The real success of Heartland was and still is the Amy and Ty love story. The dating in the season 18 trailer especially Amy's relationship with Nathan is simply the writers attempt to keep the storyline interesting, and not boring. I believe if Ty comes back to the show Heartland will continue with Ty, Amy and Lindy together again. If he doesn't return the writers will conclude the series with Amy unable to accept another(not just because Ty can't be replaced} because of her continuing strong love and feelings for Ty. She will conclude that her peace and happiness is with her as a single mother raising Lindy in the manner Ty would have wanted. In my opinion, because we had 14 years of this remarkable love story, whereby the viewers got to intimately know Ty, it makes it nearly impossible to erase him from the viewers minds and on a larger scale future Heartland seasons. It's a testament toTy's impact on the series, in that he still remains the topic of much fan discussion and love even though he has been missing for over 4 years.
He will always be the obstacle in the series and Amy's life Just watch it all over again and you'll realize that the series doesn't continue without him. It was a love too strong to be forgotten like that Amy's promises, she was always crazy about him and suddenly she forgot? This doesn't match the character's development and the love she always said she has for him.
Amy and Ty are the heart of the show! I would rather see her as a single mother than have her with Nathan or even Caleb . Amy and Ty are soulmates! Any way Ty can be brought back into the story would make the story better. All the other relationships are just minor events but Amy and Ty are the main storyline.I hope the writers make a miracle happen and bring Ty back and write the story as it should be....Amy and Ty and Lindy together again as they belong! 0:00
We don't want this show to stop. My mom and I want Ty to come back to the show and not as a dream, we want to have him come back to the show as a person and not as anything else. Just bring him back to the show now.
I do not want Amy with Nathan at all he's a jerk! And caleb is to good of a friend and when they tried to get them together in the beginning of heartland and I didn't like it! Please bring back Ty for the final season and let Amy and Ty have their happy ever after! Pay the actor anything he wants to bring him back!!
Graham Wardle has made it EXTREMELY clear multiple times on his “Time has Come” podcast, Instagram livestreams, TH-cam live chats and the many interviews that he has done that he is NOT coming back to Heartland!
Dear writers if you don’t bring Ty back on season 18 I hope the ratings for the show goes down to zero..and it’s all your own fault for taking Ty of the heartland show in the first place and not offering him more to stay, I know I won’t be watching season 18 if Ty don’t come back and I hope the rest of the fans will follow..Heartland is Ty and Amy don’t you writers understand that, and it’s not worth watching without Ty and Amy in it why can’t you kick Nathan and Caleb off the show their nothing but nuisance.
Pay the actor what ever he wants to come back we want Ty back no else has the chemistry like Amy and Ty have on heartland they fit the whole love story from beginning to end we don’t want Ty back as a dream we want him back as a real person Nathan is a jerk
How can Ty rise from the grave?!? I loved Ty & Amy as much as possible for a tv show, but, I also watched my Mother be lowered 6’ underground into her grave, just as Ty was, have I ever thought my mom would reappear, nope, I’ve prayed and cried, and begged God that I could hug her 1 more time, but, I’ve never expected to see her again, except, maybe in Heaven
Sounds like Ty will not return permanently - so this will be my last comment and I will not watch Heartland any more. Thanks again for the great shows in the past.
I don’t think Ty will be coming back, but that’s what I thought about Mallory when her horse died she came back, but I believe Thai was cremated and his ashes were spread so I highly doubt he will be coming back alive but flash backs maybe but I don’t think her daughter will be happy about a step dad I don’t want one myself
I’m thinking Ty won’t be returning to Heartland. For a split second I actually thought he was coming back but I got into a heated argument with one TH-camr just yesterday and she said that he won’t be coming back, yes Ty did die but my thoughts are he was cremated into ashes so how could he return to Heartland in human form. I can’t go off by what this TH-camr has said so he might return. This person on TH-cam sounded very confident that Ty would not be coming back to the show but she hit some heart strings in my chest and in a way hurt my feelings for having hope that Graham Wardle will return as Ty. But I honestly don’t know, I think the only way to know for sure is to see for myself if Ty is really coming back or if these videos is just fake news.
Goodbye ty, you're dead. We buried you. No come backsies😂 Nathan not only offers a new love and adventure but a possible increase in the cattle business! Nathan may be complicated but his character's arch could be amazing when he realizes he's already in love with Amy. ...oh and sorry Caleb, You're a good friend.
If ty comes back it will not be as a ghost. If he comes back it be. For good nobody knows what going to happen and hia name is on heartland. In season 18
Now the narrator says the posability of Ty's return into H L show now is ?nabl,, HL narrator make up yur dm official anser Ty is back as a regular Yes or no
My goodness! Get over Ty, he is not coming back to the show. He has said it over and over on his podcast. So get over it! Let Amy move on with Nathan. I am enjoying season 18.
