Winter is so talented being the lead dancer lead vocal sub rapper and is the also official visual so she gets a lot of screentime... she's also the most famous member (also known as aespa's fancam queen) along with karina so SM is i think capitalizing on that , and also the fact that she is also called yoo young jin's daughter who is in charge of most aespa songs and title tracks. Lastly sm is so notorious for the mistreatment of their foreign idols. Im not saying ningning is mistreated, its just that being the main vocal, its her job to do so.
Actually Ningning had the more powerful vocal in savage and in their other song forever, she also does a lot of the backing vocals. Winter has an amazing range but ningnings voice is richer and actually she changes it up more but winter has a higher voice while ningnign is deeper. I do agree I think you’re just smitten because if you listen again you’ll see that savage was ningnings era and girls was more winter but they both have each other to set up each other’s notes lol
Technically ningning is a better vocalist than winter. But winter's voice can easily reach high register notes. Ningning is very powerful and excellent on the low register and also her vocal agility is insane.. I mean her runs is everything
@@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON everyone can choose their fave voice. It's called preference. I do respect that. Mine is karina's voice. But the fact is ningning is still technically the best vocalist in aespa
When u think its ningning at first prechorus in illusion, that's karina bro😁 The second prechorus is harmonizing between ningning and winter And at the bridge when the high note " come get illusion" its karina and winter😁
Ningning and Winter both have their strengths. I love both. Karina’s vocals are very underrated.. she can sing at a high level. But she is always mixing up the rapping along with vocals and being the main dancer. She gets the most attention for her visuals and dancing but she is the ace for sure. They did a few stage performances of illusion and Girls .. those are awesome and worth checking out.
Guys i am new to your channel but it seems like you are new to the fandom as well lol idk if you are going to respond but i hope you at least read it.Just fyi, ik its for fun and i liked your friendly debate but watch out with Ningning vs Winter cause there are a lot of toxic fans and the hate that Winter is getting is already enough ;( With so many Winter anti's in the fandom its actually cool to see a reactor that has her as bias since imo she is doing the most in the group.However she is so underappreciated when it comes to her talent that it hurts-whenever someone praises the vocals its always about Ningning[understandable],about the rapping-Giselle[understandable],about the dancing-Karina[understandable] but whenever someone praises Winter it's just because of her visuals[which i mean- understandable as well but she is a whole package too,not only visual]. Now idk how familiar you are with blackpink but i'll put it like that-Winter is basically Jennie 2.0 when it comes to the hate that she is getting,especially these days is so bad that the hashtag #SMProtectWINTER is trending... Btw she is currently sick but when it comes to the music and award shows i think that she will push herself for the performances just like she did the last time when she was sick and if we win there will be encore stage,it will be cool if you check it out + if you are going to react to songs that dont have MV can you please check the line distribution one,so you know who is singing[there is a line distribution videos for each and every one of their b-sides as well],thanks!Please spread nothing but positivity,I enjoyed your reaction and review +1
Thank you so much!!! It’s sad to hear about the toxicity in these fandoms. But we would rather enjoy their talents than dwell in that toxicity. We’re having fun becoming fans and have friendly debates between our biases. They are just so good and talented - all of them - that we would rather stay in the fun and positive side of things!!! Sad to hear alll of that stuff about Jennie in Blackpink too.
Guy with the mustache doesn’t know about singing. Ning is the better singer. High notes aren’t everything. And Ningning’s high notes have more resonance.
i do prefer winter's voice in general but at this point im done with the ningning vs winter discussion..if you are new MY,enjoy i guess :d dreams come true is a remake of gg called S.E.S- thats why there was that robot speaking in whatever language it was,thats why the english is kinda broken and thats why the choreo is like that/they still had the aespa vibe in all of it but the main moves of the choreo for exaple the still from the original one,ty for the reaction ^^
I feel they do it yearly. Yeah, it sounds stupid but check it out. The first high note was given to Ningning from black mamba Then next level winter Then savage Ningning Then this year's music to winter Then probably next comeback to Ningning. But I hope SM does justice to Ningning being the main vocalist 🤧
can we not compare them? they are both great. But everyone agrees, and it is a fact that Ningning vocals is superior not only to aespa but to all 4th gen.
