one of the most heartfelt and vulnerable moments in your life and you expressed it just how you know how to best. so proud of you josh. you can feel how intense this time in your life is through this video. that's important because that's what you do when your heart is broken. you feel. and you're not afraid to do that. really admirable. love you always brother. also erin's voice is unreal.
I still watch this video over and over. It's the most beautiful and raw expression of emotion ever. I know this post will be lost in a sea of comments, but if there's even a chance it will be seen... I must say how powerful this was to me. Much love from Georgia
Josh, I am 62 and so have had a lot of life experience. I want to encourage you that in one year from now as you look back over this whole painful situation you will see that both you and colleen will be in a better place for both of you. Hearts break and hearts can mend if you chose that....Josh, chose that. Don't keep any stored up negative energy in your body...and for you I suggest you sing it away...yes...sing your emotions and thoughts and let the energy labeled pain poor out of you and you will be wiser, gentler, more forgiving of others and a generator of much peace
she really means it. she is looking at her brother who she has had some of the greatest laughs with of her life, and her eyes tell us that she feels helpless towards him. absolutely beautiful example of sibling love, she loves him with all her heart and she wants him to be happy again.
Sometimes I come back to this and I don't think I've ever see a true raw emotional Performance like this when he started to cry. I'm so sorry you went through all of this, but hindsight is truly 20/20, and you are better where you are now.
Daniella Radchenko bruh your just RUDE and gross for saying that Josh is going through tough times and the ppl who care about him are with him through this.
This was super touching and equally amazing to watch. I cried a lot because within a song you guys manage to fit genuinity, family love/support, and making peace with dark patches of your life. This was real and beautiful. I have insane amount of respect for you that you come forward with all these emotions and personal struggles together as brother and sister. Some people might be too young or too involved to really see the fact that this is not anthem for Josh's heartbreak. This does not come from a dark place. It is full of hope, positivity, support and love. Please try to understand and respect it. This is the guy that we liked as who he is not because of his associations and we should manage to reflect that like and support with its own unique measurement from now on. I believe he doesnt want to be seen as doing everything because of or for an old relationship. That's not fair to him. He is his own man and he deserves to be acknowledged as a sole strong and successful person that he is. Hope you all will read this and give it a thought. Have a great day! xxx
JoshuaDTV No worries at all :) I am just glad that you get to see this super rambly and highly emotional comment. Hope it managed to lift up your mood even just a little bit.
I actually started crying when josh started crying. I had such a good day today and when I saw this video I got sad! When I listened deeper into the song I started to remember my Pop (grandpa) who died from double lung transplant in the surgery! What I'm trying to say is everyone has someone they love in their life and has lost them, for example they died or broke up with them like josh! I hope you are reading this josh! If you are then have a positive and happy life and don't let anyone stop that! Like my Pop said "Live Life To The Fullest"
Their voices are so soothing.. Josh, I put my phone near my tummy while listening to this song and my baby started kicking and moving. Your guys voices just makes him so happy😊 I know you're in a tough place right now, but you still never fail to bring us happiness❤️ WE LOVE YOU!!
One of my favorite songs, ever. I never even knew that Erin sang...and this is just beautiful! I just lost my mother to cancer, so I'm emotional anyway...but this brought me to tears. Much love to you Josh during this difficult time!
Im not quite robotic but the older i get the less and less i cry at outward things (that have nothing to do with me) and im not even a Josh follower but this video broke me down and gave me all the feels. Pretty powerful.
Wow... You can see Joshua's pain and its like Erin knows what he's going through.... Its very rare to get a divorce like this because most divorces end with an argument or something and there both glad about it but Joshua's and Colleen's was heartbreaking but they both know that it had to be done otherwise they wouldn't be happy in there future..... Amazing song guys 10 out of 10! :)
I cried so hard to the point I thought I was gonna die.Love is a hard thing to find then keep forever.I pray for you josh and hope your sister helps you get through this rough time!Love you Erin and Josh😘💖
All these years later and this still, every time, makes me cry. The purity of emotions that leaps from this, is just undeniable. They are both so vulnerable and giving, thank you again, Josh & Erin. Xo
Way to go Josh and little sis. Show the world how you can rebuild your life after a devestating time with class and integrity. Beautiful duo. Keep giving people going through something like this hope. You are amazing!
This made me cry really hard. I'm going through a breakup right now with a guy I dated for 5 years. I'm sure it's not compared to what you're feeling- going through a divorce must be even worse. Still, I felt like I could feel and relate to what you were feeling in this video. Really beautifully sung
I'm sorry to hear about your breakup, but just know that you are always going to be strong enough and capable enough to take whatever life throws at you, Hope all is well :)
Lora Smith I also went through a breakup three months ago and I know exactly how devastated and lost you feel. I felt the same way. But please try to find little things in life that will make you happy and I swear that you will feel better soon. I found happiness again and I know you will too.. hang in there ❤❤❤
This song is so incredible when Cyndi Lauper first released it, the impact was insane. One of my favorite versions of it when she sang It on David Letterman in 1986. So wonderful to have a song that can withstand time and take new forms!
2:10 I had tears in my eyes. I was reading the description while watching the video and I just couldn't hold it back. This is such a powerful video. The fact that they had the strength to make this video is amazing.
I know. I was doing just fine till I saw them crying then I read the description and my heart hurt so much for them, and I seriously can't stop crying right now. I used to and still do honestly feel how Josh is feeling right now because of a recent relationship. Although seeing this reopened a lot of wounds, it also helped to feel the pain again. I wish I could hug Josh so bad right now, my heart hurts so much for both him and Colleen. I know where they are both coming from, but I feel so bad for Josh he is such an incredible young man and I hope he knows that even through all of this.
