Defeated | House M.D.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ส.ค. 2018
- Newbie resident, Thirteen, was given the task to treat a Patient who doesn't want go on any longer
Stream full seasons on Peacock: pck.tv/39BlAG0
Season 4 Episode 3 "97 Seconds"
The final ten fellowship candidates compete ferociously against each other when House splits them into two teams by gender. They are assigned to diagnose and treat a wheelchair user (Brian Klugman) with spinal muscular atrophy who is slowly suffocating. As the teams try to outdo the other, complications arise. Meanwhile, Foreman runs his own team at another hospital, and resorts to using a very "House-like" treatment to help a patient.
Your favorite shows, movies and more are here. Stream now on Peacock: www.peacocktv.com
Watch House on Google Play: bit.ly/2tu3kHh & iTunes apple.co/2tCSJOu
Subscribe: bit.ly/2goT95b
This is the official TH-cam channel for House M.D. Watch all of the official clips from the series, the funniest and saddest moments, and follow all of the doctor's most curious cases.
#HouseMD #IsItLupus? #Doctors
#HouseMD #HughLaurie #doctors - บันเทิง
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 69 | คู่เอก "กุหลาบดำ vs นาบิล"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PNM6U8e_HMo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Week 4 Day 1 // PRX vs RRQ | GE vs GEN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iIi2_04jGr0/mqdefault.jpg)
That dog is a good actor.
clintblackx lol that is hilarious.
More proof of "50% of every Oscar belongs to the editor."
Good point.
Did you just assume the dogs gender? What if it's an actress, not an actor? Gosh...
@@BluezCinema what if the dog doesn't identify as any of those genders? What if it thinks it's a potato chip? Did anyone ever think about that hmmm? #SavePupatoChipLives
Him asking to have his hand on the dog, I’m in bits.
Yep, I'm sitting here with tears in my eyes telling myself it's just a damn TV show.
I love how House operates as a teacher and a doctor. He fires people when he has nothing left to teach them so they can go be successful on their own and when someone fucks up bad he uses it as a teaching moment
Yeah, like he said, they both know for a fact that she'll never make that mistake again. So when the whole team got the diagnosis right, he kept the one person who learned an extra bit of something.
that's a practical teaching
That's just bs because it was house who fucked up.
Couldn't it be argued that being fired would be even MORE of an incentive to not make that mistake again? Just a thought...
@@stephaniemontenegro4482 Would you rather employ a doctor who made a terrible mistake and learned from it, or a new doctor who has yet to make a terrible mistake, but will at some point during their time with you?
That is why House kept her
4:54 the exact moment House realized what happened. The way he closes his mouth, it's real subtle, but you can totally see the anger. Great great acting.
wooooah wait yeah the acting/editing was so well done I didn't consciously notice until this comment. Good catch!
honestly she should have been fired. I would not have trusted her with another patient ever again.
@@changaming1275 sadly true. If I’m not mistaken, she likely would not only have been fired, but also charged with involuntary manslaughter due to her negligence resulting in a man’s death, as well as the dog’s depending on what state they’re in.
A man giving up and accepting death does not make me cry... A man giving up and accepting death while holding his dog... Oh you best believe I'm crying 😭😭😭
his*
God I read this before and thought "nah I'll be fine". Now holding my dog sobbing.
So basically, a sad-looking animal makes you cry infinitely more than a dying human?
Anyone else wonder why this world is going to sh*t?!
Yeah. Dying sucks and as humans we can deal with it. But our Pets? Loyal Dumbasses.. they can't rationalize death or understand it. To them we've left, not died.
I read your comment before watching the video and I am already sobbing.
I find it odd he made this about religion when I kind of interpreted it as a dude that just wants to die because existing is painful.
My thoughts exactly.
But he's aguy that could have been saved had he taken his medication. But he chose not to. Instead he killed himself and his dog. I never got this episode, or what was noble about it
@@Xelltrix Not to mention that Doctor house essentially destroyed his beliefs. To that guy, the idea of a God and an afterlife existing, gives him hope as he believes no matter how long he has left, he will be somewhere wonderful. Meanwhile to him, the idea of not any afterlife existing, makes him lose hope as there is nothing to look forward to and how he will cease to exist the moment he dies, essentially he knows he is on his death bed so he has much he can do left.
Life is definitely painful that's for sure
Did you watch the full episode? It's because of the B-plot patient for the episode.
In his last moments all he wanted was to pet and comfort his dog. That's love.
