I believe in the 14th amendment. However, if a child of illegal immigrants is born here and given instant citizenship, it should not be used as a short cut to citizenship for the parents.
This was added to the constitution to give freed slaves and their descendants citizenship and stop them from being deported. That's the only reason. It's time to amend it.
No it is not Guaranteed ! This amendment was basically meant for freed American slaves Not children of people who are here illeagally , DJT will force Supreme Court to rule on it ,Very smart 🇺🇲♥️🎸🎶 FCH
@@s.r6331 great. Then those kids are welcome to stay without their parents, who DON'T have that right. Or, they can come back when they move out of their foreign parents house. Up to the deported parents to decide.
It is absolutely ridiculous that these people think it is right for a pregnant immigrant to be able to sneak into a country, pop out a baby, and expect them to be granted citizenship. Give me a break.
Not only that have a child every 11 months expecting medical for the mother and the children. They receive wic, formula and go to every corner to pick up food at the food banks then profit from that food.
@@krystalship6245Do you really believe that people are sneaking in, having children, collecting baby formula and abusing food banks, to then sell the formula and food FOR PROFIT. This is so silly on countless levels, it just isn't profitable nor something that happens. Not to mention the fact that food banks have registration processes and are organized to give out only what people need so there is enough to go around. All your comment does is tell me you have never had to use a food bank or volunteered at one without having to expressly say that.
The 14th amendment was first initiated in 1866 right after Lincoln's emancipation proclamation freeing the slaves and ratified in 1868 which made the former slaves citizens that were here already, not people from outside the united states.
This is one of Democrats dirty games. We American people know the Democrats will continue to play this dirty games. OMG, NY governor and GA again to waste taxpayers money again.
These blue states don't have a problem bending the constitution when it's convenient, what happened to the 2nd amendment where the right to bear arms should not be infringed?
The left always state that the founders could not have rnvisioned the firearms we have today. So going by that standard the writers of the fourteenth could have never envisioned mass illegal invasion.
I saw an article the other day where they interviewed a young man picking oranges. He said he'd been here over 10 years and he and his wife worked the fields. However he's not documented but he pays taxes now. Ladies and gentlemen when I want to know is why in the heck has this person who is working and working hard not getting his citizenship. What is the problem? I know two people who went through this system did what they had to do and are now citizens. This is not brain surgery.
@@Calamity4 Only IF one or both parents are Australian. A person is NOT automatically an Australian citizen simply because they were born here. Until 20th of August 1986 we had the same system as America does. We found people were abusing the system and so it was changed, adding the requirement. Take your own advice and stop spreading lies.
okay keep it legal in your state then, but don't allow them to be a citizen but instead a resident of that state ONLY. Those states then can be flooded with the entire mess for themselves. Allow states to decide if they want it or not at least. Meanwhile Trump can fix the border and stop the flood.
The idea that two illegals can run over the border and have a kid and the kid is a citizen is ABSURD. This is a distortion of citizenship that has gone on far too long.
🙄 day one and we’re off! Right back at the assumption based headlines, and downright untrue bullshit just like last time… attack the guy on something he’s done, not something he’s “going to do” for a change,
Isnt one country in the world where thisnis allowed.. jist cause you was born in the country with out having a certain amount of time in it. So why is it a problem now lol..
Trump wrong for this one I’m glad these states suing bc if a child is born here why should that be taken away? That’s sad ash💯💯. Trying to change the past is mad crazy.
ALL DEMOCRATIC STATES
Yea!!! Stop him Job #1!!
Let's go DEMS
Well I was born here 57 year’s ago, come and get me.
@@MLM68God gave you one mouth and two ears for a reason
This was added to the constitution to protect freed slaves from being deported. It needs to be amended.
I believe in the 14th amendment. However, if a child of illegal immigrants is born here and given instant citizenship, it should not be used as a short cut to citizenship for the parents.
