"The councel I AM!" Said Yoda as he ignited his crimson and blood red short lightsaber and jumped with supersonic speed to attack while emitting a storm of force lightning capable of killing a whole clone trooper battalion at once.
@@alericantonelli4656 No. He killed the younglings because they were Jedi, and Sidious wanted all Jedi, young and old, dead so they would never become a threat to his power.
@@patriciahayes2664 There are some videos out there (and a comic, from which the knowledge in said videos is based on) that shows that Anakin DID in fact convince himself that it was a mercy killing, and that all other possible futures would have been "even worse" for them.
Horrifyingly enough, Anakin probably did the kids a mercy by giving them the 66-86 treatment. Think about it this way: would you prefer death, or living under whatever twisted experiments and indoctrination Sidious could have cooked up. For reference, we should think of what Sidious turned Maul into after he got his hands on the Zabrak at about the same age as that "master Skywalker" kid.
@@JoshuaValentine just to let you know, they would fuck your mind until you turned it the dark, Vader would cut off limbs and be extremely punishing just to teach life lessons, and you would be expendable. It’s not as good as it sounds.
@@sciathoir Yeah, the physical and mental torture as well as being a slave without will and forced to kill people, especially those who you used to be with at school does not sound very nice
"We don't need to explain why giving a four year old a laser sword wasn't the best idea" Sith master teaching their apprentices: hold my Corellian beer
Usually Sith acolytes and apprentices were older (and didn't get a lightsaber until they were actually apprenticed to a Sith Lord, if SWTOR is any indication).
@@johnquach8821 sounds like pre rule of two. I don't think one of the later Sith Lords would mind choosing the strongest 4 year old by having him kill the other. They only want the very strongest.
@@johnquach8821 Not just experienced in life but also already jaded, hateful, angry, and insane. It was easier to turn them and teach them and have them grow if they were already a Sith minus the teachings.
I think what would have made the Order better as a whole is if they allowed the young to experience all emotions, instead of suppressing the bad ones. That way, they have a better understanding of themselves and how they can improve the Galaxy and their own lives.
They didn’t suppress their bad emotions they learn to control them. That’s like saying yes allow children to have temper tantrums and basically be as mean and cruel as possible because we should let children experience full motion. No, that’s not how it works. See we’re taught at a young age on how to regulate our emotions otherwise people get hurt in the case of the Jedi their actual physical consequences. For us it’s just emotional ones. So first of all, they’re not hot to suppress their emotions or taught to control them. Geetsly actually made a video making that point abundantly clear. Why does everyone not listen to that part?
Agreed. It's about balance of feeling yet controlling emotions. Spok and General Kenobi are good examples. May you live long and prosper, and be one with the force.
the jedi order didn't have an issue with negative emotions lol, their main problem was teaching control and self discipline so that such emotions wouldn't drive their usage of the force; the dark side
I wish we had a game dedicated to us making a character that's starts from a planet of our choosing with a backstory we can choose and we start as youngling to try to become a Jedi master (if turn to the dark side) It would probably have to be in the old republic era or beyond that.
So cool, I mean I think I’m okay with both options if they are not pick to become an apprentice I like the idea of given the option of leaving the order and encouraging the learned training and experience to share with the universe And although it may seem low to be a support role for the Jedi infrastructure I think it still awesome especially if your the type to want to support the cause and all
Knowing what I do now I'd prepare for leaving the order, meaning I'd want a pilot's license and credentials showing that I have a good education (I'd need the to survive out there)...I would also learn as much as possible and stash a datapad or two outside of the temple with coordinates to worlds that once housed jedi-academies (and/or darkside academies!), so that I can find more material to study!
@@dreamingflurry2729 I don’t know why but I imagine Master Saesee Tin being head instructor for those that wished to be pilots or some one as proficient at piloting (he was second Ace pilot in the order behind Anakin)
After watching this video, I am surprised Anakin did not flunk some subjects at all. Is it possible that the Jedi Council pulled some strings to ensure that the Chosen One will become Obi-Wan's padawan no matter what?
@@flyer3154 I was about to say something similar, but yeah, Obi-Wan knew the council was screwed because, like his master before him, he left the Force guide his every action, it’s was only the clone wars that finally broke him and even then he stayed true to the Jedi ways, the true Jedi ways
Did he even go through the trials to become a padawan? He was already 9 years old and seemed to immediately become Obi-Wan's apprentice rather than join in with group living/training. Please, correct me if I'm wrong, I haven't read much from the Clone Wars erra.
It's more like the council didn't bother stopping Obi-Wan in the first place. Instead of going through standard initiate education, Anakin skipped the entire process by training under Obi-Wan right from day one. The council probably made an exception & let the whole thing slide as a way to honor Qui-Gon's sacrifice, as well an acknowledgement that something might actually come out of such exceptions, given that Obi-Wan himself never got to be a padawan & was relegated to the service corps at one point, until Qui-Gon met him.
@@FalconWindblader I guess this is why his peers are not a fan of him and even mocked him for his background. So while their jealousy and anger were justified, the way they did it clearly wasn't. Instead, directly speaking about this matter to the adults and Anakin alike will be better. But then again, kids are kids.
I feel bad for the younglings that had as much talent as other but simply didn’t get picked because there weren’t enough Jedi, maybe not a complete reason to turn to the dark side but definitely something that could put someone down that path
Always what I thought. But then I realized: The jedi were so brainwashed and indoctrinated that they would probably accept it happily. By that age, they would be so incredibly dependent on the jedi that they would do whatever they were told to, because of simple survival. If the kid fails, where does it have to go? No family, no outside support network to care for them, nothing. So yeah, they either become indentured slaves to the jedi, or indentured slaves to some crime lord or gross noble (often the same guy). The jedi really did become twisted during the high republic.
@@jimmysmith2249 And the saddest part is that there was no dark side influence that caused it, just dogmatic thinking and blind faith without continued understanding, the Jedi were doomed long before Anakin Skywalker
@@jimmysmith2249 I don’t know about Disney canon but in legends I imagined the Jedi had the data of their parents or family so if they so chose, the failed or quitting initiate could get that info.
If they constructed their lightsabers prior to the trials and being chosen as apprentices, did the non-chosen have to give their personal sabers up? And whether or not they did, what was to stop a non-chosen initiate from continuing to self-learn in the force outside the order?
@@FairbrookWingates I pretty sure they would keep their lightsaber sines it's their personal symbol as a Jedi even if their not chosen and as passed over Initiates they would likely still have access to some teachings in the force (limited of course seeing as they had not become full members as padawans). I am sure they can go to other sources, and it may have been encouraged among Jedi approved groups like the Baran Do Sages, but their teachings would never be as complete and concise as of the Jedi. For example, the Baran Do Sages would teach the basics of the force and things they specialize in like sensing and controlling the weather and Dathomir witches would give you a more ritualistic and esoteric teaching and understanding of the force rather than the more pragmatic teaching of the Jedi. It's like comparing oxford or Harvard (jedi order) to local town or country learning (all lesser force groups).
You know, I’ve always wondered two things: What happened to Master Huyang after the Clone Wars and the story of all the Younglings from the Clone Wars episode, the Gathering.