OR, as some oddballs are theorising, the guy took the risk of KILLING that very dog just to be able to die i.e. he made the pills fall over.
A subtle detail I don't think enough people talk about is Thirteen's dialogue at 7:53
"Did I drop the pills when I put them on the bed tray? Did I knock them over when I turned to leave?"
She's not just mad at herself for not paying attention, she's worried about her motor control. She's worried she's starting to show early signs of Huntington's.
omg you're right
No, I don't think so. It's normal retrospection, you imagine all the ways you could have screwed up, but don't remember.
@@Limrassoneither or. Either way, both are accurate theories however they’re based on time sensativity. One is usually commom and another is based off additional subjective information that can trigger the thought.
@@Limrasson I mean, yes, that is the normal sort of retrospection most people would probably display. But I don't see much of a chance that 13 at a time like that wouldn't be thinking of her Huntington's diagnosis and wondering, so I think OP still is correct.
Though, in the end, neither are true, since the patient rather clearly purposefully fed the medicine to the dog to get rid of the pills.
"You confused saving her life with doing the right thing."
Hella controversial statement there ma'am.
Can't sue for malpractice if they didn't act on half assumptions
John Smith In the show Dr Foreman is one of the best doctors in the world since he was trained by Dr House. He had a much a higher chance of saving the patient’s life than any other doctor in that hospital.
You'll notice I said controversial rather than right/wrong.
If you reduce the sentence, it implies that saving her life was not the right thing to do. That even if they didn't find supporting evidence of a diagnosis until the autopsy, he shouldn't have acted on a hunch alone. That's what makes it controversial. It basically comes down to "Do the ends justify the means?" and your answer could arguably be yes or no. It's a gray area of moral quandary.
I'd say this statement is just weirdly formulated semantically, and she ends up being misunderstood. By "doing the right thing", she meant "applying the appropriate method within the frame of medical rules". But Foreman learnt from House that you can take every shot ever if it's going to save the patient down the line.
At the end of the day, it just comes down to the same dilemma we see in every American drama series: manicheism doesn't work. If you try to divide reality between right or wrong, you're going to implode. Both her vision of the truth and Foreman's are legitimate.
Sometimes saving a life isn't the right thing to do.
Well that thing with the dog was probably the saddest thing I've ever seen
Don’t be sad about it. Think of it as the dog and the man went together❤️
@@butterflybeauty615 You mean the man murdered his dog in order to kill himself too.
@@Silverizael Do you believe he knew the medicine would kill his dog? If so, yeah i would agree with you. But it would probably be more likely he hadn't a clue it would affect the dog or maybe he'd just thrown the medicine away & the dog ate it without his knowledge. Who can tell...?
I guess you have never seen the inside of an Abortion clinic .... : (
@@chazzlucas6395 Have you? This is television.
I almost died. I went to a big hospital and they treated me like I was garbage. I came home to die. My sweet little dog curled up next to my stomach as I lay for months in the dark. She stayed there beside me, except to go out, eat and drink. I couldn't bare light. I was in hellish pain. She stayed. Other doctors didn't want to see me b/c after the fancy hospital I was clearly fine. Eventually, I was seen by a different doctor who did actual tests and sent me to have my eyes checked by someone who studies the brain and eyes (another part of the brain actually.) She found that my optic nerve was inflammed. MRI revealed lesions on the brain and antibodies had been high. Anyway, those other doctors almost killed me. They mocked me and ignored me but my little dog, well, she saved me. She made me hang on until I got help. I'd die for that dog. There is nothing better on earth than a loyal dog.
I was fine up till he told his dog, "Dont worry." Now I'm bawling my eyes out 😭😭😭
The dog just had to be brought in for maximum kick-in-the-gutness
GUNNRAKK He'd probably drain a goat in a heartbeat but a dog dying on a tv show oh no that's taking it too far
@GUNNRAKK Cutie modern satanists don't do that shit. Also the Symbol is also used by people who are more direction wicca then satanism
@@Soul_Alpha Modern Satanists don't really do that. You are thinking about Hollywood Satanists
I'm an ex satanist. Can confirm they dont sacrifice animals. Can confirm they are hedonistic heathens tho
Y'all are overthinking it, dude's probably a motley crue fan or something.
This is so unrealistic! no dog can chop onions like that.
All dogs shud die
Nuke us all
@@misanthropicisolation4013 All new 2000's kids need to be burned to death.
@@conabish all people that aren't my skin colour should be eaten alive
Sorry, that's me, I was making a sandwich. I like a lot of onions on my sandwich.