one of the reasons why winter has more high notes than Ning Ning is because she is Korean, while Ning Ning is Chinese,. Ning Ning could actually hit a higher note but since the agency didn't give her the line she should have, You can see aespa synk especially Ning Ning there she sings really well, even her pitch range shows that she is playing real vocals
Of course NingNing can hit higher notes and we all know this. The only reason can't be just because she's not korean. There could be so many other factors including maybe Winters highnote suited the song better or that she's more well known as a member of aespa making her more popular and easily recognised in mvs as a visual idk tbh but it can't be just because she's chinese
@@roro3738 I mean it's hard to tell with live perfs because they lip sync most of the time but honestly from what I heard at coachella yes, I would say Winter is very stable
uff ik you didnt- that thumbnail xD Guys careful,careful that's not the insomnia fandom,my's are wild thank you for the reaction i prefer winter too ;p
This always happens when Ning bias and winter bias are together ..... They are both very good Ning has a little bit wider range than winter in lower notes that's why she is the main vocal however Ningning doesn't get the main highnotes most of the time becuz unfortunately Sm never treat their Chinese artist right and winter is more popular in Korea so they pushed her a lot to shine more .... however they are both good
In KPOP there is normally a position for each member: Karina - Leader, FOTG, Main dancer, Lead Rapper and Sub-vocalist Winter - Visual, Lead dancer and Lead Vocalist Giselle - Main Rapper and Sub-vocalist Ningning - Main Vocalist FOTG - Face of the Group since Karina is a Goddess Visual - The one that will always stick your eyes with But in reality they Allrounder everyone can sing, dance, rap and they all freaking gorgeous.
*"aespa ‘ep2. Next Level’ - SM Culture Universe"* *It's a 17 minute video. It was released before aespa - 'Life's Too Short (English Ver.)' MV.* *Btw they performed 'Life's Too Short' at Coachella 2022*
The only reason why winter gets those high notes its bc she's korean and ningning is chinese, the company will always favor the korean members over the foreigners. With that being said, ningning can easily reach the same high notes as winter and even higher. overall, she has the widest range vocal and best vocal technique in aespa thus she got the main vocal position
That is not true. Rather add concessions to foreigners. It really depends on who's the most popular member. If the member who sells well is a foreigner, they invest in the member who sells well
Contrary to what mys are actually saying, most of them are criticizing winter for having the most lines and hitting the high notes saying its strained and unsupported which is clearly not true if u ask professional vocal teachers. In fact, winter is the most stable member in the group esp if u watch their coachella vid wherein nn hit the savage note in falsetto but winter went on to belt with her chest voice. It's just so funny how its her own fandom who hates winter the most when clearly she's the most capable member.
Thank you for commenting actual facts! I want someone to point what do they mean by ''strained and unsupported'' when it comes to Winter because I don't hear that and I'm not a random person who has zero idea about that like most who are commenting...I feel like she is getting too much hate for no reason,this girl is so capable...It is not a secret that she is the most stable one when it comes to actual live performance,not only coachella but more recently on GMA.During the black mamba performance they were all singing but whenever Winter did,she did it louder for the troll in the back,hitting the notes with ease while doing the choreo and being the most stable one once again.Maybe that's why she got the most lines this comeback and probably will continue for future ones. I can't wait for encore stage like the Savage one ^^
I disagreed ……her voice is kind of irritated ears but also NingNing can still reach to her range easily you just avoided -__- and live they only got one...cant totally tell who is better but the thing is Smart announcement Ning is main vocalist.but winter always high note I'm just can't take more now……
Well first of all thank you guys for the reactions,I am looking forward to them every week and I want to apologize for the long comment in advance.I'm Karina bias and her voice is the best IMO cause she's bringing something new to the table/her voice is lower and more powerful.When it comes to Winter and Ningning...Me personally,I don't think that there is something like main vocal in aespa and even if there was,it would be both of them cause they are super capable-in fact all 4 of the girls are,but like you guys were saying that there is some sort of pairing 2/2 - I do feel that as well. As for the ''power lines'' topic that you were talking about,if you are in the fandom then you will know that they are on Winter's part and it's not even a discussion. She has the ''killing part'' of the songs: Black mamba - ''I'm the aespa,there can't be two'' it went viral everywhere. Next level-it's not only her pronunciation of ''next level'' that people got addicted to,but her whole part after the switch up is what's described as ''killing part'' ,she is going off the most-growl while hitting B4 and going from E5 to sustained D5! Savage-the iconic ''Oh my gosh!Don't you know i'm a savage'' e.t...I Tried to keep this comment unbiased to the max (even tho none of them two are my actual bias) and give actual knowledge about the topics that were discussed in the video because people are always talking about things,that are have no idea about(people in general,not you guys). That was NOT an individual breakdown of their voices or saying ''who's better'' or anything like that,it's all just based on THEIR songs and the line distribution that they are GIVEN,because I feel like people keep forgetting that. I think that friendly arguments like the one you had are okay but be careful because it might backfire,a lot of toxic Ningning stans are already blaming Winter for ''stealing'' the high notes in the songs. MYs,don't hate on other member/s just because you feel like she/they are quote on quote ''stealing'' high notes or spot light,idols don't even have a saying in that...
