after this comeback winter is my bias girlie cant stop serving in each song she made sure we could feel her emotions while singing and those clear notes and adlibs my gawdd winter this winter is your go shine like north star
Winter is my number 1 favorite vocalist in kpop. Her vocals are so unique, no one sounds like her or even close. There are lots of good vocals out there but they aren’t unique.
Winter's dreamy voice transcends me to another level of existence... those melodic ad libs are psychedelic, it makes me high, it ascends me to heaven with angel Winter floating in the air above me waiting while singing this song.🥰🥰🥰
I said it once, but I'll say it again here: Lovely song and they did such an amazing job, sounds so close to the studio version. Minjeong in the bridge wow, so ethereal, what a singer, what a talent. I'm so happy she's in aespa and I hope she remains healthy.
에스파는 타이틀 곡으로는 컨셉에 찰떡인 매번 새롭게 진화한 노래 들고 나오는데 수록곡으로는 알앤비 락 발라드 등 여러 장르가 담겨 있어서 너무 좋아 이 노래도 자각몽 연장선같고 이런 몽환적인 느낌도 잘 내는 듯 그래서 앨범 수록곡도 매번 색다른 맛이어서 기대하고 듣게 되는게 있는 듯
woahhhh i love this so much we need more content like this asap!!! they’re all so stunning and they literally sound perfect, you can really see why they’re on top of the industry right now. also winter is doing dangerous things to my heart
Winter's voice is like honey
Winter hitting those adlibs and smiling like that, she makes it look too easy 🥰
She looks happy with that smile. And her voice makes us happy 💗
that's a sign of a good vocalist effortless even when singing high notes!
Winter smiling and flawlessly singing. I need her to release a solo album asap
Winter hitting the notes so mellifluously; she did it delightfully! ❤️✨
Winter's adlibs!! So satisfying and clean
winter is a beautiful siren
Winter cook, serve and ate so bad. Her vocal, her stage presence, hee visual is just💥💥💥
Winter is my godddd. How could a human’s voice just like ANGEL
i couldnt stop smiling watching Winter sing this song, she must really love it! They are all so talented, it's crazyyy!
winter is such a pretty singer, like she looks good while singing and it's so mesmerizing ❤
I love Winter's voice so much. It sounds so unique and soothing. I feel like she will be a successful soloist in the future, like IU.
I LOVE WINTEEEER VOICEEEEE
I really feel like I’m flying over the moon with Winter’s adlibs 🤯🤍
Winter‘s adlibs! 😮💨❤️
😭😭😭minjeong i'm cryin'😭😭 ur voice is so beautiful😭😭
after this comeback winter is my bias girlie cant stop serving in each song she made sure we could feel her emotions while singing and those clear notes and adlibs my gawdd winter this winter is your go shine like north star
This really is Winter's song, and Giselle's, they sound sooo good in this!! Winter's adlibs and high notes are heavenly❤
yes i agree this is a giselle and winter song
omg winter, how do you even exist? this is better than the CD, beautiful voice baby
kim minjeong blew me away omg. bias wrecking me hard with her vocals on this track 🧎♀️🩷
winter knows she sounds good
이곡은 무드가 완전 윈터한테 딱 맞는듯 ㄹㅇ 잘한다
윈터는 노래할 때 진짜 행복해 하는 게 느껴져서 나까지 기분 좋아짐
Winter is just unreal her voice is so refreshing
WINTERRRRR
I'm so happy people praises winter voicee, overall 4 of them serves vocal
Winter omg, hitting all those adlibs and high notes while also smiling and looking lika a godess, ily❤🔥
윈터는 진짜 다양한 목소리 갖고 있는 거 같음
이거 민정이 보컬 컨트롤 능력이 너무 좋은거여서 그런것 같음요!!
진짜 태연처럼 솔로로 더더대성할 것 같다 sm여돌 보컬은 진짜 대단하네 저런 보물을 어디서 찾아오는걸까 계속
Winter’s lines in last chorus took me by surprise, it’s really good.
I love to see Winter praise in the comments ❤ she really is the best vocalist
Winter's voice😭
winter, my girl..ur beautiful vocal😭🤍
❄️🤍❄️
2:11 winter did such an amazing job… I’m crying
Winter sounds exactly like the audio!! Girlie keeps eating CDs for breakfasts, lunches, and dinners
2:27 OHHH WINTER ILY
Winter is perfection
Giselle’s part in the bridge is so good, i need a duet with winter because their voices blend so well.. im sure it will sound heavenly
윈터 노래부르는 얼굴이 정말 행복해보인다
오래오래 가수해줘
this is really crazy minjeong soooo goood one of the best vocal i have seen aespa is the best u go girls
Winter is my number 1 favorite vocalist in kpop. Her vocals are so unique, no one sounds like her or even close. There are lots of good vocals out there but they aren’t unique.
definitelty one of the best of all time
Miss Winter you'll be the death of me with those vocals AND that smile
Winter Highnote, heavenly sound 😍
Winter always sing with her smile, my baby🥺
Winter’s voice is on another level 💖
Winter ad libs are so sharp. Flows beautifully. Make this song more perfect.✨
2:27 윈터 애드립 듣는데 내가 저 구름 너머로 가는듯한 느낌이 든다
ㄹㅇ 너무좋음...
