It is finally revealed which contest will play the role of Nancy in Cameron Mackintosh's production of Oliver! as the results from the public vote are announced.
Amy: Went in to be in Sister Act and Heathers in the West end, also went viral on twitter with an original song, overcame cancer and PTSD Cleo: idk haven’t heard from her since Tara: Is a coach as part of the national selection for Wales in Jr Eurovision, both winners were coached by her Francesca: Had initial success in theatre, but hasn’t been seen in recent years Keisha: Same as Cleo Sarah: Been in and out of Les Miz for several years, currently dance captain Ashley: Had a couple of jobs in U.K. tours Niamh: Featured in several west end shows including Mamma Mia and Love Never Dies Rachel: Where do I start: We Will Rock You, Wicked and Come From Away and several other roles on the West End and Broadway Samantha: Most iconic of the modern Eponines on stage and screen, eventually played Nancy in tour, originated leading roles in Amelie and Pretty Woman, soon to play Elsa in Frozen Jessie: Started our in theatre but has gone into the film industry, most recent success being Wild Rose Jodie: Has had a number of theatre roles but imo had become more of a TV personality
I might be a Nancy traditionalist but I'm so glad that Jodie won. The audience falls in love with Nancy because of her heart- not because of her rawness or grit. And you need them to fall in love with her or her death does not have the emotional payoff it should. The 2009 cast recording is my favorite because of the amazing charisma Jodie has in the role.
I saw Jodie live as Nancy. She was good, but I didn't fall in love with her. So her death didn't break my heart. Jodie was wonderful in the finale, but when it comes to the Oliver material, I honestly believe Jessie gave the more emotional, believable performance.
@@jaycievictory8461 I saw Jodie live as Nancy in Oliver at the Theatre Royal Drury Lane in London on Saturday 5th September in 2009 in the matinee afternoon performance and she was good
Both Jessie and Jodie have made wonderful careers from the show , Jessie went on to star in film and television while Jodie has had so many leading roles in what she loves most , the theatre , Both are hugh winners .
Although I agree that Jodie was the better fit for this particular part, Jessie's performance of "As Long As He Needs Me" just blew me away - so emotionally connected, so believable, she had me in tears by the end!😍😍
I'm sorry but Jessie BLEW Jodie out of the water there. She embodied the desperation, heartbreak and tragedy of Nancy mistakenly standing by her man. Jodie has a great voice but I didn't feel light and shade in that performance. I didn't feel her feeling the words. Based on those performances, Jessie should have won.
Anyone else notice how pissed off Andrew, Cameron and Barry look when their favourite didn’t win? Oof those glares and forced smiling/clapping, that’s British for “absolutely livid but we’re on TV so need to be polite” 😬😂
@@jorgizoran4340 Jodie wins at 25:27, Andrew’s reaction at 26:03, Cameron smiles the most of the three but compare him and Barry to John and Denise at 26:53 and you’ll see who is genuinely happy...
@@kastanymusica I'd say Andrew was legit angry and hiding it. Cameron was more balanced, showing happiness for Jodie while not rubbing it in Jessie's face. Barry was probably disappointed but we don't get many shots of him after the announcement, it could be possible being an overweight,old man with the final happening late, he was just tired.
I think Jodie did a great job as Nancy; Jessie turned down the opportunity to understudy Nancy to do other theater, but it’s possible that the big overall winner was 3rd place Samantha Barks who played Nancy in the UK touring company before going on to play Éponine in Les Miserables, first at the Queens Theater in London, then at the 25th Anniversary Concert and finally in the 2012 movie.
Katey parkinson Rachel is a world class performer, un matched in many way. Samantha, too has been fabulous in everything she has done, a perfect Eponine.
Samantha has had the biggest musical career no doubt. She is the definitive Eponine . But Jessie decided she wanted to be more than just a singer. She wanted to be an actress, and my goodness me she is one hell of an actress. Brilliant in everything she does. Of course she is also a fantastic singer ! IMO Super stardom awaits her
Keith Bate Jesse’s got the resemblance of Nicole Kidman and deserved most to be Nancy coz’ she had that X factor in interpretation of moving emotions in her!!! A good day to y’all!
