Did China Hack ISRO & Crash Chandrayaan-2? | Geopolitical Analysis by Abhijit Chavda
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- Checkout my Introductory course Bharata: A Biography of the Oldest Civilization
Enroll here - abhijitchavda7...
For business/collaboration, email at business.chavda@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
📸To stay in touch closely, let's connect online:
INSTAGRAM: abhijitchavda....
TWITTER: / abhijitchavda
TELEGRAM: t.me/TheAbhiji...
DISCORD: / discord
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.c...
My gear for shooting this video:
🎙Shure MV7 USB Podcast Microphone: amzn.to/3n1rcme
🎥Logitech C922 Pro Stream Webcam: amzn.to/3ZYyg1G
🎤RØDE Rodecaster Pro II: amzn.to/3Jwo3Cj
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Support The Channel:
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/Abhi...
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
✅ Subscribe To Our Other TH-cam Channels:-
Abhijit Chavda Clips: @AbhijitChavdaClips
Abhijit Chavda हिंदी (Hindi Channel): @AbhijitChavdaHindi
Abhijit Chavda Vlog: @AbhijitChavda2
Indian Interest (Podcast): @IndianInterest
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
In a captivating exploration of one of India's most significant space missions, welcome to our video dissecting the Chandrayaan-2 mission and its unforeseen descent into uncertainty. Strap in as we delve into the riveting journey of India's second lunar endeavor, designed to flaunt its prowess in lunar surface landing.
The narrative begins on September 2nd when the Vikram lander boldly separated from the orbiter, marking a monumental step towards a successful lunar landing. Fast forward to September 7th, and the lander initiates its final descent, but as it neared a mere 2.8 kilometers from the lunar terrain, catastrophe unfolded - the lander inexplicably flipped, culminating in a crash that reverberated across the globe.
Our investigation navigates through the intricate details of this heart-stopping incident, meticulously examining the technical intricacies that may have contributed to this unforeseen twist. What anomalies or miscalculations prompted this dramatic flip mere moments before touchdown? We delve into these questions and more, shedding light on the underlying complexities of space exploration.
But our journey doesn't end there - a whisper of geopolitical undertones enters the narrative. Could there have been factors beyond technical challenges that influenced the fate of Chandrayaan-2?
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
About:
The Abhijit Chavda channel is an expansive library of content that offers insights into geopolitics, contemporary world affairs and history from an Indian perspective.
Abhijit Chavda's unique research-backed worldview has made him one of the strongest voices in the Indian Digital Space, and he has represented India at international forums, including the G20 summit.
Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE and HIT the notification bell to stay up-to-date with the latest videos!
Now, i read somewhere ISRO chief said.... Chandrayan 3 will make safe landing even if everything went wrong....That's the confidence we need..... I am waiting for the day when INDIA's lander and rover land on MARS with this confidence
@@nandanns981 no need to be confident if we cannot provide them with enough security from assasinations and CIA-ISI poachings like nambi narayan sir case and honey trap of DRDO director case
It's not INDIA, but BHARAT
@@ajayChauhan-nt5xm Sat Sat Naman aapko Prabhu kaha the aap......... Bharat v Galat h ....... Bharat Varsh h fir toh Prabhu.....
Aaj aandolan kre hum aapke sath h....
Ram tere Sansaar me Bhati Bhati k log ..
Pura msg chor kr Prabhu ko bs India dikhai diya
@@zhinkunakur4751 If u focus on bad it become worst.... But if u focus on good it become better than best..... Hope u understand what I meab
@@nandanns981 For sure Sir,,,👍👍👍👍
ISRO lost so many engineers and technologists during the last 20 years.
Most of the deaths were unnatural and sudden deaths.
Nambi Narayanan by Gods grace escaped and a living proof.
Americans earlier and the Chinese later have been targeting ISRO continuously to limit their growth.
Please do a video on this subject also
not just ISRO but in other branches as well. The recent honeytrap case conducted from pak on a DRDO official in the big example. DRDO/ISRO or any government officials working with confidential stuff should be trained about not to disclose anything to anyone.
Work of Americans
Many many thanks to our scientists for Chandryan 3.May HE bless our scientists. India will rise again and again.
Why doesn’t the government protect them? Why are they crucified in the name of patriotism?
