Amazing. 101 year old film and I'm still sucked into watching it. Lol. I grew up watching these guys and the 3 stooges during the 80's, and it never gets old. The first laurel and hardy I saw was Birth Marks and I laughed sooo hard I was crying.....and I couldn't stop. These "comedians" now got nothing on these guys. They REALLY should have a L&H and 3 stooges channel.
This is a strange film in that nobody is certain when it was filmed. The only clue is a car licence plate that dates 1920. Though Stan claimed it was filmed much earlier 1917. Perhaps, though both dates are correct, part of it was film in 1917 and rest in 1920. The release date is known though 1921. And it survived because it was misplaced and later rediscovered. Many films of time were shown then recorded over. This one simply was forgot and nobody bothered to destroy it.
@@StacieMMeier Hi Stacie! Here are the production and release dates for THE LUCKY DOG, according to author Randy Skretvedt’s “Laurel & Hardy: The Magic Behind The Movies - The Ultimate Edition" (2016, 2019). “Written and filmed mid-to-late January, 1921. Released circa December 1921 by Reelcraft as part of the Sun-lite comedy series. No copyright registration exists for this film.” I believe the lack of an existing copyright registration is what made the year of release so hard to nail down for so many decades. I do remember reading several years back that this took a lot of detective work! It didn't help that most existing Public Domain prints only consist of short excerpts. If you're even a casual Laurel & Hardy fan, I cannot recommend the above book highly enough! CHEERS!!
Stan and Ollie were the best of the best. I think Stan was more funnier than Ollie and much more smarter. Each had the solo careers before teaming up together. History was made the day they got together.
This teaming almost didn't happen at all. I was a little shocked when I read in my Charley Chase biography that Stan came to Pathe' studios in the 1910s; after he made just 4 silent movies , he LEFT the studio and went to Pantages to be on the stage again !!! Charley Chase was already working steady there, and he went to the theater and enjoyed Stans comedy enough that he coaxed him to go back and make more movies ...
+John Greene Eye liner make up was used during the silent period to highlight the eyes, the films had trouble getting focus on the eyes bc they would be almost reflective to the camera, the dark eye liner acted as a border or gave a shadowing affect so that the camera could focus the eyes better
Has someone noticed that Stan Laurels face gestures are very similar to Herman Monster (Fred Gwynne) used to do too? Or its oly me that noticed this...LOL
Think of this: the girl in the film is Florence Gilbert. According to www.imdb.com/name/nm0318045/ she was born in 1904. If this was filmed in 1917, she'd be only 13! She was 16 in 1920 which is still a little young, but is much more believable.
There is debate when it was filmed. Laurel claimed it was filmed in 1917, War Debt, was around then. Because of this, it is likely Laurel was correct. However, a strange twist, part of movie shows a car with a licence plate of 1920. So it is likely that part of movie was filmed in 1917 through 1918. And rest during 1920. This wasn't uncommon though, and many at this era are unknown exactly when they were filmed. Either way, movie was released in 1921 and because of a fluke, it managed to survive. Which is a good thing...
@@StacieMMeier It was filmed during January 1921 and released on October 10th 1921. It was Florence Gilbert's 10th movie. She started in films in 1920 at the age of 16.
From wiki The precise date that the film was shot is not recorded. It had long been thought to have been made in 1917, partially due to comments Stan made about it during an interview in 1957. But it had also been dated to 1918 and 1919.However, on the basis of an examination of the dates that Stan was available for filming, and the appearance of a 1920 car license plate in one shot of the complete film, the most likely date filming took place is in the latter part of 1920 and into early 1921.The film was released for distribution in late 1921 by Reelcraft. .................................................................................................…..............:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.......................................................................................📻wiki
+horacetwiddlepass No he didn't. If you mean he took a break in 1917 perhaps. Though it seems strange a couple people who remembered the film being produce claimed it was filmed during 1917 and 1918 (For example Hardy claimed it was 1918 to 1919.) There is one likely possibility for the car licence, it was a long term one for lot usage, which did exist then (The Licence for those had the date they ran out not the date of year it was current). Most likely and highly likely they did a test shoot for stunts in 1917 and did the rest later.