Scrapped by the Empire after they took over Ilum, he was a part of Palpatine’s decorations on his secret fortress world but someone (or more likely something) reactivated him which caused a fight to break out and only the Dark Lord was strong enough to put him down, actually the juxtaposition of power is laughable, his guard was absolutely decimated by Huyang and Palpatine just scrapped him on the spot
I'm surprised that more younglings didn't turn to the dark side after going through all the hardships and not being picked because there weren't enough masters
Having raised my own child, I know how difficult it is to teach them how to control their feelings and emotions. I cannot imagine how hard it would be to train that control on the level needed for a jedi. Also, I was no helicopter mom. But, watching my young child wave a light saber around... Yeah, you can miss me with that! 😂
One way I think would improve a youngling\initiate education is maybe field trips around Corasaunt that way they can experience what it was like outside of the temple and order and can be more aware of the problems and pit falls of societies and politics
0:45 I love that youngling on the left pointing his lightsaber hilt at his chest, It's like when Anakin is slaughtering the younglings and this one is going out on his own terms🤣
guess the real takeaway lesson is, there is actually no one "right" way to produce a Jedi that both excels and remains true to the light, the order's way, master yoda's way, worked perfectly fine for obi wan, with the only hiccup being Duchess satine, but Qui Gon, who was basically as unorthodox as possible, was also undeniably and undenied, a great jedi. Heck just about every master worth remembering had their own spin on the code. and had the war itself not happened, anakin would have probably had the chance to find his own spin, the responsibility for ahsoka was well on the road of bringing out the best in him in fact.
Honestly what kept Anakin from being a great Jedi was his fear, pride and greed for attachments. If he had listened to Obi-wan and Yoda and loved Padme but understood that she would eventually die and been ok with it, he would have excelled. Jedi can actually have sex and basically do anything that wasn’t harmful or selfish so long as they were detached.
@@Dostoron What they wanted was for Anakin to not do what he did: throw a homicidal fit about Padme dying and to understand death was natural, specialy for how powerful he was. They didnt want him to ignore the sadness and think it wouldn't be important but to be ready and accept when it eventually may happen. I think Obi-Wan losing his lover in Mandalor but not giving in to his emotions was an example of what they hoped Anakin would do.
I do wonder how the Order handled Initiates going through puberty. I mean at least with humans that's is when hormones start kicking in and feelings for those of the opposite sex. Not to mention the growth spurt they go through which makes them very hungry.
lmao Yoda be looking at the Temple grocery bill like: "Send more younglings offworld, we must." Now you know why padawans are spirited away with their masters so young, and why they're shown eating from the land in some depictions. Furthermore, since the Jedi don't work or produce any products or own any assets, does the Republic foot the bill for Jedi expenses? Perhaps the cost of feeding and housing 10k Jedi is minuscule for an intergalactic government. Even if they did, isn't the accumulation of wealth, even if for subsistence, a violation of the no attachments rule as wealth is a facet of a material possession? I suppose they would have to donate every cent not used to charity. The real question is; how Jedi reconciled hunting animals with their pacifism?
*sees thumbnail* Good old child labor... that's the problem with good people, they can change for the worst. The third example at 2:04 somehow made me laugh. Must be because it's not like the otherwise relatable first two examples.
I think only having one padawan was the mistake. The jedi numbers were few and they manage to keep it low because a jedi either wasn't allowed to have 2 or more padawans, or their system made the rule so they wouldn't lose their cool where just one padawan went against their wishes, imagine each jedi having 5 padawans each doing this, so they made the rule to compensate for the masters. There could've been 1,00,00 more jedi by the time they no longer padawans but because they'd rather not want to deal with more than 1, they limited themselves in their numbers when they could've had more members to help the galaxy the way many people perceived them, not having an attachment would've been easier if you had serval padawans to not play favorites with, then you'd have a better chance that your order would be able to grow in numbers. You could by the time the numbers grew, have at least 100 jedi or more on every planet that existed within the Galactic Republic. Since you already taught them to work together, the padawans would've worked together more often instead of trying to one up each other. and maybe this reason I'm saying alone is why the story works for why Anakin would fall to the dark side because he had no one to rely on like a brother or a sister which despite the orders thinking about attachments, they were all in the same order which should've been looking out for one another and not scorn when someone thinks differently than themselves. Maybe this is why when the Jedi Civil war happened after the Mandalorian war, the order only trained one padawan each thinking this would negate rash actions where Revan ran to the Republics aid in the outer rim with the other jedi who would follow him, including Malak and Meetra Surik. Or even the first Schism was when they decided because of the Sith being a threat that kept them from training more than one padawan per jedi, where the Sith would embrace having several apprentices, who would compete with one another and even kill each other as rivals. So, by the time the Rise of Skywalker would emulate the idea that Luke saw the flaw with the jedi and decided they should no longer exist, the rule of two the Sith Lord Darth Bane created would be the idea of the jedi no longer existing by destroying the order through the actions from order 66, which wasn't his idea, but he would've approved for the sake of their 1,000-year plan. But the future is that most likely, new force user orders will come into existence reaching the point that the jedi order was at, recreating the flow of events to repeat all over again, or the Rakatan Infinite empire will reawaken taking the galaxy once again like they did 5,000 years before the republic would begin and fight it out with the Yuuzhan Vong. Or I just want the story to mean something instead of hating the franchise because the wrong people won't hire you because you have ideas, they won't pay you for. So, you write a really long comment about why the jedi should've had more than one padawan each because George told the story he wanted about the Skywalkers or what he figured. And if anyone actually reads this, I hope you value Star Wars as much as I do to see the pattern being told to us, and that Disney should hire someone with this mindset.
It takes an Order to raised an Orthodox Jedi sure. But their training often apparently leaves alot to be desired in creating fully stable functional beings not prone to a fairly big range of possible mental an emotional issues down the road. Not just spiritual an if they're gonna be any concept of "good" or "bad". Some these hard numbers though.. help us give some pretty good insight into some secrets of the franchise. Like roughly how many EXACTLY of each sorta Jedi of every level there really was. Now THAT would be ground breaking to learn
Again, why does no one understand that saying that a full range of emotion is it the effective way of saying that a child is allowed to have a temper tantrum and you’re not allowed to regulate those emotions because for some reason that’s repressing them? Their training does not leave a lot to be desired. It’s the selfishness of the person being trained that usually causes the problem because if they’re training left a lot to be desired, then there would be constant falls to the Darkside, which is not the case at all, and as for your complaint about spiritual dimensions oh yes, how dare a spiritual order of people not care about the spirituality of the very thing they worship. You keep using these words I don’t think they mean with the you think they mean.
@@Toramai-pi8wx Because Jedi bad is considered a nuanced, mature take on a universe with established binary morality. This comment claims the Order’s education fails to produce functioning people not prone to emotional/mental turmoil… when it has done so with considerable success and replicated that success for most of its insanely long history. That success is shown to come as a result of compliance with those teachings (or at least adhering to their reasoning). The Jedi Order in this regard is nothing short of a success story, the main issue with turnover is caused by noncompliance, the *one* area in which they can legitimately be considered to have failed in.
