I respect both but I love Beyoncé’s far better due to her clarity, complex riffs, tone and resonance. Her voice doesn’t crack or get raspy unless she’s aiming for that effect.
Beyoncé may be technically better, but Xtina is like one of those old singers with incredible voices that we do not see very often. Her tone is one of the most beautiful ever and she sings with a lot of soul and power.
….. People compare Beyonce to everyone and it’s exhausting. Just listening to both of their renditions of river deep and Ave Maria tells us everything we need to know about their singing capabilities . Great video nonetheless.
It's weird bc if you compare them age to age, Christina has been Christina since day one or age 8. If in the last 10 years Bey has stylistically become a more attractive vocalist then that's the more fair and better assessment. But Christina is still Christina. It's like comparing a new artist to a vet and then waiting for the vet to slow down.
If you compare Beyonce rendition of At last and Christina Rendition of At last it tells everything,if you compare it’s a man’s world by Beyonce and the same song by xtina it reveals everything
@@ntuzunkaurintah Christina has the better tone. Beyoncé has the superior technique. Christina's voice is prone to cracking. She also usually lowers the key and dodges big, difficult notes. She is not nearly as reliable as Beyoncé when singing live. She is a hit or miss. But she definitely has the much better tone.
I knew you would enjoy this Nick! I love Beyonce stamina and control. Christina tone is beautiful but sometimes she makes me nervous when she goes to high in full voice but her falsetto game is top tier.
Beyoncé's modal and well supported notes are impeccable and commendable, but Christina's Grit, Vocal Character and texture, and Stylistic Methods are Classic and another level of Art for me. It might sound unhealthy in some way but its her stylistic and artistic expression that adds character to her materials.
It really is a preference thing. I watched the whole thing and always preferred the dirt and imperfection in xtina's execution over beyonce's cleanliness.
Beyoncé sings with quite a bit of grit so idk what youre talking about. She can singing with cleanliness and pristine vocals and she can sing with grit and rawness (still with perfect vocals). Depends on the song. Though she naturally has a gritty voice. That much has been evident since Destiny child days. How can you listen to her Coachella performance or Stevie wonder tribute and say this is beyond me
So I could be wrong and if I am, please tell me because I would love to stand corrected. But obviously the vocal trilogy amongst female singers of the 90s are Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey, and Céline Dion, that’s unanimous. When it comes down to the 2000s, Obviously Beyonce and Christina are the top two but the third one is always difficult because we have to factor in who had their level of success/popularity, along with being a huge vocalist. Although she doesn’t sing better than Beyonce or Christina (and she doesn’t sound that great now lol) the only other person I can think of is Alicia Keys. Obviously singers like Kelly Clarkson or Pink are probably better vocalist, but I feel like Alicia Keys catalog gives her a notch up! What do you guys think?
The trinity were the trinity MAINLY because of their vocal ability. The success was a bonus. It would definitely be Kelly Clarkson as the third. Bey, Xtina, and Kelly are the three absolute best out. Kelly was the first American Idol for a reason. And Kelly had a GREAT run and she had HITS as well. It’s her
@@BGK8345 There’s no way on earth that Alicia Keys could ever be a part of the vocal trinity solely because of her vocal abilities. They’re above average at best. After all it’s called the vocal trinity for a reason. You have to be vocally equal or superior to Whitney, Mariah, or Celine in many, if not all, vocal abilities to be considered trinity potential. For example, when it comes to Vocal Power, Versatility, Head Voice, Dynamics, Breath Control/Stamina, and Consistency, Beyonce’s superior to Mariah. She’s quiet on per with Mimi in terms of Technique, Pitch, Vibrato, Emotiveness, Musicality and Belting. Mariah is however better in Vocal Agility, Resonance, Range, and Musicality. With Whitney, when it comes to Versatility, Breath Control/Stamina, Lows, and Range Beyonce’s superior to Whitney. She’s quite on par with Nippy in terms of Pitch, Vibrato, Vocal Agility, Emotiveness, Dynamics, and Technique. But when it comes to Vocal Power, Musicality, Resonance, Head Voice, Breath Support, Belting, Whitney is better and slightly in some parts. So as you can see, Beyonce’s got the vocal abilities to compete in various departments. Alicia on the other hand…
@@mlh1367not really. There are some singers outthere who have same technical level even some are better than them like Lisa Fischer and Vivian Reed. The trinity are rare because they r complete as an artist. They r famous, *very goodlooking* (7,5 - 9), have great voices, great performer, *great musicianship* , great charisma, *unique and generally beautiful tone* , and *being impactful for younger generation across the world* . There is no one who are as complete as them them even until now exception for Michael Jackson.
Christina Aguilera will loose when we judge in terms of technique ,but technique left aside she conquers, xtina is on and off at times but the moment she is at her best she gives a tough competition to the vocal trinities too,that is why Patti Labelle Celine Whitney and Arethra franklin gave her a shout out on how incredible vocalist she was,Xtina is the voice of the generation for a reason,people can come and dispute,but she already received the award for it and billboard Grammy and VH1 regards her as the voice of the generation too,and Xtina deserves some respect to her name
I kinda knew which way it was gonna go because I’m familiar with how low Beyoncé can go that Christina can’t go. And I know how high Christina can go with her whistle that Beyoncé can’t
Listen, I'm not even a Beyoncé fan like that but when she's compared to just anyone, the vids end up being so awkward cuz she wins by a long shot most of the time. Again I'm only a casual fan of hers at best but she has pretty much the best voice in the (mainstream) industry today.
All the video from beyonce was collected form big states with of tones of quality and microphone depths... Christinas videos was collected from randomly lives with very bad acoustic sounds.