I know it was what she wanted, I respect that. But she really let a good one go with Josh. Obviously, no one is perfect. I don't doubt their relationship had its flaws, but Josh is such a good hearted man. You don't find many like him these days.
FrancescaJoliet well ya maybe, but really all you knowing him is what he shows you. It he proved he didn't show all. So how can say that he was a really good one, without ever knowing him. I'm just saying, that's what I always think about. A lot of youtubers are just showing you one part.
FrancescaJoliet it wasn't what she wanted. it was because she couldn't make him happy, according to the video she posted. I'm really disappointed I Joshua's fans because of all the hate they're giving colleen. she's not the only one hurting right now.
I’ll never get over this. The pain associated with this cover still makes me cry to this day. Erin, thank you for being there for me Joshua. Pamela, thank you for picking up the pieces and helping build him back up.
Josh! Remember that everything happens for a reason and the difficult times that you been through is not the end but the beginning for a new and hopefully a more beautiful chapter in your life. Saty strong and I love you 💜
Josh, you are such a beautiful soul. Thank you for showing your true colors to us. Thank you for being vulnerable and allowing yourself to grieve and sharing this beautiful and difficult process with us. I have so much respect for you. You are also very lucky to have such an amazing and supportive sister and family. Listen I know you don't want to hear this, but I do not agree at all with the way Colleen handled this. It appears she didn't even try. Haven't y'all ever heard that "the first year of marriage is the hardest?" It truly is and it deserves to be fought for! You deserve to be fought for! Why is it okay to be there for the "better" but as soon as "worse or hard" kicks in people just quit?! You never get to experience the rainbow after the rain when you give up. (Not that you gave up, just speaking in general) I have been married for 10 years (also have 3 kids) and believe me we have had some lows. But we have never lost sight of our goal. We always fight fair, we never put each other down and we never give up on each other. You deserve someone who isn't going to give up on you. And let me say this "nice guys DONT finish last!" You are a nice guy. And my husband is a nice guy. My husband and I are total opposites. (Not that I'm not nice, I'm just a little spunky for lack of a better word :) I am very outspoken and can be a little difficult sometimes. We are Christians and I believe y'all are as well. I believe that their is a woman out there who will love, cherish and fight for you as much as you do for her. My husband has taught me so much about compromise and not giving up when things get hard. And I have helped him find his voice and stick up for himself. He sometimes has a hard time telling me how he feels. But I have always been very careful to not take advantage of his kindness and have helped him find his voice. We compliment each other. It is just my opinion, that it takes a special person with a good heart who isn't self consumed with fame, material items or "worldly things" to make a great marriage work. You are that special person and you deserve the same. I am so sorry that Colleen broke your heart and broke your vows but Josh I promise you God knows what He is doing in this. Please keep your faith and do not allow others to put you down or make you feel bad about yourself. I sincerely hate the way Colleen is handling this, acting as though it doesn't matter but I believe that everything is planned by God (good or bad) before it happens and that there is a master plan behind it. I promise you one day when you are sitting around the dinner table with your beautiful wife; who adores you, and your children having dinner, you are going to smile and remember me telling you this. You will find your happiness and one day you will see this as a good thing because you will see that you are being respected, treated and loved far more than you could have ever imagined and with someone who is willing to fight for you and your marriage. I sincerely pray you read this and feel encouraged. I won't say a bad word about Colleen because I know you love her but I do feel like you deserve better than the way this has played out. I am praying for you. I love your heart and I hope you will continue sharing it with us. Sincerely, Audra Pearson
Audra Pearson This is essentially the point I was trying to make in my post, but I guess my wording offended or pissed some people off. But my gosh you really hit the nail on the head. Thank you!
+Audra Pearson, are you me in the future?? I feel like the relationship you are explaining with your husband is exactly me and my boyfriend of 4 years. with all this going on and a couple other divorces happening around me I've been talking to my boyfriend about it and really making sure that our differences won't be an issue in the future (we plan on getting married when he graduates in 2018) I'm outspoken and constantly asking him and making sure I'm not upsetting him in any way because he's not used to speaking to anyone about his feelings. I agree with everything you said, as a Christian I don't take divorce lightly and it really breaks my heart when I hear anyone has to go through it. So I fear future consequences that may lead to it, but no matter how difficult it may get, I really believe it's important to fight for love, if there is still love for each other, there is still a chance, right? And you may even emerge as a stronger couple because of it! Thank you for your words of wisdom!!
Here in 2022. Still crying. Gone through true heartbreak and heartache in the last two years and I click on this because you just feel it. Such a beautifully sad and raw video.
