Sky News host fact checks Linda Burney's ‘bizarre’ cordial statement to sell the Voice
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- Sky News host Andrew Bolt has fact-checked a “bizarre” statement from Indigenous Australians Minister Linda Burney about cordial in an attempt to sell the Voice to Parliament.
“Yesterday Burney did go off script, just briefly, to try to push people’s emotional buttons to support the Voice and made this extraordinary claim to explain why we needed the Voice written into our constitution,” he said.
Ms Burney claimed in parliament when questioned about the Voice that she had been to communities where babies are “drinking sweet cordial” instead of water because it’s “cheaper”.
“I fact-checked - a litre of cordial at Aldi, for instance, on special at a discount store ... is just over $2, but Woolies is meanwhile selling 10 litres of bottled water for just $6.40; that works out to 64 cents a litre, less than a third of the price of discount cordial,” M Bolt said.
“So, I’m calling bull on Burney’s argument.”
Just vote NO.
Well said. We are fed so much BS from Burnie and others.
She is helping the no campaign no end. Keep her going!
Burney is more concerned about following the party line then caring for regional indigenous Australians.
It's a NO from me. As Graham Richardson said (and I am not a Labor party voter) we don't need the Voice, use your vote at election time!
If it was really so important Albo could have legislated it on the first sitting of Parliament. They want it in the Constitution so it can never be removed if it becomes as corrupted as previous incarnations of Aboriginal Voices to Parliament such as ATSIC. As Marsha Langton said unless it is in the Constitution so no-one can ever remove it she does not support a VOICE. And did Albo and Burney listen to Voice of the Aboriginal delegation elected by their community in far north Western Australia when they visited Canberra recently to talk with Albo and Burney as they had not heard of the voice or the Uluru statement of the Heart(their community was not invited to discussions)? NO! they and all members of the ALP and Aboriginal Industry in Canberra refused to meet with this delegation. ALP etc do NOT listen to Aboriginal VOICES today so why will they listen if the referendum succeeds. Just another pigs noses in the trough entity.
The giant natural pearl necklace and earrings show that Linda is so far removed from the vast majority of Australian aboriginal people that it's obvious she does not speak for them.
you reckon she knows what one looks like?
Trust me, go to Kogarah and see in her natural habitat there.
Her jewellery is stunning. I noticed that too
I wonder if she got the pearl necklace in the same manner as Kamalhoe Harris ?? 🤔
I'm glad you added earrings after pearl necklace. You had me worried for a minute 😆😆😆.
This is exactly why to vote no. Imagine if these clowns got the voice. My god. Thorpe Burney. Australia wake up
It’ll be slippery slope, guaranteed.
Yes please do so.
Agreed
Every single one of these bureaucrats needs to be sacked and jailed. Total incompetence.
Starting with Jackie Lambie and Lidia Thorpe and Penny Wrong .
@@bobdooly3706 agreed, just so albo can watch and wet himself seeing what's going to happen to him.
Many on the yes party are fakes mayo has no aboriginal at all ,and this marcus stewart is Scottish
Totally agree
Why doesn't she ask where all the money has disappeared to that was directed towards making Aboriginal lives better. You could buy 10 truckloads of water just from the petty change jar of the billions spent.
Albo & Burney are both proving to be incompetent. This is just wasting millions of dollars that could have spent on a worthwhile project.
Ministers should be forced to answer the questions put to them instead of totally ignoring the question.
They give her a pass because to give her a hard time (as they would a white MP) would be shouted down as racist by the ABC/media. Add to the fact she's not the brightest spark to begin with.
@@peteormond2828 As of June 1, 2023, Linda Burney’s net worth is $5 Million. There is a famous proverb on Mars that says: if you are not ashamed, do what you want, do you think that after she has tasted the taste of money she will be satisfied or will she think of a new show other than "The Noise" in which the latest fashion shows are presented to the music of kangaroo and Corroboree dances led by "Pretty Boy Albo", I was just wondering, is this satiety after hunger.