@@WatchingSundaysThey are all amazing indeed!Why is the hate?It's really simple actually.Even though Karina and Winter are the most popular members,Ningning has BY FAR the biggest fandom within the fandom MYs,whatever aespa video you open,you are gonna see ocean of comments about her(I am actually surprised because it looks like most of the people who are watching you guys or at least those ones who are commenting have Winter as bias) but since Winter is the other ''singer'' of the group(they all are like I said up there but Winter is the only one who can be considered as competition when it comes to vocal skills) whenever she get's the high notes,most lines or more challenging vocal part of certain song,these same Ningning stans are getting real mad(not all of them of course,only the toxic ones so they eventually start dragging Winter down and hating on her) so that's how and why Winter get's so much hate from ''MYs'' as if the hate that she is getting in general beyond the fandom is not enough...
@@dannydrog6100 Eh ikr...I kinda feel bad,like gurl is talented thats why she is gonna get them parts ,where is the problem In the next comeback prob Ning will,whats the big deal? Ppl just need to let her be and in general beside music,Winto is the least problematic one ahgfhga i dont understand trolls and their jealousy
NINGNING objectively does way better above fifth octave. That’s why I don’t understand why they give Winter so many high notes. They are strained and might cause her to regress.
![[Knowing Bros] CUTE aespa Winter Compilation🥰](/img/n.gif)
Winter is so talented being the lead dancer lead vocal sub rapper and is the also official visual so she gets a lot of screentime... she's also the most famous member (also known as aespa's fancam queen) along with karina so SM is i think capitalizing on that , and also the fact that she is also called yoo young jin's daughter who is in charge of most aespa songs and title tracks. Lastly sm is so notorious for the mistreatment of their foreign idols. Im not saying ningning is mistreated, its just that being the main vocal, its her job to do so.
Fun Fact: NingNing has the most developed lower register in all of 4th gen which makes her one of the best!!!
Actually Ningning had the more powerful vocal in savage and in their other song forever, she also does a lot of the backing vocals. Winter has an amazing range but ningnings voice is richer and actually she changes it up more but winter has a higher voice while ningnign is deeper. I do agree I think you’re just smitten because if you listen again you’ll see that savage was ningnings era and girls was more winter but they both have each other to set up each other’s notes lol
I think savage was winter and Giselle era but that might simple be because they stood out to me more. But in terms of vocals it was defo NingNings era
Ningning has lots of backing vocals, her low register is so impressive.
Technically ningning is a better vocalist than winter. But winter's voice can easily reach high register notes. Ningning is very powerful and excellent on the low register and also her vocal agility is insane.. I mean her runs is everything
Ningning can do everything, that's why she's the main vocalist. The mistreatment is annoying 😫 (ain't talking abt ur comment, just saying) but yeah
@@ningbangs4304 ikr. She's technically very good
*It’s Winter for me*
@@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON everyone can choose their fave voice. It's called preference. I do respect that. Mine is karina's voice. But the fact is ningning is still technically the best vocalist in aespa
@@mohamadhidayat645
*Ikr. Winter stands out to me (Vocally). IMO*
Ningning = main vocalist
Winter = lead vocalist
Both of them are great and we should stop the argument.
