After her husband, Rajesh, was arrested for the murder of their 13-year-old daughter, Nupur Talwar had spoken to NDTV about the incomprehensible tragedy and its aftermath. Watch more videos: www.ndtv.com/video
How can somebody give an interview after being struck by such a tragedy and not shed even a single tear!!! The interview was done on Aarushi’s Birthday!
+Vasav Chawla Bro..we make our minds by the way we saw things..if we watch talwar we think parents are innocent bt if saw news and other things for a second we thinks parents killed her..what actually happened that night is still a secret the truth is only known by arushi her self or the killer may be all the theories we know are wrong..the truth can be smthng else may b parents and servents both are innocent..some third person is involved cbi and police both are currpt. recenty in an interview arun kumar(who's role is played by irrfan khan) said the cutting of the wall on which killer left his hand print is still in cbi evidnce uk have the technolgy by which the DNA in wall can be extracted..but we cannot do anything bcz this is INDIA my friend
I could never get over this case since it first happened and this interview always baffles me!!! Whether they are guilty or not her demeanor is very very weird. She seems so detached and matter of fact 😐😐
No one can talk that casually about her own daughter’s murder just 8 days after it. People tear up even if it’s a natural death. No matter what anyone says it’s not difficult to understand that there was foul play and parents were involved. She isn’t curious to know who killed her daughter.
I agree I read her body language which shouts if someone hears. The guilty people always look down. Purposely they invited so many people into their homes after the murder so the police get no evidence against them.
She did say that, though not in the hammy exaggerated manner you expected. This is not one of those platforms to audition for an Ekta Kapoor melodramas.
She would be hysterical asking for justice to be served if she didn't know who did it.... Her tone is more defensive rather than pleading for finding her killer
the way she kept saying Sonia kinda makes me feel she was using manipulation tactics on her. like iykyk when you say someone's name multiple times they tend to feel safe with you and believe your words
Yup, these guys have no clue that Hemraj's body was lying in their terrace. When police came to their house, Rajesh declared Hemraj killed her daughter and escaped. This couple was there in the house & 2 people were murdered & they know nothing about that?? It raises suspicion.
The anchor is so tense while mrs nupur is trying to make herself comfortable by calling Sonia, Sonia, Sonia.There is not much talk about her daughter's memories but husband's goodness. Period
the comments remind me of Gone Girl. Cry a little, gain sympathy and you are the best person in the world. Be headstrong, talk sense and you are a liar. :)
This is funny you see the difference between the host and the mother, the mother seems tired and traumatised, seems like she has been crying for days. Don't judge too soon.
Her bodylanguage clearly says she knows the reality of incident esp when she says killer is somewhere there and dip her eyes down instead of eyecontacting the anchor. Also I can see a silent grin of a liar in her eyes.
anyone who has studied psychology at a respected university will know that this body behavior and response is normal in victims of rape or families of murdered victims etc it's media that makes us think that the natural response is crying and yelling etc. In reality, when something like this happens the person is in shock and has lack of affect/emotions- they haven't psychological coped w the sorrows of the loss - tht actually takes years to overcome and deal w.
I have studied experimental psychology at University of Cambridge, UK. I hope that's 'respected' enough for you. No, crying is not essential for expressing sadness and in deed people could be in shock. That's the story on one end - however, you should have also talk about psychopaths. Psychopaths exist in all walks of life. I am not saying that what you are saying is wrong. I am saying that you are only stating one end of the argument - a true professional opinion should be a neutral opinion. I know a girl of (from a very similar background as the girl arushi ). She attended top university on scholarship - dad came to drop her and extremely proud mother based non graduation picture, single child, innocent as anything in her daily life. Over the years it turns out her father used to touch her sexually when she was a kid and her uncle had sex with her, a memory she repressed and came out under therapy. Her mum kept silent because she wanted to save the marriage so she overlooked. This girl in adulthood suddenly also went crazy in terms of sex and secretly started leading life as a prostitute - a woman who has a day job in one of the most prestigious firms in the worlds. Happy families are not necessarily happy. The west has more records of sexual abuse of children because they take it seriously and in countries such as India they don't. I am not saying that I have a hypothesis. I am saying that it is impossible to tell and everything has been dealt with superficially. For example, a motive doesn't have to be servant being found in a compromising position and then father has an issue with it. Maybe the opposite happened. What amuses me is how people on either side is so thoroughly convinced of their opinion!
Exactly. And it's also about emotional intelligence, most of us aren't that good in EI but there ARE people who are really good with it irrespective of what comes their way, it's all about how fast you "accept" after undergoing that stage of anger and denial.
The fact still remains that it is so contradictory that they heard the door bell the next day morning when the helper came home. But unable to hear what was going on in the bedroom right next door ? Yet again there was no proof of forced entry in the house.
I heard that outside door was locked on the next day. Does it mean that they have an habitual of leaving the door open while go for sleeping ? What a funny story her parents are cooking up...
@@nikita-vp7ms seriously?? Do u think a bell makes more noise than actions which will happen during a murder especially around 1 am when everything will be silent that too in a room which is just beside yours??
Moreover if this same case would have happened in some remote village of haryana or rajasthan and the parents were uneducated wearing dhotis, then whole of so called educated johnies would have easily pointed parents as murderers....have shame and give justice to that poor soul..
That is because education teaches you not to kill in the name of honour..or kill at all. It is always more likely that fingers will be pointed at uneducated citizens, since education not only gives you marks and a job, but also a sense of morality and what is right and wrong.
Cuz honour killing usually occurs where people care about honour more than actual life and humanity , These people were very liberal with their daughter , they had a 24 hour male servant , she was allowed sleepovers and boyfriend , does honour killing make any sense?
@@shazz9194maybe boyfriend was fine but not servant. Can educated parents do something like this? Well mostly not but very few might you never know and this is one of the rarest cases of educated parents doing such a thing so yeah parents are the murderers.
her demeanour 8 days after her daughter s murder was indeed quite wierd. even the anchor seemed more pained. this interview was the major blot against her
I'm a mother of a 20 year old. When she cries for something even I will cry with her. How can a mother be this bold just after 8days of murder. I would have died with her too if she was my daughter or I would have cried during the whole interview.
Not everyone is like you , maam! They might be strong or they be might be holding back her tears I can see tiredness on her face. And nobody dies for no body. My two friends died few years back their parents are living now happily. Life always goes on!
@@saijalnaini4831 are wo ek doctor h uske lie ye blood and all this bhot common h aur 8 din hogye to kya ab tak rote rahegi 🤦 sab log ek jaise nhi hote medical me emotionally strong banate h
@@saijalnaini4831 you wrong in this context. How much bold a person could be, if she is a mother never ever help her that boldness if at all she is in a point of losing her own child. I am a bold person, however a small abrasion or a light fever my children suffer it leaves me sleepless nights. So this womans stoic attitude itself is unbelievable
anchor seems more serious then her mother..doesn't look like she lost her daughter just 8 days ago. .I came here after watching talvar,I ws thinking parents are innocent but now I am in doubt. .. .