Making this video has made me gain a lot of enemies hahaha thanks for react to my video! 🫰🏻❤️ Seeing your reaction, I confirm that I made the video well.
@Salsereo12 She did though. Matter of fact Beyoncé has been praised by all of the greats; Michael, Whitney, Mariah, Stevie, Patti. Diana, Prince, etc. And that's just to state a few lol there's many more
Ok people have got to stop taking these videos seriously hahaha These are two of the most amazing singers of our time, that have birthed young vocalists, and ya'll here arguing about who hit a better C#5 like are ya'll for real
It’s crazy how Beyonce does this while performing 2-3 hour dance marathon concerts in stilettos. Just eating her insanely talented back up dancers up!! She’s truly an unmatched artist. Christina is one of the greatest voices ever too so this isn’t shade to her either.
Was gonna comment nicely until I saw this stan being a hater. So let me say why. It's because those are what most Xtina stans are; bitter f@gs coz their fave isn't as successful, better and much more acclaimed and loved than Beyoncé.
Christina Aguilera is so much better at everything! Christina Aguilera's voice is unmatched! Xtina's tone! Xtina's passion!!!! Xtina's soul!!! B Beyoncé is a very good singer and knows how to use everything very well, but CHRISTINA AGUILERA is on another level!
It's often hard to watch such reasons because a person has a clear preference and often just disregards one of the vocalist. It was a pure joy to see your reaction because you were respectful to both and I agreed with most of your picks
Beyoncé is more technical because of her extensive training over Christina. But there is something so raw in aguilera's that makes it much more outstanding.
I love Xtina's tone and she has more power than Beyoncé. But if we compare all types of ranges, techniques, styles, riffs and runs, Beyoncé has more and people just don't see it coz she's not as showy until you really listen to her songs live. But again, love Xtina's tone far more just like Adele's and she clearly has more upper range but as a vocalist, Beyoncé is above her
She doesn’t have more power than Beyoncé. As Xtina said herself, she’s an all or nothing singer. She’s not good at mixing and she doesn’t have that level of control. You don’t hear Beyoncé ALWAYS going all out bc she has the control and resonance not to. And the fact that Jennifer Hudson, someone with a more powerful voice than Xtina, got drowned out by Beyoncé on stage, should tell you Xtina doesn’t have more power. And I don’t see how you can hear her Stevie Wonder tribute or even hear her sing with Destiny’s child when she used to go all out quite a bit and conclude Xtina has a stronger voice. It doesn’t make sense to me at all.
I said in the original post of this video that this is incredibly one sided. You can tell a Beyonce fan put this together. It should've included more moments by Christina from the past 6 years since her Liberation Tour. The creator just didn't want to give Christina credit. Christina's voice has improved with age. I think Beyonce is a good singer. I think Christina is a Great singer. Bey also lips quite a bit, which people overlook.
You just made that up and for what? Bey doesn’t lip sync very often AT ALL. You can count on one and a half hands the amount of times she’s actually done it across her 30 year career. Didnt do it a SINGLE TIME in the entire Renaissance or Formation tour or ANY live performance for the past 10-15 years. You tried it. Xtina has actually done it more than her but you’re bias so you’re going to pretend it doesn’t exist. Also, the creator could’ve used WAY better clips from Beyoncé and didn’t. It’s not her fault that Xtina doesn’t compare. Mind you, Xtina sounded great in all of her clips and still didn’t sound better than Bey who, again, the creator didn’t even use the best clips for. It’s clear you’re just mad that you know Bey is better lmao
@@milesdixon9267a clear hater. Bc he just lied on Beyoncé for no reason. And then he’s mad that he thinks Bey sounds better 😭. And these aren’t even close to being her best clips and Xtina sounded GREAT and still isn’t better. That’s something he has to cope with
@mlh1367 sweety lips the bridge of Crazy In Love. I love that your defense is Beyonce doesn't "lip sync often AT ALL." Which still owns up to the fact she lip syncs. The hive is beyond for me. Why do you think her vocals sound the same from concert to concert? No one's that proficient. Not even your best Broadway singer. I'm sure she sings a majority, maybe but a lot it is prerecorded like Mariah. Michael Jackson did the same thing from Dangerous-On. Most of their vocals are prerecorded for concerts.
Hey man. I really enjoy the conversations. Since you brought up the RStones' TOP 200 Singers of all time, I bet it would be worth you're time to actually do a 'dive' into the actual list itself. Might take a few posts to cover the long list. But after you completed the 'dive' ? Maybe rearrange this list, remove certain singers, add other unlisted ones, change their positions (of course with much followers input) and redo the list completely. Any list that has John Lennon above 190 others. Including Patsy, Elvis, Barbra, Frank, etc... is asking for a real list. Anyway, just a thought. The list is very subjective and includes much more than singing talent. IE.."Barbra Streisand is at 147!!!" Seriously and Kelly Clarkson 'CAN SING'! at #194??? Thanks for doing these reactions man❤️❤️
While you’re correct about Bey’s tone, Xtina also has a very distinct tone. However, what sets Beyonce apart from Xtina are the following: 1. Technique. Beyoncé’s technique far outclasses Xtina’s. Beyonce’s technique is enviable. While Xtina’s been practicing poor technique almost consistently. Her bad habits have her in a chock-hold. 2. Pitch. Beyonce has wayyyy better pitch than Xtina. She’s said to be pitch perfect. But there are instances of Xtina going off, even in her recent performances. 3. Versatility. Beyonce’s probably the most versatile vocalist of all time, given that she successful crossed multiple genres than any vocalist I know. And also blending genres (like listen to her song YaYa for understanding her blending abilities). 4. Lows. Beyonce’s a much more rounded, grounded, and resonant. While Xtina’s sound forced and happens with poor placement, poor technique. 5. Vocal Agility. Yes, Xtina has great riffs and runs but they are repetitive and not as complex as Beyonce’s. Also, she’s not as good at transitioning and flipping through registers like Beyonce. 6. Head Voice. They sound equal but Beyonce’s more operatic. 7. Breath Control/Stamina. Beyonce is one of the few artistes in history who can sing and dance at the same time and still be on pitch. Xtina’s not consistent in doing this.
