First Peter did not go lower than Tim. That was Tim's layering. Peter was singing in a higher range, but was drowned out by Tim. Secondly they were filming this from two different locations. Tim was somewhere on a Carribean Island filming his part where he was doing a private event, while Peter filmed his back in Oregon, therefore the light and darkness. This was from the Hobbit movie. Did you notice the camera shaking at the end of Tim's part? Oh yeah, and that was a G1 he hit.
#1 Yes Tim sang lower than me on lead vocal! #2 I did sing bass on this entire tune on the backgrounds you can hear my solo version here: th-cam.com/video/nEwzFF4HeB8/w-d-xo.html
I'm pretty sure that when recording the video, he isn't actually singing along completely, very high & low parts you don't just sing easily would be replaced by singing it an octave higher or lower & a growl I highly doubt he would do when recording the video. But.. maybe.. I wouldn't know..
Tim definitely looks like he could have been cast into Lord of the Rings or the Hobbit with that long hair and intense gaze he’s got in his eyes ! Like,, oh my heck ! Wow !
Hi Dennis, just to let you know that Peter did this song (Misty Mountains ) by himself doing all the layers and this was done before he collaborated with Tim. so it might what to go back and react to Peter's solo version of this song hope you check it out. And yes that last note shook the camera did you notice how long he held that note👍
Tim's voice makes my soul shudder right to it's very foundation , Peter's voice , on the other hand , is soothing and reassuring . Two awesome talents.
This production is so phenomenal that if they ever made another remake of The Hobbit, this should be used in that movie, and it should also be nominated in the music category for an Oscar!! I wonder, Isn’t there some kind of awards for TH-cam productions? If not, there should be! I would nominate and vote for Peter!!
It’s not even the fact that Tim had the ability and technique to GO that deep on that last note, but that he was actually able to HOLD that note for so long!! 😱
Tim's growl at the end is fearing perfectly the theme of the misty mountains. Peter's voice in interlude and solo to high notes actually make you think that you are actually in the forest of misty mountains and you hear the dryads and the elves of forest singing while Tim's voice makes you think at the battle inside the Dwarven halls
I think that Peter remains on higher notes while Tim's voice is like "cruising" in the bass notes and let Peter to do all the amazing things with his voice to high notes, I m feeling that Tim's voice as a bass singer is building the harmony while Peter's voice give more brightness and balance to the whole harmony
Vocal layering. Peter is about a 5th higher than Tim on that part you thought he went lower if I'm hearing right. But your right. Soo much going on. Peter is freaking genius. Like for reals.
This song is amazing, but you can't actually appreciate it until you hear it several times. There's just so much going on to catch all the nuances at once. Peter is a genius at layering! Do yourself a favor and listen to it on your own and close your eyes. It's soooo good! ❤
No, you misheard. what you see are two of many more tracks they previously recorded. so you may have heard Tim singing lower than himself. He did hit a G sharp 1.
The dubbing harmonies in the background came from both. If you want to know what kind of range Tim Foust has, listen to his new video, "come go with me". You won't be disappointed. Tim and Peter have done so many videos together and I always live the sounds they create together. Gladys like this as much as I did.
Hadn't realised that you'd never seen this or I'd have recommended it for you. Tim "dragon-breath" Foust at the end there doing his best impression of Smaug the Dragon from the Hobbit book/movies 🐲
Yeah if you look at Tim at the end the camera shakes. I think he’s singing a G#1. I don’t think Peter was singing lower than Tim but in the background Tim goes pretty high although not as high as Peter. I think Peter has an amazing range too....maybe 4 octaves. It’s just so good. The dwarves sing it in the Hobbit. Peter is amazing at layering. Just their two voices, it’s remarkable. Great reaction!
Any Hollens collab with Home Free -- group or individual -- has always delivered. First one was "18 You and Me," then "Amazing Grace," "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For." Each brings out Home Free's best, it has seemed to me.
No Peter didn't sing lower than Tim. They laid down several tracks of their ranges. Peter's voice sounds ethereal & Tim does the pit viper chest growl. Yes Tim looks like he's about to yank your soul out. He practically NEVER blinks in the whole video! Would hate to be on his bad side. 😉 LOVE this version over Geoff Castellucci's.
