Sebastion Rogers Case| Why didn't I think about this before?! W/ SPECIAL Guest!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ต.ค. 2024
- Credit: Missing in plain sight- She's a new channel but picks up on stuff that many don't see. Really enjoy her channel, please sub up! - • Sebastian Rogers Polic...
Credit: Missing in plain sight - • Chris proudfoot, sayin...
Credit: Missing in plain sight - • Sebastian Rogers Polic...
CREDIT: Pat Brown - (One of the best!) • MORE RED FLAGS in Rece...
Special Thanks to my Channel Members
New Amazon Link- amzn.to/3t41X5L
My Amazon Wish list- www. Have A Case Suggestion? Question? Business Inquiry? Please Email me! Alljustice4u@gmail.com
amazon.com/hz/wishlist/dl/invite/4oc8a3A?ref_=wl_share
Cash App: $Crimefactor Link- - Cash App
Venmo- @Crimefactor
My Amazon Favorite Beauty Products- a.co/7zRduhN
Song: Janji - Heroes Tonight (feat. Johnning) [NCS Release]
Music provided by NoCopyrightSounds
Free Download/Stream: ncs.io/ht
Watch: • Janji - Heroes Tonight...
Song: Janji - Heroes Tonight (feat. Johnning) [NCS Release]
Music provided by NoCopyrightSounds
Free Download/Stream: ncs.io/ht
Watch: • Janji - Heroes Tonight... - บันเทิง
They perfectly know where Sebastion is, the mom was the last to see him, so don't expect them to be going out there to look for him or much less putting out fliers!
@@ME-rv7vn yes your not gonna look for someone or something that you know where is at ...hes deceased sad but true
Thank you both for keeping this case alive !!!!!💚💚💚💚💚💚
Thank you all.
C.P. wasn't SUPPOSED to be staying at home because of trouble with CPS. He was under investigation and mad at Sebastian for making trouble thus later saying "he thought he was going to put me out of my house."
@@newsworthy2064 cp was worried he wouldn't get crusty of his daughter if sabatian was there.his plans are working!! He has his daughter-and no sabatian!!
Yep he said it & went back for revenge!
After too many missing children, I support a Sebastian’s Law for activating search warrants, cell phone trackers, car trackers & listening devices on parent’s cell phones without waiting to be approved. FL LE used them in the Soto case. If parents object to these, there’s a reason why.
I absolutely 💯 agree!!!! I personally think that even if TN had that law they wouldn't use it on the Proudfoot's. To me it looks like the Proudfoot's are being protected even though Katie was the last to see Sebastian 🤬 There's something VERY off/weird with this case.
But I would absolutely support this law also 💯
There are no 'coincidences' in criminal law.
It's time for another lie-detector test. And not the rubbish online, which can be scammed.
The world is watching. Sebastian is in our hearts, and we want him found. Justice for Sebastian 💚🙏🦋⚖️💚
Thank you Justin from Australia 🦘 for all you do. Blessings 🙏 Always.
I truly believe if Sebastian went missing that Katie would’ve called Seth. It would’ve been an automatic response to see if he went there or if he at least had heard from him. He’s a teenage boy. That to me screams foul play. And the panic from the start of him missing is because she knows what happened IMO
I’m with you on that! 💯 Why call Chris first? The step Dad that hated Sebastian and wanted him GONE! Makes No Sense to me.
Thank you Justin for a for a great live!
You have become my favorite TH-cam channel. Thank you for being drama free! You’re doing a great job getting the details of this case to help Sebastian case and we appreciate you!
Thank you so much for going over this case with fine pen and getting different views on it etc . Together we can solve things or help with something . Take 1 fresh pair of eyes sometimes to break something wide open. Justice for Sebastian and Summer we won't give up till you both are found.
Thank you for always bringing great content. Love how genuine & caring you are.
John Q is excellent and a real professional. He really gets in to the details
Right, he shines more with the round table without being cut off and he can have more attention paid to his thoughts there.
