The guilty person MUST endure the proper punishment provided by law, more so when he is supposed to have promised to uphold the law and lead the country. No pardon, no house arrest, no nothing whatsoever!!!!!!
Even I guess supposed there is no prisoner to be the leader of the country & all M’sian hv to respect our country constitution list especially about religion & race‼️‼️
Stop wasting time on a convicted criminal who stole billions of dollars from the Ratyats and enriched his families. Why must he be given special treatment just because he has millions to spend on lawyers. . What about those who steal to put food on the table for the families and sent to Jail? Should they be put on house arrest too? Does Malaysia has a special judicial system for the corrupted rich? Do those who fight for his house arrest believe Malaysia should have a special judicial system for the corrupted rich who stole from the Ratyats?
Prof, you need to do this in Malay to reach your intended target audience. GK Ganeson did a very clear review and explained correctly the legality of the addendum.
Pls don't assume that the target audience are the Malays because there are a lot of non-Malays who are vocal on this issue in opposition to the government's stand.
I think the non Malays have a good understanding of the laws...while the Malays in the rural area really need to know the narratives of this case of Najib. Many podcasts are conducted by Malays tend not tell the truth and playing dirty politics. Worst still playing the blame games against the govt and it's leaders. And so the Malay folks in the Kampong become more confused resulting in voting the stupid anti govt leaders. So prof how about you helping the rural folks to think smart ???
As a citizen of Malaysia, i see that this country operates a two tier legal systems, one for the elite/politicians and the second for normal citizens. The elites/politicians seem to enjoy a lot of preliviges provided by the power that governs the legal system. While the normal citizens and peasants always tend get the raw deal of the Law 😒
@@kingok9147 comment from idiot..this law already there long time ago..many non vvip have pardon due berkelakuan baik dalam tahanan..only under cave citizen donnow
MANYBOF OUR VOP POLITICIANS ARE INVOLVED IN ALL KINDS OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITIES AND ABUSE OF THEIR POWERS TO COLECT WANG HARAM AND ENRICH THEMSELVES NAD THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS.
Even without the freedom to go shopping is already morally to be granted a house arrest cost there will be two sets of law. One for the VVIP or have n one for the ordinary people or have not or poor. We are now trying to change the law to suit the situation of the country to suit the needs for someone or Vvip to be granted a house arrest just because he was a former PM n found guilty of his charges n granted a discount for his jail terms from 12 years to 6 years only. This is a blatant disregard to the rule of law. Might as well don't have the law n all guilty can walk free after all n demolish the prison n save the country in maintaining the rule of law😢😮😅
Sorry but I disagree with some of the things you say. Firstly it seams from some TH-cam videos that muster Najib has already vvip level in jail where he already is given permission to use mobile phone Internet and computer. Which other inmates are granted this? 30 feet around his house and once a week he is being permitted to have guest does that mean every once in a week he can have a bbq party in his home garden? And what about some one want to visit him the next day who is going to stop that. BUT most importantly you already mentioned there is no law in Malaysia that grant house arrest so does the law have to be changed for probably the one who stole the largest sum of money in history? Is it morally even fair of mister Najib to adk for all these privileges after what he has done. Even until today he keep on saying he has not done anything wrong so he is not even sorry for what he has done according to his confliction in court. Is it not that in some countries politicians where these kind of crimes done by politicians they can get life in prison or even death penalty? Should mister Najib than not be very lucky getting ONLY 6 years in jail? And an other thing should the law not be equal for every person in Malaysia? So if he is granted house arrest how about people who do a minor crime will they from now on get a slap on the wrist and being told go home but don't do it again? In my humble opinion if some one who comited such a huge crime and basically don't get any punishment that will destroy Malaysia justice system. According to his court cases he stole billions and basically no punishment than some one who steels "only" 1 million how is justice going to serve him? And let's also not forget how other countries will see Malaysia countries that are involved in these crimes? Will Malaysia not be the clown of the world in there eyes? US helped to get some of the stolen money back well they as well might think to keep it because of it. An other thing is as you mentioned there is no law in Malaysia that grants house arrest so even if you change the law now it would not be applicable to mister Najib because he is convicted already
I totally in agreement with all your points. The only dilemma this government is current facing is UMNO factions that can’t seem to distance themselves from the corrupt and convicted Najib just because they are still relying on some faction of his supporters for votes and staying relevant as a dying party. The only way for Najib to be politically alive is to keep singing the ‘I am not guilty’, ‘I didn’t have a fair trial’ and ‘I am being punished politically’ songs which his supporters swallowed wholeheartedly. PMX is hoping that buying time and efforts in his leadership in government would be enough to get a clear mandate from the rakyat without having to rely on unity from other not so friendly (and corrupt) political parties such as Umno/Gps/Grs etc. Pas/Bersatu clearly sees this and kept trying to disrupt PMX endeavours as they kept losing supports by the day to the Harapan’s parties. It is a delicate political chessboard game PMX is facing but one that he will only win if the Malaysia and its rakyat’s economic situation improves noticeably which is a big ask given the huge debts servicing and fundamental (weak education & corrupt public services) damages that he inherited.
Whatever the legal issues, how can a person facing so many court cases be even considered for a pardon from the Agung? Shouldn't he first face all the charges and the sentences meted to him by the justice system, and then apply for pardon? Pardon should be granted only once. Is Najib hoping for a DNAA for the rest of the charges?
Najib has never stopped troubling the Rakyat..... Started while he's still a PM, continue while in the prison and sadly will continue burdening the Rakyat with his non stop Antic of wanting to seek fresh air outside even when he's supposedly and ideally spend at least ,30 years at the least for his part in robbing the nation coffer.... If someone has never really been truthful with the addendum which I don't think so due to its complexity, I think it's part of KARMA coming surely to Najib for his doing, he always been lying to Rakyat all this while
Never mind the lies. He still has faithful followers who will follow and support him to the grave. Culture of the Malays . Give them a sen and they are grateful to you for life even if you are guilty of the worst kind.
Correction ... He started troubling the Rakyat way back when he became the Minister of Education....he made the education ministry lower the PMR n SPM standards...u see on TV students being surprised they got 8As without putting much work , while those studied hard to excel were disappointed to see their good grades became meaningless ?!! I know bcos my son n his friends were upset at that. And he did a stupid thing again meddling with the universities' s metriculasi n Asasi programs...by centralizing it.....thus making it harder to get into university programs of your choice......bcos metriculating at the university that offers the programs you want...gives u advantage into obtaining your desired choice of your future career Example: you want to do agriculture; UPM is where u do metriculasi not in UM or UKM etc etc
@@azillahadam9769 in short he's proven to be nothing but a useless citizen that unfortunately had lead the country in a way that brought so bad era to the country...
There is no legal dilemma. KGanesan gave a very good explanation on this. There is also no moral dilemma. Cheating & stealing is wrong & must be punished. If these crooks get away with it due to political manipulation then it is moral corruption - not a dilemma.
