Immigration is extremely controversial right now as the Trump administration is keeping preschool children in "tender age" detention centers. Watch more: bit.ly/2K9jrp8
I wish more people knew the stories, thank you so much ViceNews for this...here is Nelson Pinos, they say New Haven CT is a Sanctuary City but it is not, who could live like this facebook.com/ULANewHaven/videos/1945484762182808/?hc_ref=ARSZmo1TZXvUErvmIERM5lPdFV6yW6x7ERYfuVO55PbGGd55XKhzc4_YhHzel32TlMk
They don't want to put the children in detention centers that's why they are separating the children and taking them to housing were children go when both parents get arrested for a crime. They are damned either way , if they don't separate the families they are bad for putting children in detention centers, if they separate the children so they don't have to be in a detention center they are bad. Trump administration did not start this whole thing , enforcing the law yeah ,but they never started it. Its proven Obama's administration deported more illegal immigrants then any other President in American history and most the pictures of the detention centers posted everywhere are from 2014 under the Obama administration. The only difference between Obama's administration and Trumps is that Trump was vocal about it when Obama did it silently.
Id work it for a decent wage. Thats the only thing stopping Americans from taking these jobs. Also the desperate illegal immigrant that comes strolling in will take a lower wage and no bennefitts and the employers know this and take advantage of it. It should be more strictly enforced by law enforcement
But we already have 800,000 illegal DACA! Why aren't the 800K DACA doing these jobs! 800,000 DACA is enough to milk cow!! Where are they? They said they come here to do jobs we don't want to do!
@dennisestrada75 You're the fool being fooled by the illegal DACA! DACA are illegals that came here when they were young and now they are 18 to 30 years old. So they are technically ILLEGALS, and illegals said they come here to do jobs Americans don't want to do like "milking the cow". These illegal DACA want to go to college to steal good-paying jobs from the legal residents and Americans!
Meanwhile this little Dane grew up with cattle n goats and horses, donkies, etc. I am fucking astounded that people do not want to milk cattle for a living, its the EASIEST fuckin job on the planet! Well provided the cow dont kick you xD Not to mention that you can get fresh quality milk and cremes before its destroyed by machinery, and you can feed the local cat... seriously, why on earth is this not a popular line of work for unemployed US citizens? Is the pay bad? I am genuinely curious because I think I can find a solution!
@@forbidden1086 Spoken like a true idiot. Why is it that all ppl who speak this ignorance are actually ignorant. Learn to spell then come back. When they had become more strict on "illegals" working these jobs, farmers were left with no workers. So then they offered to increase wages upt to over 15/hr. and americans still wouldn't take the job. If ppl are upset that they take such low wages, be mad at the owners who actually hire and maintain these low wages. Which in turn actually keep America's food cost down. If you don't want hispanics here or working, don't eat, occupy any building or home made by hispanics, etc.
typical lower human first bitching their way up the police career ladder than complaining after retirement because he fears his imagine of god *WHAT* *A* *WEAK* *PERSON*
Let the workers work. Fill your "quota prison beds" with real criminals! Oh wait, it's hard to fight real criminals, much easier to round up poor workers.
But we already have 800,000 illegal DACA! Why aren't the 800K DACA doing these jobs! 800,000 DACA is enough to milk cow!! Where are they? They said they come here to do jobs we don't want to do!
@@thetruths7389 u two are fucked up in the head. These are people u are talking about, prisoners and illegal immigrants are people just like u. Slavery was abolished a long time ago, u cannot force someone to do a job. It goes against human rights. Human as in humanity, people u know
@@alwayslearning7672 u two are fucked up in the head. These are people u are talking about, prisoners and illegal immigrants are people just like u. Slavery was abolished a long time ago, u cannot force someone to do a job. It goes against human rights and humanity itself
In Canada our produce farms are staffed by Mexican workers who come on temporary work visas. One farmer told me he’d go out of business without them so it’s not just an American thing.
Claudia A. Valencia From a friend of mine that translates for a lot of these workers, and they people that hire them here in BC, treat them like sub humans. Garbage. It’s ironic, because most of the said farmers that hire them have illegals of their own family on the farm.
Rational Thinker Yes, and if you are from Europe, it is impossible to get such a visa in Canada. On the other hand, young Canadians here are so lazy, that what farmer told you, is true. Accidentally, my husband works for dairy industry. Nobody wants to work here in BC, Canada, except Philipinos, and East Indians. It is a mystery to me, how can they get work permits and permanent residency, with mostly no English and significant lack of skills. And officially, one can get work permit only in so called skilled position, so people cheat together with their employers. And immigration knows it, governement knows it. But they will not change the rules... That is how great Canada is. For person from Europe it is incredibly hard, we get permits only for 1 year... Ironically, now we sell Canadians milking robots designed and made in Europe, so even the last workers will get out of their jobs... Country abandoned God, and He gave it up to its wicked desires....
I'm a Republican but if these people are doing nothing other than helping our economy grow and staying out of trouble, Why not keep them here? Everyone has the right to accomplish the American dream.
We can't make laws based around feelings. Just because you feel the Mexicans are good doesn't mean they shouldn't follow the rules. If you come in the country illegal. You get deported.. End of story.
Thatguyuknow2550 I understand that but if we deport all these Hard working ppl our economy will decrease and both of us know that most Americans won't do these type of jobs.
+Max Max you literally heard the americans that were being asked jobs xD do you really expect them to do these types of jobs ? im not trynna be rude but Americans have a better chance of doing something much better than farming or doing these basic jobs, they have much more knowleadge to realize that they have education i dont think they would be aiming for jobs like these, i literally hate the people saying that Mexicans are taking American's jobs when in reality they are much more capable of doing other better things then farming..
+Max Max America is progressing into a better and possibly futuristic country i highly doubt Americans wouldve done the job, if mexicans were not there, let me remind you Mexicans have been here since the 1980's or even longer, yes americans wouldve done the job, but wouldnt be payed as much as other jobs that require as much education. If you are supposing that Americans wouldve done the job they wouldnt mainly because they would be interested other type of jobs that would be paid more.
Give it a rest Ella. I came from a middle class white family and started working on a dairy when I was 15. I started buy pushing cows. The worst job on the dairy. Before it was illegal Mexicans it was Portuguese people like myself that worked the dairy farms - legal Portuguese people. I repeat LEGAL. The work gets done but it does not have to be illegals.
None None ok? Then say those illegals get deported would y’all take those jobs? No bc u just said it doesn’t pay well. Might as well leave those jobs to the illegals bc no one else will take them
Wow. Such an amazing documentary. My respect and gratitude for all farm and agriculture worker. God bless and protect you guys. Thank you for all your hard work
Although immigrants are well over represented, the majority of US livestock workers (unlike crop workers) are actually US born and the majority are white. This video is propaganda. Dairy is also unhealthy to humans and the conditions on these farms are horrific and crule. They need to go out of business or be shut down. Time to go vegan, there are many good alternatives now to dairy, there is no excuse!
@@jKLa So what does vegan taste like? I can raise my own meat and raise a big garden to feed myself. I can raise and milk my own goats and make cheese, ice cream and anything else that I want. The only problem is the federal government letting in all these illegal aliens who take jobs from locals. I was paid $13 an hour at my last dairy and had all the extra spending money I could want. Country people will work these jobs, but not if hordes of illegals are just allowed to stroll across the border like it is a casual Sunday picnic. The government can stop them at the border, or we can stop them right here in the USA. Ours requires double 00 buck and is permanent.
I'm proud of my dad. Thanks to his hard work in agricultural he was able to get papers during Bill Clintons time. If it wasn't for that I probably wouldn't have been born in the states.
Bowzy Minnesoldier so we are on the same side? Well that changes my perception a little, but what will Biden offer? Just seems like a shill for the establishment
@@AssassinPictures Nobody forced them illegal immigrants to take these jobs. Jesus, you sound like a feminist who makes it like the government made laws specifically telling how the female sex should behave.
We need all the inmates in the jail eating free food from tax payers to work on these dairy farms & other agri-jobs in tight security!!! and send Mexicans their homes!! That way Inmates will have some money to spend when they get out of jail.
Speaking as someone who worked at a cannery in Upstate New York for over ten years, I want to commend you on this documentary. I have nothing but respect for the hispanic guys that worked for me. Believe me when I tell you, we hired as many local people as we could, but mostly they didn't last long enough to make it worth while. Personally, I think we owe these people better than a quick trip to the border.
Yea? How much are they being paid? A living wage? Probably not, they hire them and pay them under minimum wage. If u hire locals u would have to pay them more. It’s win win for the farmers…
Broski !. I used meth because if I said weed dealer or prostitute to many people would have said yes, we should let it slide and I wanted to get a NO in people's head. 2. This is a nonsensical statement. If you are in the country illegally and working illegally then you are a criminal. That you have not yet been arrested and convicted for this or any other crime yet is meaningless.
+aCycloneSteve Then your laws need a reform. And you may want to read this article: www.wsj.com/articles/small-businesses-lament-there-are-too-few-mexicans-in-u-s-not-too-many-1480005020 The world ain't black and white.
Yeah... Much respect to those who steal American Jobs!!! And don't pull the "But Dairy Farms are hard work" Bullshit. I worked on a dairy farm from when I was sixteen, until I was twenty three.
Harrison Lawson did you see the video? "Much respect to those who steal American Jobs" watch the video again when the commentator was asking people without jobs if they wanted to work in a dairy farm.
"If there is work, I'll start tomorrow." - Old school American/modern day immigrant. "Work? LOL. Let's talk about how much money I will make, then maybe I'll work." - modern day American
Cause literally any job back then ensured you could go to school feed your family and buy a home, minimum wage back then was literally worth much more than it is now and while minimum wage has barely increased to maybe double or triple since the 60s or 70s, college has increased by more than 1000% as well as housing and general products have gone through crazy rises while wages have barely moved and minimum wage isnt even close to a living wage like it was then.
@Victor V Taco Bell was actually an American idea, Mexican food is actually goat balls and cow tails. Sorry to destroy your fantasy, but I would have to agree about them being hard workers, probably all them balls they eat.