“You employed her, you’re responsible” but didnt she employe house??? If you’re going to put blame on employers should go all the way to the top.
uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh, responception
But Cuddy never does anything wrong, because she’s Cuddy....sarcasm intensifies
If she’s going to pull the “you hired her” card, house should pull the “you hired me” card right back
She presumably feels partly responsible but just doesn't feel the need to include that fact in her lecture of house. That's probably part of why she lectures house, it's her attempt to prevent this in the future because she has a responsibility to prevent preventable deaths at her hospital
Rule of the leader, the difference betwen cuddy and house is that house knows it is his responsability.
@@ivanadriazola1991 You're wrong. House intended to avoid the argument, just like 13 did with with him regarding the cup incident. He accepts Cuddy's judgement because, unlike the other administrator, the one that hired and fired Foreman, she is the only administrator willing to consider the posibility to look beyond House's stupid behavior and use him for a more decent purpose. It is because Cuddy did not fired House for this incident that he decided to keep 13 and treat her like Cuddy treated him first.
Usually I agree with House but in this instance, I'm with Wilson. A dying man, maybe hours, maybe months, does not need House's atheism shoved down his throat at the end.
I don't get this stereotype that smart people are atheists. Especially a man like that. A smart person should know everything is caused by something, and the existence of the universe is something. Am I meant to believe they assume nothing created the universe?
If they believe that, it leaves but 2 options for them to branch their beliefs. Either the universe was made by gods or a god, or we were created as a simulation. We are not a simulation and there is a good explanation for that too. It leaves but one answer, and it isn't atheism.
@@unitedstates4912 Problem is that religion completely hinges on the idea that there is an afterlife. That's the hook it employs to pull people in. Even if we went with your view that there is a creator or a deliberate agent which set all this into motion, why does that automatically mean our consciousness or ''soul'' survives on another plane after we die on this planet?
Something might have caused the universe to come into being BUT seeing all the scientific facts that we know of such as age of the universe/earth, the deep vastness of empty space, the existence of dinosaurs, evolution, countless other animal species having all the same biological functions as us but they are not deemed worthy of having a soul or the right to an afterlife, etc...It would be highly arrogant to be looking up at the sky and thinking we will survive forever because we are so special. If ''God'' created us in his own image, the fact that dinosaurs roamed Earth for hundreds of millions of years before us seems a very tricky question to get around, wouldn't you say?
@@ciaranoconnell4783 I believe our existence naturally would be of such low chance that it is insane to believe we were not created by hand of some greater being. Hell the fact we aren't seeing earth beamed in half by some intergalactic death laser a minute after I post this is reason enough. I don't need to explain how perfect our conditions are on this planet and how slim the chances intelligent life would develop are.
For our own importance relative to god, I believe the fact that it is impossible for us to comprehend our existence yet is the evidence we will inevitable ascend to a greater domain. In our human lives, we have but 5 senses We only comprehend the 3 x,y, and z dimensions. Our perception of time is linear in a straight line. There is so much we do not understand that I can accept but another 2 outcomes. A: We will understand everything someday and have no more questions, or B: My existence is worthless
That is also why we are not in a simulation. A simulation's creator could not possibly place such restrictions on us like that, otherwise, it would be pointless for said simulation to continue.
I don't know maybe our existence IS meaningless. Then I honestly don't care what happens to anything, but I still don't believe that and I still doubt we are here for no reason. Why can we imagine so much that we apparently would never possibly experience?
Who said god made us just to be in his image and watch us? You know some people die of cancer at 0? That's honestly all the more evidence you could use to say there is life after death.
@@ciaranoconnell4783 The bible mentions dinosaurs and other large creatures lol! Also "Problem is that religion completely hinges on the idea that there is an afterlife. That's the hook it employs to pull people in." I became a Christian because I simply looked at the facts around it, not because I was scared of dying
@@unitedstates4912 You say "everything is caused by something" - surely you've heard the argument that "gods or a god" must have been caused by something too? And if you'll allow that deities can cause themselves or are uncaused, then why don't you afford that same property to the universe?
You also say that "our existence naturally would be of such low chance that it is insane to believe we were not created by hand of some greater being" - yet miniscule chance is not zero chance, and the larger the universe and the longer it exists, the more likely it is that non-zero chance occurences are eventually going to happen. Eventually it becomes "insane" to believe that unlikely events *won't* eventually happen, given enough time and room to occur.
