The niners don’t want to do that because I guarantee he’ll have an amazing season with a healthy team and some trades, only reason Brock is struggling this year
Don't know about that. He will be an Unrestricted Free Agent after next season and can sign with anyone (cannot be franchised). If he has a healthy team and performs better than this year (highly likely) he will be worth what the QB market value is then, as opposed to now. $60mil will be the starting point. And if they don't sign him, what then? Draft another Trey Lance (their early round draft pics suck lately)? Sign an FA whose best years are behind him (49ers specialty)?
We jumped the boat on Jimmy G thinking he was the guy.. then quickly we released how screwed we were cause we couldn’t get rid of him and were locked into all that salary. Can we please learn for once. Yes, Purdy is better, but let’s see how one more year works out.
With this years performance he should be grateful that the Niners are even willing to discuss an extension. With this performance he would be benched if it was another team.
No!!!! Let him play out his contract, if he doesn’t like it, have his agent go out and see who will pay him what he wants, or find a team willing to trade for him for a Number one pick!
@@NickB0102 anyone with a functional brain knows that Brock is worth $50m. He’s taken his team to 2 ships & 1 bowl. & 7 or 8 out of the 10 highest paid quarterbacks has never come close to that
NOT A CHANCE!!! Look, I like Brock. I think he's the best NFL story since the rise of Kurt Warner and the Champion Rams. But Brock isn't Kurt. He doesn't have the arm strength to be a threat. His legs are just serviceable, but not a threat. He doesn't have the coaching staff currently to elevate his game. And he's providing to be injury prone. Brock is good. But he's not THAT DUDE!! Not to mention, the NFL is chock full of QBS who are backups just chomping at the bit to get a shot as a starter (shout out Josh Dobbs). When healthy, the Niners are one of the deepest teams in talent and have shown flashes of being top tier. But as much as we like Brock, the TEAM has too many other options they can employ to replace Brock and his delusions.
Because Brock had a major injury, this was his prove it year and this season didn’t go well. 49ers must demand another prove it year, to see if his arm is ok.
Guess what guys? If Trey Lance did the exact same thing Purdy has done thus far in his career with the Superbowl appearance and all I'm not giving him 60 million either... Let's be honest people Purdy has been over and under throwing receivers since last season.. Overthrowing a wide open receiver on the winning drive in the Superbowl for the win was all I needed to see... Jimmy G. Did the exact same thing folks took the money and ran... The Kapernick quarterback curse...😮 It's Groundhogs Day for the Scapegoat City 49ers stay tuned... 😂😂😂 I think they should get rid of Purdy and Shanahan truthful do Shanahan like they did Harbaugh nobody's else is going to leave or quit when Shanahan's out the door.. The team probably would throw a big party afterwards... Shanahan and Purdy are myths.. Shanahan's a genius play caller losing up 28-3 halftime in the Superbowl and Purdy's an all- world quarterback who can't throw the ball in the rain.. 🌧️
Brock needs to prove that he’s worth the money after a down season. We keep paying players for past performances . He has not shown much this season and therefor he has to prove that this year was an aberration rather than what is the norm, which is an average QB . The Niners have been blessed and spoiled by great QB’s and have always mad it a goal each season that’s it’s looking to win a Super Bowl . We as fans have high expectations as should the owners .
Trade Brock to Pittsburg for Fields or trade him to Cleveland for Thompson-Robinson and keep Dobbs next season cuz they Dobbs/Fields/Thompson-Robinson are all faster mobile Qbs than Brock and scrambling for some yards when no one open helps A LOT.
@@A_r78 You're not a GM either. I like Brock, but he's getting worse and worse didn't even pass to an open Taylor Jr but went for a double covered Jj instead and got picked. Thompson and Fields would scramble for some yards more like Mahomes and Lamar.
Brock’s situation isn’t the same at all as Lamar Jackson’s. Brock has played well in the playoffs and taken the 49ers to 2 NFC Championships and a Super Bowl - before getting paid. Lamar was 1-3 career in the playoffs and had never got out of the divisional round
I don't live in SF but have been a staunch Niners fan for 15 years, but, I will stop being a Niner fan if they give Purdy the big money cuz they will never be an elite team with him!