Reactions can't be generalised bro, they said it in the movie also. But yeah if it was someone close to me I'd not react this way, at the end of the day different people have different reactions
There is something disturbing behind how casually she can talk about a brutal murder of her own 13 yo daughter on her birthday. Man this is pure shame. Only if we could see what a person is seeing in his thoughts, we could see her visualising the whole terrifying and brutal incident as she talks to the reporter with clearly no grief, guilt or shame
It’s probably the dad who had an argument and killed her overnight like off weirdly and then the servant was found dead next day for the fact that they might have killed him since he might have seen something wrong & that’s why the planned all this & now she’s just taking his side now cause he’s left & she has no shame,she’s tellinh so many details about the events like she has thought abt it already alot many times,which for sure shows somethinh went wrong with the family & then the servant just witnessed it.
unsolved hi hai iss interview me uski baato se toh sab sahi lg rha h but she was licking her lips too much which is a sign of lying still if not the parents then who killed her@@maheshsahu9790
First time I am hearing someone giving interview is addressing the name of the interviewer, many many times. Usually the speaking is not for the interviewer but to the whole world….. rings a bell right?
Throughout the interview, she was calm, eyes were dead, and absolutely no expressions on her face showed that she is devastated.. She kept saying I have faith in legal system like she wants them to know how she still trusts them to not go against them.. a mother who lost her daughter so brutally wouldn't say she "trusts the legal system", she would say "how can anyone kill her.. how did anyone enter the house? I want to know who the killer is?" But she didn't say any of it. This isn't it. Her tone of voice, her body language is telling a whole another story as well.
+book worm I strongly believe that first the movie release, then Times of India support for the convicted criminal(parents) then release of the narco test indicate that parents are trying their best to convince people of India that they are innocent and victim or wrong judgement. However, there are many points clearly indicate that parents are the real culprits. 1 ).The precise cut to her throat/neck seems very suspect. Someone who used a golf club earlier would never come back to 'finish the job' with a precise cut. 3).Plus, even though he could not rape her, the autopsy report clarifies that something did happen to her, from examination of her private and redressed her cloths and undergarments. 4). burning the bed off before forensic investigations completed, applying for anticipatory bail before the case began and the police even started pointing fingers. 5). they also refused to hand over the terrace key to the police for 3 days. 6) That the clothes of both the accused were not found soaked with blood. It is highly unnatural that parents of deceased Aarushi will not cling to and hug her on seeing her murdered. 7) That it is not possible that an outsider(s) after committing the murders will muster courage to take Scotch whisky knowing that the parents of the deceased Aarushi are in the nearby room and his top priority will be to run away from the crime scene immediately. 8) That the door of the terrace was never locked prior to the occurrence but it was found locked in the morning of May 16, 2008 and the accused did not give the key of the lock to the police despite being asked to give the same.
Lets be objective. 1. Precise single stroke cut using dentist scalpel to slice the neck? Not possible. 2. 3. cleaned private parts and redressed the cloths but the pajama was low and buttock cleavage visible? If the intention was to erase evidence of sexual act, pajama would have been neatly in place with strings tied, so that no body would have any doubt. Why the issue of cleaning private parts raised after 1.5 year after initial NAD? The details mentioned about vaginal orifice etc is just "Non sense". 4. Who burnt the bed? Police asked it to be thrown on terrace do avoid media glare. Why didnt UP police seize the bed, if it was important? 5. Refuse the terrace key for three days? Your imagination. Please be clear of the facts. 6. Parents cloth did show blood signs of aarushi but not of hemraj. Regarding "why not soaked in blood?"hug and cry are all bollywood cliches. 7. Just a theory. 8. It is just a speculation. If the murderer was known to Hemraj and was with him that night, he had the access to key, especially after killing him. Hence it is possible that he could have locked the terrace and took it away.
book worm as a parent if your child is lying dead the next room the first inclination of the parent would be to know who did this to their kid rather than hastily cremating him/her. They had no interest even when the police knocked at the door. They must be involved somehow.
After watching this interview, this is what I observed with the body language and tone of talk from the mother and the way she responds to every question. The lip smacking, the eyes tilted down position when faced with brutal words like murder, death, birthday. She is in total support for the husband when asked about his involvement in the crime. She leaned more emotionally towards her husband than her dead daughter, clear indication not because she didn't love her daughter, but because she had to save of what is left for her and that's her husband. The daughter has been killed out or rage or by accident. It has to be one or the two. The mother is clearly distraught and disappointed here, that some terribly hitting gone wrong due to instant rage and anger from either her or her husband. Personally I assume, it would have been the husband. No outsider involved, 4 people alive before 12AM and out of which 2 perished. The remainder two are burdened with the proof.
And they couldn't recognize the servant's dead body including his clothings as if the servant got changed middle of the night before the incident. Officials had to call the servant's friends to recognise the dead body, Are they both not educated doctors themselves. Come on!!
This was 10 days after Aarushi's death. After crying continuously for 2-3 days one just cannot cry anymore. One gets the strength from the ones they lost. The fact that she did not cry proves she is not acting fake.
She doesn't want to say that she has killed her own daughter for having sex with her servant Hemraj. Now she is repeating the same phrase - All I can say is .......I don't know what to say..... (What else can you say Big Liar and Murderer!!!)
NONSENSE. its her only daughter. parents will cry 10, 20, 30 years after their childs death. esp if the killer is not found .. i hope this will go down in history as a cold case to be investigated again in future..
How can you say that she lost her babay and I don’t think that any mother can talk like this after seeing daughter or sons dead body. My grandma lost her son 7/8 years ago and till now when she talks about her son she starts crying she cannot control her self. And this interview was on her birthday after 8 days of her murderd and she really normal and can talk so much 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Chaar chavvani ghode pe.. God mere laude pe. Koi God ni hta bas energy hti h vo ek form se dusre form me jti h and everything is just as it is.. Nothing is wrong or bad in this world it's just a situation which keeps on changing.. We humans label it.. So relax
That's what ..this case has so many wierd things that just points fingers at talwar . 1) who would stay back after committing not one but two murders then clean arushi room . 2 ) hemraj body was dragged till terrace then body was covered with cooler panel and paritition between two terraces ( terrrace adjacent to talwar terrace ) was covered by a blanket . Which killer would take so much of pain to do so many things that too at night and at some other person house . Any way after killing they would run away so hidding the body on terrace and locking it up doesn't makes sense unless killer is from the same house 3 ) ballenti bottle found on the tabel of hall had blood of both arushi and hemraj ..so killer had a drink after killing servant and arushi . Wow killer had lots of guts I must say . 4 ) golf stick no. 6 I guess and surgical blade were never recovered . Did police check talwar 's car right after the incident . No they dint .
I didn’t see a sigh of grief in her eyes . No matter how much strong you are there comes a point when even a stone hearted breaks down but this woman is really strong.
See how she never takes Aarushis name, she keeps referring to her as "our daughter" or "someone's daughter", typical sociopathic tendencies to dissociate yourself from the victim
Is this case ever going to be resolved? No matter how many articles i read, how many documentaries i watch....it is never clear. It breaks my heart that an innocent child was killed so many years ago and nobody still knows who is the killer. Even if it is the parents, there is no way to prove it. As they showed in the movie, the initial investigation by the local police ruined the case long time ago.
How can a mom , just after 8 days of her daughter's death wear a bindi , get dressed up and not even shed a single tear ......brutual 😢...she totally is not guilty ...she's faking it for sure ...
Either she is very strong mentally or she is the culprit... 8:40 when she said yes today is Arushi birthday, I was expecting some tears to come out or maybe a emotional pause or change in voice when crying internally....... But nothing happened she continued her story.... Shocking
Its neither She is in deep shock Whenever someone is in deep shock they dont cry they dont show emotions they dont yell or scream or show any tears at all they speak normally is due to shock and stress
@@berries8691 whenever someone is in deep shock, they can't even speak a damn word. Totally silent. otherwise, it was not a shock just acting. Remember it cuts both ways.