People Ty is not coming back. He was gone alot on the last couple of seasons. The show will go on. They are other people on the show besides Ty.. I hope it's Caleb can't wait till it gets here in the USA
No TY BACK To HEARTLAND NO HEARTLAND AMY is is becoming nothing like Heartland how old is stupid love interest in talk about marriage to to Caleb or Nathan is just the end of the show. Best fans do not plan on watching Heartland anymore if if if these love interests that are being proposed that are showing up on Heartland to me and the rest of these the fans Harlan might as well just stop and just end if Heartland is going to continue Amy needs to be more of a mother than a love interest mentality a cheap soap opera star to us the fans Heartland is over if this is the case get rid of all the love interests it's coming to to to Amy and Heartland yes just destroyed the show we will go to things like Yellowstone and other shows that aren't conflicted as much Amy should be a mother like her mother and get rid of all the stupid love interests the writers are destroying the show as far as this fans are concerned Heartland is dying or is dead just that simple goodbye Heartland looking forward to watching other shows if this is the case goodbye Heartland!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
ty needs to come back it's not a show without him
The real success of Heartland was and still is the Amy and Ty love story. The dating in the season 18 trailer especially Amy's relationship with Nathan is simply the writers attempt to keep the storyline interesting, and not boring. I believe if Ty comes back to the show Heartland will continue with Ty, Amy and Lindy together again. If he doesn't return the writers will conclude the series with Amy unable to accept another(not just because Ty can't be replaced} because of her continuing strong love and feelings for Ty. She will conclude that her peace and happiness is with her as a single mother raising Lindy in the manner Ty would have wanted. In my opinion, because we had 14 years of this remarkable love story, whereby the viewers got to intimately know Ty, it makes it nearly impossible to erase him from the viewers minds and on a larger scale future Heartland seasons. It's a testament toTy's impact on the series, in that he still remains the topic of much fan discussion and love even though he has been missing for over 4 years.
@@josephfratto I was not a great fan of Tys. The story is still good with out him. I'm really enjoying the teen age Katie.
No Ty no watch
He will always be the obstacle in the series and Amy's life Just watch it all over again and you'll realize that the series doesn't continue without him. It was a love too strong to be forgotten like that Amy's promises, she was always crazy about him and suddenly she forgot? This doesn't match the character's development and the love she always said she has for him.
@@lindaharrison1426 teenage katie is boring though honestly.
❤❤🎉🎉 hope ty dose come back and Amy and ty gets back together they make a beautiful couple and I can't wait to watch it
Amy and Ty are the heart of the show! I would rather see her as a single mother than have her with Nathan or even Caleb . Amy and Ty are soulmates! Any way Ty can be brought back into the story would make the story better. All the other relationships are just minor events but Amy and Ty are the main storyline.I hope the writers make a miracle happen and bring Ty back and write the story as it should be....Amy and Ty and Lindy together again as they belong! 0:00
We don't want this show to stop. My mom and I want Ty to come back to the show and not as a dream, we want to have him come back to the show as a person and not as anything else. Just bring him back to the show now.
resurrect him?
Totally agree need him back
I do not want Amy with Nathan at all he's a jerk! And caleb is to good of a friend and when they tried to get them together in the beginning of heartland and I didn't like it! Please bring back Ty for the final season and let Amy and Ty have their happy ever after! Pay the actor anything he wants to bring him back!!
I don't want to see Amy with Nathan! Amy's one and only love is Ty. I hope that Ty comes back in season 18. Here's hoping.
Ty has to come back😢
We need ty Amy back on heartland family not Caleb not Nathan ty back to love the family he love for ever
That's right I agree with you on that
Bring Ty back
Watching from st.martin please pleas ty. Come back find it in your heart to make this old lady happy
Ty. Yes
Yes bring Ty back in. Seasons 18
Por qué siempre buscando pareja para Emy. Sólo Ty fue su gran amor ❤❤Nadie será mejor. Emy y Ty por siempre 💕
Please bring ty back Amy needs him ,no one else
Graham Wardle has made it EXTREMELY clear multiple times on his “Time has Come” podcast, Instagram livestreams, TH-cam live chats and the many interviews that he has done that he is NOT coming back to Heartland!
Bring in a look alike to play Ty. It is not the same without the Ty and Amy bond. The writers blew it.
Never be a movie till ty returns
Dear writers if you don’t bring Ty back on season 18 I hope the ratings for the show goes down to zero..and it’s all your own fault for taking Ty of the heartland show in the first place and not offering him more to stay, I know I won’t be watching season 18 if Ty don’t come back and I hope the rest of the fans will follow..Heartland is Ty and Amy don’t you writers understand that, and it’s not worth watching without Ty and Amy in it why can’t you kick Nathan and Caleb off the show their nothing but nuisance.