The observation that "there is so much we do not understand" is the exact opposite of grounds to side with "gods or a god", especially when what we *do* understand from real experimentation points away from that. In all likelihood, we will never "understand everything someday and have no more questions" because the more we know, the more questions are raised about what we don't know. But that doesn't mean anyone's existence is worthless because there doesn't need to be a general meaning for all life for you to value your own specific life. You don't need permission to value your own life, you just do. If people didn't, humans wouldn't have lasted very long.
It's very "United States" to be theist at the moment, but it's more "United States" to forge your own way in life regardless of what higher powers (like governments) want to impose on you. I hope you think on that one.
One of the saddest episodes, I'm tearing up because of the pups expression and the whines, I've seen a dog cry for her owner, it's heartbreaking
My dog whines when I get home and gets so happy and that. I wouldn't say she cries of happiness about seeing me come home, though.
Jonathan Wilfred Michelin maybe the the dog was crying because it was in pain from taking those pills
Pretty sure the dog was whimpering because it was dying after the patient murdered it.
So why not get a cat , where you can get purr instead of whining .
Eww
Battle of pretty eyes: Olivia Wilde vs Hugh Laurie
I'll go with...the dog.
anima09 evenly matched. ❤️
@@janesmith699 i vote for Hugh all the way . .Gourgeous baby blues !!!
alexander hamilton beats both of them. and im not just saying that because im a piece of hamiltrash. just look him up and go to images. or google his eye color. they were no joke violet blue. that must be the prettiest eye color out there.
Gaylord
"You can't let a dying man take solace in his beliefs?"
"His beliefs are stupid"
And there goes all tension out the window...
You really see the emotion and care in House's eyes in the last scene. He has an enormous heart but tries his best to never let anyone know.
Yeah❤
One of the most underrated episodes ever. Lots of twists and turns. Just when you thought the women were right, they were wrong, and then right again but just didn’t watch the patient swallow the pills. House then puts a metal knife into an electrical socket and attempts to almost kill himself to prove there’s no afterlife. Then, there’s an interesting piece of irony. House and Thirteen kill a patient and his dog, but both are retained. However, Foreman saves a patient’s life with House’s same gutsy methodology and gets fired. It’s also at this episode where Foreman’s patient is experiencing the same symptoms as in “House Training”. In that episode, Foreman kills a patient and isn’t able to get past his guilt. He later resigns as a result. Claiming he doesn’t want to be like House, Foreman discovers he’s too late in this episode and despite rectifying his past guilt, is fired as a result of this.
Thirteen didn't kill anyone. The patient killed the dog in order to kill himself.
@@Silverizael That's just your perception, it wasn't clear in the episode, however it was implied that dog ate the pill by accident and the patient died as a result of not getting the pill on time
@@Silverizael Wrong, the cup was chewed up.
*to prove there ISN'T an afterlife*
The saddest
Just a note for accuracy.
A trained service dog would never steal his master's pills. Or eat anything he wasn't given. Certainly he wouldn't take them off the bestest.
I think the implication was the owner fed the pills to the dog to accelerate his own death.
@@krusk3544 No.
@@Nippleless_Cage Wow, Brendan, your line of reasoning is unassailable. You have really enriched the conversation.
@@krusk3544 I always understood it this way tbh, I thought the guy seemed too calm and accepting the whole time in the hospital
@@TH-camallowedmynametobestolen "Understandable, have a nice day" but with extra steps.
Foreman: saves patient’s life
Also foreman: gets fired
The way house says "the right answer was NO" gives me chills every fricking time. Hugh Laurie you beauty! ❤️
Give me a clean death over a life of misery any day.
Just please don't murder any dogs in the process.
Peace is a lie. Dead is dead. Give me pain over death any day.
never.. survival is most important to me ..
Silverizael a far amount of people (family) won’t take in animals. Killing them and place with the owner is a kindness to the creature. They never forget.
I live in constant pain. It’s left me disabled and housebound. But I have a wonderful man, beautiful children, an amazing family.
I see both sides
“This would’ve been a perfect reason to lie”. “ Hi, Greg House”
This is why you have to stay behind to make sure that the patient takes his meds and not leave them alone with meds for even a second.
She goes "you employed her, you're responsible." I woulda snapped back. "YOU EMPLOYED ME so by that logic YOU'RE RESPONSIBLE"
That's what I thought!
