this song wasn't made to trend and have 100 million views or what not, it's a song for shinee and shaowls to honour everything theyve done and jonghyun. it's a song for shinee and shawols to healthily accept what happened and to acklnowledge that shinee is always 5 and always will be and we will forever hold jjong in our hearts even if we have to keep moving on without him physically here. there's a reason this song is never performed
This song is a tribute to their beloved, irreplaceable friend & to Shawol’s beloved SHINee member & star Jonghyun. I know Shawols come here to listen to this song. This song is a way for us to grieve & remember as well as for SHINee to grieve their loss!
Hyaah... This is making me cry. I remember how much I crossed when my cousin called me. My friend still believes I cried because of him 😭 I loved bling bling. I still do
Eliza I salute their courage & have great respect for their resilience. Grieving is such a hard process. It’s very personal & sometimes they had to grieve in public. These guys deserve so much credit for how they handled themselves when most would have fallen apart. They are probably crying inside & pushing on. But they stayed together & SHINee are still here thanks to them & thanks to the memory of Jonghyun.
Because they don't want to be apart from each other. Doing this for themselves and for both Jonghyun and their fans. After all they know all five of them love being SHINee the most and want to continue their legacy
They show that in a way they almost didn't, they show their struggles. But they show that ultimately their bond brought them back stronger for Jonghyn and his memory
"When your tears are falling just let them shed. I wish you'll think of it as if that weight inside your heart is getting out of your body drop by drop like that." - Jonghyun
Lock You Down (where Jonghyun's voice was included) is the 5th song on this ep, has all 5 members, and is the last song on the TSOL series. SHINee are always together in the end ❤❤❤❤❤
The most poignant phrases here are: "When I stand again on the road we walked on together There are five overlapping hands, tears and memories" and "Our voices are flying. We know it'll reach you wherever you are."
"My voice is important. my opinions are important. other people's voices and opinions are equally important. why are there so many people who don't understand this reasoning?"ㅡKim Jonghyun
Being here, on his birthday, makes this song even sadder. I miss his voice and his whole personality. Shinee helped me through hard times, only with a few songs. All their voices are healing and I miss them as five. But they will be always 5hinee
My birthday is April 10th 2 days after Jonghyun's bday April 8th so l always remember him when I'm celebrating mine. He was an Aries♈ like me. I missed him😭
"Physical scars and psychological scars are different. I hope everyone can think for a second that scars exist even if you can’t see them.”ㅡKim Jonghyun.
Some people are saying SHINee flops or that some say that they're disappointed that the views are not impressive. Here's what.. SHINee didn't make this song for views, for awards.. They made it for their lost brother. This is a song where they express their yearning and appreciation for Jonghyun. This is a song where they try to comfort themselves and the fans, where we give each other strength. I personally don't mind the views because I understand that not all Shawols are capable to watch this at the moment. It's difficult to watch the members' raw and honest expressions in this mv, and the heavy emotions behind their voice. To our 5 beloved boys, you guys did well ♥️ Let's continue to give each other strength and support. Let's be strong like how the boys are trying to for us, Shawols. Let's stay strong for our beloved 5HINee ♥️
daneelee It’s just expectations were high for this song for its cause , for its value and also because it’s beautiful, I honestly don’t understand that some shawols can’t watch this song !! How ? Bec they can’t stand the members vulnerable? Well , they are humans and humans do grieve , express their feelings and appreciate their loved ones .. this song has value , it’s their message and tribute to Jonghyun and it’s raw feelings , they shouldn’t be dandy , funny and dorky all the time , they are not puppets. Sorry but I’m disappointed that’s all and this is my POV .
Nah, some shawols can't watch it not solely because of the members. You have to understand some shawols are hardcore Jonghyun's fans. For instance, my friends, and they told me they love Shinee to death but this song just hits so close to home y'know. I know the members have it harder than us cos they're super close. But u gotta understand some fans too, it's hard to watch and listen to a song that is dedicated to your ultimate bias that you've lost and would never see him on stage again, *ever* . And seeing the members' heartbreaking expressions are just difficult for them. Sorry, I'm not trying to pick a fight with you or anything. I just wanted to correct you on why some shawols can't watch this mv yet, I mean at least from the perspective of some Shawols that I know of.
I agree, it was so hard for me to watch this MV, simply because it was so directed towards Jonghyun. I guess it’s because the situation is so surreal, and hardcore shawols definitely, no desperately want to stream this song, and make the views better, but we need to understand it can be hard. It was so hard for me, but I finally pulled myself together, watched it, and cried. This MV is beautiful, and it deserves so much more attention, but SHINee didn’t make this for attention or for views. They made this for Jjong. Views shouldn’t matter, and if that’s the only thing you want to look for, that’s kind of sad. Truly, we should simply come together as the SHINee World, and support their comeback to the best of our abilities. They understand it’s hard for us too, yet we gave I Want You it’s first win, and we’ll give them many more.
daneelee I wasn’t picking a fight too , I just wanted to state a different POV as a hard core blinger myself , I understand the others prospect , but I hope we face facts and move on loving and accepting everything.
meow meow but it’s a part of their comeback too , and it’s not about the views it’s about supporting a cause and certain value , it’s about unity , I looked at this song as something they wanted to share , mind you if they wanted to grieve alone they wouldn’t have performed it , it was a surprise, did any of us expected this song from their comeback? Frankly no .. so I wanted to show them how strong we can carry them forward and be one for them . Anyway your point is granted and i respect it as a different pinion .
I'm pretty sure it's Key who says it, but it's a bit confusing since we do see Minho on the screen. Either way, I think it doesn't really matter who said it because it's the words Jonghyun wanted to hear and whatever is said in this song is dedicated to him from every single member.
4:30? 4:35 is more accurate xD I hear Minho though... is it only me? edit: wait yeah i think it is Key. the more i listen to it. AAA this song is too filled with feels, it's hard not to get emotional and use up all my tissues TT^TT)
thats why my LOVE and DEVOTION towards shinee is increasing day by day. U KNOW SOME PEOPLE R RARE...COULD HAVE MORE LONILESS...THATS WHY KEEP THEM ALWAYS SAFE...BE ALWAYS IN THEIR SIDE...NO MATTER WHAT THE WIND TURN...BEZ IF U LOST THEM...U HAVE NOTHING LEFT OTHER THEN REGRETS AND THAT 'IF' 'IF THAT COULD HAPPEN......COULD HAVE SAVEDD......' I only want u to be happy and healthy LIVE LONG AND LONG AND LONG. :''')
샤이니 데뷔 이후로 언제나 샤이니의 존재와 곡들은 알고 있었지만 팬은 아니었는데 뒤늦게 샤이니 덕분에 인생 처음으로 덕질이라는 걸 해보는 늦덕입니다. 그리고 이제와 이 앨범의 가치를 뼈저리게 느끼고 있는 중이에요. 지금 생각해보면 종현이를 잃음으로써 가장 상처를 많이 받았을 사람들이 상처가 채 아물기도 전에 이런 곡을 녹음하고 뮤직비디오를 찍고 공연을 했다는 것이 얼마나 고통스러웠을지... 물론 오히려 상처를 드러내보이고 들여다봐주는 것이 회피하고 묻어두는 것보다 건강하게 이겨내는 방법이긴 하겠지만 그건 그 후의 일이잖아요. 이 당시에 이를 악물고 이 곡을, 이 앨범을 작업하면서 본인들의 상처와 상실을 들여다봤을 이 사람들이 참 대견하고, 대단하고, 자랑스럽고, 고맙네요. 늦덕이 된 이유는 샤이니의 음악성, 독창성, 인성, 팀워크 등등 많은 것이 있겠지만 무엇보다 이 사람들의 삶을 살아나가는 태도입니다. 제 주변 누구보다 저에게 삶을 어떻게 살아나가야 할지에 대해 큰 영감과 방향성을 주는 사람들이네요. 샤이니의 멤버 한명한명이.
"our voices will fly to where you are, they will reach you, we know it" "this is not the end of our story's page let's be together until the end" "Even though the road is difficult let's keep walking " "We miss you, we want to tell you but, that will not fill this empty heart tonight" these lyrics❤️
The fact that shinee themselves wrote the lyrics makes this even more heartbreaking and special at the same time. No other group will have this much of a special place in my heart like shinee. Shinee and shawols together forever 💚💚💚💚💚
ahhh WAE this last EP is so personal for both SHINee and Shawol. From *Our Page* continue to *Lock You Down* which recorded before the incident so we got to hear ot5 voices again
"My hyungs really are no ordinary people. This is really something I'm proud of, when I say SHINee are for the most part main vocalists, compared to others they also have no weaknesses and they have so many talents too."ㅡLee Taemin
for the entire duration of the video they’re portraying how lifeless they feel and how difficult it is for them to go through their daily life. the way they look so genuinely unmotivated, guys, that’s not acting. the members have already been so unbelievably strong and it astonishes me that they have enough strength to keep moving forward. shawols and shinee are together always, nothing can change that. shinee 5ever.
Congrats Jonghyun for winning 2019 Bonsang Golden Disc Award. So happy to Shawols support ❤❤❤❤❤🧚♀️ Taemin and Minho accepted the award in place of their hyung with heart warming thank you speech Minho: "Firstly, thank you for giving Jonghyun hyung such a good award. To our fans, SHINee World who showed him unchanging support, I would like to say thank you to you all in place of Jonghyun hyung". Taemin went: "Please remember our Jonghyun hyung who has loved music and the stage more than anyone else till now and do remember and look over our Jonghyun hyung's music and stage in the future too." Shinin Jonghyun forever ❤❤❤❤❤🧚♀️
Guys please please go and vote for jonghyun on soompi ...this is the last chance ..he is on the 2nd place another artist is leading with only few points...i hope you guys vote for him. There are two more category for SHINee and jonghyun❤!