He was ready to leave
Was his choice
Excited for future endeavors
I agree with Nathan but Caleb isn’t really in love with Amy. He still loves Ashley
They are making Amy like Lou was the first seasons of Heartland look at the first seasons and you’ll see what I’m talking about
Ty needs to be with her is the only one that fits with Amy
Pay the actor what ever he wants to come back we want Ty back no else has the chemistry like Amy and Ty have on heartland they fit the whole love story from beginning to end we don’t want Ty back as a dream we want him back as a real person Nathan is a jerk
How can Ty rise from the grave?!? I loved Ty & Amy as much as possible for a tv show, but, I also watched my Mother be lowered 6’ underground into her grave, just as Ty was, have I ever thought my mom would reappear, nope, I’ve prayed and cried, and begged God that I could hug her 1 more time, but, I’ve never expected to see her again, except, maybe in Heaven
Why do you do this? Bring Ty back to life .
We all hope Ty comes back because they make a cute couple and they belong together and Amy needs him and so does Lindy and everybody else
When is the series coming out
Sounds like Ty will not return permanently - so this will be my last comment and I will not watch Heartland any more. Thanks again for the great shows in the past.
Is it coming on netflix
I don’t think Ty will be coming back, but that’s what I thought about Mallory when her horse died she came back, but I believe Thai was cremated and his ashes were spread so I highly doubt he will be coming back alive but flash backs maybe but I don’t think her daughter will be happy about a step dad I don’t want one myself
I’m thinking Ty won’t be returning to Heartland. For a split second I actually thought he was coming back but I got into a heated argument with one TH-camr just yesterday and she said that he won’t be coming back, yes Ty did die but my thoughts are he was cremated into ashes so how could he return to Heartland in human form. I can’t go off by what this TH-camr has said so he might return. This person on TH-cam sounded very confident that Ty would not be coming back to the show but she hit some heart strings in my chest and in a way hurt my feelings for having hope that Graham Wardle will return as Ty. But I honestly don’t know, I think the only way to know for sure is to see for myself if Ty is really coming back or if these videos is just fake news.
Goodbye ty, you're dead. We buried you. No come backsies😂 Nathan not only offers a new love and adventure but a possible increase in the cattle business! Nathan may be complicated but his character's arch could be amazing when he realizes he's already in love with Amy. ...oh and sorry Caleb, You're a good friend.
Amy not married the Nathan the snake or caleb .Amy want till ty come back heartland. Then will be a loving and happy heartland family gane
Grahm said he wasn't coming back and didnt want to come back. He ashed that to be killed off to do other things. No, Ty is not coming back.
If ty comes back it will not be as a ghost. If he comes back it be. For good nobody knows what going to happen and hia name is on heartland. In season 18
Then how are they going to explain where Ty has been all that time and why he was pronounced dead? Why does he return?
but heartlanf beef is only cow calf not a feedlot
He was dead in coma now he is back
Money buys everything!
Now the narrator says the posability of Ty's return into H L show now is ?nabl,, HL narrator make up yur dm official anser Ty is back as a regular Yes or no
I don’t want Ty to come back
return to me
have watched the first 2 episodes season 18 and TY does not come back!
My goodness! Get over Ty, he is not coming back to the show. He has said it over and over on his podcast. So get over it! Let Amy move on with Nathan. I am enjoying season 18.
People Ty is not coming back. He was gone alot on the last couple of seasons. The show will go on. They are other people on the show besides Ty.. I hope it's Caleb can't wait till it gets here in the USA
Why can't Amy just be like her Mom.... a single Mom and a great horse whisper
No TY BACK To HEARTLAND NO HEARTLAND AMY is is becoming nothing like Heartland how old is stupid love interest in talk about marriage to to Caleb or Nathan is just the end of the show. Best fans do not plan on watching Heartland anymore if if if these love interests that are being proposed that are showing up on Heartland to me and the rest of these the fans Harlan might as well just stop and just end if Heartland is going to continue Amy needs to be more of a mother than a love interest mentality a cheap soap opera star to us the fans Heartland is over if this is the case get rid of all the love interests it's coming to to to Amy and Heartland yes just destroyed the show we will go to things like Yellowstone and other shows that aren't conflicted as much Amy should be a mother like her mother and get rid of all the stupid love interests the writers are destroying the show as far as this fans are concerned Heartland is dying or is dead just that simple goodbye Heartland looking forward to watching other shows if this is the case goodbye Heartland!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
I'm a best fan and I plan on watching it!
How can you lie so much to your fans? 😂
Ty can come back but he can come back as a different character name and be someone else
Graham is Ty who acted Ty only. People keep calling Graham Ty.
@@jeanmillburg3343 I'm aware... I said ty because I'm referring to his character ty
He does not come back
Just watched episode 4. Still no Ty
Ty cannot come back his is dead.
Agree. I am so sick if these fake Ty is coming g back stories.
He never died. He had Togo in hieding.
Listen to the facts.
You cannot come back when they scattered Ty’s ashes they need to stop saying he is coming back he even said that in his podcast
I am So sad that Ty died I loved him and Amy. Can anyone understand that Ty is never gonna come back.
Sorry but Graham Wardle will not be back. Please stop saying that he is because it's not going to happen. Get over it and let Amy go on with her life.
I won't watch if he comes back,he left the show so stay gone.
How do people fall for this crap? Graham Wardle has no interest in coming back.