@ John Que Thank you so much for getting involved in this case to help keep Sebastian name alive. @ Justin thank you for having him on your panel & Thanks for keeping Sebastian name alive. 💚💚💚
I missed most of this live, and just now got caught up. This was great! I hate that I missed the live version. It incorporates a lot of the theory I've had from the jump. To clarify some things for you: First -- The retention pond and Laurel Park neighborhood can be accessed from the Presbyterian Church too. There is a big cemetery in the rear of the church with a dirt/gravel road that will take you almost the full distance back to the pond. Then you can just walk about 50 - 100 yards left into Laurel Park & over to the pond. The church/cemetery area would've been a great place for someone to wait while another person met up with them and/or "washed up" at the retention pond. There is also a small pond in the cemetery which has not been drained. Second -- At the time of his disappearance, there were SEVERAL retention ponds in the Laurel Park neighborhood. I'd say there were at least 3 in the front section, plus the one in the middle of the neighborhood where the dogs tracked to. Then there was the one over in the cemetery area. Third -- The road into Laurel Park from the end of Kellyn Lane is now fully graded and will probably be paved soon. At the time though, they were still grading the land and had NO ROADS in the back half of Laurel Park. It was extremely rough terrain. Now, everything that has been graded has been pushed into a MASSIVE brush pile. It is full of trees, stumps, & organic debris. It is normal practice among builders to burn those piles. My worry for months has been that they have not adequately searched that brush pile. Once it is burned, if anything of significance is in it, then it would be lost forever. Third -- There is a portion of someone driving and talking about the route Katie may have taken home. There are a few other ways to get home that could've avoided a LOT of cameras and put them out very close to their home. If something happened before they ever got home from Texas Roadhouse, then it is my opinion that she could've taken grapevine to wessington then to township, & then to forest retreat. That will take you to Center Point -- which comes out on Long Hollow, right near Honeysuckle Lane.
Katie didn't worry when she heard a thud, no way she's going to worry within 3 minutes. No way checking a big house like that within 3 minutes.
Right ✅️ and the clip I heard recently was her saying "1 minute"
Same thing I was thinking & the closets? & around the house there is NO WAY! She is Lying.
Also let’s not forget that she was fully dressed when she was talking to neighbors and before LE showed up
I watched John Cue today too and his team rocks !
Yes! John can speak more there without the constant rude interruptions and cutoffs.
Great Great Live Thank you so very much!!!💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
Excellent live!
IMO CP was waiting in that house when KP and Sebastian got home after dinner. Allegedly
Agree
Strong possibility!
LE/TBI need to pull GPS or “the black box” like LE on Murdoch case.
Or vehicle infotainment systems like in the Suzanne Morphew case.
CP mom & Katie could have possibly switched vehicles. Because it was told that CP Mom was parked in front of Sebastian school @ 5:45 in the morning and that’s the route Katie took was straight to the School, And she knew he wasn’t there!
They should’ve taken something of Katy’s and had the dog track it and some of Chris’s and had the dog track it and see where it leads to because then that will tell if either one of them were out by that retention pond
@@AlexHernandez-y7q Truth Be Told
Justin, your channel is the most informative of all, I’m tired of all the drama of all the other channels. They are too busy with inner fighting and no bringing out the facts of the case. ❤
What are law enforcement letting Chris and Katie get away with this it's disgusting poor Sebastian he needs finding now 💚💚💚🙏🙏🙏🐈💔
I agree with you 100%. The Bowersox has ties with LE or the sheriff Department. (Allegedly)
👍 on replay, great discussion session Justin with John. Also glad that Mr. E could join in chat and help with his local footage🎥
I still choose to keep hope that Sebastian will be back soon safe return 💚💚💚💚
🙏🏾💚🙏🏾
So... Do you think someone could've washed something in pond and thrown it in dumpster?
💯💯💯💯💯
Possibility! But Sebastian was not wearing what Katie said he was when he supposedly vanished.
Thank u justin. If we r known by the company we keep ur doing great ❤❤🌹😎
She is spot on. I never thought about the stuff she saying. I wouldn’t panic right away. I have a 17-year-old autistic kid maybe after like five minutes if not finding him I would.
Justin im down to only a few channels that I watch. I respect you.
💯💯💯💯💯🥰💚🥰
Same
We all wish they had done some forensics in the house 👀
What's the proof they didn't? I hope your source isn't Chris Proudfoot!
Exactly! I don’t understand why they didn’t. All I can think of was a cover up! Allegedly!
