@@eve123princess9 this will be insanely funny if Bright Guardian Akira is right about Duskfur being behind the conspiracy to get rid of Curlfeather and Reedwhisker.
Incorrect. Shadowsight is also a dependent. Shadowsight(I think) is dovewings kit, dovwing I'd whitewing an birchfalls kit, birchfalls mother is ferncloud, who's father is whitestorm, who's mother is snowfur who is bluestars sister
@@PIGEONS_AndAXOLOTLSa descendant is someone born in a direct biological line eg kids, grandkids, greatgrand kids and just keep tacking on greats, whitestorm was her nephew so he wasn’t even her descendant
Maybe the next talking can be about Snowfur? Everyone loves chatting about how Bluestar handled her grief and how her relationships were strained with others, but I remember her sister was described with having lots of connections. She was always a favorite of mine :)
she's also often interpreted by fans as tethering Thistleclaw, when it's more likely (based both on her in-book behavior and on real life situations) that had she lived, he would've made her worse. remember how furious she was at the mere thought of bluefur liking a riverclan cat? or how simply driving the shadowclan cats off their territory wasn't enough, she needed a fight?
@@thecupidintraining I fell into this trap, but now I'm glad I understand just how fiery Snowfur was. Moonkitti really should make a video on her to clear the misinterpretation for a wider audience.
Yeah people like to interpret Snowfur as a soft motherly cat, when in reality she is very much a warrior. She argues with Bluefur constantly, she's not afraid to speak her mind. She wastes no time in battles and is a fierce fighter. She literally dies because she is so busy having the time of her life antagonising ShadowClan that she doesn't notice the car heading her way.
@@fanpet3912 Yeah. It's been YEARS since I've read Bluestar's Prophecy and I'm not really into reading it again, but I faintly remember not liking her much (not hating her, but not appreciating her either) so I always find it weird when people see her as this sweet, motherly cat.
I’m requesting for a Barley mini-talk because he was born in BloodClan and broke one of Scourges rules by still talking to one of his siblings Violet (in which she gets attacked by Ice and Snake) •Looked after RavenPaw when he left ThunderClan •He assisted LionClan during the battle against BloodClan, and aided in dealing with the leftover members, including Ice and Snake. •Plays a major part in RavenPaws Farewell
He’s in Greystripe’s Vow as well! I think he might actually be the oldest character in the books if not tied with Mistystar, a character who has NINE LIVES
I would really enjoy a video about Ashfoot she’s extremely underrated. I think she’s just a nice cat in general. She struggled as deputy after being named one. She was also Crowfeathers mother. After her death Ashfoot kept on visiting Crowfeather saying she couldn’t go to starclan until he’s happy. And it would be nice to hear your opinion on her. :)
I know right? It's such a shame too. We could be discussing more about Reedwhisker being a minor character and bringing up interesting things like how he could've been more relevant so and so, but it's mostly just people talking about characters they want to see. And whoever's chosen next will have comments like that as well. I'm not adding much onto the comment section in regards to Reedwhisker either, but still.
And she isn’t even taking suggestions from the comments in the mini talks, so it’s kinda annoying when the comments are all ppl randomly throwing in characters without actually discussing the video
@@justarandomperson6240 maybe we should suggest a google form in which suggestions can be made for next videos? That would clean up the comment section mostly
@@billcipher8645 that could definitely work for cleaning up the comments but I’m guessing it’s just easier to take the top most liked comment. Another thing that would be kinda interesting though is if Moon randomly picked a character from a hat, so it would be totally unexpected and it would give characters that would Never get top comment a chance to shine. But, in the end, it’s Moon’s choice for what she wants to do. It just seems like a fun little series and not anything too serious yk?
could you talk about twigbranch? i think the way the authors set her up for actually not having kits was interesting becaude usually every mainstream she-cat gets one after their arc
You should do a video on Leafstar. She’s probably the most decent leader around the lake, and the way she runs her clan is a real breath of fresh air from the other leaders. And it would be nice to know what you’d think will happen to her in the future as it seems she’s gonna be getting more spotlight since AVOS and Squirrelflights Hope.