Winter as the best voice ever. Can’t wait for solo album
1:14부터 윈터 미쳐따 마지막 즐기면 돼 하고 살짝 웃는거 개잘생김
2:31 that vibrato! beautiful
Cheff kiss
Yeah right? So stable and good!
SO GOOOOOOD 😭
I'm totally spellbound by Winter's voice 😍
WINTER ATEEE
윈터 2:15 화음쌓는거 너무 좋다 진짜 극락가는 기분임 목소리가 보물이야 ㅠㅠ
Winter’s voice is just wow … literally floating
Winter voice is so soothing
2:15 갓윈터...
개소름끼쳐 기분까지 같이 좋아짐..
왤케 매력있어여?! 윈터 씨 ㅠㅠ 2:14 ㅠㅠㅠ
윈터 예전에 아이유 노래 커버하는거 목소리 듣고 순전히 노래랑 춤 100%로 입덕했는데 목소리랑 노래 실력이 점점 좋아짐
이걸 들을 수 있어서 행복하다
Giselle is a main rapper but the way she's serving those beautiful vocals and visual is crazy
1:17 닝이랑 윈터랑 한소절씩 주고받는데 음색이 넘 좋다ㅠㅠ 윈터가 씨익 웃으면서 즐기면 돼 하는데 진짜 즐기는 사람 같아서 울음돼……..
Winter's dreamy voice transcends me to another level of existence... those melodic ad libs are psychedelic, it makes me high, it ascends me to heaven with angel Winter floating in the air above me waiting while singing this song.🥰🥰🥰
1:47 윈터에 지젤 개조타
윈터 노래 진짜 잘한다..거기다 노래를 부를때 행복해 보이는 얼굴이 보는 사람들이 행복하게 하는게 진짜 가수다..전달력에 음색이며 보컬이며 고음에 성량까지 ㄹㅇ 다 잘함
진짜.. 얼굴이 너무 행복해보여서 보는 사람도 행복해짐.. ㅎㅎ
공감요 윈터가 4세대 끝판왕
so glad we got this live version… it’s even better than the already amazing original song!
2:15 WINTER 🥹😭🤍
Winter highnote and tone❤. She keep improving.
I said it once, but I'll say it again here: Lovely song and they did such an amazing job, sounds so close to the studio version. Minjeong in the bridge wow, so ethereal, what a singer, what a talent. I'm so happy she's in aespa and I hope she remains healthy.
obsessed with this song since it came out and the live version is even better 😭
you can tell winter loves this song
윈터 와。。. 나까지 행복해져 … ♥
2:15 This note always gets me❤
Truuuuue ! She sends me to heaven, makes me dream :D
And the smile at the end 😍
윈터 마지막 애드립 미쳤다..
Winter improved so muchhh love her voice
네명 다 진짜 잘하는데 닝닝이랑 윈터가 진짜 미친거같다.. 특히 윈터는 디테일 챙기는게 말도안됨 거기다가 고음까지ㄷㄷ 어디까지 성장할지 모르는 보컬🥹 2:46 극락좌표ㅠㅠ
Winter OMG❤
윈터 와.......ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ진짜좋아
winterrr so honey voice!!! i love all my babies, they're eating CDs❤❤
겨울이 목소리 보물😍
Winter❤
Winter is the perfect ace
지젤 목소리 쫀득쫀득 넘 좋음😍
It's always such a treat to see aespa perform b-sides live 🤍 beautiful vocals
Suka banget sama suara winter
2:11 윈터.
Winter's voice feels like cloud 9. I mean, the whole song do. I'm floating!!! 😂
Wow the girls song so beautifully this song! And Winter’s adlibs are so heavenly
Wow, Winter is sooo good! that's my girl! 🩷
에스파는 타이틀 곡으로는 컨셉에 찰떡인 매번 새롭게 진화한 노래 들고 나오는데 수록곡으로는 알앤비 락 발라드 등 여러 장르가 담겨 있어서 너무 좋아 이 노래도 자각몽 연장선같고 이런 몽환적인 느낌도 잘 내는 듯 그래서 앨범 수록곡도 매번 색다른 맛이어서 기대하고 듣게 되는게 있는 듯
Winters voice on this track omw
지젤 목소리 진짜 ㅇ이뿌다..
윈터 보컬 미쳤따 넷 다 연차 쌓이면서더 잘해졌네
윈터 목소리 넘 좋다…
Winter's highnotes are the best ❤
이 곡을 무대로 볼줄이야...🩷
민정이 라이브 진짜 미쳤어👍👍👍
woahhhh i love this so much we need more content like this asap!!! they’re all so stunning and they literally sound perfect, you can really see why they’re on top of the industry right now. also winter is doing dangerous things to my heart
2:26 literally heaven
I just love the fact so much that they gave us a live of this song and on the top of that those adlibs too. It was amazing
I love Winter's voice ❤😢😮
My beautiful Goddess Winter
Winter ate this song🔥❤
Winter hitting consecutive high notes is the best🔥❤