Heyyy, you got some actual VPs! Also as a pharmacist who always brings a VP to shift clipped in my WHITE smock chest pocket, it has never leaked on me after 3 years.
I received mine about two weeks ago. Returning what's left of it today. I used it about 10 times before the nib stopped retracting. Opened the barrel to find the spring had displaced. No amount wiggling and shoving would get it to stay back in place. I didn't like the nib anyway (though I have a couple of Mahjong pens that are fine). Glad you like yours and mine could be bad luck. Just a heads-up on what could happen and how hard it is to do a simple repair.
I belive that some of the original patents for the VP have expired. The original way the pen seals when closed is extermely clever, remarkably effective, and simple. I'm impressed.
Guilloche engravers are indeed pretty cool. Ever since I saw an Art Déco cigarette case with an intricate guilloche pattern and a gorgeous turquoise enamel on it as a kid, I've been fascinated with them and wanted to know how they produced a pattern that complex. Especially the ones that can connect multiple of the simple patterns to produce a compound oscillating pattern are really interesting.
My favorite retractable in my collection is still my Decimo. I normally don’t mind metal pens with girth but it makes a difference to my hand having the Capless compared to the decimo in my hand!
I bought one of these recently. While I'm not especially a fan of the VP, I was curious. It was a much higher quality pen than I expected and I was surprised how quickly I wrote mine dry: a fancy way of saying I happily grabbed it to write quite often.
I have been using the same two A1s, and they’re my favorite A1s so far. Thanks for the close-ups, that’s fascinating. It really feels like the quality is ramping up on these. They were good to start with, but little details seem to be improving.
Hi DB. I just barely received that exact same silver-stripes version in the mail. I absolutely love the pen, DB. I think that this particular model is trying to emulate an existing chrome-stripes version from Pilot. I switched out the Majohn nib unit with a Pilot vanishing point nib unit. This is now my favorite edc pen. Incredible value. The original version of this model is north of $300.00 at US online pen retailers. I cannot afford that.
Since the entire interior assembly of these pens are supposedly interchangeable…seems like you could simply decide which one you wanted to write like what and swap around accordingly. I have a half dozen different pens like these and haven’t changed anything around yet, but I did get a “Bobby Stub” that will replace the XF in my Black Stripe A1.
Namiki Vanishing Point. I have one and I have always liked it even though it wrote rather dry. After a few nib changes it is now sufficiently wet. So I can like it even more now.
Great review! I really like that you go over the pen in detail and even cover the little things that can be a drawback. I've got the matte black w/clip and really like it. I've also got a Pilot one in blue and chrome. I use the black one way more because of the grip. Also, interestingly, mine says Moon Man on it. Keep up the great work!
So does diping the tip for around 15 - 25ish seconds, and then wiping off as usual... The feeds work on capillary action, and some are just a tad "vapor lock" prone from an otherwise "sealed" cartridge or converter... Propping a pen nib-down for a few minutes can do it... AND a casual dip-swish in ordinary water is a helpful "jump-start"... Especially useful for pens prone to "hard-starts" whether for leaving them sit too long or just for "cheap-*ss tuning" before you quite get them "right"... NOTHING against your suggestion... It just might help someone out having a couple options... ;o)
I dipped my pen endless in water, ran it under the faucet, dipped then used a tissue to draw out the water and ink just wouldn't flow done the feed to the nib. Left it sitting nib down for 30min, etc. So did 1 drop of ink and BOOM it started flowing. My other ones were no problem but the silver one wasn't cooperating
These and the proper Pilot VP have all been great. The Pilot ones are better and the nibs feel nicer, but to me these are some of the best pens in the price category
@@bhoola123 Anything works since most of my notes are for myself or non-official. Right now I have the Diamine onyx and noodler's 54th. Will probably do Diamine salamander and oxblood next.
I am curious, for the writing test with the real Pilot vanishing point, was the nib a steel one or a gold one? Amazing review, as usual! I appreciate the use of more technical, engineering tools to widen our appreciation of fountain pens.
I just got one of the MaJohn A1 pens EF nib, with "white grid" body. It looks fantastic, feels solid in the hand, the click is super-smooth and satisfying, and it writes smooth and consistently. For $40 it is a FANTASTIC pen, I think. I also have an A2 which is fine little pen (and half the price of the A1) but it feels much lighter and less expensive than the metal-bodied A1. My only disappointment is that is isn't really "white"--it's more of a "titanium silver-gray" with bright chrome accents. I bought it to match a pocket knife and wine tool I had which have whit G10 scales, and although it looks fine with them, it's not really as "matchy-matchy" as it would be if the finish were actually "white". I'm seriously considering giving it a coat of translucent cream enamel to give it a sort of "enameled guilloche" look, to make it look more like my other EDC items...
I absolutely love your content man, you make much more enjoyable videos than other TH-camrs covering this topic. And your editing style is the best I've seen in these types of videos. I sincerely hope your channel grows. Keep up the good work and God bless you. Could you possibly review the jinhao 1200A in the future I have just bought the black finish and I want to hear what you have to say?
If Moonman really wants to be a pilot killer they will make more nib options for these pens. Of course the broader the better for me, making a stacked nib for it was a bit complicated and snug but it's possible. But the your only option is a broad architect and I'm sure some people would love a stub
I was actually looking for a thread less pocket pen and saw this. Ordered two, one was on a special silly first order price, under £1 so I got that with no clip. Majohn has some tempting pens, the p139 looks good. Shame it had threads.
I'm an early adopter of the A1 as a test balloon for the VP to see whether the clip would bother me and liked it so much that I bought a VP and a Decimo. And then I found out about the new pattern. I now have one of each in silver. Interestingly, my matte black lays down a fairly generous 0.4 line with a Pilot Pink cartridge and the stripey one writes drier and gives me a 0.3 (?) line with a Pilot Black cartridge. I haven't inked up the fish scale one yet. I'll see how it'll write. I still want a vintage Capless.
I must say, I didn't expect that I would like the A1 so much. I was hoping I would like it, not that it would turn into the pen I keep in my pocket when I go out. Simply incredible. I'd prefer it to be a little lighter, so I'm honestly considering the A2. But I still want to wait to see if it has the same good durability as the A1.