@@berries8691 Then its not shock sir/mam. Shock actually means you are not able to process situations or interactions normally. If they are able to reflect and answer to questions in such a composed manner. Sorry to say, they might be guilty or not guilty but they are definitely not in a shock.
How can any mother remain calm and not shed a single tear?? This looks so shocking It isn’t possible to give such a long interview just few days after your loved one’s demise on her BIRTHDAY and not get emotional! No matter how strong a person is this is not possible, her eyes didn’t even get watery ! So unbelievable!!
This was just after 8 days... Unbelievably defensive!!! Her expressions don't match her words. She is talking like its was a robbery or theft not her daughter's murder
She definitely would have been going through a lot and each individual would have different ways of expressing their emotions and some of them keep it inside and would not want to express it out to the world....
exactly, her daughter was brutally murdered in their house, and she keeps saying how her husband has been taken away like the two situations are the same thing. This woman is a clearcut pshychopath killer.
@@mayur5860 that's highly unlikely. If someone else killed Arushi then who?? How did he entered their house. He could definitely be hemrajs friend or someone. If we assume that he killed Arushi and then escaped & Rajesh woke up and thought Hemraj killed Arushi then let me tell you its highly unlikely. The moment Hemraj would know that "unknown" guy killed arushi, he would too have escaped in fear.
-mrs talwar ko naa bhulein.. Madam player h purri Husband ki main strength h puri tarah Husband kbka bk deta sb.. But the Women is Still like Hills.. She haven't moved a bit.. Mentally strong.. Clever Fox... Beti toh gyi but aab Husband ko toh bachaa lun 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@shinchannohara2924 -mrs talwar ko naa bhulein.. Madam player h purri Husband ki main strength h puri tarah Husband kbka bk deta sb.. But the Women is Still like Hills.. She haven't moved a bit.. Mentally strong.. Clever Fox... Beti toh gyi but aab Husband ko toh bachaa lun 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@shinchannohara2924 Talwars ko halki doori samjh re ho kya.. Planning nhi master plan bnaya tha Miyaan biwi n... Police ko 1000 baar ye bole ki Hemraj n kia.. Hemraj bhaag gya.. Maa baap h.. Police n socha hoga jhooth thodi bolenge 😅🤣.. Iklauti aulaad thi.. Sach bol re h.. House help bhi gaayab h.. Chlo.. Nepal 🤣🤣 Character assassination hua Hemraj ka.. Ki wo Murderer h.. Ladki k saath Rape krta h.. Uski family Jiska kisiko pta tk nhi h.. Ye h humanity.. Talwars ko search kr rahe ho.. Ek baar uss bichaare Hemraj ki family se related kuch padhho.. Vdo dekho.. Hum audience hi ase jaanwaron ko hero bnaati h.. Bs Aarushi Aarushi.. 2 murder hue the.. Hemraj Rest in Peace Sir.. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻❣❣❣❣ Talwars murder h.. Hemraj k room door ko use kia sb krne k liye.. Qki agar by chance koi proof mila toh uske room se milega.. Police ko toh kabhi uss bichaare ki body bhi nahi milte.. Vo toh Neighborhood m kisi n Terrece p deka.. Or police ko bulaya.. Ni tih Talwars tbhi bach gye hote.. Or socho Hemraj toh milta nhi Police ko qki unhe lgta bhaag gya Or fir Talwars ka asli game shuru hota Sympathy ka.. Log bhi unka saath dete Hemraj ki family ko jail ho jaati bhaisaab.. Bhagwaan n thodi madad krdi us family ki by that neighbor🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Her eyes have no shock, no pain for her daughter who died such a horrific death just a week ago! Being 'brave' is different. The first question on her lips should be, 'who killed my daughter??' But this woman is only concerned about her husband, not her daughter. How strange is that? I think she knows who did it already. She blamed Hemraj who was found lying dead the next day on the roof. So we know it wasn't him. This is not a mother asking for justice for a heinous crime done to her daughter..she is wife waiting for her husband to return home
I remember watching this infamous interview. A lot of speculation regarding the parents' involvement in the murder began after this interview because of her stoic appearance.
I dont know if I'm wrong, but she sounds like she's uninterested to get to the bottom of this. Kind of like she's shrugging it off. I'm not talking about how she's not crying or anything, but she doesn't seem to have that hope or determination to find out who murdered her daughter.
Exactly! Normally every parent will be crying out to serve justice and find out wat happened dat unfateful night..but here she is no mood to find closure ,bcoz deep inside she knows the truth and witnessed it herself! And moreover, no sense of shock in ger behaviour..its only 8 days
@@rashmisikka5814 exactly...see how her lips quiver and how non chalant she seems.....just see Vanessa Bryant and how she reacts....nupur's behaviour seems really off track
I strongly believe that first the movie release, then Times of India support for the convicted criminal(parents) then release of the narco test indicate that parents are trying their best to convince people of India that they are innocent and victim or wrong judgement. However, there are many points clearly indicate that parents are the real culprits. 1 ).The precise cut to her throat/neck seems very suspect. Someone who used a golf club earlier would never come back to 'finish the job' with a precise cut. 3).Plus, even though he could not rape her, the autopsy report clarifies that something did happen to her, from examination of her private and redressed her cloths and undergarments. 4). burning the bed off before forensic investigations completed, applying for anticipatory bail before the case began and the police even started pointing fingers. 5). they also refused to hand over the terrace key to the police for 3 days. 6) That the clothes of both the accused were not found soaked with blood. It is highly unnatural that parents of deceased Aarushi will not cling to and hug her on seeing her murdered. 7) That it is not possible that an outsider(s) after committing the murders will muster courage to take Scotch whisky knowing that the parents of the deceased Aarushi are in the nearby room and his top priority will be to run away from the crime scene immediately. 8) That the door of the terrace was never locked prior to the occurrence but it was found locked in the morning of May 16, 2008 and the accused did not give the key of the lock to the police despite being asked to give the same.
People watching narco of krishna - oh he does this he does that .. confirmd he is the culprit Same people watching this interview - watch her body language..she is the culprit
The way she is talking, it's just impossible to accept she doesn't know the whole scene. No pain, no grief and literally zero hesitation talking about a terrifying and brutal murder of her own 13 yo daughter. Even if it was accidental she knows it and even sees it to this day when she closes her eyes about how the throat of her own girl was slit, how she screamed and how it looked. Lucky for them they had powerful contacts and the initial response police messed up the crime scene. They don't even deserve hell
I'm watching this just few minutes after watching Jiah Khan's mother talking about her after 7 years, she was looking more in grief and sad comparing this fake mother! I doubt if Arushi was really their biological child!
How can a mother of only child losing her brutally able to face national media within 8days of death.And she doesn't says a single word about her birthday even the anchor is saying...
This woman has guts, really guts.After having killed her daughter she has come for an interview.We loose our pet we cry foul but this lady having lost her only child she is so calm and compose. Poor hemraj and aarushi.
From the very first moment of the interview she looked like a person gripped with shame rather than grief or loss. she never looked into camera straight up; while appealing to public at large when being asked by the journalist, she is at loss of words and said everything with her head held low. the expression at 1:02 tells it all when she is refuting the initial charges.