Pete Hollens did a FANTASTIC job with this rendition💯 These two are the best duo ever🙌 Check out his rendition of "Sound of silence" with our man Tim! That one is amazing too🔥🔥
@@PeterHollens oh wow. I am so sorry, I assumed you layered Tim for all the low notes. I apologize for assuming. You are so awesome. I love your videos with Home Free.
@@PeterHollens is amazing and can do any voice. His voice is just like sliced bread but oh so Much better. I get goosebumps each time I hear him or his beautiful wife sing. He is amazing and he loves his reactors just like home free.
Peter shot his videos in Oregon. Tim shot his in Texas. They have done this on several videos. Their cover of the song "God Only Knows" includes their wives who are both talented singers. Geoff Castellucci has a good two part video on how to sing low on his channel.
I cant wait to see this. Also I commented on Anthem Lights new Taylor Swift medley this morning about how they should check out your reactions to their videos :)
General consensus among the vocal coaches who’ve seen it say Tim’s last note is a G#1, peter was filming in Oregon at the same time as Tim was filming on Grand Cayman island, there’s about 120 layers in the mix on this and I personally believe that we only hear Tim when we see Tim. Only Geoff (among the well known basses) can hope to reach that note, even then it would take techniques that Tim doesn’t use, mainly because he doesn’t need to.
An amazing collaboration with two powerhouse vocalists. To see Peter hitting those low notes by himself check out "Into The West" from The Lord Of The Rings.
Hi Dennis 😀 I saw that you are having troubles with adds... Just add "adblock plus" to your chrome (its free extension) and it will block adds for you. I have been using it for years and didn't have single add since. Thanks me later 😉
Here's a link to a trailer for the movie: th-cam.com/video/m5BETb-hLgA/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=NewTrailerBuzz The Hobbit and The Lord of The Rings are fictional stories that fall under the fantasy genre. As for the costumes in the movies they are drawing inspiration from medieval times and viking age among others. I think i was around the age of your boys when my dad read the novels to me and my brother. I've been a J.R.R. Tolkien fan ever since. I highly recommend you watch the movies.
Peter is really good and he can go low, but no, he did not go lower than Tim. Yes, Tim looks into my soul with this. They are cosplaying as characters from The Lord Of the Rings, so the clothing is pretty cool.
For some reason I thought you had reacted to this song before because there isn't much you haven't reacted to. No, Peter was never singing low - that was just Tim's voice layered, I think.
Peter doesn't do bass. He was layering his voice. Tim's last note was a G1 he can go as low as an A. Check out Peter's and Tim's cover of Bridge over trouble water.
I'm not trying to knock the job that Tim and Peter did on this one... but it isn't my favorite cover of Misty Mountains. I find Tim's accent intrusive on some of the lines, to be honest. Yes, he's got some brutal low notes, but there are just elements of it that lessen my enjoyment of this one. No, if you like this cover of the song, you need to look into Jonathan Young's cover of this same song. He maybe doesn't hit _as_ low as Tim does on that last note, and he doesn't have the cinematography element the way this one does, but as a complete musical package, he just _destroys_ this song. And yes, the medieval fantasy outfits are appropriate to the setting of the book/movie.
First Peter did not go lower than Tim. That was Tim's layering. Peter was singing in a higher range, but was drowned out by Tim. Secondly they were filming this from two different locations. Tim was somewhere on a Carribean Island filming his part where he was doing a private event, while Peter filmed his back in Oregon, therefore the light and darkness. This was from the Hobbit movie. Did you notice the camera shaking at the end of Tim's part? Oh yeah, and that was a G1 he hit.
#1 Yes Tim sang lower than me on lead vocal! #2 I did sing bass on this entire tune on the backgrounds you can hear my solo version here: th-cam.com/video/nEwzFF4HeB8/w-d-xo.html
@@PeterHollens You are amazing Peter!
Not only is this from the movie, but the lyrics were written by JRR Tolkien himself in the book!
that was G#1 not G1 sorry
I'm pretty sure that when recording the video, he isn't actually singing along completely, very high & low parts you don't just sing easily would be replaced by singing it an octave higher or lower & a growl I highly doubt he would do when recording the video. But.. maybe.. I wouldn't know..