@@MarieNightAndDay sorry i don't have the link..but plz download soompi app from playstore and log in the app you will find the awards we have 3 nominations i hope you vote everyday❤..if any problm feel free to msg me
i don't know if anyone pointed this out or noticed this already, but it's recommended to either take a cold shower or hold ice cubes to help overcome suicidal thoughts. I thought it was too much of a coincidence that the ice cubes appeared three times in the music video. If you're struggling with suicidal thoughts, know that this might help a bit! But most of all, don't do it alone, okay? You're not alone. Reach out to someone. I believe in you! (:
*You could see the nostalgia in their eyes, I'm so proud of them because they remained strong and they are now learning how to live with Jonghyun in their hearts.*
*You know what broke my heart? The fact they all look so mentally tired but once they step on the stage and there's the 5th microphone, they look stronger because they still feel Jonghyun's presence. That's so beautiful.*
Don’t understand any of the comments saying shut up, I think that’s genuinely what happens. Even though Jonghyun isn’t with them in body he’ll always be with them in spirit
종현아 나 5년만에 다시 이 노래를 듣고 다시 이 뮤비를 봐. 너를 추억하고 그리워하고 보고싶어서 왔어. 예전에 나의 슬픔으로 보이지 않던 멤버들의 각자 견뎌온 시간들이 보이고 여전히 눈물은 흘러도 너에게 잘지내냐고 안부도 남겨. 보고싶다. 내 친구, 내 청춘, 내 별. 잘지내지? 우리 샤이니, 우리 온쫑밍키탬 16주년 축하해.
Our Page (lyric) Can you feel it? We’re connected By our hearts that are transparent Like invisible string When I stand again on the road we walked on together There are five overlapping hands, tears and memories It’s so clear, I don’t want to forget I can’t forget The pretty words you left Behind become a poem, become a song Our voices are flying We know it’ll reach you wherever you are If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? I’m holding the precious you in my arms I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet Until the very end I’ll say that I miss you But it won’t fill up my empty heart tonight We’re facing each other, we’re still the same We’re still the boys who are dreaming The pretty words you left behind Become a poem, become a song Our voices are flying We know it’ll reach you wherever you are If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? I’m holding the precious you in my arms I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet Until the very end May 25, 2008 Boys shining brightly Like green waves of spring That time will spread and flow forever The pretty words you left behind Become a poem, become a song Our voices are flying We know it’ll reach you wherever you are If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? (If a star vanishes, will everything) I’m holding the precious you in my arms I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet Until the very end
hani Thanks for the lyrics! Omg the meaning was more beautiful (and sad) than I thought, but I'm so proud of them! 😭😭😭 I love these guys 💚 my #5hineeforever 🙌🏽
i had to stop reading like 4 times because my eyes were so teary i couldn't see, thank you so much. they needed this song to tell us how they were feeling, and we all needed it to heal with them.
I have never seen a group love each other the way that SHINee does. I'm not just talking about Kpop, but music in general. We've had boy and girl groups around forever and a day, but I have legit never seen five people love each other as fiercely as them. The fans suffered a great loss, but they lost a brother. What they lost is deeper than losing a favorite singer or labelmate. They lost a person that became a family member. People, please love each other. If you see the signs of depression, reach out and help. Ask questions, be there for someone in need, and learn about mental health. Tell your friends and family that you love them. Be a shoulder for a stranger to cry on. Thank you, SHINee, for showing us how to love.
Night Angel Xjapan is the only other group I can think of they lost 2 band members. One suicide and one accidental death. His name was hide. Yoshiki shows so much strength for his band just like my boys SHINee
you just insert this "_" in the beginning and in the end of what you want to write. like _ i love shinee _ , now put them close _i love shinee_ and here you are.
Can you feel it? We’re connected By our hearts that are transparent Like invisible string Tell me, vow to me in the sky No matter how difficult the road, we’ll keep going When I stand again on the road we walked on together There are five overlapping hands, tears, and memories It’s so clear, I don’t want to forget, I can’t forget The pretty words you left behind Become a poem, become a song Our voices fly to where you are We know it will reach you If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? The precious you is in my embrace We will fill the pages of this unfinished story together till the end I say that I miss you But it won’t fill up my empty heart tonight We’re facing each other As we always do We’re still like boys who dream today The pretty words you left behind Become a poem, become a song Our voices fly to where you are We know it will reach you If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? The precious you is in my embrace We will fill the pages of this unfinished story together till the end May 5th, 2005 boys The bright green waves of spring That time will flow forever again It will spread The pretty words you left behind Become a poem, become a song Our voices fly to where you are We know it will reach you If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? The precious you is in my embrace We will fill the pages of this unfinished story together till the end
We're all crying watching this. Can you imagine how hard the members trying to hold on their tears to shoot this mv? 😖 It feels like there's a thorn in my throat. But watching this is like the members trying to say to all that have lose their loved ones, to be strong and keep going, make yourself worthy and can be proud of.
Eau de Jenny i cant even imagine them performing this live. If it's hard to shoot this mv how hard would it be to perform this live. This is soooo beautiful though
I don't want to be a hypocrite, I learned more about SHINee after what happened. But I just remember the fact that even if I wasn't a fan, I cried my eyes out that day as I was considering the same thing around those days and I just broke down in tears looking at his fans. It's been almost 4 years and I haven't stopped listening to them since then. I'm sad I didn't meet them before, but they sure became one of my favorite groups in a very short time and I hope I can continue to support them
The video shows their lives after the incident. Minho was recording the movie 'Inrang' for that moment and had to resume recordings in a short time. It shows Key dancing alone. Onew lately has been writing lyrics and the gym is a common thing for idols. That means they tried to continue with their routine, their activities. But it was like time goes by and they are in the same place. A burdensome. They decided to walk the same path together and stay five as SHINee was the best for them. Of course, this is my interpretation. ⚘
This is a very good idea of what I saw. My other interpretation was each of them showing a different part of Jonghyun's life - song writer, choreographer, acting, and trying to stay the shape/size people expected him to be in. Both interpretations make sense to me. I like yours.
The members were so strong to comeback so shortly after such a tragic loss I don’t think many groups would be able to do it. They’ve been so strong through all of this and it hurts me that such strength is even being demanded of them. No one should have to experience this type of loss, especially this young, in the public eye and almost 10 years into their careers. Honestly, if they didn’t return to music when they did I am not sure they would have returned at all. It feels like they never got to fully take the time they needed away from the public as though they just pushed through so much to maintain any sense of normalcy in their lives. I am so proud of them and I hope they know that Shawols are always here for them, and that we are always with Jonghyun too. Most of the time, I feel happy watching older content and don’t think much about how things had ended up, but then sometimes it just hits so randomly and it hurts so much. We are all still hurting and that’s okay, but healing doesn’t mean leaving Jonghyun behind. You don’t have to feel guilty about learning to feel better, you don’t have to inflict sadness onto your heart to prove to yourself that he meant something to you. Healing will take a long time and you may never be the same as before, but it’s a process you have to allow to begin.
Thank you for sharing these beautiful words. They are greater, stronger, more beautiful (inside and out, their bodies are sooo graceful) and their music and dance moves are more powerful than before! Their compassion is golden.
Me too dear.. me too.... and i'm here for you, i'm serious. I wish he wasn't gone so i could've met him... but.. he's not so... I miss him a lot.... sorry.. for saying something so random.
It's ok to cry....this MV speak their feeling and at the same time we find comfort....let's move forward and healing together. Much love and send virtual hugs to y'all
10 years passed. it's unbelievable how it was fast, they have grown together in happiness and sadness. they are..... 5 from a boy become a best man 5 Multitalented 5 Vocals 5 Rappers 5 Visuals 5 Actors 5 Hardworking 5 Humble 5 Very soft heart 5 Models 5 Funniest 5 Dancers 5 Song writers 5 Smartest 5 Performers 5 Maker us happy and laugh 5 Everything and anything All their songs are awesome The best fandom SHINee is a born to shine the brotherhood, the family, the love not just as a group, but a true family. no matter what happen, i will see SHINee as FIVE. i'm so proud of you SHINee. i love them so much, thank you SHINee has made my life more colorful❤❤❤❤❤ 5 KINGS
People who say that Shinee should not have made this song because they are taking advantage of Jonghyun's death are so wrong!!!!! These boys NEEDED to do this song so they could HEAL you can feel that (and when you read the lyrics you know it more) There will never be a time in their lives that they won't be hurting and wondering if they could have done anything to change things but they need to heal. If singing this beautiful song and making a very touching MV is one step closer to them being able to accept what happened and move forward then I am all for it. They will always be five in their hearts and that is what this MV showed. You did well Shinee
Shey Wood d(^_^ )Agreed. I hope this song gets many wins so that the members and the fans can cry it out together at their comeback stages. I hated seeing them hold in their tears after the I Want You win. I want them to let it out and heal together with us Shawols. ( T ^ T)＼(^-^ )
They made this song not for themselves. They made this specifically for jonghyun, assuring him that they care and miss him so much, and see how strong they are, assuring him not to worry. Also for their fans, saying it's true that we missed him, but at the same time we'll move forward and make you proud, something like that. I believe it was hard for them too. Imagine losing someone you love so much and having to sing about how you feel about it to the whole world. Most of us would just keep quiet and mourn.