13:38 look as she tries so hard to fake her emotions and tries to cry to show it as she couldn't just bare it to say that "arushi had been taken away". Shame on you and shame on the justice system
@@captain4595 I am not saying them to show their teary Eyes.But at least if they had emotions for the death of their Daughter they would have Fought for her
@@captain4595Dude it was murder! Even if it was accident, parents would be devastated coz it’s sudden death. Sudden deaths are quite painful and shocking. Parents are the killers bro
People go into deep emotional shock ,yes.. they exhibit lack of emotions, yes... but people in deep shock also cannot talk so much, listen so carefully, respond so quickly .. Not for once did she wonder or say " who killed my daughter? How did they even enter? How could I not hear anthing" .... Nothing
Listen to her in video after 5:07min. The mother says "Aarushi must have witnessed something" Exactly, she probably witness her dad killing the servant. That explains a lot about that night.
And today is her birthday I mean when this interview was happening It's unbelievable to watch the mother either she is so damn strong or idk how she is doing this
No tears, licking lips all the time and smiling more than tv presenter 🤔 whoever killed servant and tried to hide his body wanted it to look like that servant killed the girl and run away 🤔 what killer would want this scenario?
4 :50 when I woke up I obviously thought it was the servant.......... 5.30 hemraj was the servent whom I trusted.......I never had any problem with him.he always cared for her. I never thought.........
@@sumitgoel8854 how would anyone raise suspicion directly on their loyal servant? The first thing naturally be .."and where is hemraj!?? Omg... he's also killed " , isn't?
Mom and dad killed her.....100% true.....coz isne ek baar bhi nahi kha ki meri beti ko kisne mara kyu maara...usne kisika ka bigada tha......ek baar bhi nahi bola
Coz the parents had planned the murder over a long period of time and they had come to terms with the fact.everything is rehearsed over here.they've gone over everything in detail.
8:40 "Anyways coming back to that day" - notice how casually she comes back to justify that they are not involved. It sounds so fake and constructed. Sometimes I feel this lady killed aarushi in the rage of anger while the father killed hemraj. Even the maid said that mother was not mourning much after discovering the body and was trying to blame hemraj. CBI head was also suspicious of her more than the father
SHE IS BLINKING LESS.. AND BLINKS DIFFERENTLY... normally the blinking rate every blink in 2 to 10 seconds. Liars blink less frequently than normal during the lie, and then speed up to around eight times faster than usual afterwards.
Having a daughter , it is always usual to keep a female as a helper.. that too living in room close to the daughter… also there is alcohol at home. Everything is suspicious isn’t it?
How can somebody give an interview after being struck by such a tragedy and not shed even a single tear!!! The interview was done on Aarushi’s Birthday!
Guilty is written on her unemotional face.
LOOK AT HER face. Etched with hurt
Shut the hell up, who are you to decide how emotions should be shown??
You have no idea what she was going though. Her husband was being accused and she HAD to stay strong and answer logical
@@9vigil Just because they're the parents doesn't mean they can't do something like this
Who came here after Madham Gowri video
I am
Me
Me😆
Me
Meee
Who came here after watching talvar....? and yes my way of thinking also changed... man.. our law is messed up..!!
+Vasav Chawla Me bro
Saleem Ismail so how was your experiance? what do you think happend.. who killed who?
+Vasav Chawla I think that krishsa (kanniya) killed both of them
Nitin Mittal i think so too, but there are some things that also points at the mom dad, i don't know man, i am confused as hell.
+Vasav Chawla Bro..we make our minds by the way we saw things..if we watch talwar we think parents are innocent bt if saw news and other things for a second we thinks parents killed her..what actually happened that night is still a secret the truth is only known by arushi her self or the killer
may be all the theories we know are wrong..the truth can be smthng else may b parents and servents both are innocent..some third person is involved cbi and police both are currpt.
recenty in an interview arun kumar(who's role is played by irrfan khan) said the cutting of the wall on which killer left his hand print is still in cbi evidnce
uk have the technolgy by which the DNA in wall can be extracted..but we cannot do anything bcz this is INDIA my friend
Hats off to this lady..either way,guilty or not..if guilty,great acting skills..if not,very strong person...
Best comment
she didn't even feel guilty.... Just because they influenced they come out from this case
Best comment
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hats off? u must be dumb
Who is watching this in quarantine?
👏👏👏
🖐
I could never get over this case since it first happened and this interview always baffles me!!! Whether they are guilty or not her demeanor is very very weird. She seems so detached and matter of fact 😐😐
Me
@@annakhan59 lol it's never ending haha
No one can talk that casually about her own daughter’s murder just 8 days after it. People tear up even if it’s a natural death. No matter what anyone says it’s not difficult to understand that there was foul play and parents were involved. She isn’t curious to know who killed her daughter.
Wow Sherlock. No tears means guilty? Nice one buddy
I agree I read her body language which shouts if someone hears. The guilty people always look down. Purposely they invited so many people into their homes after the murder so the police get no evidence against them.
She's not curious b'coz she is the one
@@drbali Yes we can see her body language.
@@drbali 😒
she was trying so hard to prove that they were a happy family.not even once she said i m dying to know who killed my daughter
She did say that, though not in the hammy exaggerated manner you expected. This is not one of those platforms to audition for an Ekta Kapoor melodramas.
@@crmznize strange though her demeanor sounds so much like ekta kapoor drama
Exactly u r right.
BECAUSE SHE MURDERER HER DAUGHTER N DRINKING WINE TEA NEAR HER DAUGHTER'S DEAD BODY
Are you Judge ??
She would be hysterical asking for justice to be served if she didn't know who did it.... Her tone is more defensive rather than pleading for finding her killer
Exactly! Like Jia khan's mother
the way she kept saying Sonia kinda makes me feel she was using manipulation tactics on her. like iykyk when you say someone's name multiple times they tend to feel safe with you and believe your words
She’s talking more about her husband being not the killer
Hemraj was a servant I trusted. And within a minute of discovering her daughters body her first reaction is "look what hemraj have done".
Yup, these guys have no clue that Hemraj's body was lying in their terrace.
When police came to their house, Rajesh declared Hemraj killed her daughter and escaped.
This couple was there in the house & 2 people were murdered & they know nothing about that??
It raises suspicion.
It's simple , she had a relationship with
@@unseentoons1687 one can't predict actually. What do u think???
@@satvik1489 who cares ! stop it already . yup you are right O_O .
@@satvik1489 but then what you say about narco test? Only God know who killed her and same with shusant
The anchor is so tense while mrs nupur is trying to make herself comfortable by calling Sonia, Sonia, Sonia.There is not much talk about her daughter's memories but husband's goodness. Period
the comments remind me of Gone Girl. Cry a little, gain sympathy and you are the best person in the world. Be headstrong, talk sense and you are a liar. :)
so TRUE
very true
+ashim choudhury I agree completely.
You are right but you forgot to add a crucial element to your statement.... Woman crying is greater than male crying.
What sense exactly could you make from this interview??
*Anybody watching this in 2019?*
I watched yesterday and search it
Yes I'm watching.
@@shakibparvez1381 Yes I'm watching and I think the parents did it
Yes after watching movie talvar
Yes
Her experiences are so cold...seems like a casual talk on a serious issue...no grief in her eyes 🤔
You haven't lost a daughter. You definitely don't know how she's feeling.
This is funny you see the difference between the host and the mother, the mother seems tired and traumatised, seems like she has been crying for days. Don't judge too soon.