Imagine not being chosen by a knight or failing and being said: "Ooof! Tough luck buddy but hey! You have 2 options, being a Farmer or giving up everything you built and learned at the moment and praying to have luck to being adopted or finding a job'
@@markmagician2471he didn't even give the trials as the council deemed that he was more than worthy since he fought and killed the first recorded sith in a thousand years and still remained in the light side of the force
🧐 . . . While I’d still be Strict about Self-Control, I’d probably be extremely chillaxed about everything else. As a Christian, a Catholic, a metaphorical Jedi of my faith, I honestly don’t believe that everyone else needs to recognize Jesus Christ as their lord & savior, but to only do what Jesus Christ would do. Its a complete contrast to my fellow Christians who’re metaphorical Sith; justifying their crimes, their, at worst, genocidal murders with Christianity, good examples in the United States of America would be the Ku Klux Klan & the Kool-Aid drinking People’s Temple of Christ. Now, anybody & everybody can also be a metaphorical Jedi of their own religions, atheists & agnostics included (if a survey asks what your religion is, what is your answer?). Anybody who justifies their evils with their religion is not a Jedi, but a Sith (in Christianity, it’s the 3rd Commandment; I honestly hope & believe that ALL religions have their own equivalent(s)). Anywho, I do have my own education reform, which incorporates this & _My Hero Academia_ & such…
I would have taken all the initiate training and left shortly after becoming a Padawan honestly the code is nonsense and the real way is balance I mightve made my way to Mandalore and get some of their training as well maybe start a house of my own House Gray 🤔🧐
It’s more like clans. They don’t bother with fancy house things though if you join the Mandalorians, you must know your trading one dogma for another. For one you have to learn Mando’a, you have to prove you for what it takes to earn your Beskar’gam and give your undying loyalty to the reigning Mandalor. It’s the Rasol’nare/ the way.
@@Amadeo790 true different dogma but in the Star Wars galaxy might be more effective either way just need their training to increase my survival rate 😵
@@Prilliyo very true and fair though as a culture that worships war and conflict, you would be expected to take danger by the horns rather than avoid it. This is why mercenary, bounty hunting and security work are popular choices and alternatives to war among the Mandalorians. A more down to earth example would be being ready at any moment to throw hands or even kill if someone disrespects you or your family/clan.
The major issue I see with the Jedi training is that they had a fundamental disconnect with the people of the Galaxy by never needing to provide for themselves or others. Think about it, how can they empathize properly when their food, shelter, clothing, transportation, money etc... was handed to them. They had no concept of the economic and social corruption that plagued the galaxy because it never affected them. It was always "not their problem" so the Republic got away with crap, and they enabled it.
@@user-nm1lx8qb3u Well, first of all, no isolating in the Temple. I'm not saying field trips to the ganglands, but they need to teach the younglings that Credits aren't just handed out. Some people get more than others. They need to see the consequences of having too much and too little early on. Around age ten they need to understand what working for needs means. Maybe have them "work" to earn the robes they ruin or get extra dessert. Something that hammers home the concept that the whole galaxy operates like that in real life not just classroom economic theory. During their days of Padawan-hood. Anything they need, transportation, clothing, food, they and their masters have to find a way to earn them when not on a mission. They're so-called simple, humble lives, were in fact as pampered as could be.
Remember that episode of star wars rebels where ashoka is in the ghost and ezra is walking in when ashoka is using her jedi hologron I think that recording is showing anakin teaching younglings isn't the academy section of the jedi order during the clone wars because of the dialogue in the holo and I know it sounds grazy but it sounds like it i hope that it gets confirmed one day but even if isn't it sounded like a fun idea
If there’s anything Anakin loved more than anything it’s family. He was only terrified of Padme’s pregnancy because of their deception about their marriage. When he said his child was a blessing he meant it.
Whoever honestly thinks it takes a village to raise a child is either lying or just flat out wrong (before anyone thinks I’m arrogant or some other bs keep reading) when I was younger we had DCFS and CPS called on us a fair amount of times to “Help” my mom. My mother was a domestic abuse survivor and a single mom who raised my brothers and I on the other hand my aunt and uncle have like 8 kids oh and my uncle is a registered sex offender and for a few years they lived down the street from a school nobody called DCFS or CPS so I’m pretty salty about stuff like that
One way for the Jedi to improve their system could have been if the failed Initiates were given more support. Just because their force potential wasn't high enough or weren't skilled enough (or were just unlucky to not be chosen) they still could have learned more about the force, especially in the Agri Corps. I mean even if they would not have been up to the level of a Padawan, with some guidance from some masters they could have progressed at their own rate, then they too could have been sent on missions. Maybe not like the padawans, more like being sent to help with terraforming projects, helping to restore/fix the ecosystem of wartorn worlds and stuff like that. If they were branching out to learn other skills related to the Living Force, could also help planets with dangerous fauna if not to tame, then at least helping to mitigate the problems or send them out as healers to help combat diseases and increasing the survivability of people on harsher worlds. Just because their skills would not have been up to the level of a Consular-class Jedi, more healers are always come handy. Especially if they are sent in groups rather than in pairs, with a master (or a more experienced member of the service corps) in charge of them, they could still have been really helpful using teamwork and specialization, thus allowing the Padawans/Knights/Masters to redirect their focus to other matters, that required their skill and experience. This also would have allowed the Order to help more people and planets, deepening the Jedi's bonds with the people of the Galaxy, who otherwise the Order couldn't reach, because the full-fledged Jedi were needed elsewhere. I think such reforms would have helped the Jedi Order and without having to change too much (since Jedi aren't ones for change).
Kids were taken without their parents consent at least in the old cannon before Disney got ahold of it. Makes sense too because if a kid is force sensitive the capacity for great evil is there if they don’t take them. They need to brainwash them into being emotionless non questioning robot. There’s always a shortage of Jedi so if you find a powerful youngling your going to take them to train whether their parents like it or not. Jedi were just as bad as the sith they just get a better reputation because of the republic propaganda. Hell they chose the wrong side in the clone wars despite repeated evidence and events that showed the republic was so corrupt it couldn’t do anything and greedy systems could do whatever they want too. Anti Alien bias was also bad in the republic, the only difference between them and the empire was the empire was fine with killing a bunch. The republic just paid lip service to being equal.
Nice video I think that if I were to suggested improvement, it would be a little bit more life skills so that way if they do choose or there quietly encouraged to leave the order they’re not completely lost. Although that might be legends thinking, because they kind of made it sound like that anybody who let the order was completely clueless on how the galaxy worked. Probably due to authors, not paying attention to the Jedi Path book or George Lucas’s suggestions.
George Lucas also preached the ideal that the force could only be balanced by zero dark only light so. Maybe he was just in it for the money after the first one? As he's admitted?
One thing that would have certainly helped the Jedi as a whole a lot more was having "field trips" for Younglings around Coruscant. Chances and opportunities to interact with Republic citizens at large, and could have helped prevent isolationist attitudes many Jedi unintentionally seemed to develop
I'm just going to make my own force sensitive order and have everyone just focus on the force and find the balance between it and make sure no younglings lose that balance, instead of passing trials and undergoing life changing experiences to become a Jedi. That's just a Grey Jedi isn't it?
Hm maybe by if they failed their test to become padawns instead of resigning them or allowing them to leave the jedi to allow them to continue their training much more and to hone their skills and knowledge of a lightsaber and the force so when they are better prepared and more ready for the test to become a padawan that they could succeed
Good fathers do love their animals, but they also understand reality. That is why they have them live a happy life to adulthood and ensure the most painless and swift deaths.
