In my opinion, I like the newer version. I just like how it looks. The fact that it looks salvaged and not clean. But the older one is still super cool. I wish I had that one. P.s got the newer AT-ST for only $40. Went on sale really quickly.
@@ethan_c The added detal in the back is where the 100 pieces went and it also added a better counterweight which caused the added stability you noticed.
In terms of value, the rogue one atst was probably the best set I’ve ever bought. In fact, all the rogue one sets had their own great merits. Great lineup, great film, great times.
I agree. If you have never heard of star wars before. Rouge one is a great film to get you started. Its one film with a good story. Cool characters. And you don't have to know a whole lot about Star wars to understand it. I'd even say its my favorite star wars movie.
Similarities of Captain Phasma and The Mandalorian: Both have shiny armour Both don’t like their troopers/cult members taking their helmets off Both faces were briefly seen in Episode 8 And LEGO gave them both plain black heads (Reply if you have noticed any other similarities!)
Both of their armor colors in LEGO are poorly misrepresented as gunmetal grey when the deserve the chrome/reflective silver treatment. A lot of people put Phasma’s cape on the Chrome Storm Trooper released a while back.
I only have the 2016 version and if u get the 2019 version just for the mandalorian figure there is no way he won’t come out in another set so wait and he’ll come out in a razorcrest
Clearly set 7127, AKA the Squidward-house looking one, is the superior AT-STD walker. But it's seriously a trip to see just how far these sets have come since the retro Lego Star wars age.
I prefer the 2016 one just because it fits in with the Imperial sets, whereas the Scavenged one is faction-less. And asides from the colour difference, they’re practically identical so....
When building the AT-ST Raider there were lots of instances where I was feeling like aspects, especially hidden internal ones, were made extra complex for no reason other than part count.
The at-st raider body have a combination of the imperial and FO at-st made by LEGO. I think the body contains the most pieces just looking at it they definitely added more pieces to its body. To me I like the imperial era at-st more then a rusty old one of the raider. The raider does come with better figures imo.
2016 at-st deserves the point for playability as the guns on the side panels don’t fall off with every touch unlike the at-st raider (you could see it happen just demonstrating the guns- you subtly pushed it back in place.) Sturdiness is an attribute to playability and with all else equal, this is a win for 2016
As much as I like the Raider, with it's rugged look and a better minifigure selection, I prefer the original Imperial design. I love how clean looking it is and I have a personal bias for Imperial vehicles. Also, the price was excellent. Honestly, It's probably the best Rogue one set imo, and one of my favorites.
I feel like the atst raiders shape is a little different I feel like they tried to get it a little closer to the shape but the old one is very nice i agree with you i like both
I love the newer Unique Raider AT ST. It's a question of taste because it is basically the same build. I just like the cables hanging out, something that nobody seems to mention. It's a nice detail that Lego could have omitted and I appreciate such details. One last thing, I do not put lights on my builds but this raider AT ST would be the only one I would use red lights inside to give it the red sinister glow as in the show.
11:05 If you look in the Return of the Jedi, just before Chewie takes over the AT-ST, you can see the controls. It shows that the control panel sticker in the 2016 Rogue One set is more accurate.
Both great sets. Any fan of Mando has to get the newer one. The nice thing with the older one is that it can be used in several cannon Mocs, while the new one is on screen for only a few minutes.
I have the new one cuz of the mandalorian fig, but I think it comes down to which look you prefer cuz they’re both great sets. I do wish I had bought the 2016 one tho because they look so cool together
I actually own both and I love them both. It's pretty cool to have them battle one another on my Lego Display. The 2016 model is your factory stock model while the 2019 model has more personality and charm. Both still beat my 2001 model in every single way, except not have Chewbacca...
Great comparison! I’ve watched all of you new ones, I think you should do a comparison with all the minifig-scale x-wing star fighters and a comparison between the 2 imperial troop transports
I have both, the knob in the back that controls the head rotation is way different on both. The 2016 version is really responsive, barely turning it causes the head to whip around really fast. The 2019 version is more controlled and doesn't whip around as bad. If you look closely in the video you can see the difference
I got the raider atst, excellent build. I'm a little disappointed at the Mandalorians print -- in the show he had his upgraded armor by this point and I feel the print should reflect that.
You actually can modify the first order AT-ST to make it look like a proper AT-ST. But the set sucks anyway. I wanted it at first, but then found out it was dumb.
The back of the raider atst is more accurate because the imperial atst didn’t have the fuel cells and “paint roller” peices on the back unlike the raider version
If u look at the newer one, it is actually more detailed. Look at the back of the body and u will see a connection to legs that is missing in the old one. Furthermore, it is also longer in the body which covers bonus pieces.
