الإنسان رغم امتلاكه للأدوات ( المهارات ،العقل ) لا يستطيع أن يصل إلي الحقيقة ،فالإنسان عاجز أمام الموت و الفناء فالممثل لا يستطيع أن يصل للماء و الكاتب هنا متأثرا بالفلسفة الوجودية
My humble take: The first 2 whistles led us to non-materialistic truth of the world. We were inexperienced, so we were scared by its horrid nature. The palm tree is human society: the shade is positivity, like parental love or friendship, which masks us from the harshness of the world. The out-sticking branch stands for the possibility of suicidal death, which is always there, but often ignored when hardship is little. The shade (societal positivity) offers only limited protection: when we grow old enough and have the tool (the scissors) that the society thinks we can utilize to make a living, the shade simple stop offering unconditional love. We were then forced to pursue what we seem as happiness (the water) with what the world offers us (the rope, the cubes). When this pursuit is unsuccessful, we think about death (the branch on the tree). But this option is highly suppressed cuz the society doesn’t encourage it. When we were once again drawn by the whistle to see the horrid real world, we are old enough and had the knowledge to realize that we should fight for this ridiculous situation. Yet one is very powerless. Knowing that we could never change it, we start to distract ourselves with what was left to us. When we are old, the society once again offers their warm protection, and it’s ok to kill ourselves now. But we don’t really care anymore. We just look at ourselves and think that why the fuck was I ever born?
@@evanes3509 That life and our interaction with it is inherently absurd and meaningless. Like this man here, we are just thrown into life with no prior knowledge of what we're going to deal with, have no idea how it works, and no matter what we do all we do is ultimately in vain. Just like the boxes and the water and the tree, everything in life is beyond our reach, the way they function make no sense and interacting with life will lead no meaningful result. That's the gist of what Beckett is about and this play and the other one Act Without Words II, is the abstract of his outlook on life. Even more abstract is his famous quote from the novel The Unnamable: "you must go on. I can't go on. I'll go on." Meaning that living and existence in their essence are absurd and meaningless, but you still do it. You still go on day to day doing your daily routine amounting to no meaningful outcome. It's absurd to live life in this sense and yet we do it, therefore life is absurd. It's not about "making it in life" per se. Life is this way for everyone from the most successful to the worst failures.
@@armind3870 what about when the water was right in his face? What is the interpretation on that because I still believe that the original comment has a good interpretation on that. Would the director agree about that because if everything is out of reach, but it is the closest it ever was to the character, then he could have made a last ditch effort but decided not to and ultimately gave up.
@@evanes3509 well I believe that the character at this point has learned of the absurdity of his struggle and accepted that any attempt is going to fail. He knows that the water is right there in his face, but he also knows that if he tries to grab for it then it's gonna jump up or pull some other trick to get out of reach like its been doing all this time. So he realizes it is hopeless and just gives up. Also this last tease serves as a tease to the audience as well. We are sitting here thinking dude the water is in your reach! Just go for it! We the audience have the same attitude towards that desirable object (water/meaning) that the character had two minutes ago. Therefore proving to us that we still haven't given up on life having meaning, that we still hope to search for meaning. It's right there! Go for it! Or you can just accept that you've been struggling for so long to no avail, and this one is just like all the other ones. It leaves it up to the audience to decide whether the water was finally within reach or not, aka whether life has meaning or not.
