Being an admirer of PWA, it is really cool. PWA is a great way to build products. The only thing that itches me is Apple's unwillingness to fully support PWA
If you mean that androids should run PWA as default then: compability with older versions If you mean gplay should do this process automatically: there might be unforseen problems with generated apps. Better to let developers deal with them i suppose.
I agree with you, App stores are the default way users look for apps, if Google created the concept of PWA they could put a category for PWA in the Play Store.
TWA is better than PWA for android th-cam.com/video/rF8nPbOiwWM/w-d-xo.html Also TWA supports everything that browser supports the file selection, Camera API, microphone API and there is absolutely no perfomance degrade
Yeah, Apple is the big PITA when it comes to PWAs...seemingly little to no interest in implementing anything but the most basic PWA features (ie service worker and add to homescreen).
I have been following the PWA path and wrapped my app finally in TWA. However, I'm struggling for weeks to publish on Play Store because the reviewers keeps repeating this information that Web Applications aren't accepted in the Play Store. I have been trying to describe to them that this is not a violation of Google guidelines but rather it is following the guidelines. did I waste my time on this contradiction??!!
Got my TWA published on Google Play, but when you open it displays a notification "Running in Chrome". Who is responsible for this notification? It should be removed, users keep asking what it means...that's silly
How the same can be possible for iphone's? I'm planning to build a TWA app for apple devices as well. Open for suggestions all the time. Thanks in advance.
Are PWA capable of getting Geolocation from device while in background, if not is there a way to still get the location save it and send it till user opens up the app ?
I'm really missing a way how to remove chrome navigation bar. I've tried to set standalone and fullscreen mode, tried to use webview and custom tabs, nothing helps me. Even 20-minutes googling about it didn't help. Any ideas?
i dont need smartphone anymore i need a smart browsing device with all built in native feature and run a PWA with native feature support ..... and make the call and other basre minimum activity in the browser itself
Looks all good.. until you try to bake an APK yourself!! The frustrations that followed when you see the 'Running in Chrome' in the notification shade. What's the point? I mean all these steps to make it a 'native' Android app. . and there's no way to suppress the notification. It is frustrating after hours and hours of work just to discover, oh crap, think i've made a wrong decision to go with PWA. And with all these heavy marketing and talks about PWA... goes down the drain, when users sees that the app they downloaded is merely a website, or worst still, they might have the impression that the app is tracking them via Chrome or such...
I think PWA will never be 'Native' apps if it keeps showing the 'Running in Chrome' notification all the time. The Chrome browser remnants got to be suppressed if it is to be a TRUE native app.
Before anyone wastes their time (as I did) by following this tutorial to create an app, you should know something very important: the "TWA" that you generate is NOT treated as a native app. It will be launched with this ugly warning message that says "Running in Chrome" and the user will have to dismiss that warning manually. You CANNOT remove this error message, and it will come back up to once per week, even after the user has dismissed it. Incredibly disappointing and defeats the entire purpose of this PWA/TWA process. Don't waste your time on this.
Being an admirer of PWA, it is really cool. PWA is a great way to build products. The only thing that itches me is Apple's unwillingness to fully support PWA
If Apple does support PWAs it will hurt there app store market
If Apple don't support pwa's theres literally no point.
@@judewestburner Depends on where your market is... Globally, Android is by far the more popular OS @79% (Q4 2019) and is projected to be 87% by 2022
@@HowaYe in general (and I'm an Android user) paying customers and businesses tend to be on iPhone
Why not "simply" enabling developers to publish their PWA through the URL on the Google play store without any extra wrapping ?
This is called "the Internet" ;)
If you mean that androids should run PWA as default then: compability with older versions
If you mean gplay should do this process automatically: there might be unforseen problems with generated apps. Better to let developers deal with them i suppose.
I agree with you, App stores are the default way users look for apps, if Google created the concept of PWA they could put a category for PWA in the Play Store.
@@SiriusFuenmayor Also, surely Google Search can be the 'app store' for PWAs...not too good for 'browsing', but for searching it should work well.
TWA is better than PWA for android th-cam.com/video/rF8nPbOiwWM/w-d-xo.html Also TWA supports everything that browser supports the file selection, Camera API, microphone API and there is absolutely no perfomance degrade
So great!!! Let's hope apple treats better PWAs
@Y K The EU should fine them for blocking competition
Yeah, Apple is the big PITA when it comes to PWAs...seemingly little to no interest in implementing anything but the most basic PWA features (ie service worker and add to homescreen).
I have been following the PWA path and wrapped my app finally in TWA. However, I'm struggling for weeks to publish on Play Store because the reviewers keeps repeating this information that Web Applications aren't accepted in the Play Store. I have been trying to describe to them that this is not a violation of Google guidelines but rather it is following the guidelines. did I waste my time on this contradiction??!!