The 49ers can't make him play out his contract. He will sit out until he is paid they can either pay him or trade him but him playing under this contract next year isn't happening. He is going to want to be the highest paid QB because it's his turn to get paid. The 49ers can try to stall but other QB's will get paid and just raise the price on Purdy.
Here is my question for you both. What precisely is it that you think makes a quarterback worth $50 million a year or more? What precisely is it that you want him to prove to you? Here is the reality. There are only 2 quarterbacks in the NFL right now that have won a Super Bowl in the past 10 years: Patrick Mahomes and Matthew Stafford, and neither of them make over $50 million a year. Here is the career playoff record of the quarterbacks who do: Dak Prescott - 2-5; Lamar Jackson 2-4; Joe Burrow 5-2; Jared Goff 5-5; Jalen Jalen Hurts 2-3; Trevor Lawrence 1-1; Jordan Love - 1-1; Tua Tagovailoa - 0-1; Justin Herbert 0-1. And of this list, only Dak, Lamar, and Jared have ever been to the playoffs more than twice. You realize Joe Burrow’s entire pedigree as a quarterback rests on 2 playoff runs in which he bested Mahomes once. And let’s not forget, he gets to throw to the same receivers he threw to in college. Lamar and Dak are terrible in the playoffs. Jared Goff plays well if his line is perfect in protecting him but cracks in the playoffs every time that fails. Jalen Hurts is feast or famine in the playoffs. So we should lowball one of the 3 most successful playoff quarterbacks of the last 10 years because we’ve been down 20 players all year. I cannot make that make sense. Who should he compete with? A Rookie? No rookie has ever gone to a Super Bowl. Sam Darnold, who couldn’t beat Brock out last year as he came off UCL surgery and who has never started a playoff game in his life? Kirk Cousins, who flamed out of Atlanta and is a career 1-3 in the playoffs and has never got past the divisional round? This is absolutely ridiculous on its face.
There was no competition.... lol. Stop sipping the Emperor Kyle kool-aid bro. There was fake competition with Brock, Sam and Trey. It was always gonna be Brock starting. They said it to make it seem like Brock earned it. Now let's say Sam legitimately didn't win by that logic wouldn't that make Kyle look stupid for listening to the fans adoring Brock instead of who can make his offense look even better? Or was it that Kyle is just not good with quarterbacks so Sam found someone who can give him a shot?? They all fade out under him. As far as playoff success goes.... Bro we should have never been in the super bowl. Brock got real lucky in the lions game when he over threw Aiyuk and the defender had the ball bounce off his face mask and Aiyuk makes a miracle of a catch. Let's not act like it was a great play.... 😂😂😂 Lamar and Josh Allen has done far more with less than Brock. Hell Lamar is looking even better than Brock did last year right now without all pro receivers. These guys actually carry the team. Brock does not. I'll take it a step further. Jimmy G did more with less for the 49ers. Team was 1-10 before he got in. No playbook rallies off 5 straight wins with bum receivers. Went 8-0 to start 2019 throwing to Kendrick Bourne, Trent Taylor and Dante Pettis😂😂😂😂 Cmon man. That's a crop of bums there. Just because the market is the market and Tua, Dak, Trevor and whoever got paid doesn't mean the 49ers HAVE to participate in the same thing. Go get someone else who can be just as good cheaper through the draft via free agency/trade. You may even get someone better than Brock. 49er fans are too scared of change. Remember Bill didn't give a damn about what the fans thought when he went with Steve instead of Joe. Harbaugh didn't give a damn about the fans feelings when he continued to start Kaepernick over Alex. Why we acting like Brock is some qb elite? Oh because he got the most 120 or 130 passer ratings?? Who cares. Did that win anything championships? No. Does that equate to being a greater player than a Tom Brady or a Peyton Manning because he had great numbers earlier than those guys?? No. Stats are the stats. What you do on the field is what really matters. You go win games especially the tight close games.