SAH SUNGGUH PUN ,,,,,kenapa rakyat patut membayar hutang kerjaan di buat oleh ahli politics gagal tabir negara dan kerajaan pun ..... sekarang rakyat perlu bangkit kenapa kita perlu bayar hutang kerjaan ????? ini dah tiba masa utk rakyat Tanya soalan ini kepada AGONG AG AGC DAN KEPADA PMX ????
@@agneslily6566 Sultan Abdullah term ended 30th January. On the 30th, he is no longer Agong. And hence, his addendum didn't make it into Pardons Board. Agong cannot make unilateral decree without the Pardons Board. It's not how it works in with Constitutional Monarchy. Hence the new YDPA issue a statement last week. Understand what he's trying to say.
Well folks...face reality in this "Malaysia Madani, Malaysia Boleh" that we are living in now. If Zahid's 47 charges could be swept that easily under the rug, then nothing surprises me anymore with this latest news. Sad to see this adendum from our King simply because it portrays in opinion a message to the rakyat that anybody who stole billions could get scot free from jail. To me this is wrong as future leaders could also see this as a ticket if they commit similar crime? As a Muslim, this is wrong by God and also by law
@@hishamosman4341 They are acting like elite as powerful as the Ydp Agong of the country. Even the royalty has the privilege they have to abide to the law 😋😅👍🙏
If one crooked criminal guy like this can be at home as house arrest then all others should have the same benefits. Otherwise there's no equality in the law
Prof, pls ask the Sult of Pahang to give a copy of the addendum. Straight-fwd action ! But what the hell is His Majesty trying to do ? Is it to Confuse the rak'yat, Create unnecessary chaos among the political parties, Splitting the people, Creating real-rubbish among the judiciary etc.? Was'salam
It was released after the pardon board meeting and its not in the discussion agenda thats why the dispute now back to high court to determine the validity of the addendum.
@@mariambintijaafar8323 We only heard of it well after, like a few months after the previous Agong's tenure had ended. That probably implies that it only came into existence well after his tenure had ended, as there is no official record of it existing. And that implies that the so-called Addendum is null and void for many and not just a single reason.
@@limfc6953 It's just an act of desperation to buy time for his plee of house arrest until the next GE16 n the faction supporting him to manoeuvre their needs to win the next election n Najib can have the chance to be PM if Anwar cannot have the full support from Umno. It's always their dirty tactic to gain control knowing unless Zahid can prove he really has the full support of Umno to be the next PM if Anwar loses control 😋😅👍🙏
A prisoner who has not served his sentence to half of his sentence is forbidden to request for house arrest . The offence committed is grave because the graft committed is in billions of ringgit. House arrest is forbidden because of the offence committed is big amount.
The rich and powerful elites enjoyed special privilege and treatment whereas ordinary citizens are not shown mercy. The saga goes to tell the world that high profile crime pays.
kenapa kerjaan AG AGc agong sultan GAGAL penjarakan AHLI POLITICS gagal tabir urus negera dan meletak kan negera dlm hutang besar ????? dan menjadi beban besar kepada kehidupan rakyat malaysia ??????
Maybe the AG did receive the so called ‘addendum’ and may out of courtesy replied to former agong that it could not be implemented for 2 reasons. 1. IT'S OUT OF TIME AS PARDON BOARD AND HOME MINISTRY HAS TAKEN ACTION AS PER PERINTAH on 29th Jan 24 2. THE FORMER AGONG HAS CEASED HIS APPT. On 30th Jan 24. THUS, ADDENDUM IS NOT VALID ANY MORE. INVALID, TIDAK TERPAKAI ATAU TIDAK LAKU. AG CONSIDERS IT'S PERSONAL MATTER NOT OFFICIAL MATTER BETWEEN HIS OFF AND FORMER AGONG. HE MAY ONLY ANSWER IN COURT. MOST IMPORTANT CONVICTS PLACE IS IN PRISONS NOT AT HOME 😂😂😂
a criminal should serve out his sentence in jail n no reduction of fines. laws cannot be turn upside down to suit the rich n powerful. no one should be Above the Law !!!!
Prof, Recently a prisoner who had served 4 months jail sentence commented that Najib is being treated special at prison cell.There seem to be a substandard treatment in our prison where certain jail inmates are getting special treatment despite a big crime is committed.😮
Those arguing that the Agong's decision is absolute where he does not take into account the people's feelings is unlikely to be the reality. The Agong is also human and if he is rational, he would probably decide based on the desire of the majority of the people taking into account the desire of the minority.
À pardon must reflect justice and should be seen to be just to all rational minds. It is sad that a king cannot understand this. It will forever be a blot in the country’s administration of justice.
Prof, nobody is talking about a serious issue in this Addendem case. This is about COnflict of Interests. One question is why the Pardon Board only met towards the very end of the previous Agong's reign. I speculate that the Agong was very hesitant and even reluctant to chair this meeting. This is because Najib is very close to him personally and also in relation to the Pahang Sultanate. If the Agong chair the meeting, would it be possible for him to act in a neutral manner because of their relationship! We have seen how Najib and Rosmah had protested and got numerous judges removed because of Conflict of Interests. I believe the Agong is fully aware of this. It was clear that the Agong was being pressured by many quarters. The rumour that the Addendem was not signed is one vital sign of this. For all we know the Addendem was written by someone else.
@@Hnnn__00 What consequences are you talking about? The possible political 'mutiny' by UMNO in the UG ship? UMNO needs to wake up and deal with the loss of support of the Malays. Don't expect to regain its past powers without meaningful reform. In fact, UMNO is currently in the best position to reform in its partnership with PH leading the UG, as corruption is not tolerated officially although the culture of corruption still exists. Give the UG another 2 terms and the systemic corruption problem would inevitably be solved.
You stole, you're caught , you're charged, you're found guilty then do your years in prison. What moral you have asking for any discount or pardon of your sentence !?
@@wannurizanshaikhmohd5548 You are obviously overestimating of the power of UMNO over the Malays. When UMNO is reformed and turn away from the corrupted past leadership, especially under Mahathir and Najib, it may regain its Malay support. The fact that some in UMNO are still fighting for Najib, the convicted fellon means that they could not move on with the UG. Luckily, the current UMNO leadership believes in the UG.
@@adamiskandar5107 Obviously u do not kno n do not understand how d law n Constitution works. If UMNO has d absolute power like d YDPA to pardon Najib, Najib would hv been d 10th PM instead of Anwar. Remember, d adendum for Najib's house arrest cums fr d YDPA 16, not UMNO.