@@brianandlynphilippines sorry to destroy ur fantasy but it looks like your idea of Mexican food comes from watching some exotic food documentary or something. Mexico has amazing food mostly based on meat, baked bread, cheese and fresh vegetables. Taco bell is an American variation of Mexican food but it's not extremely far from the real deal. No Mexican eats goat balls or cow tails on a regular basis. Those dishes exist mostly as an exotic thing in small towns in the countryside. You will not go into the Hilton Mexico City buffet and find goat balls, u will be greeted with fresh made tortillas, beans, avocados and the such
My mom and step father both work at a dairy farm, and every sunday I help them work 3-6 hours depending on who I help, to be honest it's not as hard as they make it sound. All you need to do is learn the routine and use clothes you don't mind getting dirty, sure in the beginning it might be difficult but after 1 or 2 months you'll find it easy. Plus most modern farms have metal gaurds preventing you from getting kicked, and there is usually a trough where it collects most of the shit and piss
@Nitro Eagle And expensive. And confusing. And most immigrant workers can't qualify to begin with. GTFO with that "took the time to get their citizenship".
@@anthonyharding6051 "took their time"... shit about 21 years of illegal working waiting on their child to help them out and over $10,000 in lawyer fees... We're all taking our time... Man we gonna work and no one is gonna stop us
"But hard jobs, only Mexicans do them.". This is so true. If there was an easier way for immigrants to become legal, these "low wage jobs" would be guaranteed to be taken care of.
That's untrue. The Puerto Rican guy said yes he will, but you think hey will hire him, no they won't. I'm Puerto Rican and work darn hard, but they prefer to hire Mexicans instead.
I'm a Mexican American (2nd/3rd generation; Americanized) and I agree with the one Mexican guy. Without Hispanics there won't be many farms running, and the US would starve. To those who argue against this watch the movie "A Day Without a Mexican" it will change your opinion if you're open to it.
The only reason we NEED immigrant workers is because most food comes from huge corporations, which as he said makes even family owned farms need to operate like a mill to stay competitive. If we could reverse what's happened with our food sources and stop relying on big corporations to feed us, we could go back to more smaller, local farms producing better goods. The farmers I know that still work in this way enjoy what they do. It's a life style, and they don't require mexican laborers.
Clarence notagangsta my Mexican grandparents came here legally and are in their 60s, they had three children. My great grandparents I have no idea, they moved to Ohio before I was even conceived. Also dude STFU, don't make this into a racial argument, because you know nothing about Mexicans or Hispanics.
The Myans.......I'm doing personal research on them currently getting my knowledge up on raising my consciousness and other escoteric knowings.....It's bewildering how things have shifted...... I know what happened 😶.....got damn earth invaders😥 and I'mma leave it at that.
"If you are on one side of the street with nothing and the other side of the street has everything, why can't you cross the street" That was an awesome quote that sums up undocumented immigration perfectly. We need an economic system that allows everyone an equal chance to succeed, not just those who are fortunate enough to be born with excellent circumstances.
Kidd Kulture Why do you need to take it to such extremes? It is not "everyone", trust me not everyone wants to come to America, stop deluding yourself and stop aggrandizing the situation. Like Raphael said the Unites States needs to start working as equals with other countries to solve these issues. I would really recommend you read up on what the United States has done to Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala.
I am not for open borders but there needs to be serious immigration reform that keeps bad people out and let people that are actual assets in. Farm workers are among the most valuable immigrants that come here from Mexico and South America. Farmers in Alabama are going out of business due to strong immigration laws and the lack of American's willing to do these jobs or even capable of doing them. It is the usual lack of action in congress to correct these problems and further proof that the Government should be widely privatized to be more productive and accountable. In politics we have to wait and hope to vote incompetent people out, in non Government run business you perform or you get replaced immediately. What a concept !
Jeffrey Binder We natives Americans were not for open borders either but Europeans just forced themselves into the out land! We felt sorry for you and look how we got paid!
Jeffrey Binder um did you hear how the republican led senate let the immigration bill die??? Privatization is the source of most problems in government. Remember when they said they have to fill the quotas in the prisons with undocumented workers... Have you heard of private prisons? It is private corps that benefit the most from the cheap labor of undocumented migrants. It is the privatization of major government sectors that has let the intention to make money and fill in in quotas the main mission in institutions that were supposed to benefit the public. Privatization is definitely not the answer.
Yeah, I agree. We should focus right now on sorting through illegal immigrants that are already here, deporting felons and criminals while providing a way for (otherwise) law-abiding, tax-paying immigrants to stay. It's silly for ICE to deport people who work, people who contribute to the economy of the United States.
I dont get how people say immigrants steal their jobs😂 even with the more popular jobs like construction there is always a demand for more construction workers
sandythebear more than half of US states age on consent is 16, with some " special circumstance " down to 14,15 years old such as Indiana. Just sayin...
This is so true my family has a dairy and crop farm and it's so hard to find good workers to milk. My farm milks 24 hours a day and we just hire Mexicans because they are just a little more reliable than Americans. I would like to see congress pass a year long visa that will allow Mexicans to work on the farms
Kyle Price as you can see theirs alot of misinformation going on around about farmers and immigrant workers and the simple fact is more amerikans feeling of entitlement to the land is the reason they dont want hispanics here even if their productive citizens
HoneyBee He says he wants workers on a visa. That comes with a set minimum wage ($12/hr in my state) and they are required to provide housing and transportation to work. That's a sweet deal.
derty churchtablet - Who's fault is that? The answer is our freaking government. You can't have it both ways: pay them shit then complain about their salary going overseas. If you want them to spend their hard earned money, why don't you bring their family here lol
and I'm proud of my American people finally waking up to this problem. murica is slowly turning into a enlightened nation that won't just take what the government is doing to our neighbors and own people.
Mexicans are just like pakistanis, pakistanis are doing hard work in the middle east a truly difficult job that it really needs physical strenght wherein arabs and white americans cant do that kind of job. God these people
@@Starfish6 - Is that 8.25 + tips? I'm sure that even housekeepers and dishwashers in Vegas are making more than that, but cocktails, waitresses, cashiers, and slot techs wages are basically working for tips, and not necessarily on their wages.
I have an idea. Take these young energetic homeless people and put them to work. They would gladly take a job that gives money doesn't require a college education and provides housing. They could work and grow to become better educated and have better jobs. We don't need illegal people taking American jobs and I'm not trying to be rude to any illegal people but it's not helping America having them. Less illegals=less homeless=better economy.
Homeless Americans don't even want to do that kind of job. I know some people who are hurting for a job and are still picky as to what they get. It's America, land of the lazy and excuses. The illegals will work a lot harder than an American. No offense to my country, but the truth hurts.
Did you not watch the documentary from 2:36? Americans are too lazy and too proud to do the "dirty" jobs. So what makes you think a homeless individual would want to work? They're homeless for a reason.
The truth is most of these dairy farms are owned by rich families that do not want to pay a liveable wage or offer any kind of benefits for their local communities citizens. They would rather pay under the table and continue to be essentially slave masters.
This is neither a pro or con, just sharing an experience: I come from a large American city. Many years ago I l moved to a rural area, there are many farms...but nowhere near a boarder. I noticed that there was a large illegal population. I wondered where do they come from? How do they get here? One day when sharing some comments of co-workers with a friend. The friend said to me. If they weren't here, who would pick our vegetables? We have degrees, are you going to take that type of job? Our kids get allowances. They aren't going to do it. Even if they take a summer job they will look for something like a sales associate in a store or fast food at the very least. So again, I ask you, how would the farmers survive? How would we get affordable vegetables to eat? I just looked at my friend, thinking...he's biased cause he's a vegetarian. But later when I gave it more thought, I had no answer. I still have no answer. It's not just dairy, it's farming in general.
It's the age old question. If all illegal / undocumented workers in the US were removed, your pint of milk, your pound of beef, your apple and whatever is in your grocery stores will either skyrocket in price OR not be available.
Is not just farming and agriculture, also restaurants, hotels, landscaping, painting, framing, concrete work, insulation, swimming pool building, irrigation and any hard job out there they're the majority of the labor. Did I forget anything?
学好得哥哥! 西班牙裔女孩很可爱。 Learn it well, man. Latinos are the kinest people. Mexican girls are super cute too! ^^ Aprendele bien, hermano. Los latinos son gente mas amable y simpatica. Chicas mexicanas son lindisima tambien ^^
Americans in 2019: I want a job that pays a starting salary of $75k and a bunch of awesome perks. Employer: Okay, but you need a college degree for this position. Americans in 2019: No! College is for losers and is too expensive. Give me money! God bless America... P.S. I worked in recruiting for a Fortune 50 company and this interaction happened at least once a week.
@@maritimemisfits3360 Not really. The software engineers at my company work their standard 9 hours along with unlimited time off. Depends on the industry and company.
i love how milking is described as the worst job... milking is nothing compared to having to pick a field by hand, or anything else physical in farming. i loved my milking shifts sometimes; nobody bothers you, monotonous and goes by fast, and it's just you and a buncha cows.
Ice is for immigrants but I agree there should be more effort for real criminals and not people working to put food on the table for their families and also non violent
is this an invitation to break into your country and deny paying taxes ? i mean your not the first who mentioned this in the chat and since the other ones told me I am welcome as an ilegal alien if i am white.....
Misato Blushing Europe is a conquesting country. Opposite of countries that have been conquested. The long term effects of that still linger in those conquested countries, with corrupt system based on color, class and status still affect the average person. England did not pioneer world wide drug trafficking. Latin America did and in return grew so strong the government is conflicting with them and some meso systems controlled by drug cartels. Then you have American interventions which didn’t happen in Europe because US wanted to focus on neighboring countries such a starting revolutions with in Latin countries and training their military to so they may place other political figures in office that will do what The US wants and so on. Look at Nicaragua, Panama, Mexico “disposable workers” and so on to understand the long term effects of a conquested and Intervened countries and people that also has a serious issue with Gangs and Drugs.....yeah try being a hard worker there... they get overlooked by media but never take their situation for granted thus Latinos have a large handwork ethic distilled within them due to political, societal, economic, historical, and Cultural factors. Especially here in the US
@maga guy his fucking DOGE died , thatts why he is sad but dont worry those dumbass wil feel better as soon the next video starts.... or what i think about hobbypoliticans..
@@matthiaskonold6976 So they can't "afford" to pay more so they get to get away with low pay and threat of turning illegals in if they complain about work conditions..COME ON!!!
Oh it very much matters, although illegals come in all skin colors, the assumption made here and in all these films, media outcries, etc. is that illegals are brown. So, although skin color doesn't matter to us white guys, it is very definitely important to those with an agenda, and it helps to be able to hate one skin color (white) while bonding as another skin color, say, brown.