Did this film catch the attention of Hal Roach that lead to his signing Of Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy as as a comedy duo some five years later? I await your reply.
@@shawnsmith5028 I checked wikipedia. It did not say anything about this film ,that the accidental appearance Of Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy, caught the attention of Hal Roach, before signing them as a comedy duo 5 years later.
"The Lucky Dog" title card released with film shows 1917, why would that be wrong. AFI site has it as 1917. In an iterview with Laurel one weeks after Hardy's death he said it was made in 1917 (time 6:30 to 8:30) in Stan Laurel Interview August 14th - 1957.
@ free - In that Art Friedman interview he says it was "around" that time, but he also says he worked with Babe again "a couple of years" later. It was in fact 5 years, and Stan's memory for such things was never reliable. On a visit to his home he was asked to list all his early films before Roach and he started with "Just Nuts" which was a Harold Lloyd film. Stan's first film was Nuts In May, an understandable slip. All the documentation refers to 1921, with production in January and release in October, with copyright registration in the meantime. Stan only got into the business in 1917 with Nuts In May and Hardy was contracted to Vim with the Plump and Runt series. No movies involving Jess Robbins were made between 1914 and 1918. www.imdb.com/title/tt0013341/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1
The title card is also wrong about the director, Jess Robbins. Obviously a later addition. It was released on October 10th 1921. Florence Gilbert didn't start in pictures until 1920.
That's because his pale blue eyes were hard to photograph on camera so they had to heavily paint his eyelids black in order to draw less attention to his eerily white eyes.
+planetX15 It was released on 10th October 1921 and there's a car with 1920 number plates in one scene. It also refers to Bolsheviks, who only became prominent in 1917, and in the days before "normal" communications, they weren't really known much until later. Someone also said that the tramcar was a later model than 1917, but I don't know. It could have been produced in more than one session of course.
If only Stan knew that this film would still be available for world wide viewing over a hundred years after production. Love 'em. ASpril, 2023.
Amazing. 101 year old film and I'm still sucked into watching it. Lol. I grew up watching these guys and the 3 stooges during the 80's, and it never gets old. The first laurel and hardy I saw was Birth Marks and I laughed sooo hard I was crying.....and I couldn't stop. These "comedians" now got nothing on these guys. They REALLY should have a L&H and 3 stooges channel.
History being made here, the beginning of what would become the greatest comedy partnership in history!
Agreed
00
0
,
Clean, witty, humorous and funny.
Best comedians of all time. RIP Stan and Ollie ❤
I can't quite get my mind around the fact this is 100 years old. Technology has come so far like damn!
Historic. It's a miracle this film survived. I wish HATS OFF! did, too. Stan and Babe (Hardy) forever!
Well said. They are incomparable. I'm also with you on Hats Off, and stuff does keep turning up, so there's always hope.
This is a strange film in that nobody is certain when it was filmed. The only clue is a car licence plate that dates 1920. Though Stan claimed it was filmed much earlier 1917. Perhaps, though both dates are correct, part of it was film in 1917 and rest in 1920. The release date is known though 1921. And it survived because it was misplaced and later rediscovered. Many films of time were shown then recorded over. This one simply was forgot and nobody bothered to destroy it.
@@StacieMMeier Hi Stacie! Here are the production and release dates for THE LUCKY DOG, according to author Randy Skretvedt’s “Laurel & Hardy: The Magic Behind The Movies - The Ultimate Edition" (2016, 2019).
“Written and filmed mid-to-late January, 1921. Released circa December 1921 by Reelcraft as part of the Sun-lite comedy series. No copyright registration exists for this film.”
I believe the lack of an existing copyright registration is what made the year of release so hard to nail down for so many decades. I do remember reading several years back that this took a lot of detective work! It didn't help that most existing Public Domain prints only consist of short excerpts. If you're even a casual Laurel & Hardy fan, I cannot recommend the above book highly enough! CHEERS!!