Hi Prof, you call upon your audience to trust that the government will do the right thing. How many rakyat can do this, especially after watching the behaviour of most politicians/ so-called leaders?!! 😅😅
Stealing huge some of money is king and that will set you free. Don't steal kacang putih, one can of milk powder, or a packet of Milo because you can end up in jail for a long time. 😂😅
Unusually soft of d Prof. In a Constitutional Monarchy , no one has absolute power. The Constitution is supreme. If a forner PM who is now a convict, is given special consideration, all other convicts, under similar circumstances, should be given d same treatment. Govt shud have laid out d facts, explain what it could & culdnt do. ( Wilful concealment is no different from 'hiding'.) If d law is 'grey', let d Courts declare it white or black
In the context of the past Chinese monarchy system, whatever command given in writing (edict) must have to be endorsed by stamping the royal seal on it. So if the royal addendum to be valid should be sent back to the Palace to have it endorsed with the royal seal, instead of putting it in cold storage until the Next King sits on the throne. We can use this to self-reflect on the appropriate action that should be taken by the government to maintain a transparent administration.
The whole problem is that politics and business are intertwined, generating huge amount of money for them. So people are victimised by monopolistic business. Rice, cars and even rice is under monopolies. If not separated this country will not develop and progress.
Why dont fully pardon than house arrest pardon? Wants to please the public and at same time wants to please the supporter of Najib of his good contribution to the country .
Other than this case I have never heard of the concept of house arrest. So how does it work? The prisoner is in his own house right? Hows the security then? The Prisons Dept deploy wardens and guards to ensure the prisoner does not leave his house? Is the prisoner free to communicate via phone and Internet?
Under the current practice, 'house arrest' do not apply to convicts like Najib. It's meant for minor offenders like those convicted for stealing milk/bread to feed their families, etc. They will have to wear a tracking device where their movements could be monitored by the authorities.
@adamiskandar5107 the house arrest law has not been passed yet. It was included in the 2025 budget, but as far as I know, it was just the first reading
Yes I agree those who stole milo and milk to feed their kids should be sentenced to house arrest or just community service like garbage collection for a few days. But not those who stole millions. These deserve to be jailed.
For me, 2 questions I hope the court or anybody can help to clear the air: 1) Andai kuasa Agong adalah absolute, but kuasa itu masih terikat dengan ayat digunapakai di dalam Perkara 42. Adakah penjara di rumah adalah ditafsir sebagai ringan hukum, iaitu satu dari tiga kuasa pengampunan oleh Agong (memberi ampun, tunda hukum, atau lega hukum). Mengurangkan tempoh penjara dari 10 tahun ke 2 tahun, sbg contoh, difahami sebagai lega hukum. Tetapi jika menukar hukum dari penjara 10 tahun ke ketuk ketampi 1000 kali bukan lega hukum. Jadi, adakah penjara di rumah satu lega hukum? Pendapat saya: tak. 2) jika Agong mempunyai kuasa absolut, maka mengapakah dihabiskan dakwat dan ruang tulisan di dalam Perlembagaan untuk menceritakan tentang keperluan Lembaga Pengampunan? Maknanya ada kepentingan. Jika absolut, adakah bermaksud Agong tanpa had boleh selepas bangun tidur suatu hari memaafkan satu penjara Kajang dengan keluarkan titah unilaterally? Jadi, semua pengampunan perlu dilaksanakan di dalam Mesyuarat Lembaga Pengampunan. Jika tak, bagaimana mungkin kerajaan (AG, Jab Penjara, etc) tahu Tuanku Agong atau parti lain yang mengeluarkan titah yang sah?
Is the Msian Govt still having to bear interests accrued & payable wrt bonds & other forms of borrowings to cover the financial costs arising from the scandal ??
The Best Solution will be, Put him in the Police Quarters,which is a lot not occupied,so that we can cut cost by the Policemen guarding him,and also the food supply.
You sent Masaalahnyo...KESEMUA PEHAK Nak kena tahu, Termasok PEHAK PENJARA, Kerna ini kes hukuman BERAT...DAN KEPUTUSAN ADALAH PENAL Kehakiman, yang menentukan, UNDANG UNDANG Nak kena ADEL DAN SAKSAMA SUPAYA DIHORMATI Tak kira apo jawatan sekali pon, di Takuti...RAKYAT AKAN MERASA BERAT SEBELAH.. RAJA DAN KERAJAAN ADEL Dihormati rakyat jelata, Kalau tak..JADI ROJAK NANTINYO....SUSAH JAWABNyo, Itu pandangan saya yang tulus dan ikhlas....terserah Buat penilaian..sendiri apo apo yang baik....
Di Singapura Menteri ambik satu basikal Brompton pun teruih masuk penjara. Ini lagi sebat billion billion wang Rakyat dan wang Generasi Rakyat Malaysia akan datang. Lagi mau House arrest ka??Shamless Jibby
There is no issue as the crime is very cut and clear…..money had been stolen in billions and the convict was tried in the Courts at 3 levels and found guilty unanimously by the honourable judges.crime is very very serious and as such must be in prison for the full jail term.
The previous YDPA already explained , follow the process & respect the Pardon Board decision, The KDN Minister clearly stated no such House Arrest as claimed by certain groups.
So much time has been wasted debating, arguing, accusing, etc over the non-existent addendum. Malaysia has certainly made itself a laughingstock of the world.
No special treatment. Treat him like all the rest of the convict. WHY HOUSE ARREST? Almost all the convicts are entitled to house arrest.Their crimes is so minor compared to Najid.
The govt better standby the procedure/ regulation for convicted criminal under house arrest.. How should be convicted criminal under house arrest be ??? @@@@@@ Warden/s be stationed there ? Back door be locked ? Access only by single small side gate.? All reside in the house must be listed and particulars submitted to appropriate minister for approval ? All vehicles must be listed and particulars submitted to appropriate minister for approval ? All movements of people' , vehicles in out of the house must first get the approval from appropriate minister ? Only single visitor allowed at a time and for not more than an hour.? All visitors must first get approval from the appropriate minister. ? The appropriate minister can authorise appropriate personnel's to enter the house at any time to check , supervise the house and convicted criminal ? E.& O. E 😊
Mintak SULTAN pahang selesai bayar hutang 1MDB 56 BILLION Dan mintak sultan pahang membayar kerugian kerjaan dari kegagalan najib Dahulu LEPAS TU bawa balik njib simpan kat istana pahang je kenapa rakyat patut bayar hutang 1mdb utk najib ???????
The case of Sim Kie Chon vs the Superintendent of Pudu Prisons1985, Supreme Court decided that Pardon Board merely give tendering advise to the King, it was Majesty himself who exercised the Executive Power.
The issue here is not about house arrest, it’s about gaming out PMX. You think Saka Tua, PAS, and all the people against PMX see eye to eye? Noooo… The evils now have a plot to oust PMX. May they all fail.