I agree. It should be like a court room. Answer the question or you're in contempt - pay a fine or get locked up. Sick of this nonsense. They are incapable of answering a simple question.
Labor the masters of BS and evasion
Red flag for me is the pre-prepared written "answer" to questions from the other side. I expect it with Dorothy Dixers from their party colleagues but what we're seeing from the ALP here is obviously pre-planned evasion.
Well said Andrew. I'll give some good solutions so indigenous parents don't have to force their children to drink cordial in their water. Make all the government departments, State and Federal, publicly reveal how much money has been granted to such bodies as Land Councils and public servants running around in brand new Land Cruisers and Toyota Prado's supposedly supporting their indigenous community during the last 30 years. Then show us where it has all been spent. I don't see any special indigenous hospitals or schools, and why in 2023 do we still have some members of the indigenous community in rural Australia still living in humpies and derelict cars? Where have all the billions of $$$$$ gone? I'll tell you - Not to those who really need it.
They build homes for them...they smash them up.
They buy them cars...they drive them into the dirt and abandon them.
Then they build or buy them more.
Liquorland franchises doing very well..😂
Not to mention all the abandoned Land Cruisers and Pradas etc lining the sides of sides of the isolated out back Walk away when the break down and just buy a new one.
@@edmurks236I doubt that they even have to buy a new one, they just put it on the federal government’s tab.
@@edmurks236 Learn to spell.
Voting NO to the voice
All Australians should be embarrassed with the talent we have representing the country .
Talent you say?
Just have a look at question time , you can see all the pathetic , sloppy and untidy and cheaply dressed females on the benches govey and indi as well they all look like shit . Check out the un kept hair styles the messy hair and their terrible clothes . They all couldn't give a shit , but they are having the last laugh at you critical public because they are laughing their heads off going home to their privileged lives .Its really scary these lazy slobs make decisions about your future is very frightening .
It’s always been the same with a a few noble exceptions.
Ronald McDonald would do a better job than FIFO 32% IMPLANT APHONEY ALBO.
Talent is not a word I would use
A leading “Yes” campaigner (Mayo) for the Voice to Parliament hopes it will be a step towards getting non-Indigenous Aussies to “pay the rent” for living on Australian land.
Last time I looked at my bank account there’s a big fat mortgage looking back at me. You would think white Aussies get land for free. No one gets ahead in Australia without a lot of hard work.
We already “ pay the rent” to the tune of 33 Billion yearly by all accounts.
For a grifter cunxt like mayo naise
@@swordscot and that is only for 60% of it.
@@swordscot We have always paid rent, it is called taxes.
"If politicians don't follow our advice they will be punished"
Thomas Mayo.
VOTE NO
And did not Albo himself say "Any government that rejects a suggestion from the Voice will do so at their peril"? Yet now they say the Voice will have no power to do anything and is an advisory body only. How stupid do they think Australians are?
@@saintsone7877 they think we are VERY stupid.
@@seanwalker2070 Sadly, there is much truth in your statement.
Thomas Mayo is a communist and works for the U N
@seanwalker2070
and they are right ....
Say no to homosexuality, promiscuity, tattoos and drugs.
What you think is different to what you know...& I don't think people are stupid....
That not the first load of tripe she has spoken this week.
Burney seems to think she's so far above all of us who have questions, and that it is beneath her to engage in trying to answer our legitimate questions.....as if the Australian people are unimportant in the scheme of things. How dare she treat the Australian people with such contempt......big disappointment coming your way Burney, I have a feeling you won't be in that job for much longer.
It's the normal working Australia that doesn't have a voice in parliament.
She’s an aboriginal woman. Don’t you dare question anything that she says or does. If you do, that makes you racist and sexist
She has Penny Wong as a teacher on how to not answer questions!
The Voice is a despicable process to split the Australian population.
Divide and rule
Absolutely correct.