Gotta say Americans are good at what they do
I have witnessed this channel growing from
Although I discovered Abhijit sir little later but nevertheless find his information and knowledge unmatchable to any other person/ channel !
Most enriching knowledge with accurate possibilities!!
ive been here since 10k so happy to see his rise
Same here… saw his documentary over Ganghis Khan and then he appeared on Beerbiceps
@impostor6348
@@Sunnytimtimlp
L😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Yes. Even the helicopter crash of Commander Bipin Rawat is highly suspicious on whether it was orchestrated by hacking.
@@anuraagkorchipati8794 communication system signal jamming , on board electronics distort to show wrong height and direction , the gps guiding system . Go to Google. China technology can bring down a plane with this technology.
@@anuraagkorchipati8794they have their own integrated cpus and on board computers for radar navigation and missile defense
Stop believing and spreading CT
russian choppers are prone to crashes.. lets not hunt for conspiracies everywhere.
It's not possible without deshdrohi Congress family
Why BARC, ISRO etc and other organizations are connected to outside Internet ?
Why our scientist names are known to everyone.. ?
Why our intelligence agencies don’t monitor personal conversations - emails, WhatsApp, phone of scientists with numbers which MAC address of foreign countries.. ?
you know all these things are end to end encrypted?
yeah leave the gates open and monitor each and every second
ok so whypeople use tor
Well said Brother.
They NEED internet access for their office jobs - and that’s most of them. Besides, the mission failed due to poor project management leading to a handful of software and hardware errors that *in combination* caused the failure. There was no hacking.
(And MAC addresses don’t work the way you think they do.)
As a security engineer, I feel very bad about the weak Indian cyber defense. Indian government cyber defense capability is close to ZERO!
Bhai apne desh proper cyber force wing hai hi nahi.
Can you do this ?
Please help India fix it
@@supremearyait's there. Called CSIR, and it's best 10 in the world. What's sad Is that India is lacking manforce we need for such a huge country to be kept safe against the external cyber security threats
Main problem is Govt ties with useless companies like Wipro, Infosys etc.
Always had this angle in my mind, then I used to move on thinking that I watched too many conspiracy theories
cyber security is very essential part . but including India , most of countries still in infant state ,sadly.
This time indian government bribed chinese by giving important component for their space station.....by this way they will insure safe landing of chandrayan 3 .....
@@sujitverma6029anphad...jaahil 2 kodi ke bimar aadmi 😂
I remember this bit of news at the time and i have personally no reason to believe that China WAS NOT involved in hacking ISRO. What is shameful is we have a country full of IT experts and yet zero cyber security capability. It is an absolute shame.
If you really believe that, I can sell you some moon diamonds 😂😂😂
@@ayambo3281 then start selling 😂😂😂
Could it be the USA trying to blame China?
100% if that possible
अमेरिका हो या चीन यह करके क्या फ़ायदा हुआ बस 500-600 मिलियन ज्यादा से ज्यादा 1 बिलियन का नुकसान इससे क्या भारत चाँद पर मिशन भेजना बंद होगया या फिर भारतीय आतंरिक्ष अनुसन्धान बंद हो गया।
Yes... uSa is th rculprit
@Technophile2323 standards so good that they will lie their way into a whole invasion (Iraq) and make up non-existent reasons just so that they can control some regions
@Technophile2323 usa is no different than china, if not worse
the media is just under their control so they are painted as the good guys
India badly needs strong cyber establishment for cyber security as well as cyber attacks if necessary..
No one is serious about Cyber Security in India,recently we have seen AIIMS Databases were attacked.
we need army of cyber securities like USA Russia And China . There are special arm force in big way A WING just to protect the cyber attack . Even the N korea has the cyber hacking wing , But they are only to steal Money from various companies of the world ,they do not even leave alnoe a Medical facilities so does china . They do not care who they hurt . like china tried her BEST to steal the Covid -19 vaccine tech over and over . chinese has their many many professors in USA universities to steal the research.
Probably that's why there is semiconductor push to manufacture microprocessor within India. Already launched own Operating System.
That Own operating system you are is just another Linux distro bro😏
@@ravijawla4561 I know but that's a good step forward. Improvements will happen over time because government is thinking in that direction. So this move is a important one.