le théâtre de la dérision qui prend la vie à la légèreté.. cet homme représente l'homme moderne qui essaye de comprendre ce monde superfétatoire et de créer une issue à son existence malheureuse mais en fin de compte il finit par se résigner malgré que à la fin il a trouvé ce qu'il souhaite or, c'est déjà trop tard
My name's kawther Second year Deparment English U. O. B When lwatching the play Act without word but I think that the writer he wanted to give important lesson about your life through of the play 🤔🤔
Technically, according to the script, there is no music during this whole piece. It's completely silent. Also the actor mustn't grunt or cry, only 'reflect' , but I guess that's open to interpretation
While I think this short film has multiple meanings and is up for interpretation, here’s my take on it: This is a physical representation of quitting an unhealthy addiction. When you first quit, it feels like you are thrown out into the open and all alone. You go chasing the substance, you are forcibly thrown back; you know you should stay away from it. However, it keeps grabbing your attention. It’s surrounding you, and you can’t stop thinking about it. Then, you feel ashamed. Your disappointed in yourself for how you’ve been acting. While you wallow in self-pity, the temptation presents itself. You run towards it but decided to refrain. You indulge in self-care and start focusing on taking care of yourself. The visual is wilting, its less significant now. Seeing your favorite but forbidden substance fade away hurts you, but you start to see another opportunity for getting better. The thing you need to get better is so close to you. You can see it, but you can’t quite reach it. No matter your efforts, it’s always too far away. This doesn’t mean you’ve given up. Your addiction is still calling for your attention. You’re ignoring it, you’re trying to get better, but you aren’t being rewarded. It seems like it keeps getting harder and harder. The effort doesn’t seem worth it. Every opportunity is a dead end. Despite everything, the substance is still getting louder and demanding your attention. You lose hope. You give up. Then, just at the end, you give up. You sit and pity yourself. The perfect solution floats past you. It seems too good to be true, and you let it get away. Timing isn’t always perfect, hard work isn’t always rewarded, and there isn’t always a happy ending.
My thoughts on this : This is only portraying the phase where this person has goals and everything is going against him (we all feel like it the start) and since he's not dead that leaves room for him to get to where he wants aa long as he applies the rules which are you have to act fast (seize the chance in other words)
I think he finally realizes there’s no point. Acts of Will won’t help him. He could have grabbed the water, but he would have eventually been thirsty again. He could have gone to the tree but he’d still be on a desert, eternally. The hands (symbols of the will) have in a sense reached an endgame.
I love Beckett but this is so much juvenilia hard to believe it appeared alongside the stunning endgame almost a parody - in fact screams to be sent up
In my opinion the meaning is : when you have the chance you must try as far as you can to reach your goal , and don't be lazy , and don't waste the time and you just have to think simply to find your path of goal , and it's easy to come true it , and you should believe that the time never be mercy of you and never wait for you (of course every thing under Allah's control) , so this play refers to the life and us facing the obstacles.
That's exactly the opposite of the meaning of it. Your goals don't matter. You don't matter. Nothing matters. Most things don't even exist, Allah/God don't exist, therefore nothing is attainable or even worth striving for. Unless you follow the absurdist approach, which is that nothing matters so fuck it why not have some fun?
Maryam Kareem The Deep South. I will tell you that the series from which this video came is definitive and if anything cake beckett make sense you will find it there. try watching a few others also.
please I really need help guys ,I want to know what is the importance of this play 'cause to me it is nothing but a man in the middle of the desert want to drink water. please help me because it is very important to me😢😢
+^Blisss thanks for your comment . I'm not a native speaker of English language I'm just a learner and I'm facing difficulty with this play that why I asked if anyone can give me the main idea behind this whole play
ooooohhh, now im understanding. the act is using an universal language, so everyone can understand it. its an open, absurd theaterconzept. you as person got to put yourself into it. the act in the end will let you alone with questions and one main goal is to ask others. so here you are :D
I don't think Samuel Beckett really liked this play it was meant to be a prelude to Endgame or Krapp's Last Tape along with Act Without Words 2 which he didn't like either, it was inspired by the silent films he liked to watch
كله من وره الانكليزي خلاني اشوف هيج كلاوات😭💔
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
تعليق للذكرى... احاول افهم هاي المسرحيه لان الملخصات الي دازهم الاستاذ هواي ومعقده وحاليا حردانه عند اهلي 😹وحامل وامر بأصعب فتره تعب نفسي وجسدي اتمنى اجي بيوم من الايام اشوف تعليقي والاقي كل مشاكلي محلوله ولكن مابظن ...
ها خلصتو
اتوقع انو مشاكلج نحلت هسه ، مو.. ؟
نص العالم ضربها الفضول حاليا
ها؟ بشري
ها يمعوده وين صرتي 🤔
بطران الي حط منهجنا🦦 يعني ما لكو غير هاي المسرحية😭😭😭😭
الإنسان رغم امتلاكه للأدوات ( المهارات ،العقل ) لا يستطيع أن يصل إلي الحقيقة ،فالإنسان عاجز أمام الموت و الفناء
فالممثل لا يستطيع أن يصل للماء
و الكاتب هنا متأثرا بالفلسفة الوجودية
الفلسفة العبثية وليس الوجودية
Overwhelming! Great author! Great director! Great actor!