Imagine if they would collaborate! They have the most influential voices that came from the 00s. It would be equivalent as a Mariah Carey Whitney Houston duet.
Beyonce has the better technique but christina has that wow factor to her voice that the older legendary singers had. She has that it factor and she has the better tone in my opinion
I think Christina is enjoyed more universally. She annoys some folks, but not as many as Beyonce does. Beyonce has a grating voice in my opinion. She is very talented but her belts can be hard for a lot of us to listen to.
I guess if you go off preference it may be difficult, but if you’re going off of who actually is technically better… it’s not even close. ESPECIALLY that hv section considering there was only one of them using head voice. Beyonce clears.
@@Salsero12why are going around policing people. We get it you prefer Christina Aguilera but that doesn't mean everyone should always agree with you. Like what's even ur fkn problem?
You can tell when there’s reverb. And in the vast majority of these clips, there was none. She doesn’t actually use reverb as much as y’all like to claim she does. Has she, yes. It’s often at specific times but she doesn’t need it and she’s shown that time and time again. She has power and resonance on her side, which again, she’s proven time and time again.
@@mlh1367 yes sure my dear whatever you say. but the majority of her clips are all with reverb. especially the higher notes it is very clear and obvious even if you don't want to admit it or not. plus i am not her to make any feuds with anyone i simply chose christina and someone left a comment so i had to reply i was very polite and didn't talk shit about anyone. i prefer Christina and her voice simply
Beyoncé has the technicality but no emotion, Christina has the emotion but not the technicality. Both are good tho Also, Christina has the same runs? Chiiiile!…. Plz
That’s simply not true. Beyonce’s also an emotive singer but due to her pop leanings, have had to be less soulful but has plenty videos with soul/emotion. Can give you loads of examples.
imagine that story about xtina having no tecnique but she is the only one that still singing live from the 90' ....... imagine how talented she is that even having NO TECNIQUE ... ... .... she is out there singing like in her prime and even better
@@RanchoViejoo Bey started in the 90s as well so Xtina is not the only one singing live from the 90s. I prefer Bey due to her technique, vocal control and range. Shes far more diverse in terms of singing styles and can do just about whatever she wants with her voice. Xtina is a dope singer as well but she lacks the same level of control and versatility. However, She makes up for it with power, soul and riffs.
I could never choose ONE. Bey is perfect vocally, she doesnt go outside of her range, so she never strains. Ive NEVER seen Bs voice crack, someone show me a clip!!! Christina however, has more tones to her voice than B. I believe shes 5 octave, she cant control all of em. But she can hit em on a good day. Both incredibly talented queens
For those who thinks Beyoncé is better, you know nothing about Christina’s voice and you just watched her worst videos. 😂 Beyoncé is a performer, Christina is a singer.
its funny how beyonce has the depth, dark, masculine and rich low range but its all disappear when shes in the middle range, while christina took all of that in her middle range while her lows isnt as depth as beyonce. u can clearly hear from their first Bb4, its clearly xtina has more depth, power, dark, and thicker than beyonce
This is like comparing Aretha Franklin with Patti Labelle. Each great in their own way and people pick based on preference. Also, this video clearly picked some of xtina “weaker” examples versus Beyoncé better moments. Anything can be manipulated to draw a conclusion.
Exactly. And people preferring beyonce clearly has not heard xtina sing nor has seen a full concert of hers. I’ve seen both during their prime and xtina clears absolutely everyone in hollywood
Nah, that's not true. Yes, Xtina is very talented but she lacks techniques and her belts over C5 are often tensed because she doesn't mix making her sound so coarse. Some people might find that nice in their ears but we need to face the fact that is a very bad technique and could damage one's voice.@@mikosuperable7965
@@mikosuperable7965I’ve also been to both and follow both their careers. Objectively, what makes Beyonce better are the following: 1. Technique. Beyoncé’s technique far outclasses Xtina’s. Beyonce’s technique is enviable. While Xtina’s been practicing poor technique almost consistently. Her bad habits have her in a chock-hold. 2. Pitch. Beyonce has wayyyy better pitch than Xtina. She’s said to be pitch perfect. But there are instances of Xtina going off, even in her recent performances. 3. Versatility. Beyonce’s probably the most versatile vocalist of all time, given that she successful crossed multiple genres than any vocalist I know. And also blending genres (like listen to her song YaYa for understanding her blending abilities). 4. Lows. Beyonce’s a much more rounded, grounded, and resonant. While Xtina’s sound forced and happens with poor placement, poor technique. 5. Vocal Agility. Yes, Xtina has great riffs and runs but they are repetitive and not as complex as Beyonce’s. Also, she’s not as good at transitioning and flipping through registers like Beyonce.
