold?
No. Doesn’t seem to be for sale anymore. Google it and contact the company that distributes it. HF Sport.
Because I find the Pro Match Unique horn to be deeper than other horns, I need a place to buy it. It's a shame that that horn is no longer floating on the market@@RefereeChannel
Én annak idején a Fox40 Mini-re esküdtem játékvezetőként! Fogásra is, hangra is és akusztikailag is sokkal jobb volt, mint a Fox40 Classic!
(A Fox40 Pearl pedig jó vicc volt, ahogy anno egyes kollégák fújkálták pedig kifejezetten komikus volt.)
Összegezve: Nekem a Fox40 Mini volt a legjobb, és még ma is az az igazi, amit mindenhová magammal vittem a kulcscsomómon! 😃😊🥰
1:32 is this a handheld whistle?
Yes. As you can see in the text and the way I used it.
@@RefereeChannel which whistle is the hockey whistle?
Please watch the summary at the end. You can see everything there.
Is the molten deluxe really that loud? Cause when I blow the whistle it doesn't have the same level as yours
Yes. The measurments are from a professional dB meter. Do you use this technique? th-cam.com/video/q2gl87GGb6Y/w-d-xo.htmlsi=wftl1u5zQ54RBvLt
@@RefereeChannel Does it require alot of air pressure to achieve the same level?
@@TheFinalLand All the whistles in this video were blown with my full effort. You need pretty much force to get the sound that you can hear in this video but not incredibly much.
@@RefereeChannel Thx
1:01 1:37 2:18 2:54 3:29
Pra você qual o melhor Fox 40 sharx, Fox 40 classic ou HRS?
Fox 40 Classic.
Vart köper du din domarutrustning?
Beror på vad du menar för utrustning. Tröjor köps på SvFF domarshop. Resten kan köpas valfritt ställe. Köper bara kläder när det kommer ny version. Resterande saker har jag använt flera år.
@@RefereeChannel
Ok, har redan köpt det mesta från Svff och Spintso men är riktigt shopping beroende. Letar alltid nya grejer men svårt att hitta.
Waw 😮❤
0:36 2:03 2:28 2:51 3:51 4:06
Even though it’s not the loudest in decibels, acme tornado t2000 is the best
As I say in the description, loudest doesn’t have to mean it’s the best. T2000 is a great whistle and I use it because it has a unique sound.
I am very surprised by your measurement of Fox 40 Pearl - they claim only 90 dB, and your result is 120,5 dB so much much louder than claimed. And to be honest, I trust your result more, because the specific low 'BOOM' sound made by Pearl still sounds extremely loud to my ear.
It’s not only proved by the dB value here. Even my phone sound graphs show that it’s equal to the Fox 40 Classic. Same with the Titan. They claim 90 but it’s much louder.
@@RefereeChannel And the same for Mini - they claim 'only' 109 dB while it can be even louder than Classic here! I think that all measurements claimed by Fox 40 are too low.
For comparison, Acme claims 119 dB for Cyclone 888 - nearly equals to 119,3 measured.
Yes. They should make new tests for their whistles and also state from what distance they were tested.
Bet his ears are RINGING😂
No. I used earplugs the entire time.
@@RefereeChannel Smart!
Some whistlers remind me of 90’s football
The ones with peas inside them. That’s typical for whistles before year 2000.
@@RefereeChannelOh I wonder why 😊
@kimothemo Acme was established with those types and pealess whistles weren’t good enough back then.