Stop it. None of this matters
It isn't... It only gives citizenship to the child born in the country.
This was added to the constitution to give freed slaves and their descendants citizenship and stop them from being deported. That's the only reason. It's time to amend it.
@@Calamity4Wrong. It gave protections to former slaves and their children as written in the 14A.
@ yeah? And the parents cant get deported because their child is a citizen. And no, the 14th amendment was NOT meant for this.
You don't want to leave your baby do you? Then adult and baby go
No it is not Guaranteed ! This amendment was basically meant for freed American slaves Not children of people who are here illeagally , DJT will force Supreme Court to rule on it ,Very smart 🇺🇲♥️🎸🎶 FCH
Just like the 2nd Amendment is for a well-regulated militia. We have a military now. No need for amateurs with small pew pews.
Yes. The 14th amendment was made for enslaved people. NOT Illegal immigrants.
Who gives a fk. It's a right just like your precious 2A
@@s.r6331 great. Then those kids are welcome to stay without their parents, who DON'T have that right. Or, they can come back when they move out of their foreign parents house. Up to the deported parents to decide.
Indeed it is. Smart move, Mr. President. 🇺🇸
It is absolutely ridiculous that these people think it is right for a pregnant immigrant to be able to sneak into a country, pop out a baby, and expect them to be granted citizenship. Give me a break.
Not only that have a child every 11 months expecting medical for the mother and the children. They receive wic, formula and go to every corner to pick up food at the food banks then profit from that food.
Go POP IN Your MEDS
@@krystalship6245
Yeah? So do large Jewish families. What's your point?
@@krystalship6245Do you really believe that people are sneaking in, having children, collecting baby formula and abusing food banks, to then sell the formula and food FOR PROFIT. This is so silly on countless levels, it just isn't profitable nor something that happens. Not to mention the fact that food banks have registration processes and are organized to give out only what people need so there is enough to go around. All your comment does is tell me you have never had to use a food bank or volunteered at one without having to expressly say that.
The 14th amendment was to protect freed slaves from being deported. Not for containers full of pregnant Chinese women.
The 14th amendment was first initiated in 1866 right after Lincoln's emancipation proclamation freeing the slaves and ratified in 1868 which made the former slaves citizens that were here already, not people from outside the united states.
exactly
Like Musk and Melania?
Send all back
to include 2nd generation German Americans!
@@ikeus685u wrong for that
Let's send you back too since your ancestors immigrated here. No birthright citizenship for you, sorry!
@@ikeus685the first generation was an anchor baby 😂
This is one of Democrats dirty games. We American people know the Democrats will continue to play this dirty games. OMG, NY governor and GA again to waste taxpayers money again.
These blue states don't have a problem bending the constitution when it's convenient, what happened to the 2nd amendment where the right to bear arms should not be infringed?
So your point is that both of you should be able to 💩 on the constitution? Lol this is why no intelligent people take you voter clowns seriously
What about it cuz it's still intact.. and if u wanna get rid of birthright citizenship then get rid of the 2A
The left always state that the founders could not have rnvisioned the firearms we have today. So going by that standard the writers of the fourteenth could have never envisioned mass illegal invasion.
@@s.r6331 gl getting a carry permit in those states
Trump is right, read the 14th amendment see for yourself
Ok read the 14th amendment sec 3....
Then you go bsvk since your ancestors are from europe
@martinez209 nah I think we’ll stay. You can keep cutting our lawn though.
@martinez209 our ancestors came to this country LEGALLY. Smart guy
I have dude. Look you’re not the smart one in the room you just gotta know that. You’re really not
All just be vetted and apply for legal citizenship. Legal immigration is the only way. I don’t think it’s too much to ask.
I saw an article the other day where they interviewed a young man picking oranges. He said he'd been here over 10 years and he and his wife worked the fields. However he's not documented but he pays taxes now. Ladies and gentlemen when I want to know is why in the heck has this person who is working and working hard not getting his citizenship. What is the problem? I know two people who went through this system did what they had to do and are now citizens. This is not brain surgery.