This is no doubt one of THE toughest things that can happen to you. But a year on and you will realise nothing else can break you if you can make it through this! You just seem so genuine. You will be OK ! X
I don't know if you'll see this Josh. I wanted to say that I love you. Been a big fan for over a year but I fell in love with who you are as a person, your light shines so bright and you have helped me go through some dark things. I lost the man I loved so much so in a way I understand all of this. He thought he wasn't good enough for me. Thank you for coming back. This is a beautiful cover. Keep strong and keep smiling Josh. 💖💙
I've come back to watch this so many times. when you first uploaded it, I didn't want to deal with any of the breakup drama, so about a week ago I came back and I watched this. this song makes me tear up each time I watch it. Erin and Josh, you did this song justice
I feel like from when they first mentioned their divorce Colleen has kept her feelings out of the public eye, while Josh has put it all out there. I personally would probably be more like Colleen in this situation. But, honestly, we need to stop comparing the two. People cope with things in different ways and they have different opinions on how much they want to show the world. In the end, whatever helps them heal is what they should do. I support both of them and hope they are doing alright.
exactly. they cope in different ways and no one should take sides or critique the other for how they're dealing with everything right now. everyone is different in many aspects and they each show as little or as much as they want. just because colleen happens to be showing less about personal life and feelings doesn't mean she's feeling less. she's choosing what to put out there which are the videos she's proud of and happy moments with loved ones. and just because josh puts out things that appear to be more heartfelt and sad doesn't mean he feels any more than colleen. no one knows what goes on behind the screen.
Molly Kenny I think I'd be private too if I got married and promised forever and then less than a year later you decide to love your job & traveling more than your husband and when he asks you to go to therapy you do it alone and when you ask her to take time off she says no and files for divorce
I think Josh is just being honest with everyone. He can't put on a front, nor should he have to. Recording a song like this is appropriate. And who knows how many other people out there relate to him right now and his heartbreak and pain, and needed this tonight.
That is not true Colleen and Josh had a beautiful relationship if you go and watch their vlogs you can tell that they really did love each other, Colleen most likely could just not handle the many little side fights and disagreements
2:48 -3:17 THAT RAW SIBLING MOMENT! That care in Erin's eye for her brother knowing that she's there and she understands cause he dealt with heartache too! You'll make it through Josh... AMAZING! :')
2 1/2 years later and this is still one of the most emotional, beautiful things in the world. Forever crying and having full body goosebumps from this video. ❤
man. The genuine emotion and the protective and loving way Erin looks at her brother made me cry. Josh, I'm just a random youtube comment, but I hope you get through this... break-ups suck, especially when it's not a mutual want. No, I don't hope. I KNOW you will get through this.
This song has meant a lot. I just lost my 19 year old sister in August. To you this might mean getting through a divorce but to me this means getting through the loss of a sister
Bea Smith That's fucking rude. Get the hell out of here with your shit because people are clearly going through hard times and you aren't fucking helping anyone.
This was beyond words. The talent, passion, emotion, & honesty shines through this video. I can't wait to watch your content from now on. I know that it'll be hard, but I have a feeling that you're going to show a side of you that hasn't been shown before, & more honest than ever. You don't have to share all of your personal business, but we sure do appreciate the rawness that you can present in your situation that is all too similar amongst people.
Also, Erin, your voice is beautiful! And of course, Josh, as always. I love you both so much, and I pray for you always. Continue to lean on each other. What a beautiful relationship. Thank you. Thank you for sharing this with us. ❤️
![Justin Timberlake and Anna Kendrick - "True Colors" Live at Cannes [OFFICIAL] | TROLLS](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Bp9qOlKB0F4/mqdefault.jpg)
one of the most heartfelt and vulnerable moments in your life and you expressed it just how you know how to best. so proud of you josh. you can feel how intense this time in your life is through this video. that's important because that's what you do when your heart is broken. you feel. and you're not afraid to do that. really admirable. love you always brother. also erin's voice is unreal.
You're a great friend Julien
Julien, Josh is lucky to have you. Stay strong Josh, we love you❤❤
Julien Solomita this was so cute and intense you guys should be a duo
follow me
Now that Josh's back, I feel it even better how empty this place seemed because of his absence.
The pain in his eyes fucking killed me
ikr same :(
Me too 😢
True
Aimee Caldwell same 😭💜
You can clearly see it.. I dont even understand how people can say this is fake for attention. It's clear he has a lot of pain. :(
it's so cute that they're wearing the same shoes, it warms my heart
Awe I love this
they're meant to be matching that's the point hahahah
Zeney Steyn and that's why I love it!!
I still watch this video over and over. It's the most beautiful and raw expression of emotion ever. I know this post will be lost in a sea of comments, but if there's even a chance it will be seen... I must say how powerful this was to me. Much love from Georgia
I agree - and you said that beautifully... Love, from Phoenix Arizona
killinmesma11s me too
killinmesma11s ♥️❤️♥️❤️ from Central CA. Aug 30. #cryingfordays got this on REPEAT! Love you Evans'
killinmesma11s same
I got in it when the color poped out
Josh, I am 62 and so have had a lot of life experience. I want to encourage you that in one year from now as you look back over this whole painful situation you will see that both you and colleen will be in a better place for both of you. Hearts break and hearts can mend if you chose that....Josh, chose that. Don't keep any stored up negative energy in your body...and for you I suggest you sing it away...yes...sing your emotions and thoughts and let the energy labeled pain poor out of you and you will be wiser, gentler, more forgiving of others and a generator of much peace
Agreed!
terry crane awww that is so amazing great advise I'm subscribing to you
This was beautiful thanks for being positive and sharing your wisdom
Couldn't have put it better 💕💕💕
terry crane Perfectly said!
2:50 "can't remember when the last time I saw you laughing." THE LOOK ON ERIN'S FACE BROKE MY HEART
Hannah G SAME
I felt the same :(
she really means it. she is looking at her brother who she has had some of the greatest laughs with of her life, and her eyes tell us that she feels helpless towards him. absolutely beautiful example of sibling love, she loves him with all her heart and she wants him to be happy again.
OMG ERINS VOICE IS SOOOOO GOOD!!!!! I was truly crying during this. who else did.