Because truthfully speaking, those people aren't shawols. If they themselves knew what it means to lose Jonghyun and feel even 1/4 of what the guys themselves must be feeling, then they wouldn't be saying that. We don't need that kind of negativity nor attitude, so if they can't accept a song as beautiful as this as the tribute that it is, then they can leave. They won't be missed in this Fandom and our Fandom won't be any less without them
*I don't care if this song becomes big but it truly deserves song of the year, everything is so beautiful and the message of this song is full of meaning.* *SHINee had the courage to write this song even though Jonghyun's death is still a fresh wound to all of us.* *They're a huge inspiration and their music has always been there to help a lot of people.*
changbin's grr I couldn’t agree more, we can really see how much pain and how much they’re struggling and it hurts to not be able to do something for them, but let’s do our best to support them and help them get through these rough chapters. We can do this! All the love to you and SHINee 💗💓❤️
I infinitely agree with you. They've been through so much ever since Jonghyun left this world. But they still remained strong. So they deserve so much. Shawol forever 💓💓💓
The empty mic is so hard to see. I just started crying. I can see the emptiness they are portaying in their everyday lives, he should be there but he's not. I'll always a fan. I want to give SHINee and Shawol a hug 😢 you've done well❤
jesuispetite37 I feel the same it's very sad yet beautiful to see that empty Mic. It is sad because he is no longer with us and beautiful because it shows that he still holds his place in SHINee and will always be remembered.
jesuispetite37 I bet it’s hard. But this fandom can go beyond expectations. So you can expect a lot of support coming your way. You’re not alone in this💜
when Onew says “You did good” at the end, I swear, I couldn’t control my tears, and I’m not the type that cries. I’m not a Shawol, but i have listened to them for a while. When I heard about the loss, I did get sad. I think what made me cry was to see how much they cared, and how much their fans care about them, it’s really touching. Even though this song was for Jonghyun, it reminds me of my brother. He died on March last year, so about 2 months after Jonghyun’s death. This song is beautiful, and I will support SHINee, even if they are now serving their country, I will support.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
i think this is the first time i genuinely cried listening to a song. i can hear the pain in their voices and i think thats what made me crack. you did well shinee. you did well jonghyun. 수고했어.
yeolliepollie this isn't my first time but it's one of the very few times when I listened to a song and I needed my inhaler because I could barely breath crying. And I should be sleeping now because we've got classes tomorrow and here I am...
SHINee is seriously so strong for having this comeback. us shawols were hurting but i can’t even imagine how shinee must have felt. this song deserves to be song of the year and definitely deserves some wins on music shows. shinee worked their butts off only to get hate since ppl said they used his death as an excuse... i’m excited for next year and many more years after this with shinee. our 5 boys are absolutely amazing and i love them so so much. now i can’t stop crying after watching this but please support them for a long time !!
this song/music video clearly depicts how difficult it was for SHINee to cope with Jonghyun's death but still expected to move on. this clearly deserves song of the year!
댓글을 잘 남기는 편이 아니라서 약간 부끄럽긴 하지만, 오늘 처음으로 이 뮤비를 봤어 아마 마주할 자신이 없었나 봐. 너를 마지막으로 본 지 5년이 지났네 나 아직도 콘서트 선명하게 기억해. 아직 네가 아주 그립고 보고 싶을 때가 많아 또 여전히 많이 좋아하고 사랑해. 오랜 시간 동안 삶을 포기하고 싶을 때가 정말 많았었는데 그런 나에게 샤이니는 빛이고 희망이었어. 그리고 올해에 긴 시간 앓던 우울증이 많이 나았어 나는. 이상하게 허전하고 묘하면서도 편하다. 너도 지금 편안할까? 너에게 늘 위로받기만 한 것 같아 미안하고 고마워. 너가 내 행복이고 행운이야 종현아 사랑해. 푹 쉬어. 많이 보고 싶다.
Jonghyun who stood in the spotlight (Minho) Jonghyun who composed music (Onew) Jonghyung who was passionate/ who was a dancer (Key) Jonghyung who distracted himslef with training/ who was working hard (Taemin) of course there are much more sides to our angel but I guess this are at least the images the general public had of him.
after watching it all day, I really see how these probably were what they did after Jjong's passing. Minho had his movie to film Onew concentrated on music maybe Key practiced a lot, maybe focussed on the comback (bc he is dancing to Good Night) Taemin went training what was something he and Jjong often did together. Also those scenes where time just passes by them, like the world is moving on even if it stopped for them.
*Dear SHINee,* Thank you for all the hard work. Thank you for the great vocals and music. Thank you for all the amazing performance. Thank you for being and remaining strong. Thank you for the countless memories Thank you for the past 10 years. Thank you for the coming more years. We'll stay on your side no matter what the future holds. *Love, SHAWOLs* 💚💚💚💚💚
A lot of fans said "i cant listen shinee whithout Jonghyun because i cry". I m not agree with this, Onew, Taemin, Minho and Key will must live with this all their lifes and even with this they continue this adventure for us and for Jonghyun so, please, listen them, respect SHINee even if they are physically only 4! If you are a REAL shawol, you have to support them! SHINee 💎💎💎💎💎
I mean I wouldnt judge them for not, it may not be because they dont want to and that they dont support them, it's more of it being difficult for them to face the fact that he isnt there anymore. People deal with grief in different ways.
i wouldn’t say “if you’re a real shawol-“ many people grieve in different ways, it’s a cycle. so just because you’re able to listen, wouldn’t mean they’re able to. everyone’s emotions are different and that’s okay.
After 8 months, I finally found the strength to watch this😔 It was my final year in Senior High School when I took a break from boarding School only to get home and hear the heartbreaking news. I couldn't sleep for 3 and half days straight, I took sleeping pills but even that didn't work because my brain was immune to everything. I cried every morning even after going back to school. I couldn't concentrate on my exams because I was too broken. All the money I was saving for a chance to meet you. Everything I had planned to say to you. Learning Korean on a daily basis. What was I going to do now? Even after a year of your passing, I can't seem to get over it. The pain can't go away. I wonder where you are and what you're doing. I really wish that I had met you. But that's impossible now. Jonghyun Oppa, Even though Key is my bias, I love you from the bottom of my heart like a real brother. I'm so sorry you died. I miss you everyday I got a tattoo of your name as a tribute to you. I'll always love you and I'll tell every one of my kids about you. How you helped my life. Words can't describe how much I miss you and your voice. Words can't describe how hurt I always feel when I realize that someday I'll be your Noona. It's just sad that things turned out this way. I love you so much and I hope you're shining and smiling from heaven. It hurts when a book isn't finished but is closed forever. You'll always be in my heart. As a tribute to you, I'll name my son after you. So I can never forget you. I love you so much Oppa. Rest Well😔😢
I know you wrote this 7 months ago. But I know what you mean. I've been depressed and suicidal. When he passed I stopped listening to look completely. I can finally hear it again. Yet here I am, on my way to school crying, when hearing this song.
This made me tear up. Just reading this listening to the song play. I'm not a shawol (yet? 👀) and have been listening to their music all day today and tbh, I can see why everyone said what they said about shinee and they are all correct. I'm so sorry you guys had to endure that. I don't know how I'd survive if one of mine was gone, it hurts to think about it. But I don't think he wanted anyone to be sad for him. Just keep fighting.
For me SM really lucky to still have Shinee in their agency, because shinee have all in this industry. The best leader, the best vocal, the best fashion, the best visual, and the best dancer. They all already in 1 package, ITS SHINEE. SM need to promote them more, shinee is a rare gem, very rare. Please keep them safe SM 🙏. I love this boys very much 😌
I admire Shawol so much because I'm not even his fan and I'm still so sad about his death. How can you do it? I swear I couldn't if I was you. To be watching their comeback without my heart breaking in every moment. You are the strongest fandom. You support and love the strongest group. I'm ELF, but I will always support SHINee and will remember Jonghyun forever.
Thank you. This comeback has been so hard and I've cried at every song and it's hard to listen some times, but SHINee is still five. He's still there. We might not be able to hear him or see him with them anymore, but he's still there.
We might be dying from pain. But they are being strong for Jonghyun and for us. And our love for Jong will never fade We might also have different bias (in my case Jong) but at the end we love all of them Because SHINee will always be 5 And we care for them as much as they do for us We are really grateful for everything they have taught us I don't want to generalise because I know there are some fans that are really awful But I know that's only a few of them The true shawols will always love them Even if some of them couldn't keep being on the fandom because it was too painful, but the love will never fade. ❤️ And I am so proud of them I am so proud of being a shawol And so grateful for them being in my life
Onew producing the musics trought the night. Minho filming for a drama. Taemin working a lot in the gym to give a masculinity look to people who said he´s to much female. Key training his dance to always try his best. And Jonghyun, the fifth mic. Forever one of the best singers that this world had the pleasure of listening to sing. Why am I crying? Guys, you always did the best for us, your fans. I´m really proud of you five. Please, stay happy and safe. Because you are the reasons for too much people stay happy and safe too, like me. We love you. You five are doing well.
I'm crying too while watching this, they always 5 in Shawol's heart. their harmonizing got me mesmerized, imagine if Jonghyun join them singing or maybe Jonghyun smile for them in there. Shinee and Shawol be strong enough
and I also crying while typing it because the video was played when I'm typing. Shawol you can cry as much as you want but after that, smile brightly and cheering for four of them
*It feels like their voices can heal the pain we all feel. I'm grateful they made this song. Wish we could give them the whole world. They deserve it.*
We cant please everyone and respect is heartily given not by force i always pray to God that shinee left members will give strength tocontinue performing and remain intact even they lost one this shinee group that i admired the most is unique and they are only 5members its not difficult to manage and its easy to understand each other because of their group volume
이걸 찍을 때만 해도 얼마나 힘들었을지 생각하니까 눈물이 흐른다... 종현오빠 사랑해 빈자리가 지금까지도 생각보다 커 아직 잊을 수 없어서 그런가봐 영원히 잊지 않고 생각할거야 많이 힘들었을텐데 그곳에서는 부디 잘 쉬고 있을거라고 생각해 오빠도 분명히 샤이니와 샤월들을 그리워하고 있겠지..? 우리 모두 오빠의 웃음을 잊지 않을거야
SHINee opened the door and invited us in to share their grief and their strength. People around the world...with different languages, culture, lifestyles, nationalities ....are feeling and crying together. Proud of these men in their struggle to move forward and in how they have shared with and relied on the support of each other and of Shawols. I support and love them always.
