My great grandad John Goulding served in France I think between 1915 and 1917. Got shot in the cheek and a few other places. Apparently he came back as shell of his former self
@@MikeyPaper what a stupid attitude. This story is only truly known by people like this man telling it. The amount of propaganda from that time period has made it really hard to get a genuine image of what places like the Somme were actually like.
@@MikeyPaper show some respect. He wasn’t talking in circles, every word was gripping and built his experiences and story up. These stories will never be told first hand again. He should’ve told his full story until he was done, not just skipped to the death count. Disgusting behaviour bro.
‘Do you wish me to describe all [of] this?’ It hurts my heart and soul that they didn’t have time to simply let this gentleman pour out all the details he and experiences he could or was willing to then and there on camera. Tragic for loss of an opportunity.
I was about to comment the exact same thing. What an absolute shame. My great great uncle fought in that exact battle he was going on to describe. Would have been great to know all the intrinsic details of the day.
There’s TONS of these testimonials. It’s absolutely shocking to hear these stories. And to hear overlapping details of the same stories from different men separated by decades. Amazing really.
An absolutely insane and incredible set of experiences that we won't ever experience. We're lucky enough to live in a time of comparable peace (despite how it seems at times) and if we ever have a conflict on the same scale, it won't be with the same tools and equipment that necessitated these lengthy, messy and personal battles with poor medical help and lacking things like vacuum-sealed rations or the internet. I can't imagine how horrible early war truly was, and I don't think anyone but people like this man can truly understand it.
My Grandad fought on the Somme , he was Coldstream Guards and later Machine gun Corps , he died in 1993 aged 97 , he loved the Irish , he liked a drink and his pipe . He farmed all his life and brought up six kids . It was great that I knew him
My Grandfather was also assigned to the Machine Gun Corps (from the Berkshire Regiment). He always said it saved his life because the machine guns were held back from the first wave when they went over. I believe every other Lieutenant who joined the regiment with him was killed. He ended the war as an Acting Major, still only in his mid-20s.
My great-grandfather survived Gallipoli, survived Palestine and ended up in the trenches of Europe right at the end of WW1. How he didn't die in any of these military campaigns is beyond me and I'm very grateful he did. I wouldn't be here otherwise. Amazing to see Mr Dalton in in the flesh.
My Granda was an Inniskilling Fusiller, 36th Ulster Division, survived The Somme and many other Battles, returned to Ulster and died peacefully in his Bed at 83yrs old, surrounded by his loving Family❤ We will Remember Them
My Grandad was in the Irish Rifles at The Somme, he got a piece of shrapnel in his neck from a bombardment which gave him terrible coughing fits for the rest of his life, he had a shot of Irish Whiskey and laid on his bed and died aged 87.
Cathal o'Shannon was one of Ireland's outstanding broadcasters, having been a journalist since the war ended. His father also was a celebrated journalist, politician and trade unionist,
My great uncle was a young Serjeant (correct) in the Irish Rifles. He was 22 when he was killed in March 1918 having survived, from the beginning, almost impossible odds up to that point. He has no grave but I found his memorial at Pozieres in 2010. Meant a lot.
My great grand uncle was killed Sep 1 1914 in the Irish Guards at Villers-Cottres. He was 20. All my relatives in the UK and Ireland never went to the grave though they said they wanted too. I made sure when I finally got to France this year from the US that I went to his grave. I got a rock from the wall behind the grave. It is going to his parents' grave next time I am in Galway.
So composed at 78 years of age, having experienced the horrors of the trenches. Died 2 years after this interview. Well worth reading more about this man Emmet Dalton. He was involved with smuggling arms into Dublin aged 15 in 1913, then joined the British Army for WWI. After the war joined the IRA back in Dublin. Was with Michael Collins at the ambush at Beal na Blath and advised Collins to keep driving but Collins, lacking combat experience chose to stop and fight, was killed. Emmet survived the ambush and went on to have a long career in Movie production and set up Ardmore studios. I believe there is a movie of his life.
Thank you for the details you gave regarding Collins etc. Collins was Ireland's biggest loss. He was a military man but was forced to get involved in politics when the Polititions hadn't the guts to do their duty.
My great uncle Peter was killed at The Somme. He was a private in the Canadian Army. In civilian life he was a professional baseball player. I have a photocopy of his soldier record which is a handwritten record filled in by the officers, detailing when the men transferred or out, were disciplined (e.g. AWOL), promoted, demoted, wounded or killed. The final entry in Uncle Peter's soldier record was his death, stating he was shot in the chest and leg. He wrote to his mother every day while in France, and she walked to the post office every day to fetch his letter (which was weeks behind of course). One day she sent to the post office and there was no letter, but rather a little box addressed to her in unfamiliar handwriting. It was Peter's personal effects (pocket watch, his Catholic Holy Medal which she had given to him and he wore round his neck, and a letter from his commanding officer informing the recipient of Peter's death). She walked home with the little box and never spoke a word the rest of her life, the traumatic shock so affected her brain. I have Uncle Peter's Victoria Cross.
My Mum worked in an old people’s home when I was a kid and remember her taking me to see a World War One veteran . He still had his helmet with a bullet hole in it . He let me try it on , I remember it being very heavy.
My great-great grandfather Ernest Zimmermann served in Somme as a soldier of Bavarian Regiment 14, 5th Bavarian Division, of the Imperial German Army. He survived that hell, but the mental scars earned there haunted him for the rest of his life.
July 1, Beaumont Hamel, Royal Newfoundland Regiment. "Of the some 800 Newfoundlanders who went into battle that morning, only 68 were able to answer the roll call the next day, with more than 700 killed, wounded or missing. The dead included 14 sets of brothers, including four lieutenants from the Ayre family of St. John's."
Like the Accrington Pals who lost around 600 of their 720 strong battalion killed wounded or missing in the first twenty minutes of the Somme battle 1st July 16
1000 miles of Germans, 1000 miles of French, And English, Scots and Irishmen, All fighting for a trench, And when the trench is taken, And many thousands slain, The losers, with more slaughter, Retake the trench again.
@@turloughkelly3829 all of what you have said can be true yet it still does not deny that these men volunteered to give their lives in order to protect their family and friends, which is the most heroic thing a person can do.
@@bluechip297 from the perceived threat of a German invasion. There were propaganda posters at the time depicting Germans invading Irish homes, with the posters telling Irishmen to join the army before it's too late.
I'd a granduncle with the Royal Dublin Fusiliers, he was killed on the Somme. He was 18. The thing that really gets me is when he was killed it was all over bar the shouting. He survived all that hell and almost made it home. Heartbreaking.
The strength of character he has to chat so casually about one of the worst wartime experiences you could ever possibly find yourself in is staggering. Brave man, all of them were.
1 of?The First World War trench warfare was the worst experience in human history, nothing compares to it. With all respect to World War II veterans in St Petersburg and the siege Of Leningrad, who had similar experiences, but they kept the chance to run in open plan, must have given "some" Feeling, of flexibility that you could possibly survive. However, the trenches, not only disease terrible noise, but the feeling Every single 2nd but you were going to die, Or be permanently maimed, has to be unique
I'm 59 now but I remember my Great Grandad growing up. He was one of the ones. He came home minus an arm, one eye and shrapenel in his back. He was promoted on the battlefield to Sergeant because Officers and N.C.Os were getting killed at an alarming rate.
57,470 casualties overall on the 1st july 1916. On the first day 19,240 British soldiers killed in the Battle of the Somme and 38,230 wounded . Very Brave men . We should never forget there sacrifice.
German casualty lists were roughly the same too. I think it was, combined, the Somme sector, from 1916 to 1918 1.1 million casualties. With gains of up to 3 miles...crazyness.
@@lordfogg9728 on the first day of the somme the Germans had around 6,000 casualties mainly due to the French . It was and is the worst rate of Casualties in British military history .
