Why Muslims Avoid the Historical Record
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ม.ค. 2024
- Please prayerfully consider supporting this ministry.
www.sagepayments.net/eftcart/...
Click on "Pay by credit card" - scroll down to "Directed funds" - And click on my name "Olin Giles"
Dr. Jay Smith discusses some of the historical problems associated with the Qur'an and Muhammad, the book and the man.
Thank you for the news on Hatun Jay, she is safe thank God.
So Hatun is under Protective Custody. God bless her. And may God speak to the Muslims and show them how weak their religion is that it needs to try and silence critics like Hatun, and how weak their Allah is that he can't deal with his critics himself. Hatun is like Gideon of old - Jerub Baal!
Man on what planet you live in ?? We don't care how weak you think Islam is !!! God himself don't care for what you choose to belive he gave you the prove that you free to choose what to worship and who but its better be one lord and one God or else you lost my friend you lost this life and the after with your ignorance about Islam and Muslims. Really even God tell us as Muslims he don't need us to win or to show the truth God is absolute 😊He don't need you or me to win him any followers God don't need anything from humans accept they know who created them and the law of life . For the rest you can say about Islam weak as much as you want our place of worship is always full our young kids memories the qoruan every day back to back our religion is known for logic and Prof we connect to God in prayer with no Bishop or pop if we die we go to our creator for truth if we live we live so we can have a good after life for us and our children. We dont have empty churches and we dont make a mockery out of Jesus death or we allow gay right of marriage or we kill our God or his son for the sake of human kind while the human wait for judgment day ??? Why we all wait for that day if God already forgive us... so much misery in these kind of thoughts
Thank you for all your hard work Jay. One man sows and another reaps but the Holy Spirit uses obedient Servants to break up and stir up the tuff dry soil of the heart. So that the Word might enter the heart and bear much fruit.
🙏🧡💯 I have respected Lord Jesus Christ from 1977.
Humbly conveyed from a Sikh brother 🙏
I can hardly wait for your book Dr Smith!
Thanks guys! Fine video. So happy Hatun is safe! 🙏
It's not hate speech, just cause you don't like it.
No one:
Absolutely no one:
Christian apologist: it ain't hate speech just 'cause you don't like it
First time on this channel and it’s owned my subscription. God bless.
Welcome aboard!
Love what you're doing, Olin!
Thanks Scott! Likewise brother
“ no one can do what Hatun does”Dr.Jay Smith
I’m not even 3 minutes in this video & i am already surprised.
Love will set us free
Liked and subscribed
John3:5-"l am telling you the truth," replied Jesus.,"that no one can enter the Kingdom of God without being born of water and the Spirit.Amen.John14:6- Jesus answered him,"l am the way, the truth, and the life, * no one goes to the Father except by me.Amen.* God bless to all.
Mark and Luke were significant figures in the early Christian era and played crucial roles in documenting the life and teachings of Jesus, there is no concrete historical evidence that they were contemporaneous with or direct eyewitnesses to Jesus
I totally disagree, but practically all scholars agree that John, James, Peter, and Paul give early eyewitness testimony (Gal. 1&2) and place the early creed of 1 Corinthians 15 within 3 years of the cross. Some would say months
You should look into Critical Textural Analysis of ancient works. It is a science that looks at the speech patterns, idioms, and place references. Names are compared to the names common to the place and time, and more evidence is gathered to determine if a work was really written in the place and time claimed, and even if the author is the person claimed as the author. The "chain of evidence" is also examined. That is, who did the original witness pass the evidence to, and how did those persons handle it?
The NT passed this analysis.
Jay, some questions. Wouldn't anti trinitarian Christians be familiar with the Bible? Why would Abd al Malik and Al Hajjaj need to create a text like tye Quran? Why not just interpret the Bible in a non trinitarian way as JW's and Unitarians do and Arians did?
