These are the individuals we NEED in the field of science (I'm happy to say she's inspiring me in my studies in Astrophysics @ Queen's). The bright sparks to lead humanity into the future. From Galileo to Albert Einstein to women such as Katie Bouman. Back to when science was for the passion and pursuit of understanding the universe around us and not for money or profit.
@@mbolduc Blame the mainstream medias, not her. She did a great job, but it's the medias fault for putting all the attention on her for the sole reason of being a woman.
@@saassas5879 "Andrew Chael is working on EHT projects at the intersection of theory and observation. He performs GRMHD simulations with new electron temperature evolution code to simulate movies of Sgr A* and M87 to better understand how EHT observations will constrain the plasma physics of the inner accretion flow and jet. He also is a leader on the EHT imaging working group, and has pioneered new algorithms on reconstructing images directly from robust data products like closure phase and amplitude. He is the author of the eht-imaging software library which is used across the collaboration for analyzing data and generating images ."
Congrats to you, and your team's brilliant achievement! The picture is super rad!
5 ปีที่แล้ว +8
specially to the guy that coded 850,000 of the 900,000 lines of code, the real hero from start to finish, she was just part of a big team, nice girl but lets not give her credit she doesnt deserve like if she did this alone or was some of the most important.
@@saassas5879 "Andrew Chael is working on EHT projects at the intersection of theory and observation. He performs GRMHD simulations with new electron temperature evolution code to simulate movies of Sgr A* and M87 to better understand how EHT observations will constrain the plasma physics of the inner accretion flow and jet. *He also is a leader on the EHT imaging working group, and has pioneered new algorithms on reconstructing images directly from robust data products like closure phase and amplitude. He is the author of the eht-imaging software library which is used across the collaboration for analyzing data and generating images* ."
@@-hello6177 Yes, so he helped, as one would expect lol Here's a comment from reddit: "I'm seeing a lot of comments in here by people who havent had experience with github. Githubs lines of code measurement is an estimate that is usually wrong and counts a lot of things that arent actually code. Andrew did write a good amount of code. But from a quick glance through this github, most of those "lines" are models and data, not code. He didn't write 95 percent of the code. Hes extremely accomplished and obviously very talented but I doubt he wants to be pitted against his teammate using false statistics."
I was really confused with the news items...Without this lecture many couldn't have understood it. Thank you and many congrats for the outstanding achievement...
IcyHammer Dr. Bouer stitched the code between many different teams, and the person who you're trying to give the credit to (Chael) said that he did not write 850,000 lines of code (Twitter). Dr. Bauer was vital to getting this project done, and I am proud of her.
Going back to university in science and being surrounded by so many sharp people (the majority of whom are women) has been one of the most amazing experiences of my life. Watching Dr. Bouman present is like watching someone you feel you could have a chat with, but with her intelligence stats approaching I_max. So humbling and incredible. Great work on the photo to everyone involved and particularly to Katie.
This is Science people. You theorize an idea and if it’s true you will amaze the world, just like she did on April 10th 2019. Great job to you and your team.
Young, smart, and beautiful lady.... I can feel your enthusiasm... I hope all the world will recognize you. Not only the western world. Middle East needs to hear and listen to her to see how women are doing here... to stop conflicts and and belittling woman. We need more education. And freedom in the world.
You, ma'am, are incredible. Pls, ignore these male chauvinist assholes that say that it wasn't you that made this. I am by your side. Thank you so much for your hard work. I also want to thank all the people that were involved in this project, thank you for your contribution to humanity. Y'all deserve a lot. :)
congrats to you and the team. Saw the video 8 months before and i waited to see the results. now seeing the fruits of ground breaking work done by the scientists is a good feel.
Wish all those guys: Einstein, Eddington, Hawking were alive today to see their work in action. Congratulations to Bauman and all the other awesome guys who made this possible
Sounds to me like she is explaining how they used a Generative Adversarial Network to fabricate the image. Calling it a photograph is a bit of a stretch.
@@r0uneh ._. you can see the source code in github, execute that and read, and you can read the papers too. I invite you to read actual science and then judge.