The Mandalorian one has its legs correctly connected to the fuselage. It is a small detail, but it is. Like the Rogue one better though. You get more of an epic star wars feeling with that one
Pretty evenly matched... which one would you rather own?
MandRproductions the one from 2k16
The new one. But Why isn't there Baby Yoda?
Wait isnt the rogue one one 2017
I can believe he answered
My name is Ryan too. I have both
Me: "Mom, can we get an AT-ST?"
Mom: "We have an AT-ST at home."
AT-ST at home: *is the First Order AT-ST*
@@henry7655 Sounds like you are too.
Kinda like half an AT-ST.....it doesn't even have a head (Taylor Swift/banana)
Kid:It’s the same model tho
Mom:but it’s first order
Kid:o
Captain Cardinal PUT A SOCK IN IT KID
Oof
The newer one has the better figures but that first one is just iconic
@Silver Is The Name it's iconic because it's imperial. Duh
No but new one also has big problems walking and doing stop motion it would have to slode
The 2016 figs are better imo. I mean it's the best at st driver we've ever got
@@bierbauercsaba3049 nobody remembers anybody from rogue one
Yeah
3:52 he has Finns face I think, but he has no pants on
Dude, what the hell.
Racist tho
I thought he was without underwear
._. no, just.... why would you say that...
Milanzeeman there’s nothing “racist” in this comment I really hate how people always call everything “racist”
Is the rebel trooper the guy who shouts, “I’m going!” And instantly dies?
William Robinson Yes.
Yep.
Yeah
Yea that made me laugh
He died with honor.
1:29 "the set on the left" *moves camera to the right*
Execute order 66
Levi Carmody No
LMAO
Unless he means the set’s left.
@@levicarmody5713
Yes my lord
In my opinion, I like the newer version. I just like how it looks. The fact that it looks salvaged and not clean. But the older one is still super cool. I wish I had that one. P.s got the newer AT-ST for only $40. Went on sale really quickly.
Johnathan Rose I feel like the new one stands better I have both, and the older one falls often
Got mine recently in Denmark so it was about 5 dollars cheaper for me
@@ethan_c The added detal in the back is where the 100 pieces went and it also added a better counterweight which caused the added stability you noticed.
To me the new one looks like a candycane.
Ikr
I think the 2019 one is better.
The 100 extra pieces are in the legs, back panel, and minifig.
I counted and including Baze’s gun and every accessory they both have 27 pieces in the figures.
@Jerms I love your profile picture
@@FenixFang Thank You
minifgures are the best, but legs color :(
It’s legs suck though so I am getting the older one
In terms of value, the rogue one atst was probably the best set I’ve ever bought. In fact, all the rogue one sets had their own great merits. Great lineup, great film, great times.
Those death troopers were awesome.
Im so annoyed I missed out on every single Rogue One set.
I agree. If you have never heard of star wars before. Rouge one is a great film to get you started. Its one film with a good story. Cool characters. And you don't have to know a whole lot about Star wars to understand it. I'd even say its my favorite star wars movie.
Similarities of Captain Phasma and The Mandalorian:
Both have shiny armour
Both don’t like their troopers/cult members taking their helmets off
Both faces were briefly seen in Episode 8
And LEGO gave them both plain black heads
(Reply if you have noticed any other similarities!)
Both of their armor colors in LEGO are poorly misrepresented as gunmetal grey when the deserve the chrome/reflective silver treatment. A lot of people put Phasma’s cape on the Chrome Storm Trooper released a while back.
Mando completely took off his helmet tho
Yeah I guess so
This is the way.
The Mandalorian religion not race.
They should have made a knew mandalorian rifle and blaster for the new series cos the ones in this set are too big
Bro true
*new
They should give him a face too.
2:01 ( the driver or minifigure in the middle ) kind of looks like a WWII German solder, is it just me?
Ozzy Bricks they were designed in the movie to mimic that
The entire original trilogy is heavily inspired by WW2
🧱
The empire are basically nazis in space.
Harvey Gardner well...
Can't believe you left out the headless AT-ST it easily has the most personality and best minifigures
*wink wink*
I only have the 2016 version and if u get the 2019 version just for the mandalorian figure there is no way he won’t come out in another set so wait and he’ll come out in a razorcrest
It probs be his newer look
Razor crest is way more expensive than the at-st
Cara is exclusive to the ATST Raider
@The Mandalorian this didn’t age well
@@oregonborn666Why would you ever want Cara Dune?
I love how the basic construction is the same it keeps consistencies
We all know that the first order one is the superior at-st design
Wtf how
just kidding I nkow it's a joke
I concur.