Meee!! :") I like started balling my eyes out during the second part.
Sanjana Menon yeah
me it's so sad 😭😭😭
Maddie Estes me
Maddie Estes my mom was next to me and I just started balling and she thought I was playing candy crush
Sometimes I come back to this and I don't think I've ever see a true raw emotional Performance like this when he started to cry. I'm so sorry you went through all of this, but hindsight is truly 20/20, and you are better where you are now.
I WASNT EMOTIONALLY PREPARED FOR THIS
RebelliousWarrior ikr I'm crying so hard
Same
RebelliousWarrior same I cried I really wish Colleen didn't do this to him
Gabriella Littleton how dare you say that they just went their separate ways like most people do can't you just deal with that
RebelliousWarrior same
When Joshua broke down, I teared up.
Sippy Cup yes same but I think he feels good being able to do that
Sippy Cup Same
Sippy Cup ditto.
Dana Le'Anne uh
Daniella Radchenko bruh your just RUDE and gross for saying that Josh is going through tough times and the ppl who care about him are with him through this.
This was super touching and equally amazing to watch. I cried a lot because within a song you guys manage to fit genuinity, family love/support, and making peace with dark patches of your life. This was real and beautiful. I have insane amount of respect for you that you come forward with all these emotions and personal struggles together as brother and sister. Some people might be too young or too involved to really see the fact that this is not anthem for Josh's heartbreak. This does not come from a dark place. It is full of hope, positivity, support and love. Please try to understand and respect it. This is the guy that we liked as who he is not because of his associations and we should manage to reflect that like and support with its own unique measurement from now on. I believe he doesnt want to be seen as doing everything because of or for an old relationship. That's not fair to him. He is his own man and he deserves to be acknowledged as a sole strong and successful person that he is. Hope you all will read this and give it a thought. Have a great day! xxx
lovely comment!
wow... a genuine comment for a genuine person....
this comment means everything to me. thank you. honestly. thank you.
pure beauty ❤
JoshuaDTV No worries at all :) I am just glad that you get to see this super rambly and highly emotional comment. Hope it managed to lift up your mood even just a little bit.
when he starts showing tears and Erin just holds him....
hiraa wiandaa soooooooo cute
Probably just like u
That's when😢
😢😢😢😢
Gets me every timmeeee
I actually started crying when josh started crying. I had such a good day today and when I saw this video I got sad! When I listened deeper into the song I started to remember my Pop (grandpa) who died from double lung transplant in the surgery! What I'm trying to say is everyone has someone they love in their life and has lost them, for example they died or broke up with them like josh! I hope you are reading this josh! If you are then have a positive and happy life and don't let anyone stop that! Like my Pop said "Live Life To The Fullest"
Their voices are so soothing.. Josh, I put my phone near my tummy while listening to this song and my baby started kicking and moving. Your guys voices just makes him so happy😊 I know you're in a tough place right now, but you still never fail to bring us happiness❤️ WE LOVE YOU!!
❤️
OurLifeTogether ❤️❤️❤️
OurLifeTogether that's sooo cute❤️❤️
Yes, I agree 100%. Im going to fall asleep to this song for the next 4 million years! I love you guys so much!!!
OurLifeTogether ❤❤❤
the amount of sadness and hurt in his face kills me on the inside man i love him.
I think of Erin often ❤ I hope her and her little family are doing well. Sending her love wherever she is today xo
One of my favorite songs, ever. I never even knew that Erin sang...and this is just beautiful! I just lost my mother to cancer, so I'm emotional anyway...but this brought me to tears. Much love to you Josh during this difficult time!
Kat's Pick Jewelry ❤️
Kat's Pick Jewelry god bless you and your family it must be hard
Kat's Pick Jewelry I'm sending lots of love and positive energy your way. I lost my mother almost 3 years ago to cancer and I miss her every day.
Kat's Pick Jewelry I lost my beloved bunny today, for an unexpected illness.. the pain is just so much..
Kat's Pick Jewelry Sorry about your mother ❤
I'm like a robot and never cry at anything, but this had me in tears. I think I'm dead
Madeline Nettles same 😢😢
Same!!! And it didn't only happen the first time I watched it, but the 2nd time... 3rd time...
Welcome to the other side Madeline Nettles, we're all hot messes right now xxx
Im not quite robotic but the older i get the less and less i cry at outward things (that have nothing to do with me) and im not even a Josh follower but this video broke me down and gave me all the feels. Pretty powerful.
I can't stop replaying this, his sister's voice is so beautiful 😍
Diniera Hasna that's not the point
Sabina Zahiri lol wot
Diniera Hasna i agree
Wow... You can see Joshua's pain and its like Erin knows what he's going through.... Its very rare to get a divorce like this because most divorces end with an argument or something and there both glad about it but Joshua's and Colleen's was heartbreaking but they both know that it had to be done otherwise they wouldn't be happy in there future..... Amazing song guys 10 out of 10! :)
keir ramsey Erin also went through a divorce
yea i know its horrible... :(
keir ramsey Erin also went through a divorce so she knows what it feels like
@@kaitlinbeckett3057 Not in the public though.. so it was magnified and she hurt for him im sure.
I cried so hard to the point I thought I was gonna die.Love is a hard thing to find then keep forever.I pray for you josh and hope your sister helps you get through this rough time!Love you Erin and Josh😘💖
I hope josh finds his happiness
Sarah Nicole Erin has also been through a divorce she said it in Josh's video whilst he was recovering the video is called 'divorce and healing'
Sarah Nicole same
Sarah Nicole well said. And I agree 100%
Sarah Nicole me to
I feel sooo bad for josh i wish I could do something about it😭😭😭 i love u Joshua❤️ i pray for u every day🙏🏾 I'll always be here for u🙂
I love both of u💋
Erin's voice😍 who knew?!!