I’d love to hear you talk about Ravenpaw. I never got the chance to read the manga about him, but his moments of assisting anyone who showed up to his barn were always my favorite- And you BET I cried like a baby during Ravenpaw’s Farewell. He and Barely were the sweetest duo
I think you should talk about hawkfrost, for being a popular character he has quite a bit of missed potential, we don’t see him think about the situation he’s in we just see him being evil. Plus a lot of his missed potential has a lot to do with the books just wanting bramble to look like the good guy
I think that you should do a talking video on Shellheart. He's only really mentioned or talked about when people bring up Crookedstar. I find him interesting tho, Shellheart defended his son from Rainflower when she said she wanted Stormkit to be renamed after his injury. He was also Oakheart's mentor on request of Rainflower too. Both of these things ended up happening, the renaming and mentorship, because of Rainflower. I think that it's important to note that as the deputy of RiverClan at the time, I think that he would've had a bit more control over the situations but he didn't. Personally I see Shellheart as another victim of Rain's abuse and had a leader, Hailstar, who didn't seem to object in anyway and just went along with whatever she said.
i feel like reedwhisker is one of those blank slate characters who's interesting to people more because of who he's related to than anything he actually did there are a lot of riverclan cats who feel like that to me like mosspelt who was mentioned as feathertail and stormfur's foster mother after silverstream's death but we dont see all that much of her so headcannon fills in what could be interesting about her
I would love to hear you talk about CrookedStar. He is one of my favourite cats, I adore his relationship with Oakheart and Silverstream. He's such an interesting character too, getting over his mother's lack of affection, Mapleshade and the tragedy that surrounded him.
I like to think that Reedwhisker has some flaws - such as he’s impulsive, like when he takes Hollypaw to RiverClan, etc. But he values being deputy so much he’s sometimes able to overcome his impulsiveness, only he has to shut himself off and be extremely professional to do so!
you should talk about tigerheartstar i think. he lowkey colonized riverclan in the latest book and i think him doing that whilst insisting he's not like tigerclawstar could be interesting!
Just a lil suggestion but maybe talk about Greywing (Dawn of the clans). I liked him but there were times my thoughts about him became conflicted. His story was interesting.
I predict Reedwhisker was killed by a WindClan warrior. The reason is near the end of Shadow, Frostpaw is attacked by something that smells of WindClan. It is very likely that this cat was the killer of Reedwhisker. Hope my prediction is correct! Also, who do you guys think will become the next RiverClan leader? Put your thoughts in the replies!
I still wonder what happened to Primrosepaw bc she suddenly died without any questioning or confirmation of her death?? It’s like everyone just forgot about her 💀
Hey, can we do a talk about my son White'Throat? He's such a lil man who deserves some love, and I think him and Little'Cloud's relationship are interesting
I'd like to request hollyleaf. It's kinda annoying to me how they brought her back and barely really gave her a personality anymore. It felt empty and I didn't really react when she died because of it.
I'd like to see you talk about Goldenflower, she's one of the original queens and I think she's an interesting character overall. I feel like she's underappreciated in Warriors and by the fandom. I wish we got to know more about her relationship with Tigerstar, Brambleclaw, and Tawnypelt.
Another ing about her that none of the books mention other then bluestars prohicey is her brother is lion heart so it’s sad when we dont se her mourn her bother when he dies
@@Littlemoon1221 I totally forgot about that! Yeah, I wish they mentioned something about it. She and Lionheart have kind of a cute dynamic in that book.
You should definitely do Crookedstar! His character arc is so interesting and his relationship with his family and friends is entertaining. Having lived through so many generations and hardships, and dealing with Mapleshade his WHOLE LIFE, and his pressure to “make Rainflower proud of him” and how he felt pressured to keep his promise to Mapleshade. The sacrifices he made over a tiny promise impacted his life beyond his jaw injury, and his character is so interesting and there’s so much to talk about him!
You should talk about Cinnamontail. I hardly know her but once when I was younger I saw her name in the allegiances of one of the books and went ‘omg i love that cat’ and Ive never forgotten about her, despite her not being important in the slightest
@@Sheedystar_the_cat what really? Wow Ive gotta get to reading those books, my girl cinnamontail out here getting plot relevance I knew she had it in her
Tbh, im still stuck on featherwhisker being the next cat to be talked about :0 Hes very outshined between his mentor and his apprentice and even his brother I want to see more characterization with him, how he couldve felt taking care of goosefeather and how he grieved when his brother died Then again, he wasn’t very explored enough and he was just seen as a boring medicine cat
Can you maybe do Moonflower? Her character arc kinda just gets brushed off in the books as she taken advantage by Stormtail. Sunstar also had feelings for her, although Moonflower had only feelings towards Stormtail. I feel like Stormtail just...doesn't care about her, completely ignores her existence as he chases after Dappletail. She was a great mother to Bluestar and Snowfur, and it's just sad how her 'mate' ends up treating her.
I don't know much about Reedwhisker but the comic at the back of Leopardstar's super edition is just so sweet. He's so sad his mother got kidnapped and he's so happy when she returns.