It’s Heartbreaking for me. Just speechless. Thankyou for sharing this story with the viewers. 🙏🏼
China may distract us from chandrayan to border conflict when china feel India is going to make history.
We have something called as The Great Indian army.
Cheen is NOT India's main enemy. nor paakis. Its gora saahibs who still cant forget british raaj
@@anantbhushangaur1972❤
"reclaim" History
Ckmkb
Absolutely gutted to find out that chandrayan -2 mission was compromised due to poor cyber defence.
Cyber security is crucial in modern warfare, sad to see India is lagging behind in such systems.
We really need to up the game, there should be a cyber awareness from ground level, and forces who works on such national missions should be well trained in cyberspace.
Thank you Abhijit sir, well delivered. Your expertness is impeccable.
I swear to god since that episode I was really eager to hear you talking on this in details. Finally the video is here.
It is quite infuriating to see India lag behind in modern warfare by 50 years
Thank you Abhijit Chavadaji for letting us know what actually went wrong with Chandrayan2.
In today's world cyber security and cyber attacks are huge concern for individuals as well big pvt and govt organizations alike.
@@anuraagkorchipati8794 share the link of the talk please
No wonder there wasn't much investigation in this matter probably govt knows about this nd surely working in shadow's to punish such people
They can't do much, considering China's might. They should be more transparent to India's citizens, though, and not keep the real reasons hidden.
Sometimes some things better stays hidden and China's might will not come in way china is declining and have their own issues to resolve and I'm 100% sure the ones who are involved will definitely be pay !!
Yes. Such actions are not publicised to avoid alerting the culprits that we know. Neither is counter action publicised.
Yes keep spreading rumours while the Director himself clarified what exactly went wrong.
Govt should tell the citizens then citizens would get serious in boycotting Chinese products
Absolute love to watch Abhijit sir Explanation😊🙏
Crisp and clear
I clearly remember that day, stayed awake till 4:00 am just to hear a good news after the sad demise of our Lander/Rover. I remember the trajectory graphs like it was yesterday.
Most awaited question Sir , thanks for the video 🙏🙏🙏
Thats not a question. Thats the answer.
@@MontexSingh HaHa
Why do we remain gullible with over 1000 years of history of such incidents happening with our civilization
Yeah exactly we definitely need to be more aware of possible sabotaging from foreign countries...
Because of stooges and clowns who have advocated mindless pacifism or propaganda at all costs and our emotional population which can sway away from common sense faster than the speed of light.
You should read Hindu scriptures. All the sinners after a certain time come to India because they get a chance at redemption. They don't lose all of their older habits that's the problem.
Even in your run of the mill IT companies, employees are trained consciously not to click on email links etc. It’s unacceptable that a couple of high ranking executives in ISRO just clicked on some link. I hope ISRO amps up training to employees.
Indian neuclear scientists are weak in IT, they are good in physics but, reason is India historically weak in hardcore computer science, who ever has expertise going to US
The sudden abrupt loss of control indicated sabotage, and i was also suspecting hackers or virus that could have signalled a abrupt shutdown of all systems. I was also suspicious of our opposition leaders who don't want to see our PM Modi or India grow in name and fame, and these guys can easily act through their stoogies in worker unions. There are external and internal wars waged in India.
Finally after 1 year of my #askabhijit questions i got the answer. Thank you very much sir. 🙏🏼
I was deeply saddened by Chandrayaan -2 crash !!
everyone was. I was literally sticked to TV whole night to watch the landing.
@@KrisVal-tu5li to smaj kaise aya ki kehna kya chah rha hai wo?
smaj aya na? ye vyakaran suddhikaran online mat karo yar
Si nous laissons de côté la partie piratage pour un moment, il semble y avoir des coïncidences pour deux de vos missions spatiales qui étaient les toutes premières du genre.
Il semble que la mission Chandrayaan-2 a échoué en raison d'une erreur de logicielle, comme officiellement notifié. C'était votre première tentative d'alunissage.
Maintenant, si nous revenons 30 ans en arrière, le même type d'incident s'est produit lors du lancement de votre première fusée PSLV en 1993. Cela était également dû à une erreur de logicielle.