@@lordfogg9728 no More ! German casualties were between 500,000 to 650,000 I don't know the deaths but I am sure they suffered heavy losses. Altogether 300,000 deaths from July 1st to November 18th November 1916 , 140 days .British deaths were around 125,000. It took the pressure off verdun which was a stalemate . It must of been horrific to say the least .
@@branofattrebates2847 unbelievable isn't. Like lambs to the slaughter. Unreal. Its surprising Europe bounced back. As little as it did, until it was time for another. I never met my great grandfather who died at a younger age, I'm told he was shot in the neck and face, went back to the front and got hit with shrapnel, went back to England again but the war had ended after his second stint in hospital. I took a class on WWI and WWII, where my professor, took the entire period to really get across on how tough that generation was.
Pro tip, if you're conducting an interview of a primary source and he asks "Do you want me to describe all of this?" The answer is "Yes, please.", you can cut it down later for time.
This gentleman is another example one of many thousands of Irish men from across the island of Ireland that have my respect as an Englishmen for their strength, courage and bravery in WW1 and WW2. Thank you Ireland north and south for the sacrifices your sons made for all of us
@@celtbell if he was fighting for an independent Ireland no longer controlled from London, that’s his right, Ireland belongs to those who live there, it’s upto them not, London.
@@celtbell I’m English through and through but I’m not a nationalist or an imperialist. I’m presuming here that you are Irish, as far as I’m concerned we have far more in common than we have differences. Stay safe
I knew an old man in Saarbrucken, Germany who was 4 when WW1 started. He said that his bedroom window faced west so he spent WW1 watching the flashes from the artillery and hearing the explosions. He said that he remembers when the explosions stopped.
My great granddad was decorated for bravery and initiative at Passchendaele. He was very badly wounded. Survived, and spent the rest of his life a hard drinker, and a rough-tempered man. My poor gran (his little girl) was terrified to death of him. I theorise it was the dreadful wounding that changed him, and left his personality forever tortured by survivor's guilt, anger at the War, and lingering after-effects of severe concussion (brain damage).
Thank u so much for ur bravery dear man ur courage was unsumountable ....we all in britan thank all u soldiers for ur upmost brave conduct ....cant imagine wat it was like god bless u
An Irish Soldier? I’m English and I recognise Emmet Dalton when I see him, I think he joined up when he was 17, after the war he became a great Irish patriot & fought in the Irish war of independence & then in the awful civil war that followed. He was with Michael Collins when the big Fella was tragically killed during an IRA ambush. My dear mum was Irish, born in Co Kerry in 1922.
Emmet Dalton was not the only Irish veteran of WWI who was awarded for bravery and later would join the IRA. Martin Doyle(Royal Munster Fusiliers)was awarded both the MM and the highest British award the VC. He served later with the Co Clare IRA. Michael Bishop(Irish Guards) was awarded the MM twice and would later serve with the Co.Waterford IRA. Joseph Clancy(Royal Munster Fusiliers) was awarded the DCM and would later serve with the Co.Clare IRA. John Prout served with the New York 69th the famous fighting Irish 69th which was part of the AEF(American Expeditionary Force). He was awarded the Croix DevGuerre and would later serve with the Co.Tipperary IRA. By the way Dalton helped found Ardmore Film Studios in Co.Wicklow where many great movies were made. Hope this info is useful. Stay safe in these challenging times.
@@ironmantooltime There is a new book coming out about Irish veterans of WW1 who joined the IRA during the Irish War of Independence. These men were invaluable to the IRA and their role has never been given the proper credit or analysis. I have given in my above post IRA decorated veterans of WW1 which shows the calibre of these men. I have numerous examples of IRA veterans who played a crucial part in some engagements against the Crown Forces. Check out the Dromkeen Ambush(early February 1921 in Co.Limerick)where Maurice Meade(ex Royal Irish Regiment) marksmanship accounted for a lot of Black & Tans. The famous successful Clonfin Ambush in Co.Longford in February 1921 was credited to Sean McEoin but it was Michael Gormley(ex Irish Guards) who chose the ambush location or KZ(to use modern military parlance). There was also the Rineen ambush(Co.Clare September 1920) where Ignatius O' Neil(ex Irish Guards) unleashed rapid covering rifle fire against British reinforcements(Royal Scots) and helped the IRA unit withdraw safely and escape. There was also the famous Tom Barry(ex Royal Field Artillery) who would become the most successful IRA commander in the field. Check out his role at Kilmichael ambush(November 1920) and Crossbarry(March 1921). James Flagherty(ex Connaught Rangers) played a pivotal role in the Carrowkennedy ambush in Co.Mayo in June 1921. The impact these IRA veterans of WW1 had on the guerilla army was immense. The training in terms of weapons etc was crucial. I have alway's been fascinated by IRA veterans of WW1. We must not forget that some Irish veterans of WW1 were executed by the IRA during the struggle for Independence for alleged spying. Hope this info is useful. Take care everyone in these challenging times.
@@johnroche7541 true, its like the israelis post war, they didn't take any sh1t and look where they are now: in charge of their own destiny. Not everyone agrees obvs and I'm not saying Ireland is the same, but you get my point.
This 'Irish Soldier' is Emmet Dalton. During the Irish Civil War, he held one of the highest ranks, as major general, in the pro-Treaty National Army. He was with Michael Collins when Colllins was shot and killed in August 1922.
So many generations lost. Just think how many more million men there would have been in Europe by now had there not been any world wars during the 20th century. A very sad and even sobering thought.
Yeah and it was all done on purpose. Pre-meditated mass genocide under the guise of a 'World War.' Research the 'Kalergi Plan' if you doubt me and you'll be quickly horrified. It should also make you feel extremely pissed off if you have half a brain and half a decent heart with empathy for the suffering of completely innocent civilians and yes even all the young/old soldiers on all sides in every single war
I would love to see this full interview ... amazing! I could listen to him all day. I know he has passed but there has to be full interview somewhere? My great grandfather (Dad’s side) won the Military Cross - one below Victoria Cross I believe - for his deeds at Delville Wood (part of the Somme). Still a great picture we have of him and my great grandmother walking out of Buckingham palace after being awarded. True heroes! This man. I know I wouldn’t have the guys to do what they did.
You can watch the whole interview and more here... th-cam.com/video/WM32nOhOz1Q/w-d-xo.html Emmet was awarded the MC and not the VC as he was in an Irish regiment. VCs and MCs are at the same level in terms of rank.
Private Daniel Buckley, Royal Munster Fusiliers. Enlisted October 1915. Hospitalised in April 1916. KIA December 1916. No grave. Memorialised on the Thiepval Arch. RIP.
My great grandfather served in ww1 on the us side. Although us participation was little I know absolutely nothing about his service other than a photo my grandmother shared with me after my time in the marines and before her death. I wish I knew more like I do with my grandfather's service in WW2. Incredible stories
My great uncle Harry Reade was a medic for the RAMC from the 16th ID at the Somme....he was 19 at the time and never, ever spoke about the war after he came home...ever. I wonder if this gentleman knew my great uncle.
@@johnroche7541 Dozens? Hundreds! They brought their expertese back for the trencehes and tiuned the poets and dreamers into a professional fighting force. Approx 120 were killed in Ireland during the War of Independence and Civil War.
I met a man in Clonskeagh in Dublin when I was a kid and gave me a small book .I wonder was it him , But that book has stayed with me to this Day a huge Thank You you them all !
You can sense that it weighs upon him. In other interviews with common soldiers, they are very matter of fact about the war. But with officers they carry a burden of guilt for lives lost.
My grandads dad from ringsend Dublin was in merchant navy he was on two boats that were torpedoed by Germans picked up by the yanks the first time. second time brits took him out of sea died few months after of tuberculosis. My grandad was only 6 years old. Still trying to find him on the merchant history list.