@@divaflow-lr7zs All these people in the comments speaking for law enforcement, it's a little cray cray tbh!! How about sticking to facts, this case is stressful enough without adding to it making people believe there's literally no hope for justice!! Chris is the absolute only person who eluded to this, guess what he lies, don't allow him to have that power over you.
They are so guilty of something !!! Why is LE letting them get away with it ?
What makes you think they'll get away with this?
@@triamaria mainly because LE doesn’t seem to be doing anything. I hope I’m wrong ! Thank you for keeping hope alive.
@@SandiSST They have the protect the integrity of the investigation, they have no obligation to tell us anything....this is much like the West case in Cali, it took 14 months for them to make arrests and tell us the West were suspects all along in the disappearance of their adopted sons. Imo they are quietly building a case, we shouldn't assume unless we know for sure they didn't do anything. They want to keep the Proudfoots cooperating and talking.
Typically if LE is quiet, that's a good sign. But if LE is asking the public for help, it's a sign they have very little to go on.
Having said that, with regards to Summer's case, I'm side-eyeing TN and have lost trust with the state, unfortunately.
IMO
@@Lia2222Silent but deadly!!
I enjoyed John Cue's knowledge in the Summer Well's case. Interrogate them both separately.
I've been sitting here comparing what KP allegedly said to the neighbor early that morning with what became their timeline a week or so later. Why would it benefit them to change the time of the infamous thud from 11:30 to 10 p.m. I genuinely think the 11:30 story sounds more authentic, not only because it was said before there was time to forge a story, but also because it fits with what has been said several times about Sebastian having a difficult time settling down and getting to sleep early. I wish I knew more about children on the spectrum, but I remember being really surprised when KP said she told her 15 year-old to go to bed at 9 p.m. Is that typical? It seemed ridiculously early to me, but I was a night owl even in childhood. Somebody with experience, please fill me in on this. Maybe it helps to try and have a more rigid routine? Still, I go back to the thud. How does it help them to push it forward?
Love love love this channel ❤❤❤
I DONT UNDERSTAND WHEN SHE SUPPOSEDLY HEARD THE THUD WHY SHE DID NOT GET UP AND GO CHECK ON SEBASTIAN 🤔🤔🤔
Perhaps because it's not true?
Katie has told so many lies that I don’t believe any of them.
@@Lia2222 Did You Not See I Wrote Supposedly 🤔🤔
@@kerryhall7506I think they're agreeing with you by basically
saying " because we all know she lied."
CAs she knew w/ it was
We also have to remember that info came from CP not LE
But LE is not saying anything really.
Great content. Loved the special guest and pat brown insights as well
I am happily a new subscriber! Finally I found your other channel justin! It was in my recommends and I am so so thankful.
I am more than often a re-watch of lives than a participator.
I'll definitely be looking for your next life though because this was amazing! Shout out to John Q. also!🙏💚💚💚
They were all up so late in the night, Sebastian had school, Chris and Katie had work.
I absolutely LUV your videos!!! Thank you and God bless you for your work
So weird that she didn’t take that many photos of Seb but chose to take one at Costco that day, who does that? IMO just setting up another alibi for the day, suggesting preplanning
And Texas Roadhouse, allegedly.
She had it planned to make herself look innocent.
Justin, on John’s live last night a comment was 😮left by a lady in chat, stating that one of the neighbors saw Seb go out side to the mail box and returning to the front door and struggled to
Enter the house but was not allowed… Could be nothing? Caught my eye.. l screenshot the comments so if interested I have it. l sent this mess in your live, but realize its impossible to do 10 things at once.. Thanks Robin
I just screenshot a neighbor who said she took video of the actual trash truck that looks nothing like the flashlight video. The neighbors are obviously overwhelmed by this.
I’ve heard that account too, from a day or two before he went missing. So was the code changed on the front door and he was locked out? Apparently he went around to the side door at garage to get back in.
@@NorCalSoGal With her ability to access electronic devices nothing would suprise me..
I know one thing those are flashlights and definitely not a trash truck. They took Sebastian out the Back door. Chris is Lying about Sebastian leaving out the front door.
@@NorCalSoGal I did hear that too! They probably switched up the code on Sebastian! Poor child needs to be found 💚💚💚
Justin, could they have placed him in a sea bag until he suffocated? If it’s air tight there wouldn’t be a scent to detect. Maybe they buried him in it or weighed it down and threw in water. Something to consider…they’re too confident they won’t get caught
I think they put Sebastian in some kind of Green military tarp inside the Garage. My opinion!