I have both an a2 and a pilot decimo both great. Love the size over the a1 and vanishing point. For a little over 20 dollars for the a2,it writes nice lela and also swaps nibs with the pilot.
@@irvintepper5 I love the decimo and A2. Putting the 18k Pilot nib in them is fun! It would be nice if Pilot sold the VP steel nib units separate from the pens.
Hey Doodlebud, Thanks again for the video! Mine showed up last Wednesday, also from 365Days Stationery Store. I started in reverse; first purchasing the original Pilot VP and was curious about the Majohn's A1. This is my second A1 and I've noticed that this new pen (Fisk Scale pattern) is a couple of grams lighter than the VP without it feeling "cheap". It's not much but it does feel a bit more comfortable. As you mentioned, the mechanism is not as smooth as a VP but it comes close. So far, it's pretty solid and seems to have good build quality. Let's see how it holds up!!! Thanks again!!
Like someone mentioned below, I wish Majohn would offer more nibs. I bought the A1 with the EF and found it scratchy and dry. I don't know how to tune a nib - maybe I need to watch a video on that - but I'd rather buy something that worked well out of the box. I wish they made a F nib.
I bought one Majohn a2 to try and I doubt Pilot has anything to worry about. I have a handful Pilot fountain pens. They work flawlessly. My first Majohn does not even write/let ink flow. At this point it is just a paper weight on my desk.
And that is the issue at this price. QC/Inspection just doesn't happen at the level it needs to ensuring an extremely low fault rate. Build quality is one thing, but ensuing & inspecting build quality is another realm all together
I have 4 A1s and 5 A2s (as well as 3 VPs), and all of my Majohn A1 & A2 nibs work without fault out of the box. At the price I wasn't expecting them all to work so well. You must have had an unlucky hand. Sorry.
I've never been a fan of the VP clip. But the no clip versions of the A1 have me intrigued. And now this "fish scale" pattern.... if they make a no clip version of it, I'm giving it a whirl.
Love my matte black A1 with the clip, very excellent copy of the VP. I definitely plan to get an actual VP at some point, and maybe a VP nib unit with a fine nib for the A1. The A1 makes a great work pen vs the VP for me because if anything happens to it I'm only out around $38, not $200+. It's also nice because it is retractable, so no fussing with the cap. The only problem I have with my A1 is the nib tends to leak a little. Unlike some people, mine seems to "leak" from the slit of the nib, not where the feed goes into the nib unit.
Another another carefully executed review showing and explaining many details. But no, I think Pilot won"t be scared at all. I've got an A1 of the first generation, overpaid it as I didn't know Aliexpress at that time and was very disappointed because the pen started to leak after one day of flat storage on a table (in a box, TG). Only a swap of the inkconverter (from Majohn model to the Pilot Con-40) stopped the leakage. Other users with the same problem swapped the nib (buying the extremly expensive Pilot VP nibs) to solve the leakages. I was so disappointed and never touched the A1 again, but bought instead the original Pilot VP, a purchase which kept me happy all the time. Since then I didn't even look at the much cheaper A2 version of Majohn and definetly won't buy the new A1 (V2), even though they look very attractive in their new colors and attractive patterns. That's me, once bitten....
I bought the Moonman body but inserted a Pilot extra fine nib unit. It works like a charm. The Moonman EF nib was not really extra fine. I also did not like the clip on the Pilot.
Cool Doodlebud.. Like I need any more of these.... Haha Guess I'm getting the silver stripe, silver fish scale, and black fish scale eventually. I already have a Maroon A-1 that I like to take to work. And I have a Pilot Fermo in silver that if i wanted could swap the nib unit into one of these if I wanted an 18k gold nib. Just wish these came in a bigger nib than just Ef. I'll probably have to do some work on them to get them where I want them as far as smoothness and wetness. I opened the tines on my maroon one to get it a bit more wet. I over micromeshed the nib though and made it kind of more flat, but interestingly enough it writes kind of like an Architect nib now and I love it has that uniqueness. Might try to do the same on some of these. Awesome review as usual man!!
Just bought an A2. New plastic version of the Moonman pen. My Pilot Decimo is really giving me problems. Scratchy. Dry, skips all the time. Even after cleaning. Looking at the nib, the tines are touching at the end. (You did a video on how to pull the tines apart. But I am scared I will ruin the nib) So, I got the less expensive A2 and will play with that nib until I feel comfortable with adjusting the nib tines.
@@Doodlebud Oh yes. A man's got to know his limitations. I used to grind and alter some old pens. Did some sack replacement and refurbishing. Now, I just use them. A Majohn A2 is $50 less than a Pilot replacement unit.
I take it that the Majohn converter has a bit more ink capacity because it does not have the agitator balls like those found on the Pilot models? The small eye dropper included is something appealing. Thank you for your video presentation.
Just jump on the Muji website or pop in if you have a Muji store in your area. They only sell form their stores or online. I don;t think their stuff is carried anywhere else.
very much enjoy the info. thank you. i tried your amazon link and i thought you'd be interested in knowing that while i can see your shop i cannot purchasing anything from there as it seems to be canada-only
Yeah I've told Amazon the problem and they keep saying its all automatically changed for the user. It's totally not happening. My traffic says I get 9000 clicks but only 7 purchases.... I don't think so Amazon.
My A1s have a terrible seal, after a couple days they hard start. Day to day they’re ok. Other than that the pen is quite nice. But my A2s are really good and start up even after more than a week of non use.
Thanks for another great review. I’m getting back into the fountain pen hobby. I started collecting in the 80s and now I have the time to get back to it. Can you send me a link of where I can find Muji paper in the US? I’m having a difficult time. I like that binder/spiral binding. Keep up the great work!
Nice looking finishes on the Majohn A1s! The Pilot VP size is on the verge of too girthy for me. The decimo is my favorite retractable fountain pen. That's why I got a couple of Majohn A2 faceted(18 facets really pay off in the light);the orange color is delightful; kind of a pinkish-orangey color. I also got a dark green A2. The The Pilot 18k nibs fit perfectly in them should you have them available. The Pilot steel-nib VP unit might be a good option if they are available separately. I hope I can find a vintage Pilot Capless someday; but,I'm pessimistic and don't want to wait for the day. The Majohn A2/A1 are very cool pens; but,the nibs leave a lot to be desired. If one is able to do the nibbage work they are great pens. Having to use a Majohn extra-fine nib is a struggle for me. The Majohn nibs I've had are dry, scratchy,needle-points that need more attention than I am currently able to provide to them.
