Yo! The fake wybie pulled out her out of the room with the ghost children because they were going to give her good info to stop her! And how would wybie pull her out I thought the bedlam could only do it
Okay I think it’s actually that the other father is trying to warn her about the beldam. the piano is controlled by the beldam and would probably hurt him or stop him from explicitly warning coraline so he’s trying to tell her through the lyrics of the song
This is true, as in the garden chase scene, he says lines such as "Don't wanna hurt you," And "Mother's Making Me." And at the end, when the other father basically saves Coraline, he hands her the eye of the ghost child. And I've actually believed this theory for a long time.
By calling her a doll it's possible he's saying that they can control her, she's easily manipulated and they can store her in the Pink Palace Limbo World. Like putting a doll on the second floor of a house.
While the lyrics of the song can be creepy with foreshadowing, I also saw it as a way for the Other Father to tell Coraline that he was an ally. "She's a pal of mine" as in the Other Father's friend, and not the Other Mother's. He is more conscious than the other puppets that the Other Mother controls and so, I believe that he was warning her of the dangers.
Yeah exactly, it confuses me that some people think all of them in the other world are controlled by the Beldam even though the other father warns her multiple times and Wybie has emotions of his own. It seems like the Beldam doesn’t have full control of them that’s why the piano has hands and she made sure Wybie couldn’t speak. While also sewing a smile into his face in a failed attempt to convince Caroline that things were okay
To all the comments, she puts "Soul sand" into the characters and the more you give the more free will they have, as when the cat bite the "mouse" little sand comes out, which is why it follows every command.
the wybie puppet was also more conscious, and I like to think that the beldam took a past child's soul and made wybie so future kids would have someone closer to their age to interact and possibly make them feel safer and comfortable
it's astonishing how intricate this story is. I don't think a sequel would ever be as good as the original, but it would certainly give us more information to go off of
The Fangirl. Read the whole thing it is very worth it I promise this is also my opinion so with that hope you enjoy. So first remember IT or Penny Wise is an alien from the universe called the Macroverse could the Beldam have came with him or in the same way she cold be a related, older, or even younger ancestor/species the Beldam could have had the power to create a pocket universe or 2 as an upstairs and down stairs I think just maybe because the world was killing her somehow she had to make this universe into a makeshift pocket universe/ energy collector she's not comepletly thriving on kids just partially for food from their love and then stores their sole in a separate compartment such as a dark room that does not need much energy such as the room that was used for coralines time out spot the plan was to use the eyes to power a place of the world like the garden the circus or a theater soon enough the land would be big enough to be an entire other universe or the energy for creating one by putting the world so close together making a reaction creating one where IT and the Beldam can live and repopulate by basically making another big band in that pocket universe with the aunt to contain so much or shoving into a small space. Option 2 seems most logical because you see the soles in the containment area both eyes are missing you need 4 eyes. But why not just take 2 kids you ask 4 eyes of different bloodlines if Caroline is in that basement when the Beldam is descised as her mother she is already gone and at the last battle between them what do we see the world literally contracting into the small space that will be all soon creating a big bang. I really hope you didn't get bored sorry for the graphic novel I made you read please respond for part 2 of my ideas if you want to read more
The 'she's a doll' part could be the other father trying to tell coraline that she is going to be stuck there, calling her a doll. Interesting wording for a child in a world where EVERYONE ELSE look like a doll
I think you should do a theory on why Dr. Frankenstein is so controlling of Sally and why he would always say, "You're not ready." This is song is always stuck in my head by the way.
Maybe when he said “she’s a pal of mine” that means that “you can trust me, I don’t wanna hurt you” but in a subtle way. And has anyone noticed that once the bedlam started “fading back to her normal self” so did everything else? I believe the bedlam could have just pushes her self to make everything to look amazing. Which I believe supports Fangirls theory, of scaring Coraline!
I watched the movie again last night and I noticed that the sisters who live downstairs in the otherworld originally have white buttons as eyes. Then when they shed their outer layer their new eyes are black buttons. Is there any significance to this in regards to eye color? Also, in the scene where Coraline decides to play that game regarding finding the eyes of the ghost children, the Beldam never specifies that Coraline is on a timer. This would mean Coraline would have effectively unlimited time. Could this mean that the button on the moon was not a timer but was instead an indicator of how many eye Coraline has? Could it also be that the Beldam was trying to trick Coraline into thinking she had a time limit since she forgot to impose one? Another thing. In the scene where it is really foggy(may be getting the scene slightly mixed up) and Coraline is talking to Wybie regarding the other world, the cat is out of view of Coraline and glances angrily at the doll inside her room. If the cat was working with the Beldam and Coraline was already trapped in the other world why would he do this?
Possible explanation for the She's a Doll line- this is a bit of a stretch, but what if another reason the beldam wanted to sew in buttons into Coraline's eyes was because it would create some kind of connection to the doll in which the beldam could actually control Coraline's movements? (Like a voodoo doll). So in essence, she would become the doll. Idk it just kind of popped into my head and I thought I'd share.
Also, another theory could be that she needed Coraline's eyes so that she will become the doll needed to spy on the next child. Someone else theorized that the other mother can't change the real world. But can take things via the mice and change it.
Imagine being her parents and coming home from work or the store and not seeing your daughter. You just notice a doll that looks like her and she goes missing for years. That must be a nightmare for every parent.