My Grandmother was a German immigrant. She came here during WW2‚ as a child‚ by herself‚ and had no money. Guess what she came here legally. If she could come here legally then Hispanics should come here legally.
TheMexikingisback2 Wow great job at being racist. Not all Germans are Nazis you idiot. Guess what my grandmother went through that slow tedious process. Also the US was built off of European and Asian immigrants.
RagedLemon My uncle by marriage has owned a business for years. Even when he was illegal he payed taxes through his wife who was legal. I guarantee you that 99% of illegal business owners pay taxes and there are A LOT of illegal business owners in the US
RagedLemon all the time! They use whats called TIN numbers and also pay state and sales tax u fucking imbecil. If you dont know about the issue stop talking about it.
The margin of profit is very thin. About once every ten years there is a price boom. Some farms pay a bonus when they get money but don't want to pay more because the next price bust is around the corner and lasts for a few years.
They would have to pay more if these people didn't lower the wage. I am sure some americans would do it if they got $15 and hour. You can get better job for $9 an hour. Work at Walmart, Target or any store and you get $9 or more with benefits if you are full time.
The dairy work is awesome I do it during the summer and I do it at school (farming school) You do get covered in shit but you get used to it. I would rather work in a dairy farm than being in a classroom for sure and I do both so....
Joel Cineros. Then let make their own countries work. Why aren't they fixing them? Why is America supposed to do what Mexico and the rest of Latin America should be doing for it's own people?
@@johnmcdonald9304 because America is land of the free... One of the most diverse countries in the world... Idk why yall dont attack against Cubans that step foot on this land and become legal then get all the American benefits like walefare and leave to their country to spend it asap... While these guys and almost every American citizen work until near their ending point... I've always wondered how a cuban could afford a nice brick house in a middle class neighborhood with a really nice leather interior car and sit at a Miami coffee shop all day... But if what y'all want is an all white America good luck
I honestly don't know how hard it is to become an actual citizen of the United States but why don't the owners of the company or whatever help them become legal?
What is amazing to me is whenever you watch one of these videos it is all about farm work. Like you have twenty or thirty million people doing farm work.Go into some of the warehouses or manufactory Companies and see who has those jobs.Americans don't have those jobs because they do not advertise when they need help.they will tell an illegal to bring a friend or family member. Who do you think did these jobs before.
All the is "needed" is a Foreign Guest Worker Program like the old "Bracero program" of WW2 to 1964, but the farmers back then were abusing the workers, so it was abolished. The Greedy USA businesses really love Undocumented because they keep the wages low, cannot be on Strike, and never complain. You have to Legally Immigrate with a Visa first, so you can Reside & Work. 5 years later, an Immigrant can Naturalize ( becoming US citizen ) if passes more tests & background. **** To just work, in USA, does not require Greencard or US citizenship. Just a Work Permit, Fingerprints, Health check. Having a work sponsor would be smart.
After 9/11, the path to citizenship became harder. However, company owners CAN help their immigrant workers obtain a green card IF the immigrant had started a green card application back before April 30, 2001 and have proof that they were present in the US before that. This part of the law is "Section 245(i)"...look it up for more details. It will take a few years before they receive their green card. So, many immigrants do not qualify under that. There is currently no other law for immigrants who entered illegally that allows a path to citizenship. Children of these immigrants have DACA as an option when they're older, which is a work permit, but is NOT a path to citizenship. But with Trump trying to undo everything the Obama administration did, I don't know where DACA will end up.
@@YACABE Bill Clinton passed IRAIIRA in 1996 so Illegal Entry after that date cannot Adjudicate to Immigrant status, that is why the DACA people are stuck, for now.
30 years ago nobody thought that china would be an economic power house, you may underestimate mexico and its people but it is becoming an economic power house of its own right, look at how many manufacturing company's are moving there.
Mexico is becoming a western nation, but it doesn't have the ingredients needed for it to become an economic power house, sorry, It's population is too small, and the government is still corrupt, they elected AMLO, but he's a populist who's probably not going to get a lot done. Mexico also is starting to get into service and the tech sectors, so manufacturing might disappear as quickly as it appeared, but you couldn't know for certain.
@Salvadore Andretti ohh little do you know the Mexican gov has a very strong grip they allow the corruption to happen and the corruption they dont want ends up dissolving pretty quickly
That's rather pathetic. You're unemployed but you won't take a job that requires any real work. Should we really feel sorry for the unemployed in our country?
I'm not American but looking at the pay for the amount of work they have to do is really shitty and do they get any benefits that comes with that? Probably not. If the pay isn't worth the work why bother?
Animurh My point being: there are jobs available but Americans would rather sit at home and collect unemployment while they complain about not being able to find jobs with their degree in art history or English lit.
The United States is statistically one of the hardest working countries in the world much more so than European countries but the hard working poor can't escape poverty because the odds stacked against them. This whole "the harder you work the better your life will be" is a lie.
its funny if there's employers to hire why not give this mexicans a legal working visa,this is done here on canada,we dont have illegal workers but we have workers from different country but they have working visa as long there's employers to hire ,that's the laws in canada
Hey dummy, get the fat out of your ears and listen to the video. It clearly states in America for farm work there are only seasonal visas not full year visas which is what most farms need. This was filmed in America, about American policy. How crazy is it that CANADIAN is different, almost like theyre two separate countries.
Somnivers Certain factors come up as to why they have difficulty learning English: - Some communities do not have adequate facilities for immigrants and recent arrivals to teach them the English language and provide services for them (e.g. job hunting, obtaining driver's licenses, child care support, etc.) - Their lack of or limited amount of documentation could cause them to pay significantly more to be educated at a community college, and with the pressure of feeding their families, they have little to no recourse but to work long hours - Their long work hours mean they do not have adequate time to be with their families or spend time reading books; instead, many keep the unending eat-work-sleep pattern every single day without a day or two to spend quality time with their children and partners And since our Congress has been way too slow, if not ignorant, on the issue of immigration reform, then people need to vote those incompetent politicians out of office in the next election. Those Congress members who are against immigration reform are the same people who continue to subsidize the oil and banking industries for their own wealth accumulation rather than helping out immigrants wanting to live better lives in the country.
Anthony Nachor Agreed,there are multiple factors ,it's a complex problem.But,16 years in US and not able to speak some basic English is just insane.I know immigrants are having a hard time and they work many hours ,I do appreciate those people who work hard jobs.But I just can't imagine living in a country so much time and not speaking some basic language,no language is that hard to learn in 16 years.To me that just shows lack of interest in the respective country's culture.
Anthony Nachor A plausible reason for me is that most Americans don't want to do those jobs so Mexicans only interact with each other at work .Their bosses speak Spanish to them so that's that.At home they also speak Spanish ,that's normal.I've seen this before in Spain , where people who worked there for 7-8 years were not able to say anything in Spanish.
They are being interviewed. They probably do know very basic English but in order to have a conversation about the topic they are speaking their mother tongue.
They can earn living at home... Where do poor uneducated Americans need to sneak in to improve their standard of living? Laws matter. America and Americans first.
I am a Chinese. My family and I immigrated to America in 1963, from Hong Kong legally. I was 9 years old then. I am the only one in the family did not become a citizen, therefore, my status remained as a permanent resident, I was arrested and convicted, did my time but ICE wanted to deport me but can't. Now, I am literally stuck in NYC with no paper. A man without a country and I thought I was a citizen of the world. Oh America the beautiful. Yeah right! :-)
***** And how should he leave the country without papers? Or enter any other for that matter? He also does not have a right to a refugee status in Europe. Just watch Airport with Tom Hanks.
Yeah, it’s the same story with other jobs that are labor-intensive. I am saddened by the fact that we treat these people like criminals when in reality they are carrying our economy on their backs.
That’s because the pay went from $20/hr with benefits, to $10/hr no benefits. Your Cuban friend is used to 50 cents a day, he’ll take just about anything.
Buy yourself 500 cows, buy the milking equipment, buy the feed equipment, and the machinery to grow the feed, pay to build the facility, pay all the taxes, and then come back and say YOU can afford to pay someone $15 an hour plus benifits to get a product with a very slim profit margin.
@@CRAFTSMANFISHING You are 100% right Santos. MOST people also don't think in a case like any livestock operation, especially milking, it's 24/7 365 twice a day. Yes, even Christmas and your birthday lol. And on time, if you're an hour late to milk or feed, production drops drastically. Unfortunately very few people realize these things and would put up with it. Even though I personally think everyone should pay the fair share on taxes like we all do who are citizens, even if the amount isn't fair to the working person, I won't bash the immigrants doing the work most english people think they are above doing.
Really. Kenya is free?? Kenya is so poor and I see how they would love to get out of there.TBH even low income Americans live better than a even middle class Kenya.
@@westmax8491 Kenya is one of the best countries in Africa and in the world, yes there are problems of poor governance but atleast we can afford 3meals a day and a roof over our heads and clothes on our skin,plus u don't have to worry about a white folk discriminating you or tracking your ass down to deport you. These are few of the freedom I am talking about.
@@lukasochola576 best country? Botwana Namibia Cape verse Seychelles and maybe Ghana are way better than Kenya. Also just found Kenya has the largest slum in the continent and also by quantity. That means not many kenyans meet their basic needs. I could give you credit if you said Kenya is the best in eastern Africa.
And then you have to pay more for milk. It creates a chain pricing increase. Now, if the owner pays more would Americans do it? I do not think so plus all the complaining they would do...
@@cecarblanco9933 Business is in the business of finding the lowest labor cost. If you can get get people who will work for half the cost you will. If your competition does this illegally so will you to compete. The business of business is not altruism. If no one is available to work at such a low rate you and your competition must pay more to obtain the necessary labor. Romain lettuce is about $1.50. They could double it and no one would think twice buying it. I've worked in the farming industry, in canneries. There were plenty of law abiding U.S. citizens earning a wage with benefits, legally.
This is ridiculous. The American farming industry is so profit-driven that quality in the workplace is so bad, few people will do the farm work. I live in Canada, where there are regulations preventing these FACTORY FARMS from being created. Is profit so important to any agricultural business that we need to reduce quality of food AND the workplace, not to mention adding SAFETY concerns? The lack of any protection from workplace hazards is an issue that has been addressed outside of America. Why is the USA running factory farms like third world countries with no regulations to protect the quality of their products AND the safety of workers? I don't blame anyone who refuses this work because of the lack of safety (kicking of the cows, slips trips falls, contamination, falling objects). I worry about those who take on these jobs, which have taken form of a third-world style oversight in a first world country. Ask yourself, how do you think farms in Britain, France, and Spain operate without taking advantage of undocumented workers like in the USA?