They didn’t have access to an Arabic Bible until 859AD to answer your last question
@@whychristianity8388 OK but the Ghassanids and other Arab Christuan tribes they had a Bible. In Aramaic. Aramaic and Arabic are close. Maybe the Believers were all illiterate? But why make a Quran if they are non-Trinitarian Christians? Why not translate the Aramaic Bible? Anti trinitarian Christians use the same Bible trinitarians do. Maybe Abd al Malik and the Believers were hanifiyya who were originally multi confessional as Shoemaker argues?
@@timothygreene7910 They would do it to affirm that their language, Arabic, was the language of God. It would affirm their being in effect the Chosen ones of God. Why Rabbinical Jews generally restricted the Scripture to the Hebrew texts.
@@johnschuh8616 To set themselves apart from Messianic Jews Rabbinic Jews wrote the Masoretic Bible. Precisely why non Trinitarian Christians, even Arab speaking ones would not do that. All Christian sects, even non Chalcedonians, used the Bible. They might translate it into their own language, like the Peshitta or even rework it, like the Diatessaron. But they would not monkey with it to the extent one would need to to get something like the Quran.
Unless it served the purposes of a political leader to do so. Arabic was not a literary language until Muslim times.
A Message To You !!
In The Quran Word " Muhammad or MHMD "" Meaning Not a Prophet's Name But A Title , Common Nou , Indefinite noun ,
[ See-When a noun is used to refer to an unspecified or unidentified person or thing , it is Called ( the indefinite noun ) it usually has tanween ,[ ( an ) A double fathah sign ] , [ ( in ) A double Kasrah sign , ] & [ ( un ) A double dammah sign ] , at the end of the noun and is Translated in English as " a " or " an " like- a man , a student , an apple , a car , a book , a Muhammad [ Because of Muhammad "uuun " Muhammad"IIIN " , Muhammad"AAAN " & Muhammad"eeeeen ,
In this Point -- In the Quran Muhammad "word " Meaning Not A Person's Name , But A Title , Common Noun & singular & Plural Noun , & Indefinite Noun , --
#####
Jesus is Muhammad, the Praised One
@@whychristianity8388 Yes But His Mum Too ,
MHMD Title -- For the male & female Too ,
@@mozi4305 you have no clue what you’re talking about. I don’t worship or praise Mary
@whychristianity8388 So you believe in Qur'an.
It was written in greek
Please Answer Me if you are a Scholar !! Please Save me and Save You !!
What is the Meaning of [ Laaa ilaaaha illaa Allah ] ???
See Grammar - Meccan Arabic "" Al " Meaning - "" The "" and Egyptian Arabic "" El "" Meaning "" The ""
In This Point -- ilaaaha meaning - The God , God of Ibrahim , Ishaq , Yaqub ( Quran surah No-2 , Iaaat No--133 ) , Same as Allah = Al-allah = Allah - Meaning --The God , God of Muhammad of Mecca ,
ilaaaha or Elaaha = El-allah = Ellah ( Egyptian or Egyptian Arabic ) = The God ( God of Ibrahim , Ishaq , Yaqub ) [ Surah No-2 , Iaaat No--133 ] ,
Indeed-- laaa ilaaaha illaa Allah Meaning -- No Egyptian El-allah except Meccan Al-allah ,
or No Egyptian El-allah only Meccan Al-allah ,
or No El-allah except Allah ,
or No Ellah except Allah ,
or No The God except The God , [ Surah No--2 , Iaaat No-133 ] ,
or Not The God of Ibrahim , Ishaq , & yaqub Except The God of Muhammad of Meccan ,
Because of -- In This Point Language tick Matter , there Was Many Different Arabic State and None Arabic State too ,That Why Meccan False Prophet He did Reject The God of Ibrahim , Ishaq , & Yaqub , he did Reject Egyptian & Syrian God Call-- Ellaha or ( Ellah-ra -him or Ellahim or Ellohim ) & allah , But Except only Meccan Allah , God of Muhammad of Meccan ,,,
[[;,,***
Allah is a generic name for “the god” and says nothing about who God is truly. Come to Jesus who perfectly reveals the Father
@@whychristianity8388 are u joking or being funny.....go ask jews so that they can laugh at u too😊
Some one with the name ashleyn8946 replied to my comments.now i am replying time and again and my comments are deleted as soon as i add the reply.common christians show the courage to embrass the truth.its a discussion which will Insha'ALLAH leads you all to the true path of islam
Answer the evidence presented and quit crying like a baby and highlighting your nonsense. If you run from the evidence and try to change the subject, it will be deleted
Better yet, come on the channel live and defend Islam. I will give you time to talk.
