The Anti-zionist Jews of Jerusalem 5/5
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Yoel is a member of the extreme anti-zionist jewish organisation Neturei karta.
And Israel is a member of a more liberal hasidic sect
The film revolves around their lives and shows the difficulties and conflict that arrives from living as a haredi jew in Israel
As an Arab Muslim, I love a true believer. Only a true believer can see FAITH in another's true believer's eyes. They are my Jewish brothers and sisters, there's no doubt that Israel will be a wonderful light among the nations with this people. May ALLAH bless them.
Jorge Naya Ramadan Mubarak
Yes true .... No matter what they are as long as we believe in one God and want to obey him...it was very calming and stress-free to see youshel family if Iam not wrong about his name! Anyway God bless all who praise God
i think you missed the picture, not everyone in Israel is good like them
I watched the full documentary.
I love how these Jews are true followers of the Judaism. (It is almost impossible being practicing to such an extent in the modern times; it needs great determination and sacrifice).
I was overwhelmed by their unshakable faith in God.
Being a Muslim I would say that we are also waiting for the Messiah.
So are the Jews and Christians.
Knowing more and more about the Haredim (Ultra Orthodox) Jews, now I feel like only the Zionists are waiting for the False Messiah the anti-Christ.
I believe that the true believers of all the three Abrahamic Religions will unite as brothers under the true Messiah and bring peace and harmony in the world.
God accept all your sacrifices and may also make us firm on the TRUE PATH. Amen
sounds right to me
This is such a strange documentary to me. I never knew such Jewish people existed. Neighborhoods of these Neturei Karta, the Yoel people who see Zionism much like the Oathkeepers in the US see present day US senators & government. Simply amazing. Hmmm...
As a Muslim I must give my up most respect. I never heard of such people but take my hat off to anyone that oppose Zionism may peace be with you. From a Muslim brother I offer my hand of friendship in your struggle.
I say this as someone from a christian background and that is real relgious people whether jewish, muslim christian etc know as well about what these "values" are about.
Well you're wrong. They are zionists. They just believe that if all Jews become more religious then by divine hand God will give all the Jews Israel. They believe this won't happen based on politics and (what they perceive to be) a secular state.
🤮🤮🤮🤮
thank you for posting this thoroughly enjoyable documentary - i just wish we could catch up with them again - Yoel is a seriously funny chap - very subtle humour i thought - still laughing about the quiet introduction to his cows..Israel following that dude in his car was priceless as well, he he he - more!!!
Wow the wife looks so vibrant and young. She has had her 9th child and she looks like she has not had one.
Maybe a better use of energy than getting through 2 dozen sexual partners and 100k litres of vodka.
Well, it might be because orthodox marry young and pop out kids like a vending machine..
she looks prematurely aged, to me. the poor teeth are due to poor nutrition in pregnancy
@@susanb4816 🤔
This is old, now he has some 19 children
Really😳
Very well done. I really enjoyed this. I would like to see more
Yes, it was very informative. Is your wife Jewish...lovely couple.
@@tijuanaamatullah8945 why would I marry a non Jew?
Mea Shearim was established in 1874 by Jews. Since it was established, it has been an ultra-Orthodox Jewish neighbourhood.
I love very much Yoel's family , they look like Muslims in some things, I'm Muslim and I wish them a happy life
azary abdullah there is a follow up where Joel was facing jail time for some tax issues and they were on their 15th or 16th kid
interesting to see the life of such a *family*. yet. i only saw elder men of them
Im Chistian, Im American and i support Peace. No to the ocupation.
Open Your Mind Peace Maker Can you said NO TO TERRORISTS NO TO ISLAMIC FUNDAMENTALIST?????.
Yurit Cardenas Can you say No to Zionist terrorism??? Same problem. Jews and Muslims basically getting along anywhere extremists are not. Understand? They didn't need phosphorus and bombs to do God's work. Zionists biggest enemy of Torah
Great familj, what a Nice People they are. true bliver,
I enjoyed this very much. You always gain knowledge of another groups perspective by viewing their sincerity in a cause. I learned things I never realized about their strong views. So what I got from this documentary is, they view the Israeli government's agenda as dismantling the Israelites religion.
That milking shed is disgusting, it would be shut down in any decent country
I like this mans actions and thoughts of life and his way of living as a provider its all good. Peace.