Ani MM truw
Ani MM josh
Ani MM ikkkkk
ikr!! I love her voice!!!!
Ani MM i completely agree. i really want erin to make more covers with josh
All these years later and this still, every time, makes me cry. The purity of emotions that leaps from this, is just undeniable. They are both so vulnerable and giving, thank you again, Josh & Erin. Xo
I don't know if this was a one sided divorce, but this video really shows how emotionally deep and just amazing josh is; sorry mate.
Divorce wasn't my choice. I would have tried and worked on things no matter what.
I feel you in some very similar ways, I wish the best for you, this video is truly filled with emotion. You have a kind heart.
Again, sorry mate, truly.
damn.... I didn't think Joshua would reply to this. i'm still in utter hurt about this all, for both parts.. I feel like I personally know them
omg josh replied! But I agree with your comment
Wow I totally feel his pain and I see that his sister also sees the pain her brother is going through! Wow that song was powerful!
She is also going through a divorce. She said it on his channel before he came back
Natasha Aiken lol
Richard Bouska she went through a divorce too look at his channel you might see it
Im so happy youre back, Josh. Hugs your way and hope you have been ok. Your sister is just lovely by the way. Just like you are
Emmy Engström agreed!
Emmy Engström very much agreed !
Emmy Engström agree
I remember watching this the year it was uploaded. Still my favorite cover of this song.
luv Erin's voice when with Josh and without. both amazing voices. still praying for you and all of your family
my favorite song now
The more I watch, the more I cry. This is beautiful.
Lauren Holste same
OMG Erin has such a good voice for singing and this song mad me cry its so beautiful.
made*
Amanda Kromrie me two I watch his divorcing like a million times and cried and this one
Amanda Kromrie same
I knew you were telling the truth all along. I hope your life is filled with happiness and joy because you deserve all the best
Way to go Josh and little sis. Show the world how you can rebuild your life after a devestating time with class and integrity. Beautiful duo. Keep giving people going through something like this hope. You are amazing!
Tara Monks your comment was nice ignore the child
Beautifully said Tara Monks.
Tara Monks true dat
This made me cry really hard. I'm going through a breakup right now with a guy I dated for 5 years. I'm sure it's not compared to what you're feeling- going through a divorce must be even worse. Still, I felt like I could feel and relate to what you were feeling in this video. Really beautifully sung
Lora Smith stay strong 😊😊❤️
I'm sorry to hear about your breakup, but just know that you are always going to be strong enough and capable enough to take whatever life throws at you, Hope all is well :)
Lora Smith Yay Stay strong 💗
Lora Smith ❤️❤️❤️
Lora Smith I also went through a breakup three months ago and I know exactly how devastated and lost you feel. I felt the same way. But please try to find little things in life that will make you happy and I swear that you will feel better soon. I found happiness again and I know you will too.. hang in there ❤❤❤
Omg. This is my new favorite song. Like ever. I'm crying. Ok bye.
Hailey Clark same
Hailey Clark cya then 😅😅
Hailey Clark me too!!
This song is so incredible when Cyndi Lauper first released it, the impact was insane. One of my favorite versions of it when she sang It on David Letterman in 1986. So wonderful to have a song that can withstand time and take new forms!
Its almost been a YEAR now. I feel your pain, I broke down listening to this.
Alia RBLX a year for what
Emma Regan :/
2:10 I had tears in my eyes. I was reading the description while watching the video and I just couldn't hold it back. This is such a powerful video. The fact that they had the strength to make this video is amazing.
Abigail Network I know same here
Abigail Network same
Abigail Network good not agree more with you... ❤️
I know. I was doing just fine till I saw them crying then I read the description and my heart hurt so much for them, and I seriously can't stop crying right now. I used to and still do honestly feel how Josh is feeling right now because of a recent relationship. Although seeing this reopened a lot of wounds, it also helped to feel the pain again. I wish I could hug Josh so bad right now, my heart hurts so much for both him and Colleen. I know where they are both coming from, but I feel so bad for Josh he is such an incredible young man and I hope he knows that even through all of this.
Super Giggles I love how people are just looking are just like "same!" To actual meaningful comments it's really sad what economy has come to.
I'm not gonna lie, I started crying when Josh started to cry. I loved the song, it was beautiful!!❤️ I loved Erin's voice, its so beautiful too!
Sammy Mumbauer right when he put his head down I lost it
Sammy Mumbauer me too😭😭❤️
Sammy Mumbauer I agree I really loved this
same😨
😰
i'm crying with you....
I know it was what she wanted, I respect that. But she really let a good one go with Josh. Obviously, no one is perfect. I don't doubt their relationship had its flaws, but Josh is such a good hearted man. You don't find many like him these days.
FrancescaJoliet well ya maybe, but really all you knowing him is what he shows you. It he proved he didn't show all. So how can say that he was a really good one, without ever knowing him. I'm just saying, that's what I always think about. A lot of youtubers are just showing you one part.
FrancescaJoliet it wasn't what she wanted. it was because she couldn't make him happy, according to the video she posted. I'm really disappointed I Joshua's fans because of all the hate they're giving colleen. she's not the only one hurting right now.
It's not me saying anything about her. I love her and I'm more of a fan of her than his honestly.
