6:33 here, I would like to know, when the music idea emerges, how does the composer write down such a very complicated segment? There is barely a main theme here that he can write down real quick. And if he improvise on the piano or singing, there is no recorder at his time. ... is there any document addressing this?
It finally remains the composers secret. But in this moment you can hear the main theme changing according to the situation. From the rhythm you can still recognise the theme declining from the soprano, which at the same time comes from the bass almost in it's original form. It's a very strong contradiction! Even though Schumann is a master of improvisation in his composition every single note is quite on purpose!
@@TeacherAndy thank you so much! this analysis renews my understanding to his way of composition. Maybe there is no real improvisation at least in this piece. But it's amazing how he's telling a story so naturally that the audience feels like he improvised...
Dear Mr. Andy, it’s my pleasure to find you from the TH-cam. 我的女兒正在申請大學，有些學校除了essays 外，還要求孩子們寄上一段5-8minutes的 film來介紹自己高中四年的特別經歷，我很想把這首曲子做她film的背景音樂，否則怕太boring了，Mr. Andy 請您告訴我，這首曲子適不適合作為背景音樂🎶還是您有更適合的推薦給我？那麼萧邦的夜曲okay 嗎？謝謝您的反饋❤❤❤
感謝教授分享這麼美的音樂和故事，建築出偉大的音樂愛情教堂，謝謝您！
古典音乐真的是至美，感谢分享❤❤❤❤❤
真正的爱情故事都很伟大，因为这个世界大家都是普通得平凡人
Happy-ending 的故事令人喜歡。
不論多少次，都要謝謝安迪老師的無私分享，不知道為何，流行音樂與鋼琴單一的彈奏比較，只有鋼琴的古典樂才能使我平靜下來，雖然只要音樂我都喜歡，但簡單比較上述兩者，對我的影響還是很大。
如果沒聽過您的一番曲解，我可能永遠都很難進入古典音樂的世界，而且簡單的曲子，經過您的手彈奏後，也變得有趣，謝謝您。愛情的確偉大，甚至可以改變一個人，或更多身邊的人，雖然不想再與“愛情”有關係，但我仍欣賞人類這份特殊的情感 ❤
和聲很浪漫💕同時帶著ㄧ絲徬徨不安的情緒 有一段旋律 似乎有李斯特第3號安慰曲的味道 謝謝安迪老師導聆💗
真是美好動人又浪漫的曲子，很喜歡老師流𣈱溫潤的琴聲和生動的導聆，原來樂曲的表達可以這麼豐富，開心有情人終成眷屬！❤❤
非常喜欢这首曲子，让我回想起参观舒曼和克拉拉博物馆时的心境， 谢谢老师的分享。
老師把每一首曲子都彈的很優美 好聽❤
謝謝老師分享！👏👏👏🙏👍
謝謝安迪老師🎉。 好聽的琴音、加上解說曲子含義真有意思呀！❤
老師的琴高音很美，清脆而溫暖，能在自己的家裡彈這樣的鋼琴，一定很幸福！盼望老師能多介紹更多蕭邦的音樂..
好的
在当今这个时代，生活艰难，工作繁忙，很多人失业失望，能够享受这么美好的爱情音乐真是在提醒我们真真的爱是存在的
謝謝妳。
总是能在安迪老师这里找到宁静，谢谢老师分享！
一段快樂又悲情的哀怨愛情故事·由安迪老師的琴聲詮譯出扣人心弦的旋律🎶
也曾經為舒曼·克拉拉和布拉姆斯的真摯愛情故事感動的哭了……
真愛是無價的！
謝謝❤️老師為我們彈奏如此美妙的樂章·🎶分享古老風景建築🏰·讓人心曠神怡～有些地方似曾相識啊……❤😂🥰
是taj mahal ,謝謝您。
哈哈哈🤣⋯⋯安廸老師想像力太豐富了，可以用文字表達出曲子的故事。👍
謝謝你的愛的留言 。
我很喜歡安迪老師的節目❤謝謝您
爱情到底是什么呢这么甜美又折磨一对佳人。安迪老师真的继续给我们讲舒曼和克拉拉的故事太体贴啦，演奏非常细致好听谢谢老师～❤
好甜蜜
百聽不厭
很有愛！🩷
感謝老師生動詳細的解說。
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉😊
謝謝你那麼認真地看我們的影片。
6:33 here, I would like to know, when the music idea emerges, how does the composer write down such a very complicated segment? There is barely a main theme here that he can write down real quick. And if he improvise on the piano or singing, there is no recorder at his time. ... is there any document addressing this?
It finally remains the composers secret. But in this moment you can hear the main theme changing according to the situation. From the rhythm you can still recognise the theme declining from the soprano, which at the same time comes from the bass almost in it's original form. It's a very strong contradiction! Even though Schumann is a master of improvisation in his composition every single note is quite on purpose!
@@TeacherAndy thank you so much! this analysis renews my understanding to his way of composition. Maybe there is no real improvisation at least in this piece. But it's amazing how he's telling a story so naturally that the audience feels like he improvised...
Dear Mr. Andy, it’s my pleasure to find you from the TH-cam. 我的女兒正在申請大學，有些學校除了essays 外，還要求孩子們寄上一段5-8minutes的 film來介紹自己高中四年的特別經歷，我很想把這首曲子做她film的背景音樂，否則怕太boring了，Mr. Andy 請您告訴我，這首曲子適不適合作為背景音樂🎶還是您有更適合的推薦給我？那麼萧邦的夜曲okay 嗎？謝謝您的反饋❤❤❤
我覺得可以
@@TeacherAndy Okay will do! 謝謝大師🙏