@@beastvg123 Spoken like some vegan airhead who has never spoken to a farmer in his/her life. Animal products are everything from vaccines to the phone screen on which you likely wrote that comment. You people always try to make up for your lack of nutrition, vitamins, protein and muscles with your self-righteous, hypocritical, ill-informed, often-controlling attitude.
How did padawan not end up a curosanti or being little Jedi clones? Through out the series, various Jedi were cultural marking sometimes even from there own planet. How does this work with no attachments and taken from childhood?
"...until they might become a padawan..." There, fixed it for you as the (dumb) Jedi too often refused to take certain students on as padawans and those then joined the refuse-pile, otherwise known as the Service-Corps! Hell, some of those later became inquisitors - I wounder why? (Not really, I'd hate the order, too if they considered me trash only fit to bring in the money so that they Padawans, Knights and Masters could go adventuring!)
It could have been improved by letting them (Under EXTREME supervision and vigil mind you) study the dark side of the force. That's why so many turned to it because they didn't know or understand the feelings and nature of the dark side and therefore did not know how to process it.
I can't help wondering what would happen with the younglings that did leave the Jedi Order if they failed their trials and didn't enter the service corps. They would be still children. Who took care of them and who was responsible for them?
I say they should have the option of learning how to handle grief sorrow. They should teach them about how to handle attachment and how to support people emotionally and handle strong emotions rather than discourage which most jedi tend to do despite their code.
I wonder what ever happened to all those Younglings from Season 5 of The Clone Wars. We know Gungi survived since he's in the Bad Batch Season 2 trailer, but we don't know about the rest. I always headcanon that they did escape, alongside the Droids from D-Squad, of course, in that headcanon I also thought some Clones like Jesse, Echo, the rest of the Bad Batch, and a few others helped them escape because I thought Rex would have told them about what Fives had discovered and they would have all removed their chips beforehand so when Order 66 did happen they would see what was going on, realize Fives was right and it was good they removed their chips beforehand, and then jump into action to help the Jedi. Bad Batch Season 1 and the Siege of Mandalore kind of disproved most of that, especially in the case of Jesse and Crosshair. Although, Jesse did still die in my headcanon because I thought some Clones should die during the saving of the Younglings, and I didn't want to kill Echo since he's all that's left of Domino Squad. Still, two very great shows mind you.
Well after the death of the Sith and the Russan reformation, there had to be a plan to deal with potential dangers of undirected force users all over the galaxy to avoid new Sith or dark jedi.
@@Amadeo790 Yes I think the Jedi used the republic to make laws forcing parents to give up their kids. You don't get almost all the force users in one spot by accident
@@vikingsword3485 forced seems a strong word. Kids that have the powers to bend the universe around them are very dangerous if not directed but forcing. What they did was have blood tests if everyone with in the republic to keep a census of who was force sensitive or not. I feel is more gray than truly malicious.
@@Amadeo790 I see nothing more dangerous than state run super soldiers/ enforcers working for a corrupt government. Very little is written about the details of how they get the children and the jedi do have a reputation of being kidnappers on some planets. You add in the brainwashing jedi are known to do and I doubt every force sensitives ended up in one spot because everyone loves the jedi. The Jedi were so hated most welcomed order 66
I have a theory that anakin may have either instructed the younglings to fake their deaths using vital suppressors, or stabbed/struck them where none of their vitals were. he was consuned, but couldn't bring himself to do it
Have the initiates only use wooden lightsabers until they have earned the right to have a real lightsaber during the Gathering...last but not least...the initiates should have one trip to Ahch-To, so they may have some familiarity with the humble beginnings of the Jedi path/ Bendu ways.
![Wookiee Jedi Youngling Bullies his Friend for being Trandoshan [Canon]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_bPPmfyKk54/mqdefault.jpg)
Funfact: Anakin didn't wanted to kill the younglings but then when the one kid say Master...
Yea then we know what happen.
In his eyes Anakin WAS...
In the very least Anikin dueled them instead of just slaughtering them allowing them to fall honorably in battle
Where did you get this from? This is absolutely incorrect
@@texugo_branco it’s a joke about how he was never given the rank of master
“Anakin actually loved them”
What other lies have I been told by the council!?
Well, haven't history shown that Anakin kills and hurts those he loves?
It's the Sith way...
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 thousands yo thousands 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Well, that's one way of letting go of what one's most afraid to lose.
"The councel I AM!"
Said Yoda as he ignited his crimson and blood red short lightsaber and jumped with supersonic speed to attack while emitting a storm of force lightning capable of killing a whole clone trooper battalion at once.
Anakin loving the younglings will be a absolute tragedy for everyone involved for both him and the children.
i believe he killed them to keep them out of Palatine's hands, basically a final mercy to the Order.
@@alericantonelli4656 No. He killed the younglings because they were Jedi, and Sidious wanted all Jedi, young and old, dead so they would never become a threat to his power.
@@patriciahayes2664 not true he also had plans to turn some. that’s why vader had inquisitors
@@patriciahayes2664 There are some videos out there (and a comic, from which the knowledge in said videos is based on) that shows that Anakin DID in fact convince himself that it was a mercy killing, and that all other possible futures would have been "even worse" for them.
Just add that to the growing list of tragedies in the Star Wars Universe.
Horrifyingly enough, Anakin probably did the kids a mercy by giving them the 66-86 treatment. Think about it this way: would you prefer death, or living under whatever twisted experiments and indoctrination Sidious could have cooked up. For reference, we should think of what Sidious turned Maul into after he got his hands on the Zabrak at about the same age as that "master Skywalker" kid.
Inquisitorious… enough said, take my head Anny I’d rather not be a “brother”
@@JoshuaValentine Enjoy it when Vader decides the "special forces" need to know what it's like to not have a limb randomly
@@JoshuaValentine just to let you know, they would fuck your mind until you turned it the dark, Vader would cut off limbs and be extremely punishing just to teach life lessons, and you would be expendable. It’s not as good as it sounds.
This was Anakin's thought process when he killed them. He didn't enjoy it, he decided this would be best.
@@sciathoir Yeah, the physical and mental torture as well as being a slave without will and forced to kill people, especially those who you used to be with at school does not sound very nice
"We don't need to explain why giving a four year old a laser sword wasn't the best idea"
Sith master teaching their apprentices: hold my Corellian beer
Usually Sith acolytes and apprentices were older (and didn't get a lightsaber until they were actually apprenticed to a Sith Lord, if SWTOR is any indication).
Mandalorians: *PATHETIC*
@@johnquach8821 sounds like pre rule of two. I don't think one of the later Sith Lords would mind choosing the strongest 4 year old by having him kill the other. They only want the very strongest.
@@Ben-Ken Darth Plagueis book also has the Rule of Two Sith prefer to find older apprentices more experienced in the ways of life.
@@johnquach8821 Not just experienced in life but also already jaded, hateful, angry, and insane. It was easier to turn them and teach them and have them grow if they were already a Sith minus the teachings.
I think what would have made the Order better as a whole is if they allowed the young to experience all emotions, instead of suppressing the bad ones. That way, they have a better understanding of themselves and how they can improve the Galaxy and their own lives.
They didn’t suppress their bad emotions they learn to control them. That’s like saying yes allow children to have temper tantrums and basically be as mean and cruel as possible because we should let children experience full motion. No, that’s not how it works. See we’re taught at a young age on how to regulate our emotions otherwise people get hurt in the case of the Jedi their actual physical consequences. For us it’s just emotional ones. So first of all, they’re not hot to suppress their emotions or taught to control them. Geetsly actually made a video making that point abundantly clear. Why does everyone not listen to that part?