11:20 Karina
13:19 Winter & Karina
Btw i love ur reaction & thanks for reacting aespa :)
👋👋❤️❤️🙏🙏
The rap part is Kwangyanese
We're not from kwangya so we can't understand
🤣
When u think its ningning at first prechorus in illusion, that's karina bro😁
The second prechorus is harmonizing between ningning and winter
And at the bridge when the high note " come get illusion" its karina and winter😁
Ningning and Winter both have their strengths. I love both. Karina’s vocals are very underrated.. she can sing at a high level. But she is always mixing up the rapping along with vocals and being the main dancer. She gets the most attention for her visuals and dancing but she is the ace for sure. They did a few stage performances of illusion and Girls .. those are awesome and worth checking out.
100% agree,thank you for the Karina appreciation for other than her visuals..
Giselle is actually most underrated vocally. Atleast Karina get the chance to showcase her vocal
Ningning can obviously do higher but...... well let's just hope this new comeback won't be like Spicy
Guys i am new to your channel but it seems like you are new to the fandom as well lol idk if you are going to respond but i hope you at least read it.Just fyi, ik its for fun and i liked your friendly debate but watch out with Ningning vs Winter cause there are a lot of toxic fans and the hate that Winter is getting is already enough ;(
With so many Winter anti's in the fandom its actually cool to see a reactor that has her as bias since imo she is doing the most in the group.However she is so underappreciated when it comes to her talent that it hurts-whenever someone praises the vocals its always about Ningning[understandable],about the rapping-Giselle[understandable],about the dancing-Karina[understandable] but whenever someone praises Winter it's just because of her visuals[which i mean- understandable as well but she is a whole package too,not only visual].
Now idk how familiar you are with blackpink but i'll put it like that-Winter is basically Jennie 2.0 when it comes to the hate that she is getting,especially these days is so bad that the hashtag #SMProtectWINTER is trending...
Btw she is currently sick but when it comes to the music and award shows i think that she will push herself for the performances just like she did the last time when she was sick and if we win there will be encore stage,it will be cool if you check it out + if you are going to react to songs that dont have MV can you please check the line distribution one,so you know who is singing[there is a line distribution videos for each and every one of their b-sides as well],thanks!Please spread nothing but positivity,I enjoyed your reaction and review +1
Thank you so much!!! It’s sad to hear about the toxicity in these fandoms. But we would rather enjoy their talents than dwell in that toxicity. We’re having fun becoming fans and have friendly debates between our biases. They are just so good and talented - all of them - that we would rather stay in the fun and positive side of things!!! Sad to hear alll of that stuff about Jennie in Blackpink too.
They released illusion choreo video~ then you can clearly know who sings each part ^0^
*IN RELEASE ORDER* :
*(1)* [STATION] aespa - 'Dreams Come True' MV --> *(2)* aespa - 'Illusion' Lyric Video --> *(3)* aespa - 'ep.2 Next Level' - SM Culture Universe --> *(4)* aespa - 'Life's Too Short (English Ver.)' MV --> *(5)* aespa - 'Girls' MV *(Latest Korean comeback)*
*Winter always stands out to me*
Guy with the mustache doesn’t know about singing.
Ning is the better singer.
High notes aren’t everything.
And Ningning’s high notes have more resonance.
Please Watching Sundays request reaction MV Hi-L - Hi-Way. They just comeback and this is their second comeback
i do prefer winter's voice in general but at this point im done with the ningning vs winter discussion..if you are new MY,enjoy i guess :d
dreams come true is a remake of gg called S.E.S- thats why there was that robot speaking in whatever language it was,thats why the english is kinda broken and thats why the choreo is like that/they still had the aespa vibe in all of it but the main moves of the choreo for exaple the still from the original one,ty for the reaction ^^
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
When loona react again ?
Saturday!!!!
Ok iam waiting for loona
Next saturday ?
Plz go to reacting SYNK of Aespa five videos of girls then gonna show you guys who is the officially main vocal in this group ，。。。stop argument lol
Plz update a reaction videosof them for us lol appreciate
*'Dreams Come True' originally belongs to a 1st gen K-Pop girl group S.E.S.*
Hey Sherlock check this out (Dreamcatcher) th-cam.com/video/UGslOxnF5fg/w-d-xo.html
love SES 😍
I feel they do it yearly. Yeah, it sounds stupid but check it out. The first high note was given to Ningning from black mamba
Then next level winter
Then savage Ningning
Then this year's music to winter
Then probably next comeback to Ningning.