@@edmondcromwell5491 most Agricultural work done in Spain is done by moroccans in particular and many of them are illegals. France also uses illegal work force but to a lesser extent than it's the case in Spain or Italy ( even Greece). Kids in Europe won't do Agri and farming work any more and I'm talking about places like andalucia in Spain. Illegals are a necessity over there. I know because I used to be an illegal person working fields in southern Spain. It a back breaking job in very hot temperatures. Europeans in general are past that sort of " corvèe" like the french say. I just wish people were just a bit civil in their hatred to illegals. Just think about walking in their shoes for a moment and try to contemplate the choices you have. A life stuck between a rock and a hard place, because of a lottery of where and with color or race you were born into, in witch you had no say.
My Grandson works part time at a Dairy farm in Massachusetts and loves the job, no complaint from him. He went to Smith Vocational HS and isnt afraid to get his hands dirty
some people can't get past the fact that these guys have brown skin and speak spanish. they are morons and proud of it. if deporting all of the illegal immigrants ends up hurting the usa economy in a big way and they are able to see it then it still wouldn't matter to them.
At the end of the video, you mention the key points of the video. One being “they have no way to enter the country legally” I honestly want to hear why that is, or more behind that. How is the legal process not even an option for these people?
1. My family had a dairy farm for hundreds of years in NYS, and never once hired anybody from outside the local area. 2. What is being featured here is a factory farm, and many of them are owned by Chinese companies.
Really? I don’t know an awful lot about American dairy farming, but I do know a lot about dairy farming in general, and I’d bet that they’re all family owned and run farms
its a *normal* job AREOUND the WORLD you are just spooked because u didnt notice how u entered a left extrimist media outlet bubble next time PLEASE read first in the videodescription if its a documentary or political propaganda !
I find it very amusing that many people in this comment section are giving so much credit to Spanish speakers who say they can start immediately, praising the hard-working immigrants, despite the fact that they say they are from Puerto Rico, which would make them American.
INFORMATION TO ALL!! This was filmed and created under the Obama Administration. It was published to TH-cam in 2014. Also if I am not mistaken Dairy Farms are now able to get work Visa workers for their labor force. This is old just as a reminder.
Immigration is extremely controversial right now as the Trump administration is keeping preschool children in "tender age" detention centers.
Watch more: bit.ly/2K9jrp8
VICE News that's better than being in Mexico
VICE News it's the fucking law because Obama was getting shit for having kids in the detention centers at first. It's like a day care center.
I wish more people knew the stories, thank you so much ViceNews for this...here is Nelson Pinos, they say New Haven CT is a Sanctuary City but it is not, who could live like this facebook.com/ULANewHaven/videos/1945484762182808/?hc_ref=ARSZmo1TZXvUErvmIERM5lPdFV6yW6x7ERYfuVO55PbGGd55XKhzc4_YhHzel32TlMk
trump you are doing a good job
They don't want to put the children in detention centers that's why they are separating the children and taking them to housing were children go when both parents get arrested for a crime. They are damned either way , if they don't separate the families they are bad for putting children in detention centers, if they separate the children so they don't have to be in a detention center they are bad. Trump administration did not start this whole thing , enforcing the law yeah ,but they never started it. Its proven Obama's administration deported more illegal immigrants then any other President in American history and most the pictures of the detention centers posted everywhere are from 2014 under the Obama administration. The only difference between Obama's administration and Trumps is that Trump was vocal about it when Obama did it silently.
"They steal our jobs!"
"K. U wanna work that job?"
"No it's too hard and dirty"
.......
Id work it for a decent wage. Thats the only thing stopping Americans from taking these jobs. Also the desperate illegal immigrant that comes strolling in will take a lower wage and no bennefitts and the employers know this and take advantage of it. It should be more strictly enforced by law enforcement
But we already have 800,000 illegal DACA! Why aren't the 800K DACA doing these jobs! 800,000 DACA is enough to milk cow!! Where are they? They said they come here to do jobs we don't want to do!
@dennisestrada75 You're the fool being fooled by the illegal DACA! DACA are illegals that came here when they were young and now they are 18 to 30 years old. So they are technically ILLEGALS, and illegals said they come here to do jobs Americans don't want to do like "milking the cow". These illegal DACA want to go to college to steal good-paying jobs from the legal residents and Americans!
Meanwhile this little Dane grew up with cattle n goats and horses, donkies, etc.
I am fucking astounded that people do not want to milk cattle for a living, its the EASIEST fuckin job on the planet! Well provided the cow dont kick you xD
Not to mention that you can get fresh quality milk and cremes before its destroyed by machinery, and you can feed the local cat...
seriously, why on earth is this not a popular line of work for unemployed US citizens? Is the pay bad? I am genuinely curious because I think I can find a solution!
@@forbidden1086 Spoken like a true idiot. Why is it that all ppl who speak this ignorance are actually ignorant. Learn to spell then come back. When they had become more strict on "illegals" working these jobs, farmers were left with no workers. So then they offered to increase wages upt to over 15/hr. and americans still wouldn't take the job. If ppl are upset that they take such low wages, be mad at the owners who actually hire and maintain these low wages. Which in turn actually keep America's food cost down. If you don't want hispanics here or working, don't eat, occupy any building or home made by hispanics, etc.
You can see the shame in the former ICE officer's eyes when he talks about what he did.
Andrew Kepson no there wasn’t
Can you mark the time that you see shame?
@@DalV He even said it himself. Dirty numbers
typical lower human
first bitching their way up the police career ladder
than complaining after retirement because he fears his imagine of god
*WHAT* *A* *WEAK* *PERSON*
Let the workers work. Fill your "quota prison beds" with real criminals! Oh wait, it's hard to fight real criminals, much easier to round up poor workers.
But we already have 800,000 illegal DACA! Why aren't the 800K DACA doing these jobs! 800,000 DACA is enough to milk cow!! Where are they? They said they come here to do jobs we don't want to do!
Why not use your prisoners to do the work?...prisons are full!
@@alwayslearning7672 You're right! We have over 1 million prisoners and they're not doing anything so let them milk the cow to pay back to society.
@@thetruths7389 u two are fucked up in the head. These are people u are talking about, prisoners and illegal immigrants are people just like u. Slavery was abolished a long time ago, u cannot force someone to do a job. It goes against human rights. Human as in humanity, people u know
@@alwayslearning7672 u two are fucked up in the head. These are people u are talking about, prisoners and illegal immigrants are people just like u. Slavery was abolished a long time ago, u cannot force someone to do a job. It goes against human rights and humanity itself
In Canada our produce farms are staffed by Mexican workers who come on temporary work visas. One farmer told me he’d go out of business without them so it’s not just an American thing.
That's the difference between the Canadian immigration system and US immigration system. One makes more sense than the other.
@Rational Thinker. It's neat to hear the point of view from our neighbor to the north.
Claudia A. Valencia From a friend of mine that translates for a lot of these workers, and they people that hire them here in BC, treat them like sub humans. Garbage. It’s ironic, because most of the said farmers that hire them have illegals of their own family on the farm.
& i taugh canada was part of this continent
Rational Thinker
Yes, and if you are from Europe, it is impossible to get such a visa in Canada. On the other hand, young Canadians here are so lazy, that what farmer told you, is true. Accidentally, my husband works for dairy industry. Nobody wants to work here in BC, Canada, except Philipinos, and East Indians. It is a mystery to me, how can they get work permits and permanent residency, with mostly no English and significant lack of skills. And officially, one can get work permit only in so called skilled position, so people cheat together with their employers. And immigration knows it, governement knows it. But they will not change the rules... That is how great Canada is. For person from Europe it is incredibly hard, we get permits only for 1 year... Ironically, now we sell Canadians milking robots designed and made in Europe, so even the last workers will get out of their jobs... Country abandoned God, and He gave it up to its wicked desires....
"Si hay trabajo, manana mismo" "If there is work, I'll start tomorrow". That's the spirit
Well hello there...lol
Major PainDiaz they had no choice idiot. How do you compare what is happening now to the past
Massiel U ese boricua no dura una semana ahí. Jajaja son bien flojos
Amigo Kandu la verdad me causa risa la forma que escribes. Te la voy a pasar pinché in alfabeto 😂🤣😂🤣😂
Amigo Kandu no entiendo lo que quieres comunicarme 😂🤣😂🤣😂🖕🏿🖕🏿🖕🏿🖕🏿😂😂🤣😂🤣😂lo voy a poner en Google translate 🤣
I'm a Republican but if these people are doing nothing other than helping our economy grow and staying out of trouble, Why not keep them here? Everyone has the right to accomplish the American dream.
first republican statment i like
We can't make laws based around feelings. Just because you feel the Mexicans are good doesn't mean they shouldn't follow the rules. If you come in the country illegal. You get deported.. End of story.
Thatguyuknow2550 I understand that but if we deport all these Hard working ppl our economy will decrease and both of us know that most Americans won't do these type of jobs.
+Max Max you literally heard the americans that were being asked jobs xD do you really expect them to do these types of jobs ? im not trynna be rude but Americans have a better chance of doing something much better than farming or doing these basic jobs, they have much more knowleadge to realize that they have education i dont think they would be aiming for jobs like these, i literally hate the people saying that Mexicans are taking American's jobs when in reality they are much more capable of doing other better things then farming..
+Max Max America is progressing into a better and possibly futuristic country i highly doubt Americans wouldve done the job, if mexicans were not there, let me remind you Mexicans have been here since the 1980's or even longer, yes americans wouldve done the job, but wouldnt be payed as much as other jobs that require as much education. If you are supposing that Americans wouldve done the job they wouldnt mainly because they would be interested other type of jobs that would be paid more.
Everyone who says, "Those damn illegals are stealing our jobs!" should watch this.
I totally agree with u.especially all those trump supporters
Give it a rest Ella. I came from a middle class white family and started working on a dairy when I was 15. I started buy pushing cows. The worst job on the dairy. Before it was illegal Mexicans it was Portuguese people like myself that worked the dairy farms - legal Portuguese people. I repeat LEGAL. The work gets done but it does not have to be illegals.
fuck off jimmy you were probably 15 during WW2, the world has changed fucker
the work obviously doesnt get done without them, otherwise it wouldn't be a problem. you can't just be ignorant and blind your entire life
EllaSnow I commend those who do this. I couldn't stomach it even if I was poor and desperate.
