If you get pension in Canada,you can live anywhere in the world and you pension will deposited anywhere you wish but you must file taxes,it is the pensioners money after all.
I get my pension from the US’and I live in Spain. It is also adjusted for inflation. Also, a lot of french people lives in Spain ,and they get their pensions se same as if they were in France.
@@claudinegerard5 ask Brits if they get their pensions adjusted outside the EU? in fact if algerians want it they should find an agreement with France, but knowing algerians, there is zero chance of any agreement with France
They do get their pension but what they do not get are the supplementary benefits linked to their low pensions which is there to enable them to live « decently » in France. If you contribute fully to the French pension scheme you get it back and can live wherever you want. These people either did not pay into the scheme or paid too little. A case of making your bed…or wanting your cake. Having said this these people will never be at home either in France or Algeria. They are exiles and strangers for the rest of their lives. Sad but the true condition of all migrants. You belong nowhere after a while.
i dont understand why some comments talk about algeria? Those chibanis worked all their life in France had kid grandchildren and french citizens so its a french problem its france only who don't respect her citizens and still treating them like they own them till death... Liberté? Freedom isnt it one of values of French's? Can't see it here
Seems like there is no freedom, specifically the freedom of choice in this particular instance in a Western country.... May be freedom is just another Western rhetoric...
it´s the same in the UK - you don´t get supplementary benefits if you live abroad. they are calculated and based on local living conditions. what´s the issue with that? the people that stayed in N Africa have got it worse
French pensioners can live wherever they want with their pensions. Many opt to live in Portugal, Morocco or Tunisia. Their pensions are not reduced, even though they stop paying any tax to the French system.
@@laurentlambert6347 yes same in UK. It is the extra additional payments for example in respect of rent for poorer pensioners that are paid to UK landlords. it is not possible to do that for Algerian property, or Spanish or any other country for obvious reasons
algeria occupied Provence [ south of france ] starting in 720 ad for 300 years......men were put in slavery after being castrated......france kicked them back 1100 years later minus the castration.......
@mariaglass2968 if you going to morocco or Algeria for example the french government cut your pension in half if you want you pension send to you but it's a very different story if for example you move to Spain o Italy. Double standard nothing new from the french.
The treaties and laws make no sense in a mobile society where people study, live and work abroad very often due to necessity. Algeria and France need a treaty which respects the lives and the labor that these people provided the nation.
@@Zaradean698 It's not double standards, it's an EU rule and part of the fiscal harmonisation amongst its members. Algeria left the EU in 1976, so are not concerned by the framework. Also, many countries in the world have this rule, effectively forcing people to spend most of their pension in the country to avoid the national money being spent outside.
No Millenial or Gen Z will ever have a pension like this. I wish the biggest fear about my retirement would be that I had to live in the South of France
@@naturalw33 i think you missed the point of the comment. the vast majority of people 40 and younger will NEVER get a pension. We'll work till we die. But I'm suppose to feel sorry for someone bec they get free food free housing free medicine for decades with the only caveat being they live half the year in a mild climate with wonderful food and their own muslim communities. boo freaking hoo.
@@drisely7846 oh please honey. it's not complicated. physics this isn't. I just disagree with the conclusions. they have pension periods, significant pensions. how many people in algeria have pensions? esp uneducated construction workers. crying out having to live in france? lmao
The Algerian government has plenty of money from the sale of gas and petrol. They could give these retired Algerians a decent pension. Why not help its citizens ?
@@adamlasry5225 They have contributed their whole life, so yes they're fully entitled to a pension from the state to which the contributions were paid.
Can someone please explain to me why they live alone in France in poor conditions, while the children and wife's live in algeria,why they dont return to their homeland?
@@pashawolf4305 They can't, they worked all their lives in France to provide for their families back at home. This means they haven't worked in Algeria. They have no pension benefits in Algeria. Their healthcare and pensions are tied to France, and to get it, you have to prove residency for more than half a a year at least each year in France since Sarkozy (2008).
Thats a scandal cause they didnt work for their own country but where used as cheap slave workers for a Western country , and their benefits shouldnt stop after they Move out of that country cause they worked hard for it
The self proclaimed terrorist wicked prophet Muhammad pedophile Nabi and his terrorist followers are threat to the world. Beware every one else are kafir for them
Even you shall in due time upon this planet become an elder. Our youth is fast& fleeting. Your karma will return to you full circle. "The young become the old"!!!!
![เปิด อาณาจักร หมื่นล้าน "สาระตั้ม" l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3XE0nPF4YkQ/mqdefault.jpg)
bravo et merci pour cette vidéo une génération qui mérite le respect pour l'apport de leur courage d'avoir contribuer à l'économie française
Un grand Respect aux chibanis💔 😢
So sad, tear in my eyes,one would.think algeria would do something to help them,,
Je veux prier pour ceux qui sont loin de chez eux 😢😢😢 un grand respect aux chibanis
In any other civilised country you are entitled to your pension then you can live in any country without being penalised
If you get pension in Canada,you can live anywhere in the world and you pension will deposited anywhere you wish but you must file taxes,it is the pensioners money after all.
@@Patricia-sw3ek wrong, pensions are not adjusted yearly if you live abroad
I get my pension from the US’and I live in Spain. It is also adjusted for inflation. Also, a lot of french people lives in Spain ,and they get their pensions se same as if they were in France.
@@claudinegerard5 ask Brits if they get their pensions adjusted outside the EU? in fact if algerians want it they should find an agreement with France, but knowing algerians, there is zero chance of any agreement with France
They do get their pension but what they do not get are the supplementary benefits linked to their low pensions which is there to enable them to live « decently » in France. If you contribute fully to the French pension scheme you get it back and can live wherever you want. These people either did not pay into the scheme or paid too little. A case of making your bed…or wanting your cake. Having said this these people will never be at home either in France or Algeria. They are exiles and strangers for the rest of their lives. Sad but the true condition of all migrants. You belong nowhere after a while.