Those wondering who the Interviewer is. He is Cathal O'Shannon and passed away in 2011. He served in WW2 with the RAF as a rear gunner. In my family I remember the 9 who served and three who never came home. They lie in Franch and Belgium and Turkey. My grandfather served with the Royal Irish Regiment (1684-1922) and was wounded at Mons in 1914 and was taken prisoner until 1917 when he was swopped via The Red Cross and came home to the depot of the Royal Irish in Clonmel Co. TipperRY.
goddamit I really wish I could go back and speak to these blokes. I remember when the last one died, even though I didn't really understand what was going on I still had a sense of loss
Emmet Dalton held the post of Director of Training as part of the IRA(GHQ) in Dublin during Irish War of Independence 1919-1921. His brother Charlie was also in the IRA and Charlie took part in the "Bloody Sunday(21st November 1920) assassinations against British intelligence. Emmet was awarded the MC at Guinchy in September 1916 during the latter stages of the Battle of the Sonme while serving with the Royal Dublin Fusiliers. Like many Irish veterans of the Great War he joined the IRA when he got home to Ireland. He was not the only Irish decorated veteran of WW1 to join the IRA. Emmet in later life set up Ardmore Studios in Co.Wicklow,Republic of Ireland where many famous Hollywood movies were made right up to today.
My great grandfather was a Canadian soldier who survived the Somme. He was left with shrapnel inside his head which caused him excruciating headaches for the rest of his life.
@@zeez9053 he meant that it wasn't recognized during the time. Socially there wasn't really support for the men with shell shock and ptsd. Mr Smith was on the right track and highlighting how hard it must have been for them to "just have to get on with it". He wasn't being malicious or off putting. Maybe you read his intention a bit wrong the way he wrote it.
Infantry advancing towards machine guns is slaughter on an epic scale. Hundreds of thousands of men died in that battle, and all for nothing. An entire generation of Englishmen and Germans lost.
@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 There was Irish(from both sides),Scots and Welsh there too. Check out the movie "The Trench" which stars a younger Daniel Craig. The majority of the movie takes place on 30th June just literally hours before the Battle of the Somme. It is almost like a play due to it's condensed environment. It also stars Collian Murphy and Danny Dyer.
My great grandfather was in the Scottish 9th battalion on the Somme and was wounded in the arm and went back to Scotland in 1917 because of another wound and died in 1964 because it caused a lot of problems for him medically
Emmet Dalton , joined the Irish Volunteers , then joined the Brits in 1915 , after WW1 he returned to Ireland and rejoined the Irish Volunteers (now renamed the IRA) and fought against Britain for Irish Independence. Joined the Irish Free State Army and fought in the Irish Civil War , he was with Irish leader Michael Collins when he was killed in County Cork in 1922.
I used to live in that region, and when you go in the woods you can see holes in the ground, and I mean everywhere. I also went to Verdun. I was walking on a small road and I found a HUGE shrapnell on the side, the size of my forearm. I didn't look for it, I just saw it and took it. A friend of mine found a german helmet with a bullet hole. The whole region is filled with corpses and old ammunition. This was the most brutal conflict in history for sure.
@@lecobra418 Non non, sur le sol. Au fil des années à se promener dans la forêt mon pote avait accumulé une sacrée collection, bayonnettes, casques, douilles... Les bois de Seine et Marne sont pleins de trous énormes faits par les obus.
@@s.z.9517 En Seine et Marne ?! Je pensais que tu parlais des bois de la Marne ou de la Somme là où le gros des combats à eu lieu, je sais que des combats ont eu lieu très proche de Paris mais pas qu'il restait autant de matos littérallement à même le sol surtout dans ces coins là ! Plutôt cool, j'espère que ton pote à fait un petit travail de conservation sur ce qu'il a trouvé, ça vaudrait le coup. ;)
@@lecobra418 Oui après je trouve ça un peu dérangeant perso, collectionner ce genre de trucs. Mais oui, en Seine et Marne surtout à l'Est c'est plein d'anciens champs de bataille.
My grandfather fought at the Somme with the Canadian Expeditionary Forces. He was a cranky old bastard who died in 1964 when I was 12. From what I know about his experience in both wars, he probably had every right to be the way he was.
Another horrifying fact for you: The entire graduating class of 1914 of St Cyr (France's equivelant to Sandhurst and West Point) was dead by Christmas of that year. How about another? Everyone talks about the first day of the Somme but what happened the next day? The British continued the Battle of the Somme in exactly the same way, if not the same intensity, until November. Just over 4 months of doing exactly what cost them 60,000 casualties on the first day but on a smaller scale.
@@Capt.DanInJapan I remember reading about that or something the rather, that the French were exhausted by the end of 1914. Their capabilities were down to nothing and the generals just gave each other a hard time. France thought it should be in control of foreign armys after it had just lost his. It was new to them all, even the Boche generals struggled with the fast pace in 1914, meeting deadlines, logistics, major communication problems, sending men to the eastern front but they managed to squash the French in the process. I remember another good one. France started the war with 98 trucks and at the end the army had 18,000...I think, don't quote me on that number but it was pretty big for the day and a huge ratio difference. What a waste eh. A pissing match more or less wiped out a generation.
What a fine gentleman and valiant too as he won the Military Cross. The sad and ironic fact is that as he was fighting in France for Britain, British soldiers were bombarding the post office in Dublin where other Irish men were resisting British rule..
He was fighting for the Freedom of Small Nations including his own small nation. Irish Nationalist politicians and the RC church pleaded with Irishmen to fight and to be rewarded with Home Rule.
The battle of the Somme was so brutal. Losses just staggering. How can there really ever be words to justify War? Yet it happens, even from the beginning of human civilization, and continues on today.
A great gentleman- intelligent, articulate, brave. Hard to believe we Irish ever had leaders with such integrity and courage when you consider the specimens we have to endure today!
As soon as he said he was an officer at the Somme I thought..how did you survive? But after hearing it from him..the odds were even worse than I thought.
@@jakenconor he wasn't just one man and it was the sneakiness of DeValera and he had suffered trauma from WW 1 and you are who??to judge him?let no one judge your life so harshly as you've done here today sir
@@karmakat8016 Devalera my arse. This was the man who's duty it was to protect his Chief. What did he do? He got the whole crew drunk and let them engage in a pointless firefight where the only casualty was the man he was sworn to protect! Incompetent at best! At worst... Criminal!!!
Veteran of the somme, joined the Republican movement, took part in a mountjoy jailbreak,his was member of Collins squad,was Collins when he died,God bless emmet dalton
Knew it was him straight away. Remarkable life. If they could make a film about Lawrence of Arabia, what about Dalton? As for the somme; bloody insanity. Criminal. Human beings deserve better.
A brave man from a brave generation..my great grandfather fought in and survived ypes ..And I'm fed up with people bringing politics into this...I can't see many 16 year olds now, lieing to join up, to go fight (and potentially get maimed or killed) plus living in mud trenches, tasting death in the water, smelling death etc..then there was trench foot etc...
How dare you , you miss the point...I hope you don't live in the UK..because of you do ..LEARN SOME RESPECT...or shut up....it's ungrateful hypocrites like you TROLLS, that forget that you have the freedom you have, because young MEN of 15 and older went and thought...No doubt your one of these SJWs.....in other words..Bigoted against anything British...just look at history....dickhead
My great uncle died during the Third Battle of the Somme (Paschendale) on the 17th September, 1917 having been injured the day before. He was in the 6th Battalion (Pioneers) East Yorkshire Regiment. Never have so many died such selfless yet pointless deaths as during WW1. 😓
You mean the Third Battle of Ypres? There were only 2 battles at the Somme and the Second Battle of the Somme took place in 1918 during the German Spring Offensive.
Your final remark concerning the pointlessness of the deaths is correct. The young men on both sides should have walked away from a conflict (instigated by the Aristocracy) involving weapons and should have instead, settled their dispute through competitive sport and other non-murderous activities....instead they "Fed the Guns."