Respect to the guy at 13:30 for not giving up his friends to be freed
I M they were offering him papers. Big respect
Ge Po i doubt they were going to give him papers.
his loyalty is unmatched
All the illegals I've known growing up would do the same exact thing. There's so much empathy for their fear of getting deported.
naw most likely they would just lie and deport him after he gave up his friends
No one is stealing no one's job.
if you leave something behind someone else will take it. thats life
No one's left anything behind immigrants come in and do it for cheaper, get it correct!!!
a chikkenn Is that a cow? Why aren’t you in the milking process?
tea stop being a smart ass fucking clown
None None and who’s fault is that white government the work is to hard for you any how look at these white people turn down this job get it correct
None None ok? Then say those illegals get deported would y’all take those jobs? No bc u just said it doesn’t pay well. Might as well leave those jobs to the illegals bc no one else will take them
Wow. Such an amazing documentary. My respect and gratitude for all farm and agriculture worker. God bless and protect you guys. Thank you for all your hard work
thank you someone who appreciates the an honest hard working hispanic
amazing no. the dairy industry is pure cruelty: th-cam.com/video/UcN7SGGoCNI/w-d-xo.html
Although immigrants are well over represented, the majority of US livestock workers (unlike crop workers) are actually US born and the majority are white. This video is propaganda.
Dairy is also unhealthy to humans and the conditions on these farms are horrific and crule. They need to go out of business or be shut down. Time to go vegan, there are many good alternatives now to dairy, there is no excuse!
@maga guy No they need to be put out of business dairy is evil. Go vegan to help save the planet and our own future.
@@jKLa So what does vegan taste like? I can raise my own meat and raise a big garden to feed myself. I can raise and milk my own goats and make cheese, ice cream and anything else that I want. The only problem is the federal government letting in all these illegal aliens who take jobs from locals. I was paid $13 an hour at my last dairy and had all the extra spending money I could want. Country people will work these jobs, but not if hordes of illegals are just allowed to stroll across the border like it is a casual Sunday picnic. The government can stop them at the border, or we can stop them right here in the USA. Ours requires double 00 buck and is permanent.
I'm proud of my dad. Thanks to his hard work in agricultural he was able to get papers during Bill Clintons time. If it wasn't for that I probably wouldn't have been born in the states.
Brotologist so vote blue
@@bowzist I have my questions on Joe Biden, I am no Trump supporter, but I have no sympathy to Joe Biden.
i dont see the bigger picture
BUT Hey!
*Bread* & *Games* lets vote for it!
Som Keshav I was more on Andrew or Bernie, not a big fan of Biden or Obama
Bowzy Minnesoldier so we are on the same side? Well that changes my perception a little, but what will Biden offer? Just seems like a shill for the establishment
American: “I need a job”
Guy: “We have some openings on our dairy farm that pay $9 an hour”
American: “Eww not that job”
TheOMGsee so your ok with illegals to be taken advantage of
@@AssassinPictures their not being taken advantage of, they're doing whatever work they can
@@AssassinPictures Nobody forced them illegal immigrants to take these jobs.
Jesus, you sound like a feminist who makes it like the government made laws specifically telling how the female sex should behave.
I want to apply as a dairy farm im a filipino.any want can help me this job?
We need all the inmates in the jail eating free food from tax payers to work on these dairy farms & other agri-jobs in tight security!!! and send Mexicans their homes!! That way Inmates will have some money to spend when they get out of jail.
Speaking as someone who worked at a cannery in Upstate New York for over ten years, I want to commend you on this documentary. I have nothing but respect for the hispanic guys that worked for me. Believe me when I tell you, we hired as many local people as we could, but mostly they didn't last long enough to make it worth while. Personally, I think we owe these people better than a quick trip to the border.
Thank you for saying that, sir.
Yea? How much are they being paid? A living wage? Probably not, they hire them and pay them under minimum wage. If u hire locals u would have to pay them more. It’s win win for the farmers…
9 bucks an hour plus housing? Low pay and low living facilities
In their country that’s a lot, if they can get work in their country that pays 9 bucks an hour, they would not need to come here.
Like family? And pay is 9 bucks an hour?
If they are working and paying taxes why harass them!!
So if a meth dealer pays taxes we should let it slide?
Broski
!. I used meth because if I said weed dealer or prostitute to many people would have said yes, we should let it slide and I wanted to get a NO in people's head.
2. This is a nonsensical statement. If you are in the country illegally and working illegally then you are a criminal. That you have not yet been arrested and convicted for this or any other crime yet is meaningless.
aCycloneSteve well they are not close to doing such bad things they are literally doing nothing wrong
Broski
They are doing nothing wrong, except breaking our laws.
+aCycloneSteve
Then your laws need a reform. And you may want to read this article:
www.wsj.com/articles/small-businesses-lament-there-are-too-few-mexicans-in-u-s-not-too-many-1480005020
The world ain't black and white.
Much respect to the guys in this video, and the ones who are now working in the farm or agricultural industry.
Yeah... Much respect to those who steal American Jobs!!! And don't pull the "But Dairy Farms are hard work" Bullshit. I worked on a dairy farm from when I was sixteen, until I was twenty three.
Harrison Lawson so why did you stop?
Harrison Lawson did you see the video? "Much respect to those who steal American Jobs" watch the video again when the commentator was asking people without jobs if they wanted to work in a dairy farm.
I also saw a women so much respect to the women too
lol you wouldn't work those jobs even if it was available XD
"If there is work, I'll start tomorrow." - Old school American/modern day immigrant.
"Work? LOL. Let's talk about how much money I will make, then maybe I'll work." - modern day American
The Dollar was Gold backed - old school american
The Dollarinflation is a weapon against simple folks - modern america
Some US citizens are just lazy people...
Cause literally any job back then ensured you could go to school feed your family and buy a home, minimum wage back then was literally worth much more than it is now and while minimum wage has barely increased to maybe double or triple since the 60s or 70s, college has increased by more than 1000% as well as housing and general products have gone through crazy rises while wages have barely moved and minimum wage isnt even close to a living wage like it was then.
It's sad that sometimes we forget that "they" or "illegals" are people too
it's sad that you forget that the ones profiting from illegal workers are mostly criminal organizations.
@Victor V Taco Bell was actually an American idea, Mexican food is actually goat balls and cow tails. Sorry to destroy your fantasy, but I would have to agree about them being hard workers, probably all them balls they eat.
@@AdmiralLobeam That's a pretty ignorant thing to say, you moron. Unemployment is a earned benefit, not an entitlement. Learn the fucking difference.
@@brianandlynphilippines sorry to destroy ur fantasy but it looks like your idea of Mexican food comes from watching some exotic food documentary or something. Mexico has amazing food mostly based on meat, baked bread, cheese and fresh vegetables. Taco bell is an American variation of Mexican food but it's not extremely far from the real deal. No Mexican eats goat balls or cow tails on a regular basis. Those dishes exist mostly as an exotic thing in small towns in the countryside. You will not go into the Hilton Mexico City buffet and find goat balls, u will be greeted with fresh made tortillas, beans, avocados and the such
@@brianandlynphilippines yeah, they only eat goat balls in mexico. dum dum
This could all be fixed if Congress would authorize farm labor Visas for dairy farms.
Congress could fix many of the nations problems. Butt their concern is to keep their party in office.
Some guy I worked with said they make them seasonal because if it was year round they would work somewhere else.
jesterd14 temporary work visas would allow workers to travel back and forth for seasonal work.
@@jsnagra1able they already do. In California they bring ppl to work fields. Seasonal..
@@andrestapia7329 the problem is the dairy farm is year round
I salute for everyone working here respect ✊
👍
My mom and step father both work at a dairy farm, and every sunday I help them work 3-6 hours depending on who I help, to be honest it's not as hard as they make it sound. All you need to do is learn the routine and use clothes you don't mind getting dirty, sure in the beginning it might be difficult but after 1 or 2 months you'll find it easy. Plus most modern farms have metal gaurds preventing you from getting kicked, and there is usually a trough where it collects most of the shit and piss
americans: "ooh buddy stop right there. im gunna have to say no on the dairy farm job thanks though!"
Hispanics: orale a chambiar! amonos!
Alexis Sarabia 😂😂😂 órale 👍👍👍👍
Illegal Hispanics yeah. All the Hispanic people that I know that took the time to get their citizenship wouldn't do that shit either
@Nitro Eagle And expensive. And confusing. And most immigrant workers can't qualify to begin with.
GTFO with that "took the time to get their citizenship".
@@anthonyharding6051 "took their time"... shit about 21 years of illegal working waiting on their child to help them out and over $10,000 in lawyer fees... We're all taking our time... Man we gonna work and no one is gonna stop us
@maga guy you coming too
"But hard jobs, only Mexicans do them.". This is so true. If there was an easier way for immigrants to become legal, these "low wage jobs" would be guaranteed to be taken care of.
That's untrue. The Puerto Rican guy said yes he will, but you think hey will hire him, no they won't. I'm Puerto Rican and work darn hard, but they prefer to hire Mexicans instead.
I'm a Mexican American (2nd/3rd generation; Americanized) and I agree with the one Mexican guy. Without Hispanics there won't be many farms running, and the US would starve.
To those who argue against this watch the movie "A Day Without a Mexican" it will change your opinion if you're open to it.
Clarence notagangsta your stupid your whites asses wouldnt do any of the hard ass jobs
What hard jobs? Mexicans do the rejected jobs that Americans don't do!
The only reason we NEED immigrant workers is because most food comes from huge corporations, which as he said makes even family owned farms need to operate like a mill to stay competitive. If we could reverse what's happened with our food sources and stop relying on big corporations to feed us, we could go back to more smaller, local farms producing better goods. The farmers I know that still work in this way enjoy what they do. It's a life style, and they don't require mexican laborers.
Clarence notagangsta my Mexican grandparents came here legally and are in their 60s, they had three children.
My great grandparents I have no idea, they moved to Ohio before I was even conceived.
Also dude STFU, don't make this into a racial argument, because you know nothing about Mexicans or Hispanics.
jcwack FYI, I'm skin colored White (White Hispanic/European Hispanic) so you're just harassing most white Hispanics with the statement.
Nobody
The realist niggaz alive: if there’s work I’ll start Rn
From the Aztec and the Maya to milking cows for those who are truly the immigrants. Such a tragic twist in history.