In 10 years they can say sorry to all Australians
I was quite shocked to hear recently that an aboriginal man took to court that he should be allowed to claim the age pension 3 yrs early because Aboriginal men died earlier than no Aboriginals. It then dawned on me what Aboriginals interpretation of the Voice meant to various Aboriginal people and what are the ordinary Aboriginal people expecting. I want to vote Yes but will it become one big can of worms and strife for the nation majorly divided.
@@alanbrookes6637The 1967 referendum removed race from the Australian Constitution. It certainly doesn’t need to be racist in 2023. Help to the aboriginal population can be done with legislation. I’m voting No to constitutional change.
Where is parental responsibility? Where is individual responsibility for the community problems across the board, not just remote/rural Aboriginal communities. All communities. We are Australians first.
It’s apparently my fault that strangers are giving their kids straight sugar….
They can’t sell the voice with superficial obfuscatory BS. It’s all clearly BS 🤷🏽♀️
Absolutely 👍 if it walks like BS, and talks like BS, then it’s definitely BS
“BS” stands for “Burney-speak”
A Good salesman can try and sell a polished turd but at the end of the day it’s still a turd. Everyone’s disadvantaged in the country hell I live in central Queensland and by average I do two or three years younger
@@dont_listen_to_Albo😂😂😂😂
I'm with Bolty on this one. Well said Andrew.
@@toask2576 I was only agreeing with what he said, nothing else.
@@toask2576 Check your medications when you wake up.
"We have reached the ultimate stage of absurdity where some people are being held responsible for things that happened before they were born, while other people are not held responsible for what they themselves are doing today."
Someone needs to say that to Burney
Excellent summation
Funny how we don’t keep hearing the stories about all the indigenous Aussies who have achieved success from politicians to athletes to writers. There are limitless possibilities for all Australians. If new Australians can make a go of it, why can’t every aboriginal? Is it a lack of motivation or willpower? Are indigenous people inherently unable to live in the modern world? Isn’t it racism to think so? I find it confusing. Life is a series of choices for all of us. Are indigenous Australians less capable of making good choices than the rest of us?
@@bernie4268 the racism of low expectations
One of the best statements i’ve heard in a long time
To make a cordial drink you need water! Just leave out the cordial Linda and guess what you have water!!!! I think that women is putting something other than cordial in her water!!!
I'd guess champagne,!
🤣🤣🤣
She's the Kamala Harris of Australia.
Without the cackling- thank goodness
@@ozzyace71. Thank f@%k.
That’s an insult to Kamala!
She seems more like Biden with that dementia onset problem
@@alffox9151 Fantastic comment.....I nearly wet myself laughing at what you said.....Love it!!
Describing Linda as bizarre doesn't go far enough.
This Burney woman is Australia's Nancy Pelosi... doesn't have a clue.
.....and relies on a bottle to get to the end of a day!
And how she’s become queer. Vote NO.
This seems to be the Socialist Labour Party’s theme regarding questions about the Voice! Elbow refuses to answer anything saying the questions don’t deserve a Prime-ministerial response, and Blah blah Burnie doesn’t know anything about what she is sprouting?
Have yourself a s'wonderful Referendum defeat and enjoy a resounding thumping in an early Federal election and know that being a raving Skynut has a limited future. 😒🙄🤫😊🤣
No I think it's the fascist radicals who are trying ti take over.
Cordial is added to water, you don't just have cordial.😳 But I have seen a woman give her child red wine in a bottle to help her sleep and to be quiet. No voice will help just action.
One law for all Australians. Barney doesn't know what she is talking about.
For the children's sake Vote "No"
You need metho. 😊🌴
....yeah,...and I've seen 2year Olds eating vienetta ice creams for breakfast....some good parenting going on there!!
She's a little bit 🤪
She's lying anyway if she was telling the truth she wouldn't have to read it.
I think Ally who wrote for her the script. 😂😂
Politicians really don't need a piece of paper to lie to the public man. They do it all the time.