En 1993, vos scientifiques ont appris leur leçon et il n'y a plus eu d'échec de fusée à ce jour. Je suis sûr qu'ils ont appris leurs leçons après le crash de C2 et je suis confiant que cette fois, l'alunissage sera parfait.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Faute de frappe : 20 ans remplacé par 30 ans
Exactly, these are idiots who peddle wrong information and throw stuff for $$$$$ money and viewership
Vous êtes correct.
Which country do you belong. 😊
It's our own fault, programming in chandrayan 2 was put on restricted measures so chandrayan was not able make corrections by own(revealed by ISRO only)
He never said it was own fault. Okkk
@@Maolana_ModiG Scott Manley just put a video out with a proper explanation. No Chinese interference -- just a couple of (minor) screw ups with hardware and software. Version 3 is under development and it is looking good so far -- ISRO seems to have learned a lot from Chandrayaan-2.
@@peterfireflylundyes I believe that than some conspiracy theory
#askabhijit Sir, today Russia's Luna-25 lander unfortunately crashed on the moon, and the reason was a technical glitch. Could it be possible that USA or other russian enemy countries tried to hack & crash the Russian mission?
Everyone is paranoid. Rocket science is difficult.
yes i agree china also hacked gen Rawat helicopter and was responsible for the crash and his death. India must avenge his death
China has probably hacked the minds of people in Manipur too... if we fail, just blame someone else..
Glad someone noticed & commented!
He was actually going to comment on the pulwama incident and so his own govt had him removed. U really think the govt won't and doesn't delete it's own people?
@@shyamranger this is not your pakstani govt
how do you hack a helicopter u hack the rotor blades no you fucking cant ,u hack radar and other electrical components that connect with internt but most of these arent things that could be hacked and controlled like a drone .human error hota hai mostly
Abhijit Sir thanks for this detailed and valuable explanation as i was lost and it was painful too that how we failed for Chandrayaan 2.
Dr. Kurulkar who was recently arrested in a suspected case of honeytrap for providing confidential information to a Pakistani agent.
So i hope DRDO will take proper measures to avoid such act of sabotage...
🙏🙏🙏
Not china
India must develop world class cyber security agency...to protect and attack installations.
Abhijit ji 🙏 for a Masterpiece Analysis of espionage activities carried on by major powers which perhaps only you could . The extent of espionage and the degree of requirement of cyber security is simply mind boggling , just beyond imagination . Hope ISRO and GOVT both have taken adequate cognizance specially for Chandrayan 3 . For the last 2 / 3 decades we have lost unnaturally many Brilliant and Eminent Scientists and we do not know if govt has taken any action or not or is still in deep Slumber , only God knows .
India still trying to improve their skills and should stopped mentioning china involvement in their failure!
Abhijeet is well informed and I am listening to his podcast almost Daily. I wish we had these type of information made available on national channels but they are nuts.
That's wat u get for using open source & Microsoft s.w ! Dee's projects shud b held as national security level.
As an INDIAN I am proud of ISRO
Jai hind
Jai bharat 🇮🇳👨🚀
As an Irish-American I am also Proud of India and the ISRO.... I would bet the entire world is proud....
@@donhearn2248 Thank you so much Don, It is really nice to see the support of the international viewers. Hope the world progress more! Glory to all!
Big fan of abhijit, he speaks very nicely and unlike other channels his words enters my brain easily with logic. Thank you ❤
I'd like to drop this information about 'Dhruv Rathi'. I happen to watch his take on the latest incidents and issues going on in Manipur. So I left a comment saying what he has said in the video is not really the ground reality and viewers can watch videos by 'Abhijit Chavda'. My comments were deleted. I was surprised to see this. Very suspicious. Something to ponder about.
Being a Software Engineer and did my intern in cyber security during my college time. I can write this assuredly that majority of Indian even who is working in Cyber security department (run by GOI) don't even know "C" of Cyber World.
And you guys are expecting for awareness among people who almost lost there savings in spam call and that's too when there bank account is 3steps verified along with OTP verification 😂.
Don't make Fun of anyone. Yahi manners hain tere ❤de
As a software engineer and didn't did my intern in cyber security during my college time , I can tell this assuredly that mejority of cyber attacks happen when user is soo confident in his ability that he can't be hacked
Outstanding sir..
You are true patriotic man
Sir would like to understand Russian obsession to compete Luna25 with Chandrayaan 3 !! Looks fishy
Why Russia is landing its lunar mission ( Luna 25) @ same date of chandrayan 3 .