But, but if illegals aren't allowed here they can't vote. And if they can't vote, Democrats can't stay in power 😢 /s
Is it too much to ask that you actually read the US constitution?
Tell that to Melania's parents who came here on the chain migration program her husband wanted abolished. Or is that "different?"
Trump is an anchor baby too tho
You can expect lawsuits on every executive order. He put out. And i'm sure he's ready for them
Yes, he ready.
And they will lose each case.
He learned nothing from his first clusterfuck.
Ofc he is ready! He beat nyc lawyers so he knows what’s sup lol
@@markflynn8824illl be ur life he won’t lose one
Remover the 14th Amendment They came into this country Illegally
it should be removed. It was only made for enslaved people starting in the 1800's.
That should be a law. If the parents are nit cirizens then their kids should not be
Hate much?
@@ikeus685 thats how it is in prettymuch every country
@@ikeus685 That's how every other nation works. Are you arguing that every other nation on the planet is run by "hate"?
@@ikeus685 😂😂 what lmfao
Because you are?? I guess you’re more American than anyone else 😂😂😂😂.
The Supreme Coukrt will decide...
Nothing will come of it. 😂 just a scary tactic
I support that birth right law. Go Trump
Yeppers one of Trump wife's child or children are not citizens bye bye but I forgotten Trump is above the laws of the land
States have no standing in this matter.
Go back to your ancestors country. You'll be happier there
You have no standing in reality.
Oh, so NOW you're against state's rights?
@@TotsNaterfr. These people are insane.
@@jcarterlaThe truth hurts. Learn about your Constitution instead of posting obtuse BS.
Get out
Let's call it what it actually is, anchor babies. Which is NOT what the 14th amendment intended.
WELL ITS NOT GOING TO MATTER THE STATES WILL LOSE!!!
And what will happen in the end? Cruelty won’t win
The states will lose what? It's written clearly in the constitution n need super majority of congress n states to be amended. Good luck 😂
Stop crying...Trump's mandate is not Trump's!!! It is Americans who want to end birthright citizenship ....we're done with your woke BS!!!
All immigrants? Stop the 🧢
Stop the red !!!
@@priuskiller426 This policy is clearly only targeting legal immigrants they just want to be the victim in any sort of way, it's sad.
I'm glad President Trump's signed this law, enough is enough .
Just withhold funding to 22 states
Supreme Court!
🎉❤Trump ❤USA 🇺🇸
They will loose. This amendment refers to reconciliation regarding enslaved people. Not anyone who arrives illegally and drops a baby.
Cry about it. Nothing can be done
I agree with Trump
Butcher Putin won't make a deal. Butcher Putin needs Ukrainian cities: Kherson and Zaporozhye. America get ready for wa
Good! Focus on this. Focus on the immigrants. Do that.
Illegals
If 22 states say no and 28 states say yes. 🙌 majority vote
Democracy at work,.. right? Right.
Babies born to American citizens!
That’s all right!!! Bring it up to the SUPREME Court 😎
What a waste of taxpayer money
If I had a kid in Japan, would that kid automatically be a Japanese citizen?
Nope. At least one parent needs to be a citizen.
@@kristalsea Same in Australia and most other nations.
@@JohnJ469That isn't true in Australia. The moment the child is born they are granted residency and a path to citizenship. Stop spreading lies.
@@Calamity4 Only IF one or both parents are Australian. A person is NOT automatically an Australian citizen simply because they were born here.
Until 20th of August 1986 we had the same system as America does. We found people were abusing the system and so it was changed, adding the requirement.
Take your own advice and stop spreading lies.
Dem states .thst means MONEY FOR THEM
Hold back EBT to show US birth certificates.