@@squarcircle2254you hit the nail on the head. It’s clear ppl who think Xtina is a better singer are either just biased fans of hers, haven’t heard Bey live or are even familiar with her vocal ability like that, or know nothing about vocals. And to add to your list, Xtina is historically awfully inconsistent when singing live. The same cannot be said for Beyoncé. On top of Beyoncé classically trained. Plus Xtina has admitted that she sucks at mixing. Which Beyoncé is a master at
I think what yall don’t understand is, there aren’t really any “weaker” moments from Beyoncé like there are for Xtina. Beyoncé is arguably the most consistent live singer ever. The clips they chose were actually not even the absolute best they could’ve picked but they still sounded that great to the point you think they purposely chose stronger clips for her and weaker ones for Xtina when that wasn’t the case. And Xtina sounded amazing. She just simply isn’t better than Beyoncé which I think you know
We can be honest, Beyoncé has always been better than her but Xtina still sounds great. She’s definitely a beast. But she’s not in Beyoncé realm and the Industry also knows that. That’s why she’s a top vocalist of all time on just about every vocalist ranking and why Xtina isn’t really mentioned as much. Even though she’s also great. There’s levels. That’s why Dubai paid 24 million to heat that voice and those Arabic scales she’s so great at. These weren’t even Beys best clips and she was still winning most lol
the world we live in is DISGUSTING. U have to HIDE your love for the best vocalist simply because she is overated and because ppl HATE on her talent. Beyonce is literally BEYOND the rest. Xtina is literally my fave, i hated Destinys Child and had all Xtina's albums BUT.... Beyonces vocals are perfect. I am a girl that loves whistle notes SO.... I love Xtina for that. Xtina definitely surpasses Jennifer Hudson
Love you Mr 'Singer', love Beyonce, love Chriatina!! BUT. CHRISTINA IS TWICE THE SINGER Ms Beyonce is . Sorry, but not just better, different class all together❤️❤️
Was gonna comment nicely until I saw this stan being a hater. So let me say why. It's because those are what most Xtina stans are; bitter f@gs coz their fave isn't as successful, better and much more acclaimed and loved than Beyoncé. Tone and power doesn't make you the best vocalist. Beyoncé is miles ahead.
@ThatSingerReactions Yes. That's true. But that same list put John Lennon above Patsy Cline!??! And, John Lennon and Bob Dylan above Elvis Presley. So,I myself, do not put to much value in RStones top 200! Not to mention Kelly Clarkson at #194. Give me a break. Lot more was put into that 'list' other than "singing talent". Just saying.
I respect both but I love Beyoncé’s far better due to her clarity, complex riffs, tone and resonance. Her voice doesn’t crack or get raspy unless she’s aiming for that effect.
Beyoncé may be technically better, but Xtina is like one of those old singers with incredible voices that we do not see very often. Her tone is one of the most beautiful ever and she sings with a lot of soul and power.
Beyonce is good, but christina’s insane her voice is sooooo powerfull
Man hearing them side by side is diabolical, I wonder why they've never collabed
They WILL Collab in the future, mark my words. They both adore each other. Both amazing vocalists. They're gonna bring some special out of each other
We know that nobody beats Christina’s super head voice or whatever.. It’s the cleanest with musicality the world have known to date !!
….. People compare Beyonce to everyone and it’s exhausting. Just listening to both of their renditions of river deep and Ave Maria tells us everything we need to know about their singing capabilities . Great video nonetheless.
It's weird bc if you compare them age to age, Christina has been Christina since day one or age 8. If in the last 10 years Bey has stylistically become a more attractive vocalist then that's the more fair and better assessment. But Christina is still Christina. It's like comparing a new artist to a vet and then waiting for the vet to slow down.
@@BrainPower_AI Bey has been Bey since day one. She’s consistent yet getting better with age.
@@diongustaman2484 two things can be true at the same time.
If you compare Beyonce rendition of At last and Christina Rendition of At last it tells everything,if you compare it’s a man’s world by Beyonce and the same song by xtina it reveals everything
@@ntuzunkaurintah Christina has the better tone. Beyoncé has the superior technique. Christina's voice is prone to cracking. She also usually lowers the key and dodges big, difficult notes. She is not nearly as reliable as Beyoncé when singing live. She is a hit or miss. But she definitely has the much better tone.
Cristina is Cristina only one❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Christina can go to G2 and up to Eb7. She has one of the widest vocal ranges in the world
G2 - F7 ❤
I adore Christina,
Xtina💋🔥🔥🔥
I knew you would enjoy this Nick! I love Beyonce stamina and control. Christina tone is beautiful but sometimes she makes me nervous when she goes to high in full voice but her falsetto game is top tier.
Beyoncé's modal and well supported notes are impeccable and commendable, but Christina's Grit, Vocal Character and texture, and Stylistic Methods are Classic and another level of Art for me. It might sound unhealthy in some way but its her stylistic and artistic expression that adds character to her materials.
I prefer B's tone, and Christinas power
Bey has both..she’s so diverse
Christina’s tone >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> every singer out there 😊
No.
@ hahahaha it’s the simple truth and you know it 😌
@@saulrobertomolinavillegas2950 the tone is base on each opinion 💀 u can t say that
@@saulrobertomolinavillegas2950she doesn’t even sound better than Ariana Grande, let alone Beyoncé lmao. But keep coping ig
@@mlh1367 callate
I love beyonce but Christina is Another level is insane 😳
You know nothing about vocalist..
@@mamajoycewig3041that much is clear lmao
Kelly clarkson was the third of the 2000s vocal trinity
I agree
I think Beyoncé’s better❤
Christina ❤
i love how respectful you are.
It really is a preference thing. I watched the whole thing and always preferred the dirt and imperfection in xtina's execution over beyonce's cleanliness.
XD
THIS!!