It took me several years of looking to find a vintage one for a price I wanted, but I got it. Just takes patience th-cam.com/video/MyAKahm6Igc/w-d-xo.html
I don’t know if Pilot need be scared at all. But I know that I’m scarcely tempted at all by these blatant copies of the original. I have three original Capless/VP pens. I’m really happy to have paid for the Pilot originals. The presence of these much cheaper copies somehow makes me appreciate the originals even more.
I have several of both and definitely appreciate the might higher quality of the original but when I am going to a conference or travel I don't want to risk my VPs. The copy is definitely good for that purpose and I won't be devastated if I lose my VPs or if someone with sticky fingers gets a hold of it.
What you call "fish scale" patterning looks like knurling to me. [EDIT: That is, until you viewed it under the microscope. I've no idea what the technical description would be, but certainly not "fish scaling" or knurling]. In any case, it is textured and easy to grip. I like that the MaJohn is recessed at the center joint and doesn't have two proud (bulging) rings in the center like the Pilot (which is why I like my Decimo; the rings are much less pronounced). This is a minor complaint, but I always notice when someone says "anyways;" because I majored in English in school. My professors always corrected anyone they heard saying it. Anyway is the correct word choice. Anyways is a colloquial variant of the word anyway. It is almost universally considered incorrect.
Another great video! I've had a VP for a few years now. I have the silver fish scale A1 on the way. I've had an A2 for a few weeks. I inserted a genuine Pilot cartridge into the A2, but all of the ink leaked out the front when I extended the nib. It just completely gushed out, nearly emptying the cartridge. I'm not sure what happened as I'm very familiar with the inner workings. After cleaning the pen, I filled one of the empty cartridges included with the A2, and it works fine. Will I buy another Majohn? Probably. Will I buy another VP? Definitely.
@@Doodlebud It was like opening up a flood gate, haha! 90% of the ink just burped out. I know I had everything inserted correctly. However, once I used the refillable "Majohn" cartridge, I haven't had any leakage. I do still carry the pen in a Ziploc bag just in case... Or until I feel safe. I'm wondering if the Pilot cartridge has a slightly different shape that may not play well with the Majohn.
I had low expectations of the a1 and a2. I don’t own a vp or decimo so I can’t compare. But I love these pens. They are my pens I use throughout the day in my planner and jotting other notes. I keep waiting for issues but nothing so far! Came out of the box writing smooth with good ink flow.
I just got me an endoscope for my pen videos, but I could not find any cheapo that does more than 640X480 and the frame rate is awful. What's the model name? I might decide to splurge :)
Is the difference of both coatings(like the orange finish you said about the black one) due to the paints themselves or is it because of the pattern difference? I’m also curious about the durability of the coatings, since the first majohn a1s have been reported to flake off within months. Are both Silver and Black coatings on these new finishes flake off at the same rate, or is one of the other more durable?
Hi DB!: Not really a fan of the retractable FP's, but that Silver striped one is pretty nice looking. Were both the Majohn pens an extra-fine nib? The writing looked the same size, but you didn't mention the nib size on the sliver one. The thing that actually turns me off on these pens, is not that they are retractable, but that the clip is on the wrong end! I really don't see why it's not possible to put the clip on that piece right by the clicker, like 99.9999% of all other pens, including, (can't believe I'm even using this word!) ballpoints. I might be interested in that silver one though, for the right price!
All the pens come in XF point which is the same as a Japanese F. The clip is where it is so that the nib is upright when its in a shirt/jacket pocket. If the clip was on the other end, the pen would leak into your pocket because the nib would be pointed down.
You know, I realized that after I pushed comment! Something really slick would be a RETRACTABLE clip! that way it would not be in the way of your fingers while writing! Or put the clip on the back side maybe? That way the ink wouldn't run out.
I don't like the majohn a1. The nib is to dry and small for me, but they only offer it in EF. Also after clicking it for 3 times I always have Ink stuck on the nib that accumulates under the trap door. I have two and both do that. Silicone grease on the back of the nib did not help. I love the concept of the vanishing point, but I can only advice you not to buy a majohn. For me they sadly do not deliver. Maybe I have to fork out the money for an original Pilot VP...
More nib sizes would be better. The ink getting on the nib is just part of the deal with a clicking pen that rapidly sloshes the ink in the pen. I have the same thing happen on my real Pilot VP.
@@Doodlebud After watching this video I decided to give the A1 another chance. And low and behold, I was wrong with my assessment... Using the refillable cartridge instead of the converter I had no Ink leak between nib and trapdoor so far. It seams the Converter is maybe not a hundred percent airthight and allows Ink to flow out, or the angle of the insert is different thus the nib grinds on the door... etc. Anyway, use the refillable cartridge and not the converter. :) Also I switched from a pigment Ink to a die ink from Diamine. Whith the wetter flowing Ink the Nib is now much smoother and nicer to write with. Seems If you know the quirks of the Pen it is a blast to use after all...! Thanks for the Vid anyway, might not have tried it again if it werent for it :)
I'm not totally sure. But here's the video on it along with the link to the one I'm using. It's in the description th-cam.com/video/2e1hZt60wms/w-d-xo.html
Sorry to disagree, but in my experience, these Majohn A1's just aren't quite ready for prime time. I have several and they're just not up to par. Shame on me for buying more of them thinking I'll have better luck with the next one. Could've bought another real VP for the price. They leak, they're scratchy, write dryly, dry out if they sit for more than two days. My 2 VP's just keep sailing along.