تعليق للذكرى اتمنى المرحله الجايه او بعد كم سنه ارجع واشوف تعليقي واتذكر المصاعب،واكول من جنت ثاني ،مسرحيه غامضه ع فكرة 😹❤️🌹
ويااج حبيبي اني 🥰🤭🥀
2021\2\21 يوم الأحد باجر عدنه مسرحية 😑
@@sarahamad769 ان شاء الله 😁❤️🥰
امتحان شفوي 😹💔
😂😂انتی ھم۔مرحلہ ثانیہ انکلیزیہ
احنہ باجر عدنہ مسرح
@@aa-lv2ic ييي ثاني اني صدك بسلا وياي نتي 😹💔
@@thequeen1565 ھھھہ یجوز
Wonderful. Amazing design and acting
What a great play !! ...... it has a lot of truth about our world .... ( بالمختصر مسرحيه لوز) :)
Beckett is fucking crazy and I mean that the nicest way. He cracks me up.
هذا يمثل الواقع، يعني يجب على الإنسان أن يصل إلى أعلى مستوى من العلم والثقافة وان يركز على الهدفه من الحياة، لا يتكاسل ولا يعتمد على لاغير.
ما اعتقد الشرح هيج لأن كاتب المسرحية يؤمن انو الحياة مابيها هدف
I have a lec about that tomorrow morning, i tried to watch the video to understand but lmao 😂😂😂 this is so complicated, i mean sfup samuel lol
Story of my life.
والله تجذب
My humble take: The first 2 whistles led us to non-materialistic truth of the world. We were inexperienced, so we were scared by its horrid nature. The palm tree is human society: the shade is positivity, like parental love or friendship, which masks us from the harshness of the world. The out-sticking branch stands for the possibility of suicidal death, which is always there, but often ignored when hardship is little. The shade (societal positivity) offers only limited protection: when we grow old enough and have the tool (the scissors) that the society thinks we can utilize to make a living, the shade simple stop offering unconditional love. We were then forced to pursue what we seem as happiness (the water) with what the world offers us (the rope, the cubes). When this pursuit is unsuccessful, we think about death (the branch on the tree). But this option is highly suppressed cuz the society doesn’t encourage it. When we were once again drawn by the whistle to see the horrid real world, we are old enough and had the knowledge to realize that we should fight for this ridiculous situation. Yet one is very powerless. Knowing that we could never change it, we start to distract ourselves with what was left to us. When we are old, the society once again offers their warm protection, and it’s ok to kill ourselves now. But we don’t really care anymore. We just look at ourselves and think that why the fuck was I ever born?
no. this is absurdism. it's not supposed to be interpreted like that.
@@armind3870 what's your interpretation?
@@evanes3509 That life and our interaction with it is inherently absurd and meaningless. Like this man here, we are just thrown into life with no prior knowledge of what we're going to deal with, have no idea how it works, and no matter what we do all we do is ultimately in vain. Just like the boxes and the water and the tree, everything in life is beyond our reach, the way they function make no sense and interacting with life will lead no meaningful result. That's the gist of what Beckett is about and this play and the other one Act Without Words II, is the abstract of his outlook on life. Even more abstract is his famous quote from the novel The Unnamable: "you must go on. I can't go on. I'll go on." Meaning that living and existence in their essence are absurd and meaningless, but you still do it. You still go on day to day doing your daily routine amounting to no meaningful outcome. It's absurd to live life in this sense and yet we do it, therefore life is absurd. It's not about "making it in life" per se. Life is this way for everyone from the most successful to the worst failures.
@@armind3870 what about when the water was right in his face? What is the interpretation on that because I still believe that the original comment has a good interpretation on that. Would the director agree about that because if everything is out of reach, but it is the closest it ever was to the character, then he could have made a last ditch effort but decided not to and ultimately gave up.
