This is an important scene that I wish had been included, especially for adding more understanding of Claire's time travel dilemma. Should they alter history? And what are the repercussions? This show does a good job keeping a lot of balls in the air overall, considering it's only a 60 minute show. Maybe if it had a few more 90 minute episodes?
Why did they delete this scene?? Its vital to the primary question of time travel. Hell...it was the "Prime Directive" in Star Trek to NEVER get involved.
@@shadanaljanabi The obituary and the fact that her name is on the deed to Lallybroch both suggest that she is a part of history. The consequences of her actions in the past have already happened in the future, she just doesn't know what those actions are yet. Have you seen Harry Potter and the prisoner of Azkaban? It's a bit like that, but over a greater stretch of time.
Haven't u heard about the causality theory. Imagine that she kills prince Bonnie... It will be no jacobit revolution Britain wouldn't be the Britain she knows so it might be no world War so she wouldn't be separated from her husband so they wouldnt go for a second honeymoon so as a result she won't travel through the stones so at this moment she won't exist in the 18th century so the fact that she's there with Jaimie means that history hasn't changed
@@melikhajlawi4857 Ok, but then how do you explain the obituary? It hasn't happened to her yet, so why do they find proof of something she has yet to do? And remember, she tried to change the future and they try to kill Bonnie Prince Charles, but they fail. History had been written by her before she even touched the stones.
@@Rainbow-gc6kh yes that's what I was trying to tell u history is unchangeable at least for us, people who are concerned by the events because history can be changing all the time and we don't know it because we're a consequence of that change so basically lets say that history is unchangeable because we will never know if it changes. Watch 12 monkeys, an amazing sc fi show that will help u understand the causality theory (how the time works in another words)
All Outlander fans go to Es Peoples Choice Awards and vote for Outlander for most Binge worthy show 2019. Show them how much the show still means to you!!
Wonderful show and scene. A Stuart, a James, a Jacobite could Not have occupied the British throne in the mid 18th century. They were Roman Catholics, England and Scotland were overwhelmingly Protestant by the time of Culloden. At Culloden, as many Scots fought with the British army as with the Bonnie Prince. The Jacobites fought bravely, but it was a Mug’s Game. The author as far as i remember never addresses this in the novels, which i greatly enjoyed. I made this point to Diana Gabaldon, she knows the history well. In the Tv programme the only Scots we see in the British army are scoundrels. One actually cuts off Fergus’s hand. Enough. 😀🏴🇨🇦 oh, what the hell 🇬🇧.
Love this scene! They could have Definitely left this in the episode 😍😍love Claire’s line “and you can tell the prince that he can kiss my pale white ass”😂😂😂😂😊😊
@@margaretlavender9647 yes, I know she’s playing “English” even though she’s technically Irish! And besides.. it’s good to be a “coarse American”!! I love being a “coarse American” with Irish, Scottish, and Viking ancestry! I also have a mouth of a longshoremen and truck driver’s wife and I’m Proud of it!
@@margaretlavender9647 and besides.. that scene is still Fantastic and they could have left it in for the episode! This show is one of my all time favorites and I own all the seasons so far and the entire book collection
Did you notice in the scene, Fergus says nurse instead of healer. I don’t know if that was a mistake or was that a hint at something or what? Maybe I’m making a big thing out of something but just noticed that part.
@@lilmizzy2008It has been much more than a few months, it has been at least a year by this point. They were in Paris for at least 6-8 months and this is long after that.
Having retired as a hospital nurse (started my career in the early 1970s), the ‘bugs’ became less resistant to PCN (penicillin) because doctors started using it at the beginning of a person’s fevers......... rather than let a person’s own body fight them using increased body temperatures. Plus, far too many people wanted antibiotics for a cold, or a cough, viruses rather bacterial infections. Over-use of antibiotics soon became the norm....... thankfully, this abated before I retired (I’m allergic to PCN, so it would have been a very bad treatment for me).