Whose still watching and listening to these masterpiece??? Jjong's death anniversary is nearing and I cant believe its already 1 year. Jonghyun you did well.
SHAWOLs on 18th December instead of just crying light candles at home and post it on twitter or instagram or google + tagging #candelsforJonghyun to show support for onew,min ho, key, taemin, jonghyun this is the #forgetmenot project let's do this
Just reading this one comment made me burst into tears... I miss Jonghyun so much and I'm so happy that shinee are continuing on making music they love... he did so well...
Rhiannon Edwards I'm not even a shinee fan and im holding back tears. Im so sorry you all had to go through that. I cant even imagine what it must have been like.
thisisme aw thank you so much this comment made me tear up! it's getting better little by little but in moments like this, it still hurts. thanks for supporting them, and shawols ♡
이진기 Vocalist of the nation 김종현 Angel of the nation 김기범 Nation stylist 최민호 Nation Rapper 이태민 Nation dancer 샤이니 Nation Group 샤이니 월드 Nation Fandom Does anyone agree?
문득 그런 생각이 들었어 책을 계속 읽으려면 다음 책장으로 넘어가야 하잖아. 금기어 처럼 말을 하지 못했던 분위기여서 한동안 참 마음이 아팠는데 이제는 그 시기를 잘 지나온 것 같아. 추억을 같이 나누고 공유할 수 있는 시기가 페이지를 채우는 것 처럼 자연스럽게 찾아왔으면 좋겠다. 보고싶고 수고했어
![SHINee - Our Page | 샤이니 - 네가 남겨둔 말 [Music Bank / 2018.07.06]](/img/n.gif)
They left a mic for him. They left a mic...
Jonghyun always wrote songs for SHINee but this time SHINee wrote a song for Jonghyun.
What you said is beautiful
Your Daily Intake why I'm crying cz ur comment 😭 its sad that he really no longer in this world.
THAT HIT MEEEE
His hard work get paid off
Straight to the heart 😭 that's hurts a lot. But your words are perfect for this song.
The videos is 5:10 long. 5 members. 10 years.
yep cool DAMN! COOL! Amazing how you picked up on that!
They did say that Shinee is a 5 member group even tho there are only 4 remaining members. Shinee will always be 5.
Im in tears with that comment
oh no here come the tears damnit
True 😭😭❤️
4:34 "수고했어요" 민호 말했다 ㅠㅠ Minho whispers "You did well" 😭
MusicSavedMyLife 😭😭
MusicSavedMyLife I'm crying again
MusicSavedMyLife oh yeah😭
MusicSavedMyLife this gave me chills 😭😭😭
Omg
this song wasn't made to trend and have 100 million views or what not, it's a song for shinee and shaowls to honour everything theyve done and jonghyun. it's a song for shinee and shawols to healthily accept what happened and to acklnowledge that shinee is always 5 and always will be and we will forever hold jjong in our hearts even if we have to keep moving on without him physically here. there's a reason this song is never performed
because it was never meant to be a performance chart topping song, it was one to console and comfort
This song is a tribute to their beloved, irreplaceable friend & to Shawol’s beloved SHINee member & star Jonghyun. I know Shawols come here to listen to this song. This song is a way for us to grieve & remember as well as for SHINee to grieve their loss!
aw :')
Beautiful comment.
It's beautiful. I just found out about it today. Ateez's Seonghwa listed it as a song that's important to him. I'm glad to hear and see it
"SHINee is always one, whatever we do derives from that" - Jonghyun
Kalbimin sahibi
Aşkım benim yokluğun yakıyor beni
♡
Melisa abla nerelerdesin biz seni çok özledik gel lütfen :)
:')
Let’s not cry because he’s gone, but let us smile because he was here.
iAlMarri yes he’s in a good place now☹️❤️❤️
sorry, I'm already crying. but don't worry, once i stop crying i will smile for them:)
Tank you
Hyaah... This is making me cry. I remember how much I crossed when my cousin called me. My friend still believes I cried because of him 😭 I loved bling bling. I still do
Aarushi Mittal me a
To this day, I still do not know where these boys found the strength to come back the way they did after Jonghyun. I really don't.
They did it for Jonghyun. They knew he would have wanted them to stay together as SHINee and for Shawols.
Eliza they found the strength by knowing it’s what Jonghyun would’ve wanted and it’s what would make him happy
Eliza I salute their courage & have great respect for their resilience. Grieving is such a hard process. It’s very personal & sometimes they had to grieve in public. These guys deserve so much credit for how they handled themselves when most would have fallen apart. They are probably crying inside & pushing on. But they stayed together & SHINee are still here thanks to them & thanks to the memory of Jonghyun.
Because they don't want to be apart from each other. Doing this for themselves and for both Jonghyun and their fans. After all they know all five of them love being SHINee the most and want to continue their legacy
They show that in a way they almost didn't, they show their struggles. But they show that ultimately their bond brought them back stronger for Jonghyn and his memory
"When your tears are falling just let them shed. I wish you'll think of it as if that weight inside your heart is getting out of your body drop by drop like that." - Jonghyun
The length of the video is 5:10 means 5 members and 10 years. Always and forever 5HINee 💎
Lock You Down (where Jonghyun's voice was included) is the 5th song on this ep, has all 5 members, and is the last song on the TSOL series. SHINee are always together in the end ❤❤❤❤❤
Woah 💫
Hazel Kim
❤
...WOOOWAH! Interesting and very touching - v e r y touching indeed💕
mine says 5:09
Real credits to the director tho. The message of the music video is so beautiful.
The most poignant phrases here are:
"When I stand again on the road we walked on together
There are five overlapping hands, tears and memories"
and
"Our voices are flying. We know it'll reach you wherever you are."
💎💎💎💎💎
So beautifull!
And the little "you did well"
@@shorterthanjimin Yes jonghyun always needed to hear it
"My voice is important. my opinions are important. other people's voices and opinions are equally important. why are there so many people who don't understand this reasoning?"ㅡKim Jonghyun
Вот только ты у себя один,а других много.Нельзя позволять никому оказывать давление и указывать как тебе жить.
I don’t know why my dear.
@@margaritajonaton9688 Even from your own parent(s).
Being here, on his birthday, makes this song even sadder. I miss his voice and his whole personality. Shinee helped me through hard times, only with a few songs. All their voices are healing and I miss them as five. But they will be always 5hinee
Sameeee
My birthday is April 10th 2 days after Jonghyun's bday April 8th so l always remember him when I'm celebrating mine. He was an Aries♈ like me. I missed him😭
Because they were trained to just bear the pain and move on,some give up,and some......
My heart needed this song written by SHINee remembering Jonghyun. It´s a precious jewel for the shawols.
4:35 Onew says "수고했어" which means "you did well" im crying 😭
Its onew
Cries a river
Omg😭
Its key. Not onew
lunaspiced watch the live performance you'll see onew's saying
"Physical scars and psychological scars are different. I hope everyone can think for a second that scars exist even if you can’t see them.”ㅡKim Jonghyun.
Some people are saying SHINee flops or that some say that they're disappointed that the views are not impressive. Here's what.. SHINee didn't make this song for views, for awards.. They made it for their lost brother. This is a song where they express their yearning and appreciation for Jonghyun. This is a song where they try to comfort themselves and the fans, where we give each other strength. I personally don't mind the views because I understand that not all Shawols are capable to watch this at the moment. It's difficult to watch the members' raw and honest expressions in this mv, and the heavy emotions behind their voice. To our 5 beloved boys, you guys did well ♥️ Let's continue to give each other strength and support. Let's be strong like how the boys are trying to for us, Shawols. Let's stay strong for our beloved 5HINee ♥️
daneelee
It’s just expectations were high for this song for its cause , for its value and also because it’s beautiful, I honestly don’t understand that some shawols can’t watch this song !! How ? Bec they can’t stand the members vulnerable? Well , they are humans and humans do grieve , express their feelings and appreciate their loved ones .. this song has value , it’s their message and tribute to Jonghyun and it’s raw feelings , they shouldn’t be dandy , funny and dorky all the time , they are not puppets. Sorry but I’m disappointed that’s all and this is my POV .
Nah, some shawols can't watch it not solely because of the members. You have to understand some shawols are hardcore Jonghyun's fans. For instance, my friends, and they told me they love Shinee to death but this song just hits so close to home y'know. I know the members have it harder than us cos they're super close. But u gotta understand some fans too, it's hard to watch and listen to a song that is dedicated to your ultimate bias that you've lost and would never see him on stage again, *ever* . And seeing the members' heartbreaking expressions are just difficult for them. Sorry, I'm not trying to pick a fight with you or anything. I just wanted to correct you on why some shawols can't watch this mv yet, I mean at least from the perspective of some Shawols that I know of.
I agree, it was so hard for me to watch this MV, simply because it was so directed towards Jonghyun. I guess it’s because the situation is so surreal, and hardcore shawols definitely, no desperately want to stream this song, and make the views better, but we need to understand it can be hard. It was so hard for me, but I finally pulled myself together, watched it, and cried. This MV is beautiful, and it deserves so much more attention, but SHINee didn’t make this for attention or for views. They made this for Jjong. Views shouldn’t matter, and if that’s the only thing you want to look for, that’s kind of sad. Truly, we should simply come together as the SHINee World, and support their comeback to the best of our abilities. They understand it’s hard for us too, yet we gave I Want You it’s first win, and we’ll give them many more.
daneelee I wasn’t picking a fight too , I just wanted to state a different POV as a hard core blinger myself , I understand the others prospect , but I hope we face facts and move on loving and accepting everything.
meow meow but it’s a part of their comeback too , and it’s not about the views it’s about supporting a cause and certain value , it’s about unity , I looked at this song as something they wanted to share , mind you if they wanted to grieve alone they wouldn’t have performed it , it was a surprise, did any of us expected this song from their comeback? Frankly no .. so I wanted to show them how strong we can carry them forward and be one for them . Anyway your point is granted and i respect it as a different pinion .