Kesian. Curi BERBILLION NAK duk kat RUMAH. Banyak CANTIK MUKA HANG. Rosmah NAK BAYAR ka HUTANG BERBILLION TU. Kembang jarak kembang jagung. BERANI BUAT BERANI TANGGUNG LA Najib. Ke APA RAKYAT MALAYSIA NAK TANGGUNG? Kesian oo kesian
Many difficulties have recently been faced by the nation's political situation, particularly following Umno's fall because it controlled politics. It has, in fact, led to a number of legal issues that have not yet been clearly interpreted by the courts since the country's Constitution was written, particularly those that supersede the authority of the Institution of Monarchs. Everyone is aware, meanwhile, that Malaysia operates as a parliamentary democracy with a constitutional monarchy, with His Majesty the Yang di-Pertuan Agong (YDPA) serving as the head of state. what the phrase "Constitutional Monarchy" generally means as the foundation for our comprehension of the nation's legal system? A constitutional monarchy is one in which the laws and provisions of the Constitution are the governing king's authority. It is not the same as the idea of Absolute Monarchy that existed in this nation before to the introduction of British laws. To honour the King's role as Head of State, however, many of the Absolute Powers that were once exercised have been transformed into King-only Prerogative Power. His Majesty has been given a suitable advisory council to help him execute this prerogative power and make sure that all he does is in compliance with the law and the Constitution. His Majesty can no longer be held accountable because this Advisory Board will assume responsibility for any errors made in the use of His Majesty's Prerogative Power. It differs from "Absolute Power" in that His Majesty makes all of his decisions on his own initiative and without the assistance of an advisory body. Indeed, any error can no longer be attributed to the advisory council; rather, His Majesty himself is held accountable. Therefore, all Absolute Powers have been transformed into Prerogative Powers, which need an advisory body to assume responsibility in the case that His Majesty's Prerogative Powers are exercised incorrectly, in order to shield His Majesty from blame. The sole "Absolute Power" that remains for His Majesty, however, is the ability to select the "Head of Government" or Prime Minister at His Majesty's own discretion, particularly in cases where the representatives chosen by the people do not show unequivocal support.
Najib has to be the most privileged and entitled convicted criminal in Malaysian history. He is still not remorseful and still refuses to take any accountability for the 1MDB debacle, yet demands even more special privileges as a convict.
Any plans you want to advise govt to issue house arrest to all those who have served a third (this man has not)? Any plans you have to ask for the stolen loot, whose value has doubled at least by now? Any plans you have to ask what after the current trial produces a conviction? Back to prison? Any plans you have to ask what if after ge 16 convict is PM, will pardon also exempt any future loot? Oh dear, so many questions on a rest day. Happy Sunday.
Susahlah kita kalau para politikus Malaysia yang berpengaruh baik pro kerajaan atau pembangkang seperti mempersendakan sistem kehakiman dgn mengabaikan perkara yang terkandung dalam rukun negara dan lebih dahsyat mengheret pihak istana Ramai rakyat@pengundi akan kecewa dan orang luar negara akan ketawakan kita.
Once a while such dramatic saga appears so sudden, all rakyat in different backgrounds confuse and amazed how the politician lawyers and prosecutions, defending lawyers a high surge demands .. executive / legislative/ prosection separation of power becomings a musical chair. In the finale YDPA's a letter .. everyone jumping up and down. 😅Daulat Tuanku final say yet to be presented .
NO discount, no house arrest not when Najib stole the rakyats' money.
It is so unfair, Najib stole the money for himself.
Lanjiao cibaiao shit
You mean the other politicians didnt? 😂
@@wanmrazali5446 We might as well set him free and make him our role model for the future generations!
pity..stealing is legal
some glorified the thief
The guilty person MUST endure the proper punishment provided by law, more so when he is supposed to have promised to uphold the law and lead the country. No pardon, no house arrest, no nothing whatsoever!!!!!!
Aggreed...
Fully agreed
Ohhh so how come anwar was himself pardoned by the agong?? 😂😂 Stop being a hypocrite
Even I guess supposed there is no prisoner to be the leader of the country & all M’sian hv to respect our country constitution list especially about religion & race‼️‼️
@ agreed
Stop wasting time on a convicted criminal who stole billions of dollars from the Ratyats and enriched his families. Why must he be given special treatment just because he has millions to spend on lawyers. . What about those who steal to put food on the table for the families and sent to Jail? Should they be put on house arrest too? Does Malaysia has a special judicial system for the corrupted rich? Do those who fight for his house arrest believe Malaysia should have a special judicial system for the corrupted rich who stole from the Ratyats?
No monet no talk Money speak louder than reason.
Prof, you need to do this in Malay to reach your intended target audience. GK Ganeson did a very clear review and explained correctly the legality of the addendum.
Pls don't assume that the target audience are the Malays because there are a lot of non-Malays who are vocal on this issue in opposition to the government's stand.
They Wajib at least add BM subtitles as there are Malays. and non Malays yang tak fasih BI high level Proff Tajuddin!
The targeted audience is obviously Non Malay PH supporters.😂
@@adamiskandar5107The Chinese voters believe more in Likes than Rights.😂
I think the non Malays have a good understanding of the laws...while the Malays in the rural area really need to know the narratives of this case of Najib. Many podcasts are conducted by Malays tend not tell the truth and playing dirty politics. Worst still playing the blame games against the govt and it's leaders. And so the Malay folks in the Kampong become more confused resulting in voting the stupid anti govt leaders.
So prof how about you helping the rural folks to think smart ???
This is a serious crime against the citizens of malaysia
@@ChuanTeh he is a criminal
As a citizen of Malaysia, i see that this country operates a two tier legal systems, one for the elite/politicians and the second for normal citizens. The elites/politicians seem to enjoy a lot of preliviges provided by the power that governs the legal system. While the normal citizens and peasants always tend get the raw deal of the Law 😒
you shd listen to Tengku aimus retirement speech.
A DEMOCRATIC COUNTRY WITH MANY TIERS.
In Malaysia, we as employers have no say to our employed staffs !!!
Same apply to USA, Thailand, Taiwan, South Korea and many more countries.
There are two sets of law in M'sia. 1 for the VVVIP's and another for the ordinary M'sians.
That is UNIVERSAL bro!
Who gave Najib discounted punishment again? Oh I'm sorry. It is important for unity
Right.
If there is no law they will make a new law just for him.
@@kingok9147 comment from idiot..this law already there long time ago..many non vvip have pardon due berkelakuan baik dalam tahanan..only under cave citizen donnow
Prof this matter reflects the nation's moral character. We have bad record in this space involving the VVIPs
MANYBOF OUR VOP POLITICIANS ARE INVOLVED IN ALL KINDS OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITIES AND ABUSE OF THEIR POWERS TO COLECT WANG HARAM AND ENRICH THEMSELVES NAD THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS.
USA, Thailand, South Korea, Taiwan are not?
you want blame YDPA power? do you think other country not have this law?