Their voices are layered. Tim’s voice is layered also not just Peter’s. So you were hearing Tim on Tim at the beginning.
That last note, camera shaking, All the cool layering. Hobbit costumes, and yes Tim looks into your soul.
Tim definitely looks like he could have been cast into Lord of the Rings or the Hobbit with that long hair and intense gaze he’s got in his eyes ! Like,, oh my heck ! Wow !
Hi Dennis, just to let you know that Peter did this song (Misty Mountains ) by himself doing all the layers and this was done before he collaborated with Tim. so it might what to go back and react to Peter's solo version of this song hope you check it out. And yes that last note shook the camera did you notice how long he held that note👍
Tim's voice makes my soul shudder right to it's very foundation , Peter's voice , on the other hand , is soothing and reassuring . Two awesome talents.
This production is so phenomenal that if they ever made another remake of The Hobbit, this should be used in that movie, and it should also be nominated in the music category for an Oscar!! I wonder, Isn’t there some kind of awards for TH-cam productions? If not, there should be! I would nominate and vote for Peter!!
It’s not even the fact that Tim had the ability and technique to GO that deep on that last note, but that he was actually able to HOLD that note for so long!! 😱
In Peter’s solo release, I think he said he laid down 120 tracks, but it may have been more. Tim’s low note was a G#1.
Tim was in the town of Hell Grand Cayman Island. So filming in 2 different places at the same time was amazing
Tim's growl at the end is fearing perfectly the theme of the misty mountains. Peter's voice in interlude and solo to high notes actually make you think that you are actually in the forest of misty mountains and you hear the dryads and the elves of forest singing while Tim's voice makes you think at the battle inside the Dwarven halls
There are only 2 voices in this, Peter and Tim, but there are over 120 layers of vocals.....Peter is a magician of layering....
Your reaction was great. This is one of my favorites by them. Tim bass, omg so low.
Re: the "setting" of the video. Hollens was in Oregon, Foust was in the Caribbean somewhere and each was filmed on the same day. Movie magic!
Tim was in the Cayman Islands, Grand Cayman.
I think that Peter remains on higher notes while Tim's voice is like "cruising" in the bass notes and let Peter to do all the amazing things with his voice to high notes, I m feeling that Tim's voice as a bass singer is building the harmony while Peter's voice give more brightness and balance to the whole harmony
For me, the part that shakes my soul is that fully resonant Eb2 at the beginning of the second verse from Tim.
Vocal layering. Peter is about a 5th higher than Tim on that part you thought he went lower if I'm hearing right. But your right. Soo much going on. Peter is freaking genius. Like for reals.
The last note is otherworldly !
Great reaction. Both men have tremendous ranges. I love your facial expressions throughout...
That last note of Tim’s is what people have been calling dragon’s breath.
Peter sings all the high parts and Tim sings all of the bass, both magnificently!
This song is amazing, but you can't actually appreciate it until you hear it several times. There's just so much going on to catch all the nuances at once. Peter is a genius at layering! Do yourself a favor and listen to it on your own and close your eyes. It's soooo good! ❤
No, you misheard. what you see are two of many more tracks they previously recorded. so you may have heard Tim singing lower than himself. He did hit a G sharp 1.
The dubbing harmonies in the background came from both. If you want to know what kind of range Tim Foust has, listen to his new video, "come go with me". You won't be disappointed. Tim and Peter have done so many videos together and I always live the sounds they create together. Gladys like this as much as I did.
Hadn't realised that you'd never seen this or I'd have recommended it for you. Tim "dragon-breath" Foust at the end there doing his best impression of Smaug the Dragon from the Hobbit book/movies 🐲
When I saw this today and it said “3 hours ago,” I thought it must be a re-upload after a copyright takedown.
Ooo this is amazing and Peter hollens just released a new one today with chance did you manage to catch ptx premier Dennis it was 🔥
Beautiful.
Love it Tim..
During filming Peter was at home in Colorado, Tim was on vacation in the Caribbean.
