Have both TF and MB but I'd go with Club Black 2017 batch. I also have 1st reformulation 2019 batches of Club Black and they're different off my skin as I can detect Jasmine/Incense better on the 2017 imho.
I got Mercedes Benz Club Black and a back up bottle when it first became available. I'm glad I pulled the trigger when I did because it is very hard to get now. I hope they don't discontinue it again. Thanks for the frag shootout.
Ya I think overall that’s about what the average ranking would be. Obviously some people won’t like noir extreme and club black but I know more people don’t like man in black than the other two
Ya there’s a few. The new boss bottled elixir is heavy incense and very unique and darker. Then you also have luminous night that is more of a darker smoky amber
After trying Club Black, I can 100% say I am not a fan of jasmine and it shows its presence there REALLY well. If Noir Extreme wasn't that sweet at the beginning, like some grape wine, then I would say it would be an even better fragrance.
@@FragranceDOUD damn I just smelled noir again and I may have to change my vote, that juice is one of a kind. You know what, I would’ve loved to see Carlisle in here too .
If you want to check out a niche version of Mercedes Benz club black try Arabian Oud Tarteel silver..i just got it and its almost the same with a slight pear note in the opening but it projects and lasts longer..still sweet vanilla almost identical. The presentation is insane it comes in a metal box snd the glass bottles weighs about 2lbs. MB club black is one of ny favorite fragrances and i had to have it just to have the slightest difference.
I had the Tom Ford Noir Extreme. Bvlgari Man in Black is my cold weather signature. Mercedes Benz Club i haven't tried, but i'm so eager to smell it. My experience with the Tom Ford and Bvlgari is next... Tom Ford - Quite sweet, vanilla/ice creamish, but i'm talking like masculine sweetness, mature. Real refined sweetness where it makes sense of being sweet. Performance is well... unfortunate for some reasons. Fragrances of this quality and that type of heavier ingredients should last quite some time. However i got only around 5ish, 6ish hr range. Projection is average to below average. Sadly, other than that it's a great smell for who likes sweet (i'm not that one). Bvlgari Man in Black - Now this is my all time favourite. This is to me the term for masculinity. It's boozy, spicy, leathery, woody. It seems sweet, but it's not actually. That rum/booziness settles down after a few hours, the scent becomes leathery and woody in the end 💥. Wow. Performance, not a beast mode, but not too bad either. I get around 8ish hrs. Let's call it average for this type of scent. Projection is just the perfect ratio in my opinion, not loud, but not weak at all. Just manly, simply amazing. One last thing to note. Seriously, i have tried over 300 men's fragrances... In the drydown... Bvlgari Man in Black smells... i'm speechless how incredible and amazing it is. I only wish that the performance is a bit better.
I ranked noir extreme number 1!? 😂 I’m guessing u only watched the unbiased ranking that I do based on popularity first as if I’m speaking from a subscibers perspective based on how many times I hear people say they love it but for my personal ranking noir extreme was my 1
I'd rather wear Club Black over the others for sure.
Ya I’m right there with u
Have both TF and MB but I'd go with Club Black 2017 batch. I also have 1st reformulation 2019 batches of Club Black and they're different off my skin as I can detect Jasmine/Incense better on the 2017 imho.
Ya I agree I have the 2017 batch and u get that incense and Jasmine mid more prominent
I got Mercedes Benz Club Black and a back up bottle when it first became available. I'm glad I pulled the trigger when I did because it is very hard to get now. I hope they don't discontinue it again. Thanks for the frag shootout.
Can go wrong with either of them, but I'd take Code Absolu over them.
Ya I don’t love code Absolu never have. I like it just my wife hates it so o don’t wear much
@@FragranceDOUDOh well, it's discontinued anyway..