When Jodie started singing at the end "I won't betray his trust though people say I must" felt like a big f you to ALW because it was so obvious he didn't want Jodie to win... the way she sang it with so much more power than earlier which is something he said she didn't have... it was a definite "f you, I told you I could do it" moment
They closed the voting lines 5 seconds after Jessie's performance,and before the panel endorsed Jessie... If it had closed later, perhaps the winner would have been different..
Andrew, Cameron and Barry clearly thought that Jessie was the perfect choice for Nancy. Andrew later said that he thought Jodie was too old for the part of Nancy as the character of Nancy. What a stand out star Jessie was become. She's one of the best actresses of her generation.
Glad you enjoyed it! And I unfortunately don't have Over the Rainbow. I've been looking for the episodes for a long time and still haven't found them, but if I ever do I will definitely upload them!
Jodie was right for the role at that time in her life, so pleased she won it. Well deserved, especially hearing 2 people keep harping on about Jessie all the time. You did great you deserved it for sure, and the public agreed. People need to remember that. Jessie you shone and from coming runner up went on to have an amazing career which is still happening for you, as it is for our Jodie. Well done both of you. 😊❤🎉 xx
Andrew ... The peoples choice... so not his... and cameron.. Im thrilled for jodie. so not happy for him self.. tossers she showed them shes a massive star.
Jessie won when she was born into such a talented Killarney family. Her mother, harpist / soprano Marina Cassidy is a regular at White House functions. They are equally talented, stable ladies who wander unmolested through Killarney. As does Michael Fassbender when back home in Killarney.
Apparently Jodi broke up with her fiance a few weeks after this aired. He claims she was just using him to win. She also didn't make him part of the celebrations after she had won.
Oh it was apparent for weeks that although he was still at the shows, things weren't good between them. And she seemed sad and stressed in a way that couldn't really be explained by the pressures of the show. The guy interviews with a big media source and gave a detailed account of his version of their first date, even talking about when they first had sex. He then proceeded to trash her in said media source, all while playing poor me... Freakin' narcissist. No wonder she broke up with him. Probably the timing was due to the amount of pressure and intensity in her life without adding a breakup, and the revenge he was likely to seek.
We’re Back To The I’d Do Anything 2008 Live Final For The Results Show Where We Find Out Who Have You Decided As Your Nancy In Cameron Macintosh’s 2009 West End Production Of Oliver
We’re Back To I’d Do Anything 2008 Live Final Results Show Where We Find Out Who Have You Decided As Your Nancy In In Cameron Macintosh’s 2009 West End Production Of Oliver
I'm in the States so ..I didn't even know about this show. Got here because of Jessie in I'm Thinking of Ending Things. Meanwhile, I've never heard of Jodie at all. Yeah, Jessie IS the winner in my book.
@@garyhutton2654 Yes, because Jessie seems to have done a lot. I saw Chernobyl ..I didn't know I was watching her until now actually but...yes, she was very good. Now I've seen her in I"m Thinking of Ending Things. Meanwhile, I have never heard of Jodie or seen her in anything. However, watching the final still now...I really love them both. Jodie may even be a better Nancy. But there is something about Jessie...I will continue to follow her career.
I don't like jodies facial expressions. Also she didn't do that well with their acting challenges on the show. And she does the hands thing. She is a good performer though
She answered the question she was asked and said it would be a great honour for her daughter to play on the West End stage. Where is the arrogance in that? It would also appear, at this stage, that little miss Irish momma got it right an Olivier award and an Oscar nomination!