Sounds like you got unlucky. I have multiple a1 and a2s. With fine and extra fine nibs. Haven't had any issues except for my first one. Feed was clogged and I had to throw it out
"When you want quality at a reasonable price, always grab Majohn." Now, the way you pronounce "Majohn" will determine if that was a joke or just a reasonable slogan
**UPDATE** For anyone else in the UK reading this: it seems this was a glitch of sorts, I've since tried again and the shop Doodlebud recommends does indeed ship to us. They were also around £6 cheaper than other shops selling the same pen :)
The title made me chuckle ;) Pilot worried? lolz...The western market is an after thought to them, it seems, I see it daily in Sumo as example. I am chuffed you made this video - i saw these and wondered myself?
Translation of the text? It is very contextual. It can be, and often is translated as 'temperature of writing' and should be 'feel the warmth of'.. The name is the first two characters, and I believe it is a play on it sounding like Mahjong? The two characters for the name translates as : the apex of craftsmanship.
Now that I had some more time to listen I listened to the whole thing instead of jumping around (well, almost). I just don't get the praise - copy someone else's work, only change the construction in a way that makes it slightly worse, write worse, machine it the wrong way so you leave behind machining marks and no two engraved lines are precisely the same, paint job is quite bad...so what's the point of this product? Outside of the homeless, who have no need for a fountain pen, there is nobody who can't eventually save up the extra $120 for the proper item when it is an item that lasts a lifetime. Maybe I'll be surprised when the little camera arrives and 20x shows a lot more than my 10x loupe shows.
Of course it's not as good of a nib. But it's a retractable pen that is inexpensive enough to not worry about. My job has me all over the place - walking through mechanical rooms, climbing shipladders and crossing catwalks, outdoors in 95 degree sunny weather or 15 degrees and snow. I need a pen that retracts so I don't have to worry about losing the cap, that I can leave for a week without it drying up, and isn't so expensive that I'm going to cry if I drop it.
Well, it kinda is. The patents have expired on the VP so it is fair game. But having their own design would have been good to see. But some folks just don't work that way
If the patents have expired, I'll rest my case in this case, but I think it is sad to see, on a general level, how designs are stolen, and people applaud this, just to save a few bucks. :(
Majohn is s third class product, I made a mistake buying one and now feels like throwing it aways, its 420 product. Please dont waste your hard earned money
For those interested in the engraving technique, search for "clickspring rose engine". He has acquired one of the machines as in the museum video and makes beautiful things with it.
Ninebot, a Chinese company, used to make knockoff versions of Segway's electric two-wheeled vehicles. In 2015, Ninebot bought Segway Inc.
i hope majohn expand their nib options for the A1/A2
How much more would you be willing to pay for the extra option of nib sizes?
@@kanck7909 perhaps an additional $10? The clicking mechanism is really ideal for everyday use but the current EF nib writes too wide for me.
I agree, a fine or medium would be a welcome addition
I hope that the Chinese will start making mediums, broads and stubs. That would be heaven for me as most of them are too fine for me.
@@HomerIncognito stub might be a bit much for the ink capacity on this model
I love how you go over every tiny details of pens. I haven't seen many other content creators do that
It's just how I'm wired. My work required I find all the time details to ensure there were no errors anywhere
Heyyy, you got some actual VPs! Also as a pharmacist who always brings a VP to shift clipped in my WHITE smock chest pocket, it has never leaked on me after 3 years.
"Feel the temperature of writing!"
DB: I have noooo idea what that means" 😂
I received mine about two weeks ago. Returning what's left of it today. I used it about 10 times before the nib stopped retracting. Opened the barrel to find the spring had displaced. No amount wiggling and shoving would get it to stay back in place. I didn't like the nib anyway (though I have a couple of Mahjong pens that are fine).
Glad you like yours and mine could be bad luck. Just a heads-up on what could happen and how hard it is to do a simple repair.
I belive that some of the original patents for the VP have expired. The original way the pen seals when closed is extermely clever, remarkably effective, and simple. I'm impressed.
Guilloche engravers are indeed pretty cool. Ever since I saw an Art Déco cigarette case with an intricate guilloche pattern and a gorgeous turquoise enamel on it as a kid, I've been fascinated with them and wanted to know how they produced a pattern that complex. Especially the ones that can connect multiple of the simple patterns to produce a compound oscillating pattern are really interesting.
What is done for watch faces is absolutely stunning
Just received mine today in the silver fish scale pattern. It does look like a million bucks and writes just as well as the plain black ones I have.
My favorite retractable in my collection is still my Decimo. I normally don’t mind metal pens with girth but it makes a difference to my hand having the Capless compared to the decimo in my hand!
I love love love my vintage VP. Light weight, a bit slimmer, and feels just perfect in the hand
The decimo and A2 size is way better for me. I have a medium-size hand but short fingers.
I bought one of these recently. While I'm not especially a fan of the VP, I was curious. It was a much higher quality pen than I expected and I was surprised how quickly I wrote mine dry: a fancy way of saying I happily grabbed it to write quite often.
Yeah I'm really surprised by these. Yup its a design copy, but it's also make really well. Tough to beat this pen at this price point
I have been using the same two A1s, and they’re my favorite A1s so far. Thanks for the close-ups, that’s fascinating. It really feels like the quality is ramping up on these. They were good to start with, but little details seem to be improving.
They're doing a really good job on these
Hi DB. I just barely received that exact same silver-stripes version in the mail. I absolutely love the pen, DB. I think that this particular model is trying to emulate an existing chrome-stripes version from Pilot. I switched out the Majohn nib unit with a Pilot vanishing point nib unit. This is now my favorite edc pen. Incredible value. The original version of this model is north of $300.00 at US online pen retailers. I cannot afford that.
I just received my silver “fish scale” A1 yesterday and I absolutely agree on the texture, it’s super comfy!
It really is!
Since the entire interior assembly of these pens are supposedly interchangeable…seems like you could simply decide which one you wanted to write like what and swap around accordingly. I have a half dozen different pens like these and haven’t changed anything around yet, but I did get a “Bobby Stub” that will replace the XF in my Black Stripe A1.
Thank you for the tip on priming the feed with a drop out two of ink!
Wait what does that even mean?
Thank you so much for this wonderful video: I love your "Nerd-out-sessions"!!!! FANTASTIC
Namiki Vanishing Point. I have one and I have always liked it even though it wrote rather dry. After a few nib changes it is now sufficiently wet. So I can like it even more now.