11 of my great uncles went into the Somme Only 7 came out alive (all highly decorated) After that they went home and freed Ireland God bless them and all the men who were in it (both sides)
What about the Royal Newfoundland Regiment was wiped out only 68 men answered the roll call the next day . They placed shiny bright tin triangles on their backs to see how far into German held ground they gotten to . They made great targets when the men were wounded and fell to the ground , if they moved at all they were shot immediately . General Haig never mentioned this in his memoirs all he said was that the attack failed because dead men could March no further . It was said that other regiments on that day refused to wear the shiny tin triangles because they knew that they would become easy targets .
My Great Grandfather Andrew Rourke was mortally wounded by shellfire on the Guillemont to Ginchy Road in October 1916. I imagine he was treated at a Regimental Aid Post and then transported to Casualty Clearing Station number 55. This is a distance of about 16km and would take 19 minutes to drive today. How long I wonder, did it take Andrew to reach the hospital? He died of his wounds the following day. I have been fortunate to visit his grave at Grove Town Cemetery, the site of the CCS Heroe is a word that is much abused by its overuse today. However, it is a fitting epithet for so many of those men that fought in that and other Wars.
@@tejashdasgupta1840 why be so sarcastic? ... were talking about a generation that lied about there age to fight for there country, a generation that saw terrible terrible things but grew into well rounded, strong willed men. Compare that to wimpy, self serving, complaining, spoilt, narcissistic, social justice warriors we have to displeasure of sharing this dying planet with now.
@@mlaytontaylor Seriously, if you are still using the term SJW unironically, you need to get with the times but let's adress your example shall we. We are looking at a generation that fought some of the bloodiest wars of all time and whose imperialism lead to several continents being ruined and who ruined the economies of their own coutries, because of whom, Germany's econony was eviscerated and the Nazis came to power, yeah, so I'll take my generation over yours any day.
@@tejashdasgupta1840 “your generation” ... ironic that your turned this into some kind of contest. We aren’t talking about the “leaders” that instigated wars, wars that when won allowed “your generation” to live in the peace you so enjoy today. We are talking about the men that were forced to face unspeakable horrors to free these countries from tyranny and injustice. Again, to allow YOUR GENERATION to sit around bitching about how oppressed you are on your £900 phones smh. Keep your fucking generation.
@@mlaytontaylor I turned it into a contest, you were the one who was talking about how good your generation was despite generations being good being a fake concept as people are individuals, like, have you met yourself.
Met a SGM several years ago. His mother was a WWII war bride. His grandfather was an "Old Reliable" from WWI. He was in the English Army prior to WWI. Was was in the first battle of the Somme. After the battle, he was one of 8 corporals. They were what was left of the battalions chain of command. They made his the Battalion SGM. He trained up a new company about every three months.
Some would join the IRA and distinguish themselves in the Irish War of Independence. By the way Dalton was not the only IRA man who had been decorated for bravery in WW1.
@@pepedecorozal5963 calm down? I was stating a fact, they returned to Ireland disgraced. I can guarantee you that they did hate the coloniser, most were Irish volunteers encouraged by MacNeill to join as to please the British so they would be given home rule following a “swift” war finished before Christmas.
As a nation we can be very fickle. When Maj Gen Emmet Dalton went to his grave not one government representative attended the funeral! Get your head around that!!
![ILLSLICK X YOUNGOHM - We're The same [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yUJNkobYR0E/mqdefault.jpg)
This is my Great Uncle Emmet
Respect
Greatest respect to this Gentleman.
My great grandad John Goulding served in France I think between 1915 and 1917. Got shot in the cheek and a few other places. Apparently he came back as shell of his former self
My grandmother, Agnes May Morgan, was the sister of Teresa Morgan, who married Charlie Dalton, Emmet's brother! Phew, that was a bit of a mouthful
THE Emmet Dalton who was present at Béal na mBláth? Respect.
Making this man skip to the end was a crime against history and journalism.
I disagree... he was rambling and talking in circles. I respect his story but c'mon now, get to the point.
Came looking for this. When that weasel chimed in I couldn’t believe he wasn’t hanging on every word. Fuck the commercials, this history!
@@MikeyPaper what a stupid attitude. This story is only truly known by people like this man telling it. The amount of propaganda from that time period has made it really hard to get a genuine image of what places like the Somme were actually like.
@@MikeyPaper show some respect. He wasn’t talking in circles, every word was gripping and built his experiences and story up. These stories will never be told first hand again. He should’ve told his full story until he was done, not just skipped to the death count. Disgusting behaviour bro.
@@MikeyPaper fool
‘Do you wish me to describe all [of] this?’ It hurts my heart and soul that they didn’t have time to simply let this gentleman pour out all the details he and experiences he could or was willing to then and there on camera. Tragic for loss of an opportunity.
I was about to comment the exact same thing. What an absolute shame. My great great uncle fought in that exact battle he was going on to describe. Would have been great to know all the intrinsic details of the day.
You should see the amount of time they give people to talk nowadays.
I think he paused and asked because the details he was about to go into were likely too graphic for TV in those days.
Watch the BBC great war interviews, they basically do just that
Exactly my thoughts. The journalist should have let the gentleman talk. But no. Interrupted. Incredible. Journalists sometimes arrogant.
I find it mind blowing that I am watching and listen to this man and his experience of the battle of Somme in WW1.
There’s TONS of these testimonials. It’s absolutely shocking to hear these stories. And to hear overlapping details of the same stories from different men separated by decades. Amazing really.
I used to love listening to these men's interview's when I was a kid I knew a few local men who were in the old IRA as we called it.
You can listen to recordings of Anerican civil war soldiers and black slaves when they were old (1920-30s)
Technology these days
An absolutely insane and incredible set of experiences that we won't ever experience. We're lucky enough to live in a time of comparable peace (despite how it seems at times) and if we ever have a conflict on the same scale, it won't be with the same tools and equipment that necessitated these lengthy, messy and personal battles with poor medical help and lacking things like vacuum-sealed rations or the internet.
I can't imagine how horrible early war truly was, and I don't think anyone but people like this man can truly understand it.
Videos like this on TH-cam is what the internet is for. I’m listing to a man who fought in the Somme in his own words. Amazing.
True. A pity you have to wade through so much crap to find the gems.
When men like this talk we listen. What a man.
Amen Sir!
My Grandad fought on the Somme , he was Coldstream Guards and later Machine gun Corps , he died in 1993 aged 97 , he loved the Irish , he liked a drink and his pipe . He farmed all his life and brought up six kids . It was great that I knew him
Honourable man! May Allah have mercy on his soul ameen
@@notyourdinner3446 he's Christian
My Grandfather was also assigned to the Machine Gun Corps (from the Berkshire Regiment). He always said it saved his life because the machine guns were held back from the first wave when they went over. I believe every other Lieutenant who joined the regiment with him was killed. He ended the war as an Acting Major, still only in his mid-20s.
@@Bringlish1986 Doesn't matter, they're the same entity.
@@lawenda2099 not to a Christian who believes Islam is a false prophet and false religion.
My great-grandfather survived Gallipoli, survived Palestine and ended up in the trenches of Europe right at the end of WW1.
How he didn't die in any of these military campaigns is beyond me and I'm very grateful he did. I wouldn't be here otherwise.
Amazing to see Mr Dalton in in the flesh.
Must be a coward
My Granda was an Inniskilling Fusiller, 36th Ulster Division, survived The Somme and many other Battles, returned to Ulster and died peacefully in his Bed at 83yrs old, surrounded by his loving Family❤
We will Remember Them
Imagine losing almost all of your officers and 90% of your battalion only to advance 200 yards...unbelievable
So sad
King's officials.
Very sad
The tragic truth of the stalemate on the western front
It was so horrific that many are still angry about it to this day, even though there are no veterans remaining
My Husband's grandfather was one of the 98 men
BALLS TO WARS
stand by your man
Beautiful to hear
“But by the Grace of God go I...”
My grandfather was one of the 98
I wish he didn't abbreviate it and just let the man talk
I know I was hanging on his every word...yiy can tell this man was a professional
Exactly what I was thinking.
I agree, I was really interested to hear that story. Now we never will
YES - my thought exactly just now!
What things remained unsaid forever just because of that interviewers negative response!