Have you ever heard of the Christian Amish people in the US? Similar, they also call them primitive...:)
Lets together fight zionist
That's why I'm leery about moving to Israel. Too much cigarette smoke in that country. A bad habit that the Ashkenazim schlepped over from 20th century Europe. We Americans, we dumped the habit, largely, but they never did.
Thx for the decumentry.i have lernt samthing about isreal very intersting thx
The type of Jew that I'm pretty sure Jesus was. :)
Just wondering why they dont setup their own intranet? Have the content checked before its uploaded etc. They could scan their books onto it so easily cross reference, share etc. They all seem to have loads of books. Why not upload and share? They could even upload educational courses etc. Maybe recipes for the wives, mathematics for the kids etc. If its intranet they restrict what gets uploaded.. Looking from the outside in.. the poster war is pretty childish. Maybe it would be too expensive?
I'm a Buddhist. This is what I believe to be religious role models. Thank you my Jewish brothers and sisters.😊❤
3:53 WTF? I though they were enemies.
Jerusalem.. Most parts in Mea Shearim
@ShlomoHaAvinoo I know what you mean by the Hasideans. It's probable that they were the prototypes and spiritual antecedents of the Pharisees in some manner, but not as you hold it.
In any event only some scholars argue the Hasmoneans were Hasideans and that the Hasideans were Pharisees.
I'm afraid I must disagree.
Amazing film, it made me weep for the first tiime in many years.
i will give these people whatever they want. They live in deliberate poverty and deprivation to a degree i would not enjoy myself. That's some real sacrifice.
@ShlomoHaAvinoo Lastly... Shim`on the Sadiq was a Kohen Gadol in office anywhere from the mid 3rd to early 2nd century BCE which means he couldn't have been a student of `Ezra haSofer who lived in the 5th century. And I don't exactly see any secular scholars concurring that Yose ben Yo`ezer was a Hasmonean. Even if Yose was, doesn't mean all other Hasmoneans were Pharisaic or even Hasidean. But you can't notice this pesky problem as you have a shoddy concept of logic.
@danapointg in some sense yes. they basically reject everything a normal person enjoys.
yes. but what i can respect them for despite my disagreement with their fundamentalism - they don't kill or break other commandments.
God bless Yoel and may Allah grant him paradise.
-from a muslim brother
@qigong1001 2/2 in this, you are arguing the wrong point. You believe that all types of history -even non-jewish, is fake, because Ocards implies that stories that are over 2000 yrs old are goofy, in any sense. I am not arguing that jews built the pyramids. I believe egyptians built em, but since they are over 2000 yrs, Ocards would believe it is a bogus story, as you support. If you do not support that statement, then by arguing me, you are still taking that position.
Im sorry Idont think I explain the idea completly, jews belive in the world to come, a world that depends on your acts in this world , and theres a sistem of reward andpunishment , so jews dont encourage non jews to convert, its much easier to get it right if you have seven comendments than if you have 600 plus,,,I was just trying to say that being a jew is not easy, it comes with lots of hardship...just that..sorry if i made you upset in anyway,I was just interested in your opinion..bye
You think because you are Jewsish and have 613 you are more righteous than the the person next to you?That way of thinking is very patronising , hollow and not righteous.But if makes you feel better that you think you have a superior relationship to God cause of your 613,,than all i can say is you havnt understood his message! p.s Pretty sure God would say it himself " why say 100 words when 1 will do,'
@emencz obviously you do not know history. You never read what the maccabees wrote: namely the book of maccabees. You never read Judah's battle speeches. And you do not know the names of Judah;s generals (they were Helenists!) Never once did the Hashmoneans fight "greek" culture. In fact Judaism assimilated it in the form of the yeshiva and separation between the sexes. Also you are ignorant of what happened AFTER the rededication of the temple (hint: the war intensified.)
@mikelunz He said "jews didn't build the pyramids." Not whether they exist. And instead of arguing that point, you attacked him for NOT BELIEVING THE PYRAMIDS EXIST. Your own quote reads: "YOU TELL ME THE PYRAMIDS ARE NOT REAL"? Let me repeat your own comment: "YOU TELL ME THE PYRAMIDS ARE NOT REAL". One more time: "YOU TELL ME THE PYRAMIDS ARE NOT REAL" If you are not clouded, then you are dishonestly misrepresenting his position. Be a man and apologize to him. Thanks.