@@elvince2 you mention source code, thats fine. you dont address bengejo's point above about the image shown in the video looking almost identical to the recently posted result image, i invite you to look at the actual post you replied to
Looking at this is like be someone from the future in that crowd, just seeing what they achieved and see how they nailed their mission. Katie and all the amazing team making history! Proud of watching this giant step of Science.
Very nice explanation of your sparse patch-based inverse image reconstruction method. You even had a nice picture of the Fourier domain. It takes real skill to be able to explain this sort of thing to a non-technical audience. Way to go ! Looking forward to reading your thesis.
I teach middle school science and this is when we start our unit on astronomy. I had a student ask in typical teenager fashion why we are learning about this. I remember reading about the Event Horizon Telescope and used it as an example for how scientists are still exploring and learning new things about our universe. I'm glad I found this video too. While the content is a little steep for middle schoolers, it's great to show them a young role model talking about science. Thanks!
Great example of the space between and importance in seeing the difference in the actual work and communication of it. Keep teaching it and discussing it in different ways and voices.
@Suffer No Fools Dude, any competent programmer can write code that implements an existing algorithm. Actually coming up with that original algorithm is much, much harder. Like I said, lines of code is not how you should measure contribution to a project like this.
@Suffer No Fools lmao okay incel It's the truth that coming up with an algorithm is harder than implementing an existing one. Here's a comment from reddit: "I'm seeing a lot of comments in here by people who havent had experience with github. Githubs lines of code measurement is an estimate that is usually wrong and counts a lot of things that arent actually code. Andrew did write a good amount of code. But from a quick glance through this github, most of those "lines" are models and data, not code. He didn't write 95 percent of the code. Hes extremely accomplished and obviously very talented but I doubt he wants to be pitted against his teammate using false statistics." Again: "most of those "lines" are models and data, not code. He didn't write 95 percent of the code."
Way to go Katie! Extremely proud of your mind and your accomplishments. Einstein once said, "Logic will take you from A to B ~ Imagination will take you everywhere." I think 'Herr Einstein' was directly speaking to you. You must ride upon your gift of imagination as a thought experiment first.., then everything will be revealed to you with perfect logic. See you in Stockholm some day.
Apparently the image released recently was drawn way back but perhaps it was being reconfirmed for last 3 years so that the errors and doubts are addressed. Kudos.
Love you guys plasma work, for we all over at the EU think blackholes are just a mathematical construct, we think no widgets allowed more like a plasmoid check out the electric/plasma universe
You can hear the passion in her voice. AND she nailed the prediction too.
These are the individuals we NEED in the field of science (I'm happy to say she's inspiring me in my studies in Astrophysics @ Queen's).
The bright sparks to lead humanity into the future.
From Galileo to Albert Einstein to women such as Katie Bouman.
Back to when science was for the passion and pursuit of understanding the universe around us and not for money or profit.
CONGRATULATIONS!!! I'd love to see this girl give a part 2 of this ted talk
Congratulations, you did what you set out to achieve!
Take credit for a man's work?
@@mbolduc Without her we would still have just almost useless data, you should be more respectful.
@@mbolduc Blame the mainstream medias, not her.
She did a great job, but it's the medias fault for putting all the attention on her for the sole reason of being a woman.
@ lol she created the algorithm that made this possible. Lines of code isn't the way to measure contribution to a project like this.
@@saassas5879 "Andrew Chael is working on EHT projects at the intersection of theory and observation. He performs GRMHD simulations with new electron temperature evolution code to simulate movies of Sgr A* and M87 to better understand how EHT observations will constrain the plasma physics of the inner accretion flow and jet. He also is a leader on the EHT imaging working group, and has pioneered new algorithms on reconstructing images directly from robust data products like closure phase and amplitude. He is the author of the eht-imaging software library which is used across the collaboration for analyzing data and generating images ."
Congrats to you, and your team's brilliant achievement! The picture is super rad!
specially to the guy that coded 850,000 of the 900,000 lines of code, the real hero from start to finish, she was just part of a big team, nice girl but lets not give her credit she doesnt deserve like if she did this alone or was some of the most important.
