Cha Cha Cha... the F-loop works great with the updated tuners (LRT and ALRT) makes tuning very very easy and fast!!!! I have worked all over the world with my F-Loop and 20 watts!
I've been using my FLOOP 2.0 for 3 years. I have the power compensator and usually run 50W SSB and 25W Digital. Being in an apartment downtown Montreal, I use mine indoors most of the time. On SSB, I cover North America, Western Europe with some contacts in Russia. On FT8, I got Tahiti, Angola, South America, etc. It works really well. I got so much used to the tuning than I can follow my radio while it scans. As others said, the guys on the other end are usually surprised to hear about my setup. Espcially the indoors part. It's always good fun.
I want to add that this is an awesome POTA antenna, it is portable, quick and easy to put up and take down, directional (so it has gain) and supports NVIS on the lower bands.... but this antenna really excels on 20 meters where many POTA operators and hunters have antenna capabilities, so if you are into POTA you might take a second look at this antenna. Cha Cha Cha
The magnetic loop antenna like the CHA F-LOOP 3.0 is probably the only antenna on the market that will allow you to operate 40M and 80M from indoor according that you understand its restriction and the principle behind HF propagation from a loop. Its footprint is literally 3' X 3' X 12" - Try to install a 30M, 40M, 60M and 80M antenna in that footprint or on your kitchen table!
Possibly, some QRP rigs are dirt cheap and others are very expensive (price out an Elecraft KX3 and you know what I'm talking about). I guess it depends where on the spectrum you are.
Great video. I have an F loop on order and hope to get operating soon. What headsets were you using in the car for your POTA session. I will be using it with ICOM 705. 73
I've seen people sitting right next to these magloop antennas inside their house while they're using them on the air. I suppose with QRP power, it's okay, but it always looks like a potential RF exposure issue in close quarters. KZ9V
I did a quick exposure calculation, and at 20 watts on the 20 meter band, the required distance in an uncontrolled situation was less than 1 foot. But these antennas exploit the H fields of RF radiation and I don't know if that makes a difference in the calculations, the ARRL exposure calculator didn't allow for that variable. I guess I'll have to look into that.
I think this one of your best videos! I also had rthe plesure of getting play with a 2.0. Every thing you said mirrors my experience exactly. 73 KE0SUM. I am in your log book.
Magnetic loops are bidirectional, the signal will be the strongest in the plane of the antenna and weakest on its face. With weaker signals off the plane, rotating the antenna will increase their strength.
Sitting on Rib Hill is Cheating AHAHAHAHAH.... Does that work along the Lines of the old AEA isoloop ?? I still have Jr, P's N9FOL's Antenna.. Thanks Michael...
Rib is a great place to go for some HF fun, especially if you are using a vertical antenna. From my understanding, the Isoloop is the same style of antenna, just in a different package.
I’ve had the F Loop 2.0 for a couple of years now and I LOVE IT! I use it mostly with the aluminum loop…that antenna is a snap to put together. I do recommend to people to keep extra velcro loops as the originals are thin and sometimes break when pulled too tight I bought heavier loops from Home Depot and they work just fine. Thanks for showcasing the later version…it’s a great antenna! 73 de K2KOH
I think it would pair very well with your KX3. The nice thing is that you can leave it mostly assembled and just carry the whole unit outside, put it on a tripod, and be ready to get on the air.
@@KB9VBRAntennas I do wish someone would create a loop that could stand the elements in Wisconsin and Northern Illinois. I'd like to put this on my patio, nail it down, add an antenna rotator, and just work from the kitchen table without having to go out in the snow.
Hello Michael. Thank you for the excellent review of the Chameleon F Loop antenna. I think this is an excellent choice for Parks on the Air if you are operating QRP. I have a Ciro Mazzoni Baby Loop antenna which operates QRO. If you haven‘t seen this antenna, I would encourage you to check it out. It‘s a great choice for people that live in HOA communities. It is expensive but it works very well and comes with an automatic tuner. Thank you for the great videos.
A fine description of the pros and cons of this style of antenna. It doesn't fit my current style of operation but one never knows what life will throw their way. U-rah-rah
I did not do a side by side comparison of the coax loop and the aluminum one, but I noticed a few things with the aluminum. It was a bit easier to tune, maybe because there was a little more bandwidth. Signal reports were marginally stronger with the aluminum, but that could be due to propagation. The aluminum worked very well on 30 meters, so I'll assume the same with the 40 meter band.