Great review! I really like that you go over the pen in detail and even cover the little things that can be a drawback. I've got the matte black w/clip and really like it. I've also got a Pilot one in blue and chrome. I use the black one way more because of the grip. Also, interestingly, mine says Moon Man on it. Keep up the great work!
Thanks for the review Doodlebud, I like the new textures.
Love them!
Regarding priming the pen with the cartridge : clicking it in and out a couple of times also does the trick 😊
So does diping the tip for around 15 - 25ish seconds, and then wiping off as usual... The feeds work on capillary action, and some are just a tad "vapor lock" prone from an otherwise "sealed" cartridge or converter...
Propping a pen nib-down for a few minutes can do it...
AND a casual dip-swish in ordinary water is a helpful "jump-start"... Especially useful for pens prone to "hard-starts" whether for leaving them sit too long or just for "cheap-*ss tuning" before you quite get them "right"...
NOTHING against your suggestion... It just might help someone out having a couple options... ;o)
I dipped my pen endless in water, ran it under the faucet, dipped then used a tissue to draw out the water and ink just wouldn't flow done the feed to the nib. Left it sitting nib down for 30min, etc. So did 1 drop of ink and BOOM it started flowing. My other ones were no problem but the silver one wasn't cooperating
I work in the hospital and carry the vanilla black and the patterned black all day long. Reliable writers and I love them.
These and the proper Pilot VP have all been great. The Pilot ones are better and the nibs feel nicer, but to me these are some of the best pens in the price category
@@Doodlebud I agree 100%. I just have a hard time carrying an expensive pen with me in an unpredictable environment.
Just wondering - What inks do you use at work?
@@bhoola123 Anything works since most of my notes are for myself or non-official. Right now I have the Diamine onyx and noodler's 54th. Will probably do Diamine salamander and oxblood next.
@@Innieminnie Thank you!
I am curious, for the writing test with the real Pilot vanishing point, was the nib a steel one or a gold one?
Amazing review, as usual! I appreciate the use of more technical, engineering tools to widen our appreciation of fountain pens.
The VP nib is gold.
I finally ordered mine, same two as you. I was really struggling not to buy all 4 😅
I'm probably one of few people who doesn't like Vanishing Point nib. Gonna look for Majohn A1.
I wasnt a fan for the longest time and had to intention to get one. But then the price of the A1 seduced me. Turns out..... I really like a VP!
Nice review on a nice pen. Unfortunately, these only come with EF nibs.
Nice thorough review as usual. Thanks for sharing.
Love the Peerless
Very interesting development. A1 becomes even more desirable.
I just got one of the MaJohn A1 pens EF nib, with "white grid" body. It looks fantastic, feels solid in the hand, the click is super-smooth and satisfying, and it writes smooth and consistently. For $40 it is a FANTASTIC pen, I think. I also have an A2 which is fine little pen (and half the price of the A1) but it feels much lighter and less expensive than the metal-bodied A1.
My only disappointment is that is isn't really "white"--it's more of a "titanium silver-gray" with bright chrome accents.
I bought it to match a pocket knife and wine tool I had which have whit G10 scales, and although it looks fine with them, it's not really as "matchy-matchy" as it would be if the finish were actually "white". I'm seriously considering giving it a coat of translucent cream enamel to give it a sort of "enameled guilloche" look, to make it look more like my other EDC items...
I absolutely love your content man, you make much more enjoyable videos than other TH-camrs covering this topic. And your editing style is the best I've seen in these types of videos. I sincerely hope your channel grows. Keep up the good work and God bless you. Could you possibly review the jinhao 1200A in the future I have just bought the black finish and I want to hear what you have to say?
Thnaks buddy 👍. If I get my hands on one I'll be sure to review it
I just wish they make medium nibs... even a fine nib, but they are great pens.
Yup, more nib options should be their next focus
If Moonman really wants to be a pilot killer they will make more nib options for these pens. Of course the broader the better for me, making a stacked nib for it was a bit complicated and snug but it's possible. But the your only option is a broad architect and I'm sure some people would love a stub
More nib options would be great
I love my teal A2. I want a medium nib so much tho!
“If you’re gonna copy it, you’ve done all this already, just finish the deal” 😂 5:16
Its like having the answer key to a test but only getting 75% .... WTF 😆
I was actually looking for a thread less pocket pen and saw this. Ordered two, one was on a special silly first order price, under £1 so I got that with no clip. Majohn has some tempting pens, the p139 looks good. Shame it had threads.
I'm an early adopter of the A1 as a test balloon for the VP to see whether the clip would bother me and liked it so much that I bought a VP and a Decimo. And then I found out about the new pattern. I now have one of each in silver. Interestingly, my matte black lays down a fairly generous 0.4 line with a Pilot Pink cartridge and the stripey one writes drier and gives me a 0.3 (?) line with a Pilot Black cartridge. I haven't inked up the fish scale one yet. I'll see how it'll write. I still want a vintage Capless.
I must say, I didn't expect that I would like the A1 so much. I was hoping I would like it, not that it would turn into the pen I keep in my pocket when I go out. Simply incredible. I'd prefer it to be a little lighter, so I'm honestly considering the A2. But I still want to wait to see if it has the same good durability as the A1.
I have both an a2 and a pilot decimo both great. Love the size over the a1 and vanishing point. For a little over 20 dollars for the a2,it writes nice lela and also swaps nibs with the pilot.
@@irvintepper5 I love the decimo and A2. Putting the 18k Pilot nib in them is fun! It would be nice if Pilot sold the VP steel nib units separate from the pens.
Hey Doodlebud, Thanks again for the video! Mine showed up last Wednesday, also from 365Days Stationery Store. I started in reverse; first purchasing the original Pilot VP and was curious about the Majohn's A1. This is my second A1 and I've noticed that this new pen (Fisk Scale pattern) is a couple of grams lighter than the VP without it feeling "cheap". It's not much but it does feel a bit more comfortable. As you mentioned, the mechanism is not as smooth as a VP but it comes close. So far, it's pretty solid and seems to have good build quality. Let's see how it holds up!!!
Thanks again!!
Yup its a touch lighter since some material was removed to machine in the scale pattern. Such a good pen for this price!