But I hope SM does justice to Ningning being the main vocalist 🤧
Exactly I hope they let her shine as the main Vocalist next comeback 💔🤧
Well Ningning barely got anything in spicy unfortunately 😅
can we not compare them? they are both great. But everyone agrees, and it is a fact that Ningning vocals is superior not only to aespa but to all 4th gen.
one of the reasons why winter has more high notes than Ning Ning is because she is Korean, while Ning Ning is Chinese,.
Ning Ning could actually hit a higher note but since the agency didn't give her the line she should have,
You can see aespa synk especially Ning Ning there she sings really well, even her pitch range shows that she is playing real vocals
Of course NingNing can hit higher notes and we all know this. The only reason can't be just because she's not korean. There could be so many other factors including maybe Winters highnote suited the song better or that she's more well known as a member of aespa making her more popular and easily recognised in mvs as a visual idk tbh but it can't be just because she's chinese
@@anisaafsar4528 and also winter's the most stable doing highnotes especially in live perfs.
@@roro3738 I mean it's hard to tell with live perfs because they lip sync most of the time but honestly from what I heard at coachella yes, I would say Winter is very stable
Agree some part of what u said
Ningning's the thunder and Winter's the lightning
uff ik you didnt-
that thumbnail xD Guys careful,careful that's not the insomnia fandom,my's are wild
thank you for the reaction
i prefer winter too ;p
It’s all in good fun!!! 🤣
This always happens when Ning bias and winter bias are together ..... They are both very good Ning has a little bit wider range than winter in lower notes that's why she is the main vocal however Ningning doesn't get the main highnotes most of the time becuz unfortunately Sm never treat their Chinese artist right and winter is more popular in Korea so they pushed her a lot to shine more .... however they are both good
she gets most of the main high notes in aespa’s songs tho, she also has the most
@@nnaiixx4360 no she doesn't especially in recent comeback like Spicy and Salty & Sweet
*Back again with more aespa reactions*
Yaaas!!! 👋👋👋 a friendly argument between us two 🤣
@@WatchingSundays
YEAH !!
Bruh?? You guys think it's ningning in first prechorus? Karina did that!!!
In KPOP there is normally a position for each member:
Karina - Leader, FOTG, Main dancer, Lead Rapper and Sub-vocalist
Winter - Visual, Lead dancer and Lead Vocalist
Giselle - Main Rapper and Sub-vocalist
Ningning - Main Vocalist
FOTG - Face of the Group since Karina is a Goddess
Visual - The one that will always stick your eyes with
But in reality they Allrounder everyone can sing, dance, rap and they all freaking gorgeous.
Me a Giselle bias, just standing in one corner hoping she has more lines to sing or even rap lol!
*random_k made a line distribution video for aespa's 'Illusion'. You can check out that video by your own*
Yes! We should’ve done that!!
*"aespa ‘ep2. Next Level’ - SM Culture Universe"*
*It's a 17 minute video. It was released before aespa - 'Life's Too Short (English Ver.)' MV.*
*Btw they performed 'Life's Too Short' at Coachella 2022*
Reaction mini album savage aespa please 🙏🙏
The only reason why winter gets those high notes its bc she's korean and ningning is chinese, the company will always favor the korean members over the foreigners. With that being said, ningning can easily reach the same high notes as winter and even higher. overall, she has the widest range vocal and best vocal technique in aespa thus she got the main vocal position
That is not true. Rather add concessions to foreigners. It really depends on who's the most popular member. If the member who sells well is a foreigner, they invest in the member who sells well
Contrary to what mys are actually saying, most of them are criticizing winter for having the most lines and hitting the high notes saying its strained and unsupported which is clearly not true if u ask professional vocal teachers. In fact, winter is the most stable member in the group esp if u watch their coachella vid wherein nn hit the savage note in falsetto but winter went on to belt with her chest voice. It's just so funny how its her own fandom who hates winter the most when clearly she's the most capable member.
Sad to hear any kind of hate on anyone from this group!!