Yeah if you look at Tim at the end the camera shakes. I think he’s singing a G#1. I don’t think Peter was singing lower than Tim but in the background Tim goes pretty high although not as high as Peter. I think Peter has an amazing range too....maybe 4 octaves. It’s just so good. The dwarves sing it in the Hobbit. Peter is amazing at layering. Just their two voices, it’s remarkable. Great reaction!
Incredible! That's all I can say.
There are over 120 layers in this...genious
Peter was filmed in my home state of Oregon and Tim was in the Caribbean. Thanks for the reaction.
Scary that Tim NEVER blinks in this song !
Any Hollens collab with Home Free -- group or individual -- has always delivered. First one was "18 You and Me," then "Amazing Grace," "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For." Each brings out Home Free's best, it has seemed to me.
This is special! Was this just the two of them making all the harmonies?
Hey Dennis Just letting you know that Peter just recently dropped a cover of Country Roads with Adam Chance
No Peter didn't sing lower than Tim. They laid down several tracks of their ranges. Peter's voice sounds ethereal & Tim does the pit viper chest growl. Yes Tim looks like he's about to yank your soul out. He practically NEVER blinks in the whole video! Would hate to be on his bad side. 😉 LOVE this version over Geoff Castellucci's.
It’s not only low but look how long he held it.
These two do Sounds of Silence, Greensleeves and Bridge over Troubled Water as well.
Mind blowing indeed. Have you checked out Peter and Adam C singing "Country Roads" ?
Pete Hollens did a FANTASTIC job with this rendition💯 These two are the best duo ever🙌 Check out his rendition of "Sound of silence" with our man Tim! That one is amazing too🔥🔥
Peter has said that it took he and Tim over 120 tracks to get all the layering needed.
That is Tim's "Dragon note:" G1
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I think that was Tim's voice, at the beginning, layer through track duplication.
At the beginning it sounded to me like Peter was singing the same note an octave higher but just loud enough to blend perfectly with Tim’s low melody
Peter does not sing lower than Tim, not even close. Peter recorded both of them singing multiple layers and stacked them together.
Actually all the background parts on this other than Tim's solo is me! I can sing decently low sometimes nothing like Tim tho ;)
Ayyyyyyy amazing job buddy. Thank you for taking the time to watch the reaction. Peter check your DM on IG
@@PeterHollens oh wow. I am so sorry, I assumed you layered Tim for all the low notes. I apologize for assuming. You are so awesome. I love your videos with Home Free.
@@PeterHollens is amazing and can do any voice. His voice is just like sliced bread but oh so Much better. I get goosebumps each time I hear him or his beautiful wife sing. He is amazing and he loves his reactors just like home free.
Peter shot his videos in Oregon. Tim shot his in Texas. They have done this on several videos. Their cover of the song "God Only Knows" includes their wives who are both talented singers.
Geoff Castellucci has a good two part video on how to sing low on his channel.
I cant wait to see this. Also I commented on Anthem Lights new Taylor Swift medley this morning about how they should check out your reactions to their videos :)
last note is G#1 Growl note
You should do Geoff Castallucci cover of Beatles song "Blackbird".
More great bass singing.
Did you know that Peter and Tim was not at the same location. They were in two different cities. Tim sang that at g sharp or C#
General consensus among the vocal coaches who’ve seen it say Tim’s last note is a G#1, peter was filming in Oregon at the same time as Tim was filming on Grand Cayman island, there’s about 120 layers in the mix on this and I personally believe that we only hear Tim when we see Tim. Only Geoff (among the well known basses) can hope to reach that note, even then it would take techniques that Tim doesn’t use, mainly because he doesn’t need to.
That note was G#1
Dennis,, please check out Peter’s video of “Take me Home,, Country Roads” that he did with Chance ! It’s absolutely wonderful !! ♥️♥️
It will be up tomorrow 😁
@@KingFamilyReacts Awesome ! Can’t wait to see your reaction ! :))
Chance has been busy lately between rickrolling everyone, collaborating with Peter Hollins and The Hound+Fox, and releasing a couple of solo videos 😄
E1 - Growl Note
Tim has a 5 octave range. That low note was a G#1.
An amazing collaboration with two powerhouse vocalists. To see Peter hitting those low notes by himself check out "Into The West" from The Lord Of The Rings.