Womp womp 😂😂😂 cry about it liberals
Trump is so much business to the courts
Every job I get in NYC undocumented attack me.
Does the deportation apply to nationalized citizens?
🤣😂🤣 yall mad n angry people 😂🤣😂
Proud of them. Keep America America.
Their crying 😂 MAGA
I hope trump is successful
If birthright is not wrong, why should there be fear?
The constitution can be ratified!
Of course they are 🙄
Democrats have a point! I noticed those states are richer than other half. 🍀
okay keep it legal in your state then, but don't allow them to be a citizen but instead a resident of that state ONLY. Those states then can be flooded with the entire mess for themselves. Allow states to decide if they want it or not at least. Meanwhile Trump can fix the border and stop the flood.
Vote the Democrats out
That’s what seditionists do.
Illegal is illegal!
Let these politicians & dogooders support them financially instead of taxpayers. See how quick they change their minds.
We don’t watch ABC news!
A real president
what a garbage biased channel, get a life people
Uncle trump !!!!!
Thank you
Don’t interject your opinion about the constitution. The Supreme Court will dial this in…finally.
Trump supporters never saw a Civics class that they couldn't fail.
sent all them to those states
trump cant read he just sign...
From someone who doesn't use proper punctuation!
@@jerrybessetteDIY and your point is??
@@TONYORTIZ-v9z Point is the baby does not get left behind when its illegal-alien parents are sent back to their home country,
These are pathetic blue cities, not states. Everyone needs to go no matter if you have a kid or not. They broke the law plain and simple.
Here we go. The children are upset.
EECO for rights
Can’t have Americans be protected
The idea that two illegals can run over the border and have a kid and the kid is a citizen is ABSURD.
This is a distortion of citizenship that has gone on far too long.
A advice ok if take off the 14th amendment so take off the second... amendment...
Illegal immigrants came here illegally
Like grampa F Drumpf illegal draft dodger
"Subject to the jurisdiction thereof"
but murphy want his help with congestion tolls from trump
To big to rig. That's y I am moving out of NY after 40.
🙄 day one and we’re off! Right back at the assumption based headlines, and downright untrue bullshit just like last time… attack the guy on something he’s done, not something he’s “going to do” for a change,
He signed the EO already, MAGAT.
Besides, they put abortion back to the state level, this will be also. Just watch.
Can American 🇺🇲 be a ethnicity?
The cruelty begins. This is the dark side of our society.
Lmao
The cruelty began with slavery, which upon being freed, said slaves were granted citizenship by the 14th amendment.
Yep. This was coming. That interpretation. I can hope it's made crystal clear after this is all done and settled....but this has to be done.
The crazies are off and running already
Isnt one country in the world where thisnis allowed.. jist cause you was born in the country with out having a certain amount of time in it. So why is it a problem now lol..
Did South America or Africa just take a title away from someone even know she was born and lived all her life in the country. But she was white lol 😅
What???
🙄
Yeah for legal birthright .... not illegal.
Hey tom speak English not marbles mouthful of vocabulary can't understand you're language
Extream blabla bla
Have NY, NJ, and CT even ASKED their constituents about this?
Trump wrong for this one I’m glad these states suing bc if a child is born here why should that be taken away? That’s sad ash💯💯. Trying to change the past is mad crazy.
So you think America is right and every other nation on Earth is wrong? Interesting.
I hope he succeeds we can barely take care of our own people natural American born citizens homeless rates go up yet we keep taking in immigrants.
@ItsJustChristenwhat does “natural” even mean?? Most of this land is stolen. You want natural. EVERYONE HAS TO GO. NATIVES were here FIRST.
Whenever I moved, my kids moved with me.
She needs to read the constitution, specifically the 14th amendment, or a book.
That's funny how they pick and choose what's guaranteed🎉
ΝΥ NJ and CT they wont see a dime from federal funds is a new Sherrif in town
Trump
!!!!!!!
Send them
Send every last one of them back.