The really stupid part is that in 1968 she takes back penicillin in injectable format. Acid stabilized penicillin aka tablets were invented in 1958. She could easily have taken several hundred tablets back but no for some reason we have to believe she takes it back in injectable format only used within hospital settings by 1968 with all the issues around sterilization that creates, making her the stupidest doctor on the planet.
So the way Claire pronounces it, it sounds like two separate words, we’ve always pronounced as one continuous word (without it sounding like there’s a gap) I’m not criticising - it’s just an observation 😂😂
Estaban hablando de las posibilidades de poder cambiar la historia y si el primer enfrentamiento saldría bien y a Claire le deseperaba que el príncipe Carlos fuera tan obstinado
Jamie's red hair in 2016...to die for
This is an important scene that I wish had been included, especially for adding more understanding of Claire's time travel dilemma. Should they alter history? And what are the repercussions? This show does a good job keeping a lot of balls in the air overall, considering it's only a 60 minute show. Maybe if it had a few more 90 minute episodes?
Until they get to season 3 and 4
"Tell the prince he can kiss my white pale arse" I love Claire omg
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂💚💙🧡
I wish this could have been aired.
She IS a war-time nurse. She knows what's best and is NOT be argued with. ;)
0:24 Fergus putting his hands on his hips to match his mom :)
Why did they delete this scene?? Its vital to the primary question of time travel. Hell...it was the "Prime Directive" in Star Trek to NEVER get involved.
I’m reading the first book, I’m hoping there will be more about how much of the future she tells Jamie
Poor Jamie, he wanted to be certain of at least this one victory.
They were so cute in the early seasons 🥰
SPOILER
She can't change history because she was already part of it.
How come? Didn't get your idea 🤔
@@shadanaljanabi The obituary and the fact that her name is on the deed to Lallybroch both suggest that she is a part of history. The consequences of her actions in the past have already happened in the future, she just doesn't know what those actions are yet.
Have you seen Harry Potter and the prisoner of Azkaban? It's a bit like that, but over a greater stretch of time.
Haven't u heard about the causality theory. Imagine that she kills prince Bonnie... It will be no jacobit revolution Britain wouldn't be the Britain she knows so it might be no world War so she wouldn't be separated from her husband so they wouldnt go for a second honeymoon so as a result she won't travel through the stones so at this moment she won't exist in the 18th century so the fact that she's there with Jaimie means that history hasn't changed
@@melikhajlawi4857 Ok, but then how do you explain the obituary? It hasn't happened to her yet, so why do they find proof of something she has yet to do?
And remember, she tried to change the future and they try to kill Bonnie Prince Charles, but they fail. History had been written by her before she even touched the stones.
@@Rainbow-gc6kh yes that's what I was trying to tell u history is unchangeable at least for us, people who are concerned by the events because history can be changing all the time and we don't know it because we're a consequence of that change so basically lets say that history is unchangeable because we will never know if it changes. Watch 12 monkeys, an amazing sc fi show that will help u understand the causality theory (how the time works in another words)
All Outlander fans go to Es Peoples Choice Awards and vote for Outlander for most Binge worthy show 2019. Show them how much the show still means to you!!
Would if I could have...in U.S not an option
Bree also says this in 3×05 !
Wonderful show and scene. A Stuart, a James, a Jacobite could Not have occupied the British throne in the mid 18th century. They were Roman Catholics, England and Scotland were overwhelmingly Protestant by the time of Culloden. At Culloden, as many Scots fought with the British army as with the Bonnie Prince. The Jacobites fought bravely, but it was a Mug’s Game. The author as far as i remember never addresses this in the novels, which i greatly enjoyed. I made this point to Diana Gabaldon, she knows the history well. In the Tv programme the only Scots we see in the British army are scoundrels. One actually cuts off Fergus’s hand. Enough. 😀🏴🇨🇦 oh, what the hell 🇬🇧.