Gizzy Travels, WOW you sound so bitter... A beautiful Mother who sees the true Talent in her Daughter.... Look where Jessie is Now..... Well done Jessie 1War and Peace 2 Wild Rose.. ... And lots more to come for you Jessie...Darlin... 💚So proud to be Irish 🍀💚🇮🇪
One simple trick won it for Jodie. She doesn't let her eyes leave the camera, she's singing directly at the viewer
Amy: Went in to be in Sister Act and Heathers in the West end, also went viral on twitter with an original song, overcame cancer and PTSD
Cleo: idk haven’t heard from her since
Tara: Is a coach as part of the national selection for Wales in Jr Eurovision, both winners were coached by her
Francesca: Had initial success in theatre, but hasn’t been seen in recent years
Keisha: Same as Cleo
Sarah: Been in and out of Les Miz for several years, currently dance captain
Ashley: Had a couple of jobs in U.K. tours
Niamh: Featured in several west end shows including Mamma Mia and Love Never Dies
Rachel: Where do I start: We Will Rock You, Wicked and Come From Away and several other roles on the West End and Broadway
Samantha: Most iconic of the modern Eponines on stage and screen, eventually played Nancy in tour, originated leading roles in Amelie and Pretty Woman, soon to play Elsa in Frozen
Jessie: Started our in theatre but has gone into the film industry, most recent success being Wild Rose
Jodie: Has had a number of theatre roles but imo had become more of a TV personality
Keisha has been in Matilda and School of Rock
Francesca is currently in the Tina Turner musical
Sam also stared in Cabaret, Chicago, the last five years and has her own albums and has done many concerts
Jessie's also been in the amazing mini-series Chernobyl
Jessie went to RADA
I might be a Nancy traditionalist but I'm so glad that Jodie won. The audience falls in love with Nancy because of her heart- not because of her rawness or grit. And you need them to fall in love with her or her death does not have the emotional payoff it should. The 2009 cast recording is my favorite because of the amazing charisma Jodie has in the role.
The 2009 Live London Cast Recording
I saw Jodie live as Nancy. She was good, but I didn't fall in love with her. So her death didn't break my heart. Jodie was wonderful in the finale, but when it comes to the Oliver material, I honestly believe Jessie gave the more emotional, believable performance.
@@jaycievictory8461 I saw Jodie live as Nancy in Oliver at the Theatre Royal Drury Lane in London on Saturday 5th September in 2009 in the matinee afternoon performance and she was good
@@williamfairchild7439 Yes, she was good at mine, too. Just not a massive stand-out. She seems like an absolute sweetheart, though.
@@jaycievictory8461 Oh I see
If jessie won. She might not be where she is now. Some times these things happen for the right reasons. So happy for jessie now.
What she doing now?
@@clairestevenson5192 where’ve you been? Award winning film star, musicals, TV etc check
TH-cam.
Yes Jessie is a very good actress and has done so well.
@@nickyjones7807 And, her mother is so talented and modest with it.
The same for Samantha Barks. She went on to do Les Mis on West End and the movie among other things.
Both Jessie and Jodie have made wonderful careers from the show , Jessie went on to star in film and television while Jodie has had so many leading roles in what she loves most , the theatre ,
Both are hugh winners .
Although I agree that Jodie was the better fit for this particular part, Jessie's performance of "As Long As He Needs Me" just blew me away - so emotionally connected, so believable, she had me in tears by the end!😍😍
I'm sorry but Jessie BLEW Jodie out of the water there. She embodied the desperation, heartbreak and tragedy of Nancy mistakenly standing by her man. Jodie has a great voice but I didn't feel light and shade in that performance. I didn't feel her feeling the words. Based on those performances, Jessie should have won.
Having watched to the end, she puts more light and shade and emotion into her second performance of the song at the end.
As long as eeeeeee needs me. Brilliant program bring it back bbc
as long as he needs me
@@williamfairchild7439 iam sure he does need you.
@@bethdavis1812 I mean as long as he needs me is the song from oliver
Agreed. Should have done a few more series and found a few more stars.
Anyone else notice how pissed off Andrew, Cameron and Barry look when their favourite didn’t win? Oof those glares and forced smiling/clapping, that’s British for “absolutely livid but we’re on TV so need to be polite” 😬😂
time?
@@jorgizoran4340 Jodie wins at 25:27, Andrew’s reaction at 26:03, Cameron smiles the most of the three but compare him and Barry to John and Denise at 26:53 and you’ll see who is genuinely happy...