Like someone mentioned below, I wish Majohn would offer more nibs. I bought the A1 with the EF and found it scratchy and dry. I don't know how to tune a nib - maybe I need to watch a video on that - but I'd rather buy something that worked well out of the box. I wish they made a F nib.
I can't tolerate the extra-fine Majohn nibs. Nor can I tune them/smooth them.
I bought one Majohn a2 to try and I doubt Pilot has anything to worry about. I have a handful Pilot fountain pens. They work flawlessly. My first Majohn does not even write/let ink flow. At this point it is just a paper weight on my desk.
And that is the issue at this price. QC/Inspection just doesn't happen at the level it needs to ensuring an extremely low fault rate. Build quality is one thing, but ensuing & inspecting build quality is another realm all together
Btw the seller sent me a replacement insert/nib assembly and that one was faulty too. I doubt I will ever deviate from Pilot, Rotring, Pelikan etc :)
I have 4 A1s and 5 A2s (as well as 3 VPs), and all of my Majohn A1 & A2 nibs work without fault out of the box. At the price I wasn't expecting them all to work so well. You must have had an unlucky hand. Sorry.
I've never been a fan of the VP clip. But the no clip versions of the A1 have me intrigued. And now this "fish scale" pattern.... if they make a no clip version of it, I'm giving it a whirl.
Great review. I wonder if the new finishes will also come in a roll stop version.
Love my matte black A1 with the clip, very excellent copy of the VP. I definitely plan to get an actual VP at some point, and maybe a VP nib unit with a fine nib for the A1. The A1 makes a great work pen vs the VP for me because if anything happens to it I'm only out around $38, not $200+. It's also nice because it is retractable, so no fussing with the cap.
The only problem I have with my A1 is the nib tends to leak a little. Unlike some people, mine seems to "leak" from the slit of the nib, not where the feed goes into the nib unit.
Yeah you're not the only one who's seems to have run into that problem 🤔
Another another carefully executed review showing and explaining many details. But no, I think Pilot won"t be scared at all. I've got an A1 of the first generation, overpaid it as I didn't know Aliexpress at that time and was very disappointed because the pen started to leak after one day of flat storage on a table (in a box, TG). Only a swap of the inkconverter (from Majohn model to the Pilot Con-40) stopped the leakage. Other users with the same problem swapped the nib (buying the extremly expensive Pilot VP nibs) to solve the leakages. I was so disappointed and never touched the A1 again, but bought instead the original Pilot VP, a purchase which kept me happy all the time. Since then I didn't even look at the much cheaper A2 version of Majohn and definetly won't buy the new A1 (V2), even though they look very attractive in their new colors and attractive patterns. That's me, once bitten....
You're far too generous with the assumption I carefully plan out my videos 😆.
@@Doodlebud Don't hide your light too much under a bushel. If that's an understandable translation of a german saying....
I bought the Moonman body but inserted a Pilot extra fine nib unit. It works like a charm. The Moonman EF nib was not really extra fine. I also did not like the clip on the Pilot.
The copycat makes a better converter than Pilot! Also, those cartridges with seal plugs, only manufacturer I know of that gets some of us reuse those!
I'm more impressed from the fact that you have an endoscope
I like to get down in there 🧐
Cool Doodlebud.. Like I need any more of these.... Haha Guess I'm getting the silver stripe, silver fish scale, and black fish scale eventually. I already have a Maroon A-1 that I like to take to work. And I have a Pilot Fermo in silver that if i wanted could swap the nib unit into one of these if I wanted an 18k gold nib. Just wish these came in a bigger nib than just Ef. I'll probably have to do some work on them to get them where I want them as far as smoothness and wetness. I opened the tines on my maroon one to get it a bit more wet. I over micromeshed the nib though and made it kind of more flat, but interestingly enough it writes kind of like an Architect nib now and I love it has that uniqueness. Might try to do the same on some of these. Awesome review as usual man!!
Yup, too much polishing in the same spot will typically give a nib an architect like line
@@Doodlebud A happy little accident nonetheless. Haha!
I actually have the real deal stripe silver VP. Dang it looks identical.
I didn't expect them to be this well done.
Just bought an A2. New plastic version of the Moonman pen. My Pilot Decimo is really giving me problems. Scratchy. Dry, skips all the time. Even after cleaning. Looking at the nib, the tines are touching at the end. (You did a video on how to pull the tines apart. But I am scared I will ruin the nib) So, I got the less expensive A2 and will play with that nib until I feel comfortable with adjusting the nib tines.
Good idea on trying it out on a less expensive pen first
@@Doodlebud Oh yes. A man's got to know his limitations. I used to grind and alter some old pens. Did some sack replacement and refurbishing. Now, I just use them. A Majohn A2 is $50 less than a Pilot replacement unit.
I’m interested in the Muji notebook with the snap open rings. Where can I get one in the US?
In a Muji store or the Muji website
Now to wait for the metallic A2
I take it that the Majohn converter has a bit more ink capacity because it does not have the agitator balls like those found on the Pilot models? The small eye dropper included is something appealing. Thank you for your video presentation.
Yup, it should hold a touch more
Why not just use a Pilot refillable cartridge.?
Link for that cool Muji notebook? I’d totally use your link if you have one- looked in your store- didn’t see it. Great video. Thanks!
Just jump on the Muji website or pop in if you have a Muji store in your area. They only sell form their stores or online. I don;t think their stuff is carried anywhere else.
Great video! Thanks!
very much enjoy the info. thank you. i tried your amazon link and i thought you'd be interested in knowing that while i can see your shop i cannot purchasing anything from there as it seems to be canada-only
Yeah I've told Amazon the problem and they keep saying its all automatically changed for the user. It's totally not happening. My traffic says I get 9000 clicks but only 7 purchases.... I don't think so Amazon.
Love the detail shots (o:
My A1s have a terrible seal, after a couple days they hard start. Day to day they’re ok. Other than that the pen is quite nice.
But my A2s are really good and start up even after more than a week of non use.
