This was the first song I heard back in 2005 from DT. I guess, I was only 14 in Tehran, Iran. Strange county to hear DT in. DT is in my heart ever since
Heard this song for the first time in 2007 when i was 13 years old , living in Tunisia . Metal culture was rare in my country back then due to massive internet censorship
@@ahmadabouammo8704 "listening to death metal under the fear of death penalty for listening" is the winner in the nomination 'irony of the year' )))))))))
Saw them live first time last night! I started listening to them in my teens and they came to my home town after a long 14 years. Fantastic show and Mikael is really impressive. So glad i finally saw thm.
Gentle storm, thundering silence Inferior force, uncontrolled calm Vital unlike, logic, chaos, logic The tone of which his birth ascend The beat that of a heart descend Repeating in the infinite An insight made it clear Order stormed the surface Where chaos set norm Had there always been balance? Surely not Therein lies the beauty It was solid Yet everchanging It was different Yet the same So I starve myself for energy It was solid Yet everchanging It was different Yet the same So I starve myself for energy I starve myself for energy The song around his soul will bend The notes that in this hole will melt Crawl out of science A dreamland if you dear Disorder clawed the boundaries We're ordered to stand clear Was it always different, never the same? Therein lies the beauty It was solid Yet everchanging It was different Yet the same So I starve myself for energy It was solid Yet everchanging It was different Yet the same So I starve myself for energy I starve myself for energy As there were no witnesses There was nothing to be told As nothing could be grasped The story could unfold Superimposed on the elements of anger Fear, anxiety, hate, despair, remorse So break from all that fear hold fast Exposed now turn to all you lack Let echoes be the answers Return from all the screams Wordless now the last attack So silent it hurts to listen Was it always solid, to never change? Therein lies the beauty It was solid Yet everchanging It was different Yet the same So I starve myself for energy It was solid Yet everchanging It was different Yet the same So I starve myself for energy I starve myself for energy
My friend Johnny brought me here... Damn i got goosebumb , this song was on my playlist till my time is come... Thnks johnny,.. All the way from North East India_Aizawl_Mizoram
amazing band. Stanne is an absolute showman through and through and a fantastic person to boot. After meeting him, he's very courteous and friendly, and extremely modest. great guy!
The song which embraces the life itself. Sometimes I get scared of how time flies and everything changes so fast, I just start to feel dizzy and lost. But DT manages to sew eons by making songs that withstand a trial of getting old. It helps to remember that control freaking does not workm you just have to do your best against all odds, to try surfing your wave in contraversal existence... Therein lies the beauty...
guys it's not all about the hair and the looks or whatsoever it's all in the music and the bands/artists that we enjoy, that's what really fucking matters keep headbanging
No song has ever over the time of its existence elicited more emotion from me than this beauty. Projector was such a game changer for me... 22 years ago... wow.
Still listening to this song. Still loving it. At 4:31 you can see the power in this song. When he jumps an makes an air kick. In this moment I exactly feel the same way and also want to jump and kick... Just want to freak out. 😁🤘🏻
la primera vez que escuche esta canción en el 2002 me petrifico, como pasa de la furia de las estofas al lamento del coro!!! La melodía te atrapa con la desgarradora voz gutural de Mikael Stanne junto con su tono limpio y baritono.... lo tiene todo este tema
That was an epic live version of the song ! God damn I love it when the people actually get involved to support the band other then swaying back and forth, and its even sadder when people go to concerts of there favorite bands and stand there.
Hearing the crowd sing still gives me the chills even after probably the 100th time listening to this...
Same :)
I hear you bro, at parties I'm still hyping people up with this "let's go to that gig man look at this one"
In a perfect world, this has 7.3 billion views. We do not live in a perfect world, but at least we live in a world where this exists.
Nunca palabras tan correctas.
This was the first song I heard back in 2005 from DT. I guess, I was only 14 in Tehran, Iran. Strange county to hear DT in.
DT is in my heart ever since
Heard this song for the first time in 2007 when i was 13 years old , living in Tunisia . Metal culture was rare in my country back then due to massive internet censorship
@@hochspannunglebensgefahr8014 Tunisia here before revolution ❤️❤️
Dude, I hope you managed to escape for better. It's great than even the ayatollahs cannot block this kind of music.
super song, super band, glad you are alive after this song in Iran
@@ahmadabouammo8704 "listening to death metal under the fear of death penalty for listening" is the winner in the nomination 'irony of the year' )))))))))
I'm 51 tomorrow & this song still hits me. If there's one band I need to see before I kook it, it's Dark Tranquillity 🤘
❤️ that’s awesome
Saw them live first time last night! I started listening to them in my teens and they came to my home town after a long 14 years. Fantastic show and Mikael is really impressive. So glad i finally saw thm.
you are not alone. I'm 42 and for thirty years I have been listening metal. still I'm listening and get the same taste :))
Mikael's clean vocals here are so damn great!
he looks like Marcus Corvinus from underworld xD
Italians metalheads, respect fom Brazil!
spanish!