Dam right most of those illegal are actually native Americans, the brown short ones . It makes it easier calling them Mexican and sending them back
The Myans.......I'm doing personal research on them currently getting my knowledge up on raising my consciousness and other escoteric knowings.....It's bewildering how things have shifted...... I know what happened 😶.....got damn earth invaders😥 and I'mma leave it at that.
:(
"If you are on one side of the street with nothing and the other side of the street has everything, why can't you cross the street"
That was an awesome quote that sums up undocumented immigration perfectly. We need an economic system that allows everyone an equal chance to succeed, not just those who are fortunate enough to be born with excellent circumstances.
Ha, sounds like we agree on a lot of things, man.
Too bad that the republicans in the house have too much downs to see that.
We just cant let everyone from Mexico and Central America come to the USA.
Kidd Kulture It's not everyone dude and even if it was, it would be much easier to control this issue if we just made a North American Union...
Kidd Kulture Why do you need to take it to such extremes? It is not "everyone", trust me not everyone wants to come to America, stop deluding yourself and stop aggrandizing the situation. Like Raphael said the Unites States needs to start working as equals with other countries to solve these issues. I would really recommend you read up on what the United States has done to Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala.
I am not for open borders but there needs to be serious immigration reform that keeps bad people out and let people that are actual assets in.
Farm workers are among the most valuable immigrants that come here from Mexico and South America. Farmers in Alabama are going out of business due to strong immigration laws and the lack of American's willing to do these jobs or even capable of doing them.
It is the usual lack of action in congress to correct these problems and further proof that the Government should be widely privatized to be more productive and accountable. In politics we have to wait and hope to vote incompetent people out, in non Government run business you perform or you get replaced immediately. What a concept !
That would be great it would fix alot of problems
Jeffrey Binder We natives Americans were not for open borders either but Europeans just forced themselves into the out land! We felt sorry for you and look how we got paid!
Jeffrey Binder um did you hear how the republican led senate let the immigration bill die??? Privatization is the source of most problems in government. Remember when they said they have to fill the quotas in the prisons with undocumented workers... Have you heard of private prisons? It is private corps that benefit the most from the cheap labor of undocumented migrants. It is the privatization of major government sectors that has let the intention to make money and fill in in quotas the main mission in institutions that were supposed to benefit the public. Privatization is definitely not the answer.
@maga guy crawl back to your hole troglodyte!
Yeah, I agree. We should focus right now on sorting through illegal immigrants that are already here, deporting felons and criminals while providing a way for (otherwise) law-abiding, tax-paying immigrants to stay. It's silly for ICE to deport people who work, people who contribute to the economy of the United States.
I dont get how people say immigrants steal their jobs😂 even with the more popular jobs like construction there is always a demand for more construction workers
even with undocumented workers We don't have nearly enough
god bless mexico and all my central american people
God bless you men
sandythebear more than half of US states age on consent is 16, with some " special circumstance " down to 14,15 years old such as Indiana. Just sayin...
sandythebear That's all you can come up with ? who ask you?
God Bless all the hardworking people.... and to hell with all the lazy ass people collecting a welfare check who are fully capable of finding a job.
sandythebear At least we don't have 30% percent of people obese
This is so true my family has a dairy and crop farm and it's so hard to find good workers to milk. My farm milks 24 hours a day and we just hire Mexicans because they are just a little more reliable than Americans. I would like to see congress pass a year long visa that will allow Mexicans to work on the farms
I would support that, on a county by county basis. If your county is participating no one can collect unemployment in that county as well.
You think farmers are rich? Most will die in debt.
Kyle Price as you can see theirs alot of misinformation going on around about farmers and immigrant workers and the simple fact is more amerikans feeling of entitlement to the land is the reason they dont want hispanics here even if their productive citizens
HoneyBee He says he wants workers on a visa. That comes with a set minimum wage ($12/hr in my state) and they are required to provide housing and transportation to work. That's a sweet deal.
derty churchtablet - Who's fault is that? The answer is our freaking government. You can't have it both ways: pay them shit then complain about their salary going overseas. If you want them to spend their hard earned money, why don't you bring their family here lol
fuck yeah I'm proud of my people working hard
and I'm proud of my American people finally waking up to this problem. murica is slowly turning into a enlightened nation that won't just take what the government is doing to our neighbors and own people.
Paula Deen but hurt euro poor detected
2:57 smh
These are the jobs were taking from you Trumpies. Go ahead take em.! Wouldnt last a day in my peoples shoes
those fat fucks will collapse beacuse their knees and backs don have cartilages from doing nothing all their lives and will probably get PTSD
Mexicans are just like pakistanis, pakistanis are doing hard work in the middle east a truly difficult job that it really needs physical strenght wherein arabs and white americans cant do that kind of job. God these people
jeff Mantua no Mexicans are not just like Pakistanis or whatever u said lol
Ok just to clarify Miguel Angel is speaking for the illegal Hispanics not the legal Hispanics
@maga guy Latino for AndreYang
$9.00 plus housing? Where do i apply?
Javier R. Castillo contact your local army recruiter
@@drago4671 Ha!
"Huuuuuuuuuuah!"
Javier R. Castillo go out of your way and look for thr job, id like to see you actually work there
I know Americans who are making 8.25 an hour right here in Las Vegas..Im sure Americans will do this job.I know I will.
@@Starfish6 - Is that 8.25 + tips? I'm sure that even housekeepers and dishwashers in Vegas are making more than that, but cocktails, waitresses, cashiers, and slot techs wages are basically working for tips, and not necessarily on their wages.
I have an idea. Take these young energetic homeless people and put them to work. They would gladly take a job that gives money doesn't require a college education and provides housing. They could work and grow to become better educated and have better jobs. We don't need illegal people taking American jobs and I'm not trying to be rude to any illegal people but it's not helping America having them. Less illegals=less homeless=better economy.
Some illegal people have medical issues too
Homeless Americans don't even want to do that kind of job. I know some people who are hurting for a job and are still picky as to what they get. It's America, land of the lazy and excuses. The illegals will work a lot harder than an American. No offense to my country, but the truth hurts.
***** So most Americans are lazy? Then why are we one of the most successful nations in the world?
Did you not watch the documentary from 2:36? Americans are too lazy and too proud to do the "dirty" jobs. So what makes you think a homeless individual would want to work? They're homeless for a reason.
Yea the homeless definitely don't want to do the work, i once tried to give a hobo a banana, he said, "cash only", SMH.
“College boy does manual labor for first time and is surprised”
It sounds like he's spoiled.
The truth is most of these dairy farms are owned by rich families that do not want to pay a liveable wage or offer any kind of benefits for their local communities citizens. They would rather pay under the table and continue to be essentially slave masters.
This is neither a pro or con, just sharing an experience: I come from a large American city. Many years ago I l moved to a rural area, there are many farms...but nowhere near a boarder. I noticed that there was a large illegal population. I wondered where do they come from? How do they get here? One day when sharing some comments of co-workers with a friend. The friend said to me. If they weren't here, who would pick our vegetables? We have degrees, are you going to take that type of job? Our kids get allowances. They aren't going to do it. Even if they take a summer job they will look for something like a sales associate in a store or fast food at the very least. So again, I ask you, how would the farmers survive? How would we get affordable vegetables to eat? I just looked at my friend, thinking...he's biased cause he's a vegetarian. But later when I gave it more thought, I had no answer. I still have no answer. It's not just dairy, it's farming in general.
Howd they get there? well, how'd you get there?
Jj let the homeless american do the job?
It's the age old question. If all illegal / undocumented workers in the US were removed, your pint of milk, your pound of beef, your apple and whatever is in your grocery stores will either skyrocket in price OR not be available.
Jj I
Is not just farming and agriculture, also restaurants, hotels, landscaping, painting, framing, concrete work, insulation, swimming pool building, irrigation and any hard job out there they're the majority of the labor. Did I forget anything?
I was learning English hard to prepare my US dairy internship in China, when I start my first day in Colorado dairy, I find I need learn Spanish
😂🤣
学好得哥哥! 西班牙裔女孩很可爱。
Learn it well, man. Latinos are the kinest people. Mexican girls are super cute too! ^^
Aprendele bien, hermano. Los latinos son gente mas amable y simpatica. Chicas mexicanas son lindisima tambien ^^
@@honjokun0615 the Amigos I work with is it's 50/50 on communication, if they wanna stick around.
YONGFENG ZHAO 这是有趣的
Learn it, we are super nice and have amazing food, also our ladies are very cute.
Go interview what's left of the small family run farms in NYS. You'll learn much more.
Exactly.. the American farmer cant survive on the payout/profit ratio with insurance, paychecks, maintenance etc. Well said.
Americans in 2019: I want a job that pays a starting salary of $75k and a bunch of awesome perks.
Employer: Okay, but you need a college degree for this position.
Americans in 2019: No! College is for losers and is too expensive. Give me money!
God bless America...
P.S. I worked in recruiting for a Fortune 50 company and this interaction happened at least once a week.
What kind of job is it coding lol?
$75k a year isnt hard to obtain.. but your gonna bust your ass 12+ hours a day in all kinds of weather to get it.
@@rooone6588 Yes actually. Software engineering.
@@maritimemisfits3360 Not really. The software engineers at my company work their standard 9 hours along with unlimited time off. Depends on the industry and company.
@@RabidPrairieDog drywall contracting pays that but only after 5 years and even then thats a unstable pay.
i love how milking is described as the worst job... milking is nothing compared to having to pick a field by hand, or anything else physical in farming. i loved my milking shifts sometimes; nobody bothers you, monotonous and goes by fast, and it's just you and a buncha cows.
Ice should concentrate on real criminals
Ice is for immigrants but I agree there should be more effort for real criminals and not people working to put food on the table for their families and also non violent
@@user-de5wt3mc8l yeah, best to leave nonviolent aliens alone - they're contributing to our economy for christ's sake
is this an invitation to break into your country and deny paying taxes ?
i mean your not the first who mentioned this in the chat and since the other ones told me I am welcome as an ilegal alien if i am white.....