@@Toramai-pi8wx when a star wars fan gets triggered
Agreed. It's about balance of feeling yet controlling emotions. Spok and General Kenobi are good examples. May you live long and prosper, and be one with the force.
@@Folfah You mean tells the truth? xD But it's popular to exaggerate the Order's flaws and twist them into a straw man caricature.
the jedi order didn't have an issue with negative emotions lol, their main problem was teaching control and self discipline so that such emotions wouldn't drive their usage of the force; the dark side
Anakin asked the younglings how is their health plan.
Apparently it was great.
Their health plan expired when I got to them
General Skywalker, why did we leave survivers? Good to see you again my General.
Tarkin: _"Commander... be honest with me. What are we looking at in terms of colateral?"_
Clone Cmdr.: _"Weeeeell... _*_the Vader ammount."_*
Didn't expect to see a TFS reference here.
2 things never get old , the younglings joke and the younglings .
I wish we had a game dedicated to us making a character that's starts from a planet of our choosing with a backstory we can choose and we start as youngling to try to become a Jedi master (if turn to the dark side)
It would probably have to be in the old republic era or beyond that.
Same here. Also things like Lightsaber form and crystal
Hear me out: dmc style switching but with lightsaber forms
That would be amazing
Is swtor what youre looking for?
@@second2noneonyt it's not *quite* as in-depth as what they're describing. Definitely an excellent starting point though.
"He actually loved children."
Meme fans: *impossible...*
and then anakin decided to unalive them. nice.
You betcha
@@AnakinSkywalker-bp7qj 😳
So cool, I mean I think I’m okay with both options if they are not pick to become an apprentice
I like the idea of given the option of leaving the order and encouraging the learned training and experience to share with the universe
And although it may seem low to be a support role for the Jedi infrastructure I think it still awesome especially if your the type to want to support the cause and all
Knowing what I do now I'd prepare for leaving the order, meaning I'd want a pilot's license and credentials showing that I have a good education (I'd need the to survive out there)...I would also learn as much as possible and stash a datapad or two outside of the temple with coordinates to worlds that once housed jedi-academies (and/or darkside academies!), so that I can find more material to study!
That's another reason why The Rangers exist. I agree and would do the same.
@@dreamingflurry2729 I don’t know why but I imagine Master Saesee Tin being head instructor for those that wished to be pilots or some one as proficient at piloting (he was second Ace pilot in the order behind Anakin)
*thumbnail*
Anakin showing the Jedi younglings to not choke on their aspirations.
After watching this video, I am surprised Anakin did not flunk some subjects at all. Is it possible that the Jedi Council pulled some strings to ensure that the Chosen One will become Obi-Wan's padawan no matter what?
Well Obi-Wan said he will train Anakin whether or not the jedi council would approve it
@@flyer3154 I was about to say something similar, but yeah, Obi-Wan knew the council was screwed because, like his master before him, he left the Force guide his every action, it’s was only the clone wars that finally broke him and even then he stayed true to the Jedi ways, the true Jedi ways
Did he even go through the trials to become a padawan? He was already 9 years old and seemed to immediately become Obi-Wan's apprentice rather than join in with group living/training. Please, correct me if I'm wrong, I haven't read much from the Clone Wars erra.
It's more like the council didn't bother stopping Obi-Wan in the first place. Instead of going through standard initiate education, Anakin skipped the entire process by training under Obi-Wan right from day one. The council probably made an exception & let the whole thing slide as a way to honor Qui-Gon's sacrifice, as well an acknowledgement that something might actually come out of such exceptions, given that Obi-Wan himself never got to be a padawan & was relegated to the service corps at one point, until Qui-Gon met him.
@@FalconWindblader I guess this is why his peers are not a fan of him and even mocked him for his background.
So while their jealousy and anger were justified, the way they did it clearly wasn't. Instead, directly speaking about this matter to the adults and Anakin alike will be better.
But then again, kids are kids.
I feel bad for the younglings that had as much talent as other but simply didn’t get picked because there weren’t enough Jedi, maybe not a complete reason to turn to the dark side but definitely something that could put someone down that path
Always what I thought. But then I realized:
The jedi were so brainwashed and indoctrinated that they would probably accept it happily. By that age, they would be so incredibly dependent on the jedi that they would do whatever they were told to, because of simple survival. If the kid fails, where does it have to go? No family, no outside support network to care for them, nothing. So yeah, they either become indentured slaves to the jedi, or indentured slaves to some crime lord or gross noble (often the same guy).
The jedi really did become twisted during the high republic.
@@jimmysmith2249 And the saddest part is that there was no dark side influence that caused it, just dogmatic thinking and blind faith without continued understanding, the Jedi were doomed long before Anakin Skywalker
@@jimmysmith2249 I don’t know about Disney canon but in legends I imagined the Jedi had the data of their parents or family so if they so chose, the failed or quitting initiate could get that info.
If they constructed their lightsabers prior to the trials and being chosen as apprentices, did the non-chosen have to give their personal sabers up? And whether or not they did, what was to stop a non-chosen initiate from continuing to self-learn in the force outside the order?
@@FairbrookWingates I pretty sure they would keep their lightsaber sines it's their personal symbol as a Jedi even if their not chosen and as passed over Initiates they would likely still have access to some teachings in the force (limited of course seeing as they had not become full members as padawans). I am sure they can go to other sources, and it may have been encouraged among Jedi approved groups like the Baran Do Sages, but their teachings would never be as complete and concise as of the Jedi. For example, the Baran Do Sages would teach the basics of the force and things they specialize in like sensing and controlling the weather and Dathomir witches would give you a more ritualistic and esoteric teaching and understanding of the force rather than the more pragmatic teaching of the Jedi. It's like comparing oxford or Harvard (jedi order) to local town or country learning (all lesser force groups).
Now I am interested in seeing a quiz on which jedi youngling clan a person would be in
"Master Skywalker, there are too many of us! What are you going to do?"
*Picture of Younglings standing triumphant over Anakin's corpse*
1:50 Crèche is a real world word meaning daycare/nursery. Its a French word and its also used in Belgium and the Netherlands.
You know, I’ve always wondered two things:
What happened to Master Huyang after the Clone Wars and the story of all the Younglings from the Clone Wars episode, the Gathering.
Scrapped by the Empire after they took over Ilum, he was a part of Palpatine’s decorations on his secret fortress world but someone (or more likely something) reactivated him which caused a fight to break out and only the Dark Lord was strong enough to put him down, actually the juxtaposition of power is laughable, his guard was absolutely decimated by Huyang and Palpatine just scrapped him on the spot
@@sciathoir Is this Legends or Disney canon? You should probably look it up again, it kinda sounds like you’re out certain. No offense.
@@teleportedbreadfor3days
He’s obviously talking about Legends because Huyang is in the Ahsoka show that takes place after episode 6.
@@robertdeffenbaugh9004 Or at the very least, if George and/or Filoni wrote something before the Ahsoka show
Okay, that thumbnail with "he actually *loved* children" caption makes me... uncomfortable.
Imagine going through all the hardships of becoming a jedi only to end up growing crops on a farm...