You should definitely look into the lyrics of the song that Miss Spink and Miss Forcible sing. The song is the one in the theatre, some lyrics such as: I might steal your weak heart away and And hope to lead sailors astray. Seem to be a reference to what the other mother is doing with children? This whole song seems like it's either giving us more subtle insight on the other mother or maybe some sort of backstory for the two ladies. If you listen to the song with different context it definitely feels like there is something there. Anyways, I love your videos! Keep up the good work :)
I think the other Farther is a slave and you said that the other mother could be watching them he is trying to warn her what would happen without the other mother knowing. And to support my idea at the part where Corriline is going down stairs looking for the other mother he said "can't talk mother would here" proves that the other dad is scared of her. If that doesn't convince you this will, before the other dad's death he says " so sorry so sorry mother making me do this" and he gives her the eye at the end. What do you think
@@e.martinz5945 dude this person is giving their perspectiveand theorty and its very interesting, so just appreciate it. if younhave nothing nice to say then dont say anything at alk
oh but didn't the other mother have full control of the other world? so maybe she was controlling the other father so help coraline to give her a false sense of security
Omg! I was thinking there was something with this song! Your theories are always so amazing! But I really gotta request the movie Halloweentown (again). I really think you can find some interesting things in that film. Anyways, you’re awesome!
Maybe the line: "Our eyes will be on Coraline" means that if she accepts the button eyes she will become a puppet like everyone in the other world (except for the Beldam 😮)
Olga Sot I thought of a different thing with this line where the button eyes which are the eyes everyone has in the other world will be on her meaning she will have button eyes because it is technically their eyes. My thought is kinda similar to yours
You know I'm so lucky you keep replying to me. I love your channel so much, and I hope to have a great channel like yours one day, thank you for replying to me and keeping my hopes up. xxx
she's a doll could mean *you are now my puppet...* mainly because voodoo dolls are used for control, so he's saying *you too will be controlled for the next kid*
I think your main theory about the limbo pink Palace and how coraline never really left is very interesting. I think I have something to add on to it though. Coraline did get rid of the key, yes. But as we've seen, the Bedlam still has many more. Which comes to my conclusion that that Bedlam could lure Coraline back to her lair any time she pleases. After all, it's not the real world, so nothing is really stopping her right?
Klashin' KixYT I don't think the beldam would lure her back because she can feed off of coraline easier when coraline believes that she's in the real world. Coraline loves her "real" mother more than the other mother, so if coraline thinks she's around her real mother, she will automatically give the beldam more love to feed off. Therefore giving the beldam no reason to lure her back into the lair
The tunnels don't matter, remember the first time coraline went through to the other mothers world? Remember when she went to sleep and then woke up somehow back in her world?.. Well she didn't.
Hey the fangirl can you please make a theory on the Book of Life theory on la muerte and xibalba story and background please I like to see that on your channel they're pretty cool for a Halloween thing make it there on that one cuz I love that one with Coraline or do one on Once Upon a Time theory the ABC show
I think when the other father said "our eyes will be on coraline" maybe it means that they want the button eyes witch are there eyes so that line could mean putting the buttons on the eyes. I don't know if you understand that but it is hard to explain
She's a peach could mean that the other mother wants to eat her, so he's hinting at that, she's a doll could mean about the doll. She a pal of mine could mean he doesn't want to hurt her.
I thought it was just the father wrote coraline a song "oh my twitchy witchy girl.." and then in the other world where everything is better he wrote her a better song with piano and all that jazz.
I think “she’s a pal of mine.” Is true because when the beldam is controling him on the grasshopper tractor thing he keeps on apollogizing like he dosen’t want to do this. So when he says “she’s a pal of mine” hes saying that you are my friend i dont want to hurt you , but thats just a theory 🥰✨💖🌸
Rewatched since I first watched this one before. The lyrics after seeing the other theories is creepier than ever. Coraline is always being watched and will give the Beldam a feast while thinking she's having a great time. Holy damn, Coraline!
The Fangirl did you know there's a Coraline DS game and Wii game? In the wii game, in the Other World there are rats that will attack you and later in the real world Coraline goes inside of the Barn and the rats are inside the barn, Maybe she's in the limbo world. And in the DS game I couldn't find any evidence for the limbo world but they do give the triangle stone a name "100 Year Old Candy" and when she starts the game she goes over the mirror and the candy is glowing and the ghost children tell her that the candy has powers and that it'll help Coraline find the eyes. And I rember you said you were confused why they called the shift knob, ring, and ball; an eye when the ghost children said thanks for finding my eyes. But the DS game it makes a correction and when you go into your inventory it calls them "blue eyes , green eyes etc". You should play them both on your gaming channel.
When I think of the line "she's a peach, she's a doll." For some reason I think the first line is for Coraline, and the second line is to warn her about the Beldam being able to see her through the doll. I know its a stretch, but I found this interesting to think about.
I like to think that the end part”our eyes will be on coraline” is referring to the button eyes and scince they have button eyes, it would be there eyes and they want to put the buttons on coralines eyes so they are saying our eyes (the button eyes) will be on coraline as stated in the movie that they want to put buttons on her eyes (and I just said that twice)
so I just watched coraline for the first time 2 days ago, I didn’t think anything if it. now, after I watched it I was freaking out I went right to my phone to start researching things. I found your videos and I’ve literally been watching these videos for the last two days! I love you videos, keep doing what your doing because it really helps crazy movie people like me! you are so getting a new subscriber today!!!!!!!!