Sad to see ,leader with no moral
Country spoiled by this grouping
Under house arrest ,he will go shopping everywhere
He might become PM again!
@ i pray to my mighty God, i hope he will never return again🙏🙏🙏🙏.Amitaba
@@chuajohn7985 AMEN 🙏🏻
You meant go shopping with stolen money, how the hell he has the gut to enjoy the immoral gained on his luxury..
Even without the freedom to go shopping is already morally to be granted a house arrest cost there will be two sets of law. One for the VVIP or have n one for the ordinary people or have not or poor. We are now trying to change the law to suit the situation of the country to suit the needs for someone or Vvip to be granted a house arrest just because he was a former PM n found guilty of his charges n granted a discount for his jail terms from 12 years to 6 years only. This is a blatant disregard to the rule of law. Might as well don't have the law n all guilty can walk free after all n demolish the prison n save the country in maintaining the rule of law😢😮😅
Sorry but I disagree with some of the things you say.
Firstly it seams from some TH-cam videos that muster Najib has already vvip level in jail where he already is given permission to use mobile phone Internet and computer.
Which other inmates are granted this?
30 feet around his house and once a week he is being permitted to have guest does that mean every once in a week he can have a bbq party in his home garden?
And what about some one want to visit him the next day who is going to stop that.
BUT most importantly you already mentioned there is no law in Malaysia that grant house arrest so does the law have to be changed for probably the one who stole the largest sum of money in history? Is it morally even fair of mister Najib to adk for all these privileges after what he has done. Even until today he keep on saying he has not done anything wrong so he is not even sorry for what he has done according to his confliction in court. Is it not that in some countries politicians where these kind of crimes done by politicians they can get life in prison or even death penalty? Should mister Najib than not be very lucky getting ONLY 6 years in jail?
And an other thing should the law not be equal for every person in Malaysia? So if he is granted house arrest how about people who do a minor crime will they from now on get a slap on the wrist and being told go home but don't do it again?
In my humble opinion if some one who comited such a huge crime and basically don't get any punishment that will destroy Malaysia justice system. According to his court cases he stole billions and basically no punishment than some one who steels "only" 1 million how is justice going to serve him?
And let's also not forget how other countries will see Malaysia countries that are involved in these crimes? Will Malaysia not be the clown of the world in there eyes? US helped to get some of the stolen money back well they as well might think to keep it because of it.
An other thing is as you mentioned there is no law in Malaysia that grants house arrest so even if you change the law now it would not be applicable to mister Najib because he is convicted already
I totally in agreement with all your points. The only dilemma this government is current facing is UMNO factions that can’t seem to distance themselves from the corrupt and convicted Najib just because they are still relying on some faction of his supporters for votes and staying relevant as a dying party. The only way for Najib to be politically alive is to keep singing the ‘I am not guilty’, ‘I didn’t have a fair trial’ and ‘I am being punished politically’ songs which his supporters swallowed wholeheartedly. PMX is hoping that buying time and efforts in his leadership in government would be enough to get a clear mandate from the rakyat without having to rely on unity from other not so friendly (and corrupt) political parties such as Umno/Gps/Grs etc. Pas/Bersatu clearly sees this and kept trying to disrupt PMX endeavours as they kept losing supports by the day to the Harapan’s parties. It is a delicate political chessboard game PMX is facing but one that he will only win if the Malaysia and its rakyat’s economic situation improves noticeably which is a big ask given the huge debts servicing and fundamental (weak education & corrupt public services) damages that he inherited.
The elite don't care about the ordinary people. They don't give shit about our opinion.
Whatever the legal issues, how can a person facing so many court cases be even considered for a pardon from the Agung? Shouldn't he first face all the charges and the sentences meted to him by the justice system, and then apply for pardon? Pardon should be granted only once. Is Najib hoping for a DNAA for the rest of the charges?
Thats what im thinking...
Najib has never stopped troubling the Rakyat..... Started while he's still a PM, continue while in the prison and sadly will continue burdening the Rakyat with his non stop Antic of wanting to seek fresh air outside even when he's supposedly and ideally spend at least ,30 years at the least for his part in robbing the nation coffer.... If someone has never really been truthful with the addendum which I don't think so due to its complexity, I think it's part of KARMA coming surely to Najib for his doing, he always been lying to Rakyat all this while
Never mind the lies. He still has faithful followers who will follow and support him to the grave. Culture of the Malays . Give them a sen and they are grateful to you for life even if you are guilty of the worst kind.
@thetransformationalbabyboomer sadly the one sen had never coming from his hard earned money at all.....
Correction ... He started troubling the Rakyat way back when he became the Minister of Education....he made the education ministry lower the PMR n SPM standards...u see on TV students being surprised they got 8As without putting much work , while those studied hard to excel were disappointed to see their good grades became meaningless ?!!
I know bcos my son n his friends were upset at that. And he did a stupid thing again meddling with the universities' s metriculasi n Asasi programs...by centralizing it.....thus making it harder to get into university programs of your choice......bcos metriculating at the university that offers the programs you want...gives u advantage into obtaining your desired choice of your future career
Example: you want to do agriculture; UPM is where u do metriculasi not in UM or UKM etc etc
@@azillahadam9769 in short he's proven to be nothing but a useless citizen that unfortunately had lead the country in a way that brought so bad era to the country...
There is no legal dilemma. KGanesan gave a very good explanation on this. There is also no moral dilemma. Cheating & stealing is wrong & must be punished. If these crooks get away with it due to political manipulation then it is moral corruption - not a dilemma.
29th Jan 2024 - Meeting Lembaga Pengampunan.
30th Jan 2024 - Sultan Abdullah no longer Agong.
Any addendum done after 30th Jan is not valid.
Sultan Ibrahim took office on the 31st of January 2025
SAH SUNGGUH PUN ,,,,,kenapa rakyat patut membayar hutang kerjaan di buat oleh ahli politics gagal tabir negara dan kerajaan pun ..... sekarang rakyat perlu bangkit kenapa kita perlu bayar hutang kerjaan ????? ini dah tiba masa utk rakyat Tanya soalan ini kepada AGONG AG AGC DAN KEPADA PMX ????
@agneslily6566 thats why our present YDPA suggested for Najib's family to re apply for the pardon again but najib did not agree.
@@agneslily6566 Sultan Abdullah term ended 30th January. On the 30th, he is no longer Agong. And hence, his addendum didn't make it into Pardons Board.
Agong cannot make unilateral decree without the Pardons Board. It's not how it works in with Constitutional Monarchy. Hence the new YDPA issue a statement last week. Understand what he's trying to say.
@@agneslily6566 Sultan Ibrahim took office on the 31st of January 2024, not 2025.
People holding high positions in government should be held accountable for their actions.
Agreed we should also refer to the deliberations by Constitutional law expert GK Ganeson pertaining to the pardon process.