Must have a bit of a defect in your A1. All my A1's seal pretty damn good. Can last easy 2 weeks without being used and sometimes much longer
Thanks for another great review. I’m getting back into the fountain pen hobby. I started collecting in the 80s and now I have the time to get back to it. Can you send me a link of where I can find Muji paper in the US? I’m having a difficult time. I like that binder/spiral binding. Keep up the great work!
Just go to the Muji website and everything is there.
www.muji.us/collections/binders-looseleaf-paper/products/loose-leaf-papers-kraft-binder-naba0s
@@Doodlebud thanks!!
Nice looking finishes on the Majohn A1s! The Pilot VP size is on the verge of too girthy for me.
The decimo is my favorite retractable fountain pen. That's why I got a couple of Majohn A2 faceted(18 facets really pay off in the light);the orange color is delightful; kind of a pinkish-orangey color.
I also got a dark green A2. The The Pilot 18k nibs fit perfectly in them should you have them available. The Pilot steel-nib VP unit might be a good option if they are available separately.
I hope I can find a vintage Pilot Capless someday; but,I'm pessimistic and don't want to wait for the day.
The Majohn A2/A1 are very cool pens; but,the nibs leave a lot to be desired. If one is able to do the nibbage work they are great pens. Having to use a Majohn extra-fine nib is a struggle for me. The Majohn nibs I've had are dry, scratchy,needle-points that need more attention than I am currently able to provide to them.
It took me several years of looking to find a vintage one for a price I wanted, but I got it. Just takes patience
th-cam.com/video/MyAKahm6Igc/w-d-xo.html
I don’t know if Pilot need be scared at all. But I know that I’m scarcely tempted at all by these blatant copies of the original. I have three original Capless/VP pens. I’m really happy to have paid for the Pilot originals. The presence of these much cheaper copies somehow makes me appreciate the originals even more.
I have several of both and definitely appreciate the might higher quality of the original but when I am going to a conference or travel I don't want to risk my VPs. The copy is definitely good for that purpose and I won't be devastated if I lose my VPs or if someone with sticky fingers gets a hold of it.
Hi Doodlebud, what is that astonishing blue on the real pilot vanishing point?
No idea what was in that pen at the time
The clip is intended to be offset slightly given that people have fingers, I thought their attention to focus was impressive
Please add in videos how to clean the Majohn pens.
What you call "fish scale" patterning looks like knurling to me. [EDIT: That is, until you viewed it under the microscope. I've no idea what the technical description would be, but certainly not "fish scaling" or knurling]. In any case, it is textured and easy to grip. I like that the MaJohn is recessed at the center joint and doesn't have two proud (bulging) rings in the center like the Pilot (which is why I like my Decimo; the rings are much less pronounced).
This is a minor complaint, but I always notice when someone says "anyways;" because I majored in English in school. My professors always corrected anyone they heard saying it. Anyway is the correct word choice. Anyways is a colloquial variant of the word anyway. It is almost universally considered incorrect.
I ordered an A1 based on this video. Nobody could accuse it of being a fine point. 😞
Another great video! I've had a VP for a few years now. I have the silver fish scale A1 on the way. I've had an A2 for a few weeks. I inserted a genuine Pilot cartridge into the A2, but all of the ink leaked out the front when I extended the nib. It just completely gushed out, nearly emptying the cartridge. I'm not sure what happened as I'm very familiar with the inner workings. After cleaning the pen, I filled one of the empty cartridges included with the A2, and it works fine. Will I buy another Majohn? Probably. Will I buy another VP? Definitely.
I've seen a few people report leaking issues in the comments. Haven't had that happen yet but guess it does sometimes 🤔
@@Doodlebud It was like opening up a flood gate, haha! 90% of the ink just burped out. I know I had everything inserted correctly. However, once I used the refillable "Majohn" cartridge, I haven't had any leakage. I do still carry the pen in a Ziploc bag just in case... Or until I feel safe. I'm wondering if the Pilot cartridge has a slightly different shape that may not play well with the Majohn.
I had low expectations of the a1 and a2. I don’t own a vp or decimo so I can’t compare. But I love these pens. They are my pens I use throughout the day in my planner and jotting other notes. I keep waiting for issues but nothing so far! Came out of the box writing smooth with good ink flow.
Agreed, loves these
Waiting for jinhao to make one, more metal less expensive 😅
I just got me an endoscope for my pen videos, but I could not find any cheapo that does more than 640X480 and the frame rate is awful. What's the model name? I might decide to splurge :)
I believe this is the one I got from amazon:
amzn.to/3Q5gAPO
They made an LS too!
I just may have my hands on one as we speak 😉
@@Doodlebud how is it ? Mine is on the way
Its a decent pen. The click/release mechanism is just ok I would say
@@Doodlebud okay. Let me try it. Thanks
Is the difference of both coatings(like the orange finish you said about the black one) due to the paints themselves or is it because of the pattern difference? I’m also curious about the durability of the coatings, since the first majohn a1s have been reported to flake off within months. Are both Silver and Black coatings on these new finishes flake off at the same rate, or is one of the other more durable?
What Muji notebook is coz it looks great
Hi DB!: Not really a fan of the retractable FP's, but that Silver striped one is pretty nice looking. Were both the Majohn pens an extra-fine nib? The writing looked the same size, but you didn't mention the nib size on the sliver one. The thing that actually turns me off on these pens, is not that they are retractable, but that the clip is on the wrong end! I really don't see why it's not possible to put the clip on that piece right by the clicker, like 99.9999% of all other pens, including, (can't believe I'm even using this word!) ballpoints. I might be interested in that silver one though, for the right price!
All the pens come in XF point which is the same as a Japanese F. The clip is where it is so that the nib is upright when its in a shirt/jacket pocket. If the clip was on the other end, the pen would leak into your pocket because the nib would be pointed down.
You know, I realized that after I pushed comment! Something really slick would be a RETRACTABLE clip! that way it would not be in the way of your fingers while writing! Or put the clip on the back side maybe? That way the ink wouldn't run out.
Can they take Pilot cartridges or standard long ones?
It takes Pilot converters and cartridges
Hey where did you find that big spring syringe i see in some of your videos?
I got mine on Aliexpress. I can't seem to find the same one anymore. The ones now available are much smaller and not built as well.