My theory: She’s a peach: Coraline is food to the Beldam She’s a doll: Coraline is something for the Beldam to play with (like a cat plays with its food before eating it) She’s a pal of mine: The Beldam loves Coraline I go mainly by book here. The cat, in the book, says that the Beldam loves games. And that she wants something to love. Coraline herself says that it’s true that the Beldam loves her, only that it’s not a mother’s love. It’s “like a miser loves money or a dragon loves its gold”.
I totally agreed to this why is the beldame playing with her food and also playing cat and mouse with Coraline is she going to eat her or not or leave her trapped in limbo world
Like I haven't seen many Coraline videos, besides yours (and I think I'm missing a few) so idk if this has been said yet. I watched Coraline last night and after Coraline and her mom come back from shopping, the mom goes into town to buy food (because there's no food for lunch) and Coraline goes into the other world. When she gets there she finds the note saying that she should meet Ms. Forcible and Spink for lunch, and then proceeds to walk to their apt. However, when she gets outside the sky is completely dark (except for the stars ) even though it is lunchtime 🤔 Sounds familiar, like what Wybie said about the bottom of the well.
What if when the dad says she is a doll he means that the end of the movie when she supposably goes"home"then it's all just like a film in her brain while she is a puppet for the beldam next victim, like the ghost kids!!!!😨😱😱
The Fangirl thank you! Usually I don’t watch movie theories because I just can’t find a channel that doesn’t just make up anything for clickbait, but yours are really good!
"She's as cute as a *button in the eyes* of anyone whos ever laid their eyes on coraline." This line is a direct warning of how they want to put buttons on her eyes
She's a Peach: the Other Mother wants to eat her. She's a Doll: Coraline is being manipulated and used like a toy in this case a doll. She's a Pal of Mine: The Other Father doesn't want to harm her. She's as Cute as a Button in the Eyes of everyone who ever laid their eyes on Coraline: Self explanatory, but could also imply that the Other Mother was watching Coraline for a long time. When she comes around exploring, Mom and I will never ever make it boring: The Other Mother will continue to lure her into the other world Our eyes will be on Coraline: Either the other Mother will always be watching or at some point in time she will sew buttons onto Coraline's eyes.
Can you do a video on Ursula’s back story from the little mermaid. I remember her saying this line in the movie about “when I was in the palace” and it really made me curious especially after the movie Maleficent came out and I put more thought into villains having stories as well and Ursula may not have been as bad as I thought as a kid. Even as she sang Poor unfortunate souls she never lied about what would happen, and Ariel knew full well what would happen if she failed and she was set up to fail. maybe Ursula did the whole thing to get back at Triton for stuff before Ariel was born? So that’s my idea. Thanks, love your videos.
When it says she's a doll, it relates to the doll that watches her in the real world and maybe they are controlling her through that doll or something like that
Do you ever notice how the other father says She’s a PEACH She’s a DOLL Dose this mean the other mother has made a Other Coraline out of a peach? Because She’s already made into a doll.
Your missing the point. When he sings "Cute as a button in the eyes of everyone whos ever seen coraline." Cut some words and youll get. "Button in the eyes" Hes warning her of the future.
Soooo the Beldam kills the child and leaves their soul behind in a doll, symbolizing that they need to be saved? what if the doll is a trap to make others(neighbors, loved ones, etc.) travel into the other world to save the child, giving the Beldam more people to sew buttons on and keep them there forever?
Aww, thanks Callum! My other channels are still a work-in-progress, but, someday they might be up to par. Thanks for being here (and over on the other channels too!).
I didn't miss the doll part and even rewound it cuz it gave me the creeps so bad. I'm not exactly sure why but I really like your theory... there had to be a reason the Beldam made them. She didn't seem to be about wasting her energy.
what i think it means when it says our eyes will be on coraline is that since in the other world everyone has button eyes, coraline will be just like them when she gets button eyes, so there (button) eyes will be on coraline.
"She's as cute as a BUTTON In the EYES of everyone" I haven't even watched the vid yet, and if you pointed it out, then I guess i look like a thief now
Maybe the beldam feeds of the memories of the kids , and that's why the ghost kid don't remember their parents. And by taking away their memories they wouldn't have a reason to leave and them haveing buttons sewn into their could be a way to make not question them being her and when they died they remembered . I don't know how but 🤷♀️ just an idea . Also love your videos 😍 so cool
One thing that supports that people other than the Beldam are puppets comes from the graphic novel; Coraline asks her other father if she (the beldam) is making him attack her. He confirms it and then begins to deteriorate after becoming self aware, so maybe the beldam gave people in the other world enough freedom to move and think relatively freely, but she can still control them like a puppeteer
What if “She’s a doll” is clue!!!!!!!! She’s switching between the doll and not until in the real world all thats left of coralline is...well the doll!!! Her doll is like stealing her soul or replacing her without her knowing
I rewatched the movie after watching these theories but one thing I noticed that strongly supports your claim that she never left the other world is when she goes to sleep to return home. The first night after visiting she goes to sleep in the other world but wakes up in the real one. But the night she freaks out after being asked about buttons, she goes to sleep but doesn’t return. Is this proof that coralline never returned in the first place but the beldam just changed the environment while she slept to keep up her sense of reality to trick her? (Please like this comment so fangirl will see it! Thanks!)