@neverends3188or a sand bag to fall for
@@drconflict629 Burney usually doesn’t lie but the people around her are liars and manipulative.
Tom Mayo wrote her answers...communist aboriginal party....
The tax dollars already spent need be accounted for.
The longer this goes, the more it undermines not only the “policy” around the Voice (whatever it may be), but it undermines confidence on every other policy. What the hell are these people doing ????
They're pushing their Marxist agenda that's what
What they are told to do.
What confidence?
Good work Andrew.👏
Burney is an embarrassment.🇦🇺
I have concerns about her mental faculties.
Is she Related to Biden, asking for a friend 😂🇬🇧
@@julieclonan2427 🤣🤣🤣🤣
They get billions of taxpayer dollars every year and they can't afford bottled water?
That's because the average person the money was meant for never received the money in the first place. Their (alleged) elite get it all, which is why they are fighting so hard, telling lies.
Because the top dogs are getting the dough, not the poor ones in rural Aussie.
Spot on 💯 Andrew, Hopefully she will go off script permanently. Burni is past corherant, unfortunately labour has the numbers in Parliament to pass the Albo Abo Bill
Do you think that's it right?
Vote no Australia
You’re Irish and you support your pals the Provisional IRA murderers of the innocent Australian civilians Stephen Melrose and Nick Spanos. Your opinion is less than worthless.
OK
@@jamesmorrow1646you're out voted
Listening to Burney is enough reason to vote NO, she looks to be doing it so tough, when did she walk the streets of Alice Springs or FNQ at night
People who sell cow manure have a better results than Albo and dregs with their voice
2 cents CCP bot.
@@buildmotosykletist1987 I’m sure China would love the voice 🤡
Hey atleast cow shit can actually help something grow the hells the voice gonna do black handpicked parliament? Get the kids irregardless of skin colour some better education or even better yet figure out that someone living 200km from the nearest doctor probably won’t live as long as someone in Sydney im from Mackay I probably won’t live as long as someone from Melbourne on average so be it
The remote aboriginal communities I was in 15 years ago, often the conditions were so bad, if it was anyone else they would have their kids taken off them immediately.
Rubbish. Where is your proof. You have none. Just so.e id"ot running off at the mouth . You are probably Emglish Australian born in Mosman. You are the type of whities going on about aboriginal people. Rich and privileged.
She's drunk in the house again 🤣
Frankly I don't know a great deal about this Burney character. However when ever I see her & listen to her, she seems completely out of her depth and clueless. This is what's happening all over the world when the wrong people are placed into a position not based on 'best at doing the job' but instead 'ticks a box'.
Burney always sounds drunk.
I was going to ask if she’d been drinking
This is not fair. She went to the shop and the goon was cheaper than water!
Drunk on power 🍷
Chardonnay.
Glue, E10 or VB. Take you pick
How crazy is this woman water is cheaper than cordial and why would one need the voice to address this probem ,what a nutta
Hahaha marie you're very funny. But i think the voice is enough. Or what do you think?
Burney has been on the cordials...shots and schooners of it.
She’s up there with Biden, what a waste of space.
Some of the scripts were written by the Attorney General. The question about Mayo's desire to dismantle our democracy is valid. Senator Thorpe said as much the other day in Parliament. I also note that the PM in recent speeches has refrained from mentioning the voice, instead he talks about recognition and reconciliation. The PM has the power to introduce legislation to have the voice placed into Parliament. If it is that urgent and will cure all the ills facing Indigenous people, why hasn't he done it?
because it won't be in the constitution & by just being legislated, Dutton's mob can boot it to the kerb when they get into power, as they will. Albanese needs the Greens to support him to get it into legislation, but it's no given that he can rely on those retards.
... all we need to do is vote NO..
This is Governer General territory now.. It's very obvious the Voice is a Trojan horse..
He wants to be able to blame those who vote yes for all of the consequences if it gets up……Protect Your Freedom and Your Families……VOTE NO
The whole premise of the voice that only aboriginals can solve aboriginal problems is deeply flawed.
