Shay has always been my favorite singer but aeronautical is really good too Shay just has more or his own sound while aaron is unique voice but more generic rock voice
Personally, i think shay is better at singing with his unique voice. BUT I think arron is a better song writer, and for me.. More relatable i guess. Id still pick shay lol
@@okioki1131agreed - Aaron is a better singer so can actually replicate his voice live whereas while shay had a better voice, he didn’t have the technique/control Aaron does so live he tended to sound weaker than the studio
Dang, I might be the odd one out when I say I prefer Aaron's vocals a lot more to Shay's. Not taking anything away from him, he's an amazing vocalist. But to me, Aaron fits in OM&M well especially with his screams. His vocals have improved a ton especially since the last few albums. Both singers are fantastic regardless!
I prefer Shayley as a singer, but I have to admit...this newest OM&M album and even the one before sees them at their absolute best as a whole. The bands they are both in currently bring out the absolute best of each vocalist.
I love Of Mice & Men with Aaron more than with Shayley. But Dayshell (Shayley's current band), is way better than anything I've ever heard from Of Mice & Men
langenbrunner1 they’re independent, they have complete creative control over what they make and put out, it’s a benefit of doing it like shayley has been. He’s not retiring at all.
I doubt Aaron agrees, but I feel as though his worst decision was joining OM&M, Jamie's Elsewhere was on the up and came out with a badass album recently before going over to OM&M. But both guys have their strengths so I'm on the fence. Lol
Shay had a more unique voice on the records but live, Aaron was way better...if im jamming on my iphone, i prefer shays voice because its a unique that i just like better but Aaron just had better stamina live and was objectively a more consistent live singer. He did sound better live and for as long as Aaron was in the band vs Shay there are more videos of Shay sounding not great. Off pitch, cracking, etc. I feel like ppl who are saying Shay just dont wanna let go of the OG especially if they were fans since the beginning cuz Shay is part of the identity but again, whos better live? Also you couldnt have asked for a better replacement when shay left, for all the clean vocals that exist in metalcore, this band pretty much had the best 2 that exist. then Aaron had to not only fill Shaleys shoes, but then Austins...and kill it at the same time. like common, the dude is a fucking savage...
Shay is better in studio, but Aaron kills it live. Just saw him live a few months ago and he was unbelievable. I saw shayley years ago and he was good, but I was a little disappointed.
Don’t get me wrong shay is a great singer but I listen to om&m older stuff and they were great Bc of how heavy they were but adding Aaron was a huge achievement and now that austin left I don’t think shay could lead om&m like Aaron so what I’m saying is Aaron has a more metal voice and I prefer Aaron
Debo reconocer que la voz de Shayley tiene más alma que la de Aaron, pero este último no lo hace mal tampoco (Probablemente Aaron no haya sido la mejor opción para OM&M, pero igualmente él no es para nada un mal músico)
Muy buena banda Dayshell sobretodo con su nuevo album Nexus que salio hace poco ,Amigo te invito a suscribirte a mi canal , subo videos seguido y hay variedad Saludos :D
It's a neat little comparison Whatever But you have to understand that Shayley IS OM&M Sure, Aaron is great But the soul of Of Mice & Men was gone when shay left
They're both good but I like Aaron in OM&M. In a lot of songs, they sound just about the same lol. They have very similar voices. Before really knowing the band I heard Second and Sebring live and thought Aaron was the original. Either way I love old and new OM&M.
Shay is more unique but Aaron has a much smoother and nicer straight line singing voice. He was a great replacement after shay was gone vs most singers out there
Aaron Pauley Best Clean Vocals th-cam.com/video/f2C9qCqImsY/w-d-xo.html
El Rincón De La Buena Música shayley way better he too gernc
Dayshell deserves the same recognition as OM&M. Period. Love em both.
I actually like Dayshell better than OM&M
Eric Cartman
Me too honestly. Shays voice is 1 in a million
As much as I do love Aaron's voice, no one compares to Shay.
fizz peters
Preach
Both are really good but Shay is a just more unique.
shays voice is so nostalgic, it gives me same vibe from those first couple om&m albums. he has such a unique sound
Shay has always been my favorite singer but aeronautical is really good too Shay just has more or his own sound while aaron is unique voice but more generic rock voice
aeronautical 💀
I like Aaron as a vocalist but you can't beat the best!!! Shay is incredible!!
Shaley!!!!! Fucking love Dayshell!!! Their new album Pegasus is the fucking shit!!!
Hell yeah! Shay worked his butt off to do drums, vocals and guitars for that album!
Shayley
Personally, i think shay is better at singing with his unique voice.
BUT
I think arron is a better song writer, and for me.. More relatable i guess.
Id still pick shay lol
Got love for Aaron. But Shayley DESTROYS him as a vocalist
Not live 😅
@@okioki1131agreed - Aaron is a better singer so can actually replicate his voice live whereas while shay had a better voice, he didn’t have the technique/control Aaron does so live he tended to sound weaker than the studio
Hands down it’s shay for me
Shay 👌
Dang, I might be the odd one out when I say I prefer Aaron's vocals a lot more to Shay's. Not taking anything away from him, he's an amazing vocalist. But to me, Aaron fits in OM&M well especially with his screams. His vocals have improved a ton especially since the last few albums. Both singers are fantastic regardless!
I prefer Shayley as a singer, but I have to admit...this newest OM&M album and even the one before sees them at their absolute best as a whole. The bands they are both in currently bring out the absolute best of each vocalist.