@@evanes3509 well I believe that the character at this point has learned of the absurdity of his struggle and accepted that any attempt is going to fail. He knows that the water is right there in his face, but he also knows that if he tries to grab for it then it's gonna jump up or pull some other trick to get out of reach like its been doing all this time. So he realizes it is hopeless and just gives up. Also this last tease serves as a tease to the audience as well. We are sitting here thinking dude the water is in your reach! Just go for it! We the audience have the same attitude towards that desirable object (water/meaning) that the character had two minutes ago. Therefore proving to us that we still haven't given up on life having meaning, that we still hope to search for meaning. It's right there! Go for it! Or you can just accept that you've been struggling for so long to no avail, and this one is just like all the other ones. It leaves it up to the audience to decide whether the water was finally within reach or not, aka whether life has meaning or not.
Deep. 🎭🎬🎥
This is what is repeated in every act of life....even today....forever,
Vraiment originale cette représentation.
le théâtre de la dérision qui prend la vie à la légèreté.. cet homme représente l'homme moderne qui essaye de comprendre ce monde superfétatoire et de créer une issue à son existence malheureuse mais en fin de compte il finit par se résigner malgré que à la fin il a trouvé ce qu'il souhaite or, c'est déjà trop tard
very good continue
Them whistles remind me, of that great film : Papillon (Steve Mc.Queen)
when they're all in the penitentiary (for some reason)
Half life 2 puzzles be like....
My name's kawther
Second year Deparment English
U. O. B
When lwatching the play Act without word but I think that the writer he wanted to give important lesson about your life through of the play 🤔🤔
هاي المسرحية ماضل واحد من عائلتي ماشافها 😂♥️
2020🌚💔
very nice
Yeah, a great metaphor of life.
Interesting play!
Sums up my life
الاشياء التي تقدم للانسان تدل على ماتقدمه له الحياه
Exactly
Brilliant shit
هذا المسرحيه تشير الى
ان لم تتقدم الى الامام وتسعى الى هدفك وحياتك ...ستقع في حفرة لن تنجوا فيها ابدا طوال حياتك..❤❤
نفر عندة امتحان بيها شاهد الفيد كلـه جانت النيه افتهم وما افتهمت وشكراً 😂،
عظيم جدا جدا
Technically, according to the script, there is no music during this whole piece. It's completely silent. Also the actor mustn't grunt or cry, only 'reflect' , but I guess that's open to interpretation
While I think this short film has multiple meanings and is up for interpretation, here’s my take on it:
This is a physical representation of quitting an unhealthy addiction. When you first quit, it feels like you are thrown out into the open and all alone. You go chasing the substance, you are forcibly thrown back; you know you should stay away from it. However, it keeps grabbing your attention. It’s surrounding you, and you can’t stop thinking about it.
Then, you feel ashamed. Your disappointed in yourself for how you’ve been acting. While you wallow in self-pity, the temptation presents itself. You run towards it but decided to refrain. You indulge in self-care and start focusing on taking care of yourself. The visual is wilting, its less significant now.
Seeing your favorite but forbidden substance fade away hurts you, but you start to see another opportunity for getting better. The thing you need to get better is so close to you. You can see it, but you can’t quite reach it. No matter your efforts, it’s always too far away. This doesn’t mean you’ve given up.
Your addiction is still calling for your attention. You’re ignoring it, you’re trying to get better, but you aren’t being rewarded. It seems like it keeps getting harder and harder. The effort doesn’t seem worth it.
Every opportunity is a dead end. Despite everything, the substance is still getting louder and demanding your attention. You lose hope. You give up.
Then, just at the end, you give up. You sit and pity yourself. The perfect solution floats past you. It seems too good to be true, and you let it get away. Timing isn’t always perfect, hard work isn’t always rewarded, and there isn’t always a happy ending.
To the modern viewer it now resembles a survival video game: "Build enough blocks to drink the water".
That was brutal. Beckett sure was the master of injustice.
The impossibilty of escape for fate
Good
i was forced to watch this for my drama class send help!
حرام اذا فهمت شي 🥲😂
2021😐
Hahaha love this! :D
باجر تحضيرنااا وجيت تاه افتهمها
٢٠٢٢/٢/٨
اريد افهم المسرحيه
بربكم صدك جذب استاذ عبسكه ماشرح وانتو مخليلي فيديو شفته صارت بيه حاله نفسيه 😒😭شون بلا
True but what do we do its a must to see it
very interesting.
where's the joyful in this play please told me
@@maryamkareem8214 It's not joyful. This is Samuel Beckett we're talking about here.