@qigong1001 3/3 The pyramids were built by egyptians over 2000 years ago. Ocards questions believing in story's that are over 2000 years. If the pyramids were built by the egyptians over 2000 years ago, then Ocards believes that it is a questionable story: - That is the argument, in complete Modus Ponens. You cannot argue it as being my clouded mind, as it is the correct academic approach to the argument. If you are intelligent, then defeat me with a truth table. We will leave it to Legality.
@mikelunz OcardsO said: "jews didn't build the pyramids." And he is correct. He did not say "the pyramids did not exist. Put away your ideological biases. Its clouding your ability to read others comments. There exists plenty of archaeological papers that discuss the real history of the pyramids with actual documents from that time period.
About the jews who dont follow the lawsof the Tora they didnt learned at home how to be a jew. Somewhere over the rainbow they left the jewish lifestyle of their forefathers but there a many Baalei Tshuva, secular jews who go back to their Tora!
Honey jews dont want non jews to convert , exacly because of the 613 miztvot, why put i
your self in such a stress you have 7 mitzvot from noach...to exchange 7 easy ones for 613 not always easy ones you need lots of determination and study ...
AHH justone more thing,jews dont want people toconvert to their religion, they never ever do. THats against the religion, but if anon jew wants to convert he can do it. But because he wants , noone is gonna ask him to.
thats very funny what you said because theres no "cult" in eastern europe. Christianity is main religion in that part of europe, but I guess that everything that is not judaism is not a religion to you haha.
@MegaPkdos they do not represent the jewish people at all. if so than why is the greatest concentration od jews is in israel?? why their are haredim that serve in the idf?? why do haredim abroad support israel??
I like Orthodox Jews.
how funny. just europeans. their costumes, women'sscarfs, all of them are fairly 19th century european style seen in many 19th century paintings.
depressing
in the place where Israel is there was Palestyna. What zionists did to the Palestinian people was almost the same what nazist did to jews.
Beautiful people ❤️
Interesting, I'm a Christian with Celtic roots, Iberian and I feel a strong connection to this people. I wished they were more open to the outside world(not to change their ways) but so we could meet them.
Why do they print up posters saying to remove the cell phone towers when they're using cellphones for themselves? Someone needs to tell these people how the mobile phone system works.
Thank you for sharing their lives. it was great to know them! Rachel is very a sweet woman and the kids lovely!
5:50 it was strange when she stopped mid sentence because he husband walked in. She clammed up and acted nervous....I wonder why.
is it forbidden to breathe?
I'd say that Hitler saw the Jews as an economical threat to Germany. They were powerful and Germany was going through a crisis, so they blame it on the Jews. Not sure what that "hunger" for the fruits was about, maybe something symbolic, or sacred that all want to get a piece, as in a blessing. They reminded me of my family,the elders, back in the village when I was a kid, all the food preparations, home made bread, many other things. Amazing the common humanity we can feel towards strangers. :)
This was very interesting, thanks for uploading.
What an interesting look into a basic split between two anti-Zionist groups of Hassidim. I met some anti-Zionist elders living in Mexico City in 1961 and before that I didn't know
there were any anti-Zionists. These people know how to do non violent direct action and they are really good at it. In Honolulu I went to a demonstration with Hawaiians seeking
to prevent the bulldozers from digging up the bones of ancestors in order to build a shopping center. This is the same thing. And in the first film one of them indicates that he
would rather live under muslim rule than Zionist rule. So fascinating. Thank you.
amazing documentary ,,loved it ...
Thanks for the videos. However, I would like to make some modest observations. First thing. I've seen a lot of 'ultra-Orthodox' movies, some set in New York and some in London, I'm talking about the Satmar. Not for the people but for the environments, I preferred these to those of Jerusalem. There is a calmer atmosphere and the city is tidier. Second thing. I have the impression that the little things of everyday life, cigarettes in the very young and also during work in adults, hair dyeing even for girls, for example, things that are of little value for me, things seen only in Jerusalem, are one of the ways to slowly weaken the identity of the ultra-Orthodox and the Orthodox, as well as harm all human beings. Last observation. I believe that every human being should also work in nature. City life alone is not good for us.
Dental work!!