Alex Taylor I said that. I know I don't know him personally. I know things aren't always what they look like. It's just unfortunate.
FrancescaJoliet you never know who made the divorce happen. it want just all her.
This hits harder when you know the pain and context of all that C did to Josh. I am so so glad Joshua survived. ❤ We are so happy you are here.
so as a girl who deals with depression this song has lifted me... thank you
+Carla Bogart, I've been going through depression too. Everything's going to be okay. This song always makes me feel so much better.
Every single time I watch this I cry
Jorgiana Jenkins: same. why do I keep watching over and over?
+melissa stegall bc it's too damn good!
same....
hello
"every single time"? LML its been out for a few hours how many times did u watch this?
TWINS!!!!! 😂😂😂
Josh, I missed you SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much!!!!!!!
Erin, YOUR VOICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And THE FEELS! I broke up with someone near and dear to my heart. I know it is hard. I will get easier. Love you so much.
Mackenzie Buchter me too. It will be okay. :)
Who else didn't know Erin could sing.
yeah, totally took me by surprise !! must run in the fam !!
Vincent Winston Ii me omg
Vincent Winston Ii 🙋🏼
Vincent Winston Ii me!
Vincent Winston Ii no idea omg she is SOOOOOO good whith gosh aswell I bet u r as them
I just had the worst day of my life and watching this video made me burst out crying
THE duckyc I hope you're ok 💖
Take your time! :)
guacamole812 thank you!
Paul Wilson Tan thank you!
I hope you had a better day today :)
This breaks my heart seeing the way she looks at him with such meaning in her eyes and when they cry oh Jesus
It breaks my heart to see josh crying..
Me 2 😫😭😢
Alma Guter same here
Me too
Alma Guter when he crys, I cry
Alma Guter me too 😭😭
I’ll never get over this. The pain associated with this cover still makes me cry to this day. Erin, thank you for being there for me Joshua. Pamela, thank you for picking up the pieces and helping build him back up.
Josh! Remember that everything happens for a reason and the difficult times that you been through is not the end but the beginning for a new and hopefully a more beautiful chapter in your life. Saty strong and I love you 💜
Lama Abdullah everything doesn't happen for a reason. Sometimes life just sucks. But he will move on and find someone deserving to be loved by him.
Laurie Beth H Josh is such a great guy and he will move on and I truly hope that he finds his true love!
Beebs A. Lol I live in Alabama, so I won't be anywhere near her, but didn't you just do what you accused me of doing? Hypocrite.
For some reason every time I watch this I'm cutting onions
i feel you :(
Who started cutting onions next to me?!?!?????? 😭😭
We love you Josh X stay strong dude ❤️❤️❤️
Eloraa Ccripps oops, it was me... Sorry about that
Eloraa Ccripps oops my bad it was me too
Eloraa Ccripps me and I'm cutting them with you :,/
This sibling relationship is so beautiful!
It makes me miss my little brother so much 😔
I see so much pain and grief in his eyes... and in the eyes of his sister,who knows perfectly what he is dealing with.. I am so sorry for him ..
Erin's voice is beautiful
I can tell that Erin was crying
Why am I crying??? Omg it hurts me more to see him hurting.....
Me too😭
same
Cynthia White same i agree with you fully
I am still crying every time I watch this. It´s so beautiful and raw! They are SO talented!!
3 years later and it still makes me cry.
Ditto 💔
Same
I'm actually sobbing so happy your back you were missed and you are loved 💓
Dianna Ysabel omg same
Erin is such a good singer!! (so is Josh but we already knew that)
Erin Emiko yep
Erin Emiko I was very curious about how did she sound like she sounds so good
I don't know anything about these two people, but that girl's voice is pure gold.
So sad! Especially since they have both been divorced. This is a hard time in Josh's life but hopefully, eventually, he can move on and be happier!
I'm just glad they didn't have kids!
Jen W Erin was divorced??
Olivia Soto YES 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😢😯👺😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😩😫😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😟😞😔😭😭😭😭😭
Jen W yes
Olivia Soto yes!
Josh, you are such a beautiful soul. Thank you for showing your true colors to us. Thank you for being vulnerable and allowing yourself to grieve and sharing this beautiful and difficult process with us. I have so much respect for you. You are also very lucky to have such an amazing and supportive sister and family. Listen I know you don't want to hear this, but I do not agree at all with the way Colleen handled this. It appears she didn't even try. Haven't y'all ever heard that "the first year of marriage is the hardest?" It truly is and it deserves to be fought for! You deserve to be fought for! Why is it okay to be there for the "better" but as soon as "worse or hard" kicks in people just quit?! You never get to experience the rainbow after the rain when you give up. (Not that you gave up, just speaking in general) I have been married for 10 years (also have 3 kids) and believe me we have had some lows. But we have never lost sight of our goal. We always fight fair, we never put each other down and we never give up on each other. You deserve someone who isn't going to give up on you. And let me say this "nice guys DONT finish last!" You are a nice guy. And my husband is a nice guy. My husband and I are total opposites. (Not that I'm not nice, I'm just a little spunky for lack of a better word :) I am very outspoken and can be a little difficult sometimes. We are Christians and I believe y'all are as well. I believe that their is a woman out there who will love, cherish and fight for you as much as you do for her. My husband has taught me so much about compromise and not giving up when things get hard. And I have helped him find his voice and stick up for himself. He sometimes has a hard time telling me how he feels. But I have always been very careful to not take advantage of his kindness and have helped him find his voice. We compliment each other. It is just my opinion, that it takes a special person with a good heart who isn't self consumed with fame, material items or "worldly things" to make a great marriage work. You are that special person and you deserve the same. I am so sorry that Colleen broke your heart and broke your vows but Josh I promise you God knows what He is doing in this. Please keep your faith and do not allow others to put you down or make you feel bad about yourself. I sincerely hate the way Colleen is handling this, acting as though it doesn't matter but I believe that everything is planned by God (good or bad) before it happens and that there is a master plan behind it. I promise you one day when you are sitting around the dinner table with your beautiful wife; who adores you, and your children having dinner, you are going to smile and remember me telling you this. You will find your happiness and one day you will see this as a good thing because you will see that you are being respected, treated and loved far more than you could have ever imagined and with someone who is willing to fight for you and your marriage. I sincerely pray you read this and feel encouraged. I won't say a bad word about Colleen because I know you love her but I do feel like you deserve better than the way this has played out. I am praying for you. I love your heart and I hope you will continue sharing it with us.
