It should be regarded as one of an hidden middle German Romantic style Symphony . It's sounding so many strong influences of Spohr , Mendelssohn and Gade etc... in the background 👍 .
I really love how the two passages at 17:54 and 20:59 are emphasized with those intense timpany rolls in this interpretation, in contrast to many others.
Bravo!! Hasta ahora no estaba demasiado convencido del nuevo titular, Macelaru, pero comienza a convencerme, bravo wdrso, como siempre, bravo Macelaru!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Oh, the performance was excellent! I was trying to say that it is the only decent one on the internet. I wish Bruch's 2nd and 3rd would get published also.
2nd and 3rd movements - fantastic - i would surmise the symphony is neglected with the outer movements not holding their own - material is okay but not strong enough - not expecting Brahms or Beethoven sized grandeur, but still something that hits with a bit more emotional impact - that being said, Bruch is an amazing composer and I love a lot of his music - I simply wish all the movements were as engrossing as the slow movement
What you assert as your own opinion some critic came up with long decades ago. This critic obviously had a distaste for Bruch due to beliefs, ethnicity or whatever reasons. This symphony is as complete and flawless as one can be, daresay I'd risk that it's more coherent than any of Brahms' or Beethoven's. Forget critics and just listen to the music
@@tobyfriedman-f3t he was fond of Jewish culture and music that's sure, but we don't know his exact heritage. He could have some Jewish blood in him, but probably he himself was ambiguous about it.
@@douglasyiuchinglok307 I think it was removed before publication, so you probably need to consult the original MS or a new score if it has been published. The movement is not in the first published score available on IMSLP.
Brunch’s symphonies are unjustly neglected so it’s wonderful to have a fine live performance on TH-cam.
7
È indescrivibile tutta l'opera di Max bruch.
One of the most serene pieces of music ever written.
Revisited again. Streamed it on tv when it premiered a year ago. Beautiful!
Thank you! ❤
Wow!! Great performance!! Thank you!! :) :)
You are welcome! 😉
Nice to hear that you enjoyed it.
@@WDRKlassik :)
überwältigend! komposition und interpretation!bravooooooo
Magnifique, dommage que les symphonies de Bruch soient si peu jouer.
It should be regarded as one of an hidden middle German Romantic style Symphony .
It's sounding so many strong influences of Spohr , Mendelssohn and Gade etc... in the background 👍 .
I really love how the two passages at 17:54 and 20:59 are emphasized with those intense timpany rolls in this interpretation, in contrast to many others.
Bravo!! Hasta ahora no estaba demasiado convencido del nuevo titular, Macelaru, pero comienza a convencerme, bravo wdrso, como siempre, bravo Macelaru!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Un CD con las sinfonías de Bruch interpretado por vosotros sería genial!!!
Can't wait for 2 and 3 to come out
😊
Oh, the performance was excellent! I was trying to say that it is the only decent one on the internet. I wish Bruch's 2nd and 3rd would get published also.
2nd and 3rd movements - fantastic - i would surmise the symphony is neglected with the outer movements not holding their own - material is okay but not strong enough - not expecting Brahms or Beethoven sized grandeur, but still something that hits with a bit more emotional impact - that being said, Bruch is an amazing composer and I love a lot of his music - I simply wish all the movements were as engrossing as the slow movement
What you assert as your own opinion some critic came up with long decades ago. This critic obviously had a distaste for Bruch due to beliefs, ethnicity or whatever reasons. This symphony is as complete and flawless as one can be, daresay I'd risk that it's more coherent than any of Brahms' or Beethoven's. Forget critics and just listen to the music
@@sage_silvestris i did not know about the critics and did just listen to the music when i wrote my opinion
This finale is as powerful as Brahm’s 4th.
And yes…. Bruch was Jewish
@@tobyfriedman-f3t he was fond of Jewish culture and music that's sure, but we don't know his exact heritage. He could have some Jewish blood in him, but probably he himself was ambiguous about it.
I heard this symphony originally has five movements.
As far as I know, only the recent Trevino recording plays the original 2nd movement (Intermezzo. Andante Con Moto).
@@bomcabedal So where do you think I can find the score of that movement?
@@douglasyiuchinglok307 I think it was removed before publication, so you probably need to consult the original MS or a new score if it has been published. The movement is not in the first published score available on IMSLP.
I thought the thumbnail was Jon Snow!
The opening's far too slow - sadly.
You can't always listen to masterpieces. I wouldn't want a Rembrandt on my hallway wall.
Correction. I do like Chiaroscuro.