Language can’t be a barrier to human connection. I don’t need to read the lyrics to know what their feeling.
Love has no borders ♥
Yes, the song and their ekspresion enough to show the lyrics ~
who's having a shinee marathon in 2020?
shinee crystal me!! ^^
me hahahh im really miss five of them
Streaming like mad.
streaming until their anniversary
Another mad Shawol here!😁
May 25, 2008
13 years passed, But our boys will forever shine.
14 years* :D
15 years ❤❤❤
Up to 16 and forever ❤
Around 4:30 when it shows the mic.... onew says “you did well”
The words Jonghyun always wanted to hear. We miss you..
Caroline Olivia I am pretty sure it was Minho
Lilipu from the lyric teasers that's Key
I'm pretty sure it's Key who says it, but it's a bit confusing since we do see Minho on the screen. Either way, I think it doesn't really matter who said it because it's the words Jonghyun wanted to hear and whatever is said in this song is dedicated to him from every single member.
4:30? 4:35 is more accurate xD I hear Minho though... is it only me? edit: wait yeah i think it is Key. the more i listen to it. AAA this song is too filled with feels, it's hard not to get emotional and use up all my tissues TT^TT)
Caroline Olivia 9
I felt like sobbing today so HERE I AM.
Sup bro..love ur reaction😣😍
Hi , I often watch your react video, especially the shinee one 😄
same :’D
I hope your reaction to shinee now they are back
same
They're some of the strongest human beings I've ever seen.
thats why my LOVE and DEVOTION towards shinee is increasing day by day.
U KNOW SOME PEOPLE R RARE...COULD HAVE MORE LONILESS...THATS WHY KEEP THEM ALWAYS SAFE...BE ALWAYS IN THEIR SIDE...NO MATTER WHAT THE WIND TURN...BEZ IF U LOST THEM...U HAVE NOTHING LEFT OTHER THEN REGRETS AND THAT 'IF'
'IF THAT COULD HAPPEN......COULD HAVE SAVEDD......'
I only want u to be happy and healthy LIVE LONG AND LONG AND LONG.
:''')
샤이니 데뷔 이후로 언제나 샤이니의 존재와 곡들은 알고 있었지만 팬은 아니었는데 뒤늦게 샤이니 덕분에 인생 처음으로 덕질이라는 걸 해보는 늦덕입니다.
그리고 이제와 이 앨범의 가치를 뼈저리게 느끼고 있는 중이에요.
지금 생각해보면 종현이를 잃음으로써 가장 상처를 많이 받았을 사람들이 상처가 채 아물기도 전에 이런 곡을 녹음하고 뮤직비디오를 찍고 공연을 했다는 것이
얼마나 고통스러웠을지...
물론 오히려 상처를 드러내보이고 들여다봐주는 것이 회피하고 묻어두는 것보다 건강하게 이겨내는 방법이긴 하겠지만 그건 그 후의 일이잖아요.
이 당시에 이를 악물고 이 곡을, 이 앨범을 작업하면서 본인들의 상처와 상실을 들여다봤을 이 사람들이 참 대견하고, 대단하고, 자랑스럽고, 고맙네요.
늦덕이 된 이유는 샤이니의 음악성, 독창성, 인성, 팀워크 등등 많은 것이 있겠지만 무엇보다 이 사람들의 삶을 살아나가는 태도입니다.
제 주변 누구보다 저에게 삶을 어떻게 살아나가야 할지에 대해 큰 영감과 방향성을 주는 사람들이네요. 샤이니의 멤버 한명한명이.
마자..
진짜로요… 남들 눈에는 그냥 외모만 보고 좋아하는게 아이돌일지 몰라도 샤이니는 진짜 인생 그리고 가치관에 영향을 주는, 내 인생에 없어서는 안될 존재에요…
같은 마음입니다🩵
It's okay to cry
me. stop making this abt you.
" ... crying is a natural response to pain" -Baymax, 2014
K-BOP ENTHUSIAST stop making this about you jfc.
K-BOP ENTHUSIAST who asked
Bangtan's Bae yeeeeees
"our voices will fly to where you are, they will reach you, we know it"
"this is not the end of our story's page let's be together until the end"
"Even though the road is difficult let's keep walking "
"We miss you, we want to tell you but, that will not fill this empty heart tonight"
these lyrics❤️
julia samuels it's deep😭
😭😔
dema octamia ik :(
Omg iam crying now 😭😭😭
julia samuels i cry
The fact that shinee themselves wrote the lyrics makes this even more heartbreaking and special at the same time. No other group will have this much of a special place in my heart like shinee. Shinee and shawols together forever 💚💚💚💚💚
ahhh WAE I know right this makes this song even more special, it comes right from their hearts. It's just so beautifully made. 💚
ahhh WAE this last EP is so personal for both SHINee and Shawol. From *Our Page* continue to *Lock You Down* which recorded before the incident so we got to hear ot5 voices again
changbin's grr that's why I'm still crying tbh
ahhh WAE can‘t add anything to this. Beautifully said 😍👍
ahhh WAE I'm sending lots of hugs and tissues to you, it's tough I know ;-;
"My hyungs really are no ordinary people. This is really something I'm proud of, when I say SHINee are for the most part main vocalists, compared to others they also have no weaknesses and they have so many talents too."ㅡLee Taemin
for the entire duration of the video they’re portraying how lifeless they feel and how difficult it is for them to go through their daily life. the way they look so genuinely unmotivated, guys, that’s not acting. the members have already been so unbelievably strong and it astonishes me that they have enough strength to keep moving forward. shawols and shinee are together always, nothing can change that. shinee 5ever.
exocist ❤️
I wonder how many people around the world are sitting in their rooms crying because of this MV at the moment.. 😔
Oh My Lord Taecyeon I’m one of them 3”:
That's exactly what I'm doing right now
Count me in, and it's not the first or second time either...💔💔💔💔💔
Oh My Lord Taecyeon too many
Oh My Lord Taecyeon me
Congrats Jonghyun for winning 2019 Bonsang Golden Disc Award. So happy to Shawols support ❤❤❤❤❤🧚♀️ Taemin and Minho accepted the award in place of their hyung with heart warming thank you speech
Minho: "Firstly, thank you for giving Jonghyun hyung such a good award. To our fans, SHINee World who showed him unchanging support, I would like to say thank you to you all in place of Jonghyun hyung".
Taemin went: "Please remember our Jonghyun hyung who has loved music and the stage more than anyone else till now and do remember and look over our Jonghyun hyung's music and stage in the future too."
Shinin Jonghyun forever ❤❤❤❤❤🧚♀️
Guys please please go and vote for jonghyun on soompi ...this is the last chance ..he is on the 2nd place another artist is leading with only few points...i hope you guys vote for him. There are two more category for SHINee and jonghyun❤!
@마리안나 thanq so much..i hope you vote for him and SHINee everyday❤...as there are 3 nomination...1 forSHINee and 2 for jonghyun😊
@@taemin1390 what is the link to vote?
@@MarieNightAndDay sorry i don't have the link..but plz download soompi app from playstore and log in the app you will find the awards we have 3 nominations i hope you vote everyday❤..if any problm feel free to msg me
@@taemin1390 😢😭😭😭
i don't know if anyone pointed this out or noticed this already, but it's recommended to either take a cold shower or hold ice cubes to help overcome suicidal thoughts. I thought it was too much of a coincidence that the ice cubes appeared three times in the music video. If you're struggling with suicidal thoughts, know that this might help a bit! But most of all, don't do it alone, okay? You're not alone. Reach out to someone. I believe in you! (:
Thank you
thank you
beautiful words
Jonghyun always wrote songs for SHINee but this time SHINee wrote a song for Jonghyun.
*You could see the nostalgia in their eyes, I'm so proud of them because they remained strong and they are now learning how to live with Jonghyun in their hearts.*
*You know what broke my heart? The fact they all look so mentally tired but once they step on the stage and there's the 5th microphone, they look stronger because they still feel Jonghyun's presence. That's so beautiful.*
Shut the fuck up already
changbin's grr do anything to get likes huh? Smh
m chill out
hey can u not some ppl feel bad
Don’t understand any of the comments saying shut up, I think that’s genuinely what happens. Even though Jonghyun isn’t with them in body he’ll always be with them in spirit
종현아 나 5년만에 다시 이 노래를 듣고 다시 이 뮤비를 봐. 너를 추억하고 그리워하고 보고싶어서 왔어. 예전에 나의 슬픔으로 보이지 않던 멤버들의 각자 견뎌온 시간들이 보이고 여전히 눈물은 흘러도 너에게 잘지내냐고 안부도 남겨. 보고싶다. 내 친구, 내 청춘, 내 별. 잘지내지? 우리 샤이니, 우리 온쫑밍키탬 16주년 축하해.
Our Page (lyric)
Can you feel it?
We’re connected
By our hearts that are transparent
Like invisible string
When I stand again on the road we walked on together
There are five overlapping hands, tears and memories
It’s so clear, I don’t want to forget
I can’t forget
The pretty words you left
Behind become a poem, become a song
Our voices are flying
We know it’ll reach you wherever you are
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
I’m holding the precious you in my arms
I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet
Until the very end
I’ll say that I miss you
But it won’t fill up my empty heart tonight
We’re facing each other, we’re still the same
We’re still the boys who are dreaming
The pretty words you left behind
Become a poem, become a song
Our voices are flying
We know it’ll reach you wherever you are
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
I’m holding the precious you in my arms
I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet
Until the very end
May 25, 2008
Boys shining brightly
Like green waves of spring
That time will spread and flow forever
The pretty words you left behind
Become a poem, become a song
Our voices are flying
We know it’ll reach you wherever you are
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
(If a star vanishes, will everything)
I’m holding the precious you in my arms
I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet
Until the very end
hani Thanks for the lyrics! Omg the meaning was more beautiful (and sad) than I thought, but I'm so proud of them! 😭😭😭 I love these guys 💚 my #5hineeforever 🙌🏽
virtual hug #SHINeeIsFive
i had to stop reading like 4 times because my eyes were so teary i couldn't see, thank you so much. they needed this song to tell us how they were feeling, and we all needed it to heal with them.