ישראל אני ראיתי מהתחלה שהוא ואשתו והבת שלו בעוונותיו הרבים לא אנשי אמת,מה זה הוא מרשה לבת שלו להראות כמו דוגמנית בפורים ואשתו עם פאה מתיפיפת,,לעומת זאת יואל עניו אשתו צנועה הילדים צנועים וישראל מלכלך עליהםץץאין לו חלק לעלם הבא לפי ראות עני הוציא שם רע על יהודים יותר טובים ממנו
Once again we can see another proof that religion has devastating effect on human spirit. Especially when human spirit is still free in children. Thats why spirituality can never harm u and never locks u because it doesnt require common acceptance. Anyway people rather fell into this mess for the same reason over and over: to be free. Unfortunately exactly the opposite happens but they rather stay blind to not see it.
@ShlomoHaAvinoo I'm not quite Qaraite *but* ur propaganda with which I'm well familiar is for naught and I've actually refuted it more times than I care to remember. U've fallen for claims u haven't duly scrutinized yet. Devarim 17 orders no such thing *except* when u get it fed thru a Rabbinic prism (taken out of context+ heavily doctored and thus divorced from the straightforward meaning). Your Chain has some chronological (& at least 1 geographical) holes in it which betray its fabrication.
@ShlomoHaAvinoo Rambam didn't receive word from YHWH, so I'm not exactly interested in his opinion on this matter. Secondly, your Orthodox friends insist at least the Mishna+Gemara (or only the Mishna) are the Oral Law while many others of them include subsequent volumes like Shulhan `Arukh and even the Qabbala books under this category. When you folks make up your minds I'll sit up and take notice if this is determined authoritatively and all Orthos concir in unison.
Yoel tem uma família linda e filhos preciosos. Me corta o coração pensar que um dia vão obrigá-los a servir ao exército mais cruel da face da terra!
They won't. The orthodox jews don't join the army.
@@davidwhite4874 why don't they? Didn't King David have a military.
@@ej1722 They feel young men should be studying the Torah only.
@@davidwhite4874 is that in Tanach? Did ancient Israelites have Torah schools? And did Tanach have exempt from military service because of Torah school? I'm very curious.
@@ej1722 That's the way the ultra orthodox Jews feel today. I have no idea what they felt about the subject in past millennia. Ask them.
watertownrivers -
Were cigarettes prominent then? I thought the tobacco leaf was a native american plant.
I suppose it's yes or no about tampons and their use too.
Or Motorbikes. Or rollerblades. Or crochet hooks.
Anyway, we are to treat our bodies as temples - that's what I read.
Paul said to drink red wine every day. ^_^
@TheLordIdanZiegeL
maybe because its in jerusalem?
and we know,
i wish that they represented all jews.
at least these ones think..
unlike that zionist state you've built on my land
@ShlomoHaAvinoo It's more preferable if they'd destroy Me`a She`arim and obliterate the local NK and Satmar populuses therein.
Those two families in the film are beautiful! 💗💗
If you are anti-Zionist, and you are Jewish, why are you in Jerusalem? I would just like to hear a sensible answer.
It is easy. One of most sensible reasons is they, their parents and grand parents were born there.
They are in Israel because God himself called them to be their!
They are against the the Zionist state not against Jews living in Jerusalem.
They were already living there before the zionists created the State of Israel. They live in the old part of Jerusalem, where their families have lived for hundreds of years. They did not go in the diaspora. They miss a Jerusalem where Jews, Muslims and Christians could live in harmony, for hundreds of years, before Zionists decided to create an artificial country against God's will. Israel could only be created when the Mesiah comes.
They are oldest settlers around Jerusalem, Jaffa and Tiberias after Zionist terrorist groups throw them out of their cities like they did to Arabs in Hebron. Safed was wiped out of Haredim by Haganah. Neturei Karta is one the oldest organizations protecting the Old Settlements they are a government themselves lol.
@timcp1 Being that you believe in JC I invariably disagree with what you've argued but this time I echo your statements.