MORAL is rare commodity amongst Our Leaders😢🧐😓
Well folks...face reality in this "Malaysia Madani, Malaysia Boleh" that we are living in now. If Zahid's 47 charges could be swept that easily under the rug, then nothing surprises me anymore with this latest news. Sad to see this adendum from our King simply because it portrays in opinion a message to the rakyat that anybody who stole billions could get scot free from jail. To me this is wrong as future leaders could also see this as a ticket if they commit similar crime? As a Muslim, this is wrong by God and also by law
@@hishamosman4341 They are acting like elite as powerful as the Ydp Agong of the country. Even the royalty has the privilege they have to abide to the law 😋😅👍🙏
If one crooked criminal guy like this can be at home as house arrest then all others should have the same benefits. Otherwise there's no equality in the law
Tarik balik pengurangan tempoh dan denda Najib.
Prof, pls ask the Sult of Pahang to give a copy of the addendum. Straight-fwd action !
But what the hell is His Majesty trying to do ?
Is it to Confuse the rak'yat, Create unnecessary chaos among the political parties, Splitting the people, Creating real-rubbish among the judiciary etc.?
Was'salam
But the pardon board don't have the record according to the news report., how come?
It was released after the pardon board meeting and its not in the discussion agenda thats why the dispute now back to high court to determine the validity of the addendum.
@@mariambintijaafar8323 We only heard of it well after, like a few months after the previous Agong's tenure had ended.
That probably implies that it only came into existence well after his tenure had ended, as there is no official record of it existing.
And that implies that the so-called Addendum is null and void for many and not just a single reason.
@@limfc6953 It's just an act of desperation to buy time for his plee of house arrest until the next GE16 n the faction supporting him to manoeuvre their needs to win the next election n Najib can have the chance to be PM if Anwar cannot have the full support from Umno. It's always their dirty tactic to gain control knowing unless Zahid can prove he really has the full support of Umno to be the next PM if Anwar loses control 😋😅👍🙏
A prisoner who has not served his sentence to half of his sentence is forbidden to request for house arrest . The offence committed is grave because the graft committed is in billions of ringgit. House arrest is forbidden because of the offence committed is big amount.
The rich and powerful elites enjoyed special privilege and treatment whereas ordinary citizens are not shown mercy. The saga goes to tell the world that high profile crime pays.
"If you can't do the time, don't do the crime." --- a proverb
kenapa kerjaan AG AGc agong sultan GAGAL penjarakan AHLI POLITICS gagal tabir urus negera dan meletak kan negera dlm hutang besar ????? dan menjadi beban besar kepada kehidupan rakyat malaysia ??????
Maybe the AG did receive the so called ‘addendum’ and may out of courtesy replied to former agong that it could not be implemented for 2 reasons. 1. IT'S OUT OF TIME AS PARDON BOARD AND HOME MINISTRY HAS TAKEN ACTION AS PER PERINTAH on 29th Jan 24 2. THE FORMER AGONG HAS CEASED HIS APPT. On 30th Jan 24. THUS, ADDENDUM IS NOT VALID ANY MORE. INVALID, TIDAK TERPAKAI ATAU TIDAK LAKU.
AG CONSIDERS IT'S PERSONAL MATTER NOT OFFICIAL MATTER BETWEEN HIS OFF AND FORMER AGONG. HE MAY ONLY ANSWER IN COURT. MOST IMPORTANT CONVICTS PLACE IS IN PRISONS NOT AT HOME 😂😂😂
@ correction done txs 😊
@@lynnnina3878 thank you.
Exactly.
Meeting of the Pardon Board is on the 29th January 2024. 30th January 2024, Sultan Abdullah is no longer Agong.
Sultan Ibrahim took office on 31st of January 2025@@zafir7007
@@zafir7007 d question is why d agong only decide on his last day ....???? Something fishy....😊
a criminal should serve out his sentence in jail n no reduction of fines. laws cannot be turn upside down to suit the rich n powerful. no one should be Above the Law !!!!
Justice must prevail..
Prof,
Recently a prisoner who had served 4 months jail sentence commented that Najib is being treated special at prison cell.There seem to be a substandard treatment in our prison where certain jail inmates are getting special treatment despite a big crime is committed.😮
Don't be surprised that is true.
Those arguing that the Agong's decision is absolute where he does not take into account the people's feelings is unlikely to be the reality. The Agong is also human and if he is rational, he would probably decide based on the desire of the majority of the people taking into account the desire of the minority.
Prof ,you know it's all about you scratch my back, and I will scratch yours in the past,present, and future.
À pardon must reflect justice and should be seen to be just to all rational minds. It is sad that a king cannot understand this. It will forever be a blot in the country’s administration of justice.
Prof. Please make this same video in Bahasa Malaysia.
Thank you.
Prof, nobody is talking about a serious issue in this Addendem case. This is about COnflict of Interests. One question is why the Pardon Board only met towards the very end of the previous Agong's reign. I speculate that the Agong was very hesitant and even reluctant to chair this meeting. This is because Najib is very close to him personally and also in relation to the Pahang Sultanate. If the Agong chair the meeting, would it be possible for him to act in a neutral manner because of their relationship! We have seen how Najib and Rosmah had protested and got numerous judges removed because of Conflict of Interests. I believe the Agong is fully aware of this. It was clear that the Agong was being pressured by many quarters. The rumour that the Addendem was not signed is one vital sign of this. For all we know the Addendem was written by someone else.
If all the prisoners are offered house arrest, all the prinsons will be empty and billions will be saved from mantaince costs
If only Najib wasn't involved with 1MDB, this problem won't happen.
Things happens, deal with it.
Stealing is against my religion, some other did it behine my back
@@wannurizanshaikhmohd5548 Then let there be consequences. Deal with that
@@Hnnn__00 What consequences are you talking about? The possible political 'mutiny' by UMNO in the UG ship? UMNO needs to wake up and deal with the loss of support of the Malays. Don't expect to regain its past powers without meaningful reform. In fact, UMNO is currently in the best position to reform in its partnership with PH leading the UG, as corruption is not tolerated officially although the culture of corruption still exists. Give the UG another 2 terms and the systemic corruption problem would inevitably be solved.
Absolutely. 💯 agree.
You stole, you're caught , you're charged, you're found guilty then do your years in prison.
What moral you have asking for any discount or pardon of your sentence !?
Amazing how we can have this kind of leaders who are supposed to look ofter the rakyats' coffers.
So...there isn't any specific law on house arrest in Malaysia.
There's always the 1st time for everything.
@@wannurizanshaikhmohd5548 You are obviously overestimating of the power of UMNO over the Malays. When UMNO is reformed and turn away from the corrupted past leadership, especially under Mahathir and Najib, it may regain its Malay support. The fact that some in UMNO are still fighting for Najib, the convicted fellon means that they could not move on with the UG. Luckily, the current UMNO leadership believes in the UG.