Thank you for commenting actual facts! I want someone to point what do they mean by ''strained and unsupported'' when it comes to Winter because I don't hear that and I'm not a random person who has zero idea about that like most who are commenting...I feel like she is getting too much hate for no reason,this girl is so capable...It is not a secret that she is the most stable one when it comes to actual live performance,not only coachella but more recently on GMA.During the black mamba performance they were all singing but whenever Winter did,she did it louder for the troll in the back,hitting the notes with ease while doing the choreo and being the most stable one once again.Maybe that's why she got the most lines this comeback and probably will continue for future ones. I can't wait for encore stage like the Savage one ^^
I disagreed ……her voice is kind of irritated ears but also NingNing can still reach to her range easily you just avoided -__- and live they only got one...cant totally tell who is better but the thing is Smart announcement Ning is main vocalist.but winter always high note I'm just can't take more now……
@@PP-js1qx winter is better at live singing though
@@minjeongvisualace do yall hate ningning or something
WTF is girth? LOL
🤣🤣 it’s our way of reacting to rap lines that hit hard!!!
Well first of all thank you guys for the reactions,I am looking forward to them every week and I want to apologize for the long comment in advance.I'm Karina bias and her voice is the best IMO cause she's bringing something new to the table/her voice is lower and more powerful.When it comes to Winter and Ningning...Me personally,I don't think that there is something like main vocal in aespa and even if there was,it would be both of them cause they are super capable-in fact all 4 of the girls are,but like you guys were saying that there is some sort of pairing 2/2 - I do feel that as well. As for the ''power lines'' topic that you were talking about,if you are in the fandom then you will know that they are on Winter's part and it's not even a discussion. She has the ''killing part'' of the songs: Black mamba - ''I'm the aespa,there can't be two'' it went viral everywhere. Next level-it's not only her pronunciation of ''next level'' that people got addicted to,but her whole part after the switch up is what's described as ''killing part'' ,she is going off the most-growl while hitting B4 and going from E5 to sustained D5! Savage-the iconic ''Oh my gosh!Don't you know i'm a savage'' e.t...I Tried to keep this comment unbiased to the max (even tho none of them two are my actual bias) and give actual knowledge about the topics that were discussed in the video because people are always talking about things,that are have no idea about(people in general,not you guys). That was NOT an individual breakdown of their voices or saying ''who's better'' or anything like that,it's all just based on THEIR songs and the line distribution that they are GIVEN,because I feel like people keep forgetting that. I think that friendly arguments like the one you had are okay but be careful because it might backfire,a lot of toxic Ningning stans are already blaming Winter for ''stealing'' the high notes in the songs. MYs,don't hate on other member/s just because you feel like she/they are quote on quote ''stealing'' high notes or spot light,idols don't even have a saying in that...
Thank you!! We’re having a friendly debate indeed! But weird they there would be a level of hate in any of these girls!! They’re all amazing!!
@@WatchingSundaysThey are all amazing indeed!Why is the hate?It's really simple actually.Even though Karina and Winter are the most popular members,Ningning has BY FAR the biggest fandom within the fandom MYs,whatever aespa video you open,you are gonna see ocean of comments about her(I am actually surprised because it looks like most of the people who are watching you guys or at least those ones who are commenting have Winter as bias) but since Winter is the other ''singer'' of the group(they all are like I said up there but Winter is the only one who can be considered as competition when it comes to vocal skills) whenever she get's the high notes,most lines or more challenging vocal part of certain song,these same Ningning stans are getting real mad(not all of them of course,only the toxic ones so they eventually start dragging Winter down and hating on her) so that's how and why Winter get's so much hate from ''MYs'' as if the hate that she is getting in general beyond the fandom is not enough...
@@dannydrog6100 Eh ikr...I kinda feel bad,like gurl is talented thats why she is gonna get them parts ,where is the problem
In the next comeback prob Ning will,whats the big deal? Ppl just need to let her be and in general beside music,Winto is the least
problematic one ahgfhga i dont understand trolls and their jealousy
@@Fitri-fr3fc ningning is not problematic
*Dreamcatcher dropped SuA's 'No Dot' [Special Clip]*
🔥🔥
NINGNING objectively does way better above fifth octave. That’s why I don’t understand why they give Winter so many high notes. They are strained and might cause her to regress.
*Btw ITZY will comeback on July 15th*
😱😱😱