@@Doodlebud shame
I don't like the majohn a1. The nib is to dry and small for me, but they only offer it in EF. Also after clicking it for 3 times I always have Ink stuck on the nib that accumulates under the trap door. I have two and both do that. Silicone grease on the back of the nib did not help. I love the concept of the vanishing point, but I can only advice you not to buy a majohn. For me they sadly do not deliver. Maybe I have to fork out the money for an original Pilot VP...
More nib sizes would be better. The ink getting on the nib is just part of the deal with a clicking pen that rapidly sloshes the ink in the pen. I have the same thing happen on my real Pilot VP.
@@Doodlebud After watching this video I decided to give the A1 another chance. And low and behold, I was wrong with my assessment... Using the refillable cartridge instead of the converter I had no Ink leak between nib and trapdoor so far. It seams the Converter is maybe not a hundred percent airthight and allows Ink to flow out, or the angle of the insert is different thus the nib grinds on the door... etc. Anyway, use the refillable cartridge and not the converter. :) Also I switched from a pigment Ink to a die ink from Diamine. Whith the wetter flowing Ink the Nib is now much smoother and nicer to write with. Seems If you know the quirks of the Pen it is a blast to use after all...! Thanks for the Vid anyway, might not have tried it again if it werent for it :)
Did they fix the sharp transition at the clip to the barrel?
That silver guy for the win. Maybe lose the clip.
isnt the clip annoying? Maybe even more for left handed writers?
You have the option to selection one without a clip but has roll stop near the clicker end instead.
s.click.aliexpress.com/e/_DmraNiP
On the Apexel is yours with or without CPL filter?
I'm not totally sure. But here's the video on it along with the link to the one I'm using. It's in the description
th-cam.com/video/2e1hZt60wms/w-d-xo.html
Sorry to disagree, but in my experience, these Majohn A1's just aren't quite ready for prime time. I have several and they're just not up to par. Shame on me for buying more of them thinking I'll have better luck with the next one. Could've bought another real VP for the price. They leak, they're scratchy, write dryly, dry out if they sit for more than two days. My 2 VP's just keep sailing along.
Sounds like you got unlucky. I have multiple a1 and a2s. With fine and extra fine nibs. Haven't had any issues except for my first one. Feed was clogged and I had to throw it out
"When you want quality at a reasonable price, always grab Majohn."
Now, the way you pronounce "Majohn" will determine if that was a joke or just a reasonable slogan
My ass waiting for someone to make bootleg of Pilot Myu
I would buy that in an instant
Do they take the Pilot nib units?
They do.
The nib actually does come off the feed does not
The only downside is majohns don’t come in medium or even fine nib
u got a coupon code for this?
The sellers site might have something.
@@Doodlebud lol i dont need discount tbh i thought maybe if im gonna buy it anyway i might help u by using ur code
They don’t ship to the UK 😭
That's odd. Perhaps another Aliexpress store does
@@Doodlebud do you know if the pen comes from the same factory regardless of the seller? I’m only wanting to buy from your positive review 😅…
@@eleanor.shadow yup, comes from the same manufacturer. Find a store that ships to the UK that has positive feedback and you should be good 👍
@@Doodlebud excellent! Thanks for letting me know 😀
**UPDATE** For anyone else in the UK reading this: it seems this was a glitch of sorts, I've since tried again and the shop Doodlebud recommends does indeed ship to us. They were also around £6 cheaper than other shops selling the same pen :)
Now...how to get rid of the annoying clip.
That's easy. Just grab the clip & pull it back. Keep pulling until.....no more clip 😁
The title made me chuckle ;) Pilot worried? lolz...The western market is an after thought to them, it seems, I see it daily in Sumo as example. I am chuffed you made this video - i saw these and wondered myself?
Translation of the text? It is very contextual. It can be, and often is translated as 'temperature of writing' and should be 'feel the warmth of'.. The name is the first two characters, and I believe it is a play on it sounding like Mahjong? The two characters for the name translates as : the apex of craftsmanship.
Now that I had some more time to listen I listened to the whole thing instead of jumping around (well, almost). I just don't get the praise - copy someone else's work, only change the construction in a way that makes it slightly worse, write worse, machine it the wrong way so you leave behind machining marks and no two engraved lines are precisely the same, paint job is quite bad...so what's the point of this product? Outside of the homeless, who have no need for a fountain pen, there is nobody who can't eventually save up the extra $120 for the proper item when it is an item that lasts a lifetime. Maybe I'll be surprised when the little camera arrives and 20x shows a lot more than my 10x loupe shows.
No, because they cannot match a Pilot nib.
Yup, the 18K pilot nib is better
Of course it's not as good of a nib. But it's a retractable pen that is inexpensive enough to not worry about. My job has me all over the place - walking through mechanical rooms, climbing shipladders and crossing catwalks, outdoors in 95 degree sunny weather or 15 degrees and snow. I need a pen that retracts so I don't have to worry about losing the cap, that I can leave for a week without it drying up, and isn't so expensive that I'm going to cry if I drop it.
To me, this looks like a design theft...
Well, it kinda is. The patents have expired on the VP so it is fair game. But having their own design would have been good to see. But some folks just don't work that way
If the patents have expired, I'll rest my case in this case, but I think it is sad to see, on a general level, how designs are stolen, and people applaud this, just to save a few bucks. :(
@@Megadad60 because not everyone can afford 100usd pens.
"How are they doing this for this price?" With Chinese domestic goods, usually the answer is forced labour
It's amazing how people seem to go out of their way to find the most god awful noise to add to their videos. Seriously wtf? Good video otherwise.
Majohn is s third class product, I made a mistake buying one and now feels like throwing it aways, its 420 product. Please dont waste your hard earned money
I mean, why would anyone want to own anything made in china. I rather use a good quality pen, but thats just personal opinion
chinese doesnt always mean bad quality. majohn and penbbs are on par or sometimes better quality than major brands' cheaper pens.
I am sorry, but your argument is instantly out the window the moment a 2 dollar jinhao writes better and is better made than a lamy
I'm sorry, but isn't most of the things made in China these days?
For those interested in the engraving technique, search for "clickspring rose engine". He has acquired one of the machines as in the museum video and makes beautiful things with it.