@ Again cesar, she created the algorithm that made this possible. Lines of code isn't the way to measure contribution to a project like this.
@@saassas5879 "Andrew Chael is working on EHT projects at the intersection of theory and observation. He performs GRMHD simulations with new electron temperature evolution code to simulate movies of Sgr A* and M87 to better understand how EHT observations will constrain the plasma physics of the inner accretion flow and jet. *He also is a leader on the EHT imaging working group, and has pioneered new algorithms on reconstructing images directly from robust data products like closure phase and amplitude. He is the author of the eht-imaging software library which is used across the collaboration for analyzing data and generating images* ."
@@-hello6177 Yes, so he helped, as one would expect lol
Here's a comment from reddit:
"I'm seeing a lot of comments in here by people who havent had experience with github. Githubs lines of code measurement is an estimate that is usually wrong and counts a lot of things that arent actually code. Andrew did write a good amount of code. But from a quick glance through this github, most of those "lines" are models and data, not code. He didn't write 95 percent of the code.
Hes extremely accomplished and obviously very talented but I doubt he wants to be pitted against his teammate using false statistics."
Yeah about 500.000
I was really confused with the news items...Without this lecture many couldn't have understood it. Thank you and many congrats for the outstanding achievement...
Most of the news stories I read, were unclear on what was done. I agree, this helps a lot.
Its been two year, I have being waiting for the blackhole image.. and the good news.. results are out. Image is awesome. Congratulations guys :)
Also, the image at t=272 is really similar to the actual one, really cool!
Yes. Now its true..done
IcyHammer Dr. Bouer stitched the code between many different teams, and the person who you're trying to give the credit to (Chael) said that he did not write 850,000 lines of code (Twitter). Dr. Bauer was vital to getting this project done, and I am proud of her.
The passion you talk with about this makes me proud of humans!
Is this the most applied PhD thesis ever? Incredible prediction. Take a bow Katie Bouman & team
The people making fun of the camera quality must watch this
Bouman's 2019 Ted Talk:
TOLD. YOU. SO.
Thank you for coming to my TED talk.
Who's here after the image has been released?
not me. im from past. its better. see ya losers.
I’m here after the Sagittarius A* image was released
Came here from Dr. Becky
@@HalStallworth same here
delighted for her that in 2019 everything their team worked on came true.
I don’t think I’ve seen a presentation so personally moving before. Great work everyone.
Mankind will be remembered you forever. Such a great idea you came up with the limited resources and finally you made it.
Mankind will forever remember you and your teams achievement.
If we don't go extinct, that is...
Yes I do
No one's going to remember an affirmative action Make a Wish kid
I hope in the distance future where we are advance, we can take a look at this moment and think to ourselves "look how far we have come".
Going back to university in science and being surrounded by so many sharp people (the majority of whom are women) has been one of the most amazing experiences of my life. Watching Dr. Bouman present is like watching someone you feel you could have a chat with, but with her intelligence stats approaching I_max. So humbling and incredible. Great work on the photo to everyone involved and particularly to Katie.
This is Science people. You theorize an idea and if it’s true you will amaze the world, just like she did on April 10th 2019. Great job to you and your team.
One of the best Ted talks I've seen! Loads of relevant information delivered in a short time. Only thing missing was the moon picture.
Could you imagine if everyone was this intelligent, enthusiastic and amazing!
wow. they achieved it in time and with accurate prediction of what it would look like. well done to everyone
Pretty amazing how close the simulation is to the real thing.
That's science for you!!
Considering there are a lot of gaps in the data, it makes you wonder how much bias was put into filling them in.
@@capnopossum298 That's one reason they had four teams working on it, independently, then they shared their results when they were done.
@@michaelbauers8800 Independent teams with independent algorithms? I haven't heard anything about that. Do you have a source?
Reality always surpase the fantasy
She's like a human golden retriever with her enthusiasm.
Young, smart, and beautiful lady.... I can feel your enthusiasm... I hope all the world will recognize you. Not only the western world. Middle East needs to hear and listen to her to see how women are doing here... to stop conflicts and and belittling woman. We need more education. And freedom in the world.