I'm surprised that more younglings didn't turn to the dark side after going through all the hardships and not being picked because there weren't enough masters
Too bad we weren't shown a scene of how much Anakin loved children in the movies.
Having raised my own child, I know how difficult it is to teach them how to control their feelings and emotions. I cannot imagine how hard it would be to train that control on the level needed for a jedi.
Also, I was no helicopter mom. But, watching my young child wave a light saber around... Yeah, you can miss me with that! 😂
One way I think would improve a youngling\initiate education is maybe field trips around Corasaunt that way they can experience what it was like outside of the temple and order and can be more aware of the problems and pit falls of societies and politics
“Children were never taken without their parents permission” -Jedi propaganda
0:45 I love that youngling on the left pointing his lightsaber hilt at his chest, It's like when Anakin is slaughtering the younglings and this one is going out on his own terms🤣
Like when Ben hands Luke a lightsaber for the first time and he IMMEDIATELY points it straight at his face .
guess the real takeaway lesson is, there is actually no one "right" way to produce a Jedi that both excels and remains true to the light, the order's way, master yoda's way, worked perfectly fine for obi wan, with the only hiccup being Duchess satine, but Qui Gon, who was basically as unorthodox as possible, was also undeniably and undenied, a great jedi.
Heck just about every master worth remembering had their own spin on the code. and had the war itself not happened, anakin would have probably had the chance to find his own spin, the responsibility for ahsoka was well on the road of bringing out the best in him in fact.
Honestly what kept Anakin from being a great Jedi was his fear, pride and greed for attachments. If he had listened to Obi-wan and Yoda and loved Padme but understood that she would eventually die and been ok with it, he would have excelled. Jedi can actually have sex and basically do anything that wasn’t harmful or selfish so long as they were detached.
@@Amadeo790
In fairness, detached is a bit of a vague instruction there.
@@Dostoron What they wanted was for Anakin to not do what he did: throw a homicidal fit about Padme dying and to understand death was natural, specialy for how powerful he was. They didnt want him to ignore the sadness and think it wouldn't be important but to be ready and accept when it eventually may happen. I think Obi-Wan losing his lover in Mandalor but not giving in to his emotions was an example of what they hoped Anakin would do.
Today, I like children
-Hondo Ohnaka
"I need an adult?"
TFS Gohan.
Based Indy we follow far too many of the same channels
I do wonder how the Order handled Initiates going through puberty. I mean at least with humans that's is when hormones start kicking in and feelings for those of the opposite sex. Not to mention the growth spurt they go through which makes them very hungry.
lmao Yoda be looking at the Temple grocery bill like:
"Send more younglings offworld, we must."
Now you know why padawans are spirited away with their masters so young, and why they're shown eating from the land in some depictions. Furthermore, since the Jedi don't work or produce any products or own any assets, does the Republic foot the bill for Jedi expenses? Perhaps the cost of feeding and housing 10k Jedi is minuscule for an intergalactic government. Even if they did, isn't the accumulation of wealth, even if for subsistence, a violation of the no attachments rule as wealth is a facet of a material possession? I suppose they would have to donate every cent not used to charity. The real question is; how Jedi reconciled hunting animals with their pacifism?
Correction: the Jedi Order only taught forms 1-6. They considered Form 7 Juyo to be dark side and only Mace Windu taught Form 7 Vaapaad
At first glance, that thumbnail looked like a scene from Robot Chicken 🤣🤣
*sees thumbnail* Good old child labor... that's the problem with good people, they can change for the worst.
The third example at 2:04 somehow made me laugh. Must be because it's not like the otherwise relatable first two examples.
I think only having one padawan was the mistake. The jedi numbers were few and they manage to keep it low because a jedi either wasn't allowed to have 2 or more padawans, or their system made the rule so they wouldn't lose their cool where just one padawan went against their wishes, imagine each jedi having 5 padawans each doing this, so they made the rule to compensate for the masters. There could've been 1,00,00 more jedi by the time they no longer padawans but because they'd rather not want to deal with more than 1, they limited themselves in their numbers when they could've had more members to help the galaxy the way many people perceived them, not having an attachment would've been easier if you had serval padawans to not play favorites with, then you'd have a better chance that your order would be able to grow in numbers. You could by the time the numbers grew, have at least 100 jedi or more on every planet that existed within the Galactic Republic. Since you already taught them to work together, the padawans would've worked together more often instead of trying to one up each other. and maybe this reason I'm saying alone is why the story works for why Anakin would fall to the dark side because he had no one to rely on like a brother or a sister which despite the orders thinking about attachments, they were all in the same order which should've been looking out for one another and not scorn when someone thinks differently than themselves. Maybe this is why when the Jedi Civil war happened after the Mandalorian war, the order only trained one padawan each thinking this would negate rash actions where Revan ran to the Republics aid in the outer rim with the other jedi who would follow him, including Malak and Meetra Surik. Or even the first Schism was when they decided because of the Sith being a threat that kept them from training more than one padawan per jedi, where the Sith would embrace having several apprentices, who would compete with one another and even kill each other as rivals. So, by the time the Rise of Skywalker would emulate the idea that Luke saw the flaw with the jedi and decided they should no longer exist, the rule of two the Sith Lord Darth Bane created would be the idea of the jedi no longer existing by destroying the order through the actions from order 66, which wasn't his idea, but he would've approved for the sake of their 1,000-year plan. But the future is that most likely, new force user orders will come into existence reaching the point that the jedi order was at, recreating the flow of events to repeat all over again, or the Rakatan Infinite empire will reawaken taking the galaxy once again like they did 5,000 years before the republic would begin and fight it out with the Yuuzhan Vong. Or I just want the story to mean something instead of hating the franchise because the wrong people won't hire you because you have ideas, they won't pay you for. So, you write a really long comment about why the jedi should've had more than one padawan each because George told the story he wanted about the Skywalkers or what he figured. And if anyone actually reads this, I hope you value Star Wars as much as I do to see the pattern being told to us, and that Disney should hire someone with this mindset.
It takes an Order to raised an Orthodox Jedi sure. But their training often apparently leaves alot to be desired in creating fully stable functional beings not prone to a fairly big range of possible mental an emotional issues down the road. Not just spiritual an if they're gonna be any concept of "good" or "bad".
Some these hard numbers though.. help us give some pretty good insight into some secrets of the franchise. Like roughly how many EXACTLY of each sorta Jedi of every level there really was. Now THAT would be ground breaking to learn
Again, why does no one understand that saying that a full range of emotion is it the effective way of saying that a child is allowed to have a temper tantrum and you’re not allowed to regulate those emotions because for some reason that’s repressing them? Their training does not leave a lot to be desired. It’s the selfishness of the person being trained that usually causes the problem because if they’re training left a lot to be desired, then there would be constant falls to the Darkside, which is not the case at all, and as for your complaint about spiritual dimensions oh yes, how dare a spiritual order of people not care about the spirituality of the very thing they worship. You keep using these words I don’t think they mean with the you think they mean.
@@Toramai-pi8wx Because Jedi bad is considered a nuanced, mature take on a universe with established binary morality.
This comment claims the Order’s education fails to produce functioning people not prone to emotional/mental turmoil… when it has done so with considerable success and replicated that success for most of its insanely long history.
That success is shown to come as a result of compliance with those teachings (or at least adhering to their reasoning). The Jedi Order in this regard is nothing short of a success story, the main issue with turnover is caused by noncompliance, the *one* area in which they can legitimately be considered to have failed in.