@@kastanymusica I'd say Andrew was legit angry and hiding it. Cameron was more balanced, showing happiness for Jodie while not rubbing it in Jessie's face. Barry was probably disappointed but we don't get many shots of him after the announcement, it could be possible being an overweight,old man with the final happening late, he was just tired.
@@jorgizoran4340 Cameron was more angry than Andrew. He smile was so forced, you could tell he wasn't happy.
I think Jodie did a great job as Nancy; Jessie turned down the opportunity to understudy Nancy to do other theater, but it’s possible that the big overall winner was 3rd place Samantha Barks who played Nancy in the UK touring company before going on to play Éponine in Les Miserables, first at the Queens Theater in London, then at the 25th Anniversary Concert and finally in the 2012 movie.
Also Rachel, she's been in wicked and come from away both in the west end and broadway aswell as many other shows, tours and concerts!
Katey parkinson Rachel is a world class performer, un matched in many way.
Samantha, too has been fabulous in everything she has done, a perfect Eponine.
And then she was also in Chess, Chicago and originated the role of Viviane in the adaptation of Pretty Woman! She won!
Samantha has had the biggest musical career no doubt. She is the definitive Eponine . But Jessie decided she wanted to be more than just a singer. She wanted to be an actress, and my goodness me she is one hell of an actress. Brilliant in everything she does. Of course she is also a fantastic singer !
IMO Super stardom awaits her
Keith Bate Jesse’s got the resemblance of Nicole Kidman and deserved most to be Nancy coz’ she had that X factor in interpretation of moving emotions in her!!! A good day to y’all!
When Jodie started singing at the end "I won't betray his trust though people say I must" felt like a big f you to ALW because it was so obvious he didn't want Jodie to win... the way she sang it with so much more power than earlier which is something he said she didn't have... it was a definite "f you, I told you I could do it" moment
Jodie prenger was my favourite nancy in bbc Oliver and is now my winner 🏆
I loved Jessie
I was happy jodie won it, I went to see the play and did see her has the winner.
They were both great
They closed the voting lines 5 seconds after Jessie's performance,and before the panel endorsed Jessie...
If it had closed later, perhaps the winner would have been different..
I don't think so. ALW and Mackintosh made it clear they wanted Jessie the previous night and week.
The days when it wasn't all about the judges. Unlike today's rubbish when we all know it is.
Strange now that Samantha is now a bona fide west end star and Jessie Buckley is a wonderful actress.
So glad Jodie is in Corrie 😊
So well deserved jodie prenger I love you more I can not believe that you won the competition you have made me proud
And now she’s in Corrie! Get in Jodie!!
I am glad Jodie won, saw her in the show and got autograph very kind think she deserved it.
Andrew, Cameron and Barry clearly thought that Jessie was the perfect choice for Nancy. Andrew later said that he thought Jodie was too old for the part of Nancy as the character of Nancy. What a stand out star Jessie was become. She's one of the best actresses of her generation.
How wonderful to see this series again. Thank you so much for uploading. Do you have Over the Rainbow too?
Glad you enjoyed it! And I unfortunately don't have Over the Rainbow. I've been looking for the episodes for a long time and still haven't found them, but if I ever do I will definitely upload them!
best of luck finding them 😊❤ it's my favourite show ever, it would be awesome to see the episodes in full once more 😂
cassiopeia on hiatus there’s quite a lot of clips of over the rainbow on youtube
Alison Newbury there’s a lot of clips on TH-cam
@@gemmadisney5 but full episodes???
I am watching this show years after it aired, but I thought Jodi was the best Nancy too! It was a triumphant moment for all of us big ladies😃
Samantha, Jessie, Jodie... they've all done better than Denise Van Outen and more likely to get on telly than John Barrowman.
Jodie was right for the role at that time in her life, so pleased she won it. Well deserved, especially hearing 2 people keep harping on about Jessie all the time. You did great you deserved it for sure, and the public agreed. People need to remember that.
Jessie you shone and from coming runner up went on to have an amazing career which is still happening for you, as it is for our Jodie. Well done both of you. 😊❤🎉 xx
I've heard Jessie was upset that she didn't get the part.
Jesse was the magic Nancy..Jodie is the safe Nancy .