@qigong1001 I am pretty sure that I know that the Jews did not build the pyramids. You are misunderstanding what I am saying. I am saying that if our history books tell us stories of beyond 2000 years, such as the pyramids, or even the Pythagorean theorem. In this instance, 0cards said: its 2011 and People still believe in stories from 2000 years ago. Even you said that: there are archaeological papers that discuss the real history of the pyramids. You proved my point, you believe in stories.
oh the irony! Hanukah was how Jews won independence through force of arms. Even when the Greeks stopped the anti Jewish legislation after the death of Antiochus the Maccabee continued to fight for independence. When the Jews returned to the temple, the war only intensified. And yes, the Greeks killed Jews for being Jewish people and not for their religion as can be attested by attle of Bet Emmaus and the murders of Dathema and other massacres. Read the book of Maccabees
@ZviJ1 cannabis is the messiah the Jews are waiting for,the plant of renownEz.34:29 the memorialised plant of EX.25:31-40,the men-owrah...".and the jews had OWRAH joy and gladness. " Est.8:16, " the oil of gladness"Prov.45:7.the restoration of Elijah is cannabis amnesty!! Machabee
I didn't understand the ending. They were shaking hands and jokin. Wtf?
So what about if the "born" Jew doesn't follow traditionally those traditions and "expectations"? How come you're considered always a "Jew" but someone who may seek to be one, is so unwelcome? Wasn't this the reason why Gog chose the Jews in the first place? To share, and bring the people, humanity to Him...Elohim???
For the question about who wrote the torah and atc...you could go here simpletoremember.comand look for audio video RAbbi Kelemen A rational aproach tothe divine origin of Torah. He s a great speaker! Good luck!
Im only speculating on another persons reason and thoughts,could be both but it could also be that he saw a minority being succesful in a foreign land while his fellow germans struggled with everyday life in their own country??
Maccabees
There is a strong sense in which Rachel is right, NK for all their many faults and crippling problems, are more like the Maccabees than secular Israelis, if a Maccabee would suddenly appear from the graves who do you think he'd identify with more buddhist Ben Gurion or Yoel and Israel?
What a contradiction!' a non-jew can convert but on the other hand jews dont want people to convert,they never do', And what do you think thy Lord would think of that statement???
@qigong1001 #2 further more, you are saying that since I believe that the pyramids are ancient, and that I believe that they are over 2000 years old, then I have an ideological bias clouding my ability to read others comments?
i support their causes, but they look so dirty. Their homes are a mess their beards and clothing look so frumpy. Cleanliness is next to Godliness so they should tidy up a bit!
I Don't know much about these People But Thanks for Posting,It was very interesting."I still don't know what they believe in when they say Torah or Talmud etc is that like the Old Testament Prophets? Books Like Moses & Amos,Zechariah etc...?
Hello (: I am a Jew I have a good experiences and good memories when the Irish came to Tel Aviv for a football match between
Israeli team and Irish team, we sat with them together in a pub and they taught us how to dance Irish dance and they introduced my first Guinness (;, I bought them beer from Israel (Goldstar) It was fun was a good party , that part of a whole day's events,yes good memories
@ShlomoHaAvinoo i had no chois)you have israeli name to tho, dont wory relegens wont last for long time if science will do hes job good
They don't know where that tape is going. - Who has the agenda to film, etc.
When I see them I like them because they are living like real Jews
The man is truly deranged, I fear for his children
Oi mina! Entao a religiao judaica echeia de leis. Um judeu sempre sera um judeu e um gentil que quer se transformar em judeu tem essa possibilidade desde que passe o processo de converssao. Parte do processo da converssao e dizer a esta pessoa algumas vezes que emlehor
que e melhor que ele nao se converta. Para saber se seus motivos sao sinceros se o que esta pessoa quer e ser parte do povo de Israel por um motivo legitimo. Como exemplo um nao judeu nao pode se converter por querer se casar com um judeu..e etc..
are these people on a mission to make themselves look as unattractive as possible?
Creepy creepy ppl, creepy looks, creepy beliefs, creepy practices, basically the creepiest of creeps, the creepmeisters
"oy vey, I was never issued I.D." That dudes definitely wanted for some serious shit.
Some serious sht = having different beliefs
those "farming" operations are an insult to creation
Thank you for uploading this documentary. Do you know where I might find this with subtitles in English, please? Thank you. :)
May G-d takes care of these Ytsé Rara! Treaters ! >_
Your people? What are you doing on TH-cam then???
(: ! peace and one human family? About it I say Amen
and i enjoyed it...nooo didn't want it to finish!
Hej,
I think, they were speaking Yiddish between eachother. cuz when there was a lady who came to buy eggs. I could nearly understand them due to similarty between german and yiddish.
Yes and in the end she said gute nacht. So sometimes I hear german world.