Same here, months gone but not able to figure it out to publish it. Review comments are always same, looks like they are auto generated
@@optimistanoop have you or fayez ticked the "this app is for children" or said that the app is ok for
@@specy_ thanks for the reply, this seems helpful, I will try and let you know here.
@@optimistanoop Well?
Cached files from service worker expire pretty fast , 3 days and app stop works without internet. Is there any way to embed images/files into apk ?
Got my TWA published on Google Play, but when you open it displays a notification "Running in Chrome".
Who is responsible for this notification? It should be removed, users keep asking what it means...that's silly
Yeah thats really sucks, im still trying to find a way how to hide that
did you find any way to remove this notification ?
@@qaedid936 did you find any way to remove this ?
What are the native features of android we can use with this approach?
how to change jdk file path ?? i have written wrong path
bubblewrap no longer generates assetlinks.json
Does Google web sign in works with TWA ?
It's definitely progress but it's still pretty complicated 🤯
totally agree with you!... the less the clicks the better
which one would you choose masters for cross-platform?
1-bringing web to other device ?
2-bringing other technologies to the web ?
1
Looks fine but why would I use this instead of cordova which builds for multiple platforms not just android?
Beats me. Been a Cordova guy for a decade and whilst it's not always been the smoothest ride it has at least worked the while time
It is as simple?
I have question, in native app I can make UDP message to client or server is PWA Capable for this ?
Thank you for this tutorial. unfortunately, I'm getting the following error: "Bubblewrap is not recognized as an internal or external command".
Can this be used programmatically, so I can have a button to make an apk from my PWA using some configuration on my web site?
It's years down the line with PWA and TWA's & I am still struggling with the monetization options 😅
So it's not a good idea to use that method?
How the same can be possible for iphone's?
I'm planning to build a TWA app for apple devices as well.
Open for suggestions all the time.
Thanks in advance.
You can also do this without downloading anything, using Microsoft's PWABuilder
Alas not, that creates a PWA from a website, not an APK from a PWA
Are PWA capable of getting Geolocation from device while in background, if not is there a way to still get the location save it and send it till user opens up the app ?
TWA supports everything that browser supports do give it a try th-cam.com/video/rF8nPbOiwWM/w-d-xo.html
Hi ,
May I know we can hide/remove address bar. It's possible ? If possible please share here step by step
Thanks
Anandharaj Ramasamy change the "display" property in your manifest.json to "standalone" (there are others as well)
@@georgehowarth2388 thanks. It's work for me ☺️👍
Hope this can be simplified and improved!
I'm really missing a way how to remove chrome navigation bar. I've tried to set standalone and fullscreen mode, tried to use webview and custom tabs, nothing helps me. Even 20-minutes googling about it didn't help. Any ideas?
you need to upload correct assetlinks.json inside /.well-known directory on your web server
@@AlexGuerrero007 thank you! It helps.
TWA is better than PWA for android th-cam.com/video/rF8nPbOiwWM/w-d-xo.html TWA also removes chrome navigation bar do give it a try
i dont need smartphone anymore i need a smart browsing device with all built in native feature and run a PWA with native feature support ..... and make the call and other basre minimum activity in the browser itself
so we don't have to use ionic/cordova anymore. great
You still need it for your iOs app
Notification requires permission from user. While this is "Trusted Web Activities" it should have delegated by default.
Looks all good.. until you try to bake an APK yourself!! The frustrations that followed when you see the 'Running in Chrome' in the notification shade. What's the point? I mean all these steps to make it a 'native' Android app. . and there's no way to suppress the notification. It is frustrating after hours and hours of work just to discover, oh crap, think i've made a wrong decision to go with PWA. And with all these heavy marketing and talks about PWA... goes down the drain, when users sees that the app they downloaded is merely a website, or worst still, they might have the impression that the app is tracking them via Chrome or such...
I think PWA will never be 'Native' apps if it keeps showing the 'Running in Chrome' notification all the time. The Chrome browser remnants got to be suppressed if it is to be a TRUE native app.
did you find any way to remove this ?
I dont andustand any think
👍🏻👏🏻
Before anyone wastes their time (as I did) by following this tutorial to create an app, you should know something very important: the "TWA" that you generate is NOT treated as a native app. It will be launched with this ugly warning message that says "Running in Chrome" and the user will have to dismiss that warning manually. You CANNOT remove this error message, and it will come back up to once per week, even after the user has dismissed it. Incredibly disappointing and defeats the entire purpose of this PWA/TWA process. Don't waste your time on this.
Hola, hagamos un grupo de 5 personas, y le pagamos a algún desarrollador para que nos dé clases
Should have built it sooner🥵
Or just pass the URL to your friend. Done, no need for play store.
Better title: Let's say HYPOTHETICALLY you want to ship your PWA as an android app.
No thanks! NO ADMOB or ADSENSE/SPA SUPORT!