Yes, but it was television and not TH-cam. There were time constraints. I do hope his story in full was recorded at some point elsewhere.
My Grandad was in the Irish Rifles at The Somme, he got a piece of shrapnel in his neck from a bombardment which gave him terrible coughing fits for the rest of his life, he had a shot of Irish Whiskey and laid on his bed and died aged 87.
What a champ ⚔️🇮🇪
God bless your Grandad.
May Allah have mercy on his brave brave soul. Ameen
RIP to a great man
Was it the Irish whisky that killed him, should have had a decent scotch huh. 😑
The interviewer is Cathal O'Shannon. He was a Lancaster tail gunner during WWII.
Thanks. That explains why he's so well versed and is such a competent interviewer.
One vet to another. Mad respect between them i would guess
Cathal o'Shannon was one of Ireland's outstanding broadcasters, having been a journalist since the war ended.
His father also was a celebrated journalist, politician and trade unionist,
My great uncle was a young Serjeant (correct) in the Irish Rifles. He was 22 when he was killed in March 1918 having survived, from the beginning, almost impossible odds up to that point. He has no grave but I found his memorial at Pozieres in 2010. Meant a lot.
My great grand uncle was killed Sep 1 1914 in the Irish Guards at Villers-Cottres. He was 20. All my relatives in the UK and Ireland never went to the grave though they said they wanted too. I made sure when I finally got to France this year from the US that I went to his grave. I got a rock from the wall behind the grave. It is going to his parents' grave next time I am in Galway.
So composed at 78 years of age, having experienced the horrors of the trenches. Died 2 years after this interview. Well worth reading more about this man Emmet Dalton. He was involved with smuggling arms into Dublin aged 15 in 1913, then joined the British Army for WWI. After the war joined the IRA back in Dublin. Was with Michael Collins at the ambush at Beal na Blath and advised Collins to keep driving but Collins, lacking combat experience chose to stop and fight, was killed. Emmet survived the ambush and went on to have a long career in Movie production and set up Ardmore studios. I believe there is a movie of his life.
What's the name of the film? Some life.
@@cigh7445 It's a documentary called 'Emmet Dalton remembers'.
You can find it on TH-cam.
Thank you for the details you gave regarding Collins etc. Collins was Ireland's biggest loss. He was a military man but was forced to get involved in politics when the Polititions hadn't the guts to do their duty.
Fascinating. Thanks for sharing.
My great uncle Peter was killed at The Somme. He was a private in the Canadian Army. In civilian life he was a professional baseball player. I have a photocopy of his soldier record which is a handwritten record filled in by the officers, detailing when the men transferred or out, were disciplined (e.g. AWOL), promoted, demoted, wounded or killed. The final entry in Uncle Peter's soldier record was his death, stating he was shot in the chest and leg. He wrote to his mother every day while in France, and she walked to the post office every day to fetch his letter (which was weeks behind of course). One day she sent to the post office and there was no letter, but rather a little box addressed to her in unfamiliar handwriting. It was Peter's personal effects (pocket watch, his Catholic Holy Medal which she had given to him and he wore round his neck, and a letter from his commanding officer informing the recipient of Peter's death). She walked home with the little box and never spoke a word the rest of her life, the traumatic shock so affected her brain. I have Uncle Peter's Victoria Cross.
My Mum worked in an old people’s home when I was a kid and remember her taking me to see a World War One veteran . He still had his helmet with a bullet hole in it . He let me try it on , I remember it being very heavy.
My great-great grandfather Ernest Zimmermann served in Somme as a soldier of Bavarian Regiment 14, 5th Bavarian Division, of the Imperial German Army. He survived that hell, but the mental scars earned there haunted him for the rest of his life.
Wasn’t Hitler also in a Bavarian regiment?
pig
July 1, Beaumont Hamel, Royal Newfoundland Regiment.
"Of the some 800 Newfoundlanders who went into battle that morning, only 68 were able to answer the roll call the next day, with more than 700 killed, wounded or missing. The dead included 14 sets of brothers, including four lieutenants from the Ayre family of St. John's."
Like the Accrington Pals who lost around 600 of their 720 strong battalion killed wounded or missing in the first twenty minutes of the Somme battle 1st July 16
A whole generation of brave young Newfoundlanders lost but never forgotten.❤🍁🪨🇨🇦
1000 miles of Germans,
1000 miles of French,
And English, Scots and Irishmen,
All fighting for a trench,
And when the trench is taken,
And many thousands slain,
The losers, with more slaughter,
Retake the trench again.
....then the Australian general ,,General Monash,, arrived . With his meticulous detailed planning the war soon ended following his arrival .
Now we just hand it over without a whimper...
In war nobody wins
@@charlesdickens6706 Australians killing their European brothers is nothing to boast about.
Don't forget the ANZAC, Australian New Zealand Army Corps
Emmet Dalton there,a very brave man well worth looking up.
To ALL of the soldiers, ALL, on both sides, that fought during the great wars.
You are all respected.
I’m so glad these brave men have had their stories & experiences saved on video so they are NEVER forgotten. ❤️❤️
God bless him and all veterans. All those fellas were real heroes.
They died for nothing. It was a pointless, murderous war. A gargantuan waste of human life. Nothing heroic about it - just futile.
@@turloughkelly3829 all of what you have said can be true yet it still does not deny that these men volunteered to give their lives in order to protect their family and friends, which is the most heroic thing a person can do.
@@Iukeeey protect their family and friends from what?
@@bluechip297 from the perceived threat of a German invasion. There were propaganda posters at the time depicting Germans invading Irish homes, with the posters telling Irishmen to join the army before it's too late.
@@Iukeeey The propaganda recruiting posters for Irishmen to join the British Army went into overdrive after the sinking of the Lusitania.
Emmet Dalton. A masterpiece soldier. Michael Collins died in his arms. I salute you sir.
An honorable soldier imo
Thanks for posting this important detail. Colins was a true Irish soldier.
I'd a granduncle with the Royal Dublin Fusiliers, he was killed on the Somme. He was 18. The thing that really gets me is when he was killed it was all over bar the shouting. He survived all that hell and almost made it home. Heartbreaking.
The strength of character he has to chat so casually about one of the worst wartime experiences you could ever possibly find yourself in is staggering. Brave man, all of them were.
1 of?The First World War trench warfare was the worst experience in human history, nothing compares to it. With all respect to World War II veterans in St Petersburg and the siege Of Leningrad, who had similar experiences, but they kept the chance to run in open plan, must have given "some" Feeling, of flexibility that you could possibly survive. However, the trenches, not only disease terrible noise, but the feeling Every single 2nd but you were going to die, Or be permanently maimed, has to be unique
I'm 59 now but I remember my Great Grandad growing up. He was one of the ones. He came home minus an arm, one eye and shrapenel in his back. He was promoted on the battlefield to Sergeant because Officers and N.C.Os were getting killed at an alarming rate.
57,470 casualties overall on the 1st july 1916. On the first day 19,240 British soldiers killed in the Battle of the Somme and 38,230 wounded . Very Brave men . We should never forget there sacrifice.
German casualty lists were roughly the same too.
I think it was, combined, the Somme sector, from 1916 to 1918 1.1 million casualties. With gains of up to 3 miles...crazyness.
@@lordfogg9728 on the first day of the somme the Germans had around 6,000 casualties mainly due to the French . It was and is the worst rate of Casualties in British military history .
@@branofattrebates2847 ahhh ok. So Boche didn't get it the first day like the Brits eh. I'm pretty sure they were similiar when the Somme was over no?
@@lordfogg9728 no More ! German casualties were between 500,000 to 650,000 I don't know the deaths but I am sure they suffered heavy losses. Altogether 300,000 deaths from July 1st to November 18th November 1916 , 140 days .British deaths were around 125,000.
It took the pressure off verdun which was a stalemate .
It must of been horrific to say the least .