I have great success with the MFJ-935C loop tuner, its ability to handle 150 watts is a huge plus! You do have to use different loop sizes but it’s really good.
Thank you for the video. I am trying to decide which mag loop to go for, and watching this helped me understand the pros and cons of the Chameleon version. QUESTION: Would adding a third loop/length theoretically make it tune for even lower frequencies like the 160meter band ?
It possibly could, but I don't know. My concern would be if the tuning unit has enough capacitance to work on 160 meters. Reading the user guide, it states that with a double loop, the tuner will operate down to 2.8 MHz, so it is a possibility. But the bigger concern is that on 160m your bandwidth will be practically a hair's width. On 80m it has 6 KHz of bandwidth. You can safely say that on 160 the bandwidth will be less than 3 KHz. If you ever try it, let me know if it works.
@@KB9VBRAntennas Thank you for the reply. I am trying to decide if I will build my own mag loop or if I should buy one. Building is better because it is fun - but buying is easy as it saves time :) I might try to do both so I have one for reference.
I bought the DIY Cha Loop 3.0 about 6 months ago. I was so excited that I could afford this at the lower price. It will not tune 30-10 meters at all. I think the switch is defective. One of the pins is loose. I contacted Chameleon and told them about the problem. They said I had to send it back to them on my dime and give them another 100 or so for them to fix it. I do realize there was no service that came with this purchase. But I could have bought an assembled unit for the extra money I'll need to spend fixing this one. I was so disappointed I put it back in the box since then. Well, I got it out and tried to see if I could do anything myself. Question: Does anyone know where to get another switch?
Thank you for this very helpful vieo, Michael. Enjoyed it as always. Alpha loops sells alpha mag loops that take 100 Watts. Now is that then a different construction difference or anexaggerated claim ? Thanks !
Not having any experience with the Alpha Loop, I went down the rabbit hole a bit to figure out how they can claim 100 watt transmit on sideband (50 watt CW and 10 watt digital). The short answer is that I couldn't find any videos or reports backing up the claim. Everyone using the loop uses it QRP. In their advertising, they say they use a 'tuned circuit' and 'faraday wrapped' coupling loop. My guess is that their capacitor has wider plate spacing that limits arcing. But that introduces other inefficiencies into the system. What I find telling in their materials is that they recommend only 10 watts digital. Since digital modes are full duty cycle (on average SSB is only 30% duty cycle), that's a better indicator of true power handling capability. They are banking on the fact that most people don't push their output to the limit on phone.
Thank you for the detailed review. The build quality appears to be excellent on this antenna. I would be curious to see how this antenna performs with Winlink or FT8. Would you consider doing a video with this antenna in an area with a high/bad noise floor. I have yet to see anyone attempt this on YT.
In the video I did a comparison on FT8 between the Magnetic Loop and a 1/4 wave vertical antenna. While not highly scientific, the results between the two antennas where within 1-3 dB of each other with the mag loop being slightly stronger.
Nice review cool tech, can,t see why they want $500 and up for a cap, lmr400 and some aluminium, way over priced, must have some thing to do with the name.
The tuning box is not weather resistant, so you will not want to expose it to the elements for long periods of time. In my case, I was able to wipe it down after using it to prevent any water penetration.
Great video Michael. I was surprised how far you can reach with a loop antenna and 5 watts. I’ve got a question in regards to your headset. In your videos, do you have the audio going to your headset and a speaker. Or are you just using the mic on the headset? Thanks, and have a good evening. Bill, KC2KNA
I use a 2 channel wireless microphone to record my audio (Rode Wireless Go II). I wear one microphone for my audio and the 2nd microphone is attached to the Line Out port on the transceiver. You can a clean line out on Yaesu radios by connecting to the data port. The two channels are then mixed down and levels adjusted during editing. I have video that explains my process in detail: th-cam.com/video/tOqzZPphE7k/w-d-xo.html
@@KB9VBRAntennas thanks for the explanation Michael. I’ll check out that video. You had me sold on the Heil headset the first time I saw you use it. I’ve got to get the version for the Icom. Have a great day….. Bill, KC2KNA
The height above ground for magnetic loop isn't really important. Usually keeping the loop about 36" is sufficient. But I've operated the F-LOOP 3.0 directly installed on the floor or ground numerous times without any issues!