Beyoncé sings with quite a bit of grit so idk what youre talking about. She can singing with cleanliness and pristine vocals and she can sing with grit and rawness (still with perfect vocals). Depends on the song. Though she naturally has a gritty voice. That much has been evident since Destiny child days. How can you listen to her Coachella performance or Stevie wonder tribute and say this is beyond me
So I could be wrong and if I am, please tell me because I would love to stand corrected. But obviously the vocal trilogy amongst female singers of the 90s are Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey, and Céline Dion, that’s unanimous. When it comes down to the 2000s, Obviously Beyonce and Christina are the top two but the third one is always difficult because we have to factor in who had their level of success/popularity, along with being a huge vocalist. Although she doesn’t sing better than Beyonce or Christina (and she doesn’t sound that great now lol) the only other person I can think of is Alicia Keys. Obviously singers like Kelly Clarkson or Pink are probably better vocalist, but I feel like Alicia Keys catalog gives her a notch up! What do you guys think?
The trinity were the trinity MAINLY because of their vocal ability. The success was a bonus. It would definitely be Kelly Clarkson as the third. Bey, Xtina, and Kelly are the three absolute best out. Kelly was the first American Idol for a reason. And Kelly had a GREAT run and she had HITS as well. It’s her
@@BGK8345 There’s no way on earth that Alicia Keys could ever be a part of the vocal trinity solely because of her vocal abilities. They’re above average at best. After all it’s called the vocal trinity for a reason. You have to be vocally equal or superior to Whitney, Mariah, or Celine in many, if not all, vocal abilities to be considered trinity potential.
For example, when it comes to Vocal Power, Versatility, Head Voice, Dynamics, Breath Control/Stamina, and Consistency, Beyonce’s superior to Mariah. She’s quiet on per with Mimi in terms of Technique, Pitch, Vibrato, Emotiveness, Musicality and Belting. Mariah is however better in Vocal Agility, Resonance, Range, and Musicality.
With Whitney, when it comes to Versatility, Breath Control/Stamina, Lows, and Range Beyonce’s superior to Whitney. She’s quite on par with Nippy in terms of Pitch, Vibrato, Vocal Agility, Emotiveness, Dynamics, and Technique. But when it comes to Vocal Power, Musicality, Resonance, Head Voice, Breath Support, Belting, Whitney is better and slightly in some parts.
So as you can see, Beyonce’s got the vocal abilities to compete in various departments. Alicia on the other hand…
@@mlh1367not really. There are some singers outthere who have same technical level even some are better than them like Lisa Fischer and Vivian Reed.
The trinity are rare because they r complete as an artist.
They r famous, *very goodlooking* (7,5 - 9), have great voices, great performer, *great musicianship* , great charisma, *unique and generally beautiful tone* , and *being impactful for younger generation across the world* .
There is no one who are as complete as them them even until now exception for Michael Jackson.
i prefer xtinas voice
Christina Aguilera will loose when we judge in terms of technique ,but technique left aside she conquers, xtina is on and off at times but the moment she is at her best she gives a tough competition to the vocal trinities too,that is why Patti Labelle Celine Whitney and Arethra franklin gave her a shout out on how incredible vocalist she was,Xtina is the voice of the generation for a reason,people can come and dispute,but she already received the award for it and billboard Grammy and VH1 regards her as the voice of the generation too,and Xtina deserves some respect to her name
I think you decided before even recording the video lol.
I kinda knew which way it was gonna go because I’m familiar with how low Beyoncé can go that Christina can’t go. And I know how high Christina can go with her whistle that Beyoncé can’t
Christina 4ever!!!
Beyoncé won by farrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr 🤣🤣 i also reacted to this video so i know for sure!
Wait! Where? I haven't seen it!
@@YonceMimi Babe its for members first, comes out next week tho!!!😁
Not at all
Listen, I'm not even a Beyoncé fan like that but when she's compared to just anyone, the vids end up being so awkward cuz she wins by a long shot most of the time. Again I'm only a casual fan of hers at best but she has pretty much the best voice in the (mainstream) industry today.
Beyonce tone more ❤❤
😅😂😂😂
@@Salsero12 She said tone. 😂😂😂
@@bimbam9603 and no lies were told. Beyonce’s tone clears
They are top notch 00s vocalist for me !!! I might hv to agree that Kelly Clarkson will be completed them as Vocal Trinity of 00s.
Dos de las más grandes artistas de este siglo 🎉
Christina Aguilera. 💎✨
React to Christina aguileras 25th anniversary spotify
All the video from beyonce was collected form big states with of tones of quality and microphone depths...
Christinas videos was collected from randomly lives with very bad acoustic sounds.
You’re so real for this 🤣
Making this video has made me gain a lot of enemies hahaha thanks for react to my video! 🫰🏻❤️ Seeing your reaction, I confirm that I made the video well.
Christina... The only one praised by Whitney. Point blank period
whitney also praised beyonce dummy
@@jacobkirk7298nope
@@Salsero12 Yes she DID. DUMMY!
@@jacobkirk7298Thank you! Ppl love talking out they a**
@Salsereo12 She did though. Matter of fact Beyoncé has been praised by all of the greats; Michael, Whitney, Mariah, Stevie, Patti. Diana, Prince, etc. And that's just to state a few lol there's many more
I couldn’t think of a better comparison of vocals and ability.
Christina Aguilera better range, tone and skills
Both amazing but vocally Beyonce is better she's one of the best vocalists ever
Xtina 👑👑👑👑
Both icons
Ok people have got to stop taking these videos seriously hahaha These are two of the most amazing singers of our time, that have birthed young vocalists, and ya'll here arguing about who hit a better C#5 like are ya'll for real
It’s crazy how Beyonce does this while performing 2-3 hour dance marathon concerts in stilettos. Just eating her insanely talented back up dancers up!! She’s truly an unmatched artist. Christina is one of the greatest voices ever too so this isn’t shade to her either.
Beyonce struggled so much at C6😂
Both amazing…I prefer Christina but Beyonce is technically better
Beyoncé's vocal range is immaculate; from top to bottom, fully connected.