I feel like there was a lot of missed potential with Reedwhisker, particularly in the second arc. I think it would have been interesting if he had been written to be Hawkfrost's apprentice, and became torn in the dilemma where there's a fight whether Hawkfrost, who became deputy in Mistyfoot's absence, or Mistyfoot, who was deputy before she got captured, should be deputy
Reedwhisker is way too much of a background character, he could’ve had such things going for him. Being one of BlueStar’s kin, he could’ve had some moments with BlueStar, or he could’ve become a secondary character in Mistystar’s súper editions.
I’d enjoy a talk about Mousewhisker, he’s the oldest of Daisy’s kin and the only one to not be dead. Plus, there’s a few odd moments where you could easily buy he was seeing Minnowtail; such as her being suspiciously good at climbing trees or him talking about fish that one time.
Reedwisker became one of my favorite cats over the course of the series, what they did to him was just plain dirty. I waited for so long to see him become leader and they just kill him?! He was way to smart to just wonder off alone and die
I’d love it if you talked about Snowfur! A large part of the fandom sees her as the ‘soft uwu Thistleclaw wife’ when in reality she’s an absolute girlboss. In Bluestar’s Prophecy, she’s very feisty and loud and always ready to fight. She was super social and got over Moonflower’s death rather quickly versus her sister. She died chasing THREE ShadowClan warriors off her territory after beating them with just Bluefur. She was always my favorite character for her spunk and attitude, and it reeeeaaaaally irks me to see her largely reduced to exactly what we all hate; a generic bg queen, or some guy’s wife.
Shattered ice I think would be a cool cat to have a mini-talk on, he was introduced in DotC, and we see a nice scene with him and Thunder he becomes I think 1 of 2 cats to go to riverclan, than in Tallstar's revenge it says he was wc when he was rc, and the story does affect a little about Tallstars behavior in tunnelingbright before it was take away, and we 1st hear his story in the 1st few pages, so I think Shatteredice would be a good cat to talk about.
Maybe you could do a talking on one of Frostfur’s kits: Bracken, Cinder, Bright and Thorn. Cinder and Bright got more attention than their brothers. They also had a really good relationship. The Erins probably forgot that they were even related. But it’s just so sweet with how Cinder taught Bright some herbs and medicine cat skills when Cloudtail was off with Daisy and Cinder kinda comforted her in a why. Cinder and Bright would be really cool for a talking video!!
I think you should talk about Sandgorse. He kinda disowned his son and tried to guilt him in to being a tunnler-Sandgorse played a big role in Tallstar ‘s life.
I think Mothwing is going to become leader of RC. Maybe make a video about that exploring this possibility and her bad or good qualities as a leader? To me it felt like the books are leading up to that
Could you do a video about Thrushpelt? He is quite different to other toms who have not had their feelings reciprocated (ex. ashfur, bumblestripe) and it’d be interesting to hear what you have to say!
I shall request a mini-talking for Stormfur, in my opinion, he's a good well-written character whos had alot going on in his life, he has adapted to 3 different places(The tribe, Thunderclan, and Riverclan), has been "dead" to the tribe, and etc. In all I think that would be a really good video. :)
You should do Mothwing next. Or her mother Sasha. (I always find it weird how Sasha just showed up before the clans left), there's certainly a lot to talk about with either of these two
Hey moon! I’ve been a fan for many years 🥹 your videos always make me smile and think about warrior cats super fondly. Ever since the age of 8 I was a diehard squirrelflight (and she cat in general) fan and remember arguing with many fans (way too young) online who didn’t like her lol! It’s awesome to see someone also love her so much, I remember when she was hated. I feel like she cats in general have gotten more love as the fandom matured-and that’s really awesome to see! Hope you’re doing well❤ thanks for making videos
I like to think that Reedwhisker was from Mistystar‘s secret second litter of kits, and he was the only one that survived. (Just to give some explanation for why he is a literal child at like 36 years old or something)
Trying to shoot my shot 14 hours in. I suggest my favourite character Feathertail, a vast majority of people may glare at me and state she has no character and I only like her as she’s pretty and a Riverclan prophecy cat… well yes… BUT! For those who say she has no personality I present my favourite book, A shadow in Riverclan, I feel like they could’ve added a bit more ptsd but there’s some fernxfeather and Sashaxfeather stuff in there. It also just adds heaps more character development and gives her well deserved anger, although I wish she hadn’t’t just randomly forgiven leopardstar out of now-where so the book could end. Love the art too.
I’d like to request a mini talk on Doestar! She was the leader before pinestar. Honestly this is more of a request for a discussion on pre-bluestar thunderclan. You mentioned how harsh it was and I agree!!! I’d love to hear your thoughts.
I really wanna see a talking video of Speckletail. She lost 3 of her kits(Mistlekit,Lionheart and Snowkit) and she lost her mate(I’m pretty sure it’s Smallear). I find her really interesting too!