First things first. Andrew welcome back. Second things second. The 'Voice' is doomed.
Second thing second? Too much logic for this debate.
Hope ya right Ed. There's alot of feel-good no brainers in this country
in communities where the water is below world standards local councils supply water free. Yuelamu, Laramba and Nyirripi being three examples I know of who have been supplied free drinking water free of charge to community members.
Shows how little Burney knows about Aboriginal communities.
Andrew, cordial is made with water, you have to have water to make cordial
If she is the best we have OMG pathetic.
Never knew people like Linda were actually born😮
These politicians tell us how hard the indigenous have suffered and less life expectancy etc etc.
Don't tell us how much is being spent on them ,while the rest of Australians suffer!
If the children are being fed cordial instead of water then no wonder they have a limited life expectancy.
Wow we need "The Voice" to get the kids off the cordial 😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣👍
👍🏽
Great point 👉
😂
Boycott Cottees!!
Which section of the current constitution requires Aboriginal children to be fed cordial?
Why doesn't she run into the bush and drink cordial, but you will need some water with that!
She would not survive in the bush.
All while wearing Gucci of course. Love how these clueless puppets try to relate to us “commoners”.
Don't you have to ADD water to cordial to make it drinkable?
Burney’s is so out of her depth she is drowning.
Let’s do Weekend at Burney’s and try to find out what drugs she’s on!!! So we can avoid them
what a joke, attempting to equivocate the voice as being necessary to stop kids being given cordy in instead of water
Burney seems very unwell, struggling to breathe and speak her dribble
sick em rex , keep it up
She doesn't answer any questions - ever.
This woman get a sentence out without struggling
Gosh and we are to believe her?
@Sky I really like the reporter. Please keep him .
With all the things Burney says the voice can't or won't do, what the hell is point of having it? To Bolt's point of already knowing the problems and doing bugger all to fix them, how does the voice change that?
So good to have you back on air Andrew.
What has linda burney done with all the money....
Ummm, what do you mix cordial with? Is she saying those kids were drinking cordial concentrate?
Pull the other one!
When you remove the foundation, the whole building collapses.
If one was to ask Linda Burney what day it is she would need the script and still stuff it up.
Vote No
Well said,Andrew. We certainly do need a Voice but it's a Voice of Sanity! Thanks for exposing these phonies & the useful idiots that support their dangerous ideas.
Linda telling the truth about the voice is like believing James Mason was an angelic choirboy who would never have harmed a soul
Cordial has to be mixed with water anyway. They wouldn't be drinking it straight.
Ya just don't know , I have heard they discovered another great way to use petrol .
@@alank616 yeah I've had first hand experience of what petrol sniffing can do. I use to work at the Alice Springs Hospital.
Perfectly said Andrew. Labor won't answer any questions because they either don't know, or are hiding the truth. Vote NO to dividing Australians by race.
I want my own "Affairs Minister" please????
She (Linda) is definitely a good story teller for her mob 😁
VOTING NO!!! All BS!!!
linda the liar.
It’s like $5 for a 1L bottle of cordial…what is she talking about? Lol
Last time I checked... you need WATER to add to the CORDIAL lol
She always sounds like she's been enjoying some Parliament House wine...
Burney sounds like a dear old grandmother who speaks from the heart, but has nothing to say. Sound familiar?
Yeah. i had a though of that too. What do you think?
The ' Voice ' is dead on arrival !
How much does a carton of VB cost, must be cheaper than water as well.
Andrew, I'd use stronger words than just tripe, rubbish, BS, bull, garbage to describe Burney et al's arguments for a Voice. So we need a multi-million $ Voice to advise the minister some children were being fed sweetened cordial when she found out directly by talking with a citizen. What measures did she immediately take to determine how widespread this practice was & what measures to implement to stop this practice! I'll have a private guess what the answer is.
Cordial is mixed with .... WATER.
