If by perfect you mean perfectly even in tempo and dynamics, I agree. It sounds robotic to me, and robotic playing is called typewriting, not piano playing.
Mistakes: Measure 6, Bass clef 3rd note should be a G. Measure 17, Treble clef should be a B not D on second to last note. Measure 23, Bass clef last note should be a Bb. Checked against my Henle edition.
Tell me if I'm wrong, but isn't there supposed to be "jumping" legato and staccato throughout the song. Like one hand is staccato and the other is legato and they keep switching?
Guys I’m year one piano beginner (starting from zero) and something like this, to me, looks so much more difficult than any Liszt or Chopin piece ahahahaha is it just an impression?
All of Bach‘s Inventions and Klavier Suites have their own challenges to be conquered. Chopin and Liszt belonging to the romantic period contain a language of their own.
@@usaroman yeah it was dumb of me to compare the two, but you know, normally, people believe Liszt is the hardest overall (and for good reason) while imho there’s also to consider these kind of pieces which are definetely among the hardest to play as well!
I would say his two part inventions is quite a few tiers easier than the vast majority of what Chopin wrote. However if you look up the well tempered clavier or the Bach Partitas, those pieces by Bach are exceedingly challenging to pull off.
It's an impression, listen to more piano music. The inventions are a good introduction to fugues and contrapuntal writing, but they are easier than 99% of any Liszt of Chopin piece
C’est très mal joué, pas de piqué, pas de découpe du phrasé, pas de respiration ni de tempo fort accentué, pas de ralenti à la fin… ce doit être un enregistrement électronique…
I dont think we should play Bach like a robot . We should use articulation, dynamics and timing to shape the phrases. these midi performances are so bad tbh 😐
![How to Play Bach | Invention No.13 in A minor [Tutorial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ohzCZjkjvMc/mqdefault.jpg)
![How to Play Bach | Invention No.13 in A minor [Tutorial]](/img/tr.png)
![[TH] VCT Pacific - Regular Season - สัปดาห์ที่ 3 วันที่ 4 // TS vs DFM - GE vs PRX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ln3PWDmVkng/mqdefault.jpg)
Beautiful!
Mmmph. Too perfect. Sounds like a computer playing it perfectly.
it is. You can clearly hear Musescore 4
If by perfect you mean perfectly even in tempo and dynamics, I agree. It sounds robotic to me, and robotic playing is called typewriting, not piano playing.
ME ENCANTA ESTE TEMA
Good BMV piece
Beautiful
your videos are soo good and relaxing! i will subscribe to you
Mistakes: Measure 6, Bass clef 3rd note should be a G. Measure 17, Treble clef should be a B not D on second to last note. Measure 23, Bass clef last note should be a Bb. Checked against my Henle edition.
It's ironic that even played by a computer this version has its mistakes.
@@Enri45100 the user wrongly transcribed/ copied the piece.
Also measure 4, bass clef, 2nd beat, the B should tie to the 3rd beat 16th note but they have a C instead.
🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🥀🥀🥀🥀🥀🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
MIDI all the way, baby
surement
第四小節低音譜上寫GB聲音是DG
Tell me if I'm wrong, but isn't there supposed to be "jumping" legato and staccato throughout the song. Like one hand is staccato and the other is legato and they keep switching?
Sim. Com portato. E andamento não tão rápido.
O problema é que é uma máquina
Guys I’m year one piano beginner (starting from zero) and something like this, to me, looks so much more difficult than any Liszt or Chopin piece ahahahaha is it just an impression?
All of Bach‘s Inventions and Klavier Suites have their own challenges to be conquered. Chopin and Liszt belonging to the romantic period contain a language of their own.
@@usaroman yeah it was dumb of me to compare the two, but you know, normally, people believe Liszt is the hardest overall (and for good reason) while imho there’s also to consider these kind of pieces which are definetely among the hardest to play as well!
I would say his two part inventions is quite a few tiers easier than the vast majority of what Chopin wrote. However if you look up the well tempered clavier or the Bach Partitas, those pieces by Bach are exceedingly challenging to pull off.
It's an impression, listen to more piano music. The inventions are a good introduction to fugues and contrapuntal writing, but they are easier than 99% of any Liszt of Chopin piece
You haven’t listened to enough Chopin and Liszt if you think this looks harder, listen to Chopin ballade no 4 or Liszt piano sonata in b minor….
Wait isn't BWV?
What level is this piece
quite easy; I guess around abrsm grade 4
BMW lmao 😂😂😂
BMV 😎
第二小節低音譜上寫C聲音是D
Ошибка, последняя нота в первом такте не до, а ре. И во втором такте таже ошибка. Звучит правильно, а написано с ошибкой
WTF? Notation mistakes on measures 4, 6, 17, and 23. I immediately heard the difference.
Wo brennt's?
Not good at all, this has to be played with feeling, it can also be played on a churchorgan.sounds really great.
Achei muito rápido o andamento para essa peça... deveria ser mais andantino.
Malades
Deve ser um robô...
Ou c'est Poutine qui joue lol.
exact . lol.
C’est très mal joué, pas de piqué, pas de découpe du phrasé, pas de respiration ni de tempo fort accentué, pas de ralenti à la fin… ce doit être un enregistrement électronique…
Not bad but very stiff like a midi performance.
I'm pretty sure it IS an automated midi performance
I dont think we should play Bach like a robot
. We should use articulation, dynamics and timing to shape the phrases. these midi performances are so bad tbh 😐
Вам что, заняться не чем?? Зачем людей обманываете? Это не живое исполнение - компьютер, да еще и сделано убого!
En tout cas, ça permet d'avoir la partition en live... Et si c'était joué au clavecin ça donnerait quoi ?