Crookedstar? I don’t rlly have a reason for it, actually, I just think he experienced a lot, being manipulated by mapleshade and all. He also suffered quite a lot, his jaw being permanently disfigured, feeling he's required to leave his clan as 'just a burden', losing his mate and most of his kits- he has a relatively action-packed book, and I feel like you could take advantage of that!
This is probably isnt gonna be seen, but can you talk about tallstar? He had a great super edition and had a good character arc (in my opinion) and he had that relationship with jake. Pls talk about tallstar, he’s my fav guy :3
nightstar needs a video. mostly for being the only relatively competent shadowclan leader in the main timeline of the books (excluding dawn of the clans or any character from the guide books.) i mean you got to give him credit he was able to lead a clan that lost most of its abled warriors, was able to convince enemies to reunite against a common foe, and was able to do all of this while unable to be recognized as a leader in starclan. in the end his leadership was wrecked by tragedies and challenges that only the only leader equivalent failed to even manage (rowanstar), and you could also argue that nightstar had it worse.
I’d love to hear about Thrushpelt! He was an average warrior who took care of Bluestars kits but somehow did not notice when they ended up in Riverclan books later at a gathering?? He also is brothers with Thistleclaw and the mentor of Spottedleaf (if we’re still going with Spottedleaf’s Heart being canon) and this is super WEIRD. You're telling me he’s related to Thistleclaw and somehow didn't advise his own apprentice to stay away from him? I just think he's a really sweet lad who deserves to be spoken about due to the writing doing him major injustice. (´ｰ｀)
JUNIPERCLAW!! stop im so obsessed with his character he is one of the best side characters his backstory is sooo interesting i beg. if my friends see this you're unsurprised im sorry the rot has consumed me
You know as much as Mistystar’s character deteriorated over the years, you gotta admit she actually remained a pretty decent mom to Reedwhisker.
Waiting for the Erins to realize that Reedwhisker was the last descendant of Bluestar so they can retcon a small child to be his child
Hopefully they will make Duskfur Reedwhisker’s mate and Curlfeather and Podlight his kids.
@@eve123princess9 this will be insanely funny if Bright Guardian Akira is right about Duskfur being behind the conspiracy to get rid of Curlfeather and Reedwhisker.
Incorrect. Shadowsight is also a dependent. Shadowsight(I think) is dovewings kit, dovwing I'd whitewing an birchfalls kit, birchfalls mother is ferncloud, who's father is whitestorm, who's mother is snowfur who is bluestars sister
Descendant*
@@PIGEONS_AndAXOLOTLSa descendant is someone born in a direct biological line eg kids, grandkids, greatgrand kids and just keep tacking on greats, whitestorm was her nephew so he wasn’t even her descendant
RIP in peace, Reedwhisker. You sure were alive for a while and then you weren't anymore.
Maybe the next talking can be about Snowfur? Everyone loves chatting about how Bluestar handled her grief and how her relationships were strained with others, but I remember her sister was described with having lots of connections. She was always a favorite of mine :)
she's also often interpreted by fans as tethering Thistleclaw, when it's more likely (based both on her in-book behavior and on real life situations) that had she lived, he would've made her worse. remember how furious she was at the mere thought of bluefur liking a riverclan cat? or how simply driving the shadowclan cats off their territory wasn't enough, she needed a fight?
@@thecupidintraining I fell into this trap, but now I'm glad I understand just how fiery Snowfur was. Moonkitti really should make a video on her to clear the misinterpretation for a wider audience.
Yeah people like to interpret Snowfur as a soft motherly cat, when in reality she is very much a warrior. She argues with Bluefur constantly, she's not afraid to speak her mind. She wastes no time in battles and is a fierce fighter. She literally dies because she is so busy having the time of her life antagonising ShadowClan that she doesn't notice the car heading her way.
@@fanpet3912 Yeah. It's been YEARS since I've read Bluestar's Prophecy and I'm not really into reading it again, but I faintly remember not liking her much (not hating her, but not appreciating her either) so I always find it weird when people see her as this sweet, motherly cat.
I’m requesting for a Barley mini-talk because he was born in BloodClan and broke one of Scourges rules by still talking to one of his siblings Violet (in which she gets attacked by Ice and Snake)
•Looked after RavenPaw when he left ThunderClan
•He assisted LionClan during the battle against BloodClan, and aided in dealing with the leftover members, including Ice and Snake.
•Plays a major part in RavenPaws Farewell
I think he'd be better for a full talking video!
@@HorsesIC I agree
I love barley, so yea he defo needs a talking video!!