I thought i was the only one who is seeing that. They really did not even mention how injury ridden the entire team was. How 9er receivers had the least amount of separation out of all the teams. Aiuyk started rusty as hell after his contract negotiations. Deebo is 30lb lighter and dropped a lot of passes. O-line is also terrible. Also, I hear a lot of brain dead takes like “he is a nobody without his elite players” . Lmao, show me who is… the only exception this year was Allen. Mahomes was carried by defense and with game deciding calls or blunders seemingly going their way every single time.
100% agree with letting him play out his contract and prove it. I do believe he can as well.
his contract is over..?
The niners don’t want to do that because I guarantee he’ll have an amazing season with a healthy team and some trades, only reason Brock is struggling this year
Don't know about that. He will be an Unrestricted Free Agent after next season and can sign with anyone (cannot be franchised). If he has a healthy team and performs better than this year (highly likely) he will be worth what the QB market value is then, as opposed to now. $60mil will be the starting point. And if they don't sign him, what then? Draft another Trey Lance (their early round draft pics suck lately)? Sign an FA whose best years are behind him (49ers specialty)?
@@underrated4499that’s a boldface lie lol. That’s only one of MANY rzns y Brock is struggling this year
We jumped the boat on Jimmy G thinking he was the guy.. then quickly we released how screwed we were cause we couldn’t get rid of him and were locked into all that salary. Can we please learn for once. Yes, Purdy is better, but let’s see how one more year works out.
With this years performance he should be grateful that the Niners are even willing to discuss an extension. With this performance he would be benched if it was another team.
No!!!! Let him play out his contract, if he doesn’t like it, have his agent go out and see who will pay him what he wants, or find a team willing to trade for him for a Number one pick!
Hell nah dude doesn’t have any leverage if he believes he is worth $50m - $60m play your final year
Brock is getting paid for $50m. Cry about it
@ are you paying him?
@@NanszuI guess you’re paying Purdy $50m because the Niners won’t. Niners have no money to pay a spaghetti arm quarterback.
@@NickB0102 anyone with a functional brain knows that Brock is worth $50m. He’s taken his team to 2 ships & 1 bowl. & 7 or 8 out of the 10 highest paid quarterbacks has never come close to that
So you’re saying Steve Young a hall of fame and a true elite quarterback brain is dysfunctional that’s messed up
NOT A CHANCE!!! Look, I like Brock. I think he's the best NFL story since the rise of Kurt Warner and the Champion Rams. But Brock isn't Kurt. He doesn't have the arm strength to be a threat. His legs are just serviceable, but not a threat. He doesn't have the coaching staff currently to elevate his game. And he's providing to be injury prone. Brock is good. But he's not THAT DUDE!! Not to mention, the NFL is chock full of QBS who are backups just chomping at the bit to get a shot as a starter (shout out Josh Dobbs). When healthy, the Niners are one of the deepest teams in talent and have shown flashes of being top tier. But as much as we like Brock, the TEAM has too many other options they can employ to replace Brock and his delusions.
No let him play it out.
Because Brock had a major injury, this was his prove it year and this season didn’t go well. 49ers must demand another prove it year, to see if his arm is ok.
Guess what guys? If Trey Lance did the exact same thing Purdy has done thus far in his career with the Superbowl appearance and all I'm not giving him 60 million either... Let's be honest people Purdy has been over and under throwing receivers since last season.. Overthrowing a wide open receiver on the winning drive in the Superbowl for the win was all I needed to see... Jimmy G. Did the exact same thing folks took the money and ran... The Kapernick quarterback curse...😮 It's Groundhogs Day for the Scapegoat City 49ers stay tuned... 😂😂😂 I think they should get rid of Purdy and Shanahan truthful do Shanahan like they did Harbaugh nobody's else is going to leave or quit when Shanahan's out the door.. The team probably would throw a big party afterwards... Shanahan and Purdy are myths.. Shanahan's a genius play caller losing up 28-3 halftime in the Superbowl and Purdy's an all- world quarterback who can't throw the ball in the rain.. 🌧️
That's the truth
get RIDDA THE BUM. unless you wanna suffer the next 5 YEARS and remain just a contestant in the NFC WEST. !!
