Reading some comments on here, I didn't realize there were so many Scott Gorham bashers among Lizzy fans. Gorham may not have been as technically skilled as Gary Moore or John Sykes, but Gorham played with heart. There was substance as well as style to his playing, which is a hard combo to get right. Gorham is a great guitarist, really underappreciated
@@alexainsworth9102 I thought Snowy did ok with Lizzy. Being up against the likes of Gorham, Moore and Robertson will make most guitarists look mediocre.
"When I'm in England, I say, I'm from Ireland. When I'm in Ireland, I say, I'm from Dublin. When I'm in Dublin, I say, I'm from Crumlin. When I'm in Crumlin, I say, Leighlin Road. When I'm in Leighlin Road, I say, I'm a Lynott." - Phil Lynott
스노위 와이트Snowy White라는 블루스 기타리스트가 있었던 아름다운 시절에 감사합니다. 20대 시절에 어렵게 듣던 Thin Lizzy의 음악이 이제는 너무나 정겹게 들리네요 그리운 Gary Moore도 생각나고.. Greetings From Korea 50대 남자가
VERY IRISH!! Black Rose, Yankee Rose Yellow Rose of Texas , EVERY ROSE HAS ITS THORNS , . . . this Black Rose of Shari owns them all unapologetically . . . 🌹❤️
Ireland's greatest rock band - bar none, & that includes U2 who sold out to US imperialism. Phil Lynott is a genius who has never received the credit he deserves. He created a unique sound and wrote some of the greatest classic rock songs ever, like Jailbreak, Renegade, and the Boys are Back in Town, ably aided and abetted by Brian Downey and the two geat guitarists, sometimes three. Phil was a great bassist, creative artiste, and a charismatic front man. RIP son of Ireland. The Black Rose holds you close to its heart.
A classic in every sense of the word. Thin Lizzy is a band of the ages and will always be so. RIP Gary Moore and Phil Lynott. Both masters of the music they make. Brillaint stuff.
i hope Phil can see how his music is still dancing in the moonlight. He left Way toooooooo soon. I wish my kids could see him, I wish more of this world could have seen his brilliance.
Lots of people on here saying how bad this version is and how bad there were Well I bet any one of you would love to have been at a thin lizzy concert to be in the presence of this great band and all the musicians in it I was fortunate enough to have done this through all there line ups and it was always a very special experience Even at the near end , the middle and at the very beginning Thin lizzy
Unreachable, phil lynotts voice having All time catching a Cold, unique. Snowy White and scott gorham on guitar, brian downey on drums. Tremendous, i find no words, what a sound with irish Traditional elements. Greetings from county dithmarsha, germany.
BRIAN DOWNEY IS A GOD!!! If u go back and listen to anything from Black Rose you can see how effective he at working amazing fills in to the beat as well as not undermine the awesomeness of Scott Gorman and Gary Moore guitars on the album
Whatever you say, I don't hear the audience complaining. Snowy White did a fantastic job, Chinatown and Renegade feature some of the finest harmonies, solos and riffs among the entire Lizzy discography catalog. Too bad he came into the picture once Lynott & Gorham were into heroin. Absolutely underrated guitarist, who needs Moore or Robertson, I insist!
You're either trolling or utterly delusional! Bell, Robbo, Moore and Sykes all smoked Snowy White, in every category of guitar playing. White only got the gig because Phil & Scott were totally fucked up on heroin. White is a blues guitarist, at best. That style normally translates over very well to rock and metal, but White just didn't fit. I liked the songs Renegade, Chinatown and Killer on the Loose. The albums though were weak as piss, overall. Black spots on an otherwise excellent discography. Live in concert, White was dull as ditch-water. Boring solos and no movement, no interaction with the audience. Just nothing. It nearly killed Thin Lizzy
I agree with you Snowy doesn't fit thin Lizzy, however he's absolutely amazing at what he does in his music! He's such a melodic player and has some really soulful music and such a sweet tone!
Cantan estupendamente bien ,hay partes donde salen en evidencia cada miembro de la tropa ,batería guitarras ...son buenísimos,los amo. Q pena q ya ni están...GRANDES MÚSICOS,unos CRACKS!
was democracy and the views of teh people and this is what the peoples of this island voted for in ireland.. so thats the way it is and i believe in that..thank you
Phil looking handsome as ever....Sigh, Scot looks cool....Got my ticket for Hammersmith in Jan 2011. Can't belive he's been gone for 25 years. Phil had so much more to do.....poet, songwriter and the best front man ever. Eternally Out Here!!!!! Wish it was Gary Moore alongside Scot as you know it makes sense....
Desgraciadamente en esa época phil y scot ya tenían problemas con la heroína y se les notaba .Maldito veneno. Rip por phil siempre te estaré agradecido por tu musica
John Nesbitt agreed Downey carried the band at that time Phil and Scott were whacked out of their minds and and Snowy probably would have been doing his laundry than be there
This song was written mostly by Gary Moore and no other guitar player ever came close to playing it as it was written. Add that to the fact that Lynott and Gorham were off their faces and Snowy White would have preferred to be off window cleaning and you've pretty much got it. And as for the ridiculous keyboards loitering in the background! Thank Christ for Brian Downey.