He’s in Greystripe’s Vow as well! I think he might actually be the oldest character in the books if not tied with Mistystar, a character who has NINE LIVES
He also helped assemble WarriorClan!
can't believe she didn't mention any of the important events from reedwhisker's renaissance
I would really enjoy a video about Ashfoot she’s extremely underrated. I think she’s just a nice cat in general. She struggled as deputy after being named one. She was also Crowfeathers mother. After her death Ashfoot kept on visiting Crowfeather saying she couldn’t go to starclan until he’s happy. And it would be nice to hear your opinion on her. :)
The fact that most of these comments are about talking videos for other cats and not a lot of things to say about Reedwhisker, says a lot.
I know right? It's such a shame too. We could be discussing more about Reedwhisker being a minor character and bringing up interesting things like how he could've been more relevant so and so, but it's mostly just people talking about characters they want to see. And whoever's chosen next will have comments like that as well. I'm not adding much onto the comment section in regards to Reedwhisker either, but still.
If he had become Reedstar, we would have so much more to talk about!
And she isn’t even taking suggestions from the comments in the mini talks, so it’s kinda annoying when the comments are all ppl randomly throwing in characters without actually discussing the video
@@justarandomperson6240 maybe we should suggest a google form in which suggestions can be made for next videos? That would clean up the comment section mostly
@@billcipher8645 that could definitely work for cleaning up the comments but I’m guessing it’s just easier to take the top most liked comment. Another thing that would be kinda interesting though is if Moon randomly picked a character from a hat, so it would be totally unexpected and it would give characters that would
Never get top comment a chance to shine. But, in the end, it’s Moon’s choice for what she wants to do. It just seems like a fun little series and not anything too serious yk?
could you talk about twigbranch? i think the way the authors set her up for actually not having kits was interesting becaude usually every mainstream she-cat gets one after their arc
You should do a video on Leafstar. She’s probably the most decent leader around the lake, and the way she runs her clan is a real breath of fresh air from the other leaders. And it would be nice to know what you’d think will happen to her in the future as it seems she’s gonna be getting more spotlight since AVOS and Squirrelflights Hope.
Yes!! Fave leader!
I’d love to hear you talk about Ravenpaw. I never got the chance to read the manga about him, but his moments of assisting anyone who showed up to his barn were always my favorite- And you BET I cried like a baby during Ravenpaw’s Farewell. He and Barely were the sweetest duo
I think you should talk about hawkfrost, for being a popular character he has quite a bit of missed potential, we don’t see him think about the situation he’s in we just see him being evil. Plus a lot of his missed potential has a lot to do with the books just wanting bramble to look like the good guy
I think that you should do a talking video on Shellheart.
He's only really mentioned or talked about when people bring up Crookedstar. I find him interesting tho, Shellheart defended his son from Rainflower when she said she wanted Stormkit to be renamed after his injury. He was also Oakheart's mentor on request of Rainflower too. Both of these things ended up happening, the renaming and mentorship, because of Rainflower. I think that it's important to note that as the deputy of RiverClan at the time, I think that he would've had a bit more control over the situations but he didn't. Personally I see Shellheart as another victim of Rain's abuse and had a leader, Hailstar, who didn't seem to object in anyway and just went along with whatever she said.
i feel like reedwhisker is one of those blank slate characters who's interesting to people more because of who he's related to than anything he actually did
there are a lot of riverclan cats who feel like that to me like mosspelt who was mentioned as feathertail and stormfur's foster mother after silverstream's death but we dont see all that much of her so headcannon fills in what could be interesting about her
I would love to hear you talk about CrookedStar. He is one of my favourite cats, I adore his relationship with Oakheart and Silverstream. He's such an interesting character too, getting over his mother's lack of affection, Mapleshade and the tragedy that surrounded him.
Well Bluestar technically has remaining descendants because her nephew, Whitestorm had kids who PROBABLY had kids who went on to have kids
I was hoping the ending was
“So yeah, that’s reedwhisker”
“He’s a cat
He’s a guy
He existed
Now he die”
Woulda been a good rhyme
You should talk about goosefeather, he has a whole novella and he's honestly amazing ,I would love to see anything on him tbh
The next cat you should talk about should be either needletail or barley they both dont get much attention and are such amazing underrated characters
i need to turn on some sort of presidential alert to go to my phone the second these videos come out so i have any hope of getting a star flower video
Always going to request my girl Brambleberry 💙
Please do Sorreltail, she’s gone through so much tragedy in her life yet still remains one of the strongest female characters in the series.
I like to think that Reedwhisker has some flaws - such as he’s impulsive, like when he takes Hollypaw to RiverClan, etc. But he values being deputy so much he’s sometimes able to overcome his impulsiveness, only he has to shut himself off and be extremely professional to do so!
I think I want a new mini-talking on Clear Sky's kit Tiny Branch or a regular talking about Lightning Tail
Requesting Turtle Tail-- You know, fRoM dAwN oF tHe ClAnS. She is lovely and underrated and absolutely should have gotten a POV in the books.