Sincerely, Audra Pearson
Audra Pearson This was said so perfectly all I can do is applaud you! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Audra Pearson This is essentially the point I was trying to make in my post, but I guess my wording offended or pissed some people off. But my gosh you really hit the nail on the head. Thank you!
Audra Pearson Beautifully stated and I agree 100%
Rachel Landry Saunier Thank You! That was very kind. I hope he reads it and really understands how special he is.
+Audra Pearson, are you me in the future?? I feel like the relationship you are explaining with your husband is exactly me and my boyfriend of 4 years. with all this going on and a couple other divorces happening around me I've been talking to my boyfriend about it and really making sure that our differences won't be an issue in the future (we plan on getting married when he graduates in 2018) I'm outspoken and constantly asking him and making sure I'm not upsetting him in any way because he's not used to speaking to anyone about his feelings. I agree with everything you said, as a Christian I don't take divorce lightly and it really breaks my heart when I hear anyone has to go through it. So I fear future consequences that may lead to it, but no matter how difficult it may get, I really believe it's important to fight for love, if there is still love for each other, there is still a chance, right? And you may even emerge as a stronger couple because of it! Thank you for your words of wisdom!!
OMG I LOVE HOW THEYRE MATCHING THATS SO CUTE!!!
This is beautiful!
Here in 2022. Still crying. Gone through true heartbreak and heartache in the last two years and I click on this because you just feel it. Such a beautifully sad and raw video.
I am not crying, I'm just cutting onions😭
Dance moms Edits lol
Dance moms Edits same 😭
Dance moms Edits same 😿
Dance moms Edits same 😭
Dance moms Edits hi
Welcome back Joshua! We all missed you! And man do the Evans have talent ❤
I agree💗💗
Angel Marie ikr I missed hin
*him
Welcome back Josh!! We missed you!!
Feel better soon
am I the only one who watches this over and over but still tears up? :'(
I can't say anything else because I'm speechless, I love you both
agreed
Lucinda 101 thankyou one other person like me who loves both of them
Lucinda 101 When Josh started to cry, I just bursted into tears. I miss him so much.😟
Hes a good guy.... a REALLY good guy.
This is no doubt one of THE toughest things that can happen to you. But a year on and you will realise nothing else can break you if you can make it through this! You just seem so genuine. You will be OK ! X
Sama r You will never be given anything in life that you can't handle or bear.... 😀
such a raw and beautiful duet ❤️
raybans&suntans ' agreed
*still listening a year later and crying
Leah Harris me too.
Leah Harris im listening for the 86th time in 2018
Leah Harris girl same!! Now 2 years later! 😭😢
3 years later and this still makes me cry
Leah Harris *3 years
this is by far my favorite song that i've heard you sing! and i never realized erin had such a beautiful voice too
andddd i'm crying 😕
Jackie Harris I feel so bad right now :/
SAME HERE
me too.
Jackie Harris Erin's better than josh.
Such an amazing song. You and Erin are a great duet. No matter what we all here are there for you!
You made me cry what I saw the tear streaks running down your face.
I don't know if you'll see this Josh. I wanted to say that I love you. Been a big fan for over a year but I fell in love with who you are as a person, your light shines so bright and you have helped me go through some dark things. I lost the man I loved so much so in a way I understand all of this. He thought he wasn't good enough for me. Thank you for coming back. This is a beautiful cover. Keep strong and keep smiling Josh. 💖💙
Update, it’s 2022 and this still moves me.
I always come back to this.
Its Now 2023🫶
@@not_sweatyundeez6029summer 2023. True colors everywhere and it is delicious cumpuppence. 😅
Josh your back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Keep loving yourself
You are un amazing person
Stay strong
We all love you
Be happy everyday
Don't cry
Think about all the good things in life nothing bad
Evelyn Robinson Don't cry craft
Josh you are honestly so inspiring. Love is always in your heart, just keep the light in your life.
Omg I feel your pain halp
I've come back to watch this so many times. when you first uploaded it, I didn't want to deal with any of the breakup drama, so about a week ago I came back and I watched this. this song makes me tear up each time I watch it. Erin and Josh, you did this song justice
So glad you have Pamela. It’s great to see you smile again. But watch this every once in awhile and I now hate seeing you so sad.
erins voice absolutely salys my life
Joshs is amazing as well
Wow.. Im speechless
What am i doing With ny life Pham, I cried. I am SO GLAD AND HAPPY HE'S BACK!!