2c CCP bot
@@__Diagnosis : LOL, now you are stalking me.
I condemn the evil CCP, you are a member of the CCP.
@@AnAlsAWOL : I condemn the evil CCP. Do you ?
@@AnAlsAWOL : Why didn't you condemn the CCP? You will never post a proper condemnation of the CCP, just an innocuous "I do".
Any idiot like you who sits here all day knows that like all Aussies I despise the CCP. I know how bad the CCP are from my neighbours in Falun Gong.
She sounds as if she's drunk
GEE, AND I ALWAYS ASSUMED CORDIAL HAD TO BE MIXED WITH WATER TO EVEN MAKE THE STUFF DRINKABLE.
SATT.
Ahhh, the “cordial” paradox!!😂 The water isn’t good enough, but we don’t want a fix for the water… we want more money to flavour the water, regardless of the health (socioeconomic implications) that will continue!
Cordial can only make crappy water taste better, and if your willing to drink it mixed with cordial… it wasn’t so bad in the first place!!!
Considering that the PM and his ministers have no denounced Thomas Mayos comments, we can only assume that they support them. Linda Burney in fact, reckons that Mayo is a decent fellow. I have a theory - If you are wondering about the fine print of the Voice and what will happen after the referendum - I have been reading the UN General Assembly on the rights of Indigenous people. There are numerous chapters, but it essentially says that Indigenous people have the right for self determination. This is interesting, because when Gough Whitlam started campaigning for aboriginal rights, that was his main goal and various Labour governments have continued in this vein. Now, Gough is Albanese’s hero and he wants to emulate Gough and live up to Gough’s expectations or even go one better and deliver Gough’s goal and deliver the UN General Assembly goals.
This also fits with the goals of the 1982 National Aboriginal Conference, where a draft Makaratta detailed requirements for self determination or Aboriginal Sovereignty. There are some pretty scary demands in this Draft (eg tax relief for 195 years, payment of 5% of GDP for 195 years etc- research it for yourself). Aboriginal Sovereignty was also the main driver at the Canberra Tent Embassy. Articles from this Makaratta appear also to be included in the Uluṟu Statement from the Heart. Marcia Langton and Patrick Dodson would be most aware of the 1982 Makaratta. And the kicker - In 2022 an expression of interest was released by Penny Wong for an Aboriginal Ambassador to “lead indigenous perspectives experiences and interests into foreign policy and First Nations trade and investment” - I expect because the Voice has further un-mentioned goals. So, when Albanese says “trust us”, it will all be worked out after the referendum. Just like his pre-election promises - that has worked out too well.
So why doesn’t the government want to give out further details on the Voice? In absence of any detail from the government, it can only be concluded that Aboriginal self determination or Aboriginal Sovereignty is the clear driver behind the Voice and these details are what is being kept from the Australian people. So a No vote would be appropriate.
It's like a Weekend at Bernie's.
what we need is an AUDIT from the 36MILLION we give the abos every year
You mean $33 billion not million...
Billion plus what they receive from mining
@@Yvonne-le6ju
Rubbish!
Each year the Australian Federal Government pays for Indigenous programmes , to the value of $ 33 billion dollars....
Nothing to do with mining ...
Mining fees are paid by the corporation involved , to the Indigenous Land Councils & are not paid by the State or Federal governments!
$8 for 2 litres of cordial in remote communitys. $12 for 24x 600ml bottles. Fact
Which makes it $1.20 a litre. Fact.
@@tellyfaulkner3466 she obviously didn't study economic's.
@@ericrochester8835 No, it was probably rocket science lol.
But you need the water to mix with the cordial 😮😮😮
@@user-hj5jf3zl5l Use the tap. Take your hand and turn.
We have to pass the bill in order to know what is in the bill-Nancy Pelosi rules.
Do we actually have light weights like that in parliament? My god!
You need water to mix with the cordial?
Well, at least she didn’t claim they’re drinking bong water 😂