Her bodylanguage clearly says she knows the reality of incident esp when she says killer is somewhere there and dip her eyes down instead of eyecontacting the anchor. Also I can see a silent grin of a liar in her eyes.
anyone who has studied psychology at a respected university will know that this body behavior and response is normal in victims of rape or families of murdered victims etc it's media that makes us think that the natural response is crying and yelling etc. In reality, when something like this happens the person is in shock and has lack of affect/emotions- they haven't psychological coped w the sorrows of the loss - tht actually takes years to overcome and deal w.
awsm comment
Look at her eye! There is no emotion! Just my opinion! Plz stop hating me :)
I have studied experimental psychology at University of Cambridge, UK. I hope that's 'respected' enough for you. No, crying is not essential for expressing sadness and in deed people could be in shock. That's the story on one end - however, you should have also talk about psychopaths. Psychopaths exist in all walks of life. I am not saying that what you are saying is wrong. I am saying that you are only stating one end of the argument - a true professional opinion should be a neutral opinion. I know a girl of (from a very similar background as the girl arushi ). She attended top university on scholarship - dad came to drop her and extremely proud mother based non graduation picture, single child, innocent as anything in her daily life. Over the years it turns out her father used to touch her sexually when she was a kid and her uncle had sex with her, a memory she repressed and came out under therapy. Her mum kept silent because she wanted to save the marriage so she overlooked. This girl in adulthood suddenly also went crazy in terms of sex and secretly started leading life as a prostitute - a woman who has a day job in one of the most prestigious firms in the worlds. Happy families are not necessarily happy. The west has more records of sexual abuse of children because they take it seriously and in countries such as India they don't. I am not saying that I have a hypothesis. I am saying that it is impossible to tell and everything has been dealt with superficially. For example, a motive doesn't have to be servant being found in a compromising position and then father has an issue with it. Maybe the opposite happened. What amuses me is how people on either side is so thoroughly convinced of their opinion!
Person goes into shock and don't display emotions: True.
But Nupur Talwar is desperately trying to show emotions.
Exactly. And it's also about emotional intelligence, most of us aren't that good in EI but there ARE people who are really good with it irrespective of what comes their way, it's all about how fast you "accept" after undergoing that stage of anger and denial.
The fact still remains that it is so contradictory that they heard the door bell the next day morning when the helper came home. But unable to hear what was going on in the bedroom right next door ?
Yet again there was no proof of forced entry in the house.
The AC was off when Bharti mandal came.
I heard that outside door was locked on the next day. Does it mean that they have an habitual of leaving the door open while go for sleeping ? What a funny story her parents are cooking up...
Exactly paas k ghar mein itna kuch hua unhe kuch pata nhi chala..Is this believable!!
they heard it by the third time. also doesnt a bell have a more resonating and generally louder sound?
@@nikita-vp7ms seriously?? Do u think a bell makes more noise than actions which will happen during a murder especially around 1 am when everything will be silent that too in a room which is just beside yours??
Moreover if this same case would have happened in some remote village of haryana or rajasthan and the parents were uneducated wearing dhotis, then whole of so called educated johnies would have easily pointed parents as murderers....have shame and give justice to that poor soul..
That is because education teaches you not to kill in the name of honour..or kill at all. It is always more likely that fingers will be pointed at uneducated citizens, since education not only gives you marks and a job, but also a sense of morality and what is right and wrong.
Cuz honour killing usually occurs where people care about honour more than actual life and humanity , These people were very liberal with their daughter , they had a 24 hour male servant , she was allowed sleepovers and boyfriend , does honour killing make any sense?
@@adityatrueblue because honour killing is still common in Haryana
@@shazz9194maybe boyfriend was fine but not servant. Can educated parents do something like this? Well mostly not but very few might you never know and this is one of the rarest cases of educated parents doing such a thing so yeah parents are the murderers.
her demeanour 8 days after her daughter s murder was indeed quite wierd. even the anchor seemed more pained. this interview was the major blot against her
"Even the anchor seemed more pained"- I liked it. Very true
I'm a mother of a 20 year old. When she cries for something even I will cry with her. How can a mother be this bold just after 8days of murder. I would have died with her too if she was my daughter or I would have cried during the whole interview.
Not everyone is like you , maam! They might be strong or they be might be holding back her tears I can see tiredness on her face. And nobody dies for no body. My two friends died few years back their parents are living now happily. Life always goes on!
@@saijalnaini4831 are wo ek doctor h uske lie ye blood and all this bhot common h aur 8 din hogye to kya ab tak rote rahegi 🤦 sab log ek jaise nhi hote medical me emotionally strong banate h
Exactly..koi bhi maa itna strong nehi hoti k aise beti k maut ho jaata h nd she s giving interview so boldly..this s not normal
@@saijalnaini4831 you wrong in this context. How much bold a person could be, if she is a mother never ever help her that boldness if at all she is in a point of losing her own child. I am a bold person, however a small abrasion or a light fever my children suffer it leaves me sleepless nights. So this womans stoic attitude itself is unbelievable
@@saijalnaini4831 i think u r not a mother...... Jb bnogi tb pta chalega
anchor seems more serious then her mother..doesn't look like she lost her daughter just 8 days ago. .I came here after watching talvar,I ws thinking parents are innocent but now I am in doubt. .. .
Me too
chutia movie dekhke aur tv dekhke murder ke bare main opinion banana bandh kar...its not that simple.
Good point rafeeq
Reactions can't be generalised bro, they said it in the movie also. But yeah if it was someone close to me I'd not react this way, at the end of the day different people have different reactions
This interview is of may 2008. The month when her daughter was killed.
She's lying
There is something disturbing behind how casually she can talk about a brutal murder of her own 13 yo daughter on her birthday. Man this is pure shame. Only if we could see what a person is seeing in his thoughts, we could see her visualising the whole terrifying and brutal incident as she talks to the reporter with clearly no grief, guilt or shame
bhai tujhse personal question puchhu tujhe kya lagta hai mujhe toh yeah case unsolved lagta hai
@@maheshsahu9790Parents are the killers. Trust me on this.
It’s probably the dad who had an argument and killed her overnight like off weirdly and then the servant was found dead next day for the fact that they might have killed him since he might have seen something wrong & that’s why the planned all this & now she’s just taking his side now cause he’s left & she has no shame,she’s tellinh so many details about the events like she has thought abt it already alot many times,which for sure shows somethinh went wrong with the family & then the servant just witnessed it.
unsolved hi hai iss interview me uski baato se toh sab sahi lg rha h but she was licking her lips too much which is a sign of lying still if not the parents then who killed her@@maheshsahu9790
First time I am hearing someone giving interview is addressing the name of the interviewer, many many times. Usually the speaking is not for the interviewer but to the whole world….. rings a bell right?
Throughout the interview, she was calm, eyes were dead, and absolutely no expressions on her face showed that she is devastated.. She kept saying I have faith in legal system like she wants them to know how she still trusts them to not go against them.. a mother who lost her daughter so brutally wouldn't say she "trusts the legal system", she would say "how can anyone kill her.. how did anyone enter the house? I want to know who the killer is?" But she didn't say any of it. This isn't it. Her tone of voice, her body language is telling a whole another story as well.
Who else think that parents is the real killer?
They are surely hiding something.
They only killed nobody else
Me
Me too
Me too
Lack of tears means guilty? Poor mom looks tired and stressed out!! This is a situation no one will understand unless they find themselves in.
+book worm Absolutely agree with you! We happen to live in society where it's necessary to fake a cry to express pain - what a messed up concept.