Yo Ryan u should do top 10 lego star wars sets of all time (by ur opinion not just bricklink)
I would rather own the rogue one at st because it's more generic
Oof
_oof size large_
@Thomas Santino if you were an army builder like me then you would understand
Took me a minute but he didn’t talk about his shirt
I bought the 2019 At-St it's a great set to have!
I totally agree
I did too
Tbh its a lot cooler
Clearly set 7127, AKA the Squidward-house looking one, is the superior AT-STD walker.
But it's seriously a trip to see just how far these sets have come since the retro Lego Star wars age.
I'm glad they didn't change too much because they are both at-st's from the same universe so it makes sense to have them generally similar.
I feel like the 2016 version would have been much better if they would have included a fourth minifig, like maybe a shore trooper
That at st is based of those used on jedha and there were no shoretroopers there so it should have had a regular stormtrooper included
The mandalorian version looks so much cooler. It’s not even a competition to me
I have the rogue one atst but I still think the best non ucs atst was the one in the battle of endor set
Yes it looks amazing and has only a few Parts
I prefer the 2016 one just because it fits in with the Imperial sets, whereas the Scavenged one is faction-less. And asides from the colour difference, they’re practically identical so....
When building the AT-ST Raider there were lots of instances where I was feeling like aspects, especially hidden internal ones, were made extra complex for no reason other than part count.
And those stickers on the 1x2 wedge bricks, nice touch but when will you even see that
The 2016 model was actually a lot tighter I have them both and 2019 compared to 2016, 2016 is a lot tighter on the joints and spinning the head wise
12:25 AT-AT???
Yeah heard that
Lol
I heard that
The at-st raider body have a combination of the imperial and FO at-st made by LEGO.
I think the body contains the most pieces just looking at it they definitely added more pieces to its body.
To me I like the imperial era at-st more then a rusty old one of the raider. The raider does come with better figures imo.
2016 is sutch a good set
I would recomend that 1
Just original !!
2016 at-st deserves the point for playability as the guns on the side panels don’t fall off with every touch unlike the at-st raider (you could see it happen just demonstrating the guns- you subtly pushed it back in place.) Sturdiness is an attribute to playability and with all else equal, this is a win for 2016
As much as I like the Raider, with it's rugged look and a better minifigure selection, I prefer the original Imperial design. I love how clean looking it is and I have a personal bias for Imperial vehicles. Also, the price was excellent. Honestly, It's probably the best Rogue one set imo, and one of my favorites.
I agree
I feel like the atst raiders shape is a little different I feel like they tried to get it a little closer to the shape but the old one is very nice i agree with you i like both
I love the newer Unique Raider AT ST. It's a question of taste because it is basically the same build. I just like the cables hanging out, something that nobody seems to mention. It's a nice detail that Lego could have omitted and I appreciate such details.
One last thing, I do not put lights on my builds but this raider AT ST would be the only one I would use red lights inside to give it the red sinister glow as in the show.
What you said about the rebel trooper is why I like clone troopers over resistance and rebel troopers and then storm troopers can’t aim
Your my favorite youtuber inspire me to build LEGO.🔥
:)
I can’t believe you answered
Love your vids I am kinda new to TH-cam but I have been with your channel since the beginning
Love That There’s Only One Like And I Love Ur Shirt. I'd Get The AT-ST Raider
11:05 If you look in the Return of the Jedi, just before Chewie takes over the AT-ST, you can see the controls.
It shows that the control panel sticker in the 2016 Rogue One set is more accurate.
1:45 i love how the third biggest AT-ST are starting to show up , the third one. 😀
The second one fits more in my Ewok Village 🤩
Both great sets. Any fan of Mando has to get the newer one. The nice thing with the older one is that it can be used in several cannon Mocs, while the new one is on screen for only a few minutes.
I want a Force Unleashed AT KT.
Yay Wookiee enslavement! That should actually be a feature of the set if they make it.
I don't think that they'll ever come back to Unleashed to make sets about it, since it's over 10 years old game and it's not canon anymore.
If there was the first order AT ST on this comparison it would win just because of his exclusive non-head design
I have the new one cuz of the mandalorian fig, but I think it comes down to which look you prefer cuz they’re both great sets. I do wish I had bought the 2016 one tho because they look so cool together
I got the newer one for $40 since it was on sale, I love the color scheme for it and it's a great display piece
The base for the head is larger on the 2019 version which would make the piece count larger
İs it the rebel friend in your pfp 😂
I actually own both and I love them both. It's pretty cool to have them battle one another on my Lego Display. The 2016 model is your factory stock model while the 2019 model has more personality and charm. Both still beat my 2001 model in every single way, except not have Chewbacca...