I read it while listening to the song. I cried 😭
EVERYONE LIKE THIS COMMENT OF HIM OR HER. THIS DESERVE TO BE ON TOP
*Everything about this masterpiece is beautiful, raw and bittersweet. It comes right from their hearts. Shawols will always be by Shinee's side.*
changbin's grr yess let's work hard in supporting them
Changbin's grr
Ow nice name .. sk fan here ❤
I have never seen a group love each other the way that SHINee does. I'm not just talking about Kpop, but music in general. We've had boy and girl groups around forever and a day, but I have legit never seen five people love each other as fiercely as them. The fans suffered a great loss, but they lost a brother. What they lost is deeper than losing a favorite singer or labelmate. They lost a person that became a family member. People, please love each other. If you see the signs of depression, reach out and help. Ask questions, be there for someone in need, and learn about mental health. Tell your friends and family that you love them. Be a shoulder for a stranger to cry on. Thank you, SHINee, for showing us how to love.
Night Angel Xjapan is the only other group I can think of they lost 2 band members. One suicide and one accidental death. His name was hide. Yoshiki shows so much strength for his band just like my boys SHINee
I see another group love each other than other group ..the group is BTS ^^ THEIR BROTHERHOOD ARE AMAZING ... BTS!
Thank you for that. That made me tear up.
enough with bts when it's not about bts
I think it's very disrespectful to talk about another group under someone else's video. Especially SHINee knowing what they've gone through.
5 years now and I always come back here and watch the same videos every year.
I miss you Jonghyun ♥️
You did well Angel 🌹
*Sending virtual hugs to everyone. I think we could all need it after watching this*
Thea Bruun *Yes. ... Thank you♡*
Thea Bruun thx
Thea Bruun thank you, i'll hug you too
thank you. I really needed it. *hugs for you too*
thanks.. you too..
A year has passed...
😭
yes , Everybody miss him , but he will always be in our hearts ...
@@fernandaruiz2770 of course
yes ikr
zahraa khalid yeah too fast and I always cry in a depressing way I always think about his pure smile and soul #RIPkimjonghyun
*_Shinee will always be 5hinee._*
changbin's grr sorry, but how to make our comments in italic?
you just insert this "_" in the beginning and in the end of what you want to write. like _ i love shinee _ , now put them close _i love shinee_ and here you are.
Ooooh, _thanks_ for the info.
do you happen to know how to make it bold?
SHINee forever use * at the first and last. Like * +SHINEE+ * but make it close
bαngταn sonyεοndαn彡 _thankyou_
내가 다시 샤이니 무대를 마주할 수 있게 해준 노래
Can you feel it?
We’re connected
By our hearts that are transparent
Like invisible string
Tell me, vow to me in the sky
No matter how difficult the road, we’ll keep going
When I stand again on the road we walked on together
There are five overlapping hands, tears, and memories
It’s so clear, I don’t want to forget, I can’t forget
The pretty words you left behind
Become a poem, become a song
Our voices fly to where you are
We know it will reach you
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
The precious you is in my embrace
We will fill the pages of this unfinished story together till the end
I say that I miss you
But it won’t fill up my empty heart tonight
We’re facing each other
As we always do
We’re still like boys who dream today
The pretty words you left behind
Become a poem, become a song
Our voices fly to where you are
We know it will reach you
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
The precious you is in my embrace
We will fill the pages of this unfinished story together till the end
May 5th, 2005 boys
The bright green waves of spring
That time will flow forever again
It will spread
The pretty words you left behind
Become a poem, become a song
Our voices fly to where you are
We know it will reach you
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
The precious you is in my embrace
We will fill the pages of this unfinished story together till the end
My heart T-T
😍thqnks for the lyrics btw
Its 25 may 2008😊
Thankful for the lyrics thou
You did well~ 😌
Seriously SM, you should start to add english caption to all your artist official MV
That’s so true
Kinda unrelated but I agree. There’s an option for people to submit a translation on TH-cam but ofc SM doesn’t accept them
🙏plz
its kpop music so why dont you learn Korean lol
I thought there would be one but i am shocked to see the mv without subtitles .SM is carefree😴
N if there was we would be crying even more😍😍
We're all crying watching this. Can you imagine how hard the members trying to hold on their tears to shoot this mv? 😖 It feels like there's a thorn in my throat. But watching this is like the members trying to say to all that have lose their loved ones, to be strong and keep going, make yourself worthy and can be proud of.
Eau de Jenny i cant even imagine them performing this live. If it's hard to shoot this mv how hard would it be to perform this live. This is soooo beautiful though
I don't want to be a hypocrite, I learned more about SHINee after what happened. But I just remember the fact that even if I wasn't a fan, I cried my eyes out that day as I was considering the same thing around those days and I just broke down in tears looking at his fans.
It's been almost 4 years and I haven't stopped listening to them since then. I'm sad I didn't meet them before, but they sure became one of my favorite groups in a very short time and I hope I can continue to support them
The video shows their lives after the incident. Minho was recording the movie 'Inrang' for that moment and had to resume recordings in a short time. It shows Key dancing alone. Onew lately has been writing lyrics and the gym is a common thing for idols. That means they tried to continue with their routine, their activities. But it was like time goes by and they are in the same place. A burdensome. They decided to walk the same path together and stay five as SHINee was the best for them.
Of course, this is my interpretation. ⚘
I am crying now.
Anei ._. Me too
This is a very good idea of what I saw.
My other interpretation was each of them showing a different part of Jonghyun's life - song writer, choreographer, acting, and trying to stay the shape/size people expected him to be in.
Both interpretations make sense to me. I like yours.
shinee thing I was thinking the same. Really 😞❤️
We have been in this together (SHINee & Shawols) We have been strong and we have been supporting us 💎💪
let us not cry because he is gone but let us smile because he was here
Yaa but I cant help.it
Spread this comment it's just the least u can do when jonghyunie safed some of ours lifes with their music...
@@duckman4764 can't help :'(
Me with tears currently running down my face: 😀
After seeing that 5th microphone I couldn't stop crying.
Solita Writes me too
Same
Solita Writes me too
Same 😭😭
Solita Writes me too 😭😭😭😭😭😭
오랜만에 들어도 여전히 눈물이 나지만 이제는 샤이니와 샤월이 함께 그를 그리워하고 추억할 수 있어서 다른 의미로 마음이 울렁이게 된다. 종현아 사랑해.
The members were so strong to comeback so shortly after such a tragic loss I don’t think many groups would be able to do it. They’ve been so strong through all of this and it hurts me that such strength is even being demanded of them. No one should have to experience this type of loss, especially this young, in the public eye and almost 10 years into their careers. Honestly, if they didn’t return to music when they did I am not sure they would have returned at all. It feels like they never got to fully take the time they needed away from the public as though they just pushed through so much to maintain any sense of normalcy in their lives. I am so proud of them and I hope they know that Shawols are always here for them, and that we are always with Jonghyun too. Most of the time, I feel happy watching older content and don’t think much about how things had ended up, but then sometimes it just hits so randomly and it hurts so much. We are all still hurting and that’s okay, but healing doesn’t mean leaving Jonghyun behind. You don’t have to feel guilty about learning to feel better, you don’t have to inflict sadness onto your heart to prove to yourself that he meant something to you. Healing will take a long time and you may never be the same as before, but it’s a process you have to allow to begin.
😭😭😭
True words ❤️
😭❤❤
Thank you for sharing these beautiful words. They are greater, stronger, more beautiful (inside and out, their bodies are sooo graceful) and their music and dance moves are more powerful than before! Their compassion is golden.
Your words 😭😭❤️ yes, healing will take a long time. Healing doesn't mean leaving jjong behind. He's always with us🌕 watching us from above🦕
Jonghyun's mic stand in the middle... I can't. 5HINee 💙
It's 2020 & I'm still shed into tears whenever I heard this song. We truly love you Jonghyun. We miss you so bad.
Same here, I cry Everytime I hear this song, he was my favorite member of the group,
2020
Yes yes yes, Jonghyun is my bias, not was, is.😭💜
So true 😭😭
Me too dear.. me too.... and i'm here for you, i'm serious. I wish he wasn't gone so i could've met him... but.. he's not so... I miss him a lot.... sorry.. for saying something so random.
Happy 14th Anniversary dear SHINee.
I love you Onew
I love you Jonghyun
I love you Key
I love you Minho
I love you Taemin
Shinee always 💙💙💙💙💙
I knew I would cry. I knew it. And here I am.
Rhiannon Edwards I thought I could do it but here I am a complete mess right now
Rhiannon Edwards me too.. and here me now still watch them and remembering my bae :'(
Same here😭
Rhiannon Edwards same
It's ok to cry....this MV speak their feeling and at the same time we find comfort....let's move forward and healing together. Much love and send virtual hugs to y'all
A person only dies when he is forgotten.
For that very reason, you can take it for granted, Kim Jong - Hyun will always be with us.
i cried even more now that i read this thank u for saying this
10 years passed. it's unbelievable how it was fast, they have grown together in happiness and sadness.
they are.....