Future Browns QB
Brock needs to prove that he’s worth the money after a down season. We keep paying players for past performances . He has not shown much this season and therefor he has to prove that this year was an aberration rather than what is the norm, which is an average QB . The Niners have been blessed and spoiled by great QB’s and have always mad it a goal each season that’s it’s looking to win a Super Bowl . We as fans have high expectations as should the owners .
Purdy better have a Lamar esq campaign his contract year then back it with another mvp type season to let them know
What nonsense are you talking about smh
Should’ve gone hard after Brady and Rodgers back when those guys were relevant. Could’ve had a few more rings by now.
3 weeks left and out of the playoff race with 15 TDs? No leverage Bro
The Lamar Jackson treatment sounds like the best bet
Who would extend any player that’s playing terrible? Please?
The Cowboys did.
Is that Juice's J-strap on the tree?
Trade Brock to Pittsburg for Fields or trade him to Cleveland for Thompson-Robinson and keep Dobbs next season cuz they Dobbs/Fields/Thompson-Robinson are all faster mobile Qbs than Brock and scrambling for some yards when no one open helps A LOT.
Brock is more valuable to trade for picks than pay him $60 million-
💯 Thanks for saying my thoughts exactly.
Lmaoo
Fields is buns
Thompson also BUNS
This is why you’re not a GM
This ain’t madden
@@A_r78 You're not a GM either. I like Brock, but he's getting worse and worse didn't even pass to an open Taylor Jr but went for a double covered Jj instead and got picked. Thompson and Fields would scramble for some yards more like Mahomes and Lamar.
@@patrickland4367 Agreed.
Isn’t he 8-8 in his last 16 regular season games?
Brock’s situation isn’t the same at all as Lamar Jackson’s. Brock has played well in the playoffs and taken the 49ers to 2 NFC Championships and a Super Bowl - before getting paid.
Lamar was 1-3 career in the playoffs and had never got out of the divisional round
If they pay Brock this year, I'm considering rooting for a different team.....😢 I'll be back when Management changes.
I'm bent.
I can acknowledge how special Brock has been, but do I want to sign him to a Max deal? Mmmmm I'm leaning towards no
Yup
I don't live in SF but have been a staunch Niners fan for 15 years, but, I will stop being a Niner fan if they give Purdy the big money cuz they will never be an elite team with him!
The 49ers can't make him play out his contract. He will sit out until he is paid they can either pay him or trade him but him playing under this contract next year isn't happening. He is going to want to be the highest paid QB because it's his turn to get paid. The 49ers can try to stall but other QB's will get paid and just raise the price on Purdy.
HELL NO ! hasn't proved himself YET.. earn it FIRST like everyone else..
Extend the man contract there's nobody out there better
Sure but it won't be 60 million.
Don't do it baby I said they should not have paid jimmy
Anyone thinking cousins? 😂
Throw in mordecai! 😂
Throw in the practice squad qb lol
John n Kyle are lousy at negotiating contracts, players end up getting what they want. Jed loves to write fat checks too.
Make Brock play out his contract and tag him if he sucks again $60 million? This guy isnt Mahomes or Josh Allen they dont choke in big games
Tell me what all pros Brock makes better no one smh
Brock is not him.. We need to look for a real QB for once..Kyle needs to stop with the bs..
Here is my question for you both. What precisely is it that you think makes a quarterback worth $50 million a year or more? What precisely is it that you want him to prove to you? Here is the reality.
There are only 2 quarterbacks in the NFL right now that have won a Super Bowl in the past 10 years: Patrick Mahomes and Matthew Stafford, and neither of them make over $50 million a year. Here is the career playoff record of the quarterbacks who do: Dak Prescott - 2-5; Lamar Jackson 2-4; Joe Burrow 5-2; Jared Goff 5-5; Jalen Jalen Hurts 2-3; Trevor Lawrence 1-1; Jordan Love - 1-1; Tua Tagovailoa - 0-1; Justin Herbert 0-1. And of this list, only Dak, Lamar, and Jared have ever been to the playoffs more than twice.