Ideal height is about one loop diameter above ground. But ground effect plays a minimal role in magnetic loop performance, so they will operate well at ground level.
Great review. I enjoy the videos! Thank you for the details in this one. I'm interested in a loop for QRP and hunting POTA. I'm trying to decide between the Chameleon and the Alex Loop. I mostly make SSB contacts on 20m at this point in my ham journey using 5w or less. I understand the basic concept of tuning a loop. Can anyone give some guidance on process for tuning when hunting POTA stations? Do you tune just outside the frequency range of the station you're hunting so you don't impede current conversations on the target frequency? Maybe use 1w when doing so? I like the idea of being able to, when necessary, to have an antenna that I can put on a tripod and not worry about putting a wire in a tree or a stake in the ground that might violate some rules of a park. Any feedback is appreciated.
In tuning the loop, if you are doing it by ear of with an analyzer, you can be on the frequency as the activator. If you are going to transmit, then you should be off frequency a bit in order to not intentionally interfere. In the 10 - 40 meter bands, you will have enough bandwidth in order to move 3 kHz or so away and make your adjustments.
@KB9VBRAntennas. Thank you for that. Please let me break this down and make sure I understand correctly, 1) I find the frequency of the station that I want to attempt to contact. 2) I adjust the frequency of my radio about 3kHz above or below the frequency of the POTA site. 3) I tune the loop to that frequency by a) tuning for the highest noise, and b) sending a carrier, at say 1w and adjusting the loop dial and watching the SWR on the radio. 4) Then I tune the radio to the POTA site, increase my power on the radio, and wait for the appropriate time to throw out my call. 5) Because the turning is so sharp, I will probably have to re-adjust the tuning using the loop dial to bring the SWR back to an appropriate level while I’m putting out my call. But I shouldn’t have to move the dial much to get a low SWR. Do I have that right?
You are basically correct. The tuning is sharp on magnetic loop, but there is enough bandwidth on the 10 - 40 meter bands in that you can move a few KC's off, make the tune, and go back to the calling station without further adjustment.
Well I have to say this is an excellent review. I’m sure a lot of time and effort went into it. But another con you forgot to mention is its price. $500-650 not including if you want the auto tuner & power compensator. But I guess it’s an easier pill to swallow when you’re getting it for free or at minimum a deep discount for producing the review. Don’t get me wrong, Chameleon makes excellent products but this isn’t $650 excellent. So, is this something you would purchase if you had to pay full price? I’m also curious as to how much power is radiated using the power compensator if you wanted to run 60 watts.
I don't believe the price is a negative. If you search, you will see that the F-Loop 3.0 is priced competitively with other brands. There is a reason I don't generally talk about pricing in my reviews. First, prices change and listing a price dates the video and second, price can be a measure of value by the viewer and what might be out of the budget of some, may be an acceptable value proposition by others. Chameleon did send me this antenna unsolicited. I do not ask manufacturers or vendors for product samples. If they wish to give me something, that's on them. I also don't accept every free offer I receive. I refuse cheap handheld radios and other products that don't fit the scope of the channel. Finally, to answer your question. Last fall I purchased an F-Loop kit from Chameleon. I paid $300 for the kit. It was going to be a winter project/construction video. Before I had the chance to build the antenna, I received the fully constructed F-Loop. Instead of spending 20-25 hours building and recording the construction video, I spent 25 hours writing, shooting, editing, producing this review. I believe that was a fair exchange. I may still build my F-Loop, or I may give it away. I haven't decided yet.
This video was a lot more involved due to the complexity of the subject. It required a lot of setups and variations in the background video. But, on average, at this quality level, I'm spending about an hour of production for every finished minute of video.
I have the Chameleon Receive Only and I am happy with it no matter the steep price. Recently was considering a loop for transmission and once again no matter those F-Loop 3.0 are expensive as hell I was about to drop the money until found the little detail that you even have to read and re-read the description because is kind of hidden and is that is 25 watts ONLY? really? or even worst 10w for CW so I bet for digital will be the same or less. So $500 plus shipping and taxes for a QRP antenna? No thanks, looking at the Alpha antennas that at least can do 100w. When Chameleon comes with a 100w loop then I may be interested if I don't have to put a second mortgage in my house to afford it.