@@branofattrebates2847 unbelievable isn't. Like lambs to the slaughter. Unreal. Its surprising Europe bounced back. As little as it did, until it was time for another. I never met my great grandfather who died at a younger age, I'm told he was shot in the neck and face, went back to the front and got hit with shrapnel, went back to England again but the war had ended after his second stint in hospital. I took a class on WWI and WWII, where my professor, took the entire period to really get across on how tough that generation was.
Pro tip, if you're conducting an interview of a primary source and he asks "Do you want me to describe all of this?" The answer is "Yes, please.", you can cut it down later for time.
in fairness this would probably have been going out live
This gentleman is another example one of many thousands of Irish men from across the island of Ireland that have my respect as an Englishmen for their strength, courage and bravery in WW1 and WW2.
Thank you Ireland north and south for the sacrifices your sons made for all of us
@@celtbell if he was fighting for an independent Ireland no longer controlled from London, that’s his right, Ireland belongs to those who live there, it’s upto them not, London.
@@nigeh5326 yeah fair enough...his name is Emmett Dalton..he was with Michael Collins when he was killed
@@celtbell I’m English through and through but I’m not a nationalist or an imperialist.
I’m presuming here that you are Irish, as far as I’m concerned we have far more in common than we have differences.
Stay safe
@@nigeh5326 if only more thought like you mate. We would all get on fine
@@terencebigballs8531 well I’ve raised my 2 sons to think the same way. Thanks 👍
I knew an old man in Saarbrucken, Germany who was 4 when WW1 started. He said that his bedroom window faced west so he spent WW1 watching the flashes from the artillery and hearing the explosions. He said that he remembers when the explosions stopped.
This is astonishing thanks for preserving it for future generations
My great granddad was decorated for bravery and initiative at Passchendaele. He was very badly wounded. Survived, and spent the rest of his life a hard drinker, and a rough-tempered man. My poor gran (his little girl) was terrified to death of him. I theorise it was the dreadful wounding that changed him, and left his personality forever tortured by survivor's guilt, anger at the War, and lingering after-effects of severe concussion (brain damage).
Thank u so much for ur bravery dear man ur courage was unsumountable ....we all in britan thank all u soldiers for ur upmost brave conduct ....cant imagine wat it was like god bless u
An Irish Soldier? I’m English and I recognise Emmet Dalton when I see him, I think he joined up when he was 17, after the war he became a great Irish patriot & fought in the Irish war of independence & then in the awful civil war that followed. He was with Michael Collins when the big Fella was tragically killed during an IRA ambush. My dear mum was Irish, born in Co Kerry in 1922.
Quite, some understatement.
Emmet Dalton was not the only Irish veteran of WWI who was awarded for bravery and later would join the IRA.
Martin Doyle(Royal Munster Fusiliers)was awarded both the MM and the highest British award the VC. He served later with the Co Clare IRA.
Michael Bishop(Irish Guards) was awarded the MM twice and would later serve with the Co.Waterford IRA.
Joseph Clancy(Royal Munster Fusiliers) was awarded the DCM and would later serve with the Co.Clare IRA.
John Prout served with the New York 69th the famous fighting Irish 69th which was part of the AEF(American Expeditionary Force). He was awarded the Croix DevGuerre and would later serve with the Co.Tipperary IRA. By the way Dalton helped found Ardmore Film Studios in Co.Wicklow where many great movies were made. Hope this info is useful. Stay safe in these challenging times.
Almost as if characterisation of the IRA as terrorist was a touch simplistic..
@@ironmantooltime There is a new book coming out about Irish veterans of WW1 who joined the IRA during the Irish War of Independence. These men were invaluable to the IRA and their role has never been given the proper credit or analysis. I have given in my above post IRA decorated veterans of WW1 which shows the calibre of these men. I have numerous examples of IRA veterans who played a crucial part in some engagements against the Crown Forces. Check out the Dromkeen Ambush(early February 1921 in Co.Limerick)where Maurice Meade(ex Royal Irish Regiment) marksmanship accounted for a lot of Black & Tans. The famous successful Clonfin Ambush in Co.Longford in February 1921 was credited to Sean McEoin but it was Michael Gormley(ex Irish Guards) who chose the ambush location or KZ(to use modern military parlance). There was also the Rineen ambush(Co.Clare September 1920) where Ignatius O' Neil(ex Irish Guards) unleashed rapid covering rifle fire against British reinforcements(Royal Scots) and helped the IRA unit withdraw safely and escape. There was also the famous Tom Barry(ex Royal Field Artillery) who would become the most successful IRA commander in the field. Check out his role at Kilmichael ambush(November 1920) and Crossbarry(March 1921). James Flagherty(ex Connaught Rangers) played a pivotal role in the Carrowkennedy ambush in Co.Mayo in June 1921. The impact these IRA veterans of WW1 had on the guerilla army was immense. The training in terms of weapons etc was crucial. I have alway's been fascinated by IRA veterans of WW1. We must not forget that some Irish veterans of WW1 were executed by the IRA during the struggle for Independence for alleged spying. Hope this info is useful. Take care everyone in these challenging times.
@@johnroche7541 true, its like the israelis post war, they didn't take any sh1t and look where they are now: in charge of their own destiny. Not everyone agrees obvs and I'm not saying Ireland is the same, but you get my point.
This 'Irish Soldier' is Emmet Dalton. During the Irish Civil War, he held one of the highest ranks, as major general, in the pro-Treaty National Army.
He was with Michael Collins when Colllins was shot and killed in August 1922.
So many generations lost. Just think how many more million men there would have been in Europe by now had there not been any world wars during the 20th century. A very sad and even sobering thought.
Yeah and it was all done on purpose. Pre-meditated mass genocide under the guise of a 'World War.' Research the 'Kalergi Plan' if you doubt me and you'll be quickly horrified. It should also make you feel extremely pissed off if you have half a brain and half a decent heart with empathy for the suffering of completely innocent civilians and yes even all the young/old soldiers on all sides in every single war
@@TheRealShawnCrowe there's always one tinfoil hat idiot
@@TheRealShawnCrowe genuine conspiracy theory nonsense. Not everything has a big huge secret sometimes people wanna shoot each other
Yeah man, Russia had the third largest population before ww1
I would implore anybody to take a trip to the Somme, they are owed our respect.
Going to watch world war 1 in colour tonight, thoroughly enjoyed learning about WW1 on ,'They Shall Not Grow Old"
You can have nothing but respect for these young men....
I would love to see this full interview ... amazing! I could listen to him all day. I know he has passed but there has to be full interview somewhere?
My great grandfather (Dad’s side) won the Military Cross - one below Victoria Cross I believe - for his deeds at Delville Wood (part of the Somme). Still a great picture we have of him and my great grandmother walking out of Buckingham palace after being awarded.
True heroes! This man. I know I wouldn’t have the guys to do what they did.
You can watch the whole interview and more here... th-cam.com/video/WM32nOhOz1Q/w-d-xo.html
Emmet was awarded the MC and not the VC as he was in an Irish regiment. VCs and MCs are at the same level in terms of rank.
Private Daniel Buckley, Royal Munster Fusiliers. Enlisted October 1915. Hospitalised in April 1916. KIA December 1916. No grave. Memorialised on the Thiepval Arch. RIP.
My great grandfather served in ww1 on the us side. Although us participation was little I know absolutely nothing about his service other than a photo my grandmother shared with me after my time in the marines and before her death. I wish I knew more like I do with my grandfather's service in WW2. Incredible stories
My great uncle Harry Reade was a medic for the RAMC from the 16th ID at the Somme....he was 19 at the time and never, ever spoke about the war after he came home...ever. I wonder if this gentleman knew my great uncle.
the man who had to retell michael collins trip to dublin from cork on his death. lived a tough life. hero.
Dozens of IRA men were veterans of WW1 and a couple had been decorated for bravery.
@@johnroche7541 Dozens? Hundreds! They brought their expertese back for the trencehes and tiuned the poets and dreamers into a professional fighting force. Approx 120 were killed in Ireland during the War of Independence and Civil War.