She was highlighting the fact he turned the treatment of a patient into a competition that resulted in him dying, House was absolutely accountable as he was meant to be mentoring them
That would be a terrible argument, she could reply with "If i am responsible of your team's actions, i dont need you"
And then you would have been fired
If she wasn't responsible, there'd be no point for her to say anything to House. Yes she is responsible, which is precisely why she confronted him. She had to make sure he wouldn't do it again, as it is on her responsibility.
This episode always bothered me in that when 13 gave him the pills, she put them on the table to get the water for him but that table got moved while she was getting the water by two other members of the team. It was never her fault. It was the other team that caused this. House was ultimately to blame in the he had two teams competing over this case, and it cost the patient and his dog their lives.
I think everyone is to blame in this case.
The patient should have said that he didn't get the pills.
Thirteen literally forgot to finish her operation.
The other team cared more about making their own tests than treating the patient.
As for House, not only his employment game was dangerous for his patients and he knew it, but he also was careless because he knew the diagnostic, and even tried to experience the after-life instead of monitoring the game.
And finally... the dog is also to blame. He's the one who took the pills, he's the one who killed his master and himself.
I really blame everyone in this situation, even Cuddy for letting House do something as risky as this employment game.
@godlessmath The patient is not an adult. He is a PARALYZED adult. Of course she needed to take care of him a bit more than the average Joe.
As for the other team: remember they each had their own operation to do. It wasn't their responsibility to give the pills, it was 13's. They didn't even _know_ he had to take pills, or at least didn't know he didn't take them (since, again, 13 should have given them).
13 had ONE JOB, give him the pills (making sure he took them). She failed. ALL OTHER REASONS are excuses. IF you're supposed to drop off your kid at the daycare, but left the kid in a hot car because the building down from the daycare was on fire and you got distracted and "forgot" your kid in the hot car, every word that comes out of your mouth after that will be a pathetic excuse. WHY? Because you're the parent and you have the task of taking your kid to daycare and rendering that child into the care of the staff there!
@@victorpradha9946 cool story but the other reasons are valid
This was totally on House. He was playing games with his team while he should have focused on the patient. Usually it works for him but this time it killed the patient. And after he kills him he has the audacity to tell him there is no afterlife.
This episode has an error: House sticks a fork in the wall socket to be dead for a while to see if there is an afterlife; yet some seasons earlier, in the episode where he is diagnosing his own leg case with the students, he says he was clinically dead for a minute, and he was still conciouss.
House? Being contradictory?
The fact that House gave Thirteen a second chance made me tear up more than the dog being pet by the owner, but only by a little
He really shouldn't have.
@@jetuber why? She's a good doctor, and what he said is true, she ain't gonna make the same mistake after what happened there
I’m a grown man fully acknowledging this is a show but the scene where the patient dies right after getting his hand placed on his dogs head made me burst into tears.
Not only is this truly sad, but it also wakes up this anxiety in me where i once again remember my mortality.
At any point we could get an illness that renders us in pain or immobile, bringing a lot of suffering.
And any point we could stop to exist. Leave behind loved ones and simply disappear.
Yeah but right now you are ALIVE AND FINE... so don't spend the little bit of time we get to ride the roller coaster worrying about when the ride will end. Just enjoy the hill you are going down right now.
Great acting by the dying men with his dog it was such pleasant acting by both
Pleasant?
Pleasant ?
Pleasant?
Pleasant?
Pleasant?
Is everyone just ignoring the fact that like all the main characters got fired minus House and the other one
'If I was going to fire you, I wouldn't be giving you the lecture. I know you'll never let anything like this happen again.' House is definitely not an asshole, he's like a dad.
This was just very powerful to me. His acting and look of acceptance really sold it.
I just realized how smart the people who wrote this show are cus most people who get melanoma have red hair and freckles it increases the chances drastically so that’s crazy
Aaron Lopata There were few doctors who worked together with the writers.
1 doctor on the writing staff, 3 others proff reading the scripts
ReconCrusader u didn’t know gingers get melanoma only someone reading up on melanoma or studying would know that
Name Doesn’t matter I didn’t know that, well that means I’m screwed because I have red hair and freckles 😂😂
Lily McFalls not true avoid the sun and eat all alkaline diet because cancer will not and cannot thrive in a all alkaline diet period such examples are blueberries,almond,nuts,silk milk , blackberries, fish is a good choice too avoid eating red meats bacon , fast food you know common sense but look up all alkaline diet thank me later .
Just so you know - in the U.K. in the NHS as a doctor it takes a LOT more than your senior just going “you’re fired” because you made a risky call that saved a patient’s life despite being counter to protocol. That scene was just ridiculous to suggest a doctor can lose his job on such flimsy grounds.
try to remember that this is not a documentary... it is a drama tv show... but yeah... you are right
Different employment standards in America too maybe. Are the doctors here even unionized?
