The only 2 issues I personally have with the new designs is that they're far too cartoony and Axel became the stereotypical "Stupid one" at least in looks.
I really shouldn't say "became". He was always a few fuses short of a set, but it's the apparent flanderization they made with his design. I think the way Ray got their designs is by taking the pre-existing ones and dialing their base character attributes to 10.
I think the only critique I have is that the character designs are too rigid and blocky. From an animation standpoint, it leaves you very limited with what you’re supposed to do. On top of that, the designs aren’t that great that will leave you wanting to see more of this type of fixed artwork. That’s all though. I know this isn’t supposed to be anything that’s taken serious, but I loved YFM. Just a small critique Ray will probably never see
My personal issue is that Puff Puff’s glasses stick out from his face and therefore give him a nerdy look. Also, DeeJay looks kinda goofy ngl 🗿💀. Benatar looks more like a nerd too. Axel looks super goofy and nice now, but they all went for the typical “bad boy” look which I think suited them all (except for Puff Puff) a lot better.
I actually appreciate how they made Axel and Benatar more distinct from each other taking in consideration they were nearly identical originally. Dee Jay looked better with no visible eyes, though
I personally love your Benatar redesign! It’s so cool and fits his character well! One thing I would ask ot add is a trash can Edit: damn 1 month later people in the comments don’t get it? Ok then
Yea honestly I'm not 100% on board but I think the axel design is the worst. I'm just happy yfm is back, and ray is trying to do something original with it.
Hour early,I got a eyelash in my eye and gotta sleep with it, Wish me luck i dont get a eye infection, Speaking of eyes, Ray added eyes to the characters for more emotion thats why
i dont know why the initial designs covered all their eyes, but i dont know why they got rid of them. How id fix the designs as an artist and aspiring animator: Axel: slightly less exaggerated shoulders, no hat (or the hat covering the eyes) and the old hair back Dee Jay: change the afro to the old one and cover his eyes, and add the second stripe on his jacket Benatar: old hair, covered eyes OR one eye showing and blue eyes, change his trousers to match his blazer and for the love of god make him sing in a british accent Puff: completely scrap it, bring back the previos puff design and shorten the torso because that man is built like a dachschund on two legs
Dee Jay and Axel are my least favorite designs to be honest. I don't understand what they were doing with Dee Jay's mouth?? the weird, puckered lips thing just doesn't look right. It's not a normal facial expression that people make, let alone Dee Jay. It would make sense if the expression was a onetime thing during part of a music video, but it seems like it's his default facial expression?? Axel just looks like a stereotypical dumb cartoon character. Sure, he wasn't the smartest of the band members, but I don't think it was his entire personality. He was just a beefy, edgy guy with less than average intelligence. His default facial expression also just doesn't look right. This was a pretty funny video though lol- sorry about the rant, I'm just passionate about character design lmao-
Axel’s design is the only thing that’s wrong with the newer designs. Aside from that the second thing is the eyes one all of the characters since they didn’t have any visible eyes aside from Puff Puff
Puff Puff (the one in red) now looks like sans to some extent also he originally had eyes so what's with that change?, Deejay (afro guy) well your new design is fine i mean nothing that wrong with it, Axel (the one with the skull) now looks like he's even stupider but more character i guess, and benatar (the one i haven't talked about yet obviously) well your redesign did do a small change to his character most important obilterating him entirely, idk i know this is meant to be a memey video and it's funny but idk
I swear people on the internet will literally attack anything bruh..
They did
@@Ineedmychiar ATTACK THIS BITCH
@@Ineedmychiar true
I swear
Unfortunately they did
The only 2 issues I personally have with the new designs is that they're far too cartoony and Axel became the stereotypical "Stupid one" at least in looks.
I really shouldn't say "became". He was always a few fuses short of a set, but it's the apparent flanderization they made with his design. I think the way Ray got their designs is by taking the pre-existing ones and dialing their base character attributes to 10.
sonic boom knuckles
Agreed
@@KitronMK I swear
They really gave axel the sonic boom knuckles treatment 💀
Axel got this "Knuckles from Sonic Boom" thing. This is my biggest problem.
Same bro I didn’t think many people thought about that
I like the new axel
Lmao 10 years later and benetar still can't catch a break
He doesn't deserve one
@@HeIsBigFella hell yea axel
@@HeIsBigFella holy shiz it's the real Axel the buff emo guy
@@HeIsBigFella black mail
@@sleepytimetea4278 you dont even make sense man I don't judge mail based on color
I think the only critique I have is that the character designs are too rigid and blocky. From an animation standpoint, it leaves you very limited with what you’re supposed to do. On top of that, the designs aren’t that great that will leave you wanting to see more of this type of fixed artwork. That’s all though. I know this isn’t supposed to be anything that’s taken serious, but I loved YFM. Just a small critique Ray will probably never see
Exactly. Puff puff is literally a blockhead. And the mouth hes doing in the picture in this puts me off too
My personal issue is that Puff Puff’s glasses stick out from his face and therefore give him a nerdy look. Also, DeeJay looks kinda goofy ngl 🗿💀.