@@adamiskandar5107 Obviously u do not kno n do not understand how d law n Constitution works. If UMNO has d absolute power like d YDPA to pardon Najib, Najib would hv been d 10th PM instead of Anwar. Remember, d adendum for Najib's house arrest cums fr d YDPA 16, not UMNO.
Moral question is Bos Ku should rot in jail.
The addendam issue should be put to rest,right thinking netizens can gauge for themselves the validity of the addendum.
Hi Prof, you call upon your audience to trust that the government will do the right thing. How many rakyat can do this, especially after watching the behaviour of most politicians/ so-called leaders?!! 😅😅
Does this prove that
Money is King
Cash is King
Duit is King?
What else is King?
Stealing huge some of money is king and that will set you free.
Don't steal kacang putih, one can of milk powder, or a packet of Milo because you can end up in jail for a long time. 😂😅
House Rest not House Arrest!
Meetings with the elites too
@yeanlilian Naturally!
Unusually soft of d Prof. In a Constitutional Monarchy , no one has absolute power. The Constitution is supreme. If a forner PM who is now a convict, is given special consideration, all other convicts, under similar circumstances, should be given d same treatment.
Govt shud have laid out d facts, explain what it could & culdnt do. ( Wilful concealment is no different from 'hiding'.)
If d law is 'grey', let d Courts declare it white or black
In the context of the past Chinese monarchy system, whatever command given in writing (edict) must have to be endorsed by stamping the royal seal on it. So if the royal addendum to be valid should be sent back to the Palace to have it endorsed with the royal seal, instead of putting it in cold storage until the Next King sits on the throne. We can use this to self-reflect on the appropriate action that should be taken by the government to maintain a transparent administration.
Soalan saya simple je kenapa rakyat malaysia menjadi mangsa pembayar hutang kerjaan ??????
Sbb semua duit datang dr rakyat untok rakyat....so hutang pn rakyat kene bayar...
The whole problem is that politics and business are intertwined, generating huge amount of money for them. So people are victimised by monopolistic business. Rice, cars and even rice is under monopolies. If not separated this country will not develop and progress.
Why dont fully pardon than house arrest pardon? Wants to please the public and at same time wants to please the supporter of Najib of his good contribution to the country .
Ridiculous..
Other than this case I have never heard of the concept of house arrest. So how does it work? The prisoner is in his own house right? Hows the security then? The Prisons Dept deploy wardens and guards to ensure the prisoner does not leave his house? Is the prisoner free to communicate via phone and Internet?
Me too after 65 of years of living.
Under the current practice, 'house arrest' do not apply to convicts like Najib. It's meant for minor offenders like those convicted for stealing milk/bread to feed their families, etc. They will have to wear a tracking device where their movements could be monitored by the authorities.
@adamiskandar5107
the house arrest law has not been passed yet. It was included in the 2025 budget, but as far as I know, it was just the first reading
Those who stole a tin of milo can be on house arrest, but for politicians who stole millions should be jail
Yes I agree those who stole milo and milk to feed their kids should be sentenced to house arrest or just community service like garbage collection for a few days. But not those who stole millions. These deserve to be jailed.
If house arrest is allowed, it should be applicable to every convict.
For me, 2 questions I hope the court or anybody can help to clear the air:
1) Andai kuasa Agong adalah absolute, but kuasa itu masih terikat dengan ayat digunapakai di dalam Perkara 42. Adakah penjara di rumah adalah ditafsir sebagai ringan hukum, iaitu satu dari tiga kuasa pengampunan oleh Agong (memberi ampun, tunda hukum, atau lega hukum). Mengurangkan tempoh penjara dari 10 tahun ke 2 tahun, sbg contoh, difahami sebagai lega hukum. Tetapi jika menukar hukum dari penjara 10 tahun ke ketuk ketampi 1000 kali bukan lega hukum. Jadi, adakah penjara di rumah satu lega hukum? Pendapat saya: tak.
2) jika Agong mempunyai kuasa absolut, maka mengapakah dihabiskan dakwat dan ruang tulisan di dalam Perlembagaan untuk menceritakan tentang keperluan Lembaga Pengampunan? Maknanya ada kepentingan. Jika absolut, adakah bermaksud Agong tanpa had boleh selepas bangun tidur suatu hari memaafkan satu penjara Kajang dengan keluarkan titah unilaterally? Jadi, semua pengampunan perlu dilaksanakan di dalam Mesyuarat Lembaga Pengampunan. Jika tak, bagaimana mungkin kerajaan (AG, Jab Penjara, etc) tahu Tuanku Agong atau parti lain yang mengeluarkan titah yang sah?
Is the Msian Govt still having to bear interests accrued & payable wrt bonds & other forms of borrowings to cover the financial costs arising from the scandal ??
Maybe Najib will be placed in a government owned house. Not in his own house.
The Best Solution will be,
Put him in the Police Quarters,which is a lot not occupied,so that we can cut cost by the Policemen guarding him,and also the food supply.
😂😂😂
Moral and legal in a country where racism is legal
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Sir many citizens won't know the meaning of house arrest🙏🏼
3R Politick.
You sent
Masaalahnyo...KESEMUA PEHAK Nak kena tahu,
Termasok PEHAK PENJARA, Kerna ini kes
hukuman BERAT...DAN KEPUTUSAN ADALAH
PENAL Kehakiman, yang menentukan, UNDANG
UNDANG Nak kena ADEL DAN SAKSAMA SUPAYA
DIHORMATI Tak kira apo jawatan sekali pon, di
Takuti...RAKYAT AKAN MERASA BERAT SEBELAH..
RAJA DAN KERAJAAN ADEL Dihormati rakyat jelata,
Kalau tak..JADI ROJAK NANTINYO....SUSAH JAWABNyo,
Itu pandangan saya yang tulus dan ikhlas....terserah
Buat penilaian..sendiri apo apo yang baik....
To sum up, najib is not human, humans have feelings and conscience.
Agreed 👍
Where's our Malaysian legal fairness? Rich people can be easily forgiven 😢😢😢
I have learnt a discount word today: DiNajibkan. 😅
This word very good to explain the situation
Was it not revealed previously that the Govts members of the Board had not recommended any reduction?
the validity and legality of the pardon is now questionable. It should be invalidated, and reconsidered by the pardon board.
Di Singapura Menteri ambik satu basikal Brompton pun teruih masuk penjara. Ini lagi sebat billion billion wang Rakyat dan wang Generasi Rakyat Malaysia akan datang. Lagi mau House arrest ka??Shamless Jibby
The craziest thing is those top leader behind who supporting the house arrest to put in place for the biggest convicted criminal thief of the nation.
Prof, adakah value moral is mist important for politik
There is no issue as the crime is very cut and clear…..money had been stolen in billions and the convict was tried in the Courts at 3 levels and found guilty unanimously by the honourable judges.crime is very very serious and as such must be in prison for the full jail term.