Is there any chance that Russia is doing this to fail Chandrayan 3?
Love this content and the Knitty gritty that covers all, Keep going Sir
And now india started using its own operating system before landing of chandrayan3
is it true ?
@@RamasArrowyes windows replace by Indian government
@@Unknown-jy7ku Is it linux based ?
@@RamasArrow Maharaj abb mujay itana details nahi pata hai
Great video and awesome explaination.
Abhijit sir 🙏🔥
Only devout Hindus can sacrifice their personal well-being for the well-being of Bharat because only devout Hindus love the ancient civilization and culture of Bharat
Only 10 years is left for hindu. Be ready for....
i thought the same thing but then again if it were to happen then as an ethical hacker i know that we as hacker cannot hack some completely clean some residue still remains basically hacking an organization like isro takes days to get into systems by bypassing firewalls
This doubt hasn't crossed my mind in a very long time. Did communists want India divided into 17 regions? What is the truth? If anyone knows, kindly respond.
Please see the discrepancies of landing coordinates of Chandran-2 and Chandran-3 which very clear show the glaring errors by ISRO.
Landing Coordinates of present Lander 69.3730 32.3190
Landing Coordinates of present Rover 69.367621 32.348126
Design Landing Coordinates of ISRO-Chandrayan-2 (now) 69.367621 32.348126
Impact Site Coordinates by Shanmuga- for Chandrayan-2 (now) 69.37302 32.32017
Expected Landing coordinate of ISRO-Chandrayan-2 (Dec 3-2019 ) 70.9 22.7
Impact Site Coordinate of Chandrayan-2 as per Shanmuga (Dec 3-2019) 70.881 22.784
This is the same thing that i thought.
The first thing came in my mind after crase was "is there any Chinese involvement in this" the reason behind this was there was no clear explanation on why chandrayan 2 crashed.... Now everything is clear.... Thanks to this knowledgeable man..... My fav. on TH-cam
You're right, China provided fake and inferior components
Cannot blame the chinaman without real proof.
@@frodobaggins2852 I respect ISRO and it's explanation...... And i more thing this man has more knowledge than most of the so called INTELLECTUALS didn't have .....
A country of blamers 😮
Your Girls rapped on bus also caused by Chinese espionage
As s security Researcher I'm deeply sad about Indian website low WAF protection, its to easy to hack any govt website or service, really need a proper infrastructure for Indian cyber security sector
Abhijeet... It's suuuper... God bless you...that's all a Sr. Citizen can say...🙏
Exactly my suspicion that grew the very momemt it failed. In fact I was fearing for such a move either by China's or the US cyber intels long before it was even launched. I still have doubts even this time as well but let's strongly hope this time we can make it happen.
China did hack our moon mission last time, it was mentioned in a foreign site, but then there were few talks on various forums as well.
You should know hackers will use multiple proxy servers to hack. Hackers will use your enemies proxy to hack so you will blame them. Thats how you are unable to trace them. If i'm yr enemy, it will be stupid for me to hack you knowing you will surely point finger at me.
At present, China can manufacture 7nm semiconductor chips, while India can manufacture 7mm potato chips, 1 mm = 1,000,000 nanometers. This gap must be because China hacked India’s iron pot/wok filled with hot oil.
जय श्रीराम🙏,
नमन इतने आवश्यक विषय निरंतर उठाने के लिए एवं इतनी सरलता से इतने गंभीर एवं जटिल विषयों को समझने के लिए। इश्वर आप पर अपनी असीम कृपा बनाए रखे।
जय मां भारती🙏
Reading all these comments in this program made me realise most hindustanies realy care for their countries success in space programs.I feel its moon success is more important then life itself.Way to go people.
Inverted pendulum is in itself a complicated design. See how many times Elon Musk's starship crashed.
It's impossible to jam the long wavelength radio signals which such communication links use. If China has an insider in ISRO to press the wrong button, then it's a different story. Or it may not even be China - it may be a disgruntled employee of ISRO, who did it. There is always competetion for promotion and recognition within such organisation.
To rise as a super power, DON'T blame others for your OWN failures. Especially if the blamed ones are light years ahead of you in technological advancements.
1.5 billion dollars ISRO budget is totally a joke 😢
while yes i agree the funding needs to be upped considering the ambitious projects we are working towards, i also wud like to point out something.