Benatar looks more like a nerd too.
Axel looks super goofy and nice now, but they all went for the typical “bad boy” look which I think suited them all (except for Puff Puff) a lot better.
Dee jay and axel look HELLA goofy
Puff puff and benetar on the other hand look like this emoji 🤓
Benatar kinda looks like a scrapped boy band character merged with a height increasing surgery for a 4 year old
Benatar deserves ir
I mean what you expect dee jay head be like than since in Bitch got a penis
Before got rework in the in next studio
I love how instead of instantly massacring it you made it slowly but surely turn into a meme
Congratulations! You made me track your location.
2:22 this is basically what ray actually did lmao
The only issue I have is axel being buff. He looks like a goofy ahh character that would be included in SpongeBob mabye
I actually appreciate how they made Axel and Benatar more distinct from each other taking in consideration they were nearly identical originally. Dee Jay looked better with no visible eyes, though
I agree with all of that, but Axel got done dirty rly.
@@Ecliptic-P I like how he looks, he reminds me of Kronk from Emperor's New Groove
@@Ecliptic-P he looks like sonic boom knuckles
He looks like squidward in that plankton's band episode
As much as I hate all the designs (besides puff) I think the art style is actually pretty good.
Puff is the only character design I like
No way that's sans from undertale
I personally love your Benatar redesign! It’s so cool and fits his character well! One thing I would ask ot add is a trash can
Edit: damn 1 month later people in the comments don’t get it? Ok then
whatd benatar ever do?!? 😭
Don't talk to them. They're just a puff stan. Probably. And yes I am assuming.
@CalmCricket yea dude for sure
children in replies be like:
okay
I'm pretty sure the redesign ray did was to differentiate them from the cosmic toast era
Yeah, probably because they were just plain and simple assholes
The way he just gets rid of Dee Jays mouth lmao.
Looks better
Axel, Sans Sans, Dee Jay and [REDACTED]
Yea honestly I'm not 100% on board but I think the axel design is the worst. I'm just happy yfm is back, and ray is trying to do something original with it.
RIP BENETAR 2011-2022
Puff went from tord to Tom pretty quick 😂😂🤣🤣
REMINDS ME OF DA
H E R O B R I N E
I know its eddsworld, but I have no idea who those characters are
One word. HOW
@@jy-ol4cx eddsworld never interested me but i know the names from fnf mods
Or Sans.
Bro turned puff into scott the woz
this is perfection you got puff, axel, deejay, and mr. transparent
Axel: helmet covered his eyes
Puff Puff: tom from eddsworld
Dee Jay: literally Dee Jay
Benetar: Deleted
He watched the video
Axel looks like he’s voiced by Patrick Warburton and would cook Spinach Puffs
He looks like kronk?
@@lucidstarx3456 No I meant Joe Swanson who else am I talking about
@@DEAD_ACCOUNT0000 kronk, he makes spinach puffs and is voiced by the same guy
Tho I actually thought you were talking about joe Swanson at first
@@lucidstarx3456 Nah bro I’m talkin bout Flynn from Skylanders Trap Team
At least they gave the rest of the members eyes
I hate the eyes tbh. At least on axel and DeeJay
Makes them more expressive
@@ItsCalmCricketYT I feel like having their hair in their eyes shows more personality
If you want a name.blame rah because he made the designs.
Ray*
"Fixing the YFM redesigns!"
**deletes benatar**
dee jay with the airpods
The designs used in YFMTS and 2012 was the best in my opinion
Pagewaster is like Axel from YFM , They dont like benatar and they hate him
I actually think that the new designs are really good
I actually like the way you fixed these!
You really did not
@@giddy9831 I thought that Deejay looked good.
love how benitar is just gone
fuck benatar all my homies hate benatar
Axel, Axel’s poor soul
“I don’t think this looks like anyone on TH-cam right now”
Scott the woz
The real answer is right under your nose.
Hour early,I got a eyelash in my eye and gotta sleep with it, Wish me luck i dont get a eye infection, Speaking of eyes, Ray added eyes to the characters for more emotion thats why
How’s your eye?
@@zayLongstrokervevo Its been good! thanks for asking, My eye had mucus and when i woke up the eyelash fell out, It was dry for a day but im good now!
@@begonebots8438 oh thank god
They should’ve kept the eyes obscured
For Benatar it’s fine but it’s my personal opinion
Dude i LITERALLY live in your walls
You cannot even fathom how small you are in comparison to the grand scheme of things.
@@Pagewaster cringe
@@seven.456 :)
@@Pagewaster Erm... Rati o.. I win Po Poo Balls
@@seven.456 un-cringe
we luv the benatar slander
Bentar looks like a newborn
Benatar: g o n e
DeeJay: McHair
Puff puff: herobrine
Axel: tf2 soldier
Bruh my man axel built like he's from the stone age
ngl replacing benatar with a grey brick was the best idea you've ever come up with
You have not seen anything else I have made.