Did any one notice the 911 call that came in with no connection on dispatch? Weird 🤷♀️
After seeing Riley Strain’s mom, Katie is definitely cold and not grieving Sebastian. I pray that TN LE knows more than they’re telling us and they’re waiting for a tip, confession or the discovery of Sebastian dead or alive.
I personally think they are protecting the Proudfoot's. There was another case of a child disappearing that I read about and those parents are sitting in jail.
My biggest question has always been, why did he immediately need to go back to Memphis or Ms to get the camper? At they point, why would he assume it was going to be a longterm, ongoing search??🤔
Thank you Justin !
Panic set in so quick because she realized chris actually carried out what he'd probably been threatening for months! That's why she immediately called Chris. Seth said she sleeps like a rock, Chris kept her on the phone until midnight and bowersox snuck Sebastian out, and bye bye Sebastian. No way would Katie tell anyone her suspicion she knows what happened but probably relieved he's gone. No way would they include Katie on what they did
That crazy video that came out in the beginning, where 3 people were doing something, could have been them loading Sebastian into a vehicle. Maybe it was nothing but it looked like three people struggling.
New sub🩷thanks for all you do and continue to do in this case! I appreciate you telling facts and not all this crazy drama that surrounds this case ! Its very sad all they are doing is causing chaos and distraction and takes the focus off of Poor Sebastion !! 💚I pray they find him n find him soon! And I hope he gets the justice he deserves! 💚thank you again! Watching from Hornlake MS! About 10 mins from the Yogi RV park 🥹💚praying for Sebastian 💚
Watching on replay! I’ll have to check out John’s lives.
Please do. They listen to him there and acknowledge his thoughts after he speaks.
I knew, imo that Chris was there that night that Sebastian went missing.
I believe so too! Or not to far away. I do not believe for one minute he was in Memphis @ work .
If they did a 3 way call...KP would have heard the Sheriff say he was on his way. In my honest opinion, that give KP more time to get home and not trace her whereabouts.
When we analyzed the audio we got a lot out of it. I wish you could have some one clean it up better.
2:18:40 hey just to let you know the temperature wasn’t that low on those two days in Hendersonville Sunday high was 57 low of 24 and Monday high was 69 low 37, in Tn this is pretty normal the weather is allll over the place here.
Katie had the house professionally cleaned right after he left.
In stead of searching for Sebastian
Yep! The house was cleaned with Bleach before LE or sheriff Dept etc was called. This was premeditated!
“Here we go-“ CP
Yeah we know exactly what he was saying. …!
What makes u think they didmt bury him in cementary or around the chruch.seeing cp told seth to go to chruch to get close to god n he might find his son. That sounds like a clue to me.
In regard to Pat Brown talking about Katie panic first interview and not so much second interview and how odd…. Not taking up for Katie but after repeating the same thing over and over I can kinda understand that. But not searching for your kid? Not out there side by side with Seth? No. I will never get that.
And Seth lives about an hour away from Hendersonville. So it’s not like Sebastian could walk there.
@@Redlily5150 Id be literally begging for anyone who had my kid to bring them back while begging people to help search!! I don't care how many times I had to say it .....I wouldn't stop!!
@@triamaria that’s exactly right and that is the reason none of this sets right with me.
And she has never searched! Not one time.
Katie hated Sebastian as much as CP did. Everything to them was Sebastian fault. The poor child should have been taken out of that home . I wish Sebastian had told his dad Seth everything before now And he probably would still be here.
Justice for Sebastian 💚💚💚
@@divaflow-lr7zs you know them?
Even more shady is that they didn't even call 911, they called the Sheriff or some other law enforcement didn't they? It wasn't even KP that called either.
Exactly Justin she has to pass the kitchen in order to get to Sebastian room. So she would’ve known he wasn’t in the kitchen.
They also saw Chris’s mom at Worshams General Store at 5:30 am Feb 26th. Maybe Melissa was with her.
I thought she was parked in front of the School? Anyways I think her & Katie switched vehicles because they are the same. Either way it’s very suspicious to me. 🤔
Sorry I guess I missed the live so I’ll catch up and watch the replay. Simply love your channel.