Similar, but stylistically different, I think it really counts on what you would want personally
Great comparison! I’ve watched all of you new ones, I think you should do a comparison with all the minifig-scale x-wing star fighters and a comparison between the 2 imperial troop transports
The Mandalorian one needs a Baby Yoda.
Then you might as well bring every single villager?
I find that the 2019 at st looks like the captured resistance walker from star wars battlefront 2.
Ya it does i love battle front 2
Really great video Ryan! my opinion is
2016: the build
2019: the minifigures
I just bought the 75254 ATST and I love it.
I got the Rogue One At-St, so I don't really need the At-St Raider
Yes you do
That's fair
I got it because I missed out on that set, and I want an ATST
Mandr, the 2016 atst should win the design category as it was the first to use that design
I have both, the knob in the back that controls the head rotation is way different on both. The 2016 version is really responsive, barely turning it causes the head to whip around really fast. The 2019 version is more controlled and doesn't whip around as bad. If you look closely in the video you can see the difference
I love your channel keep up the good work
I got the raider atst, excellent build. I'm a little disappointed at the Mandalorians print -- in the show he had his upgraded armor by this point and I feel the print should reflect that.
you are my faverouit lego reviewer (I don't know if I spelt that right)
No, you didn’t
I had 2 of the 2016 rouge one at-st and broke both of them when I was younger, I’m glad I still have the mandolorian one in tact.
He left it out because he knew the first order would lose
Not even that. It’s not super comparable. I had no interest in including it because it’d be boring/
@@MandRproductions but, it does also suck, we can't forget that
Yeah it’s pretty crap!
200 thousand subscribers go go go
I've ordered the 2019 one...it still hasn't arrived
Did it come yet
Did you pre order it?
Did it come yet...
Did you get it
I'm really glad you did not include the AT-ST from the Last Jedi Sets considering it is missing the head/control area. Great judgment!
You actually can modify the first order AT-ST to make it look like a proper AT-ST.
But the set sucks anyway. I wanted it at first, but then found out it was dumb.
I mean, it is a standard ATST, but missing its head, which is the interesting part of an ATST
I have two of the ones from 2019 and I'm thinking about modding one to look like the one from 2016
In my opinion the both are good set and I already own the newer one so I don't know which is the better set
Mandr is just Florida man of the Lego star wars community
Do a deathstar comparison
As good as the first one is,I like the Mando one more as I like the scrapper asthetic and it's a little more chonky
The back of the raider atst is more accurate because the imperial atst didn’t have the fuel cells and “paint roller” peices on the back unlike the raider version
Another thing you should base them on is building experience. Sort of like how fun the build was and if there was any cool unique building design
I love this video!!
THE WIRES ON THE LEG, RYAN!!! THE WIRES ON THE LEG!!!!
Yeah!!!!
I still have the '15 version. Its proudly displayed on my shelf.
Great vid I have both sets and like both of them
I prefer the mando, but if they remade the rouge one and made the design a little better, that would be my favorite imo
when the Razor-crest comes out in September how well do you think it will sell
I have the 2016, 2018, and the 2019 version of the AT-ST
AT-AT? 12:27
JaWa utinni!
CoolCryingTurtleZ #1 suinnne!
It’s clear MandR that the extra 10 usd value is in all those extra stickers!!!
Were they both fun to build though?
Wow 2 vids in 1 day!
I think these both could use some extra leg articulation. If anyone has any modification guild, please let me know.
Good Review.
Me at 3 AM: wow , ay 0.5 speed the video sounds like he's DRUNK or very sleepy.
The right side gun turret for the 75254 is pretty loose wish they would have made it a bit more solid with a little bit longer rod piece
6:48 I think that piece was half of a
helmet for a villain in avengers sets
If u look at the newer one, it is actually more detailed. Look at the back of the body and u will see a connection to legs that is missing in the old one. Furthermore, it is also longer in the body which covers bonus pieces.
I think I will choose the new one because the printed pieces cool tbh
It is interesting that they made the box bigger for the AT-ST raider.
The Mandalorian one has its legs correctly connected to the fuselage. It is a small detail, but it is. Like the Rogue one better though. You get more of an epic star wars feeling with that one
Thanks I needed this bc I was having a hard time pocking between them
Like the colors on the new one but both are equally good. Love them both.
Lego should’ve included a detachable top to the first order a At St said that would’ve made it 10 times better.
I love the shirt don't worry Ryan I want a 501st battle pack too
You are a great person to me I love your videos
I feel like LEGO is purposely not making a 501st battle pack just to mess with us
Lego waited for you to post that comment to release it so that they could furthermore mess with you.
I have both and I don’t like them that much. They look and feel stiff, and are missing crucial point of articulation in the legs.