The same in the Netherlands 🇳🇱 that rules to the Pensioners
I have a NL national pension, and I live in Spain.
@@johndavies1506 At the end You will be back to the Netherlands 🇳🇱 for Good 😁😁😁😁
Al Jazeera! Please, make a documentary about the Peshawar School Massacre in Pakistan in December 2014.
PLEASE REMEMBER
THE Massacre and Murder of ALGerian Of Innocent Men, Women and Children by The
FRENCH
i dont understand why some comments talk about algeria? Those chibanis worked all their life in France had kid grandchildren and french citizens so its a french problem its france only who don't respect her citizens and still treating them like they own them till death... Liberté? Freedom isnt it one of values of French's? Can't see it here
Seems like there is no freedom, specifically the freedom of choice in this particular instance in a Western country.... May be freedom is just another Western rhetoric...
They will never be real French, just like you would never be real Japanese even if you were living there 40 years. They have to go
it´s the same in the UK - you don´t get supplementary benefits if you live abroad. they are calculated and based on local living conditions. what´s the issue with that? the people that stayed in N Africa have got it worse
French pensioners can live wherever they want with their pensions. Many opt to live in Portugal, Morocco or Tunisia. Their pensions are not reduced, even though they stop paying any tax to the French system.
@@laurentlambert6347those French pensioners don't get pension credit to top up their money.
@@laurentlambert6347 yes same in UK. It is the extra additional payments for example in respect of rent for poorer pensioners that are paid to UK landlords. it is not possible to do that for Algerian property, or Spanish or any other country for obvious reasons
would be nice to have a French version
Of what, an explanation of all this. There is'nt one.
Would be nice to have a French explanation, more like.
I meant a French translation for French people who do not speak Arabic and or English and know so little about Chibani's situation
Just one question how did that support himself in Algeria for 6 months without using his bank card where his pension was deposited .???
The french really f,,k up Algeria, another colonial power
algeria occupied Provence [ south of france ] starting in 720 ad for 300 years......men were put in slavery after being castrated......france kicked them back 1100 years later minus the castration.......
IT APPEARS THAT THE FRENCH PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM IS BY FAR SUPERIOR THAN US. WHAT ABOUT GERIATRIC CARE?
You do not lose your social security check if you leave France after you retire.
@mariaglass2968 if you going to morocco or Algeria for example the french government cut your pension in half if you want you pension send to you but it's a very different story if for example you move to Spain o Italy. Double standard nothing new from the french.
The treaties and laws make no sense in a mobile society where people study, live and work abroad very often due to necessity. Algeria and France need a treaty which respects the lives and the labor that these people provided the nation.
@@Zaradean698 It's not double standards, it's an EU rule and part of the fiscal harmonisation amongst its members.
Algeria left the EU in 1976, so are not concerned by the framework.
Also, many countries in the world have this rule, effectively forcing people to spend most of their pension in the country to avoid the national money being spent outside.
Can someone please tell me what the beautiful intro music is in this poignant documentary.
This only happened to Algerians and not Tunis? or any other North African country?
No Millenial or Gen Z will ever have a pension like this. I wish the biggest fear about my retirement would be that I had to live in the South of France
You sound like a crab in a bucket.
I think you missed the point of the doc.
@@naturalw33 i think you missed the point of the comment. the vast majority of people 40 and younger will NEVER get a pension. We'll work till we die. But I'm suppose to feel sorry for someone bec they get free food free housing free medicine for decades with the only caveat being they live half the year in a mild climate with wonderful food and their own muslim communities. boo freaking hoo.
@@tf4156 The more you write, the more it becomes clear that you've missed the point of the document 😅
@@drisely7846 oh please honey. it's not complicated. physics this isn't. I just disagree with the conclusions. they have pension periods, significant pensions. how many people in algeria have pensions? esp uneducated construction workers. crying out having to live in france? lmao
The Algerian government has plenty of money from the sale of gas and petrol. They could give these retired Algerians a decent pension. Why not help its citizens ?
They worked their whole life for france. The pensions they get are their full right and not a charity
@@adamlasry5225 uncivilized countries,governments official getting fat off stolen money
@@adamlasry5225 They have contributed their whole life, so yes they're fully entitled to a pension from the state to which the contributions were paid.
Like seriously?..did they worked for Algeria? Did they paid any taxe to Algeria state or they worked and paid taxe to France?...just asking...
Can someone please explain to me why they live alone in France in poor conditions, while the children and wife's live in algeria,why they dont return to their homeland?
@@pashawolf4305 They can't, they worked all their lives in France to provide for their families back at home. This means they haven't worked in Algeria. They have no pension benefits in Algeria. Their healthcare and pensions are tied to France, and to get it, you have to prove residency for more than half a a year at least each year in France since Sarkozy (2008).
@@imanethe1175 merci
La France de l'exploitation de l'homme.
Grave,la France des droits de l'homme 😂😂😂
Thats not a scandal thats the fiscal rule for everyone!!!!
Thats a scandal cause they didnt work for their own country but where used as cheap slave workers for a Western country , and their benefits shouldnt stop after they Move out of that country cause they worked hard for it
@@NahidAmar nobody forced them to take a boat to France! they could have stayed in Algeria and live in poverty
The self proclaimed terrorist wicked prophet Muhammad pedophile Nabi and his terrorist followers are threat to the world. Beware every one else are kafir for them
Even you shall in due time upon this planet become an elder. Our youth is fast& fleeting. Your karma will return to you full circle. "The young become the old"!!!!
It's in humane and cruel!!!