You should do crowfrost he always interested m, he is also part of the dead deputies, Also the name crowfrost just sounds amazing.
you should talk about tigerheartstar i think. he lowkey colonized riverclan in the latest book and i think him doing that whilst insisting he's not like tigerclawstar could be interesting!
Alfador my beloved, you can lay on my keyboard anytime
Just a lil suggestion but maybe talk about Greywing (Dawn of the clans). I liked him but there were times my thoughts about him became conflicted. His story was interesting.
👨⚖️All I can see is that he wears a business tie and speaks like the voice Game Grumps gave to Monica.🤖
RIP to that Bluestar dynasty
The doodle of Reedpaw drowning made me laugh LMAO "mothwing, reedpaw is drowning" "this aint about him"
what about a mini talking about shrewpaw? He had such a big personality?
I am once again asking for a Purdy episode. His character has so much overlooked potential you don't understand
Okay, for the timeline: Reedwhisker is adopted his mom lied to him. She told him he was just small for his age
I’m ngl I’m pretty sure they meant about him being the last Appledusk remnant.
I predict Reedwhisker was killed by a WindClan warrior. The reason is near the end of Shadow, Frostpaw is attacked by something that smells of WindClan. It is very likely that this cat was the killer of Reedwhisker. Hope my prediction is correct!
Also, who do you guys think will become the next RiverClan leader? Put your thoughts in the replies!
I don’t know, when will Mothwing or Frostpaw choose one?
"Im glad he didn't become leader he would have been too competent" thid js how I feel about brackenfur. He should have been deputy, not brambebutt
Would love a talk on Sagewhisker!! Or Applefur (OOTS) Cloudpelt, or Rainswept Flower
Can we get a Onestar talking? His novella talks about his regret about Smoke and Darktail, and he’s overall interesting.
Can we have a mini talking about rainwhisker?
thank you, moonkitti
Wow I can't believe moonkitti killed reedwhisker
FROZEN 2!!! FROZEN 2!!! FROZEN 2!!! FROZEN 2!!! FROZEN 2!!! FROZEN 2!!! FROZEN 2!!!
Hey it’s fine I’ll read it…….soon…….OK IM ON BOOK 1 😭
I still wonder what happened to Primrosepaw bc she suddenly died without any questioning or confirmation of her death?? It’s like everyone just forgot about her 💀
Hey, can we do a talk about my son White'Throat? He's such a lil man who deserves some love, and I think him and Little'Cloud's relationship are interesting
Wait I thought stone fur had kits with brook? Eh maybe I'm dumb
Yeah I distinctly remember them having kids as well, unless they all died or smth
Edit: We confused Stonefur and Stormfur
@@ricegorm it appears so
Can you talk about jayfeather? He's my favorite and there's a lot for him that you could do
what about podlight? ive always liked his name and he's mentioned a lot throughout the books
Mistystar did die btw
Pls talk abt berrynose my life would be complete
Could you make a animation with clan cats and climate change?
Cause there isn't much snow anymore and it could be funny :D
Gjj😊
I'd like to request hollyleaf. It's kinda annoying to me how they brought her back and barely really gave her a personality anymore. It felt empty and I didn't really react when she died because of it.
Reeeeeed
Can you do Flamepaw/Nightheart? I just want to see what your opinion is on him and how you think his character is going to roll out!
Still want to see rainflower 😶 awful mom, decent character, I still hate her 😭
I'd like to see you talk about Goldenflower, she's one of the original queens and I think she's an interesting character overall. I feel like she's underappreciated in Warriors and by the fandom. I wish we got to know more about her relationship with Tigerstar, Brambleclaw, and Tawnypelt.
Another ing about her that none of the books mention other then bluestars prohicey is her brother is lion heart so it’s sad when we dont se her mourn her bother when he dies
@@Littlemoon1221 I totally forgot about that! Yeah, I wish they mentioned something about it. She and Lionheart have kind of a cute dynamic in that book.
RIP Reedwhisker, always the bridesmaid never the bride
You should definitely do Crookedstar! His character arc is so interesting and his relationship with his family and friends is entertaining. Having lived through so many generations and hardships, and dealing with Mapleshade his WHOLE LIFE, and his pressure to “make Rainflower proud of him” and how he felt pressured to keep his promise to Mapleshade. The sacrifices he made over a tiny promise impacted his life beyond his jaw injury, and his character is so interesting and there’s so much to talk about him!
You should talk about Cinnamontail. I hardly know her but once when I was younger I saw her name in the allegiances of one of the books and went ‘omg i love that cat’ and Ive never forgotten about her, despite her not being important in the slightest
She has some what of importance in the newest book idk if you read it so I won’t say any spoilers
@@Sheedystar_the_cat what really? Wow Ive gotta get to reading those books, my girl cinnamontail out here getting plot relevance I knew she had it in her
im just saying she totally has a curly tail i do not care what canon says
Me with Curlfeather (before ASC)
I like Cinnamontail!