Puerto Ricans accepted the job right away, see! Even they are legally Americans too, but they are Hispanic, so yeah, they know how to work hard, :>)
As a Latino, I see it in the Latino Culture Hermana. Not just un grupo, casi todo’ somos así
@@Pandroo018 be careful latino culture
Misato Blushing because of corrupt governments, cartels, gangs and America intervention 🤦♂️ Learn history bud
Misato Blushing Europe is a conquesting country. Opposite of countries that have been conquested. The long term effects of that still linger in those conquested countries, with corrupt system based on color, class and status still affect the average person. England did not pioneer world wide drug trafficking. Latin America did and in return grew so strong the government is conflicting with them and some meso systems controlled by drug cartels. Then you have American interventions which didn’t happen in Europe because US wanted to focus on neighboring countries such a starting revolutions with in Latin countries and training their military to so they may place other political figures in office that will do what The US wants and so on. Look at Nicaragua, Panama, Mexico “disposable workers” and so on to understand the long term effects of a conquested and Intervened countries and people that also has a serious issue with Gangs and Drugs.....yeah try being a hard worker there... they get overlooked by media but never take their situation for granted thus Latinos have a large handwork ethic distilled within them due to political, societal, economic, historical, and Cultural factors. Especially here in the US
Puerto Rican’s just get their papers and they go lazy like Americans
Damn.. so sad what's happening
@maga guy his fucking DOGE died , thatts why he is sad
but dont worry those dumbass wil feel better as soon the next video starts....
or what i think about hobbypoliticans..
Impressive documentary. Strong arguments with strong evidence.
Same thing in the hospitality and restaurant industry
The horse kept bumping him because it said "shut up or well gt in trouble "
if these employees would pay a few more dollars an hour they could get American workers but their greed is causing them to hire cheaper labor.
Didn't you watch the video ? They Can not afford to pay them more
@@matthiaskonold6976 So they can't "afford" to pay more so they get to get away with low pay and threat of turning illegals in if they complain about work conditions..COME ON!!!
You obviously have no idea how the dairy industry or concepts of microeconomics like SG&A work.
You should pay more attention to the documentary really 🤦♂️
I don’t know what state you live in but some of the poorer states can’t afford to pay higher wages
My first job was milking on a dairy and I loved it... Also I'm white not that that matters
Oh it very much matters, although illegals come in all skin colors, the assumption made here and in all these films, media outcries, etc. is that illegals are brown. So, although skin color doesn't matter to us white guys, it is very definitely important to those with an agenda, and it helps to be able to hate one skin color (white) while bonding as another skin color, say, brown.
My Grandmother was a German immigrant. She came here during WW2‚ as a child‚ by herself‚ and had no money. Guess what she came here legally. If she could come here legally then Hispanics should come here legally.
Fuck Germans, she should have stayed in germany. When were Hispanics allowed to come legally like europeans?
TheMexikingisback2 Actually Hispanics are allowed to come here legally. There are other ways to get here besides crossing the border ;)
TheMexikingisback2 Wow great job at being racist. Not all Germans are Nazis you idiot. Guess what my grandmother went through that slow tedious process. Also the US was built off of European and Asian immigrants.
RagedLemon
My uncle by marriage has owned a business for years. Even when he was illegal he payed taxes through his wife who was legal. I guarantee you that 99% of illegal business owners pay taxes and there are A LOT of illegal business owners in the US
RagedLemon all the time! They use whats called TIN numbers and also pay state and sales tax u fucking imbecil. If you dont know about the issue stop talking about it.
They are like "family". Would you pay a family member $9 an hour to do that job. Bunch of BS. They just want cheap labor.
The margin of profit is very thin. About once every ten years there is a price boom. Some farms pay a bonus when they get money but don't want to pay more because the next price bust is around the corner and lasts for a few years.
They would have to pay more if these people didn't lower the wage.
I am sure some americans would do it if they got $15 and hour.
You can get better job for $9 an hour. Work at Walmart, Target or any store and you get $9 or more with benefits if you are full time.
The dairy work is awesome I do it during the summer and I do it at school (farming school) You do get covered in shit but you get used to it. I would rather work in a dairy farm than being in a classroom for sure and I do both so....
Good for you Daniel! I wish id gone to a vocational school. My Husband and both grandkids did
If ur getting covered in shit. Ur not doin it right.. What damn school u paying for
It's fun lol!
@@andrestapia7329 He said Farming School so it makes sense since animals are gonna be shitting without warning.
Heart breaking my people are fighting just to work hard and build a home with family.
go back to mexico and do it there.
Joel Cineros. Then let make their own countries work. Why aren't they fixing them? Why is America supposed to do what Mexico and the rest of Latin America should be doing for it's own people?
@@johnmcdonald9304 because America is land of the free... One of the most diverse countries in the world... Idk why yall dont attack against Cubans that step foot on this land and become legal then get all the American benefits like walefare and leave to their country to spend it asap... While these guys and almost every American citizen work until near their ending point... I've always wondered how a cuban could afford a nice brick house in a middle class neighborhood with a really nice leather interior car and sit at a Miami coffee shop all day... But if what y'all want is an all white America good luck
I honestly don't know how hard it is to become an actual citizen of the United States but why don't the owners of the company or whatever help them become legal?
What is amazing to me is whenever you watch one of these videos it is all about farm work. Like you have twenty or thirty million people doing farm work.Go into some of the warehouses or manufactory
Companies and see who has those jobs.Americans don't have those jobs because they do not advertise when they need help.they will tell an illegal to bring a friend or family member. Who do you think did these jobs before.
Immigration lawyers are expensive. Right now dairy farms are operating in survival mode.
All the is "needed" is a Foreign Guest Worker Program like the old "Bracero program" of WW2 to 1964, but the farmers back then were abusing the workers, so it was abolished.
The Greedy USA businesses really love Undocumented because they keep the wages low, cannot be on Strike, and never complain.
You have to Legally Immigrate with a Visa first, so you can Reside & Work.
5 years later, an Immigrant can Naturalize ( becoming US citizen ) if passes more tests & background.
**** To just work, in USA, does not require Greencard or US citizenship. Just a Work Permit, Fingerprints, Health check. Having a work sponsor would be smart.
After 9/11, the path to citizenship became harder.
However, company owners CAN help their immigrant workers obtain a green card IF the immigrant had started a green card application back before April 30, 2001 and have proof that they were present in the US before that. This part of the law is "Section 245(i)"...look it up for more details. It will take a few years before they receive their green card.
So, many immigrants do not qualify under that. There is currently no other law for immigrants who entered illegally that allows a path to citizenship.
Children of these immigrants have DACA as an option when they're older, which is a work permit, but is NOT a path to citizenship. But with Trump trying to undo everything the Obama administration did, I don't know where DACA will end up.
@@YACABE Bill Clinton passed IRAIIRA in 1996 so Illegal Entry after that date cannot Adjudicate to Immigrant status, that is why the DACA people are stuck, for now.
I'm a hispanic (3rd generation americanized) and I'm honestly frightened by this
Good, shed some light on one person at a time.
2 AM to Noon, for me, it's the hours more than anything that would drive me nuts!!!
Great documentary Vice! Thank you.
30 years ago nobody thought that china would be an economic power house, you may underestimate mexico and its people but it is becoming an economic power house of its own right, look at how many manufacturing company's are moving there.
Mexico is becoming a western nation, but it doesn't have the ingredients needed for it to become an economic power house, sorry, It's population is too small, and the government is still corrupt, they elected AMLO, but he's a populist who's probably not going to get a lot done. Mexico also is starting to get into service and the tech sectors, so manufacturing might disappear as quickly as it appeared, but you couldn't know for certain.
@Salvadore Andretti ohh little do you know the Mexican gov has a very strong grip they allow the corruption to happen and the corruption they dont want ends up dissolving pretty quickly
That's rather pathetic. You're unemployed but you won't take a job that requires any real work. Should we really feel sorry for the unemployed in our country?
I'm not American but looking at the pay for the amount of work they have to do is really shitty and do they get any benefits that comes with that? Probably not. If the pay isn't worth the work why bother?
Animurh My point being: there are jobs available but Americans would rather sit at home and collect unemployment while they complain about not being able to find jobs with their degree in art history or English lit.
I would do then again I am Hispanic. Do have 2 jobs wouldn't mind a 3rd one during the summer when I'm not in school
The United States is statistically one of the hardest working countries in the world much more so than European countries but the hard working poor can't escape poverty because the odds stacked against them. This whole "the harder you work the better your life will be" is a lie.
Spencer Chudyk It's pretty much get a good education or you are fucked
I would 100% do that job wtf we Americans are sad people sometimes
its funny if there's employers to hire why not give this mexicans a legal working visa,this is done here on canada,we dont have illegal workers but we have workers from different country but they have working visa as long there's employers to hire ,that's the laws in canada
Hey dummy, get the fat out of your ears and listen to the video. It clearly states in America for farm work there are only seasonal visas not full year visas which is what most farms need. This was filmed in America, about American policy. How crazy is it that CANADIAN is different, almost like theyre two separate countries.
I can see you are not a native speaker. "Why not give this Mexicans"...... And your name is a dead giveaway.
The legal immigrants and the ones with Visa don't want to work there either. So how is it that they say they are the only ones that do that job?
16 years and not able to speak the damn language.I've nothing against those people but come on.
Somnivers Certain factors come up as to why they have difficulty learning English:
- Some communities do not have adequate facilities for immigrants and recent arrivals to teach them the English language and provide services for them (e.g. job hunting, obtaining driver's licenses, child care support, etc.)
- Their lack of or limited amount of documentation could cause them to pay significantly more to be educated at a community college, and with the pressure of feeding their families, they have little to no recourse but to work long hours
- Their long work hours mean they do not have adequate time to be with their families or spend time reading books; instead, many keep the unending eat-work-sleep pattern every single day without a day or two to spend quality time with their children and partners
And since our Congress has been way too slow, if not ignorant, on the issue of immigration reform, then people need to vote those incompetent politicians out of office in the next election. Those Congress members who are against immigration reform are the same people who continue to subsidize the oil and banking industries for their own wealth accumulation rather than helping out immigrants wanting to live better lives in the country.
Anthony Nachor
Agreed,there are multiple factors ,it's a complex problem.But,16 years in US and not able to speak some basic English is just insane.I know immigrants are having a hard time and they work many hours ,I do appreciate those people who work hard jobs.But I just can't imagine living in a country so much time and not speaking some basic language,no language is that hard to learn in 16 years.To me that just shows lack of interest in the respective country's culture.
Anthony Nachor
A plausible reason for me is that most Americans don't want to do those jobs so Mexicans only interact with each other at work .Their bosses speak Spanish to them so that's that.At home they also speak Spanish ,that's normal.I've seen this before in Spain , where people who worked there for 7-8 years were not able to say anything in Spanish.