What am i doing With ny life so much pham
love your profile pic ;)
What am i doing With ny
I love my phamily
I feel like from when they first mentioned their divorce Colleen has kept her feelings out of the public eye, while Josh has put it all out there. I personally would probably be more like Colleen in this situation. But, honestly, we need to stop comparing the two. People cope with things in different ways and they have different opinions on how much they want to show the world. In the end, whatever helps them heal is what they should do. I support both of them and hope they are doing alright.
exactly. they cope in different ways and no one should take sides or critique the other for how they're dealing with everything right now. everyone is different in many aspects and they each show as little or as much as they want. just because colleen happens to be showing less about personal life and feelings doesn't mean she's feeling less. she's choosing what to put out there which are the videos she's proud of and happy moments with loved ones. and just because josh puts out things that appear to be more heartfelt and sad doesn't mean he feels any more than colleen. no one knows what goes on behind the screen.
Molly Kenny I think I'd be private too if I got married and promised forever and then less than a year later you decide to love your job & traveling more than your husband and when he asks you to go to therapy you do it alone and when you ask her to take time off she says no and files for divorce
I think Josh is just being honest with everyone. He can't put on a front, nor should he have to. Recording a song like this is appropriate. And who knows how many other people out there relate to him right now and his heartbreak and pain, and needed this tonight.
Hailey Josh shouldnt get back together with her in the first place. He couldve found the real love of his life by now.
That is not true Colleen and Josh had a beautiful relationship if you go and watch their vlogs you can tell that they really did love each other, Colleen most likely could just not handle the many little side fights and disagreements
I'm watching this exactly 3 years after and it's hard to believe that it's been that long! Great song, I'm still crying 💖👌
2:48 -3:17 THAT RAW SIBLING MOMENT! That care in Erin's eye for her brother knowing that she's there and she understands cause he dealt with heartache too! You'll make it through Josh... AMAZING! :')
JoshuaDTV Please sing more with Erin. I love this!
Yassssss I agree!!!!!
YAY JOSH!! Welcome back and we missed you but we treated your sister great and we loved her! ❤️❤️❤️
Woo the feels! You guys are amazing ❤️
welcome back josh
2 1/2 years later and this is still one of the most emotional, beautiful things in the world. Forever crying and having full body goosebumps from this video. ❤
Back again ❤
I love Erin's voice
ALSO THE DESCRIPTION
Jamie Myrick-Duckett Cubing same her voice is beautiful and Joshua's also!! I've watched them for like 3 years and this made me cry 😭
Jamie Myrick-Duckett Cubing same
Me to this is such an amazing duet and I'm soo glad you are back josh I missed you
ERIN HAS AN AMAZING VOICE!!!
this made me cry
Michael McCarthy same
Omg! I love this so much that I watched it 40 times already
I love Erin's voice😍
YESSSS
Same!!!
Danika Boissonneault samee it's amazing
Danika Boissonneault actually make that 400 times 😭😭😭
Erin is so adorable, Josh and Erin are so lucky to have eachother..If I could of had them for siblings my life would be unbelievable ❤️
man. The genuine emotion and the protective and loving way Erin looks at her brother made me cry.
Josh, I'm just a random youtube comment, but I hope you get through this... break-ups suck, especially when it's not a mutual want. No, I don't hope. I KNOW you will get through this.
OMG I'm actually crying this is so beautiful...
same erin has such a beautiful voice and so glad josh is back
Me too it got to be right at the end
OMG is it only me who started crying when they started crying
Niamh Donnelly me 2
Niamh Donnelly nope lol I was like "Oh no here I go *starts crying*"
Lol me 2
nope your not the only one
Niamh Donnelly me
Im sorry you went through so much. Im sorry people doubted you. You truly are an amazing soul and you deserve all the happiness!
This song has meant a lot. I just lost my 19 year old sister in August. To you this might mean getting through a divorce but to me this means getting through the loss of a sister
Bea Smith That's fucking rude. Get the hell out of here with your shit because people are clearly going through hard times and you aren't fucking helping anyone.
+Bea Smith is that really necessary? :(
I hope you never experience that kind of loss, only to Gabe someone say something so heartless to you.
to have**
Lauren, I'm so sorry for your loss! that's awful ♡ ♡
Lauren Adderley , I lost my sister on August 19 too. she was 22. it was an unexpected nightmare. I know and feel your pain.
This was beyond words. The talent, passion, emotion, & honesty shines through this video. I can't wait to watch your content from now on. I know that it'll be hard, but I have a feeling that you're going to show a side of you that hasn't been shown before, & more honest than ever. You don't have to share all of your personal business, but we sure do appreciate the rawness that you can present in your situation that is all too similar amongst people.
Autumn D love y'all
You are amazing josh x keep being you, thats what shines the brightest x
Autumn D hey josh
Autumn D same! I loved it so much I actually cried. I didn't realize Erin had such a beautiful voice
JoshuaDTV you are incredible you have one of the best voices ever
Beyond BEAUTIFUL. I love you two so much. ❤️ #cryingfordays
Also, Erin, your voice is beautiful! And of course, Josh, as always. I love you both so much, and I pray for you always. Continue to lean on each other. What a beautiful relationship. Thank you. Thank you for sharing this with us. ❤️
EDucating Shanny omg Shanny I love you so much!!💗💗❤️❤️ I was crying throughout the whole video
y
2 questions....
who else started crying when they did?
who else wants to do a duet with josh?
me
Every time
Me
At 2:53 I feel Erin was saying that genuinely and that completely breaks my heart
I thought the same exact thing :'( I just want them all to be happy.