Tbh, im still stuck on featherwhisker being the next cat to be talked about :0
Hes very outshined between his mentor and his apprentice and even his brother
I want to see more characterization with him, how he couldve felt taking care of goosefeather and how he grieved when his brother died
Then again, he wasn’t very explored enough and he was just seen as a boring medicine cat
*“He existed and now he’s gone.”*
This is what I think about every unimportant character
Can you maybe do Moonflower? Her character arc kinda just gets brushed off in the books as she taken advantage by Stormtail. Sunstar also had feelings for her, although Moonflower had only feelings towards Stormtail. I feel like Stormtail just...doesn't care about her, completely ignores her existence as he chases after Dappletail. She was a great mother to Bluestar and Snowfur, and it's just sad how her 'mate' ends up treating her.
she done a video about stormtail where it talks about that a bit!
@@birchfalls oh i'm aware, i just wanted a more Indepth conversation around her - as that video mostly spoke about Stormtail.
I don't know much about Reedwhisker but the comic at the back of Leopardstar's super edition is just so sweet. He's so sad his mother got kidnapped and he's so happy when she returns.
I feel like there was a lot of missed potential with Reedwhisker, particularly in the second arc. I think it would have been interesting if he had been written to be Hawkfrost's apprentice, and became torn in the dilemma where there's a fight whether Hawkfrost, who became deputy in Mistyfoot's absence, or Mistyfoot, who was deputy before she got captured, should be deputy
Reedwhisker is way too much of a background character, he could’ve had such things going for him. Being one of BlueStar’s kin, he could’ve had some moments with BlueStar, or he could’ve become a secondary character in Mistystar’s súper editions.
I’d enjoy a talk about Mousewhisker, he’s the oldest of Daisy’s kin and the only one to not be dead. Plus, there’s a few odd moments where you could easily buy he was seeing Minnowtail; such as her being suspiciously good at climbing trees or him talking about fish that one time.
I like the little bits with Mistystar and Reedwisker :] they imply that they're really close to eachother and I like that. He's a mama's boy.
I think you should do Needletail. She is really interesting and is a big main character in AVOS. She's really interesting as Violetshines guardian!
Reedwisker became one of my favorite cats over the course of the series, what they did to him was just plain dirty. I waited for so long to see him become leader and they just kill him?! He was way to smart to just wonder off alone and die
Reedwhisker really was a Warrior Cat
I’d love it if you talked about Snowfur! A large part of the fandom sees her as the ‘soft uwu Thistleclaw wife’ when in reality she’s an absolute girlboss. In Bluestar’s Prophecy, she’s very feisty and loud and always ready to fight. She was super social and got over Moonflower’s death rather quickly versus her sister. She died chasing THREE ShadowClan warriors off her territory after beating them with just Bluefur. She was always my favorite character for her spunk and attitude, and it reeeeaaaaally irks me to see her largely reduced to exactly what we all hate; a generic bg queen, or some guy’s wife.
Shattered ice I think would be a cool cat to have a mini-talk on, he was introduced in DotC, and we see a nice scene with him and Thunder he becomes I think 1 of 2 cats to go to riverclan, than in Tallstar's revenge it says he was wc when he was rc, and the story does affect a little about Tallstars behavior in tunnelingbright before it was take away, and we 1st hear his story in the 1st few pages, so I think Shatteredice would be a good cat to talk about.
I’d love to hear more about Barley! Or Ravenpaw! I just love to hear about these barn kitties
Maybe you could do a talking on one of Frostfur’s kits: Bracken, Cinder, Bright and Thorn. Cinder and Bright got more attention than their brothers. They also had a really good relationship. The Erins probably forgot that they were even related. But it’s just so sweet with how Cinder taught Bright some herbs and medicine cat skills when Cloudtail was off with Daisy and Cinder kinda comforted her in a why.
Cinder and Bright would be really cool for a talking video!!
When you think about it, the only living cats related to Bluestar are all of Sorreltail’s kits and their kits.
There’s also MistyStar too-
But you know 😀
@@LovelyUnknown13they said living. Mistystar is dead that woman dropped dead in the middle of an argument
@@0.721x she got ratioed
I think you should talk about Sandgorse. He kinda disowned his son and tried to guilt him in to being a tunnler-Sandgorse played a big role in Tallstar ‘s life.
I agree!
Maybe you could consider Runningnose? He was Yellowfang’s apprentice and was pretty friendly with her after she left for Thunderclan, as I remember.