Love this scene! They could have Definitely left this in the episode 😍😍love Claire’s line “and you can tell the prince that he can kiss my pale white ass”😂😂😂😂😊😊
Arse. She’s English, not coarse American.
@@margaretlavender9647 yes, I know she’s playing “English” even though she’s technically Irish! And besides.. it’s good to be a “coarse American”!! I love being a “coarse American” with Irish, Scottish, and Viking ancestry! I also have a mouth of a longshoremen and truck driver’s wife and I’m Proud of it!
@@margaretlavender9647 and besides.. that scene is still Fantastic and they could have left it in for the episode! This show is one of my all time favorites and I own all the seasons so far and the entire book collection
Agree as well they were great in the early seasons...and this scene was fullll of chemistry...Ahhh Jamie's red hair...too hot
This was an important scene that should have stayed in. I see boo reason for it to be cut other than time restraint.
Amo Jamie e Claire beijos 😻😘💙❤❤💙💜💚
Cuantas escenas que no están en la serie..una lástima
Adoro essa série maravilhosa.
Did you notice in the scene, Fergus says nurse instead of healer. I don’t know if that was a mistake or was that a hint at something or what? Maybe I’m making a big thing out of something but just noticed that part.
I think being around Claire long enough made him understand the difference.
At this point he's been with claire for a few months and she's basically his mother. No doubt she taught him s few things.
@@lilmizzy2008It has been much more than a few months, it has been at least a year by this point. They were in Paris for at least 6-8 months and this is long after that.
I love Jamie❤
We all love Jamie! ❤️
I know it’s fiction but Claire introducing penicillin 150 years early would probably kill millions. She’s giving the bugs a huge head start.
Having retired as a hospital nurse (started my career in the early 1970s), the ‘bugs’ became less resistant to PCN (penicillin) because doctors started using it at the beginning of a person’s fevers......... rather than let a person’s own body fight them using increased body temperatures. Plus, far too many people wanted antibiotics for a cold, or a cough, viruses rather bacterial infections. Over-use of antibiotics soon became the norm....... thankfully, this abated before I retired (I’m allergic to PCN, so it would have been a very bad treatment for me).
The really stupid part is that in 1968 she takes back penicillin in injectable format. Acid stabilized penicillin aka tablets were invented in 1958. She could easily have taken several hundred tablets back but no for some reason we have to believe she takes it back in injectable format only used within hospital settings by 1968 with all the issues around sterilization that creates, making her the stupidest doctor on the planet.
@@jonathanbuzzard1376 I’ve read every book. All nine of them. If they follow them then it’s gonna get crazy. 16 episodes this season.
@@johnblackhead2384 still doesn't excuse having Claire take back injectable penicillin rather than a bottle of pills.
@@jonathanbuzzard1376 What I meant was that the show is following the books.
I was born and grew up in Prestonpans but Jesus it’s so weird to hear it the way Claire is pronouncing it 😂😂
So the way Claire pronounces it, it sounds like two separate words, we’ve always pronounced as one continuous word (without it sounding like there’s a gap)
I’m not criticising - it’s just an observation 😂😂
Erin Sharp do you by any chance pronounce it prestenpannz, I was trying to figure out how you could say it as one word and got that
Claire is my go to girl. No one else need apply.
They should have kept this broo💀 special the part where she says “he can kiss my pale white ass”
Wow love Jamies red hair... hotter than...
It was double talk.
Como quisiera que tuviera subtítulos. Entiendo muy poco el Inglés.
Estaban hablando de las posibilidades de poder cambiar la historia y si el primer enfrentamiento saldría bien y a Claire le deseperaba que el príncipe Carlos fuera tan obstinado
The only scenes that should have been deleted were unnecessary sex scenes🤮
Legend in portuguese please 😢
legal
@Raimunda Vieira ¿Donde está la biblioteca?