You realize Joe Burrow’s entire pedigree as a quarterback rests on 2 playoff runs in which he bested Mahomes once. And let’s not forget, he gets to throw to the same receivers he threw to in college.
Lamar and Dak are terrible in the playoffs. Jared Goff plays well if his line is perfect in protecting him but cracks in the playoffs every time that fails. Jalen Hurts is feast or famine in the playoffs.
So we should lowball one of the 3 most successful playoff quarterbacks of the last 10 years because we’ve been down 20 players all year. I cannot make that make sense.
Who should he compete with? A Rookie? No rookie has ever gone to a Super Bowl. Sam Darnold, who couldn’t beat Brock out last year as he came off UCL surgery and who has never started a playoff game in his life? Kirk Cousins, who flamed out of Atlanta and is a career 1-3 in the playoffs and has never got past the divisional round?
This is absolutely ridiculous on its face.
There was no competition.... lol. Stop sipping the Emperor Kyle kool-aid bro. There was fake competition with Brock, Sam and Trey. It was always gonna be Brock starting. They said it to make it seem like Brock earned it. Now let's say Sam legitimately didn't win by that logic wouldn't that make Kyle look stupid for listening to the fans adoring Brock instead of who can make his offense look even better? Or was it that Kyle is just not good with quarterbacks so Sam found someone who can give him a shot?? They all fade out under him. As far as playoff success goes.... Bro we should have never been in the super bowl. Brock got real lucky in the lions game when he over threw Aiyuk and the defender had the ball bounce off his face mask and Aiyuk makes a miracle of a catch. Let's not act like it was a great play.... 😂😂😂 Lamar and Josh Allen has done far more with less than Brock. Hell Lamar is looking even better than Brock did last year right now without all pro receivers. These guys actually carry the team. Brock does not. I'll take it a step further. Jimmy G did more with less for the 49ers. Team was 1-10 before he got in. No playbook rallies off 5 straight wins with bum receivers. Went 8-0 to start 2019 throwing to Kendrick Bourne, Trent Taylor and Dante Pettis😂😂😂😂 Cmon man. That's a crop of bums there. Just because the market is the market and Tua, Dak, Trevor and whoever got paid doesn't mean the 49ers HAVE to participate in the same thing. Go get someone else who can be just as good cheaper through the draft via free agency/trade. You may even get someone better than Brock. 49er fans are too scared of change. Remember Bill didn't give a damn about what the fans thought when he went with Steve instead of Joe. Harbaugh didn't give a damn about the fans feelings when he continued to start Kaepernick over Alex. Why we acting like Brock is some qb elite? Oh because he got the most 120 or 130 passer ratings?? Who cares. Did that win anything championships? No. Does that equate to being a greater player than a Tom Brady or a Peyton Manning because he had great numbers earlier than those guys?? No. Stats are the stats. What you do on the field is what really matters. You go win games especially the tight close games.
Just cut him
God grant Cohn fans are brainless 😂
I thought i was the only one who is seeing that. They really did not even mention how injury ridden the entire team was. How 9er receivers had the least amount of separation out of all the teams. Aiuyk started rusty as hell after his contract negotiations. Deebo is 30lb lighter and dropped a lot of passes. O-line is also terrible.
Also, I hear a lot of brain dead takes like “he is a nobody without his elite players” . Lmao, show me who is… the only exception this year was Allen. Mahomes was carried by defense and with game deciding calls or blunders seemingly going their way every single time.
@ and they call purdy a system qb and say we should’ve kept darnold, but look at Darnolds team and nobody saying shi 😂
@realjeezyjack Isn't it funny that in order to be a qb in this league, you must have arm talent, which he lacks severely. It's pathetic.
We need to bring Trey Lance Back!!! Dallas didn't pick up his 5th year opinion
Grant you are awful. Imagine you are Brock and you been under paid for the last three years. What would you do?
If he's as good as his fanboys make out, he needs to get out from under Kyle before Kyle ruins him. What would that look like?🤔