Imagine not being chosen by a knight or failing and being said: "Ooof! Tough luck buddy but hey! You have 2 options, being a Farmer or giving up everything you built and learned at the moment and praying to have luck to being adopted or finding a job'
If I didn't get chosen as a Padawan, I would join a service core and keep practicing my combat skills daily. Kenobi didn't make it at first either.
Kenobi got lucky he almost got sent to become a miner if Qui Gon Jinn didn't pick him as his padawan
I honestly wouldn't mind being sent to the agricultural corps ngl
@@markmagician2471he didn't even give the trials as the council deemed that he was more than worthy since he fought and killed the first recorded sith in a thousand years and still remained in the light side of the force
🧐 . . . While I’d still be Strict about Self-Control, I’d probably be extremely chillaxed about everything else.
As a Christian, a Catholic, a metaphorical Jedi of my faith, I honestly don’t believe that everyone else needs to recognize Jesus Christ as their lord & savior, but to only do what Jesus Christ would do. Its a complete contrast to my fellow Christians who’re metaphorical Sith; justifying their crimes, their, at worst, genocidal murders with Christianity, good examples in the United States of America would be the Ku Klux Klan & the Kool-Aid drinking People’s Temple of Christ.
Now, anybody & everybody can also be a metaphorical Jedi of their own religions, atheists & agnostics included (if a survey asks what your religion is, what is your answer?). Anybody who justifies their evils with their religion is not a Jedi, but a Sith (in Christianity, it’s the 3rd Commandment; I honestly hope & believe that ALL religions have their own equivalent(s)).
Anywho, I do have my own education reform, which incorporates this & _My Hero Academia_ & such…
Youngling routine:
Wake up
Breakfast
Train
Get slaughtered
I would have taken all the initiate training and left shortly after becoming a Padawan honestly the code is nonsense and the real way is balance I mightve made my way to Mandalore and get some of their training as well maybe start a house of my own House Gray 🤔🧐
It’s more like clans. They don’t bother with fancy house things though if you join the Mandalorians, you must know your trading one dogma for another. For one you have to learn Mando’a, you have to prove you for what it takes to earn your Beskar’gam and give your undying loyalty to the reigning Mandalor. It’s the Rasol’nare/ the way.
@@Amadeo790 true different dogma but in the Star Wars galaxy might be more effective either way just need their training to increase my survival rate 😵
@@Prilliyo very true and fair though as a culture that worships war and conflict, you would be expected to take danger by the horns rather than avoid it. This is why mercenary, bounty hunting and security work are popular choices and alternatives to war among the Mandalorians. A more down to earth example would be being ready at any moment to throw hands or even kill if someone disrespects you or your family/clan.
What I want to know is how what they did with species who aged fast or aged slow compared to the average human?
The major issue I see with the Jedi training is that they had a fundamental disconnect with the people of the Galaxy by never needing to provide for themselves or others. Think about it, how can they empathize properly when their food, shelter, clothing, transportation, money etc... was handed to them. They had no concept of the economic and social corruption that plagued the galaxy because it never affected them. It was always "not their problem" so the Republic got away with crap, and they enabled it.
Really? Sounds cool, but could you elaborate further on this? How would you train a youngling in this mindset?
@@user-nm1lx8qb3u Well, first of all, no isolating in the Temple. I'm not saying field trips to the ganglands, but they need to teach the younglings that Credits aren't just handed out. Some people get more than others. They need to see the consequences of having too much and too little early on. Around age ten they need to understand what working for needs means. Maybe have them "work" to earn the robes they ruin or get extra dessert. Something that hammers home the concept that the whole galaxy operates like that in real life not just classroom economic theory. During their days of Padawan-hood. Anything they need, transportation, clothing, food, they and their masters have to find a way to earn them when not on a mission. They're so-called simple, humble lives, were in fact as pampered as could be.
Anakin The Deader of the kids?
Anakin loved younglings so much he took a piece of one with him.
“It takes a village to raise a child”
Not if the parents are present
Hmm, if I were reincarnated as one of these kids, I better be in the Katarn clan, not the otherwise good Dragon clan.
: Sees thumbnail.
Memers: No, that's not true! That's IMPOSSIBLE!
"Master Skywalker there are too many of them what are we going to do?
Anakin;😈
Me;😂
Remember that episode of star wars rebels where ashoka is in the ghost and ezra is walking in when ashoka is using her jedi hologron I think that recording is showing anakin teaching younglings isn't the academy section of the jedi order during the clone wars because of the dialogue in the holo and I know it sounds grazy but it sounds like it i hope that it gets confirmed one day but even if isn't it sounded like a fun idea
If there’s anything Anakin loved more than anything it’s family. He was only terrified of Padme’s pregnancy because of their deception about their marriage. When he said his child was a blessing he meant it.
Whoever honestly thinks it takes a village to raise a child is either lying or just flat out wrong (before anyone thinks I’m arrogant or some other bs keep reading) when I was younger we had DCFS and CPS called on us a fair amount of times to “Help” my mom. My mother was a domestic abuse survivor and a single mom who raised my brothers and I on the other hand my aunt and uncle have like 8 kids oh and my uncle is a registered sex offender and for a few years they lived down the street from a school nobody called DCFS or CPS so I’m pretty salty about stuff like that
Simple: they got treated better than their counterparts in the Sith academy.
Getting slaughtered should be on the list too.
One way for the Jedi to improve their system could have been if the failed Initiates were given more support. Just because their force potential wasn't high enough or weren't skilled enough (or were just unlucky to not be chosen) they still could have learned more about the force, especially in the Agri Corps. I mean even if they would not have been up to the level of a Padawan, with some guidance from some masters they could have progressed at their own rate, then they too could have been sent on missions. Maybe not like the padawans, more like being sent to help with terraforming projects, helping to restore/fix the ecosystem of wartorn worlds and stuff like that. If they were branching out to learn other skills related to the Living Force, could also help planets with dangerous fauna if not to tame, then at least helping to mitigate the problems or send them out as healers to help combat diseases and increasing the survivability of people on harsher worlds. Just because their skills would not have been up to the level of a Consular-class Jedi, more healers are always come handy. Especially if they are sent in groups rather than in pairs, with a master (or a more experienced member of the service corps) in charge of them, they could still have been really helpful using teamwork and specialization, thus allowing the Padawans/Knights/Masters to redirect their focus to other matters, that required their skill and experience. This also would have allowed the Order to help more people and planets, deepening the Jedi's bonds with the people of the Galaxy, who otherwise the Order couldn't reach, because the full-fledged Jedi were needed elsewhere.
I think such reforms would have helped the Jedi Order and without having to change too much (since Jedi aren't ones for change).
Kids were taken without their parents consent at least in the old cannon before Disney got ahold of it. Makes sense too because if a kid is force sensitive the capacity for great evil is there if they don’t take them. They need to brainwash them into being emotionless non questioning robot. There’s always a shortage of Jedi so if you find a powerful youngling your going to take them to train whether their parents like it or not. Jedi were just as bad as the sith they just get a better reputation because of the republic propaganda. Hell they chose the wrong side in the clone wars despite repeated evidence and events that showed the republic was so corrupt it couldn’t do anything and greedy systems could do whatever they want too. Anti Alien bias was also bad in the republic, the only difference between them and the empire was the empire was fine with killing a bunch. The republic just paid lip service to being equal.