@@heritage195 You can get an accurate number if you go through IRA pension files with British records.
@@heritage195 Forgot to mention Clonfin ambush!
@@heritage195 Rineen,Kilmichael,Glenwood,Dromkeen,
Clonfin,Ballyvourney,Crossbarry,
Headford,Carrowkenbedy.
I met a man in Clonskeagh in Dublin when I was a kid and gave me a small book .I wonder was it him , But that book has stayed with me to this Day a huge Thank You you them all !
You can sense that it weighs upon him.
In other interviews with common soldiers, they are very matter of fact about the war.
But with officers they carry a burden of guilt for lives lost.
Common soldiers? No such thing. Plenty of common civilians though!
Imagine writing a letter to 800 mothers!
A Somme veteran and Collins's adjutant interviewed by an ex RAF ww2 veteran!
My grandads dad from ringsend Dublin was in merchant navy he was on two boats that were torpedoed by Germans picked up by the yanks the first time. second time brits took him out of sea died few months after of tuberculosis. My grandad was only 6 years old. Still trying to find him on the merchant history list.
Those wondering who the Interviewer is. He is Cathal O'Shannon and passed away in 2011. He served in WW2 with the RAF as a rear gunner. In my family I remember the 9 who served and three who never came home. They lie in Franch and Belgium and Turkey. My grandfather served with the Royal Irish Regiment (1684-1922) and was wounded at Mons in 1914 and was taken prisoner until 1917 when he was swopped via The Red Cross and came home to the depot of the Royal Irish in Clonmel Co. TipperRY.
Let’s never forget them!
goddamit I really wish I could go back and speak to these blokes. I remember when the last one died, even though I didn't really understand what was going on I still had a sense of loss
My Grandad Jack and his twin brother Charlie both fought in France and survived…thank you all, from the bottom of my heart.
He played a very prominent role in the Free state side of the Irish Civil War and was with Michael Collins when he was shot.
Emmet Dalton held the post of Director of Training as part of the IRA(GHQ) in Dublin during Irish War of Independence 1919-1921. His brother Charlie was also in the IRA and Charlie took part in the "Bloody Sunday(21st November 1920) assassinations against British intelligence. Emmet was awarded the MC at Guinchy in September 1916 during the latter stages of the Battle of the Sonme while serving with the Royal Dublin Fusiliers. Like many Irish veterans of the Great War he joined the IRA when he got home to Ireland. He was not the only Irish decorated veteran of WW1 to join the IRA. Emmet in later life set up Ardmore Studios in Co.Wicklow,Republic of Ireland where many famous Hollywood movies were made right up to today.
My great grandfather was a Canadian soldier who survived the Somme. He was left with shrapnel inside his head which caused him excruciating headaches for the rest of his life.
My great grandfather fought in great slaughter from 1914 until he came back in 1918, a changed man, and he died in a sanatorium 8 years later.
An absolute horror show. Such a gentlemen to go through that end come out so composed.
Mr Smith didn’t you ever hear of shell shock if that’s not post t s d ? Get your facts right and study
@@zeez9053 he meant that it wasn't recognized during the time. Socially there wasn't really support for the men with shell shock and ptsd. Mr Smith was on the right track and highlighting how hard it must have been for them to "just have to get on with it". He wasn't being malicious or off putting. Maybe you read his intention a bit wrong the way he wrote it.
@@Minime163 my great uncle did the same.
Infantry advancing towards machine guns is slaughter on an epic scale. Hundreds of thousands of men died in that battle, and all for nothing. An entire generation of Englishmen and Germans lost.
@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 There was Irish(from both sides),Scots and Welsh there too. Check out the movie "The Trench" which stars a younger Daniel Craig. The majority of the movie takes place on 30th June just literally hours before the Battle of the Somme. It is almost like a play due to it's condensed environment. It also stars Collian Murphy and Danny Dyer.
My great grandfather was in the Scottish 9th battalion on the Somme and was wounded in the arm and went back to Scotland in 1917 because of another wound and died in 1964 because it caused a lot of problems for him medically
Total respect ..
My great grandfather who's Irish fought in the same battle
Emmet Dalton , joined the Irish Volunteers , then joined the Brits in 1915 , after WW1 he returned to Ireland and rejoined the Irish Volunteers (now renamed the IRA) and fought against Britain for Irish Independence. Joined the Irish Free State Army and fought in the Irish Civil War , he was with Irish leader Michael Collins when he was killed in County Cork in 1922.
I used to live in that region, and when you go in the woods you can see holes in the ground, and I mean everywhere. I also went to Verdun. I was walking on a small road and I found a HUGE shrapnell on the side, the size of my forearm. I didn't look for it, I just saw it and took it. A friend of mine found a german helmet with a bullet hole. The whole region is filled with corpses and old ammunition. This was the most brutal conflict in history for sure.
You found those relics buried or just laying there? Tu peux me répondre en français ou en anglais comme tu veux.
@@lecobra418 Non non, sur le sol. Au fil des années à se promener dans la forêt mon pote avait accumulé une sacrée collection, bayonnettes, casques, douilles... Les bois de Seine et Marne sont pleins de trous énormes faits par les obus.
@@s.z.9517 En Seine et Marne ?! Je pensais que tu parlais des bois de la Marne ou de la Somme là où le gros des combats à eu lieu, je sais que des combats ont eu lieu très proche de Paris mais pas qu'il restait autant de matos littérallement à même le sol surtout dans ces coins là ! Plutôt cool, j'espère que ton pote à fait un petit travail de conservation sur ce qu'il a trouvé, ça vaudrait le coup. ;)
@@lecobra418 Oui après je trouve ça un peu dérangeant perso, collectionner ce genre de trucs. Mais oui, en Seine et Marne surtout à l'Est c'est plein d'anciens champs de bataille.
My grandfather fought at the Somme with the Canadian Expeditionary Forces. He was a cranky old bastard who died in 1964 when I was 12. From what I know about his experience in both wars, he probably had every right to be the way he was.
Amazing interview, great Irish accent, great story teller
The fact that 26 of the 28 officers in that battalion died in one day is staggering. Shocking.
Another horrifying fact for you: The entire graduating class of 1914 of St Cyr (France's equivelant to Sandhurst and West Point) was dead by Christmas of that year.
How about another? Everyone talks about the first day of the Somme but what happened the next day? The British continued the Battle of the Somme in exactly the same way, if not the same intensity, until November. Just over 4 months of doing exactly what cost them 60,000 casualties on the first day but on a smaller scale.
@@Capt.DanInJapan The human meat grinder... and to think it happened all over again 20 years later
Officers are targeted I warfare.
Unreal eh
@@Capt.DanInJapan I remember reading about that or something the rather, that the French were exhausted by the end of 1914. Their capabilities were down to nothing and the generals just gave each other a hard time. France thought it should be in control of foreign armys after it had just lost his. It was new to them all, even the Boche generals struggled with the fast pace in 1914, meeting deadlines, logistics, major communication problems, sending men to the eastern front but they managed to squash the French in the process. I remember another good one. France started the war with 98 trucks and at the end the army had 18,000...I think, don't quote me on that number but it was pretty big for the day and a huge ratio difference. What a waste eh. A pissing match more or less wiped out a generation.
A brave man, thankyou for your service, a Hero.
What a fine gentleman and valiant too as he won the Military Cross. The sad and ironic fact is that as he was fighting in France for Britain, British soldiers were bombarding the post office in Dublin where other Irish men were resisting British rule..
Irish regiments that were in Dublin in 1916 were used to suppress the 'Rising".
He was fighting for the Freedom of Small Nations including his own small nation. Irish Nationalist politicians and the RC church pleaded with Irishmen to fight and to be rewarded with Home Rule.
I always wanted to see a documentary with interviews form veterans.
God bless them all, we will not forget them.
The battle of the Somme was so brutal. Losses just staggering. How can there really ever be words to justify War? Yet it happens, even from the beginning of human civilization, and continues on today.
Not 'losses' but 'men killed'.