I love Of Mice & Men with Aaron more than with Shayley. But Dayshell (Shayley's current band), is way better than anything I've ever heard from Of Mice & Men
i love both but shayley has such an amazing voice it’s so unique
Shay 😆
shay
Shay for sure and his band Dayshell is just so awesome someone needs to sign them to a record deal I don’t want Shayley to retire
langenbrunner1 they’re independent, they have complete creative control over what they make and put out, it’s a benefit of doing it like shayley has been. He’s not retiring at all.
I doubt Aaron agrees, but I feel as though his worst decision was joining OM&M, Jamie's Elsewhere was on the up and came out with a badass album recently before going over to OM&M. But both guys have their strengths so I'm on the fence. Lol
When you can’t sleep at night
Shay had a more unique voice on the records but live, Aaron was way better...if im jamming on my iphone, i prefer shays voice because its a unique that i just like better but Aaron just had better stamina live and was objectively a more consistent live singer. He did sound better live and for as long as Aaron was in the band vs Shay there are more videos of Shay sounding not great. Off pitch, cracking, etc. I feel like ppl who are saying Shay just dont wanna let go of the OG especially if they were fans since the beginning cuz Shay is part of the identity but again, whos better live? Also you couldnt have asked for a better replacement when shay left, for all the clean vocals that exist in metalcore, this band pretty much had the best 2 that exist. then Aaron had to not only fill Shaleys shoes, but then Austins...and kill it at the same time. like common, the dude is a fucking savage...
Shay is better in studio, but Aaron kills it live. Just saw him live a few months ago and he was unbelievable. I saw shayley years ago and he was good, but I was a little disappointed.
Shayley Dayshell Bourget! All of his notes resonate so much more and it turns any song to gold
It's never going to not be Shayley for OM&M
Don’t get me wrong shay is a great singer but I listen to om&m older stuff and they were great Bc of how heavy they were but adding Aaron was a huge achievement and now that austin left I don’t think shay could lead om&m like Aaron so what I’m saying is Aaron has a more metal voice and I prefer Aaron
now do it again live we’ll see what people think
Idk. both fantastic vocalists... that first jamie elsewheres LP is forever goated.
TSASWC is such a great album from Aaron, though I like London Kyles album a lot
Tom Selleck
No comparison, SHAYLEY!
*SHAY will always be the best vocalist of OM&M*
Debo reconocer que la voz de Shayley tiene más alma que la de Aaron, pero este último no lo hace mal tampoco (Probablemente Aaron no haya sido la mejor opción para OM&M, pero igualmente él no es para nada un mal músico)
Cuando Primera Vez Escuche " Of Mice & Men " Me encanto su Voz Es armonioso " Shayley " Siempre Hasta Ahora le sigo En la Banda " DayShell "
Muy buena banda Dayshell sobretodo con su nuevo album Nexus que salio hace poco ,Amigo te invito a suscribirte a mi canal , subo videos seguido y hay variedad Saludos :D
En vivo suena mal si:/ los conciertos de of mice and men en vivo con shayley no suenan tan bien como uno esperaria
It's a neat little comparison
Whatever
But you have to understand that Shayley IS OM&M
Sure, Aaron is great
But the soul of Of Mice & Men was gone when shay left
Aaron is awesome in live
Ofc shay
If shay never closed out The Flood the way he did it would probably be Aaron for the win
opino lo mismo gana Shayley
shay all d way
SHAYYY
Shayley all day. No contest
Shay every day.
also its hard to compare cuz shayley was a better singer in his somewhat short prime. pauly will sound good for years..
No comparison! Shayley is better!! Now that Austin is gone, I dont really care for OM&M. I prefer Dayshell
They're both good but I like Aaron in OM&M. In a lot of songs, they sound just about the same lol. They have very similar voices. Before really knowing the band I heard Second and Sebring live and thought Aaron was the original. Either way I love old and new OM&M.
should have played some clips with shayley in covette...
shay forever!
Am i the only one who like Aaron more
Aaron
shay is better period
There is no denying SHAYLEY IS A 1000X BETTER Than aron
Dayshell > OM&M with Aaron > OM&M with Shayley
real
Shay is amazing but I prefer Aaron
Shay
Both are good but shay has a better and can keep a higher note than Aaron
Sorry but im team shayley all day
No contest. Shayley is better.
Shayley es mejor yo queria que se quede en of mice & men
Shay is more unique but Aaron has a much smoother and nicer straight line singing voice. He was a great replacement after shay was gone vs most singers out there
Aaron duh
Imagine how much om&m would suck if Staley lead it like Aaron did
Either 👌💀
Aaron all the way, he's my boo 💕
Aaron has way better flow and sings far better and was a way better fit for of mice and men
Gamedev1909
That's your opinion and I can't help it if you're wrong
Shay isn’t what he was
Verstanden Baker This is a joke right? He is literally on another level with Dayshell
Chris lomax Well, I like 4 or 5 songs from them, the good thing is that he is winning against depression; I can’t wait to see the new album
Chris lomax he blows live in my opinion. But I love his work in studio for OM&M. Dayshell has a couple decent songs, but not really my style.
Shay sound horrible live and aaron sounds even better so...
Mateo Vergara not really...shayley sounds great live.
If shay isn’t drinking, he’s infinitely better live.
Shayley
Shay
Aaron