Sweet 👍 Now do one on the Sith acolytes please 🥺
I imagine the same but with a sprinkle of hunger games and Darwinism.
@@Amadeo790 👌😂🤣
Nice video I think that if I were to suggested improvement, it would be a little bit more life skills so that way if they do choose or there quietly encouraged to leave the order they’re not completely lost. Although that might be legends thinking, because they kind of made it sound like that anybody who let the order was completely clueless on how the galaxy worked. Probably due to authors, not paying attention to the Jedi Path book or George Lucas’s suggestions.
George Lucas also preached the ideal that the force could only be balanced by zero dark only light so. Maybe he was just in it for the money after the first one? As he's admitted?
One thing that would have certainly helped the Jedi as a whole a lot more was having "field trips" for Younglings around Coruscant. Chances and opportunities to interact with Republic citizens at large, and could have helped prevent isolationist attitudes many Jedi unintentionally seemed to develop
So the Jedi toss away failed students instead of helping them grow that is terrible even for the Jedi.
Then animan said let’s end all this
I heard Anikin got bullyed by many of his jedi youngling peers.
Other way around
Sounds like imperial propaganda
I wonder what place the underdogs in the jedi order are placed in.
I'm just going to make my own force sensitive order and have everyone just focus on the force and find the balance between it and make sure no younglings lose that balance, instead of passing trials and undergoing life changing experiences to become a Jedi.
That's just a Grey Jedi isn't it?
Love...how did the jedi not know about this.
The Anakin PR machine at work 😂😂😂
Hm maybe by if they failed their test to become padawns instead of resigning them or allowing them to leave the jedi to allow them to continue their training much more and to hone their skills and knowledge of a lightsaber and the force so when they are better prepared and more ready for the test to become a padawan that they could succeed
Seems to me that Anakin "loved" the younglings like farmers "love" animals.
Good fathers do love their animals, but they also understand reality.
That is why they have them live a happy life to adulthood and ensure the most painless and swift deaths.
@@MirrenTheDragonKnight I guess loving=killing, then. cope harder.
@@beastvg123 Spoken like some vegan airhead who has never spoken to a farmer in his/her life.
Animal products are everything from vaccines to the phone screen on which you likely wrote that comment.
You people always try to make up for your lack of nutrition, vitamins, protein and muscles with your self-righteous, hypocritical, ill-informed, often-controlling attitude.
He didnt love them when he executed operation knightfall
How did padawan not end up a curosanti or being little Jedi clones? Through out the series, various Jedi were cultural marking sometimes even from there own planet. How does this work with no attachments and taken from childhood?
"...until they might become a padawan..." There, fixed it for you as the (dumb) Jedi too often refused to take certain students on as padawans and those then joined the refuse-pile, otherwise known as the Service-Corps! Hell, some of those later became inquisitors - I wounder why? (Not really, I'd hate the order, too if they considered me trash only fit to bring in the money so that they Padawans, Knights and Masters could go adventuring!)
This is Republic Propaganda
How do the Jedi make sure that those who choose to leave the order don't start new force traditions?
It could have been improved by letting them (Under EXTREME supervision and vigil mind you) study the dark side of the force. That's why so many turned to it because they didn't know or understand the feelings and nature of the dark side and therefore did not know how to process it.
I can't help wondering what would happen with the younglings that did leave the Jedi Order if they failed their trials and didn't enter the service corps. They would be still children. Who took care of them and who was responsible for them?
Being a youngling isn't easy.
so the general tone seems to be Strict, but sincerely caring.
Just remember:
Nobody blamed the lightsaber.
Yes, human children, Tusken children, Anakin would just light up every time he saw them 😂
This is super interesting!
Can you make a video on the planet Ossus?
I say they should have the option of learning how to handle grief sorrow. They should teach them about how to handle attachment and how to support people emotionally and handle strong emotions rather than discourage which most jedi tend to do despite their code.
a good story would be - what happened to jedi who were in the service core after order 66 eh ? prob a very grisly fate...
yea I would assume they were killed in the temple massacre.
Really a shame that the Clone Wars didn't have a story with the farmer jedi... could have been hunt are spy/traitor story.
With the John Deere Tractor, lol
Luke's New Jedi Order was the best.
I wonder what ever happened to all those Younglings from Season 5 of The Clone Wars. We know Gungi survived since he's in the Bad Batch Season 2 trailer, but we don't know about the rest.
I always headcanon that they did escape, alongside the Droids from D-Squad, of course, in that headcanon I also thought some Clones like Jesse, Echo, the rest of the Bad Batch, and a few others helped them escape because I thought Rex would have told them about what Fives had discovered and they would have all removed their chips beforehand so when Order 66 did happen they would see what was going on, realize Fives was right and it was good they removed their chips beforehand, and then jump into action to help the Jedi. Bad Batch Season 1 and the Siege of Mandalore kind of disproved most of that, especially in the case of Jesse and Crosshair. Although, Jesse did still die in my headcanon because I thought some Clones should die during the saving of the Younglings, and I didn't want to kill Echo since he's all that's left of Domino Squad. Still, two very great shows mind you.
😇William oscer garvin; And this is why anakin skywalker should continue to love children instead of killing them.
The thumbnail💀💀
This is all cap I hate kids
Anakin is awesome
Never taken without the parents consent sounds like Jedi/Republic propaganda to me
Well after the death of the Sith and the Russan reformation, there had to be a plan to deal with potential dangers of undirected force users all over the galaxy to avoid new Sith or dark jedi.
@@Amadeo790 Yes I think the Jedi used the republic to make laws forcing parents to give up their kids. You don't get almost all the force users in one spot by accident
@@vikingsword3485 forced seems a strong word. Kids that have the powers to bend the universe around them are very dangerous if not directed but forcing. What they did was have blood tests if everyone with in the republic to keep a census of who was force sensitive or not. I feel is more gray than truly malicious.
@@Amadeo790 I see nothing more dangerous than state run super soldiers/ enforcers working for a corrupt government. Very little is written about the details of how they get the children and the jedi do have a reputation of being kidnappers on some planets. You add in the brainwashing jedi are known to do and I doubt every force sensitives ended up in one spot because everyone loves the jedi. The Jedi were so hated most welcomed order 66
Would Order 66 include former Jedi that ended up in the service Corp?
Yes; they would kill all Jedi and anyone associated with them
@@DLR1997 damn they definitely wouldn't survive since they don't have any real combat skill
don’t worry anakin is gonna treat them very very well..
I have a theory that anakin may have either instructed the younglings to fake their deaths using vital suppressors, or stabbed/struck them where none of their vitals were. he was consuned, but couldn't bring himself to do it
Stop it 😂
11 months ago 😮
Loved them to death.... 😅
Have the initiates only use wooden lightsabers until they have earned the right to have a real lightsaber during the Gathering...last but not least...the initiates should have one trip to Ahch-To, so they may have some familiarity with the humble beginnings of the Jedi path/ Bendu ways.
You're Star wars channel is dope! Way way better than Star wars theory and eckhearts ladder
1:47 every bg3 player “oh I know that one!”
I bet one of the lost clans is, clan Solo...
I'll show myself out...
We gonna just ignore that these kids were all pretty much abducted