Actually, almost anywhere, a professionally-graded employee is hired on a probationary basis with any new employer, regardless of that employee's previous experience. As a recently hired employee, Foreman most likely would have been within his probationary period, enabling the employer to terminate employment for cause, cause in this case being failure to follow established protocol (remember that "protocol" in a health-care setting equates to "rules, regulations or statutes" in other professions).
@Shay Monte' So?
The only thing accurate about House is the medicine. Literally nothing else is. A practicing physician like House could never exist in any modern hospital because he would never pass his residency. Plus, Cutty EXPECTS to be sued because of House specifically? She budgets for them? That's malpractice right there.
The medicine, however, is real. As I understand it, every case in each episode is taken from a medical journal write-up somewhere in the world. Just not every one taking place in New Jersey.
*"Don't worry, I'm not scared."*
That was probably the part I started crying, especially seeing the poor pupples.
Dude says "I'm not scared" youtubes auto caption says "I'm scared".
If you guys are wondering this is season 4 episode 3. Its called "97 Seconds".
it says in the desc
It says in the desc
James Clark, Yes I know but sometimes people don't read the description and choose to read the comments and search for the season and epiosde there. Good point though.
Ariana Zuniga Hey wow wow the other dude said it first why am I taking the heat for this??? xD
@@scratchnsniff5405 Yes, I know that but sometimes people don't look at the description and choose to look at the comments and search for the season and episode there.
after watching this i realized dogs are the my breaking point , almost cried ,,, , ;(
A dog, like most animals, is both a weaker being and an animal. It's a tragedy a dog died or, any animal, when a higher force (humans) were the cause, because we're supposed to protect the weaker animals. Yet they are still animals, don't always think logical or predictable. A person dies they are a casualty because a lot of times (not all the times, no disrespect to innocent blood) the human himself was the cause of death. A dog bites a child, the child is at fault because the dog is still an animal, unpredictable and illogical.
The "hyprocrisy" comes from wanting to protect weaker animals (in the sense that you could easily kill them) but also respecting that they are still animals and you don't always understand them when they act out of fear or illogical.
With my logic its a known schizophrenic with aggressive tendencies that doctors know could boil up at any time and then letting that schizophrenic play with your child. That would be the correct example. Dogs may be rational, but no dog is evil when they are born. Circumstances and mishandling makes the attack things. Bulldogs for example can be very loving dogs yet they are always portrayed as this evil and aggressive dog. With your logic a good example would be someone that doesnt know how to drive a car driving a car and crashing and then blaming the car on the accident. (Someone that doesnt know how to handle what they're doing and doing something wrong, then having a bad consequence) Also with the last sentence you seem very superior and god-like to the dog, wanting to kill it when it doesnt behave the way you want it to behave, not allowing it to be its own animal but your toy that you discard when it doesnt work right.
Also the example with the child is somewhat misleading because i'm assuming theres an adult nearby (as you should always supervise children playing with animals, for the exact reasons stated in the earlier comment) which is meant to have full control over the situation.
To complete the comment, if you were a victim of crime, you'd prefer to shoot some random animal as redemption, but not pursue the actual criminal. (Not punishing the one that should be in full control over the situation at that moment, but some other party)
Are you a cat person or just a moron? I can't seem to figure it out
But in the law, if a schizophrenic pleas insanity they get to go to a mental institution because they were not 100% rational. That is why they don't go to prison. They go to a mental institution because they didn't know right or wrong. Like an animal. So yes, even in your example, that is logical.
did some1 order dogmeat kobab 🤤🍗 ?
The most difficult episodes in the series. The sad passing of the poor, invalid man who wanted for nothing but to enjoy time with his dog had it ripped away from him due to a silly mistake. The acting was absolutely superb.
“You’ve confused saving her life with doing the right thing” is one of the most insane sentences I’ve ever heard lol
House: A show that can make us laugh hysterically, cry uncontrollably and think deeply about the body we possess!
6:36 "I may be playing 'Orderly number 48', but dammit I'm gonna make an impression!"
Is that you?
After that performance he should be orderly number 9
"It is in the nature of medicine that you are going to screw up. You are going to kill someone." - He put that out there all the way back in season 1.