The antenna is also directional. So each time you've a QSO then rotate the antenna slowly until you can the best RX!
Cha Cha Cha
Cha Cha Cha... the F-loop works great with the updated tuners (LRT and ALRT) makes tuning very very easy and fast!!!!
I have worked all over the world with my F-Loop and 20 watts!
I use mine indoors for bad weather. I have worked all over the world with my QRP rigs.
Thankyou for this excellent video! appreciated the explanation and your experiences
I've been using my FLOOP 2.0 for 3 years. I have the power compensator and usually run 50W SSB and 25W Digital. Being in an apartment downtown Montreal, I use mine indoors most of the time. On SSB, I cover North America, Western Europe with some contacts in Russia. On FT8, I got Tahiti, Angola, South America, etc. It works really well. I got so much used to the tuning than I can follow my radio while it scans.
As others said, the guys on the other end are usually surprised to hear about my setup. Espcially the indoors part. It's always good fun.
I want to add that this is an awesome POTA antenna, it is portable, quick and easy to put up and take down, directional (so it has gain) and supports NVIS on the lower bands.... but this antenna really excels on 20 meters where many POTA operators and hunters have antenna capabilities, so if you are into POTA you might take a second look at this antenna. Cha Cha Cha
Looks like a great antenna, but probably only for specific situations with limited space.
I agree pretty much with your thoughts, except for a "fun" antenna.I found i it kind a pain. Loved the video.
F-Loop is the best of the mag loops
Sounds like a really great antenna but a might bit expensive if just operating qrp. Thanks for reviewing!
The magnetic loop antenna like the CHA F-LOOP 3.0 is probably the only antenna on the market that will allow you to operate 40M and 80M from indoor according that you understand its restriction and the principle behind HF propagation from a loop. Its footprint is literally 3' X 3' X 12" - Try to install a 30M, 40M, 60M and 80M antenna in that footprint or on your kitchen table!
Possibly, some QRP rigs are dirt cheap and others are very expensive (price out an Elecraft KX3 and you know what I'm talking about). I guess it depends where on the spectrum you are.
Great video. I have an F loop on order and hope to get operating soon. What headsets were you using in the car for your POTA session. I will be using it with ICOM 705. 73
I use the Heil BM-17 dual headset. I did a review on it a couple years ago: th-cam.com/video/qB1z2g8m090/w-d-xo.html
I've seen people sitting right next to these magloop antennas inside their house while they're using them on the air. I suppose with QRP power, it's okay, but it always looks like a potential RF exposure issue in close quarters.
KZ9V
I did a quick exposure calculation, and at 20 watts on the 20 meter band, the required distance in an uncontrolled situation was less than 1 foot. But these antennas exploit the H fields of RF radiation and I don't know if that makes a difference in the calculations, the ARRL exposure calculator didn't allow for that variable. I guess I'll have to look into that.
I think this one of your best videos! I also had rthe plesure of getting play with a 2.0. Every thing you said mirrors my experience exactly. 73 KE0SUM. I am in your log book.
Awesome, it's a fun antenna and I'm sure I will be showing up in future videos.
Great video
I am also making a magnetic loop antenna and video
Omni directional verse nulls, how does the maglube compare? 73 and thanks, KF0NNQ.
Magnetic loops are bidirectional, the signal will be the strongest in the plane of the antenna and weakest on its face. With weaker signals off the plane, rotating the antenna will increase their strength.
A magnetic loop like the CHA F-LOOP 3.0 will radiate DX and NVIS simultaneously!
Sitting on Rib Hill is Cheating AHAHAHAHAH....
Does that work along the Lines of the old AEA isoloop ??
I still have Jr, P's N9FOL's Antenna..
Thanks Michael...
Rib is a great place to go for some HF fun, especially if you are using a vertical antenna. From my understanding, the Isoloop is the same style of antenna, just in a different package.
@@KB9VBRAntennas I know. Just teasing....
DId the Same in My Ainchaint CB days.
I’ve had the F Loop 2.0 for a couple of years now and I LOVE IT! I use it mostly with the aluminum loop…that antenna is a snap to put together. I do recommend to people to keep extra velcro loops as the originals are thin and sometimes break when pulled too tight I bought heavier loops from Home Depot and they work just fine. Thanks for showcasing the later version…it’s a great antenna! 73 de K2KOH
Stellar presentation. Thank you!