Russia's gdp is not even 1/20th of America's, nvm american vassals/nato members. and yet russia has shown them their place in last 18months, that is, also with he fact that they haven't even brought out their air arsenal. as much as the budget, how it is used efficiently is important.
we DEFINITELY shouldn't cut corners, at the same time just to get at par with america allocating the same figure is.....
Abhijit Sir is a Gem of our Country ❤️🙏🏽🇮🇳
@Abhijit Chavda i think we do make chip. there is one fab plant in mohali and they (space mission) need chip which have big node (low efficiency) to protect them from cosmic radiation. But nobody knows about the chip design.
Anyway russia is landing its luna 1 day before..and it mysteriously looks like chandrayan 2
Save some money for eating bat soup…. the economy is crashing. Time to send another balloon 🎈
Yeah, this is a matter of concern!!! But, for now I'll dump this theory because, even to establish a connection with a satellite at this distance requires huge antennas & that too all around the world !!!
And the problem is that many of our big brains in IT are working in US and outside India.
What ISRO's achievent...can't even protect it's satelites from hacking...what a shame
What a shame Indians demoralising their own country. Itna dimaag hai to tu isro me scientist banja gadhe
Happens. Now we know, and we know what to need to be done.
Xi jinping really enjoyed watching ISRO chief crying on the shoulder of modi too
Imagine the possibility of hacking ISRO during gaganyaan mission..ISRO must do something serious for enhancing cybersecurity.
The Indian government should be able test all of these hypotheses because there are traces of intrusions into systems, and can be tested if it was a genuine onboard problem or something transmitted. Also per protocol ISRO would have an exact replica of the Chandrayaan-2 and processor chipsets used and all program coding. If sabotage did occur the Indian government with NASA's help would have by now determined the cause however they may not disclose it publicly. Also one has to understand the final minutes of these missions are all automated, the distances are too vast to make any coarse correction transitions, its basically a blackout period until is lands. I think it was a technical glitch which will be corrected.
We area cybersecurity company who are experts in digital forensics. If given a chance, we can help them to figure out if they are hacked.
Wonder what happened to Ajit Doval ji's helicopter.
#JaiHind ❤
Yes... Its looking like same as you said is might be right👍
Cybersecurity is very complex and difficult subject. Hope all the organisations of India focus more on cybersecurity. Not only defensive, but also attacking capabilities have to be improved continuously.
0:25 innocence on your face
lol
Would Maya OS mitigate these kind of cyber attacks?
About Radio communication, the data capture, possible with right frequency. The so called Radio frequency ID in terms of its bandwidth, possible with another data capturing, collided. But the ISRO announced, time of landing, temporarily, those radio communication can be stalled for safe landing. The IP adress, even 6 octel , ( IP6) seems to be not safe.
There are several issues that come up:
1. Why does India need to connect vital facilities to the Internet? The core operations and R&D could be completely disconnected. If connectivity has to be provided between different R&D centers, these could be handled through dedicated, highly secure, fiber optic lines that India already has under one government agency or other.
2. If the Kudankulam hack happened through the simple means of an email link sent to the top-most bureaucrats, then clearly something utterly stupid was allowed to happen: no link should be allowed to be opened unless vetted by some cyber agency, especially emails to the top bureaucrats of the organization, even emails ostensibly coming from internal "sources".
3. Mr. Chavda refers to semiconductors used by ISRO that are foreign-sourced, so the malware could have been inserted here. That begs the question: if Apollo 11 that sent the first humans to the moon was made possible by technologies literally eons behind what is available today (for example, the electronics that go into a medium-priced smartphone today is about a million times more powerful than the one used in Apollo 11), then why not have ISRO collaborate with Semiconductor Corp (SCL) to design, make, and deliver indigenous semiconductors that are 25 years behind the current state of technology but still allow for computations to make our space endeavors possible? SCL, for example, does not have the technology or means to develop and manufacture, say, 1 nm chips, but it sure has the means to design and manufacture 40 nm ones. After all, ISRO's current space projects are still behind what NASA's Apollo 11 achieved and, even if ISRO gets to that point, it would still replicate NASA's achievement with lower technologies? Yes, this sounds utterly anachronistic - if we have the latest and greatest at our means, why go back to technologies that are ancient by comparison? The counter-intuitive argument is that: first, ISRO does not have to spend time and resources on ensuring we have anti-hacking mechanisms in place that cannot be foolproof by any means and, second, China or any other hacker would not be able to touch what is indigenous and, perhaps, an older technology that would not be amenable to new technologies, methods, programming tools, etc. Moreover, it would give ISRO the ability to work with less "horsepower" - ie, older technologies - and deliver the same results. That would be be cheaper and less prone to threats from outside.