HIPPA applied to my job… Processing Payroll.. when dealing with Payroll accounts. (Employees Information)
Regarding the sea bag, I have 3 kids in the military. One of just one that who put her time in and when she was done had to return all the items that were giving to her. So I wouldn’t think they would still have that IMO but idk since they are no longer active duty. Not that they couldn’t buy one but there would be record of that.
He had boots from seth
Hello All
What about the fact that KP didn’t try to look in Sebastian’s phone to see if he called someone texted someone or googled directions somewhere before calling the sheriff or even cp
She probably did & just lying about it. Why was it charging in the kitchen instead of his room?
I go with the idea that Chris might have been home as early as Friday. Definitely so much investigating that was never done. Are TN LE waiting for a confession or are they protecting Chris & Katie?
I just said it in another comment that I believe they are protecting the Proudfoot's 🤬 There's something VERY off/weird going on with this case. I honestly don't think we'll ever see this case come to an end BUT I hope & pray I'm wrong 😔
Get them pearls
I sadly think the only way Sabastian will ever be found is if law enforcement does a better job and is more stern with katie and chris. I just dont see them getting information from them if they aren't be harder on the proudfoots. I hope to god each day we wale up one day and we see he is found maybe by the grace of god❤WE KEEP YOU IN OUR HEARTS SABASTIAN. YOU DID NOT DESERVE THIS😢WE LOVE YOU BUDDY💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
Wait, what? Melissa is worried that Seb may have gotten into the back seat of a car, fell asleep and woke up after someone got to their job and got out of the car.
Why would she think that? Partial truth? Super creepy. KPCP know. Plus others, IMO.
Oh she knows what is going on . He was put in a car & escaped, Running for his life but could only run so fast being Barefoot. but Chris caught up with him and it was over. So Melissa tell it all Because you know. IMO
You did see him & talked mean to him the night before???
I guess I was very lucky. My ex husband loved my oldest son as his own. When my son hurt my ex husband hurt. My ex was and still is very protective of my son even if my son is a adult. Even though we are not together we all have a good relationship.
First the Christy cement HD50 , then the distance 337 that just popped up on my tripometer suddenly
Hi Justin ) poker party ? First I heard of that interesting I’m sure gathering .
Why not put Katie in jail until she is ready to talk, like they did John Skeleton from Michigan, he is still in prison and that happen in 2010.
Are they staying in that house during CP's summer visitation? I wonder if they left Sebastian's room the way it was> This case is so sad and frustrating. I'm praying , in the name of Jesus, he's found soon.
They need interviewed again!
what about the house being cleaned by professional cleaners. I heard that several times
That’s very suspicious 🤔 But I did hear the house had been cleaned but I thought it was by Cp & KP. SMH 🤦♀️
Justin yes technically if Chris was the one that called he would have to call non emergency line if you do 911 in Memphis it goes to Memphis not to Sumner county. But Katie could've called it right away
I don't understand a LOT of things involving this case. CPS, the Proudfoot's and so many others have failed Sebastian on so many levels 😔
I have been saying that way before that he said that they were together
I remember my sister's dog got out n ran away ....I found her up n outside at 3 a.m. searching with a flashlight for her dog ....she was feeling so devastated she could not sleep or even sit still.......I rest my case....I've never blamed summers parents but I "feel" it with Sebastian's ...I have a feeling stepdad was home more than he claims because it's possible he left his phone at work but that is just a guess that's possibly wrong.....the "thud" she heard bothers me like she's describing something ...and setting it up in case she's caught.....Sebastian had a blood vessel or something on his head that apparently if it were struck could cause harm ....I always feel that someone struck him accidentally or intentionally right on that blood vessel.....that was probably the thud....ppl tend to add some truth to a lie to keep the story straight...
Really can we believe everything they said they are lying😡🚩
NO WE CAN'T!!! They've lied since day #1 and their stories changed constantly 🤬
No we cant
I think they didnt call the 911 line cuz everyone knows those lines are recorded.....records are kept....it would also take longer to comnect to local police and get to their home ..and whywere they so strict about his being on the laptop....?.i undertand at home alone but just for a few mins ....that rubs me wrong....
I got to thinking did anybody check his bed to see if he'd been in bed the covers would be messed up.