Rock!!
+MetalUniversity they are Swedish
+Mike Kiske Swedish
keep it up!
His clean vocs are so godlike
I was there... crying for DT...
complimenti per il coro \m/ COINVOLGENTE
lp
Man...this live version is sick..
Its 4june2023... Never gets old.. Greetings from Aizawl_NE India
I can't imagine what he was feeling seeing all of those people sing your music and great singing too.
Perfect band, perfect crowd, perfect show. Wish I could have been there.
I was there. And trust me bro, the atmosphere was magic. Never felt a connection so deep between the crowd and the band.
I get those Goosebumps everytime I hear this song. Im 32 and 16 years ago I saw them live. Feels like yesterday
Gentle storm, thundering silence
Inferior force, uncontrolled calm
Vital unlike, logic, chaos, logic
The tone of which his birth ascend
The beat that of a heart descend
Repeating in the infinite
An insight made it clear
Order stormed the surface
Where chaos set norm
Had there always been balance?
Surely not
Therein lies the beauty
It was solid
Yet everchanging
It was different
Yet the same
So I starve myself for energy
It was solid
Yet everchanging
It was different
Yet the same
So I starve myself for energy
I starve myself for energy
The song around his soul will bend
The notes that in this hole will melt
Crawl out of science
A dreamland if you dear
Disorder clawed the boundaries
We're ordered to stand clear
Was it always different, never the same?
Therein lies the beauty
It was solid
Yet everchanging
It was different
Yet the same
So I starve myself for energy
It was solid
Yet everchanging
It was different
Yet the same
So I starve myself for energy
I starve myself for energy
As there were no witnesses
There was nothing to be told
As nothing could be grasped
The story could unfold
Superimposed on the elements of anger
Fear, anxiety, hate, despair, remorse
So break from all that fear hold fast
Exposed now turn to all you lack
Let echoes be the answers
Return from all the screams
Wordless now the last attack
So silent it hurts to listen
Was it always solid, to never change?
Therein lies the beauty
It was solid
Yet everchanging
It was different
Yet the same
So I starve myself for energy
It was solid
Yet everchanging
It was different
Yet the same
So I starve myself for energy
I starve myself for energy
Valeeeeu irmão metaleiro 🤘🤘🤘
@@eduardoruthes7810 Tmj! Éh nóiz! Uí ór tugedher!
Oh my fucking lord how I love Dark Tranquillity and its live performances.
My friend Johnny brought me here... Damn i got goosebumb , this song was on my playlist till my time is come... Thnks johnny,..
All the way from North East India_Aizawl_Mizoram
one of the best death vocals i have ever heard...and im listening many years metal.
This isn't death metal Lol.
Dukeljk it’s melodic death vocals which is close enough.
Hail to Milan from Slovakia the crowd is amazing
right?
presne tak ❤
Grazie!
amazing band. Stanne is an absolute showman through and through and a fantastic person to boot. After meeting him, he's very courteous and friendly, and extremely modest. great guy!
The clean part sounds so aweome live.
Wow! The crowd is just awesome.
Impeccable performance. It's rare to find a band that can perform live, as good as they sound in an album.
that's sad, cause most bands I listen to can perform just as good as on cd. If you like Dark Tranquillity, do you know Insomnium or Amorphis?
The moment I see and hear stuff like this makes me love myself that I chose the path of metal. Just b-e-a-utiful.
This song has a sort of somber calmness to it. Gloomy but peaceful.
The song which embraces the life itself. Sometimes I get scared of how time flies and everything changes so fast, I just start to feel dizzy and lost. But DT manages to sew eons by making songs that withstand a trial of getting old. It helps to remember that control freaking does not workm you just have to do your best against all odds, to try surfing your wave in contraversal existence... Therein lies the beauty...
This audience
Depois de tantos anos, ainda volto aqui pra ver essa performance como se eu ainda tivesse 14 anos. 😅
muito bom mesmo.
I feel sorry for anyone who listens to this and doesn't see the beauty in it. Which means, sadly, i feel sorry for 99% of the world's population :*(
this whole album is excellent, still pumping it like crazy, hi from Türkiye
This whole live is my fav metal live show ever with the at the gates réunion at wacken and my dying bride's for darkest yes in Krakow ❤️
La banda captando la increible energia de ese publico demencial, les devuelve temas como este.
its amazing how many metal vocalists have beautiful voices.
guys
it's not all about the hair and the looks or whatsoever
it's all in the music and the bands/artists that we enjoy, that's what really fucking matters
keep headbanging
2023 anyone? I will be different, and yet the same :)
This clip should have 2 millions views...