Peter said it is 150 mixed tracks.
You need to react to Geoff Castellucci‘s rendition this one is wonderful with him but Geoff is also great
Hi Dennis 😀
I saw that you are having troubles with adds... Just add "adblock plus" to your chrome (its free extension) and it will block adds for you.
I have been using it for years and didn't have single add since.
Thanks me later 😉
Tim's lowest growl note is F#1
The last note was an G#1 growl note.
I have watch this video many times and Peter didn't go lower.
peter was in Unison with Tim at the beginning which means he was singing the same notes as tim was
I don't listen to the lyrics either!!! What a great realization, when the notes and visual doesn't make the lyrics mean anything!
That was a G sharp 1
Here's a link to a trailer for the movie: th-cam.com/video/m5BETb-hLgA/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=NewTrailerBuzz
The Hobbit and The Lord of The Rings are fictional stories that fall under the fantasy genre. As for the costumes in the movies they are drawing inspiration from medieval times and viking age among others.
I think i was around the age of your boys when my dad read the novels to me and my brother. I've been a J.R.R. Tolkien fan ever since. I highly recommend you watch the movies.
Peter sings in three octaves. Tim sings in six octaves. Peter did not go deeper then Tim. Nice review! Great song!
Remember, Peter layers different tracks, so I don’t think he was lower than Tim. Does no one but me think Tim Foust the mutant is not blinking?
Please react to Peter's cover of "I See Fire"! It's also from the Hobbit and is one of my absolute favourite covers of his!
7:59
I've read that it's a G#1.
Peter didnt go lower than Tim, but he still got a range, you should check his solo version of Misty Mountains
Peter is really good and he can go low, but no, he did not go lower than Tim. Yes, Tim looks into my soul with this. They are cosplaying as characters from The Lord Of the Rings, so the clothing is pretty cool.
For some reason I thought you had reacted to this song before because there isn't much you haven't reacted to. No, Peter was never singing low - that was just Tim's voice layered, I think.
for a second i saw Brock Lesnar was reacting loooool
Ha, that was a G dude, ha. This is pre Lord of the Rings, but made after, The Hobbit.
Peter can't go lower then Tim he was always higher
React to baba yetu Peter hollens and Lindsey stirling
I DID BABA YETU WITH LINDSEY!?!?!
@@PeterHollens i mistake
You sing with malukah
Sounds like a G2
Nope incorrect
@@kkchnnl821 then what is it?
@@that1mamalady G#1 growl
yes Peter can go as low and lower then tim but he rarely does in this case he doesn't
Peter couldn't sing lower than Tim at all. Not even in a dream.
It was D1
No, Peter didn't go lower, they did multiple tracks so you're probably picking up another track of Tim's voice
Look at Terri Johnson’s comment just above yours Peter himself replied and said that it was him.
Lol, not 20 seconds after you restarted the video due to ads, I had to sit through ads.
Good reaction by the way.
Did you get to listen to 2and chance yet when you do let me know
not its all layers
Peter doesn't do bass. He was layering his voice. Tim's last note was a G1 he can go as low as an A. Check out Peter's and Tim's cover of Bridge over trouble water.
g1
The lows were always Tim.
Ad block. Ever heard of it? It's not black magic man. That ad in the beggining fucked up the whole vibe of the song...
My bad. I'm usually good about clipping those out. That one got past me
Peter can go pretty deep but not to Tim´s level , in Amazing Grace , Peter almost follows Tim down
Peter can not hit that low
I'm not trying to knock the job that Tim and Peter did on this one... but it isn't my favorite cover of Misty Mountains. I find Tim's accent intrusive on some of the lines, to be honest. Yes, he's got some brutal low notes, but there are just elements of it that lessen my enjoyment of this one. No, if you like this cover of the song, you need to look into Jonathan Young's cover of this same song. He maybe doesn't hit _as_ low as Tim does on that last note, and he doesn't have the cinematography element the way this one does, but as a complete musical package, he just _destroys_ this song.
And yes, the medieval fantasy outfits are appropriate to the setting of the book/movie.
You have a TH-cam channel doing reactions to TH-cam videos and you can't spring for TH-cam Premium? Lame. :/