100 years ago. Incredible
If only it had been realized right off the bat that Laurel and Hardy were a perfect duo, we could have had ten more years of their films together.
Still awesome 100 years later.. 🤩
A mystic golden age of anything. Full of charm and character in every little detail.
I LOVE DOGS this movie was boss! Laurel and Hardy are the best duo ever in comedy!
I can't resist watching those two characters.
The start of the greatest comedy duo ever
Stan and Ollie film got me here and im so.glad i did The world famous duos 1st film together
Stan and Ollie were the best of the best. I think Stan was more funnier than Ollie and much more smarter. Each had the solo careers before teaming up together. History was made the day they got together.
My favourite from the boys was another dog movie, "Laughing Gravy" Definitely one of the best films ever made.
It was a positive omen that this film is called "Lucky Dog." Stan and Babe were both "lucky dogs" to be teamed together!
pure gold, and the legends were born. thank you for for showing this lost jem!
This teaming almost didn't happen at all. I was a little shocked when I read in my Charley Chase biography that Stan came to Pathe' studios in the 1910s; after he made just
4 silent movies , he LEFT the studio and went to Pantages to be on the stage again !!!
Charley Chase was already working steady there, and he went to the theater and enjoyed Stans comedy enough
that he coaxed him to go back and make more movies ...
Wonderful to see this. And Joshua Rifkin playing Scott Joplin is a bonus.
SOME OF THE SILENTS ARE FUNNIER THAN THE TALKIES 😂
I think 21 is gonna be a good year ...
Me too 😔
It’s been bad so far
I have some bad news to tell you 😬
All i can think when i watch this is...
“That’s Cooking mama’s soundtrack”
I literally freaking died at 2:00 😂😂😂
You could not have perished, you would not have been able to compose and post your comment.
holy crap, this is almost 100 years old movie =)
Fiilis1 One day you will be, too.
Nooo, i'm forever 25years old!
Fiilis1 now it is
@@EliezerPennywhistler if he's lucky.
omg this gives me RMS Celtic Cedric Baltic Adriatic Romanic Republic Laurentic 1 Mégantic and Zealandic vibes
whom
Stan was told that he would not have the right look for movies. He had very pale blue eyes that looked dead on film, thus the heavy eye makeup.
+John Greene Eye liner make up was used during the silent period to highlight the eyes, the films had trouble getting focus on the eyes bc they would be almost reflective to the camera, the dark eye liner acted as a border or gave a shadowing affect so that the camera could focus the eyes better
That was an excuse about the eyes
Ha-ha, they also said his thin voice was no good for sound films, but...........
Super j adore❤️❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍😁
On les aime! C'est drôle! Merci!
ho questo cd bellissimo
bravo maestro
Wow...real comedy...
Very good
Ever green L&H!
This video is exactly 101 years old today
jajaja me encantan.
Stan was great
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Mayhem. And the rest is history
Wow
This came out 100 years ago...
Has someone noticed that Stan Laurels face gestures are very similar to Herman Monster (Fred Gwynne) used to do too? Or its oly me that noticed this...LOL
Stan got there first.
Think of this: the girl in the film is Florence Gilbert. According to www.imdb.com/name/nm0318045/ she was born in 1904. If this was filmed in 1917, she'd be only 13! She was 16 in 1920 which is still a little young, but is much more believable.
@ JS. Correct. The film was made in January 1921 and released in October that year. Florence Gilbert only came into the movie business in 1920.
1921.
At the start the landlady says "it's beginning to look like war debt". America joined WW1 in 1917 so I presume the film was made in 1917.
Yes, but the debt came after the war.
There is debate when it was filmed. Laurel claimed it was filmed in 1917, War Debt, was around then. Because of this, it is likely Laurel was correct. However, a strange twist, part of movie shows a car with a licence plate of 1920. So it is likely that part of movie was filmed in 1917 through 1918. And rest during 1920. This wasn't uncommon though, and many at this era are unknown exactly when they were filmed. Either way, movie was released in 1921 and because of a fluke, it managed to survive. Which is a good thing...