The Somme was over 100 years ago. Amazing to listen to a survivor of that horrible event. And wars continue on and on and on.
This is how we should teach history in schools. There is more wisdom in the tone of his words than in entire books.
All they are taught today is how wars disproportionately affect minorities.
A great gentleman- intelligent, articulate, brave. Hard to believe we Irish ever had leaders with such integrity and courage when you consider the specimens we have to endure today!
As soon as he said he was an officer at the Somme I thought..how did you survive?
But after hearing it from him..the odds were even worse than I thought.
Advancing under a creeping barrage with zero communications between infantry and artillery units would have been fucking terrifying.
An Irish hero. RIP Emmet Dalton.
Do you not think he should have done a better job of protecting his Commander in Chief in Cork? What was he playing at??
@@jakenconor he wasn't just one man and it was the sneakiness of DeValera and he had suffered trauma from WW 1 and you are who??to judge him?let no one judge your life so harshly as you've done here today sir
@@jakenconor how many times have you laid down your life? Just so we can be aware of your credentials to judge over this man.
@@B8kedBean how many times did this man lay down his life?? He died in his bed..an old man
@@karmakat8016 Devalera my arse. This was the man who's duty it was to protect his Chief. What did he do? He got the whole crew drunk and let them engage in a pointless firefight where the only casualty was the man he was sworn to protect! Incompetent at best!
At worst... Criminal!!!
Such valuable material
Veteran of the somme, joined the Republican movement, took part in a mountjoy jailbreak,his was member of Collins squad,was Collins when he died,God bless emmet dalton
Surprised how many here did not pick up that it was him. Founded Ardmore Studios in Bray
Knew it was him straight away. Remarkable life. If they could make a film about Lawrence of Arabia, what about Dalton? As for the somme; bloody insanity. Criminal. Human beings deserve better.
Any man who climbed over the parapit in that war is a hero. My great grandfather Pte. William Collins was at the Somme and he never got over it.
I can't resist.The parapet or the war?
@@dnhy7951bad taste...
@@vern146 I thought it was funny....
My grandad served in hussars my father air force both from Sallynogin I served in infantry 1970s and they still called me a left footer
A brave man from a brave generation..my great grandfather fought in and survived ypes ..And I'm fed up with people bringing politics into this...I can't see many 16 year olds now, lieing to join up, to go fight (and potentially get maimed or killed) plus living in mud trenches, tasting death in the water, smelling death etc..then there was trench foot etc...
Yes but what have you done besides glamorise child soldiers.
How dare you , you miss the point...I hope you don't live in the UK..because of you do ..LEARN SOME RESPECT...or shut up....it's ungrateful hypocrites like you TROLLS, that forget that you have the freedom you have, because young MEN of 15 and older went and thought...No doubt your one of these SJWs.....in other words..Bigoted against anything British...just look at history....dickhead
How horrible that lower class people aren't sent off to die like vermin. What awful times we live in
My great uncle died during the Third Battle of the Somme (Paschendale) on the 17th September, 1917 having been injured the day before. He was in the 6th Battalion (Pioneers) East Yorkshire Regiment.
Never have so many died such selfless yet pointless deaths as during WW1. 😓
You mean the Third Battle of Ypres? There were only 2 battles at the Somme and the Second Battle of the Somme took place in 1918 during the German Spring Offensive.
Your final remark concerning the pointlessness of the deaths is correct. The young men on both sides should have walked away from a conflict (instigated by the Aristocracy) involving weapons and should have instead, settled their dispute through competitive sport and other non-murderous activities....instead they "Fed the Guns."
11 of my great uncles went into the Somme
Only 7 came out alive (all highly decorated)
After that they went home and freed Ireland
God bless them and all the men who were in it (both sides)
Lest we forget 🇬🇧🇮🇪
love the irish thank you...and im english
What about the Royal Newfoundland Regiment was wiped out only 68 men answered the roll call the next day . They placed shiny bright tin triangles on their backs to see how far into German held ground they gotten to . They made great targets when the men were wounded and fell to the ground , if they moved at all they were shot immediately . General Haig never mentioned this in his memoirs all he said was that the attack failed because dead men could March no further . It was said that other regiments on that day refused to wear the shiny tin triangles because they knew that they would become easy targets .
When he says, "do you wish me to describe all this," can't tell if he wants the anchor to say no. I'm thinking um yes please.
Same
Memoirs of an infantry officer by Siegfried Sassoon is a very interesting read if people are interested.
My Great Grandfather Andrew Rourke was mortally wounded by shellfire on the Guillemont to Ginchy Road in October 1916. I imagine he was treated at a Regimental Aid Post and then transported to Casualty Clearing Station number 55. This is a distance of about 16km and would take 19 minutes to drive today. How long I wonder, did it take Andrew to reach the hospital?
He died of his wounds the following day.
I have been fortunate to visit his grave at Grove Town Cemetery, the site of the CCS
Heroe is a word that is much abused by its overuse today. However, it is a fitting epithet for so many of those men that fought in that and other Wars.
Then you look at today's generation... dear oh dear.
It's so bad that we don't fights wars that don't kill tens of millions of people, isn't it.
@@tejashdasgupta1840 why be so sarcastic? ... were talking about a generation that lied about there age to fight for there country, a generation that saw terrible terrible things but grew into well rounded, strong willed men. Compare that to wimpy, self serving, complaining, spoilt, narcissistic, social justice warriors we have to displeasure of sharing this dying planet with now.
@@mlaytontaylor Seriously, if you are still using the term SJW unironically, you need to get with the times but let's adress your example shall we. We are looking at a generation that fought some of the bloodiest wars of all time and whose imperialism lead to several continents being ruined and who ruined the economies of their own coutries, because of whom, Germany's econony was eviscerated and the Nazis came to power, yeah, so I'll take my generation over yours any day.
@@tejashdasgupta1840 “your generation” ... ironic that your turned this into some kind of contest. We aren’t talking about the “leaders” that instigated wars, wars that when won allowed “your generation” to live in the peace you so enjoy today. We are talking about the men that were forced to face unspeakable horrors to free these countries from tyranny and injustice. Again, to allow YOUR GENERATION to sit around bitching about how oppressed you are on your £900 phones smh. Keep your fucking generation.
@@mlaytontaylor I turned it into a contest, you were the one who was talking about how good your generation was despite generations being good being a fake concept as people are individuals, like, have you met yourself.
Met a SGM several years ago.
His mother was a WWII war bride.
His grandfather was an "Old Reliable" from WWI.
He was in the English Army prior to WWI.
Was was in the first battle of the Somme.
After the battle, he was one of 8 corporals.
They were what was left of the battalions chain of command.
They made his the Battalion SGM.
He trained up a new company about every three months.
The fact many of these Irish men went to WWI for Ireland and left as heroes but returned as Traitors astounds me.
Some would join the IRA and distinguish themselves in the Irish War of Independence. By the way Dalton was not the only IRA man who had been decorated for bravery in WW1.
From another island with a fraught relationship with our colonial power, calm down. You don't need to hate the colonizer to long for independence.
@@pepedecorozal5963 calm down? I was stating a fact, they returned to Ireland disgraced. I can guarantee you that they did hate the coloniser, most were Irish volunteers encouraged by MacNeill to join as to please the British so they would be given home rule following a “swift” war finished before Christmas.
A lot of them, including the man being interviewed here, returned and joined the IRA immediately after the war ended.
As a nation we can be very fickle. When Maj Gen Emmet Dalton went to his grave not one government representative attended the funeral! Get your head around that!!
Growing up we all think our Dads are heroes! But these are the real heroes. Total respect
It seems comparable that each WW1 battle sank battleships full of men with few survivors, just an unimaginable toll and scar to live with.
God Bless you.
Does anyone know where I can find the full interview? This is absolutely amazing and mind blowing to hear about his personal experience.
Google emmet dalton interview
Yw
To hear this man talk about history is incredible but scary also may he rip
What a slaughter. Imagine going over the top with your pals and seeing 80% of them killed.