دخت🙆🏻♀️
جيد
My thoughts on this :
This is only portraying the phase where this person has goals and everything is going against him (we all feel like it the start) and since he's not dead that leaves room for him to get to where he wants aa long as he applies the rules which are you have to act fast (seize the chance in other words)
Good evening l think the conflict in this play between the man and the fate
😇
وينك
En estas andamos los mexicanos.
Sin duda camarada, las palabras ya no alcanzan.
Lewis smile that's the point of this play
السلام عليكم شنو اسم هذه المسرحيه
و عليكم السلام ورحمة الله
Act without words
Good play, but it’s still not “high” resolution if that is what supposed to be meant by “high”. This is just upscale low res image
Holy water symbol of life, number 9 symbol of bad omen and death, stick symbol of oldness and death, bundle symbol of death,
when you betatest a Kaizo Mario game
ديله هسه اني شفهمت علمود اشرح للدكتوره استغفر الله دجيبي مسرحيه بيها خير 🌚😂
جماعة الانكليزي من ذالكم استاذ امين وجاي تتابعون المسرحيه شدتحسون 😂😂😂😂😂
هههههه اني منهم .احس راح انسحل
@@user-jy3hq3lt6j 😂😂
Hhhhhhhh amen going to kill us
MORX 2 الحمدلله ع كل حال😂💔
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 اي والله ذله
الاستاذ طلب من يمنه ملاحظات ع المسرحيه وني مافهمت شي منها ممكن ليعرف يساعدني 🌹🥺
احنه هممم واريد احد ينطيني عنهه شي مافهمتهه
عندج؟
@@ayatmohammed3531 شنو عندي؟!
Dá um like se estás neste vídeo porque andas na EPTC---
Tantalus
he wanted to drink water but he falls down
شنيييي هاااييي 😂💔
This is absurd... Lmao...I'm hilarious!
The writer what do you mean by this play
mohammad moreb the writer is dead
اذا اكو احد يعرف الثيمات مال هاي المسرحيه اكون ممنونه
Star English absurd play ( it discusses manners of meaning and feelings)
@@DADA_._ شنو يعني ذا
Remo whistle
I couldn't understand. Is there any translation to English?
But it has no WORDS to be translated !
@@zfadhul Oh. Aren’t you sweet..
على ذَا .......
عندي بحث عن هذي المسرحيه فيدوني شنو اكتب ومعلومات
@senioreta senioreta صدك ؟اريد اعرف عنهه اشياء كلشي مافهمت وعندي بحث التخرج بيهه😩
@senioreta senioreta باه ياريت بس شلون تدزيهه الي احتاج اقراهه اني ياريت ،هو يصير هوا تدزيلي الانستا مالتج😂
@senioreta senioreta اوك عيني هسه اضيفج
@senioreta senioreta اكول انتي ولد لو بنيه؟؟😅شو الحسابات كلهن صور ولد بلانستا ماكو حساب بنت شنو الصوره الي مخليتهه؟؟
@senioreta senioreta تمام دزيتلج اضافه
Why did the actor keep slapping his hands at the end of a scene? your interpretation
I think he finally realizes there’s no point. Acts of Will won’t help him. He could have grabbed the water, but he would have eventually been thirsty again. He could have gone to the tree but he’d still be on a desert, eternally. The hands (symbols of the will) have in a sense reached an endgame.
one more whistle and im out of here
kab khatam hoga yeh
نفر عنده امتحان بيها الأحد وكلشي مفتهمت منها 🤡💔2023/4/28
ها نجحت😂💅
@@user_joy86 لا والله حملتها😂😂😂
@@user-tg1fc6nj5y ربنا يوفقك انتم السابقون و نحن اللاحقون🗿💔
@@user_joy86 حبيبي والله 🦦
I love Beckett but this is so much juvenilia hard to believe it appeared alongside the stunning endgame
almost a parody - in fact screams to be sent up
HELLO listening test ho rhi hai kya tumahari bhi??
Haan
استغفر الله 😂😂😂😂
In my opinion the meaning is : when you have the chance you must try as far as you can to reach your goal , and don't be lazy , and don't waste the time and you just have to think simply to find your path of goal , and it's easy to come true it , and you should believe that the time never be mercy of you and never wait for you (of course every thing under Allah's control) , so this play refers to the life and us facing the obstacles.