@@whychristianity8388 The subject is not changed.you are running from the evidence brother.what i said is 100 % accurate.is it not written in your bible that the sun moves around the earth?And did some jews sects not worship EZRA as the son of GOD as you christians worship JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H as the son of GOD?I replied according to the subject and according to the statement given by someone named ashley.common answer my question.QURAN is the only book which matches with the recent scientific discoveries.No any other religious book matches with modern science.QURAN is the true word of THE ONE AND TRUE ALLAH SWT.that's it.
@@mahboobalam9735 first of all, I have no idea what you’re talking about as far the person you were replying to. This is my channel and I’m asking you to respond to the evidence presented in the video. I’m even inviting you on the channel to defend your faith, but you know that you can’t because you believe a lie
@@whychristianity8388 ok you are saying about ny faith islam that it is a lie NAUZUBILLAH.Brother you in a state of ignorance.THE HOLY QURAN was preserved by the companions of THE LAST PROPHET HAZRAT MOHAMMAD P.B.U.H in their hearts.And that memorization is still going on.its the miracle of ALLAH SWT that THE WHOLE QURAN is memorized by muslims.your christians can't memorize your bibles as they are fabricated.Now see the gospel of john,mark,luke and mathew are even not written by the forementioned names.We muslims love JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H more than you christians and believe that HE is the prophet of ALLAH SWT.what i am asking is that it is mentioned in your bible that the sun moves around the earth while QURAN says that all the heavenly bodies(planets) moves in an orbit and also rotates around its own axis.Now brother you plz tell me bible is cOrrect ir QURAN regarding the solar system.Just for the sake of argument reply to my question.
MAY ALLAH SWT give you hidayath to turn to the true path of islam.ameen.
when inter acting with muslems I find they will go right to the Trinity and they do have a point The word trinity is not in the Bible and as the Trinity doctrin stated by the Cathlioc church is not a bibical doctrin Yes there is a Father creator who was in the Body of Jesus with out measure but at the same time fills heaven and earth and he sent back his spirit as the Holy Ghost to fill the body of bealivers So if your interacting with Jews or Muslems You need to speak as the scriptures speak and not follow church teachings that are messed up
The Trinity is a biblical doctrine taught throughout the Old and New Testament. Stop the nonsense. Neither is the word Tawheed found in the Quran, but the doctrine is there
The world bible is not in the bible isn't it? But does that word contradict the gods teaching?
There are numerous passages that there GOD is in the land talking to Abraham and before God destroyed Sodom he (GOD) ask the GOD in heaven to pour fire from heaven to Sodom.
@@whychristianity8388 you are unbelievable even with your own kin you behave like a monster when they disagree with your nonsense
@@0786AHA sounds like Islamic gibberish
@@whychristianity8388 pagans can't relate to monothiests... That's for sure. 💯☑️☑️☑️
Muslims are not avoiding Anything you have a Great Imagination ISLAM does not need yours or anybody who has the same thinking as you Sir Dr. What ever you call yourself I am certain you Earned it, so with due respect ISLAM needs not defend itself yes maybe Muslims.
You can’t defend Islam because there is no positive evidence to support your prophet. It’s all a lie!
Just another god cult. There are so many.
I would love to discuss this with you?
@@whychristianity8388discuss we me....I love Laugh at ur joke
idk why christians telling the quran is false when the trinity makes no sense either.
Idk why Muslims telling us the Trinity is false when the Quran makes no sense.