OMG ONE OF YOUR OTHER THEORYS ARE TRUE! IT DAYS WHEN SHE COMES EXPLORING THEYLL NEVER MAKE IT BORING that means they knew she would explore and eventually find the blank spot in the other world confirming that they wanted her to feel like she's winnibg
Hey I'm re-watching Coraline and I noticed in the beginning when she goes out exploring with her dowsing rod and she comes upon the well, the well is surrounded by a fairy ring. In your Coraline conversations with Allmonsters GoToSpace, he talks about the Beldam being a changeling which is a type of fairy. Fairy rings, as far as lore goes, are the only way to see fairies and are like portals to their world. Also according to fairy ring rules whenever you go into a fairy ring you should have someone standing outside to pull you out in the event a changeling tries to abduct you. I don't know if this is at all relevant but I thought it was worth sharing.
Omg yes!!! New Coraline vid! I absolutely LOVE your vids!! I know you’ve mentioned it before, but it truly would be AWESOME if you could collab with the theorizor❤️
one theory, that I have, is that the ghost children aren't real. I think this because, when Coraline refused the buttons. The other mother, then wanted a way to keep her there, in order to have her soul.... so when she threw Coraline in the mirror with the ghost kids, this gave her time to set up a way to keep Coraline there. So, when the ghost kids told her their story, and how they accepted the buttons, and she ate their souls. This made her .ore scared of her, and made her want to do something. so when Wybee, who may also be controlled by the other mother to keep her distracted... cause she tells him what to do. when he takes Coraline out of the mirror, the kids are gone immediately when he comes in. this might state that THEY WERE NEVER THERE.... and that the other mother pit them there to make her scared. And when the other mother and her were in the kitchen, she knew that Coraline would want to play a game......so she made the button on the moon, and that she didn't think Coraline would so it. but if she did, she had enough time to make a plan. another theory, is that when. you go through the door, it isn't real, you just see what you want your life to be, and enjoy yourself......
After coraline says she's going to bed after she's offered the buttons , the other mother says "it's all made up " it's at 1:08 on movie clips , does she mean Coraline's bed or the other world?p.s. I made it to the end😊
"Our eyes will be on Coraline" literally means that they will put *their eyes* (aka buttons) on Coraline's face.
MIND=BLOWN
JoJo or there just always watching her
JoJo HOLY F CKING SH T
I took it as they are just watching her through the little me doll
Yo! The fake wybie pulled out her out of the room with the ghost children because they were going to give her good info to stop her! And how would wybie pull her out I thought the bedlam could only do it
They mean they are watching her through the doll but yeah it can mean that to
Okay I think it’s actually that the other father is trying to warn her about the beldam. the piano is controlled by the beldam and would probably hurt him or stop him from explicitly warning coraline so he’s trying to tell her through the lyrics of the song
also when he calls her a pal it shows he cares and wants to help. Also he helps her get the eye
And when he's evil when she's looking for the first eye you can hear the other father say in a distorted voice: sorry......
This is true, as in the garden chase scene, he says lines such as "Don't wanna hurt you," And "Mother's Making Me." And at the end, when the other father basically saves Coraline, he hands her the eye of the ghost child. And I've actually believed this theory for a long time.
Wooooooooah
She’s as cute as a button in the eyes... what if that was a warning that the beldam wanted to put buttons on her eyes
By calling her a doll it's possible he's saying that they can control her, she's easily manipulated and they can store her in the Pink Palace Limbo World. Like putting a doll on the second floor of a house.
Ichi true
No I think the “She” he’s referring to is the other mother. “She’s a doll,” saying that the other mother is the doll watching Coraline.
Ichi true
Klaus O'Shaunacey I also took the lyric Our eyes will be on Coraline as referring to the doll and they watch her everyday life through it.
Ichi BUT THE OTHER FATHER HELPED HER REMEMBER? MAYBE IN A GOOD WAY?
I think "she's a doll" means that they 're playing with Coraline in the other world ,she is being manipulated by the other mother like a puppet
No, he was talking about the coraline doll, he was warning her about it
stinkhole 13 yes true that
i always thought that lyric was about the doll that the beldam sent her..
While the lyrics of the song can be creepy with foreshadowing, I also saw it as a way for the Other Father to tell Coraline that he was an ally. "She's a pal of mine" as in the Other Father's friend, and not the Other Mother's. He is more conscious than the other puppets that the Other Mother controls and so, I believe that he was warning her of the dangers.
KuroMokoChan whybe I thinks that his name also tried to help her and free her but she had to go back
Yeah exactly, it confuses me that some people think all of them in the other world are controlled by the Beldam even though the other father warns her multiple times and Wybie has emotions of his own. It seems like the Beldam doesn’t have full control of them that’s why the piano has hands and she made sure Wybie couldn’t speak. While also sewing a smile into his face in a failed attempt to convince Caroline that things were okay
To all the comments, she puts "Soul sand" into the characters and the more you give the more free will they have, as when the cat bite the "mouse" little sand comes out, which is why it follows every command.
the wybie puppet was also more conscious, and I like to think that the beldam took a past child's soul and made wybie so future kids would have someone closer to their age to interact and possibly make them feel safer and comfortable
Yess
it's astonishing how intricate this story is. I don't think a sequel would ever be as good as the original, but it would certainly give us more information to go off of
She’s as cute as a “Button in the eyes”.Does that not ring a bell?