+book worm I strongly believe that first the movie release, then Times of India support for the convicted criminal(parents) then release of the narco test indicate that parents are trying their best to convince people of India that they are innocent and victim or wrong judgement. However, there are many points clearly indicate that parents are the real culprits. 1 ).The precise cut to her throat/neck seems very suspect. Someone who used a golf club earlier would never come back to 'finish the job' with a precise cut. 3).Plus, even though he could not rape her, the autopsy report clarifies that something did happen to her, from examination of her private and redressed her cloths and undergarments. 4). burning the bed off before forensic investigations completed, applying for anticipatory bail before the case began and the police even started pointing fingers. 5). they also refused to hand over the terrace key to the police for 3 days. 6) That the clothes of both the accused were not found soaked with blood. It is highly unnatural that parents of deceased Aarushi will not cling to and hug her on seeing her murdered. 7) That it is not possible that an outsider(s) after committing the murders will muster courage to take Scotch whisky knowing that the parents of the deceased Aarushi are in the nearby room and his top priority will be to run away from the crime scene immediately. 8) That the door of the terrace was never locked prior to the occurrence but it was found locked in the morning of May 16, 2008 and the accused did not give the key of the lock to the police despite being asked to give the same.
Lets be objective.
1. Precise single stroke cut using dentist scalpel to slice the neck? Not possible.
2.
3. cleaned private parts and redressed the cloths but the pajama was low and buttock cleavage visible? If the intention was to erase evidence of sexual act, pajama would have been neatly in place with strings tied, so that no body would have any doubt. Why the issue of cleaning private parts raised after 1.5 year after initial NAD? The details mentioned about vaginal orifice etc is just "Non sense".
4. Who burnt the bed? Police asked it to be thrown on terrace do avoid media glare. Why didnt UP police seize the bed, if it was important?
5. Refuse the terrace key for three days? Your imagination. Please be clear of the facts.
6. Parents cloth did show blood signs of aarushi but not of hemraj. Regarding "why not soaked in blood?"hug and cry are all bollywood cliches.
7. Just a theory.
8. It is just a speculation. If the murderer was known to Hemraj and was with him that night, he had the access to key, especially after killing him. Hence it is possible that he could have locked the terrace and took it away.
book worm as a parent if your child is lying dead the next room the first inclination of the parent would be to know who did this to their kid rather than hastily cremating him/her. They had no interest even when the police knocked at the door. They must be involved somehow.
People like u r so easy to manipulate :)
5:57 how strange? She is smiling
I know. Scary !
She seems so desperate to prove that she is not accused.
amazing how confident she is !!!!
After watching this interview, this is what I observed with the body language and tone of talk from the mother and the way she responds to every question. The lip smacking, the eyes tilted down position when faced with brutal words like murder, death, birthday. She is in total support for the husband when asked about his involvement in the crime. She leaned more emotionally towards her husband than her dead daughter, clear indication not because she didn't love her daughter, but because she had to save of what is left for her and that's her husband. The daughter has been killed out or rage or by accident. It has to be one or the two. The mother is clearly distraught and disappointed here, that some terribly hitting gone wrong due to instant rage and anger from either her or her husband. Personally I assume, it would have been the husband. No outsider involved, 4 people alive before 12AM and out of which 2 perished. The remainder two are burdened with the proof.
Nah man her parents didnt kill her
Yes may be her husband did crime and she is saving him
What about NARCO TESTS
Yeah, agree. She had to save what was left for her. And that was her husband.
And they couldn't recognize the servant's dead body including his clothings as if the servant got changed middle of the night before the incident. Officials had to call the servant's friends to recognise the dead body, Are they both not educated doctors themselves. Come on!!
This was 10 days after Aarushi's death. After crying continuously for 2-3 days one just cannot cry anymore. One gets the strength from the ones they lost. The fact that she did not cry proves she is not acting fake.
She doesn't want to say that she has killed her own daughter for having sex with her servant Hemraj. Now she is repeating the same phrase - All I can say is .......I don't know what to say.....
(What else can you say Big Liar and Murderer!!!)
NONSENSE. its her only daughter. parents will cry 10, 20, 30 years after their childs death. esp if the killer is not found .. i hope this will go down in history as a cold case to be investigated again in future..
How can you say that she lost her babay and I don’t think that any mother can talk like this after seeing daughter or sons dead body. My grandma lost her son 7/8 years ago and till now when she talks about her son she starts crying she cannot control her self. And this interview was on her birthday after 8 days of her murderd and she really normal and can talk so much 🤔🤔🤔🤔
I think she is lying , how can she talk so much normal on her child,s birthday.
Shika Rai bcoz she is educated and also smart
God knows everything . Justice will be served.
Don’t worry.
He is watching ! God is our protector .
Fucking god... While murder where was he??? Sleeping with angels 😂
🤣 delusions
Yeah keep telling urself that, but in reality there is no God there is only pure evil of human
Yes definitely... that's why we have so much evil and injustice in this world.
Chaar chavvani ghode pe..
God mere laude pe.
Koi God ni hta bas energy hti h vo ek form se dusre form me jti h and everything is just as it is.. Nothing is wrong or bad in this world it's just a situation which keeps on changing.. We humans label it.. So relax
she is talking so coolly.
she doesn't look like she's lost her daughter recently. That too gruesome murder..
body language can help solve the case...
She sounds like my 4 year old who lost their pencil in school
she's guilty
The terrace door was locked with hemraj's body.. Which killer brings a lock to a murder?
Killers are parents of aarushi talwar
@@arunsaji8127 true
That's what ..this case has so many wierd things that just points fingers at talwar .
1) who would stay back after committing not one but two murders then clean arushi room .
2 ) hemraj body was dragged till terrace then body was covered with cooler panel and paritition between two terraces ( terrrace adjacent to talwar terrace ) was covered by a blanket . Which killer would take so much of pain to do so many things that too at night and at some other person house . Any way after killing they would run away so hidding the body on terrace and locking it up doesn't makes sense unless killer is from the same house
3 ) ballenti bottle found on the tabel of hall had blood of both arushi and hemraj ..so killer had a drink after killing servant and arushi . Wow killer had lots of guts I must say .
4 ) golf stick no. 6 I guess and surgical blade were never recovered . Did police check talwar 's car right after the incident . No they dint .
the journalist is more serious than the mother while speaking..this explains many things!
I didn’t see a sigh of grief in her eyes . No matter how much strong you are there comes a point when even a stone hearted breaks down but this woman is really strong.
See how she never takes Aarushis name, she keeps referring to her as "our daughter" or "someone's daughter", typical sociopathic tendencies to dissociate yourself from the victim
Is this case ever going to be resolved? No matter how many articles i read, how many documentaries i watch....it is never clear. It breaks my heart that an innocent child was killed so many years ago and nobody still knows who is the killer. Even if it is the parents, there is no way to prove it. As they showed in the movie, the initial investigation by the local police ruined the case long time ago.
Yes the case is runied , even if parents are guilty it will never be solved now
How can a mom , just after 8 days of her daughter's death wear a bindi , get dressed up and not even shed a single tear ......brutual 😢...she totally is not guilty ...she's faking it for sure ...
Either she is very strong mentally or she is the culprit... 8:40 when she said yes today is Arushi birthday, I was expecting some tears to come out or maybe a emotional pause or change in voice when crying internally....... But nothing happened she continued her story.... Shocking
Its neither
She is in deep shock
Whenever someone is in deep shock they dont cry they dont show emotions they dont yell or scream or show any tears at all they speak normally is due to shock and stress
@@berries8691 i dont think so ...here parents are the culprit
@@berries8691 whenever someone is in deep shock, they can't even speak a damn word. Totally silent. otherwise, it was not a shock just acting. Remember it cuts both ways.
@@212go some can speak/ reply as well.
Being shocked comes in various forms and types
@@berries8691 Then its not shock sir/mam.
Shock actually means you are not able to process situations or interactions normally.
If they are able to reflect and answer to questions in such a composed manner. Sorry to say, they might be guilty or not guilty but they are definitely not in a shock.