I think Mothwing is going to become leader of RC. Maybe make a video about that exploring this possibility and her bad or good qualities as a leader? To me it felt like the books are leading up to that
Could you do a video about Thrushpelt? He is quite different to other toms who have not had their feelings reciprocated (ex. ashfur, bumblestripe) and it’d be interesting to hear what you have to say!
no views, yet there are 8 comments and 62 likes? what?!
I shall request a mini-talking for Stormfur, in my opinion, he's a good well-written character whos had alot going on in his life, he has adapted to 3 different places(The tribe, Thunderclan, and Riverclan), has been "dead" to the tribe, and etc. In all I think that would be a really good video. :)
Stormfur sucks but your points are valid.
You should do Mothwing next. Or her mother Sasha. (I always find it weird how Sasha just showed up before the clans left), there's certainly a lot to talk about with either of these two
Oh, Sasha. She holds a special place in my heart as the protaganist who introduced me to the world of Warriors.
If you want a more Sasha content I definitely recommend a shadow in Riverclan
Hey moon! I’ve been a fan for many years 🥹 your videos always make me smile and think about warrior cats super fondly. Ever since the age of 8 I was a diehard squirrelflight (and she cat in general) fan and remember arguing with many fans (way too young) online who didn’t like her lol! It’s awesome to see someone also love her so much, I remember when she was hated. I feel like she cats in general have gotten more love as the fandom matured-and that’s really awesome to see! Hope you’re doing well❤ thanks for making videos
I like to think that Reedwhisker was from Mistystar‘s secret second litter of kits, and he was the only one that survived. (Just to give some explanation for why he is a literal child at like 36 years old or something)
Trying to shoot my shot 14 hours in. I suggest my favourite character Feathertail, a vast majority of people may glare at me and state she has no character and I only like her as she’s pretty and a Riverclan prophecy cat… well yes… BUT! For those who say she has no personality I present my favourite book, A shadow in Riverclan, I feel like they could’ve added a bit more ptsd but there’s some fernxfeather and Sashaxfeather stuff in there. It also just adds heaps more character development and gives her well deserved anger, although I wish she hadn’t’t just randomly forgiven leopardstar out of now-where so the book could end. Love the art too.
Talking Goldenflower? I love her character a lot and I feel like she gets over-looked a lot.
I’d like to request a mini talk on Doestar! She was the leader before pinestar. Honestly this is more of a request for a discussion on pre-bluestar thunderclan. You mentioned how harsh it was and I agree!!! I’d love to hear your thoughts.
The holly leaf drawing in the river is everything
I really wanna see a talking video of Speckletail. She lost 3 of her kits(Mistlekit,Lionheart and Snowkit) and she lost her mate(I’m pretty sure it’s Smallear). I find her really interesting too!
Another one I'd like to see is a mini talk on Tall Shadow
Crookedstar? I don’t rlly have a reason for it, actually, I just think he experienced a lot, being manipulated by mapleshade and all. He also suffered quite a lot, his jaw being permanently disfigured, feeling he's required to leave his clan as 'just a burden', losing his mate and most of his kits- he has a relatively action-packed book, and I feel like you could take advantage of that!
Still requesting for Snowfur, I really want to know what you think about her and also she a has a lot of backstory that could be talked about!
This is probably isnt gonna be seen, but can you talk about tallstar? He had a great super edition and had a good character arc (in my opinion) and he had that relationship with jake. Pls talk about tallstar, he’s my fav guy :3
nightstar needs a video. mostly for being the only relatively competent shadowclan leader in the main timeline of the books (excluding dawn of the clans or any character from the guide books.) i mean you got to give him credit he was able to lead a clan that lost most of its abled warriors, was able to convince enemies to reunite against a common foe, and was able to do all of this while unable to be recognized as a leader in starclan. in the end his leadership was wrecked by tragedies and challenges that only the only leader equivalent failed to even manage (rowanstar), and you could also argue that nightstar had it worse.
I’d love to hear about Thrushpelt! He was an average warrior who took care of Bluestars kits but somehow did not notice when they ended up in Riverclan books later at a gathering?? He also is brothers with Thistleclaw and the mentor of Spottedleaf (if we’re still going with Spottedleaf’s Heart being canon) and this is super WEIRD. You're telling me he’s related to Thistleclaw and somehow didn't advise his own apprentice to stay away from him? I just think he's a really sweet lad who deserves to be spoken about due to the writing doing him major injustice. (´ｰ｀)
JUNIPERCLAW!! stop im so obsessed with his character he is one of the best side characters his backstory is sooo interesting i beg. if my friends see this you're unsurprised im sorry the rot has consumed me
Didn't Reedwhisker have a crush on Feathertail? Or am I confusing him with some other tom?