Jodie is one of my Nancys and will always be.
Jodie 1
Jodi IS WICKED looking no idea how she won this!!!!
Andrew ... The peoples choice... so not his... and cameron.. Im thrilled for jodie. so not happy for him self.. tossers she showed them shes a massive star.
They were both furious.
Jessie won when she was born into such a talented Killarney family. Her mother, harpist / soprano Marina Cassidy is a regular at White House functions. They are equally talented, stable ladies who wander unmolested through Killarney. As does Michael Fassbender when back home in Killarney.
Unlike Fassbender though, she hasn’t been accused of beating her partner so severely that they needed hospitalisation.
I rooted for Jodie from the start. It was terrific when she won.
NO, Jessie has so much more heart!! I can't believe people didn't see that!
I don't know, I found it hard to connect with her 🤔
Apparently Jodi broke up with her fiance a few weeks after this aired. He claims she was just using him to win. She also didn't make him part of the celebrations after she had won.
Oh it was apparent for weeks that although he was still at the shows, things weren't good between them. And she seemed sad and stressed in a way that couldn't really be explained by the pressures of the show.
The guy interviews with a big media source and gave a detailed account of his version of their first date, even talking about when they first had sex. He then proceeded to trash her in said media source, all while playing poor me... Freakin' narcissist. No wonder she broke up with him. Probably the timing was due to the amount of pressure and intensity in her life without adding a breakup, and the revenge he was likely to seek.
They all were hot : attractive & talented exactly what the Oliver’s said in 1 analysis they were fit and I would had been their age 🌈🌈♥️🧔♀️🤎🖤🧩🩷💜
Sam did well with population & Jodie is still good but there was too much stereotypes about age
We’re Back To The I’d Do Anything 2008 Live Final For The Results Show Where We Find Out Who Have You Decided As Your Nancy In Cameron Macintosh’s 2009 West End Production Of Oliver
We’re Back To I’d Do Anything 2008 Live Final Results Show Where We Find Out Who Have You Decided As Your Nancy In In Cameron Macintosh’s 2009 West End Production Of Oliver
Who's the winner now Jessie Buckley ☘️
@littlesmew no your not getting it lol 🇨🇮☘️💚
@littlesmew ironic I chatting?? Good luck ☘️🇨🇮🇨🇮🇨🇮☘️☘️
I'm in the States so ..I didn't even know about this show. Got here because of Jessie in I'm Thinking of Ending Things. Meanwhile, I've never heard of Jodie at all. Yeah, Jessie IS the winner in my book.
@@stepper914 can I I ask why Suzanne in your opinion
@@garyhutton2654 Yes, because Jessie seems to have done a lot. I saw Chernobyl ..I didn't know I was watching her until now actually but...yes, she was very good. Now I've seen her in I"m Thinking of Ending Things. Meanwhile, I have never heard of Jodie or seen her in anything. However, watching the final still now...I really love them both. Jodie may even be a better Nancy. But there is something about Jessie...I will continue to follow her career.
The camera 🎥 looking back was on Niamh a lot are they sure they made a mistake oh wait vigility
🌊📿🦕
Hello And Welcome Back To I’d Do Anything 2008 The Live Final Results
Who Have You Decided As Your Nancy? Is I’d Do Anything 2008 The Live Final Results Show
Jessie should have won.
Wtf is Adrew on about Jodies performance was so good, either of them would of been a brilliant Nancy...
I don't like jodies facial expressions. Also she didn't do that well with their acting challenges on the show. And she does the hands thing. She is a good performer though
Little miss irish momma got it wrong such arrogance.
She answered the question she was asked and said it would be a great honour for her daughter to play on the West End stage. Where is the arrogance in that?
It would also appear, at this stage, that little miss Irish momma got it right an Olivier award and an Oscar nomination!
Gizzy Travels, WOW you sound so bitter... A beautiful Mother who sees the true Talent in her Daughter.... Look where Jessie is Now..... Well done Jessie
1War and Peace
2
Wild Rose.. ...
And lots more to come for you Jessie...Darlin... 💚So proud to be Irish 🍀💚🇮🇪
Jodie 1