What about“our eyes will be on Coraline” in the end... but I do see where you’re going.
this some dark stuff from a cheerful tune
Right? That's probably why I never paid much attention to it!
Well it was written by They Might be Giants so,,
The Fangirl. Read the whole thing it is very worth it I promise this is also my opinion so with that hope you enjoy. So first remember IT or Penny Wise is an alien from the universe called the Macroverse could the Beldam have came with him or in the same way she cold be a related, older, or even younger ancestor/species the Beldam could have had the power to create a pocket universe or 2 as an upstairs and down stairs I think just maybe because the world was killing her somehow she had to make this universe into a makeshift pocket universe/ energy collector she's not comepletly thriving on kids just partially for food from their love and then stores their sole in a separate compartment such as a dark room that does not need much energy such as the room that was used for coralines time out spot the plan was to use the eyes to power a place of the world like the garden the circus or a theater soon enough the land would be big enough to be an entire other universe or the energy for creating one by putting the world so close together making a reaction creating one where IT and the Beldam can live and repopulate by basically making another big band in that pocket universe with the aunt to contain so much or shoving into a small space. Option 2 seems most logical because you see the soles in the containment area both eyes are missing you need 4 eyes. But why not just take 2 kids you ask 4 eyes of different bloodlines if Caroline is in that basement when the Beldam is descised as her mother she is already gone and at the last battle between them what do we see the world literally contracting into the small space that will be all soon creating a big bang. I really hope you didn't get bored sorry for the graphic novel I made you read please respond for part 2 of my ideas if you want to read more
omg 95 likes
Susan Sue isn't it usually?😜
The 'she's a doll' part could be the other father trying to tell coraline that she is going to be stuck there, calling her a doll. Interesting wording for a child in a world where EVERYONE ELSE look like a doll
I think you should do a theory on why Dr. Frankenstein is so controlling of Sally and why he would always say, "You're not ready." This is song is always stuck in my head by the way.
I always thought he somewhat lusts for her and doesn’t want her to leave him..also it’s creepy how he makes a wife who looks exactly like him
Talented Nerdy Girl 2001 *Finklestein
I have a theory that he created sally to be his slave
Maybe when he said “she’s a pal of mine” that means that “you can trust me, I don’t wanna hurt you” but in a subtle way. And has anyone noticed that once the bedlam started “fading back to her normal self” so did everything else? I believe the bedlam could have just pushes her self to make everything to look amazing. Which I believe supports Fangirls theory, of scaring Coraline!
I watched the movie again last night and I noticed that the sisters who live downstairs in the otherworld originally have white buttons as eyes. Then when they shed their outer layer their new eyes are black buttons. Is there any significance to this in regards to eye color?
Also, in the scene where Coraline decides to play that game regarding finding the eyes of the ghost children, the Beldam never specifies that Coraline is on a timer. This would mean Coraline would have effectively unlimited time. Could this mean that the button on the moon was not a timer but was instead an indicator of how many eye Coraline has? Could it also be that the Beldam was trying to trick Coraline into thinking she had a time limit since she forgot to impose one?
Another thing. In the scene where it is really foggy(may be getting the scene slightly mixed up) and Coraline is talking to Wybie regarding the other world, the cat is out of view of Coraline and glances angrily at the doll inside her room. If the cat was working with the Beldam and Coraline was already trapped in the other world why would he do this?
Laff700 idk
Laff700 Maybe he changed his mind somehow and the bedlam is no longer controlling him or never even was .
Your second point is actually ingenious! Like wow it's just awesome
in the movie the other mother says that she has until the moon thing happens
She’s as cute as
“A button in the eyes”
Of everyone etc.
He is warning her!!
Possible explanation for the She's a Doll line- this is a bit of a stretch, but what if another reason the beldam wanted to sew in buttons into Coraline's eyes was because it would create some kind of connection to the doll in which the beldam could actually control Coraline's movements? (Like a voodoo doll). So in essence, she would become the doll. Idk it just kind of popped into my head and I thought I'd share.
Also, another theory could be that she needed Coraline's eyes so that she will become the doll needed to spy on the next child. Someone else theorized that the other mother can't change the real world. But can take things via the mice and change it.
Imagine being her parents and coming home from work or the store and not seeing your daughter.
You just notice a doll that looks like her and she goes missing for years.
That must be a nightmare for every parent.
You should definitely look into the lyrics of the song that Miss Spink and Miss Forcible sing. The song is the one in the theatre, some lyrics such as: I might steal your weak heart away and And hope to lead sailors astray. Seem to be a reference to what the other mother is doing with children? This whole song seems like it's either giving us more subtle insight on the other mother or maybe some sort of backstory for the two ladies. If you listen to the song with different context it definitely feels like there is something there. Anyways, I love your videos! Keep up the good work :)
I think the other Farther is a slave and you said that the other mother could be watching them he is trying to warn her what would happen without the other mother knowing. And to support my idea at the part where Corriline is going down stairs looking for the other mother he said "can't talk mother would here" proves that the other dad is scared of her. If that doesn't convince you this will, before the other dad's death he says " so sorry so sorry mother making me do this" and he gives her the eye at the end. What do you think
Learn how to spell first
@@skunkyclouds god damn learn how to be less damn nosy
@@e.martinz5945 shut up.