There was a car parked outside by his house at 3am.
Justin was the poker party on Friday ever reported to LE? This was the first time I have heard of it.
Justy, is it "Jules the K9 Handler?" If so, talk to Brittney at Allegedly asap
Did I read somewhere that a ball cap was found at the retention pond? That it had a shamrock on it like Chris' hat in this photo?
I did hear that too. Maybe when Narked Diver was searching.
I haven't heard that one..
@@Maui204 I wish I could remember where I heard that.
Watching late, couldn't it be questioned if he was still at 1130, she didn't go check on him only says she spoke to him, no proof he's there or even ok
And that is Crazy!
Hipaa is not only for healthcare workers. The shoe thing is possible. My friend's son is 5"6 and he wears a 12 in men. 😂 lol I got some feet on me too. Its a lot of big feets out here. Seth said in an interview that Sebastian's shoe size was pretty big too and Seb isnt that tall for the size shoe he wears.
If Sebastian and his mom were out that evening, is it possible that he didn't come home with her?
She never said whether his bed looked slept in that means a lot
Good thought! I never seen anyone say this before. They will start saying it now on a different channel. 😂
@@Janice-kp8on well I mean I would think that would be a huge detail, like did he ever get into bed also she never says that she looked in bathroom when looking for him
@@Janice-kp8on no mam we won't stop looking for Sebastian
I think he was locked in the garage, so when she got up and unlocked the garage door and he wasn't in there, she panicked, no reason to look through the house. She took the car out to make things look good.IMO
Welll,it’s about time it’s a Criminal Investigation Hallelujah 👏🏻😎This Case shouldn’t of waited SO LONG,too so this!! LE has given them Enough time too Do,what they’ve done 😒 Blows my mind 🤯
@@tracyhicks8441 What??? Who says LE has waited, they don't have to call it a criminal investigation for it to be one!!!
@@triamaria It has Not been treated as such Every one sees that. Now,after he’s been Gone so long it’s become criminal 🙄
It Blows my mind too! What’s really going on with LE?
@@tracyhicks8441 Nawww.....law enforcement is playing the Proudfoots, you really think Chris would have ran his mouth like he has if they called it a criminal investigation from the start?? Law enforcement doesn't bring in the FBI and all those outside agencies for a simple missing child case. I've seen this before.....most recently the West case in Cali. The DA has been involved for several months and sitting in on police interviews, Chris slipped saying that on Websluthes. Pay attention!!
Why didn't she ask neighbor to look for him or if she had seen Sébastien that morning
Because she already knew what happened & where Sebastian was.
He slept in garage too
Who did? Did LE say that in the presser or?
@@Lia2222 Chris and Katie said he did
@@meow-ox3md whaaat? Where can I listen to that? I'd like to hear it, please
@@Lia2222I’ve not heard anyone say that Sebastian slept in the garage. I think it’s a rumor that started with speculation and was somehow adopted as truth.
Sebastian did sleep in the Garage. Chris stated to Katie he was tired of smelling Piss in the house. And I think the night of his disappearance he slept in the Garage not his Bedroom.
Chris said that he won't go out the back door because of the noise it made too much noise and it scared him he also said he would be caught on cameras if he went out the back door
Chris told a Lie about the door! But of course cameras from the neighbor caught them on camera. I wonder why they didn’t have cameras? But 3 weeks later after Sebastian went missing the neighbor stated they were having some installed? But I think they had some before then and maybe uninstalled them.
What about contacting Dr. Phil? He said he's focusing on missing kids this year and just saw a show his own private investigators and found father and two daughters he abducted etc. Please 🙏 contact Dr. Phil and let him and his investigators on this Sebastian case?
Would one of the parents have to be the ones to contact him themselves?
No it's not a private or civil case it's a public case an amber alert situation. Dr. Phil said this year focusing on missing kids. Anyone can contact him them staff and give details about the case. He has his own private investigators and can investigate alibis employees co workers CPS documents court documents everything.
@@HoneyDassah oh cool
We need to tell Seth about this 🙏🏻
Whoever did something to SabAstian after they did what they did they went to clean there shoes or items
The dogs are given Sebastian's scent to track. So whatever scent they would get, would be Sebastian's.
She never checked the bathroom that be my first place I would check