Hussam N. i love this information can you tell me more about this play if you know please because l have an examination
@@mariamfiras8552 Me too it is really difficult actually my exam tomorrow 😪😥
That's exactly the opposite of the meaning of it.
Your goals don't matter. You don't matter. Nothing matters. Most things don't even exist, Allah/God don't exist, therefore nothing is attainable or even worth striving for. Unless you follow the absurdist approach, which is that nothing matters so fuck it why not have some fun?
Remember the time we watched TH-cam in p.com lmao
I didn't understand anything and I have exam in this play if anybody knows something about it please told me
just pass the exam.
your instructor doesn't care if you understand it.
but maybe your grade is in the crate that floats by...
or maybe it's in the smaller box.
WATER!!! your A+ is in the bottle of water! Yes! That's it!
I think.
oh thanks,,,where are you from
this man always hear the sound and begins to be crazy😂
Maryam Kareem
The Deep South. I will tell you that the series from which this video came is definitive and if anything cake beckett make sense you will find it there. try watching a few others also.
please I really need help guys ,I want to know what is the importance of this play 'cause to me it is nothing but a man in the middle of the desert want to drink water. please help me because it is very important to me😢😢
+katrina katrina everyone has its own interpretation : fail recommit, fail recommit, fail recommit. you have everything in ya hands.
+^Blisss thanks for your comment . I'm not a native speaker of English language I'm just a learner and I'm facing difficulty with this play that why I asked if anyone can give me the main idea behind this whole play
ooooohhh, now im understanding. the act is using an universal language, so everyone can understand it. its an open, absurd theaterconzept. you as person got to put yourself into it. the act in the end will let you alone with questions and one main goal is to ask others. so here you are :D
+^Blisss now I get it, I really appreciate your time thank you so much greeting from Iraq.👏👏
I just love you :) keep it awesome and head on mate :) good night from germany :D
is this minecraft
I have tomorrow exam in this play
and I don't understand any thing 👊
How was the exam
Pazar kadar hoca ödev verdi anlayan bilgi versin
مرحله ثانيه انكليزي 🙂🙂2021/2/20
مرحلة ثانية انكَليزي يحاول فهم هذه المسرحية 🤝٢/٢٢
🤣🤣🤣
2021/2/23 مرحله ثانيه ... احاول افهم وياكم ✌️😸
مرحلة ثانية 3/16 نحاول فهمها همات 😹😹👌🏻
All the theatre buffs in the comments: Look at this wonderful commentary on the meaninglessness of life
Me: Haha box man go brrrr
يابه شكد اثول شلع كلبي الفطير🤦♀️
هههههه اي ولله ماشفت هيج اثول مثله 😅😅😅
مو مسرحيه ضيم
This is like a machine AI,
simulating an environ with a Human - to observe him problem solving with only raw empiricism to go by.
I don't think Samuel Beckett really liked this play it was meant to be a prelude to Endgame or Krapp's Last Tape along with Act Without Words 2 which he didn't like either, it was inspired by the silent films he liked to watch
Incredibly funny. Incredibly bleak. Like life the t'ing itself.
والله من يمي تعبت وطلعت روحي 😒👎🏻
وينكم طلاب جامعه كركوك ودكتور هلاء القصه خانقه جداا
a man without aims in this life
this what called the theater of absurd
a man with aims that can never be attained, that is the absurd
Rob Harris please help me l have exam with this اني عندي امتحان باجر اريد مساعده
what the hill 😑😑
#بس غلط
شنو هل تمسلت ه̷̷َـَْـُذآ كلشي مافهمت
حنين حسين واني بعد عندي باجر متحان
اذا عدكم وسيله تواصل ادزه الكم بللتفصيل اقروها تنجحون ان شاء الله
تمسلت ..🤕🤕
@@hussainenglish4190
عزيزي اذا تگدر تدزها اكون ممنون منك
@@user-wz9uz9io2s اني باجر امتحاني 😥
هي هاي هم يسموها مسرحيه استغفروالله ياربي
عميقه شويه
Oh,my god😳I don't understand anything in the play.😑😑😑