I keep rewatching songs from this concert because the crowd is as amazing as the band itself. Respect from India!
I need a dark tranquillity show right now!!
We all do!
This is my favorite song of DT and it's live an absolute banger as well. Could listen all day
Io i Dark tranquillity li vidi a Roma durante il tour di Projector e chiusero il concerto proprio con THEREIN...cosa dire...fantastici
WOW! I have the DVD, and I have to say, I've never seen an atmosphere like that at a concert. Amazing.
No song has ever over the time of its existence elicited more emotion from me than this beauty. Projector was such a game changer for me... 22 years ago... wow.
I am high, and this is the humanity's peak in thought evolution
Best Live Performance and the Best Crowd EVER!
Esos coros! Así es cómo una banda se conecta en verdad con su público. Son inmensos DT!!!
Vackert Italien - Bella Italia!!!
Amazing performance...
SwedeMackster tack så mycket från italien
One of the most awesome live performances ever.
when Projector was initially released, it got alot of flak becos of the the clean vox. but this is one of their very best imo.
This and Lethe are my favorites
I can't get this out of my head since the concert!
Btw this video get my to melodic death metal back in the 2010!
One of the best song ever, and a stunning performance! The whole concert is amazing, the dvd quality is well above average... a must have!
I love dark tranquillity.
How did I miss this?
The performance is so good. Italian fans really made this special 👍🤘🏻
Esa rola es mi favorita
chingona
The best live performance of that song.. by far!!! I would sell my soul to the devil to have been there....
Love music 💓
i was there! Awesome performance! Good crowd energy! \m/
Still listening to this song. Still loving it. At 4:31 you can see the power in this song. When he jumps an makes an air kick. In this moment I exactly feel the same way and also want to jump and kick... Just want to freak out. 😁🤘🏻
in Italy we love DT
I love the calm part when everyone singing along ;D gives me chills
simply awesome, epic song and great crowd
Perfect song, perfect performance, perfect sound, perfect video and perfect crowd!
Wonderful album, one of my favourite of all time!!!
One of the best live performances ive ever seen, awesome!
Over the years DT has stated true to what the sound is. They are the best at what they do.
Great music with awesome recording and perfect video quality! Simply awesome!
q idolos gran grupo
sin palabras....
great live sound, too. each instrument sounds perfect...!!!
Damn! This song is so great!!! And the crowd helps to be it too!!!
Excelente banda ! Su poesía es maravillosa !
Awesome song.. All of their song are great
Amo está canción!!!!
i was in there concert yesterday in casablance, one the best night. thanks DT
epic moment when this song starts
Not only is this song amazing, but this is the best live recording i have ever seen!!!
Son secoss!
Amo este tema!
Охренительно! 👍Хочу тоже попеть в зале! 🤘
Awesome. Hail Dark Tranquility.
One word! WOW! this is amazing im crying every time im watching this
la primera vez que escuche esta canción en el 2002 me petrifico, como pasa de la furia de las estofas al lamento del coro!!! La melodía te atrapa con la desgarradora voz gutural de Mikael Stanne junto con su tono limpio y baritono.... lo tiene todo este tema
It is this kind of thing that shows that they will be remembered long after they're gone. :)
Chills.
Amazing band
this is beautiful....
This version makes me cry :')
this band is without peers in their genre amazing tunz well played and so bloody professional. keep it up DT
Getting chills this is just epic. Wanna see them live.
such a beautiful voice
Therien lies the beauty!
OMG THIS IS SO AMAZING! I LOVE THEM!
THIS SONG GIVE ME CHILLS!
MY FAVORITE BAND EVER!
That was an epic live version of the song ! God damn I love it when the people actually get involved to support the band other then swaying back and forth, and its even sadder when people go to concerts of there favorite bands and stand there.
Wow, it reminds me of the crowd here in Tel Aviv! This is so beautiful :)
AMAZING
I was there!! god, what an evening...
can't wait to get the DVD as well
One of the best liveacts ever.
Seeing them in San Francisco Sunday. Can't wait!!
Here in 2018 :D
I have seen them Live and they are amazing....
italians are the best and the most active audience i have ever seen. Just like Liverpool FC fans
this song is so beautiful
Amazing live performance. Easily one of my favorite modern metal acts.
amazing freaking band.
bravissimo milan !!!
2023 still coming back...