Well screwing up in medicine and trusting that a patient who wanted to die would take his meds aren’t really the same thing lol
@@jamesynfgkinda are
I like the fact that when the patient said that he wants to give up that House looked a bit shocked, like he was in disbelief that the patient would give up so easily
This actually made me cry seeing him with the dog and saying its ok
Not many scenes make me sad but this was extremely heart wrenching
That scene when he asks that they put his hand on the dogs head....just before he dies.....makes me cry everytime
Every single time I hear the piano start playing I grab the tissues. The score for this show was so good
When he was petting the dog, he reminded me of my Dad when he died and I cried so hard
6:21 - Cuddy, I know you're trying to make a point, but that broken logic makes no sense. You employed House, and by extension, employed 13, meaning it's your fault the patient died.
But in the case if medicine, if a patient dies from unforeseen event, who is at fault?
Ulquiorra Cifer that's pretty much how all works work if you can say that. As a boss you have to go for the one that's bellow you and that other person would go for the other responsable.
Fault and responsibility are 2 different things sometimes. The buck stops with Cuddy but House is to blame.
IT IS her fault, thats why shes angry. If a doctor under House supervision kills somebody, u think House is in danger? NO, cuddy is in danger. Thats why she is mad at him
It was everyone’s fault, but house was the one to blame for most of it, if you watch the episode you’ll see 13 didn’t make sure the guy took the pills (her fault) because the men arrived to do a lot of tests on the patient, but the women didn’t informed anyone of their first diagnosis which was the right diagnosis, but all of it was because of the “competition”. Also house didnt care because he was distracted with the suicidal guy from the clinic, which ended up dying anyways...IMO cuddy was right, most of it was houses fault for treating the life of the guy like a game, putting his employees against each other and on top of it being distracted with something else instead of supervising the condition of HIS actual patient, he was the guys doctor after all, and he was irresponsible and not doing his job so it’s his fault
"Hi, Greg House!"
This guy is at the epitome of humour and I love it...
This is the only episode that truly touched me. watching him look into the dogs eyes as his life seeped out and to know that it could all be avoided
The difference between a good and a bad boss.
GOD DAMMIT WHY IS IT THIS THAT ACTUALLY GETS ME FOR ONCE, IVE SEEN SO MANY EPISODES AND THE ONE WITH DOGGE GETS ME
This is the first legit clip that actually had me crying
What a difficult and sobering/mature decision to make. A life of intense suffering isn’t a life at all. Fantastic acting by all involved. Watching the dog react was horrifying to see.
“I know you’re not going to let anything like this happen again.” For as blunt as House can be, I appreciate the wisdom in keeping 13. He knows she’s a good doctor and the regret she feels is enough, better to be a learning experience, the price was already paid.
So did the patient have skin cancer? Was he going to die anyway and Thirteen's screw up just made him die faster or was he going to live and be fine if she didn't screw up?
Nah, he just had worms and would've lived, he probably wanted to die. Which is probably why he spilled the cup on the floor. Since he cannot get up, either he just wanted to remove it or purposely gave it to the dog so it would go with him.
HOW DARE THEY PLAY WITH MY HEART LIKE THIS
I'm usually not one to cry at these episodes, although they are very emotional. But god damnit the dog got me sobbing 😭
The only House clip that’s ever made me cry god damn
The dialogue between Wilson and House is awesome. Essential issues, "Misery's better than nothing"... philosophers get to work!
Do a compilation of every bet that house has one. It will be quite a hefty list
this moment in the episode was heartbreaking
literally wasn’t bawling till the dog
6:29 could’ve swore I saw House tearing up just a little bit
Ivermectin 🤣 This hits differently in 2021
Muh horse medicine.
@@Lord_Yoshi which was always a funny angle for the left to take because the majority of ivermectin’s recorded uses are human medical reasons
@@Lord_Yoshi
Thats nobody's fault but the people who bought the stuff for horses because they were ignoring doctors to treat a viral infection with an anti parasitic.
At least it was targeting a parasite in this episode.
“He shouldn’t be making a decision based on a lie!”
I know he’s talking about religion, but this still applies to life. Some things you just don’t know about, yeah, but you should be confident in your life choices. Know the rewards and consequences before you decide. And don’t be stupid about it. Don’t cut corners, and learn from your mistakes.
We lie without even knowing we lie. It's our nature. We're wired to seek confirmation and to be suspicious of out-group contradictions. The logic centers of our mind serve our emotions and will concoct rational-seeming excuses after the fact, and do everything in its power to defend them.
Virtually all thinking is religious thinking.