You wanna choose Beyonce but give it a tie when she's in an arena with all kinds of reverb and Christina in a car..ok . 😅😂😅 your judgments are invalid
Yet here you are making your 1628th comment on this vid, biased much?
Was gonna comment nicely until I saw this stan being a hater. So let me say why.
It's because those are what most Xtina stans are; bitter f@gs coz their fave isn't as successful, better and much more acclaimed and loved than Beyoncé.
You don’t wanna do that brother Beyoncé sung listen in the car in full without a struggle don’t do that lol
If you dont like Beyonce just say that. The amount of times you’ve commented on this video bashing bey😂😂
Stadium* something Christina never did 😘😘
Man that's hard! But Bey
Christina Aguilera is so much better at everything! Christina Aguilera's voice is unmatched! Xtina's tone! Xtina's passion!!!! Xtina's soul!!! B Beyoncé is a very good singer and knows how to use everything very well, but CHRISTINA AGUILERA is on another level!
As a vocalist, Beyonce is better.
@@andersontrujillo8337 factually yes, based on your feelings ofc not :))))
I'm sorry but Beyonce is Genreless in vocals, Rap, Opera, Pop, Swing, Gospel. She has more range in other Genres in versatility
Xtina ❤❤❤❤
It's often hard to watch such reasons because a person has a clear preference and often just disregards one of the vocalist. It was a pure joy to see your reaction because you were respectful to both and I agreed with most of your picks
Beyoncé is more technical because of her extensive training over Christina. But there is something so raw in aguilera's that makes it much more outstanding.
I love Xtina's tone and she has more power than Beyoncé.
But if we compare all types of ranges, techniques, styles, riffs and runs, Beyoncé has more and people just don't see it coz she's not as showy until you really listen to her songs live.
But again, love Xtina's tone far more just like Adele's and she clearly has more upper range but as a vocalist, Beyoncé is above her
She doesn’t have more power than Beyoncé. As Xtina said herself, she’s an all or nothing singer. She’s not good at mixing and she doesn’t have that level of control. You don’t hear Beyoncé ALWAYS going all out bc she has the control and resonance not to. And the fact that Jennifer Hudson, someone with a more powerful voice than Xtina, got drowned out by Beyoncé on stage, should tell you Xtina doesn’t have more power. And I don’t see how you can hear her Stevie Wonder tribute or even hear her sing with Destiny’s child when she used to go all out quite a bit and conclude Xtina has a stronger voice. It doesn’t make sense to me at all.
i just love how hard this video was for you
Like because we are talking iconic vocalist
Beyoncé is magnificent. Her vocal instrument is well preserved and healthy as she just entered her vocal prime.
I said in the original post of this video that this is incredibly one sided. You can tell a Beyonce fan put this together. It should've included more moments by Christina from the past 6 years since her Liberation Tour. The creator just didn't want to give Christina credit. Christina's voice has improved with age. I think Beyonce is a good singer. I think Christina is a Great singer. Bey also lips quite a bit, which people overlook.
hater
@@milesdixon9267 you're just following me from video to video 😆 🤣 😂
You just made that up and for what? Bey doesn’t lip sync very often AT ALL. You can count on one and a half hands the amount of times she’s actually done it across her 30 year career. Didnt do it a SINGLE TIME in the entire Renaissance or Formation tour or ANY live performance for the past 10-15 years. You tried it. Xtina has actually done it more than her but you’re bias so you’re going to pretend it doesn’t exist. Also, the creator could’ve used WAY better clips from Beyoncé and didn’t. It’s not her fault that Xtina doesn’t compare. Mind you, Xtina sounded great in all of her clips and still didn’t sound better than Bey who, again, the creator didn’t even use the best clips for. It’s clear you’re just mad that you know Bey is better lmao
@@milesdixon9267a clear hater. Bc he just lied on Beyoncé for no reason. And then he’s mad that he thinks Bey sounds better 😭. And these aren’t even close to being her best clips and Xtina sounded GREAT and still isn’t better. That’s something he has to cope with
@mlh1367 sweety lips the bridge of Crazy In Love. I love that your defense is Beyonce doesn't "lip sync often AT ALL." Which still owns up to the fact she lip syncs. The hive is beyond for me. Why do you think her vocals sound the same from concert to concert? No one's that proficient. Not even your best Broadway singer. I'm sure she sings a majority, maybe but a lot it is prerecorded like Mariah. Michael Jackson did the same thing from Dangerous-On. Most of their vocals are prerecorded for concerts.
Hey man. I really enjoy the conversations. Since you brought up the RStones' TOP 200 Singers of all time, I bet it would be worth you're time to actually do a 'dive' into the actual list itself. Might take a few posts to cover the long list. But after you completed the 'dive' ? Maybe rearrange this list, remove certain singers, add other unlisted ones, change their positions (of course with much followers input) and redo the list completely. Any list that has John Lennon above 190 others. Including Patsy, Elvis, Barbra, Frank, etc... is asking for a real list. Anyway, just a thought. The list is very subjective and includes much more than singing talent. IE.."Barbra Streisand is at 147!!!" Seriously and Kelly Clarkson 'CAN SING'! at #194??? Thanks for doing these reactions man❤️❤️
BEYONCEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE VOICEEE THIS IS CRAZYYYY
Beyoncé just operatic notes in head voice but aguilera is just a beast in that register .
Beyoncé’s tone is just more pleasing on them ears, not that Xtina is not great but if a decision has to be made… well Bee is winning❤❤❤
No
Beyoncés tone is what is INCOMPARABLE! Christina can hit every note Beyoncé can on any day but Beyoncés tone is what sets her apart!!
no, Christina may go higher, but she doesn't reach Beyoncé's lows, much less with such quality throughout the range that Beyoncé carries.