@@e.martinz5945 dude this person is giving their perspectiveand theorty and its very interesting, so just appreciate it. if younhave nothing nice to say then dont say anything at alk
oh but didn't the other mother have full control of the other world? so maybe she was controlling the other father so help coraline to give her a false sense of security
Omg! I was thinking there was something with this song! Your theories are always so amazing! But I really gotta request the movie Halloweentown (again). I really think you can find some interesting things in that film. Anyways, you’re awesome!
Aww, thank you. .
Hi fan girl
Actually I know by Coraline maybe the next victim in this by keeping her trapped like the ghost kids with button eyes and never returning home
“Shes as cute as *a button in the eyes* of everyone who ever laid there eyes on Coraline!” Hes litterally saying “a button in the eyes” MIND BLOWN
Maybe the line: "Our eyes will be on Coraline" means that if she accepts the button eyes she will become a puppet like everyone in the other world (except for the Beldam 😮)
Oooh, this is true too!
Olga Sot I thought of a different thing with this line where the button eyes which are the eyes everyone has in the other world will be on her meaning she will have button eyes because it is technically their eyes. My thought is kinda similar to yours
HE'S SAYING THAT SHE'S A DOLL, SHE IS LITERALLY A DOLL, THEY MADE A DOLL OF HER!
Clicked as fast as possible again, this time I managed not to scream. XD
You remembered Rule #1! Good job!
You know I'm so lucky you keep replying to me. I love your channel so much, and I hope to have a great channel like yours one day, thank you for replying to me and keeping my hopes up.
xxx
What’s rule #2
she's a doll could mean *you are now my puppet...* mainly because voodoo dolls are used for control, so he's saying *you too will be controlled for the next kid*
I have just been binge watching these videos. Great Job!!
Well thank you for being here and binging!
Same
I think your main theory about the limbo pink Palace and how coraline never really left is very interesting. I think I have something to add on to it though. Coraline did get rid of the key, yes. But as we've seen, the Bedlam still has many more.
Which comes to my conclusion that that Bedlam could lure Coraline back to her lair any time she pleases. After all, it's not the real world, so nothing is really stopping her right?
Klashin' KixYT i don't think there's really a need to lure her back though
Klashin' KixYT I don't think the beldam would lure her back because she can feed off of coraline easier when coraline believes that she's in the real world. Coraline loves her "real" mother more than the other mother, so if coraline thinks she's around her real mother, she will automatically give the beldam more love to feed off. Therefore giving the beldam no reason to lure her back into the lair
The tunnels don't matter, remember the first time coraline went through to the other mothers world? Remember when she went to sleep and then woke up somehow back in her world?.. Well she didn't.
Actually the Well is another portal to the other world I believe
❤️❤️❤️love your videos
Same!
Hey the fangirl can you please make a theory on the Book of Life theory on la muerte and xibalba story and background please I like to see that on your channel they're pretty cool for a Halloween thing make it there on that one cuz I love that one with Coraline or do one on Once Upon a Time theory the ABC show
"She's as cute as a *button* in the *eyes* of everyone who has ever laid their *eyes* on *CORALINE*
I have had an intense infatuation with Coralline since it came out when I was eight years old. I LOVE your whole playlist its just what I needed!
I think when the other father said "our eyes will be on coraline" maybe it means that they want the button eyes witch are there eyes so that line could mean putting the buttons on the eyes. I don't know if you understand that but it is hard to explain
She's a peach could mean that the other mother wants to eat her, so he's hinting at that, she's a doll could mean about the doll. She a pal of mine could mean he doesn't want to hurt her.
I thought it was just the father wrote coraline a song "oh my twitchy witchy girl.." and then in the other world where everything is better he wrote her a better song with piano and all that jazz.
I think “she’s a pal of mine.” Is true because when the beldam is controling him on the grasshopper tractor thing he keeps on apollogizing like he dosen’t want to do this. So when he says “she’s a pal of mine” hes saying that you are my friend i dont want to hurt you , but thats just a theory 🥰✨💖🌸
Rewatched since I first watched this one before. The lyrics after seeing the other theories is creepier than ever. Coraline is always being watched and will give the Beldam a feast while thinking she's having a great time. Holy damn, Coraline!
The Fangirl did you know there's a Coraline DS game and Wii game? In the wii game, in the Other World there are rats that will attack you and later in the real world Coraline goes inside of the Barn and the rats are inside the barn, Maybe she's in the limbo world. And in the DS game I couldn't find any evidence for the limbo world but they do give the triangle stone a name "100 Year Old Candy" and when she starts the game she goes over the mirror and the candy is glowing and the ghost children tell her that the candy has powers and that it'll help Coraline find the eyes. And I rember you said you were confused why they called the shift knob, ring, and ball; an eye when the ghost children said thanks for finding my eyes. But the DS game it makes a correction and when you go into your inventory it calls them "blue eyes , green eyes etc". You should play them both on your gaming channel.
We started the PS2 Coraline game and then we moved and I still haven't unearthed my PS2 since then. EVENTUALLY we will get back to it though.
i was gonna go to sleep and then i saw that you uploaded a new video
here i am
Oh no, don't not sleep! Go rest!
When I think of the line "she's a peach, she's a doll." For some reason I think the first line is for Coraline, and the second line is to warn her about the Beldam being able to see her through the doll. I know its a stretch, but I found this interesting to think about.