That woman is one of the loveliest I have ever seen.
CONGRATULATIONS! Humankind remember this forever!!!
Been waiting patiently ever since I watched this years ago, congrats for finally pulling it off.
You, ma'am, are incredible. Pls, ignore these male chauvinist assholes that say that it wasn't you that made this. I am by your side. Thank you so much for your hard work. I also want to thank all the people that were involved in this project, thank you for your contribution to humanity. Y'all deserve a lot. :)
Congrats Dr. Katie & to the whole team, you did incredible achievement. Keep it up!
congrats to you and the team. Saw the video 8 months before and i waited to see the results. now seeing the fruits of ground breaking work done by the scientists is a good feel.
Wish all those guys: Einstein, Eddington, Hawking were alive today to see their work in action. Congratulations to Bauman and all the other awesome guys who made this possible
Saw this talk a while ago, and now i get to see the results! Beautiful!
congrats to your team !!! we finally got it all thanks to you.
Sounds to me like she is explaining how they used a Generative Adversarial Network to fabricate the image. Calling it a photograph is a bit of a stretch.
Some TEDx vids are not worth the time, but this one is legitimate
Amazing!!! What an interesting speaker, didn't even heard the world ' i' 3 times on the whole speech.
🎉🎉 woo girl power!! You go Katie (and team of course)
Funny that the pic from using the "Everyday Puzzle Pieces" is really close to the original image we got 2 days ago. 12:28
Wow just noticed that too.
yes they are that lazy in the lies its likely to just be a screengrab from this video. people dont question these clowns
@@r0uneh ._. you can see the source code in github, execute that and read, and you can read the papers too. I invite you to read actual science and then judge.
@@elvince2 you mention source code, thats fine. you dont address bengejo's point above about the image shown in the video looking almost identical to the recently posted result image, i invite you to look at the actual post you replied to
She did 6% of the work and gets full credit WTF it was a group of 200+ people from all around the world
Hot panda 1213 Lies.
Congrats Katie Bouman for brilliant piece of work!
Who edited this? She talks about the highest resolution picture of the Moon, and it doesnt show..
Congrats to you and your team for this brilliant discovery... Thank you so much
Congratulations. Einstein is smiling down on you and your team and saying "Thank you."
Stephen Hawking is probably drooling now too.
Looking at this is like be someone from the future in that crowd, just seeing what they achieved and see how they nailed their mission. Katie and all the amazing team making history! Proud of watching this giant step of Science.
Congratulation Katie. What a wonderful work.
Who's here because she actually photographed one?
Props to this lady genius! 🔥🔥
@@monkpkey Yes, I did. Why?
Congrats to you, and your team for the brilliant achievement . Awesome work .
Very nice explanation of your sparse patch-based inverse image reconstruction method. You even had a nice picture of the Fourier domain. It takes real skill to be able to explain this sort of thing to a non-technical audience. Way to go ! Looking forward to reading your thesis.
She did it, guys!
I teach middle school science and this is when we start our unit on astronomy. I had a student ask in typical teenager fashion why we are learning about this. I remember reading about the Event Horizon Telescope and used it as an example for how scientists are still exploring and learning new things about our universe. I'm glad I found this video too. While the content is a little steep for middle schoolers, it's great to show them a young role model talking about science. Thanks!
This video gave me goosebumps.
Damn they got it on point, that theoretical image matched the real one perfectly.
Great example of the space between and importance in seeing the difference in the actual work and communication of it. Keep teaching it and discussing it in different ways and voices.
And you did it! Great respect for her, and the rest of the team as well of course! Fascinating lecture. 😊👍🏻
Congratulations Dr Katie Bouman and team.
That's badass Katie! Way to be awesome
@Suffer No Fools I smell envy ..
@Suffer No Fools she created the algorithm that made this possible. Lines of code isn't the way to measure contribution to a project like this.
@Suffer No Fools Dude, any competent programmer can write code that implements an existing algorithm.
Actually coming up with that original algorithm is much, much harder.