Yea I really preferred the obscured eyes that Axel and Deejay had. Benatar was fine with eyes I guess. I'd prefer if he just wasn't here all together.
let me fix benatar
*fucking deletes him*
Tbh I just appreciate the fact they are back
I like how he just removed benatar
*hate
I think it looks okay in motion. Just needs tweaking.
Like what's Puff's hair and glasses?
Axel looks like soldier from tf2
*never thought this will be an reality.*
ok I'm going to rank Gens by looks
1: Gen 2
2: Gen 3
3: Gen 1
No more puff puff, benater, and axel, now it's guy, pagewaister, and floating keyboard guitar with hands
they did my boy axel wrong😔✊
man’s removed benatar what’s with these homies dissing my boy 😭
i dont know why the initial designs covered all their eyes, but i dont know why they got rid of them. How id fix the designs as an artist and aspiring animator:
Axel: slightly less exaggerated shoulders, no hat (or the hat covering the eyes) and the old hair back
Dee Jay: change the afro to the old one and cover his eyes, and add the second stripe on his jacket
Benatar: old hair, covered eyes OR one eye showing and blue eyes, change his trousers to match his blazer and for the love of god make him sing in a british accent
Puff: completely scrap it, bring back the previos puff design and shorten the torso because that man is built like a dachschund on two legs
bro doesnt even know axel
Sure he doesn't man
i thought you would turn puff puff into sans for a second
💀skletin
I swear the trash can in the thumbnail looks like its from my grade 2 math book
Bentar be like: "
n
o
t
h
i
n
g
"
puff puff looks like a martian
I'm upset that thay gave Axel the knuckles treatment
Bro did my boy Benatar dirty
This guy has a point
bro turned puff puff into herobrine
You just have to make them creepier
Really good
Can someone tell me what is the music playing in the video, called?
Its a song I made myself called Element HD 420. You can listen to it on my Soundcloud.
I dunno where your comment went but I got the notification. You can use any of my music as long as I'm credited. It's practically Royalty Free
@@Pagewaster Alright thanks! I think I accidentally deleted it or something, I am not sure.
Why does everyone hate Benatar? He’s the best one!!
Axel got the knuckles treatment
deejay looks like even more of a fantasy then before
I LOVE BOW YOU JUST GOT RID OF FUCKING BENWTAR
i love the new designs but axel come on
Dee Jay and Axel are my least favorite designs to be honest. I don't understand what they were doing with Dee Jay's mouth?? the weird, puckered lips thing just doesn't look right. It's not a normal facial expression that people make, let alone Dee Jay. It would make sense if the expression was a onetime thing during part of a music video, but it seems like it's his default facial expression??
Axel just looks like a stereotypical dumb cartoon character. Sure, he wasn't the smartest of the band members, but I don't think it was his entire personality. He was just a beefy, edgy guy with less than average intelligence. His default facial expression also just doesn't look right.
This was a pretty funny video though lol- sorry about the rant, I'm just passionate about character design lmao-
gen 2 benatar looks like hes supposed 2 be short idk how 2 explain
I really love your benatar redesign
bro looks like your favorite martini xd
I can't believe he predicted Jesse Cale's absense in gen 2 😭
I've got a whole damn theory surrounding it
Better without Benatar :)
Axel’s design is the only thing that’s wrong with the newer designs. Aside from that the second thing is the eyes one all of the characters since they didn’t have any visible eyes aside from Puff Puff
Dee Jay had eyes all the way back in "we like them girls" because Legos have eyes
He also had eyes in transphobic techno
@@toothpaste3702 true
naw what did benatar do to you brah 😭
He existed wrong and for that he paid the price
i like the second one is just basic but good 😩
Puff Puff (the one in red) now looks like sans to some extent also he originally had eyes so what's with that change?, Deejay (afro guy) well your new design is fine i mean nothing that wrong with it, Axel (the one with the skull) now looks like he's even stupider but more character i guess, and benatar (the one i haven't talked about yet obviously) well your redesign did do a small change to his character most important obilterating him entirely, idk i know this is meant to be a memey video and it's funny but idk
I made Puff look like my avatar
@@Pagewaster ohhhhhhhh that was the joke whoops
man hates eyes
I get that this is a joke but In all seriousness I dont like seeing there eyes
That guy with the viking helmet is axel
RIP to the homie Benetar 🙏🕊
Benatar is no more
I swear they made axel so stupid, but the rest look pretty good
I’m mostly fine with it except for Benatar looking like an anime boy
puff looks like tom from eddsworld
True
HOLY SHIT IS THAT SCOTT THE WOZ??!?!?
They should have kept the YFMTS puff puff
This is way badder than the original
😡 Take that back
I actaully liked axels redesign
You don't know there names it's axel puff puff dee Jay benatar
I know their names. I always knew their names. You fell for my hilarious little lies.
@@Pagewaster very clever
LMFAOO LOVE THIS
This looks like yfmts is gonna arid on TV on adult swim 🤣
hopefully they keep the same design for yfmts...
goofy ahh axel
Bentar really ho is going to play the guitar HUH HUH
I actually dont really hate benatars new look 🤷♂️ i mean its not the best but it isnt really bad, expect axel i hate it