Kevin D. When it comes to hope maybe, but if you’re thinking about what steak to eat for dinner, that’s not religious. And definitely not when you’re thinking about sports or real storytelling. But I always have been thinking about how the heck religion can make it’s way into a story when, in stories, you don’t need a god.
@@LoriWolfcat Sure much of that is. What to eat? We often make poor choices but find rationalizations to make us feel better. "I had a bad day." "Just one more won't matter." and more. Or what if it's a food we're unfamiliar with and we turn it away? We used emotion to decide (because we couldn't know we wouldn't like it), and then we rationalize why we didn't want it after the fact, probably making minor things bigger than they really were.
Sports? Um, yeah, very emotional thinking. Sports is tribal, tribal is emotional.
Stories? We read stories because they make us feel. That's what sticks with us the most. How we felt going through that journey.
The human language is emotion, and our thought are emotional, peppered with real logic and reason when we're lucky.
As someone with a service dog, this hurt to watch. I never want my Keelah to wonder why I didn't wake up one day, and that's genuinely kept me from suicide many times. Ima go cry and hug my baby bear now.
Hope you are doing okay!
Keep on keeping on! Truly hope you're doing well.
Gets me every time 🥲😭
I love this show and the actors ❤️
I am graduating from nursing school in August and can’t wait to help people just like this man. I am already crying just knowing how many people I will see lose their loved ones.
Oh God the only one thing that makes me cry is the idea of leaving my 4 legged friend behind .
Omg, the guy holding the dog as he took his last few breaths made me cry
Dude dying on a TV show, it happens.
Dude dying on a TV show with his dog giving... giving him.... BAAW!!
6:20 I LOVE this scene
It's the only time Lisa shows she is House's BOSS
6:22 Look at that look House gives her. He knows this time she isn't playing around
There's no negotiation
No witty banter
No compromise
No sympathy
She is Ice cold
As a former EMT who has seen people "cross the bridge" that was a REALLY good portrayal of slow cancerous death. That actor did a bang-up job. Of course, in real life there's not often a fluffy dog to cry and beautiful supermodel doctor by your side... but the way he grew weaker and could barely speak... that was pretty bang on.
Also... I've seen (and my brother the Paramedic has also seen) old dying people shoot wide-awake for a brief moment of lucidity and say something like "Oh they're here! they're here for me!" or scream out a deceased loved one's name and reach out their hand to grab some invisible hand and then die. So maybe House is wrong afterall... who knows?
The fact that the dog cried knowing he was gone tipped me over the edge :( Now I'm a wreck.
The dog actor is priceless. ❤
R.I.P. Doggo :(
House can do almost anything and Cuddy never gets really angry. Until House saves lives. But when he screws up she gets angry for real. She is not yelling or screaming but when she says: "You are responsible." it leaves even House speechless. This shows her true character.
That dog was so good... right until the end.
I’m crying at the dog part
House the type of guy to go into a hospice and tell everyone there there's no god just misery.
This was a sad episode.. but I liked it when he stabbed an electrical socket
It kinda annoyed me, since that's not how it works. He wouldn't have been electrocuted
DarkPhoenix It depends. If it’s a gfci switch it’ll trip and interrupt, but I’m pretty sure older sockets would still zap you
Seriously why is it that whenever a dog is brought into a situation like this i start bawling
the very second they bring the dog over this goes from 1 to 1000000 in a millisecond
They HAD to put the damn dog in didn't they?!
Goddamn cute pupper making me cry...
Luckily the dog is a paid actor...
4:20 ivermectin makes it's appearance before covid 😜
Then and billions of other times.
that dog part made me tear up thanks
goddammit.. I forgot how much I cried watching this the first time, and now I'm here drying my eyes once again..
Is this what it's like to die alone ?
Brooks Equine I’d probably say it’s pretty damn close.
No, this is what it's like to die with a dog.
@@levoGAMES :at least he had a sentient being who loved him in his last days .
This is so hitting home .
I've NO FAMILY but my Border Collie. Sooo , I'm right there with this dying guy . It's scarey really .
You can make your own family. =)
I admit, I don't like dogs, but despite of that, that scene with the dog made me very emotional. I didn't know borkers could chop onions. And without being seen by the camera. Bravo!
Omg the dog 😭😭😭
Famous last words: "It's ok. I'm not scared." I love that.
Why'd they have to put in the dog?! I am bawling here...that got me crying.
A man accepting death and giving up? It hurts bad
A man accepting death with his best friend by his side? It’s freaking painful
A man accepting death with his best friend dying moments later? Words can’t describe...