5 from a boy become a best man
5 Multitalented
5 Vocals
5 Rappers
5 Visuals
5 Actors
5 Hardworking
5 Humble
5 Very soft heart
5 Models
5 Funniest
5 Dancers
5 Song writers
5 Smartest
5 Performers
5 Maker us happy and laugh
5 Everything and anything
All their songs are awesome
The best fandom
SHINee is a born to shine
the brotherhood, the family, the love not just as a group, but a true family. no matter what happen, i will see SHINee as FIVE. i'm so proud of you SHINee. i love them so much, thank you SHINee has made my life more colorful❤❤❤❤❤
5 KINGS
shine bright do u have instagram, i really love your comments.
shine bright *Happy Day 5HINee And my friends Showels* 😿😿💖💖
I've no words, but my heart knows and understands it all.♥️
I ain't a shawol but your comment makes me cry(i like shinee tho im not a hater)🙂
shine bright so true 😢
오랜만에 찾아왔는데.. 이 당시 그들이 얼마나 큰 용기와 다짐을 하고 이 노래를 녹음하고, 준비했을지..감히 상상도 되지 않는다
앞으로도 계속 행복만 했으면 좋겠음.
People who say that Shinee should not have made this song because they are taking advantage of Jonghyun's death are so wrong!!!!!
These boys NEEDED to do this song so they could HEAL you can feel that (and when you read the lyrics you know it more) There will never be a time in their lives that they won't be hurting and wondering if they could have done anything to change things but they need to heal. If singing this beautiful song and making a very touching MV is one step closer to them being able to accept what happened and move forward then I am all for it.
They will always be five in their hearts and that is what this MV showed.
You did well Shinee
Shey Wood d(^_^ )Agreed. I hope this song gets many wins so that the members and the fans can cry it out together at their comeback stages. I hated seeing them hold in their tears after the I Want You win. I want them to let it out and heal together with us Shawols. ( T ^ T)＼(^-^ )
They made this song not for themselves. They made this specifically for jonghyun, assuring him that they care and miss him so much, and see how strong they are, assuring him not to worry. Also for their fans, saying it's true that we missed him, but at the same time we'll move forward and make you proud, something like that. I believe it was hard for them too. Imagine losing someone you love so much and having to sing about how you feel about it to the whole world. Most of us would just keep quiet and mourn.
Shey Wood wow what I cant actually believe is people are deadass saying that... fuck off
Shey Wood they never had they loved one leaving them then. Or they just dont have a feeling.
Because truthfully speaking, those people aren't shawols. If they themselves knew what it means to lose Jonghyun and feel even 1/4 of what the guys themselves must be feeling, then they wouldn't be saying that. We don't need that kind of negativity nor attitude, so if they can't accept a song as beautiful as this as the tribute that it is, then they can leave. They won't be missed in this Fandom and our Fandom won't be any less without them
*I don't care if this song becomes big but it truly deserves song of the year, everything is so beautiful and the message of this song is full of meaning.*
*SHINee had the courage to write this song even though Jonghyun's death is still a fresh wound to all of us.*
*They're a huge inspiration and their music has always been there to help a lot of people.*
changbin's grr I couldn’t agree more, we can really see how much pain and how much they’re struggling and it hurts to not be able to do something for them, but let’s do our best to support them and help them get through these rough chapters. We can do this! All the love to you and SHINee 💗💓❤️
I infinitely agree with you. They've been through so much ever since Jonghyun left this world. But they still remained strong. So they deserve so much. Shawol forever 💓💓💓
this is beyond that award.....it deserves the most precious recommendation.....😭😭😭
Aaron 나가주세요 :)
Stop commenting on this video fucking attention seeker, this is a place for shawols not attention like whores 🙄
The empty mic is so hard to see. I just started crying. I can see the emptiness they are portaying in their everyday lives, he should be there but he's not. I'll always a fan. I want to give SHINee and Shawol a hug 😢 you've done well❤
jesuispetite37 I feel the same it's very sad yet beautiful to see that empty Mic. It is sad because he is no longer with us and beautiful because it shows that he still holds his place in SHINee and will always be remembered.
jesuispetite37
I bet it’s hard.
But this fandom can go beyond expectations.
So you can expect a lot of support coming your way.
You’re not alone in this💜
종현이 생각 나서 왔어. 항상 듣지만 의미를 생각하지
않고 들어 이 노랜. 그냥 듣는다? 의미를 곱씹어 보며 들으면 그냥 눈물이 나와. 보고 싶고 버텨줘서 고맙고 항상 사랑해 김종현 그리고 샤이니.
when Onew says
“You did good” at the end, I swear, I couldn’t control my tears, and I’m not the type that cries. I’m not a Shawol, but i have listened to them for a while. When I heard about the loss, I did get sad. I think what made me cry was to see how much they cared, and how much their fans care about them, it’s really touching. Even though this song was for Jonghyun, it reminds me of my brother. He died on March last year, so about 2 months after Jonghyun’s death. This song is beautiful, and I will support SHINee, even if they are now serving their country, I will support.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I think it's Minho at the end
Lesson of the day: no one will ever top SHINee besides SHINee themselves.
*EVER*
ahhh WAE 你
Very true
pREACH
True dat
ahhh WAE Of course. Minho said "The only people who can beat shinee........is shinee themselves" True fact 101.
i think this is the first time i genuinely cried listening to a song.
i can hear the pain in their voices and i think thats what made me crack.
you did well shinee.
you did well jonghyun.
수고했어.
I cried so hard while listening to this song
jonghyun :(
it didnt help me cause its 3am and im sensitive asf right now...
yeolliepollie this isn't my first time but it's one of the very few times when I listened to a song and I needed my inhaler because I could barely breath crying. And I should be sleeping now because we've got classes tomorrow and here I am...
im sensitive asf right now to..
김종현이 보이진 않지만 저 마이크 앞에서 멤버들 하나하나 부드럽게 쳐다보면서 누구보다 열정적으로 같이 노래 불렀을 거라 믿어
SHINee is seriously so strong for having this comeback. us shawols were hurting but i can’t even imagine how shinee must have felt. this song deserves to be song of the year and definitely deserves some wins on music shows. shinee worked their butts off only to get hate since ppl said they used his death as an excuse... i’m excited for next year and many more years after this with shinee. our 5 boys are absolutely amazing and i love them so so much. now i can’t stop crying after watching this but please support them for a long time !!
let's support them for a long long time!!!! 💎
this song/music video clearly depicts how difficult it was for SHINee to cope with Jonghyun's death but still expected to move on. this clearly deserves song of the year!
Lucy-chan Totally agree. Their voice and the chorus - just so genuine and crystal clear of their feelings.
So true, the melody is sad but hopeful in some parts, the song is really just beautiful. It really shinee's color.
Lucy-chan so now maybe people will get off their backs about them "moving on too quickly" or about them "forgetting Jonghyun".
This song. Their vocals. I'm crying tears of happiness and sadness.
댓글을 잘 남기는 편이 아니라서 약간 부끄럽긴 하지만, 오늘 처음으로 이 뮤비를 봤어 아마 마주할 자신이 없었나 봐. 너를 마지막으로 본 지 5년이 지났네 나 아직도 콘서트 선명하게 기억해. 아직 네가 아주 그립고 보고 싶을 때가 많아 또 여전히 많이 좋아하고 사랑해. 오랜 시간 동안 삶을 포기하고 싶을 때가 정말 많았었는데 그런 나에게 샤이니는 빛이고 희망이었어. 그리고 올해에 긴 시간 앓던 우울증이 많이 나았어 나는. 이상하게 허전하고 묘하면서도 편하다. 너도 지금 편안할까? 너에게 늘 위로받기만 한 것 같아 미안하고 고마워. 너가 내 행복이고 행운이야 종현아 사랑해. 푹 쉬어. 많이 보고 싶다.
Jonghyun who stood in the spotlight (Minho)
Jonghyun who composed music (Onew)
Jonghyung who was passionate/ who was a dancer (Key)
Jonghyung who distracted himslef with training/ who was working hard (Taemin)
of course there are much more sides to our angel but I guess this are at least the images the general public had of him.
Nali2013 it could also be seen as what they did to cope, at least that’s what I thought.
itsprettyodd yes that's possible
Nali2013 and the winter 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
after watching it all day, I really see how these probably were what they did after Jjong's passing.
Minho had his movie to film
Onew concentrated on music maybe
Key practiced a lot, maybe focussed on the comback (bc he is dancing to Good Night)
Taemin went training what was something he and Jjong often did together.
Also those scenes where time just passes by them, like the world is moving on even if it stopped for them.
*Dear SHINee,*
Thank you for all the hard work.
Thank you for the great vocals and music.
Thank you for all the amazing performance.
Thank you for being and remaining strong.
Thank you for the countless memories
Thank you for the past 10 years.
Thank you for the coming more years.
We'll stay on your side no matter what the future holds.
*Love, SHAWOLs*
💚💚💚💚💚
Agree. Shawols will always be with you.
SHINee, thank you for all you did for us 💖💞❣💟❤
Mee too. Mucha admiración desde España 😍
Jjongie always wrote songs for SHINee and now SHINee wrote a song for him...
Dubu Dirori 😭😭😭😭😥😥😥
😭😭😭
Dubu Dirori Don't touch me I can't...
Oh my heart- 😭😭😭😭😭😢
I’m crying😭😭
Dubu Dirori true
A lot of fans said "i cant listen shinee whithout Jonghyun because i cry".
I m not agree with this, Onew, Taemin, Minho and Key will must live with this all their lifes and even with this they continue this adventure for us and for Jonghyun so, please, listen them, respect SHINee even if they are physically only 4!
If you are a REAL shawol, you have to support them!
SHINee 💎💎💎💎💎
Well said.
Yes!
I mean I wouldnt judge them for not, it may not be because they dont want to and that they dont support them, it's more of it being difficult for them to face the fact that he isnt there anymore. People deal with grief in different ways.
i wouldn’t say “if you’re a real shawol-“ many people grieve in different ways, it’s a cycle. so just because you’re able to listen, wouldn’t mean they’re able to. everyone’s emotions are different and that’s okay.