It’s pretty much amazing! Micheal covered just about everything the CHA F-LOOP 3.0 is capable of! 👌👌👌
Comme toujours.
Great review, Michael. This might be perfect in my HOA backyard with my KX3. You got me interested.
I think it would pair very well with your KX3. The nice thing is that you can leave it mostly assembled and just carry the whole unit outside, put it on a tripod, and be ready to get on the air.
I have worked the world on 20 watts and the F Loop!
@@KB9VBRAntennas I do wish someone would create a loop that could stand the elements in Wisconsin and Northern Illinois. I'd like to put this on my patio, nail it down, add an antenna rotator, and just work from the kitchen table without having to go out in the snow.
Hello Michael. Thank you for the excellent review of the Chameleon F Loop antenna. I think this is an excellent choice for Parks on the Air if you are operating QRP. I have a Ciro Mazzoni Baby Loop antenna which operates QRO. If you haven‘t seen this antenna, I would encourage you to check it out. It‘s a great choice for people that live in HOA communities. It is expensive but it works very well and comes with an automatic tuner. Thank you for the great videos.
I agree with you about the Ciro Mazzoni Baby-loop. I have mine on a rotor and have been very happy with my DV using 100w.
A fine description of the pros and cons of this style of antenna. It doesn't fit my current style of operation but one never knows what life will throw their way. U-rah-rah
Fantastic review and explanation, Michael. Thank you. 73
Can this antenna be mag mounted?
Good , very good!!! 73!!!!
Thank you for the review!
Another usefull video. Did you test with the all metal loop option and was this better than the LMR400 coax?
I did not do a side by side comparison of the coax loop and the aluminum one, but I noticed a few things with the aluminum. It was a bit easier to tune, maybe because there was a little more bandwidth. Signal reports were marginally stronger with the aluminum, but that could be due to propagation. The aluminum worked very well on 30 meters, so I'll assume the same with the 40 meter band.
Great video. Can you leave the antenna outdoors more permanently? Does it withstand exposure to rain, snow and cold temperatures?
No -this unit is made for portable and temporary installation and WIL NOT handle rain or snow!
The tuning box is not weather sealed, so it is not designed for long term outdoor use.
I have great success with the MFJ-935C loop tuner, its ability to handle 150 watts is a huge plus!
You do have to use different loop sizes but it’s really good.
Thank you for the video. I am trying to decide which mag loop to go for, and watching this helped me understand the pros and cons of the Chameleon version.
QUESTION: Would adding a third loop/length theoretically make it tune for even lower frequencies like the 160meter band ?
It possibly could, but I don't know. My concern would be if the tuning unit has enough capacitance to work on 160 meters. Reading the user guide, it states that with a double loop, the tuner will operate down to 2.8 MHz, so it is a possibility. But the bigger concern is that on 160m your bandwidth will be practically a hair's width. On 80m it has 6 KHz of bandwidth. You can safely say that on 160 the bandwidth will be less than 3 KHz. If you ever try it, let me know if it works.
@@KB9VBRAntennas Thank you for the reply. I am trying to decide if I will build my own mag loop or if I should buy one. Building is better because it is fun - but buying is easy as it saves time :) I might try to do both so I have one for reference.
I bought the DIY Cha Loop 3.0 about 6 months ago. I was so excited that I could afford this at the lower price.
It will not tune 30-10 meters at all.
I think the switch is defective. One of the pins is loose. I contacted Chameleon and told them about the problem.
They said I had to send it back to them on my dime and give them another 100 or so for them to fix it.
I do realize there was no service that came with this purchase. But I could have bought an assembled unit for the extra money I'll need to spend fixing this one.
I was so disappointed I put it back in the box since then.
Well, I got it out and tried to see if I could do anything myself.
Question: Does anyone know where to get another switch?
I've had mine since 2015 a solid bit of kit, amazing quality. People seem genuinely surprised when you tell them you are on
Don't forget mag loops are directional and to turn off your rigs tuner.
Great and so educational video!
dont have a radio or anything yet, just doing research. really appreciate this information. thank you
Save money. Put up a decent doublet.
Thank you for this very helpful vieo, Michael. Enjoyed it as always. Alpha loops sells alpha mag loops that take 100 Watts. Now is that then a different construction difference or anexaggerated claim ? Thanks !