While you’re correct about Bey’s tone, Xtina also has a very distinct tone. However, what sets Beyonce apart from Xtina are the following:
1. Technique. Beyoncé’s technique far outclasses Xtina’s. Beyonce’s technique is enviable. While Xtina’s been practicing poor technique almost consistently. Her bad habits have her in a chock-hold.
2. Pitch. Beyonce has wayyyy better pitch than Xtina. She’s said to be pitch perfect. But there are instances of Xtina going off, even in her recent performances.
3. Versatility. Beyonce’s probably the most versatile vocalist of all time, given that she successful crossed multiple genres than any vocalist I know. And also blending genres (like listen to her song YaYa for understanding her blending abilities).
4. Lows. Beyonce’s a much more rounded, grounded, and resonant. While Xtina’s sound forced and happens with poor placement, poor technique.
5. Vocal Agility. Yes, Xtina has great riffs and runs but they are repetitive and not as complex as Beyonce’s. Also, she’s not as good at transitioning and flipping through registers like Beyonce.
6. Head Voice. They sound equal but Beyonce’s more operatic.
7. Breath Control/Stamina. Beyonce is one of the few artistes in history who can sing and dance at the same time and still be on pitch. Xtina’s not consistent in doing this.
Imagine if they would collaborate! They have the most influential voices that came from the 00s. It would be equivalent as a Mariah Carey Whitney Houston duet.
Beyonce has the better technique but christina has that wow factor to her voice that the older legendary singers had. She has that it factor and she has the better tone in my opinion
They need to collab. Vocally it would be the Mariah and Whitney of this generation.
I think Christina is enjoyed more universally. She annoys some folks, but not as many as Beyonce does. Beyonce has a grating voice in my opinion. She is very talented but her belts can be hard for a lot of us to listen to.
Beyonce will always be above most because she does full Choreograph and Vocals
Beyoncé with the magical vibrato
As an independent voter, not a super fan of either one of them...I love you Dom, but I disagreed with so many of your choices. 😊
Like what?
You want me to rewatch the whole video and tell you specifically which ones?
I guess if you go off preference it may be difficult, but if you’re going off of who actually is technically better… it’s not even close. ESPECIALLY that hv section considering there was only one of them using head voice. Beyonce clears.
You misspelled Christina
@@Salsero12why are going around policing people. We get it you prefer Christina Aguilera but that doesn't mean everyone should always agree with you. Like what's even ur fkn problem?
@@Salsero12Lol. Xtina isn’t a better overall artiste than Beyonce.
React to Miley Cyrus vs Christina Aguilera next by me ✌🏽❤️
Beyoncé is technically better and FAR more versatile. But Christina is amazing as well
man come on beyonce's vocals are full of reverb it sounds bigger and echoed it is obvious especially the higher notes
You can tell when there’s reverb. And in the vast majority of these clips, there was none. She doesn’t actually use reverb as much as y’all like to claim she does. Has she, yes. It’s often at specific times but she doesn’t need it and she’s shown that time and time again. She has power and resonance on her side, which again, she’s proven time and time again.
@@mlh1367 yes sure my dear whatever you say. but the majority of her clips are all with reverb. especially the higher notes it is very clear and obvious even if you don't want to admit it or not. plus i am not her to make any feuds with anyone i simply chose christina and someone left a comment so i had to reply i was very polite and didn't talk shit about anyone. i prefer Christina and her voice simply
Beyoncé has the technicality but no emotion, Christina has the emotion but not the technicality. Both are good tho
Also, Christina has the same runs? Chiiiile!…. Plz
That’s simply not true. Beyonce’s also an emotive singer but due to her pop leanings, have had to be less soulful but has plenty videos with soul/emotion. Can give you loads of examples.
imagine that story about xtina having no tecnique but she is the only one that still singing live from the 90' ....... imagine how talented she is that even having NO TECNIQUE ... ... .... she is out there singing like in her prime and even better
@@RanchoViejoo Bey started in the 90s as well so Xtina is not the only one singing live from the 90s. I prefer Bey due to her technique, vocal control and range. Shes far more diverse in terms of singing styles and can do just about whatever she wants with her voice. Xtina is a dope singer as well but she lacks the same level of control and versatility. However, She makes up for it with power, soul and riffs.
@@RanchoViejoobut she’s not the only singer from the 90s singing live…..Beyoncé and Brandy also sing live. So no need to lie to big up Christina
I could never choose ONE. Bey is perfect vocally, she doesnt go outside of her range, so she never strains. Ive NEVER seen Bs voice crack, someone show me a clip!!! Christina however, has more tones to her voice than B. I believe shes 5 octave, she cant control all of em. But she can hit em on a good day. Both incredibly talented queens
For those who thinks Beyoncé is better, you know nothing about Christina’s voice and you just watched her worst videos. 😂 Beyoncé is a performer, Christina is a singer.
❤❤❤❤Queen Beyonce is Queen Beyonce❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
TWO RESPECT BUT ❤❤❤❤I LOVE QUEEN BEYONCE ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
its funny how beyonce has the depth, dark, masculine and rich low range but its all disappear when shes in the middle range, while christina took all of that in her middle range while her lows isnt as depth as beyonce. u can clearly hear from their first Bb4, its clearly xtina has more depth, power, dark, and thicker than beyonce
This is like comparing Aretha Franklin with Patti Labelle. Each great in their own way and people pick based on preference. Also, this video clearly picked some of xtina “weaker” examples versus Beyoncé better moments. Anything can be manipulated to draw a conclusion.