@@StacieMMeier It was filmed during January 1921 and released on October 10th 1921. It was Florence Gilbert's 10th movie. She started in films in 1920 at the age of 16.
At 3:20 welcome Oliver Hardy
cant get a truck in a ford garage xD
From wiki
The precise date that the film was shot is not recorded. It had long been thought to have been made in 1917, partially due to comments Stan made about it during an interview in 1957. But it had also been dated to 1918 and 1919.However, on the basis of an examination of the dates that Stan was available for filming, and the appearance of a 1920 car license plate in one shot of the complete film, the most likely date filming took place is in the latter part of 1920 and into early 1921.The film was released for distribution in late 1921 by Reelcraft.
.................................................................................................…..............:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.......................................................................................📻wiki
@ Fox - yes and Florence Gilbert only made her first film in 1920, and this was about her 10th.
It was released on October 10th 1921.
Also, Jess Robbins took a break from the movie industry from 1914 - 19, and made no films in 1917.
+horacetwiddlepass
No he didn't. If you mean he took a break in 1917 perhaps. Though it seems strange a couple people who remembered the film being produce claimed it was filmed during 1917 and 1918 (For example Hardy claimed it was 1918 to 1919.) There is one likely possibility for the car licence, it was a long term one for lot usage, which did exist then (The Licence for those had the date they ran out not the date of year it was current). Most likely and highly likely they did a test shoot for stunts in 1917 and did the rest later.
Stacie - give a list of the films he made between 1914 an 1919.
Did this film catch the attention of Hal Roach that lead to his signing Of Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy as as a comedy duo some five years later? I await your reply.
Check wikipedia.
@@shawnsmith5028 I checked wikipedia. It did not say anything about this film ,that the accidental appearance Of Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy, caught the attention of Hal Roach, before signing them as a comedy duo 5 years later.
👍😀🇩🇪
👍👣
funny... the picture said 1917
They were poor and filthy appeared at their beginning
So was this made in 1917 but released in 1921?
"The Lucky Dog" title card released with film shows 1917, why would that be wrong. AFI site has it as 1917. In an iterview with Laurel one weeks after Hardy's death he said it was made in 1917 (time 6:30 to 8:30) in Stan Laurel Interview August 14th - 1957.
@ free - In that Art Friedman interview he says it was "around" that time, but he also says he worked with Babe again "a couple of years" later. It was in fact 5 years, and Stan's memory for such things was never reliable. On a visit to his home he was asked to list all his early films before Roach and he started with "Just Nuts" which was a Harold Lloyd film. Stan's first film was Nuts In May, an understandable slip. All the documentation refers to 1921, with production in January and release in October, with copyright registration in the meantime. Stan only got into the business in 1917 with Nuts In May and Hardy was contracted to Vim with the Plump and Runt series. No movies involving Jess Robbins were made between 1914 and 1918.
www.imdb.com/title/tt0013341/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1
The title card is also wrong about the director, Jess Robbins. Obviously a later addition. It was released on October 10th 1921. Florence Gilbert didn't start in pictures until 1920.
@@mrsbrownandhercat Also I believe the car Stan nearly gets run over by wasn't produced until after 1917.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Stan looks like he has 2 black eyes-lol
That's because his pale blue eyes were hard to photograph on camera so they had to heavily paint his eyelids black in order to draw less attention to his eerily white eyes.
Just to remind about the mistaken title card - directed by Jess Robbins.
+mrsbrown andhercat So it is 1921?
+planetX15 It was released on 10th October 1921 and there's a car with 1920 number plates in one scene. It also refers to Bolsheviks, who only became prominent in 1917, and in the days before "normal" communications, they weren't really known much until later. Someone also said that the tramcar was a later model than 1917, but I don't know. It could have been produced in more than one session of course.
8
これ、ゲームの元ネタ？
That hand in lower right made it impossible for me to watch.
Looks like Laurel is ripping off Buster Keaton.
They both made their first movies in 1917.
Putting a pup in the trash and covering it up? I don't find that humorous.
Nobody really cares what you think.