Like I said, lines of code is not how you should measure contribution to a project like this.
@Suffer No Fools lmao okay incel
It's the truth that coming up with an algorithm is harder than implementing an existing one.
Here's a comment from reddit:
"I'm seeing a lot of comments in here by people who havent had experience with github. Githubs lines of code measurement is an estimate that is usually wrong and counts a lot of things that arent actually code. Andrew did write a good amount of code. But from a quick glance through this github, most of those "lines" are models and data, not code. He didn't write 95 percent of the code.
Hes extremely accomplished and obviously very talented but I doubt he wants to be pitted against his teammate using false statistics."
Again: "most of those "lines" are models and data, not code. He didn't write 95 percent of the code."
@@sherlyreji1273 ah so you realized that the guy didn't actually write 850,000 lines of code based on that link I posted, right?
And also I'm a dude
CONGRATULATIONS!
Kudos to you! First Margret Hamilton then, you. Inspiration to scientists in general, and a victory for women in science.
Just awesome.
Looking forward to the images you take.
Andddd they’re out
Pic of Sag A* just released to the media. Amazing work!
Amazing job on the achievement and fantastic seminar- in very simple language, easily understandable.
Congratulations Katherine and also your research team.
Way to go Katie! Extremely proud of your mind and your accomplishments. Einstein once said, "Logic will take you from A to B ~ Imagination will take you everywhere." I think 'Herr Einstein' was directly speaking to you. You must ride upon your gift of imagination as a thought experiment first.., then everything will be revealed to you with perfect logic. See you in Stockholm some day.
Congratulations team. You REALLY did it.
Amazing achievement. Congratulations.
I fell in love, congrats for this huge success
Way to go Katie! More power to you
Apparently the image released recently was drawn way back but perhaps it was being reconfirmed for last 3 years so that the errors and doubts are addressed. Kudos.
What an incredible person!
@3:08 For those who say the picture is LOW-RES and not useful
Congratulations! 👏👏👏
Congrats! You have made a mark on science and math that will forever be remembered. There are no words for how grateful I feel to you and your team!
So good 👍🌌
absolutely amazing! Congratulations for your work and thank you for believing in yourself and making this come true. GRL PWR
SHE DID IT! GO KATIE!!!!!!!
AND NOW YOU'VE DONE IT!!!! CONGRATULATIONS!
You go girl!
Great Achievement Katie!! The way you explained, you and your team proved it bang on. Many Congratulations!
She did that congrats Katie bouman
Too bad space doesn't even exist.
It exists between your two ears.
Really appreciatable work by scientists....
Katie Bouman you are an icon who will go down in history!
Oh boy, we should give hundred percent of our income to NASA and MIT to build an Earth sized telescope.
She is total nerdtastic. ladies need to be more like her.
Who's here from the news?? 🙋🏾♂️
This is the first look at what will kill all life in existence..and there is nothing you can do to stop it
I could be mistaking her enthusiasm for excitement and nervousness. This kind of presentation may be a new thing for her.
Hoje temos a certeza absoluta que ela sabe mesmo como fazer isso, DEUSA!
Andrew Chael é o autor da biblioteca de software usada para analisar data e gerar imagens
Congratulations on the results.
🍊 on the 🌝 Incredible achievement! Congrats Dr Bouman! 🙌🏻🙌🏻
Thanks, that was an excellent lecture. Very understandable and succinct.
Why is the background stage setting solo cups?
Hurr Durr Daniel is a dummy pants
Thanks now I can't unsee that.
PleSerecycle
Party out back!
Cuz Phoebe was in charge of the cups.
Excellent presentation, and fantastic work on the algorithm.
Congratulations for getting it after these years.
Very clear explanation.🙂
Love you guys plasma work, for we all over at the EU think blackholes are just a mathematical construct, we think no widgets allowed more like a plasmoid check out the electric/plasma universe
12:27 looks so close to the actual picture
This video deserves more views
Congratulations, you got it.
Sometimes someone make gifts to humanity... You did it this time... Thanks to you and all your team... 04/10 world´s BlackHole day