@@FlorinToader ya I know but it’s crazy my ultas are still fully stocked
@@FragranceDOUDlol guess there's a ton of ppl that hate it as well, then
I wish I could find Absolu
Great battle keep those vs coming 💪🏾💪🏾👏🏽👏🏽💫💫💫💫
I sure will buddy thanks for the love
@@FragranceDOUD no doubt brohamski
…love Club Black, don’t like the tobacco in the Bvlgari, prefer Essence and haven’t smelled the TF…but i think your ranking is good…
Ya I think overall that’s about what the average ranking would be. Obviously some people won’t like noir extreme and club black but I know more people don’t like man in black than the other two
Hey Randy! Love the channel
Ya there’s a few. The new boss bottled elixir is heavy incense and very unique and darker. Then you also have luminous night that is more of a darker smoky amber
I’ve never tied Club Black but always heard great things. Love the other 2, but for my taste, I’d rank MIB just ahead of TF NE.
@@joseg8498 see some people say that and I can see what ur saying but I absolutely love it especially at the $50 price point
Great video Randy 🤜🏽🤛🏽💯😤. Love all of these fragrances and I own all three. I pretty agree with you 💯😂. Stay blessed King!
🤜 appreciate you and the kind words. Stay Smellin good
After trying Club Black, I can 100% say I am not a fan of jasmine and it shows its presence there REALLY well. If Noir Extreme wasn't that sweet at the beginning, like some grape wine, then I would say it would be an even better fragrance.
Club Black for the win
A tough one. Imma say noir extreme, man in black and then club black. Club black is addictive but the other two are more interesting and different.
I actually knew that would be ur rating. I was 100% sure about it lol
@@FragranceDOUD u know me so well lol
Only smelled TF and bvl. tF more gourmandy and BVL is pure class man. bVL with slight nod for me, more versatile
I can def see that noir extreme drydown is def gourmandish
@@FragranceDOUD damn I just smelled noir again and I may have to change my vote, that juice is one of a kind. You know what, I would’ve loved to see Carlisle in here too .
If you want to check out a niche version of Mercedes Benz club black try Arabian Oud Tarteel silver..i just got it and its almost the same with a slight pear note in the opening but it projects and lasts longer..still sweet vanilla almost identical. The presentation is insane it comes in a metal box snd the glass bottles weighs about 2lbs. MB club black is one of ny favorite fragrances and i had to have it just to have the slightest difference.
I had the Tom Ford Noir Extreme. Bvlgari Man in Black is my cold weather signature. Mercedes Benz Club i haven't tried, but i'm so eager to smell it.
My experience with the Tom Ford and Bvlgari is next...
Tom Ford - Quite sweet, vanilla/ice creamish, but i'm talking like masculine sweetness, mature. Real refined sweetness where it makes sense of being sweet. Performance is well... unfortunate for some reasons. Fragrances of this quality and that type of heavier ingredients should last quite some time. However i got only around 5ish, 6ish hr range. Projection is average to below average. Sadly, other than that it's a great smell for who likes sweet (i'm not that one).
Bvlgari Man in Black - Now this is my all time favourite. This is to me the term for masculinity. It's boozy, spicy, leathery, woody. It seems sweet, but it's not actually. That rum/booziness settles down after a few hours, the scent becomes leathery and woody in the end 💥. Wow. Performance, not a beast mode, but not too bad either. I get around 8ish hrs. Let's call it average for this type of scent. Projection is just the perfect ratio in my opinion, not loud, but not weak at all. Just manly, simply amazing.
One last thing to note. Seriously, i have tried over 300 men's fragrances... In the drydown... Bvlgari Man in Black smells... i'm speechless how incredible and amazing it is. I only wish that the performance is a bit better.
agree but the performance of MIB is not good at all on me, it's also similar to PDM Herod in my opinion...
EROOOOOOSSSSSSS
Lol
NOT. Noir Extreme All Day Everyday. Not even close. Agree to disagree.
I ranked noir extreme number 1!? 😂 I’m guessing u only watched the unbiased ranking that I do based on popularity first as if I’m speaking from a subscibers perspective based on how many times I hear people say they love it but for my personal ranking noir extreme was my 1
@@FragranceDOUD well my bad. I musta missed that part. I’m gonna run it back. And then hit you with a Sub.