4. It is not just ISRO or the BARC facilities are that are exposed. The financial sector - another vital system - is equally exposed in its entirety as the Indian financial institutions are woefully under-equipped, lack awareness and knowledge, and merrily run without the slightest controls. Sucheta Dalal's YT videos document how privacy and security issues are exposed on a daily basis.
5. All the above argue for a systematic review and an alternative model created in cooperation with leading academic institutions, security agencies, and the organizations involved. This would have to design for a set of concentric circles involving complete isolation, to fewer and monitored interfaces, to full integration to the Internet that can enable operations and customer engagement.
Dear Abhijit, I guess ISRO makes its own chips (guess in the range of 80-120 mm nodes)
Indians are so innocent and so emotionally swayed , that we fail to realize how how cunning , ruthless and downright evil our enemies can be . That’s why events like hotel Mumbai happens . You know which people in india are always suspicious and aware of enemies move ? Manipuris !
A m- prosessor can not be mis wired, but a m- controller can be mis programmed !
I knew this thing before just after that failure. my tution teacher said me this, but they told that it was a group of korean hackers. they did have advanced firewall, they also suggested about a hackers group in mumbai(i don't know thier name), He had huge contacts. I guess this info not be disclosed then.. it's shame that isro was hacked.
sir, but at IISC recently ISRO chief Somnath revealded what went wrong which was broadcasted on NEWS18 KANNADA 5 days ago, what do you think of those reasons too?
Abhijit ur fears are realistic. Let us see the finale on augst 23.
There are lot of experienced cyber defense professionals in India. The need of the hour is to open up opportunities for them without age bar constraints
No words for your explanation and research. Salute you, sir.
#AskAbhijit.. Sir what's the original name of Khyber Pass? I know it was named after the Arab conquered of Khyber fort of Jewish people.. That pass was used by invaders to attack Indian subcontinent.
Thanks Abhijit sir for sharing such a crucial information about our India's enemies who from time to time pushed our country backwards with all evil & venomous tactics.
We lost many of our engineers from time to time losing their lives with mysterious circumstances.
Tough measures should be taken!!
Sir surely most likely it is usa responsible than by North Korea.
Conclusion of this video is Bharat needs to Atma-nirbhar in every sector.
Sir, gareeb scientist has explained the reason based on recent ISRO inputs. Wish you can do a collab with him and explore the possibility of hack.
was looking for this comment
And I always thought, that you guys have the best tech support in the world! 😉😁😇
😂
Tech support and cyber security are two different concepts dude.
@@SujitNair7 I know; I was just badly joking. Very badly. ;)
@@cbhlde the Chinese are well prepared and better at cyber security and warfare.. our country still has to take that field of defense as seriously as China..
@@cbhlde racist much white guy
We are humans and we seek our explanations for our failures, and we improve. Even I was sad when Vikram Lander did not make it during Chandrayaan 2, but I do not know with certainty that china or anyone else had anything to do with our failure.
It is not like a machine connected to internet which can be hacked at run-time. Furthermore, the software for landing is autonomous and preprogrammed because the delay in communication signals prevent any real-time control, even by ISRO. Telemetry is a 1-way channel from spacecraft to the space agency. There is a very, very tiny possibility that software was hacked when Vikram's software was being programmed and installed before launch. But again, it is extremely tightly controlled, and I doubt ISRO wouldn't have found anything amiss even after 4 years of investigations and rather ISRO has already mentioned what the inadequacies were in the software.
And suddenly in 2021 China tests thorium based reactor and now in 2023 it is Green to Go...🤔🤐
Japanese Lunar mission also failed right
Israel mission too
just now subscribed 😉
Good timing of the video. Very good explanation. Thank you. We needed this.
If if it is true. joke on India tho
Because We can do pretty much nothing about it.