They will never truly be only 4 in my heart! He lives within them and that’s a miracle
After 8 months, I finally found the strength to watch this😔
It was my final year in Senior High School when I took a break from boarding School only to get home and hear the heartbreaking news.
I couldn't sleep for 3 and half days straight, I took sleeping pills but even that didn't work because my brain was immune to everything.
I cried every morning even after going back to school.
I couldn't concentrate on my exams because I was too broken. All the money I was saving for a chance to meet you. Everything I had planned to say to you. Learning Korean on a daily basis. What was I going to do now?
Even after a year of your passing, I can't seem to get over it. The pain can't go away. I wonder where you are and what you're doing. I really wish that I had met you. But that's impossible now.
Jonghyun Oppa, Even though Key is my bias, I love you from the bottom of my heart like a real brother. I'm so sorry you died.
I miss you everyday
I got a tattoo of your name as a tribute to you.
I'll always love you and I'll tell every one of my kids about you.
How you helped my life. Words can't describe how much I miss you and your voice.
Words can't describe how hurt I always feel when I realize that someday I'll be your Noona.
It's just sad that things turned out this way. I love you so much and I hope you're shining and smiling from heaven.
It hurts when a book isn't finished but is closed forever.
You'll always be in my heart. As a tribute to you, I'll name my son after you.
So I can never forget you.
I love you so much Oppa.
Rest Well😔😢
I know you wrote this 7 months ago. But I know what you mean. I've been depressed and suicidal. When he passed I stopped listening to look completely. I can finally hear it again. Yet here I am, on my way to school crying, when hearing this song.
"It hurts when a book isn't finished but is closed forever." that hit home..
This made me tear up. Just reading this listening to the song play. I'm not a shawol (yet? 👀) and have been listening to their music all day today and tbh, I can see why everyone said what they said about shinee and they are all correct. I'm so sorry you guys had to endure that. I don't know how I'd survive if one of mine was gone, it hurts to think about it. But I don't think he wanted anyone to be sad for him. Just keep fighting.
Pls I hope u r brave enough now.
Be strong and I know it's easy to say but going through the phase is difficult
Pls be voice for jong Hyun oppa
Oh my god these people are crazy, I'm posting this shit on Reddit.
For me SM really lucky to still have Shinee in their agency, because shinee have all in this industry. The best leader, the best vocal, the best fashion, the best visual, and the best dancer. They all already in 1 package, ITS SHINEE. SM need to promote them more, shinee is a rare gem, very rare. Please keep them safe SM 🙏. I love this boys very much 😌
YES PLEASEEEEEEEEEEE.
LOUDERRRR
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
My ultimates in KPop. No one can better SHINee for me! They are a part of my heart! ♥️
Yes pls promote them more 🙏 I'm a babywol and I'm so glad I came across these boys💎💎💎💜💜💜
I admire Shawol so much because I'm not even his fan and I'm still so sad about his death. How can you do it? I swear I couldn't if I was you. To be watching their comeback without my heart breaking in every moment. You are the strongest fandom. You support and love the strongest group. I'm ELF, but I will always support SHINee and will remember Jonghyun forever.
We pull strength from SHINee, from Jonghyun, and from fellow Shawol.
Thank you. This comeback has been so hard and I've cried at every song and it's hard to listen some times, but SHINee is still five. He's still there. We might not be able to hear him or see him with them anymore, but he's still there.
Me too. An elf. Will always support them. They're my fav too
Thank you so much for your support love 💗
We might be dying from pain. But they are being strong for Jonghyun and for us.
And our love for Jong will never fade
We might also have different bias (in my case Jong) but at the end we love all of them
Because SHINee will always be 5
And we care for them as much as they do for us
We are really grateful for everything they have taught us
I don't want to generalise because I know there are some fans that are really awful
But I know that's only a few of them
The true shawols will always love them
Even if some of them couldn't keep being on the fandom because it was too painful, but the love will never fade.
❤️
And I am so proud of them
I am so proud of being a shawol
And so grateful for them being in my life
My comfort song bruh..i listen to this when I'm completely sad
As I have always said, thank you SHINee. ❤️
Onew producing the musics trought the night.
Minho filming for a drama.
Taemin working a lot in the gym to give a masculinity look to people who said he´s to much female.
Key training his dance to always try his best.
And Jonghyun, the fifth mic. Forever one of the best singers that this world had the pleasure of listening to sing.
Why am I crying?
Guys, you always did the best for us, your fans. I´m really proud of you five. Please, stay happy and safe. Because you are the reasons for too much people stay happy and safe too, like me.
We love you. You five are doing well.
I'm crying too while watching this, they always 5 in Shawol's heart. their harmonizing got me mesmerized, imagine if Jonghyun join them singing or maybe Jonghyun smile for them in there. Shinee and Shawol be strong enough
I'm crying while reading your comment
and I also crying while typing it because the video was played when I'm typing. Shawol you can cry as much as you want but after that, smile brightly and cheering for four of them
This hurt me deep in my soul. Beautiful song, can't help but feel that it's missing one more beautiful voice. So proud of these guys.
Jjong's voice is in their song 'Lock You Down' you should check it out :)
i feel the same ;-----;♥
It's beautiful realize that Shawols are still together and support Shinee forever! Also welcome to the new shawols :)
*It feels like their voices can heal the pain we all feel. I'm grateful they made this song. Wish we could give them the whole world. They deserve it.*
changbin's grr I’m agree with you ❤️
This is so beautiful.
You're so strong, Shawols love you, 5hinee💜💜💜
Tbh I was a bit emotional then I see your icon and name and I can't help but lmaooooooo
Podato Poda wjxbwjen I hope I made you a bit less sad😂💜
Too underrated it's a shame. Every one that loves Kpop should be giving this song a like. No matter what fandom you're from.
Ofcourse.
We cant please everyone and respect is heartily given not by force i always pray to God that shinee left members will give strength tocontinue performing and remain intact even they lost one this shinee group that i admired the most is unique and they are only 5members its not difficult to manage and its easy to understand each other because of their group volume
I agree.
Well said🔥
Chynna Bartee YESSS, yesss❣️
이걸 찍을 때만 해도 얼마나 힘들었을지 생각하니까 눈물이 흐른다... 종현오빠 사랑해 빈자리가 지금까지도 생각보다 커 아직 잊을 수 없어서 그런가봐 영원히 잊지 않고 생각할거야
많이 힘들었을텐데 그곳에서는 부디 잘 쉬고 있을거라고 생각해
오빠도 분명히 샤이니와 샤월들을 그리워하고 있겠지..? 우리 모두 오빠의 웃음을 잊지 않을거야
SHINee opened the door and invited us in to share their grief and their strength. People around the world...with different languages, culture, lifestyles, nationalities ....are feeling and crying together. Proud of these men in their struggle to move forward and in how they have shared with and relied on the support of each other and of Shawols.
I support and love them always.
Whose still watching and listening to these masterpiece???
Jjong's death anniversary is nearing and I cant believe its already 1 year. Jonghyun you did well.
SHAWOLs on 18th December instead of just crying light candles at home and post it on twitter or instagram or google + tagging #candelsforJonghyun to show support for onew,min ho, key, taemin, jonghyun this is the #forgetmenot project let's do this
4:35 Onews "You did well" is probably for Jonghyun 🥺
yes, I'm crying 😭😭
I thought they wrote this for jonghyun?
yeosang lines stan, read the lyrics
since I saw your comment I keep trying to hear it but I don't :(
@@candyforexo3214 he said it in korean
This song is a hymn to life, to loss and especially to eternal love.
Lovely sentiment ❤️
That place they kept for Jonghyun that part is making me weep so bad. Breaking barriers in music.
Hrishitaa Chetia I was already tearing up and when I saw the space for Jonghyun I balled by eyes out ❤
I KNOW RIGHT. This was my first kpop band, tho I was never in the fandom this band is so close to my heart istg feels like home
lee jinki
kim jonghyun
kim kibum
choi minho
lee taemin
5HINee 💎💎💎💎💎
4:35 ‘수고했어’ (you worked hard). He really did. They all did.
Just reading this one comment made me burst into tears... I miss Jonghyun so much and I'm so happy that shinee are continuing on making music they love... he did so well...
Lydia130613 Oh, thank you for pointing this out... The song and the lyrics are so beautiful and meaningful I’m literally choking... 😢
Lee Jinki
Kim Jonghyun
Kim Kibum
Choi Minho
Lee Taemin
SHINee💎💎💎💎💎
If you ever get sad just remember the world is 4.543 billion years old and somehow you managed to exist the same time as SHINee.
You did well.
That's so beautiful, thank you :')
thank you for your comment
Four angels singing to an angel we all miss ♡
Rhiannon Edwards I'm not even a shinee fan and im holding back tears. Im so sorry you all had to go through that. I cant even imagine what it must have been like.
thisisme aw thank you so much this comment made me tear up! it's getting better little by little but in moments like this, it still hurts. thanks for supporting them, and shawols ♡
이진기 Vocalist of the nation
김종현 Angel of the nation
김기범 Nation stylist
최민호 Nation Rapper
이태민 Nation dancer
샤이니 Nation Group
샤이니 월드 Nation Fandom
Does anyone agree?
♥️
NOBODY CAN DISAGREE. periodt T^T shinee im so proud of you
I agree with you on this
One more Visual of the nation 😀
I greee
문득 그런 생각이 들었어
책을 계속 읽으려면 다음 책장으로 넘어가야 하잖아. 금기어 처럼 말을 하지 못했던 분위기여서 한동안 참 마음이 아팠는데 이제는 그 시기를 잘 지나온 것 같아. 추억을 같이 나누고 공유할 수 있는 시기가 페이지를 채우는 것 처럼 자연스럽게 찾아왔으면 좋겠다. 보고싶고 수고했어