I like to think that the end part”our eyes will be on coraline” is referring to the button eyes and scince they have button eyes, it would be there eyes and they want to put the buttons on coralines eyes so they are saying our eyes (the button eyes) will be on coraline as stated in the movie that they want to put buttons on her eyes (and I just said that twice)
This is amazing!!!!!!!
so I just watched coraline for the first time 2 days ago, I didn’t think anything if it. now, after I watched it I was freaking out I went right to my phone to start researching things. I found your videos and I’ve literally been watching these videos for the last two days! I love you videos, keep doing what your doing because it really helps crazy movie people like me! you are so getting a new subscriber today!!!!!!!!
“Our eyes will be on coraline”
The eyes of the other people (aka the buttons) will be on coraline
My theory:
She’s a peach: Coraline is food to the Beldam
She’s a doll: Coraline is something for the Beldam to play with (like a cat plays with its food before eating it)
She’s a pal of mine: The Beldam loves Coraline
I go mainly by book here. The cat, in the book, says that the Beldam loves games. And that she wants something to love. Coraline herself says that it’s true that the Beldam loves her, only that it’s not a mother’s love. It’s “like a miser loves money or a dragon loves its gold”.
Britney Hill It’s the name for what The other mother is. It’s what she’s referred to in the book by the ghost children.
I totally agreed to this why is the beldame playing with her food and also playing cat and mouse with Coraline is she going to eat her or not or leave her trapped in limbo world
Like I haven't seen many Coraline videos, besides yours (and I think I'm missing a few) so idk if this has been said yet. I watched Coraline last night and after Coraline and her mom come back from shopping, the mom goes into town to buy food (because there's no food for lunch) and Coraline goes into the other world. When she gets there she finds the note saying that she should meet Ms. Forcible and Spink for lunch, and then proceeds to walk to their apt. However, when she gets outside the sky is completely dark (except for the stars ) even though it is lunchtime 🤔
Sounds familiar, like what Wybie said about the bottom of the well.
I'm new on this channel and I love it! Thank you for making such awesome videos!
Thank you for being here!
What if when the dad says she is a doll he means that the end of the movie when she supposably goes"home"then it's all just like a film in her brain while she is a puppet for the beldam next victim, like the ghost kids!!!!😨😱😱
Hi I watched one video of this and now I’m hooked! I watched this movie yesterday before a Halloween party and I see how much I missed!
Well, welcome to the fanily Kyla!
The Fangirl thank you! Usually I don’t watch movie theories because I just can’t find a channel that doesn’t just make up anything for clickbait, but yours are really good!
Kyla Klein cute cat profile pic
"She's as cute as a *button in the eyes* of anyone whos ever laid their eyes on coraline."
This line is a direct warning of how they want to put buttons on her eyes
He did his best to warn her.
A doll is something that you play with. You control it.
She's a Peach: the Other Mother wants to eat her.
She's a Doll: Coraline is being manipulated and used like a toy in this case a doll.
She's a Pal of Mine: The Other Father doesn't want to harm her.
She's as Cute as a Button in the Eyes of everyone who ever laid their eyes on Coraline: Self explanatory, but could also imply that the Other Mother was watching Coraline for a long time.
When she comes around exploring, Mom and I will never ever make it boring: The Other Mother will continue to lure her into the other world
Our eyes will be on Coraline: Either the other Mother will always be watching or at some point in time she will sew buttons onto Coraline's eyes.
Omg I know this song off by heart and whenever I hear it I sing along lmao
Can you do a video on Ursula’s back story from the little mermaid. I remember her saying this line in the movie about “when I was in the palace” and it really made me curious especially after the movie Maleficent came out and I put more thought into villains having stories as well and Ursula may not have been as bad as I thought as a kid. Even as she sang Poor unfortunate souls she never lied about what would happen, and Ariel knew full well what would happen if she failed and she was set up to fail. maybe Ursula did the whole thing to get back at Triton for stuff before Ariel was born? So that’s my idea. Thanks, love your videos.
Raven Smith theres is a book about this
Your Theory's make sense👍
Abigail Hernandez they do.
I love all your videos so much!! Really makes me think when I'm re-watching certain movies/shows.
Can I just say I love you, you genuinely make my day with these videos xxx
When it says she's a doll, it relates to the doll that watches her in the real world and maybe they are controlling her through that doll or something like that
i totally didn’t hum the song the whole time i was watching this..
In his song it says you’re pal of mine and pals are friends! Friends stick together so he’s stuck in the other world!
If Coraline actually realised the lyrics, i think the movie would be shorter!! Great video though!!!
Do you ever notice how the other father says She’s a PEACH She’s a DOLL Dose this mean the other mother has made a Other Coraline out of a peach? Because She’s already made into a doll.
Your missing the point. When he sings "Cute as a button in the eyes of everyone whos ever seen coraline."
Cut some words and youll get.
"Button in the eyes"
Hes warning her of the future.
The Peach means that they gonna eather
Soooo the Beldam kills the child and leaves their soul behind in a doll, symbolizing that they need to be saved? what if the doll is a trap to make others(neighbors, loved ones, etc.) travel into the other world to save the child, giving the Beldam more people to sew buttons on and keep them there forever?
The doll one is warning her about beldam, the button one is warning her again.
Another note is when he says “this piano plays me” is him hinting that he’s a puppet of the other mother
Really love your video. People need to realise you have two more channels which are amazing 😘
Aww, thanks Callum! My other channels are still a work-in-progress, but, someday they might be up to par. Thanks for being here (and over on the other channels too!).