Exactly. And people preferring beyonce clearly has not heard xtina sing nor has seen a full concert of hers. I’ve seen both during their prime and xtina clears absolutely everyone in hollywood
Nah, that's not true. Yes, Xtina is very talented but she lacks techniques and her belts over C5 are often tensed because she doesn't mix making her sound so coarse. Some people might find that nice in their ears but we need to face the fact that is a very bad technique and could damage one's voice.@@mikosuperable7965
@@mikosuperable7965I’ve also been to both and follow both their careers. Objectively, what makes Beyonce better are the following:
1. Technique. Beyoncé’s technique far outclasses Xtina’s. Beyonce’s technique is enviable. While Xtina’s been practicing poor technique almost consistently. Her bad habits have her in a chock-hold.
2. Pitch. Beyonce has wayyyy better pitch than Xtina. She’s said to be pitch perfect. But there are instances of Xtina going off, even in her recent performances.
3. Versatility. Beyonce’s probably the most versatile vocalist of all time, given that she successful crossed multiple genres than any vocalist I know. And also blending genres (like listen to her song YaYa for understanding her blending abilities).
4. Lows. Beyonce’s a much more rounded, grounded, and resonant. While Xtina’s sound forced and happens with poor placement, poor technique.
5. Vocal Agility. Yes, Xtina has great riffs and runs but they are repetitive and not as complex as Beyonce’s. Also, she’s not as good at transitioning and flipping through registers like Beyonce.
@@squarcircle2254you hit the nail on the head. It’s clear ppl who think Xtina is a better singer are either just biased fans of hers, haven’t heard Bey live or are even familiar with her vocal ability like that, or know nothing about vocals. And to add to your list, Xtina is historically awfully inconsistent when singing live. The same cannot be said for Beyoncé. On top of Beyoncé classically trained. Plus Xtina has admitted that she sucks at mixing. Which Beyoncé is a master at
I think what yall don’t understand is, there aren’t really any “weaker” moments from Beyoncé like there are for Xtina. Beyoncé is arguably the most consistent live singer ever. The clips they chose were actually not even the absolute best they could’ve picked but they still sounded that great to the point you think they purposely chose stronger clips for her and weaker ones for Xtina when that wasn’t the case. And Xtina sounded amazing. She just simply isn’t better than Beyoncé which I think you know
Beyoncé is miles ahead of her in vocals and tone
We can be honest, Beyoncé has always been better than her but Xtina still sounds great. She’s definitely a beast. But she’s not in Beyoncé realm and the Industry also knows that. That’s why she’s a top vocalist of all time on just about every vocalist ranking and why Xtina isn’t really mentioned as much. Even though she’s also great. There’s levels. That’s why Dubai paid 24 million to heat that voice and those Arabic scales she’s so great at. These weren’t even Beys best clips and she was still winning most lol
That’s not being honest. Christina is a legendary singer, she doesn’t care about technique.
Christina is far better
I prefer Christina's tone and music. But Beyonce has a better technique.
Than who?
The nerve to say this 😂😂
@@mrexecutive😂❤
In your dreams, maybe
Baby Beyoncé WINS 😂😂😂
23:02 *beyone aint even hit the note yet* “Beyoncé” *because beyhive knows the Coachella operatic vocals*
Just give me some Jimmy, John, Diesel and Michael Hutchence RIP 🙏🏻💔😭
beyonce is FAR better
DUDE YOU NEED TO REACT TO BRAZILIAN GOSPEL VOCAL GROUP
KEMUEL SINGING JERICO YOU GONNA GO CRAZY
Beyoncé better
❤❤❤❤QUEEN BEYONCE ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ IS QUEEN❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
XTINA MEJOR VOZ Y BELLEZA ❤❤
28:07 lol
Please reac to Taylor swift vs Sabrina carpenter 🙏🙏
Please, what song was Xtina singing in 27:01
I believe it's 'Unless It's With You' or 'Deserve'
Thanks a lot, really appreciate. For some reason that falsetto makes me wanna cry, it's so emotional.@@antonio_hudozhnik
Beyoncé only queen
Jay vs Diddy next please lol
😂😂😂😂
YOU'RE MISSING HARRY MACK'S LEGENDARY GIRLS AT GUGGENHEIM FREESTYLE COME ON DUDE DON'T SLEEP ON IT
the world we live in is DISGUSTING. U have to HIDE your love for the best vocalist simply because she is overated and because ppl HATE on her talent. Beyonce is literally BEYOND the rest. Xtina is literally my fave, i hated Destinys Child and had all Xtina's albums BUT.... Beyonces vocals are perfect. I am a girl that loves whistle notes SO.... I love Xtina for that. Xtina definitely surpasses Jennifer Hudson
I mean love Christiana so much but she not Better than Beyonce and that’s ok
Love you Mr 'Singer', love Beyonce, love Chriatina!! BUT. CHRISTINA IS TWICE THE SINGER Ms Beyonce is
. Sorry, but not just better, different class all together❤️❤️
Keep dreaming lol
💯💯💯
Was gonna comment nicely until I saw this stan being a hater. So let me say why.
It's because those are what most Xtina stans are; bitter f@gs coz their fave isn't as successful, better and much more acclaimed and loved than Beyoncé.
Tone and power doesn't make you the best vocalist.
Beyoncé is miles ahead.
Rolling stone got Beyoncé number 8 out of 200 lol
@ThatSingerReactions Yes. That's true. But that same list put John Lennon above Patsy Cline!??! And, John Lennon and Bob Dylan above Elvis Presley. So,I myself, do not put to much value in RStones top 200! Not to mention Kelly Clarkson at #194. Give me a break. Lot more was put into that 'list' other than "singing talent". Just saying.
Xtina mil veces 👌🏼