How can any mother remain calm and not shed a single tear?? This looks so shocking
It isn’t possible to give such a long interview just few days after your loved one’s demise on her BIRTHDAY and not get emotional! No matter how strong a person is this is not possible, her eyes didn’t even get watery ! So unbelievable!!
She shaid hemraj care for her and he was the man whom i trusted... then why she blaim hemraj kill her as soon as discovered the body...waah madam
This was just after 8 days... Unbelievably defensive!!! Her expressions don't match her words. She is talking like its was a robbery or theft not her daughter's murder
Yess exactly.
She definately knows something very concrete about the murder.
True......
She definitely would have been going through a lot and each individual would have different ways of expressing their emotions and some of them keep it inside and would not want to express it out to the world....
Exactly
exactly, her daughter was brutally murdered in their house, and she keeps saying how her husband has been taken away like the two situations are the same thing. This woman is a clearcut pshychopath killer.
Money and corruption saved Talwar's...This happens only in our Great Nation India...
Chandramouli Srinivasan correct
Chandramouli Srinivasan you are absolutely right
Chandramouli Srinivasan plz mujhe btaiye ye case bnd ho chuka hai ya chal rha hai
@@droverthinker3930 the case is close
Yes
She is acting to weep . She is nt looking genuine. She and her husband killed their own daughter in anger.
Have u seen?
Yeah
@@ishwarimokal5229 😂. We should request the CBI to handover the case for you.
@@ishwarimokal5229 saas bahu ki kahani nahi hai beti ..........
Murder case hai
Obviously
crazy how a mother can go on tv when her daughter had been murdered 8 days ago
She loves her husband more than her daughter... I am also a mother... I am 100 % sure she is a lier
Yes her face is telling .. a mother will cry dying her eyes tling there is something .. not even bit of sorrow on her face
Ya u are right
@Be honest just be honest if a person has cried for 12days and gone through so much would their eyes be able to cry after that?
Not everybody is alike.
@@qa8822 ofcourse they can, for months, years decades if they really loved the kid
My dog stepped on the bee...
Sonia is sounding more sincere and serious than Mrs. Talwar.
Strong person will also cry in this situation
How can be she smile during the interview
I'm not sure whether the parents are culprit...but I'm sure they know something about this murder...
May be someone else killed Arushi and parent's presumed Hemraj killed her and in anger they killed Hemraj
@@mayur5860 that's highly unlikely.
If someone else killed Arushi then who?? How did he entered their house.
He could definitely be hemrajs friend or someone. If we assume that he killed Arushi and then escaped & Rajesh woke up and thought Hemraj killed Arushi then let me tell you its highly unlikely.
The moment Hemraj would know that "unknown" guy killed arushi, he would too have escaped in fear.
-mrs talwar ko naa bhulein..
Madam player h purri
Husband ki main strength h puri tarah
Husband kbka bk deta sb..
But the Women is Still like Hills.. She haven't moved a bit..
Mentally strong..
Clever Fox... Beti toh gyi but aab Husband ko toh bachaa lun 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@shinchannohara2924 -mrs talwar ko naa bhulein..
Madam player h purri
Husband ki main strength h puri tarah
Husband kbka bk deta sb..
But the Women is Still like Hills.. She haven't moved a bit..
Mentally strong..
Clever Fox... Beti toh gyi but aab Husband ko toh bachaa lun 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@shinchannohara2924 Talwars ko halki doori samjh re ho kya.. Planning nhi master plan bnaya tha Miyaan biwi n... Police ko 1000 baar ye bole ki Hemraj n kia.. Hemraj bhaag gya.. Maa baap h.. Police n socha hoga jhooth thodi bolenge 😅🤣.. Iklauti aulaad thi.. Sach bol re h.. House help bhi gaayab h.. Chlo..
Nepal 🤣🤣
Character assassination hua Hemraj ka.. Ki wo Murderer h.. Ladki k saath Rape krta h..
Uski family
Jiska kisiko pta tk nhi h..
Ye h humanity..
Talwars ko search kr rahe ho..
Ek baar uss bichaare Hemraj ki family se related kuch padhho.. Vdo dekho..
Hum audience hi ase jaanwaron ko hero bnaati h..
Bs Aarushi Aarushi..
2 murder hue the..
Hemraj Rest in Peace Sir..
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻❣❣❣❣
Talwars murder h..
Hemraj k room door ko use kia sb krne k liye.. Qki agar by chance koi proof mila toh uske room se milega..
Police ko toh kabhi uss bichaare ki body bhi nahi milte..
Vo toh Neighborhood m kisi n Terrece p deka.. Or police ko bulaya..
Ni tih Talwars tbhi bach gye hote..
Or socho Hemraj toh milta nhi Police ko
qki unhe lgta bhaag gya
Or fir Talwars ka asli game shuru hota Sympathy ka.. Log bhi unka saath dete
Hemraj ki family ko jail ho jaati bhaisaab.. Bhagwaan n thodi madad krdi us family ki by that neighbor🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Her eyes have no shock, no pain for her daughter who died such a horrific death just a week ago! Being 'brave' is different. The first question on her lips should be, 'who killed my daughter??' But this woman is only concerned about her husband, not her daughter. How strange is that?
I think she knows who did it already. She blamed Hemraj who was found lying dead the next day on the roof. So we know it wasn't him.
This is not a mother asking for justice for a heinous crime done to her daughter..she is wife waiting for her husband to return home
she looks tired of just being tired...
Tired of covering it up
I remember watching this infamous interview. A lot of speculation regarding the parents' involvement in the murder began after this interview because of her stoic appearance.
In nirbhaya's case I have seen her mother crying n the pain in her eyes even after years but Arushi mother is talking so casually as compared
People react differently to trauma although she is kinda acting weird ngl very casual
I dont know if I'm wrong, but she sounds like she's uninterested to get to the bottom of this. Kind of like she's shrugging it off. I'm not talking about how she's not crying or anything, but she doesn't seem to have that hope or determination to find out who murdered her daughter.
Exactly! Normally every parent will be crying out to serve justice and find out wat happened dat unfateful night..but here she is no mood to find closure ,bcoz deep inside she knows the truth and witnessed it herself! And moreover, no sense of shock in ger behaviour..its only 8 days
@@rashmisikka5814 Big lol. everyone has his own way of processing grief!
@@tadiploma7875 big lol to your life too loser
@@rashmisikka5814 exactly...see how her lips quiver and how non chalant she seems.....just see Vanessa Bryant and how she reacts....nupur's behaviour seems really off track
Because she knows who killed her daughter and the hired help. It was her and her husband
6:12 If He always Cared For Her Then Why You Blamed Himself for the murder from the very beginning???
Great point. Why she have to even suspect hemraj
In the movie Talwar, they are shown to hear the door bell next morning with the AC on. Did they really not hear anything in the dead of the night?
dipeshmody awesome comment tht made me think thrice
brilliant !
The movie is apeshit
It was just a PR for parents
brilliant question
haven't u heard about AC timer....???
Why do parents keep male servant ..don't they know today world
Right..