The Fangirl it's okay. Keep up with the Coraline vids
Ive been waiting for this. This part is the favourite part of the movie
I didn't miss the doll part and even rewound it cuz it gave me the creeps so bad. I'm not exactly sure why but I really like your theory... there had to be a reason the Beldam made them. She didn't seem to be about wasting her energy.
I love this movie the song is forever stuck in my head
The line “our eyes will be on coralline” could also mean as in their eyes the buttons will be on her eyes.
what i think it means when it says our eyes will be on coraline is that since in the other world everyone has button eyes, coraline will be just like them when she gets button eyes, so there (button) eyes will be on coraline.
i love your voice
Thank you
3 Things
1. I made it to the end
2. Can you do some series of unfortunate events theories?
3. Great vid, Love your channel!
"She's as cute as a BUTTON
In the EYES of everyone"
I haven't even watched the vid yet, and if you pointed it out, then I guess i look like a thief now
Maybe the beldam feeds of the memories of the kids , and that's why the ghost kid don't remember their parents. And by taking away their memories they wouldn't have a reason to leave and them haveing buttons sewn into their could be a way to make not question them being her and when they died they remembered . I don't know how but 🤷♀️ just an idea . Also love your videos 😍 so cool
One thing that supports that people other than the Beldam are puppets comes from the graphic novel; Coraline asks her other father if she (the beldam) is making him attack her. He confirms it and then begins to deteriorate after becoming self aware, so maybe the beldam gave people in the other world enough freedom to move and think relatively freely, but she can still control them like a puppeteer
I really love your videos so much
Thank you Karron!
I was waiting for this, you are awesome
What if “She’s a doll” is clue!!!!!!!! She’s switching between the doll and not until in the real world all thats left of coralline is...well the doll!!! Her doll is like stealing her soul or replacing her without her knowing
I love all of your videos!! Just watched all of the Coraline's AMAZING!!!!!!
I live for these 😂
Oh,there're so many questions about this movie!Its really so mysterious and i never get tired of digging deeper
I rewatched the movie after watching these theories but one thing I noticed that strongly supports your claim that she never left the other world is when she goes to sleep to return home. The first night after visiting she goes to sleep in the other world but wakes up in the real one. But the night she freaks out after being asked about buttons, she goes to sleep but doesn’t return. Is this proof that coralline never returned in the first place but the beldam just changed the environment while she slept to keep up her sense of reality to trick her? (Please like this comment so fangirl will see it! Thanks!)
Always make it til the end:)
Keep up the awesome work:)
You are amazing! Your videos are so great! I love you so much!
OMG ONE OF YOUR OTHER THEORYS ARE TRUE! IT DAYS WHEN SHE COMES EXPLORING THEYLL NEVER MAKE IT BORING that means they knew she would explore and eventually find the blank spot in the other world confirming that they wanted her to feel like she's winnibg
Hey I'm re-watching Coraline and I noticed in the beginning when she goes out exploring with her dowsing rod and she comes upon the well, the well is surrounded by a fairy ring. In your Coraline conversations with Allmonsters GoToSpace, he talks about the Beldam being a changeling which is a type of fairy. Fairy rings, as far as lore goes, are the only way to see fairies and are like portals to their world. Also according to fairy ring rules whenever you go into a fairy ring you should have someone standing outside to pull you out in the event a changeling tries to abduct you. I don't know if this is at all relevant but I thought it was worth sharing.
I like to think that "our eyes will be on Coraline" is his way of telling her that they will give her their button eyes.
He really cared for her
I think that when he said our eyes are on coraline could also be foreshadowing how they offer her button eyes later on in the movie
Omg yes!!! New Coraline vid! I absolutely LOVE your vids!! I know you’ve mentioned it before, but it truly would be AWESOME if you could collab with the theorizor❤️
For that one, the ball is in his court. Right now it’s not his thing.
I think Wybi andCoraline have a crush on each other and when they grow up i think they are going to get married and have kids.
years, YEARS, and no one knows the entire story, thts whats so amazing about ccoraline
love ur videos! i always still till the end of ur vidoes!
Great video!!!! Thank you for all the coriline!!!!!! You make me love this movie even more!!!!!!!!
one theory, that I have, is that the ghost children aren't real. I think this because, when Coraline refused the buttons. The other mother, then wanted a way to keep her there, in order to have her soul....
so when she threw Coraline in the mirror with the ghost kids, this gave her time to set up a way to keep Coraline there. So, when the ghost kids told her their story, and how they accepted the buttons, and she ate their souls. This made her .ore scared of her, and made her want to do something.
so when Wybee, who may also be controlled by the other mother to keep her distracted... cause she tells him what to do. when he takes Coraline out of the mirror, the kids are gone immediately when he comes in. this might state that THEY WERE NEVER THERE.... and that the other mother pit them there to make her scared. And when the other mother and her were in the kitchen, she knew that Coraline would want to play a game......so she made the button on the moon, and that she didn't think Coraline would so it. but if she did, she had enough time to make a plan.
another theory, is that when. you go through the door, it isn't real, you just see what you want your life to be, and enjoy yourself......
I adore this theory and your channel great theory like always !
Yay a new video! Thanks!
Ahh this channel is amazing!
Aww thank you!
It's still my jam though
After coraline says she's going to bed after she's offered the buttons , the other mother says "it's all made up " it's at 1:08 on movie clips , does she mean Coraline's bed or the other world?p.s. I made it to the end😊
Ooooh, maybe it has a double meaning!