Not having any experience with the Alpha Loop, I went down the rabbit hole a bit to figure out how they can claim 100 watt transmit on sideband (50 watt CW and 10 watt digital). The short answer is that I couldn't find any videos or reports backing up the claim. Everyone using the loop uses it QRP. In their advertising, they say they use a 'tuned circuit' and 'faraday wrapped' coupling loop. My guess is that their capacitor has wider plate spacing that limits arcing. But that introduces other inefficiencies into the system.
What I find telling in their materials is that they recommend only 10 watts digital. Since digital modes are full duty cycle (on average SSB is only 30% duty cycle), that's a better indicator of true power handling capability. They are banking on the fact that most people don't push their output to the limit on phone.
Thank you for the detailed review. The build quality appears to be excellent on this antenna. I would be curious to see how this antenna performs with Winlink or FT8. Would you consider doing a video with this antenna in an area with a high/bad noise floor. I have yet to see anyone attempt this on YT.
In the video I did a comparison on FT8 between the Magnetic Loop and a 1/4 wave vertical antenna. While not highly scientific, the results between the two antennas where within 1-3 dB of each other with the mag loop being slightly stronger.
Nice review cool tech, can,t see why they want $500 and up for a cap, lmr400 and some aluminium, way over priced, must have some thing to do with the name.
If you can make them cheaper, same quality, same performance, same material send me a PO and I’ll take 500 units. 60 days lead time! 👍
That Heil BM17 headset, which element is that? I'm assuming you're on the Yaesu FT891.
Since my transceivers are Yaesu, I'm using the standard element in my BM-17 headset and not the Icom element.
While watching the video I noticed it was snowing. Can the antenna work if it's raining outside? I don't think the tuning box can handle rain.
The tuning box is not weather resistant, so you will not want to expose it to the elements for long periods of time. In my case, I was able to wipe it down after using it to prevent any water penetration.
Great video Michael. I was surprised how far you can reach with a loop antenna and 5 watts. I’ve got a question in regards to your headset. In your videos, do you have the audio going to your headset and a speaker. Or are you just using the mic on the headset? Thanks, and have a good evening. Bill, KC2KNA
I use a 2 channel wireless microphone to record my audio (Rode Wireless Go II). I wear one microphone for my audio and the 2nd microphone is attached to the Line Out port on the transceiver. You can a clean line out on Yaesu radios by connecting to the data port. The two channels are then mixed down and levels adjusted during editing. I have video that explains my process in detail: th-cam.com/video/tOqzZPphE7k/w-d-xo.html
@@KB9VBRAntennas thanks for the explanation Michael. I’ll check out that video. You had me sold on the Heil headset the first time I saw you use it. I’ve got to get the version for the Icom. Have a great day….. Bill, KC2KNA
I do the assembly by lying everything flat on the ground and then attach it to the tripod . VO1OK
That's not a bad idea. If you tripod also has a quick release plate, then mounting it would be a breeze.
Correct. I use a tripod similar to yours
How does the height above ground affect the performance of the loop?
The height above ground for magnetic loop isn't really important. Usually keeping the loop about 36" is sufficient. But I've operated the F-LOOP 3.0 directly installed on the floor or ground numerous times without any issues!
Ideal height is about one loop diameter above ground. But ground effect plays a minimal role in magnetic loop performance, so they will operate well at ground level.
Great review. I enjoy the videos! Thank you for the details in this one. I'm interested in a loop for QRP and hunting POTA. I'm trying to decide between the Chameleon and the Alex Loop. I mostly make SSB contacts on 20m at this point in my ham journey using 5w or less. I understand the basic concept of tuning a loop. Can anyone give some guidance on process for tuning when hunting POTA stations? Do you tune just outside the frequency range of the station you're hunting so you don't impede current conversations on the target frequency? Maybe use 1w when doing so? I like the idea of being able to, when necessary, to have an antenna that I can put on a tripod and not worry about putting a wire in a tree or a stake in the ground that might violate some rules of a park. Any feedback is appreciated.
In tuning the loop, if you are doing it by ear of with an analyzer, you can be on the frequency as the activator. If you are going to transmit, then you should be off frequency a bit in order to not intentionally interfere. In the 10 - 40 meter bands, you will have enough bandwidth in order to move 3 kHz or so away and make your adjustments.