Have to give " House Arrest" to certain other prisoners too.
A common thief in the prison will ask for house arrest 😂
Why oh why the issuance of the said addendum, knowing very well the controversies it WILL cause?
The previous YDPA already explained , follow the process & respect the Pardon Board decision, The KDN Minister clearly stated no such House Arrest as claimed by certain groups.
For serving less than one third of his prison term, the pardon board should not even entertain the request for royal pardon.
So much time has been wasted debating, arguing, accusing, etc over the non-existent addendum. Malaysia has certainly made itself a laughingstock of the world.
House arrest then it's district arrest, state arrest and ........you are free!
After u complted the punishment period, u r free.
Yes,he maybe free but he will still be labeled as a convict n cannot participate in politics for one term n his record will remind as a convict,,
No special treatment. Treat him like all the rest of the convict. WHY HOUSE ARREST? Almost all the convicts are entitled to house arrest.Their crimes is so minor compared to Najid.
The govt better standby the procedure/ regulation for convicted criminal under house arrest..
How should be convicted criminal under house arrest be ???
@@@@@@
Warden/s be stationed there ?
Back door be locked ?
Access only by single small side gate.?
All reside in the house must be listed and particulars submitted to appropriate minister for approval ?
All vehicles must be listed and particulars submitted to appropriate minister for approval ?
All movements of people' , vehicles in out of the house must first get the approval from appropriate minister ?
Only single visitor allowed at a time and for not more than an hour.?
All visitors must first get approval from the appropriate minister. ?
The appropriate minister can authorise appropriate personnel's to enter the house at any time to check , supervise the house and convicted criminal ?
E.& O. E
😊
How he still giving access to media and voice out while in jail??
Mintak SULTAN pahang selesai bayar hutang 1MDB 56 BILLION Dan mintak sultan pahang membayar kerugian kerjaan dari kegagalan najib Dahulu LEPAS TU bawa balik njib simpan kat istana pahang je kenapa rakyat patut bayar hutang 1mdb utk najib ???????
Ada berani kah ????
The case of Sim Kie Chon vs the Superintendent of Pudu Prisons1985, Supreme Court decided that Pardon Board merely give tendering advise to the King, it was Majesty himself who exercised the Executive Power.
The addendum exists but is it constitutional ?
Of course NO.. No house arrest exist in the constitutions and never happened in the past history!
The issue here is not about house arrest, it’s about gaming out PMX. You think Saka Tua, PAS, and all the people against PMX see eye to eye? Noooo…
The evils now have a plot to oust PMX. May they all fail.
Najib followers must be rasional and logically thinking of what kind of felony he has committed that give big impact to the nation and the rakyat
Masalah pas tiba tiba jadi org bagus...
Kesian. Curi BERBILLION NAK duk kat RUMAH. Banyak CANTIK MUKA HANG. Rosmah NAK BAYAR ka HUTANG BERBILLION TU. Kembang jarak kembang jagung. BERANI BUAT BERANI TANGGUNG LA Najib. Ke APA RAKYAT MALAYSIA NAK TANGGUNG? Kesian oo kesian
charged during Tun M premiership
convicted during Muhyidin premiership
lose appeal during Ismail premiership
pardoned during Anwar premiership
Many difficulties have recently been faced by the nation's political situation, particularly following Umno's fall because it controlled politics. It has, in fact, led to a number of legal issues that have not yet been clearly interpreted by the courts since the country's Constitution was written, particularly those that supersede the authority of the Institution of Monarchs.
Everyone is aware, meanwhile, that Malaysia operates as a parliamentary democracy with a constitutional monarchy, with His Majesty the Yang di-Pertuan Agong (YDPA) serving as the head of state. what the phrase "Constitutional Monarchy" generally means as the foundation for our comprehension of the nation's legal system? A constitutional monarchy is one in which the laws and provisions of the Constitution are the governing king's authority.
It is not the same as the idea of Absolute Monarchy that existed in this nation before to the introduction of British laws. To honour the King's role as Head of State, however, many of the Absolute Powers that were once exercised have been transformed into King-only Prerogative Power.
His Majesty has been given a suitable advisory council to help him execute this prerogative power and make sure that all he does is in compliance with the law and the Constitution. His Majesty can no longer be held accountable because this Advisory Board will assume responsibility for any errors made in the use of His Majesty's Prerogative Power.
It differs from "Absolute Power" in that His Majesty makes all of his decisions on his own initiative and without the assistance of an advisory body. Indeed, any error can no longer be attributed to the advisory council; rather, His Majesty himself is held accountable. Therefore, all Absolute Powers have been transformed into Prerogative Powers, which need an advisory body to assume responsibility in the case that His Majesty's Prerogative Powers are exercised incorrectly, in order to shield His Majesty from blame.
The sole "Absolute Power" that remains for His Majesty, however, is the ability to select the "Head of Government" or Prime Minister at His Majesty's own discretion, particularly in cases where the representatives chosen by the people do not show unequivocal support.
A pardon is only given to a morally wrong person . Is this felon a morally wrong person ?
Agong already acting against the constitution,.. which he cannot be politically bias or messing with Judicial system ,..
Salam fr Melbourne
Just tell the truth. How we work reflect on our beliefs (positive) so scary how our generation will be next!
Jail the thief for ...a long time or msia will look stupid
that lawyer desperately needs to look back at Articles concerned in the constitution.
Najib has to be the most privileged and entitled convicted criminal in Malaysian history. He is still not remorseful and still refuses to take any accountability for the 1MDB debacle, yet demands even more special privileges as a convict.
Any plans you want to advise govt to issue house arrest to all those who have served a third (this man has not)? Any plans you have to ask for the stolen loot, whose value has doubled at least by now? Any plans you have to ask what after the current trial produces a conviction? Back to prison? Any plans you have to ask what if after ge 16 convict is PM, will pardon also exempt any future loot? Oh dear, so many questions on a rest day. Happy Sunday.
Why have a Pardon Board , AG or for that matter any law at all in Malaysia. Just allow 1 man control this Malaysia Boleh land.
Susahlah kita kalau para politikus Malaysia yang berpengaruh baik pro kerajaan atau pembangkang seperti mempersendakan sistem kehakiman dgn mengabaikan perkara yang terkandung dalam rukun negara dan lebih dahsyat mengheret pihak istana Ramai rakyat@pengundi akan kecewa dan orang luar negara akan ketawakan kita.
Najib deserves justice and that is in prison and not in the comfort of his home.
Once a while such dramatic saga appears so sudden, all rakyat in different backgrounds confuse and amazed how the politician lawyers and prosecutions, defending lawyers a high surge demands .. executive / legislative/ prosection separation of power becomings a musical chair. In the finale YDPA's a letter .. everyone jumping up and down. 😅Daulat Tuanku final say yet to be presented .