What's in the quran is also from the same line of prophets Christians deny you cant be a Christian if you don't know the towrah and you can't be a Jewish without being a Muslim all of these stories books connect you to a certain truth God is one judgement day will come be carefull for what you must do or say in this life
@@bashsami3301 just more Islamic garbage. We all know the Quran plagiarized Jewish legends along with others
@@whychristianity8388 so you claim to belive thar Jesus didn't say sons of israel my lord and your lord is one?
@@whychristianity8388 so you claim also that we made the legend's true with our word of God thank you ...I know without us around in the world everyone will deny Jesus and we will be the only one knowing God didn't let Jesus die he toke him to heaven to the day he was promised to return 🙏 and save people like you who made a mockery of God by killing his son or by making a God so like humans that he need a son not a prophet oh so shameful the worst part in you all that you like to watch the body of your so presumed God dead and killed when we know the truth he was never Crucified was never killed We know the truth and you can't hide it forever
Mr.dr.jay smith MAY ALLAH SWT give you hidayath to turn to the true path of islam.ameen.your christianity is created by paul not JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H.JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H always taught islam and never claimed divinity and never said that i am GOD and WORSHIP ME.JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H was circumcized as we muslims are but majority of your christians are uncircumcised.which shows that you christians only follow paul and not JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H.There are alot of manipulations in the bible.for example the word begotten son was a fabrication and added as a manipulation to the bible which was later on removed.The bible says that the sun moves around the earth which is completely false and goes against the modern science.QURAN says that all the heavenly bodies(planets) moves in an orbit and rotates around its own axis.
As far as the presrvation of THE HOLY QURAN is concerned,it was memorized by the companions of THE LAST HOLY PROPHET HAZRAT MOHAMMAD P.B.U.H.And its the miracle of ALLAH SWT that that memorization of THE HOLY QURAN is still going on by muslims and will be memorized by muslims till the day of judgement as ALLAH has promised its preservation.
So MAY ALLAH SWT give all of you hidayath to turn to the true path of islam.ameen.
The quran is full of inconsistencies, contradictory verses, and illogical stories about 1. Mohammad flying from here to there, bargaining with God how many times muslims should pray in a day. It was 50 times down to 5 times after Moses approved the 5 times a day saying, 'It's enough.' 2. Mohd told his friend that the sun set in a puddle of muddy water, etc, etc. Just 2 examples prove the quran is not directly from God ....
Mr.iris you are completely wrong.what you have said is just your wrong belief.every single word of THE HOLY QURAN is a word of THE ONE AND TRUE ALLAH.you are among the disbelievers in QURAN.you said that it us mentioned in QURAN that the sun sets in a muddy spring of water but you took it in a wrong sense.it is the story of ZULQARNAIN when he reaches a certain place and sees as if the the sun was setting in a muddy spring of water.it was a reflection of sunlight.your sense of understanding is wrong.And your bible is full of mistakes because the word of gospel of john,mathew,luke and so on are not the word of them.that is completely fabricated.And the word trinity was added as a fabrication by the roman catholic church.your christianity is created by paul not JESUS CHRIST P.B.U.H.MAY ALLAH SWT give you hidayath to turn to the true path of islam.ameen.
@@mahboobalam9735Your quran is full of mistakes. It mixes up Mary with the sister of Arron and Moses and says the jews worship Ezra as the son of God like the christian’s do. Even one mistake in quran disproves it unlike in the bible who was written by man though inspired by God.
Jesus Christ language was Aramaic, but Bible originated in Greek languages. Original language disappeared.
@mahboobalam9735 you really have a way to defend your holy book. No matter what the evidence, you still refuse to accept the fact that it is flawed. My, my! Even your scholar admitted that your beloved narrative quran has holes! Numerous of them 😆. ..and that is fact, boy.
Islam is last testement of the one True God
Prove it!
Wrong!
Lucifer AKA Satan is a fallen angel; not the "one True God".
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@IGuess... so you beleive Jesus who the jews say that they killed and who ate and went to toilet is and died and went to helll according to you is God