@KB9VBRAntennas. Thank you for that. Please let me break this down and make sure I understand correctly, 1) I find the frequency of the station that I want to attempt to contact. 2) I adjust the frequency of my radio about 3kHz above or below the frequency of the POTA site. 3) I tune the loop to that frequency by a) tuning for the highest noise, and b) sending a carrier, at say 1w and adjusting the loop dial and watching the SWR on the radio. 4) Then I tune the radio to the POTA site, increase my power on the radio, and wait for the appropriate time to throw out my call. 5) Because the turning is so sharp, I will probably have to re-adjust the tuning using the loop dial to bring the SWR back to an appropriate level while I’m putting out my call. But I shouldn’t have to move the dial much to get a low SWR. Do I have that right?
You are basically correct. The tuning is sharp on magnetic loop, but there is enough bandwidth on the 10 - 40 meter bands in that you can move a few KC's off, make the tune, and go back to the calling station without further adjustment.
Well I have to say this is an excellent review. I’m sure a lot of time and effort went into it. But another con you forgot to mention is its price. $500-650 not including if you want the auto tuner & power compensator. But I guess it’s an easier pill to swallow when you’re getting it for free or at minimum a deep discount for producing the review. Don’t get me wrong, Chameleon makes excellent products but this isn’t $650 excellent.
So, is this something you would purchase if you had to pay full price? I’m also curious as to how much power is radiated using the power compensator if you wanted to run 60 watts.
I don't believe the price is a negative. If you search, you will see that the F-Loop 3.0 is priced competitively with other brands. There is a reason I don't generally talk about pricing in my reviews. First, prices change and listing a price dates the video and second, price can be a measure of value by the viewer and what might be out of the budget of some, may be an acceptable value proposition by others.
Chameleon did send me this antenna unsolicited. I do not ask manufacturers or vendors for product samples. If they wish to give me something, that's on them. I also don't accept every free offer I receive. I refuse cheap handheld radios and other products that don't fit the scope of the channel.
Finally, to answer your question. Last fall I purchased an F-Loop kit from Chameleon. I paid $300 for the kit. It was going to be a winter project/construction video. Before I had the chance to build the antenna, I received the fully constructed F-Loop. Instead of spending 20-25 hours building and recording the construction video, I spent 25 hours writing, shooting, editing, producing this review. I believe that was a fair exchange. I may still build my F-Loop, or I may give it away. I haven't decided yet.
@@KB9VBRAntennas wow that’s a lot of work! A big part of the reason I haven’t gotten into the whole TH-cam submission craze. My hats off to you Mike!
This video was a lot more involved due to the complexity of the subject. It required a lot of setups and variations in the background video. But, on average, at this quality level, I'm spending about an hour of production for every finished minute of video.
I have the 2.0 and it works. I just wish it could work to 100W more power at the loses on the lower frequenices.
You can get the CHA POWER COMPENSATOR to increase the power to about 60W SSB 30WC W.
@@carllavoie3804 Yes I know and I have the power compensator. Alpha antennas have one that works to 100w but Chameleon has better build quality.
@@thuff3207 loop are made to be used QRP unless you use a remote tuner which we also have.
It's too small for 80 m. Marketing may say it will work at 80 but physics say too small.
The loop isn't too small to work on 80M and physics also says that it will work. Practical tests also shows that it works on 80M.
It’s not very efficient, but it is usable.
I have the Chameleon Receive Only and I am happy with it no matter the steep price. Recently was considering a loop for transmission and once again no matter those F-Loop 3.0 are expensive as hell I was about to drop the money until found the little detail that you even have to read and re-read the description because is kind of hidden and is that is 25 watts ONLY? really? or even worst 10w for CW so I bet for digital will be the same or less. So $500 plus shipping and taxes for a QRP antenna? No thanks, looking at the Alpha antennas that at least can do 100w. When Chameleon comes with a 100w loop then I may be interested if I don't have to put a second mortgage in my house to afford it.
lol ok
Nice vacuum variable cap would allow 100w but double the price at the very least.
A vacuum variable capacitor cost on itself about $1,300 brand new after that, the entire design of the loop would have to be entirely redone....
I saw a vacuum cap 'high power' magnetic loop at hamvention and almost choked at the price.