Sab angrez ho gye hain
Aapne sahi kaha
Aadmi naukar kyun rakha
👍
Sufiyaan Shaikh best comment✌️👌
@@maryammaryam-dh3jy Arrey accha Admi hota to nahi karta
What an actor...bravo
I strongly believe that first the movie release, then Times of India support for the convicted criminal(parents) then release of the narco test indicate that parents are trying their best to convince people of India that they are innocent and victim or wrong judgement. However, there are many points clearly indicate that parents are the real culprits. 1 ).The precise cut to her throat/neck seems very suspect. Someone who used a golf club earlier would never come back to 'finish the job' with a precise cut. 3).Plus, even though he could not rape her, the autopsy report clarifies that something did happen to her, from examination of her private and redressed her cloths and undergarments. 4). burning the bed off before forensic investigations completed, applying for anticipatory bail before the case began and the police even started pointing fingers. 5). they also refused to hand over the terrace key to the police for 3 days. 6) That the clothes of both the accused were not found soaked with blood. It is highly unnatural that parents of deceased Aarushi will not cling to and hug her on seeing her murdered. 7) That it is not possible that an outsider(s) after committing the murders will muster courage to take Scotch whisky knowing that the parents of the deceased Aarushi are in the nearby room and his top priority will be to run away from the crime scene immediately. 8) That the door of the terrace was never locked prior to the occurrence but it was found locked in the morning of May 16, 2008 and the accused did not give the key of the lock to the police despite being asked to give the same.
@@fifihudson3450 where did you get the information?
if she trusted hemraj so much, how is it that he is the first person who she thinks killed Arushi?
how calm and confident she is ... amazing !!!!
she is a legend
She knows the reality
9.40 is really suspicious.Answering no would have been easy.This is very common when lying.Even we do this.
A lot of things here clearly point to the fact that she is lying.Only a trained mind will know.
And you, I assume, are that.
Then she could fake crying right to get to ppl's emotions easily? Y wouldn't she do that
Well, are you a trained mind?
She didn't even cried a single tear 😱..... Only blinked her eye in such a manner like Ohh God! How she is able to do so?
People watching narco of krishna - oh he does this he does that .. confirmd he is the culprit
Same people watching this interview - watch her body language..she is the culprit
The way she is talking, it's just impossible to accept she doesn't know the whole scene. No pain, no grief and literally zero hesitation talking about a terrifying and brutal murder of her own 13 yo daughter. Even if it was accidental she knows it and even sees it to this day when she closes her eyes about how the throat of her own girl was slit, how she screamed and how it looked. Lucky for them they had powerful contacts and the initial response police messed up the crime scene. They don't even deserve hell
I'm watching this just few minutes after watching Jiah Khan's mother talking about her after 7 years, she was looking more in grief and sad comparing this fake mother! I doubt if Arushi was really their biological child!
True .
How can a mother of only child losing her brutally able to face national media within 8days of death.And she doesn't says a single word about her birthday even the anchor is saying...
Because she had a strong character.She is able to hold her emotions properly.Not every person is like that
This woman has guts, really guts.After having killed her daughter she has come for an interview.We loose our pet we cry foul but this lady having lost her only child she is so calm and compose. Poor hemraj and aarushi.
Palak paneer = Juice in Sushant's case
Why did they kept a man hemraj as servent since they have grown up girl?
Is this the way an Indian mother reacts on her daughter's death and on her husbands custody???
I came here after watching talwar n I was convinced the parents are innocent.. after watching this I'm not too sure..she seems to be lying..:/
I too felt the same thing at first, but you know what.. some people cannot show what they feel on their faces. They are not actors rit?
+jyothsna konathala All of us (including me) thinking we're Sherlock about this case because we have watched Talvar...😂😂😂
+Bob Bobson I haven't watched talwar
Marmik Desai
Totally true
From the very first moment of the interview she looked like a person gripped with shame rather than grief or loss. she never looked into camera straight up; while appealing to public at large when being asked by the journalist, she is at loss of words and said everything with her head held low. the expression at 1:02 tells it all when she is refuting the initial charges.
13:38 look as she tries so hard to fake her emotions and tries to cry to show it as she couldn't just bare it to say that "arushi had been taken away". Shame on you and shame on the justice system
What a wonderful actor!
Just see her face clearly ..seems kind of evil smile behind the face
We have Nirbhaya Mother who fight till last for her Daughter and here she has not even a tear in her eye.
Just because you have emotions, doesn't mean they will show them.Some people are emotionally strong.Crying in front of everyone is just useless
@@captain4595 I am not saying them to show their teary Eyes.But at least if they had emotions for the death of their Daughter they would have Fought for her
Correct
@@captain4595Dude it was murder! Even if it was accident, parents would be devastated coz it’s sudden death. Sudden deaths are quite painful and shocking.
Parents are the killers bro
@@mihirjoshi8934 Just because someone doesn't show emotion,doesn't mean they don't have emotion
She keeps going off track to avoid questions. Because any question will have to be answered with a lie.
People go into deep emotional shock ,yes.. they exhibit lack of emotions, yes...
but people in deep shock also cannot talk so much, listen so carefully, respond so quickly ..
Not for once did she wonder or say " who killed my daughter? How did they even enter? How could I not hear anthing" ....
Nothing
Listen to her in video after 5:07min. The mother says "Aarushi must have witnessed something" Exactly, she probably witness her dad killing the servant. That explains a lot about that night.
seems she is talking about someone elses child not her own dead child. NO EMOTION AT ALL
Right
This is exactly how I talk when I'm lying.
Lol 😂😂😂
@@chandanh347 😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Hahahahaha
😂😂😂😂
And today is her birthday I mean when this interview was happening
It's unbelievable to watch the mother either she is so damn strong or idk how she is doing this
No tears, licking lips all the time and smiling more than tv presenter 🤔 whoever killed servant and tried to hide his body wanted it to look like that servant killed the girl and run away 🤔 what killer would want this scenario?
4 :50 when I woke up I obviously thought it was the servant..........
5.30 hemraj was the servent whom I trusted.......I never had any problem with him.he always cared for her. I never thought.........
She mean to say She trusted him before the murder
But after she discovered the dead body she raised alarm of Servant involvement obviously
@@sumitgoel8854 how would anyone raise suspicion directly on their loyal servant? The first thing naturally be .."and where is hemraj!?? Omg... he's also killed " , isn't?
Mom and dad killed her.....100% true.....coz isne ek baar bhi nahi kha ki meri beti ko kisne mara kyu maara...usne kisika ka bigada tha......ek baar bhi nahi bola
Arushi killed by her own parents...her expression seems so casual..
This lady is smiling looks like she dnt mind tht her daughter died....suspicious
Coz the parents had planned the murder over a long period of time and they had come to terms with the fact.everything is rehearsed over here.they've gone over everything in detail.
Give her and him third degree case 1minute me solve ho jayega
She is not sad 😒 She is a murderer 🤨🤨
Its been over 15 years i cannot still get over the suspicion on parents. Even at any point of angle, the parents looks so suspicious.
Action speaks louder than words 🙁
8:40 "Anyways coming back to that day" - notice how casually she comes back to justify that they are not involved. It sounds so fake and constructed. Sometimes I feel this lady killed aarushi in the rage of anger while the father killed hemraj. Even the maid said that mother was not mourning much after discovering the body and was trying to blame hemraj. CBI head was also suspicious of her more than the father
i m absolutely sure that this lady along with her husband killed Aarushi
SHE IS BLINKING LESS.. AND BLINKS DIFFERENTLY... normally the blinking rate every blink in 2 to 10 seconds. Liars blink less frequently than normal during the lie, and then speed up to around eight times faster than usual afterwards.
😂😂😂
Good observation
Bomkesh bakshi ki mousi
Get lost..
Aapka number do didi. CBI se case open karwaate hai.
Having a daughter , it is always usual to keep a female as a helper.. that too living in room close to the daughter… also there is alcohol at home. Everything is suspicious isn’t it?