They are being interviewed. They probably do know very basic English but in order to have a conversation about the topic they are speaking their mother tongue.
*****
could be
Respect for all them hard working Mexicans trying make a living out here
They can earn living at home... Where do poor uneducated Americans need to sneak in to improve their standard of living? Laws matter.
America and Americans first.
I’m a white person and work on a dairy. I enjoy it and work just as hard as them! I also know a lot of people who do so who work just as hard!
Where are they??
I worked on a farm and never saw white guys do that the one that did left by lunch time never came back
I am a Chinese. My family and I immigrated to America in 1963, from Hong Kong legally. I was 9 years old then. I am the only one in the family did not become a citizen, therefore, my status remained as a permanent resident, I was arrested and convicted, did my time but ICE wanted to deport me but can't. Now, I am literally stuck in NYC with no paper. A man without a country and I thought I was a citizen of the world. Oh America the beautiful. Yeah right! :-)
Joseph Lee There's thousands with your same story in Chinatown. And there's tens of millions in China who wish they could be you.
***** And how should he leave the country without papers? Or enter any other for that matter? He also does not have a right to a refugee status in Europe. Just watch Airport with Tom Hanks.
Ari Bjarnason Sry -
The Terminal
the construction industry has the same problem about lack of labor and i witnessed it first hand
My husband works in spray-foam insulation...Americans don't last a week.
Though one Cuban-American lasted a year. 👏🏼
Yeah, it’s the same story with other jobs that are labor-intensive. I am saddened by the fact that we treat these people like criminals when in reality they are carrying our economy on their backs.
big fundamental true that
That’s because the pay went from $20/hr with benefits, to $10/hr no benefits. Your Cuban friend is used to 50 cents a day, he’ll take just about anything.
That was my job as a teenager in New York.
+TheDocwiz Mine as well.
better then working on a line in a factory or cleaning out portable toilets etc.
Ill do it for $15.00 an hour plus benefits.
Lord Vader ill do u for a light saber
Adel Aali oof
Buy yourself 500 cows, buy the milking equipment, buy the feed equipment, and the machinery to grow the feed, pay to build the facility, pay all the taxes, and then come back and say YOU can afford to pay someone $15 an hour plus benifits to get a product with a very slim profit margin.
It's possible. If you want pay $50 a gallon. That's the only way. Take the jobs let's see if you can do it.
@@CRAFTSMANFISHING You are 100% right Santos. MOST people also don't think in a case like any livestock operation, especially milking, it's 24/7 365 twice a day. Yes, even Christmas and your birthday lol. And on time, if you're an hour late to milk or feed, production drops drastically. Unfortunately very few people realize these things and would put up with it. Even though I personally think everyone should pay the fair share on taxes like we all do who are citizens, even if the amount isn't fair to the working person, I won't bash the immigrants doing the work most english people think they are above doing.
who are illegal immigrants? please ask American Indians :D
Not even "Indians"
Good one! Not.
Native Americans*
Not even close to a viable comparison.
I am American Indian and guess what that's What Thanksgiving is for they made peace so STFU
Thats why i would rather stay in my country
Kenya, despite corruption and poor governance we are free
Really. Kenya is free?? Kenya is so poor and I see how they would love to get out of there.TBH even low income Americans live better than a even middle class Kenya.
@@westmax8491 Kenya is one of the best countries in Africa and in the world, yes there are problems of poor governance but atleast we can afford 3meals a day and a roof over our heads and clothes on our skin,plus u don't have to worry about a white folk discriminating you or tracking your ass down to deport you. These are few of the freedom I am talking about.
@@lukasochola576 best country? Botwana Namibia Cape verse Seychelles and maybe Ghana are way better than Kenya. Also just found Kenya has the largest slum in the continent and also by quantity. That means not many kenyans meet their basic needs. I could give you credit if you said Kenya is the best in eastern Africa.
Lukas Ochola That’s great! Some people have a hard time understanding less is more to many
Lol ok buddy
I can't wait to go back home and see my kids 😔
Good luck bro may you see your kids soon
When dude was squeegeeing the poop and mentioned Taco Bell, i started to gag. I love Vice News.
So, if you didn't have the illegal labor and had to pay a descent wage/benefits to attract legal labor, wouldn't that be better?
And then you have to pay more for milk. It creates a chain pricing increase. Now, if the owner pays more would Americans do it? I do not think so plus all the complaining they would do...
@@cecarblanco9933 Business is in the business of finding the lowest labor cost. If you can get get people who will work for half the cost you will. If your competition does this illegally so will you to compete. The business of business is not altruism. If no one is available to work at such a low rate you and your competition must pay more to obtain the necessary labor. Romain lettuce is about $1.50. They could double it and no one would think twice buying it. I've worked in the farming industry, in canneries. There were plenty of law abiding U.S. citizens earning a wage with benefits, legally.
I think you should watch the last 5 min of this video again , and please pay attention this time ..
@@josephthompson1176 So a cheaper alternative displaces the existing labor force, sounds familiar...
@@josephthompson1176 i think u shut learn to read the video desciption , ITS PROPAGANDA .... it literly stands there ... stupid libtard...
This is ridiculous. The American farming industry is so profit-driven that quality in the workplace is so bad, few people will do the farm work. I live in Canada, where there are regulations preventing these FACTORY FARMS from being created. Is profit so important to any agricultural business that we need to reduce quality of food AND the workplace, not to mention adding SAFETY concerns? The lack of any protection from workplace hazards is an issue that has been addressed outside of America. Why is the USA running factory farms like third world countries with no regulations to protect the quality of their products AND the safety of workers?
I don't blame anyone who refuses this work because of the lack of safety (kicking of the cows, slips trips falls, contamination, falling objects). I worry about those who take on these jobs, which have taken form of a third-world style oversight in a first world country.
Ask yourself, how do you think farms in Britain, France, and Spain operate without taking advantage of undocumented workers like in the USA?
your not wrong. farm AKA as milk factory
Haha, farms in Europe use Romanians and eastern europeans, who work for less, it's all the same, sorry, canadian, but you don't live in a utopia.
@@edmondcromwell5491 most Agricultural work done in Spain is done by moroccans in particular and many of them are illegals. France also uses illegal work force but to a lesser extent than it's the case in Spain or Italy ( even Greece). Kids in Europe won't do Agri and farming work any more and I'm talking about places like andalucia in Spain. Illegals are a necessity over there. I know because I used to be an illegal person working fields in southern Spain. It a back breaking job in very hot temperatures. Europeans in general are past that sort of " corvèe" like the french say. I just wish people were just a bit civil in their hatred to illegals. Just think about walking in their shoes for a moment and try to contemplate the choices you have. A life stuck between a rock and a hard place, because of a lottery of where and with color or race you were born into, in witch you had no say.
My Grandson works part time at a Dairy farm in Massachusetts and loves the job, no complaint from him. He went to Smith Vocational HS and isnt afraid to get his hands dirty
Jumping the border tonight to the US wish me luck
Lmaooo
Good luck!! Haha
lol
I wonder if people will stop complaining about immigration after watching this.
Nope.
Harrison Lawson thought so
Little Breez-E ha, you must be new here.
some people can't get past the fact that these guys have brown skin and speak spanish. they are morons and proud of it. if deporting all of the illegal immigrants ends up hurting the usa economy in a big way and they are able to see it then it still wouldn't matter to them.
Brian Morgan yeah agreed. Some things just won't change.
Have to keep those private prisons/holding camps full to make money! How many politicians are getting kick backs?
I did this when I was a kid in high school. It Sucked! The winters were the worst.
GOD protect us...from those who say they're your children
Chances are Mexicans built your house too
Not mine. Built it myself. Wanted to make sure it was done right.
entertextimagebelow but the materials done by illegal immigrants :))
Courage & Congress in the same sentence is almost a laughable absurdity.
At the end of the video, you mention the key points of the video. One being “they have no way to enter the country legally”
I honestly want to hear why that is, or more behind that. How is the legal process not even an option for these people?
This was actually fun because the interviewer was willing to do anything
1. My family had a dairy farm for hundreds of years in NYS, and never once hired anybody from outside the local area.
2. What is being featured here is a factory farm, and many of them are owned by Chinese companies.
GUMMYBEAYUH so you expect us to believe that?
Really? I don’t know an awful lot about American dairy farming, but I do know a lot about dairy farming in general, and I’d bet that they’re all family owned and run farms
Unless you only had 3 cows in your farm lol you funny
5:42 never eating Taco Bell again
3:00 - 4:00 Skip the rest of the video. This is the only minute you need to watch.
too bad vice didn't blur out the farm name on the workers coverall patch...
I thought they if an immigrant married a citizen they could apply and get papers to become a citizen.
Darlene Shriver they do but is a long process take years and a lot money in paperwork lawyers some applications cost about 400 dls
milking cows isn't nasty its daily job here in kenya 🇰🇪🇰🇪😂😂
David Ngure kabisa
Hehe kali sana
To ur average American Joe it too hard and nasty
its a *normal* job AREOUND the WORLD
you are just spooked because u didnt notice how u entered a left extrimist media outlet bubble
next time PLEASE read first in the videodescription if its a documentary or political propaganda !
That's what I thought 😂.
Naeza ifanya vizuri sana with their current pay rate 😂.
Americans can do those jobs. We would demand good pay and safe working conditions.
17 year old white kid would work at those farms definitely i am trying to get a job at one.
+luke short your a pice of shit dude I want to work so that's a bad thing and BTW not a drop out just need money.
Im from western ny and working on a farm is not as bad as u think people are just babies now a day
Absolutely!! I've worked on my families dairy farm my entire life. I love it, people just hate to put in a hard days work.
You're one of the rare breeds of hard working Americans who have the been taught to work hard.
Do roofing and you will see another hard job
Every lawmaker needs to see this! NOW!
Just wondering ,how many of u citizens would take a job like this?
I find it very amusing that many people in this comment section are giving so much credit to Spanish speakers who say they can start immediately, praising the hard-working immigrants, despite the fact that they say they are from Puerto Rico, which would make them American.
Many Americans would not agree to that lol. Americans very brutal to anyone not white.
INFORMATION TO ALL!! This was filmed and created under the Obama Administration. It was published to TH-cam in 2014. Also if I am not mistaken Dairy Farms are now able to get work Visa workers for their labor force. This is old just as a reminder.
H2A visas are only for seosonal agricultural jobs and they where granted during the Obama administration as well... Dairy jobs are year round