Totally. Agreed with all replies to this comment. Moore had a different technique to the others, resulting in a failure to reproduce his work while off your tits, lol. There's a great version of Gary with Scott on a reunion gig. Brian Robertson also comes out and makes a tit of himself. Dressed like he was when he was 20 and playing like he was when he was on heroin!
@@Pattbonn47 Agree, The reunion version is the best version I have heard, only Gary Moore can play it with the feel and speed required, I liked Robbo at his best too but the reunion tribute gig wasnt his best effort, looked like he was in 2nd gear. Downey never fails to impress, just played better with age....
It really does sound like Scott breaks a string at the really fast part ....and there really is no other way to do it without that open g string ...Snowy has a clean sound , but sounds like he is nailing the fast harmony bit ....Gary Moore guitar parts are a tall order .
Gary Moore stated in at least one interview that Gorham never managed to learn that section. It was certainly far faster than anything else he did play.
Brian Downey oh yeah! Good drummer is alway cure for drunk guitarist :D I had the same... forgot how to play my songs, and needed minuts, not seconds to recover my memory ... It sucks, but we arent bots. Scott is imho one of the most influential rock guitarist .
@wattsta07 That is the ever awesome Brian Downey,drummer from the lean days, and the best double bass drummer since the dawn of rock time....well, him and Ian Paice.... I met Brian...he sent my once small son ( now big boy! ) custom signed sticks. Bri is ma darlin'! Thin Lizzy is still timeless!
Jeanette, ich hab' dir das nich gesagt, jetzt schreib' ich's hierhin: Ich liebe Dich. Schon immer. Ich finde dich nicht mehr, paarmal versucht, na auch egal, ich wünsche und ich hoffe, das es dir sehr gut geht, wie mir. Ich liebe dich, kein Zweifel, so siehts aus. Danke! Für alles, danke.
Did Scott lose a string during the solo? The solo's faster part starts well but in 4:30 it goes wrong and he is not able to play the solo properly after that point.
Reading some comments on here, I didn't realize there were so many Scott Gorham bashers among Lizzy fans. Gorham may not have been as technically skilled as Gary Moore or John Sykes, but Gorham played with heart. There was substance as well as style to his playing, which is a hard combo to get right. Gorham is a great guitarist, really underappreciated
Snowy seems to be the same with people bashing him but not seeing how amazing his own music really is, Snowy just wasn't the right guitarist for Lizzy
@@alexainsworth9102 I thought Snowy did ok with Lizzy. Being up against the likes of Gorham, Moore and Robertson will make most guitarists look mediocre.
Couldnt agree more saw them several times and goram was electric.
Scott Gorham is the best Lizzy's guitarist along with Robbo. Always been, Always Will be. Period.
@@tadzagogo Scott was closest to Phil out of all the guitarists, which I think made a difference to the bands overall sound.
Brian Downey is such a great drummer.
Agree!
Saw him play at the annual vibe for Phil a couple years ago and he still rules
"When I'm in England, I say,
I'm from Ireland.
When I'm in Ireland, I say, I'm from Dublin.
When I'm in Dublin, I say, I'm from Crumlin.
When I'm in Crumlin, I say, Leighlin Road.
When I'm in Leighlin Road, I say,
I'm a Lynott." - Phil Lynott
I love this mate ❤🍻
It’s not powerful or meaningful is it lol
스노위 와이트Snowy White라는 블루스 기타리스트가 있었던 아름다운 시절에 감사합니다.
20대 시절에 어렵게 듣던 Thin Lizzy의 음악이 이제는 너무나 정겹게 들리네요
그리운 Gary Moore도 생각나고..
Greetings From Korea 50대 남자가
The greatest Irish rock band of all time and one of the best anywhere.
One of the best songs ever
VERY IRISH!! Black Rose, Yankee Rose Yellow Rose of Texas , EVERY ROSE HAS ITS THORNS , . . . this Black Rose of Shari owns them all unapologetically . . . 🌹❤️
Ireland's greatest rock band - bar none, & that includes U2 who sold out to US imperialism. Phil Lynott is a genius who has never received the credit he deserves. He created a unique sound and wrote some of the greatest classic rock songs ever, like Jailbreak, Renegade, and the Boys are Back in Town, ably aided and abetted by Brian Downey and the two geat guitarists, sometimes three. Phil was a great bassist, creative artiste, and a charismatic front man. RIP son of Ireland. The Black Rose holds you close to its heart.
Thin Lizzy all the way- U2?
U2 who?
the best bands to come out of Ireland are Thin Lizzy, The Cranberries and U2, in that order
But phil isnt underrated. All people appreciate his work, also his unique voice.
@@somedaysometime You missed out the Chieftains and Clannad, not to mention Enya. Criminal omissions.
@@johnlittle4833When I hear Enya, my feet are going to sleep 😴. Terrible
We never forget how good a drummer you are Brian Downey,,, Met you in KK last month , A LEGEND
A classic in every sense of the word. Thin Lizzy is a band of the ages and will always be so. RIP Gary Moore and Phil Lynott. Both masters of the music they make. Brillaint stuff.
I miss Thin Lizzy, the best hardrock band ever!
Idk about that one bud
Personally for me ,everything Lizzy did was good whatever guitarist was in the band . Blessed I saw them live just the once
The legendary Brian Downey on drums!
I remember when i first bought this.My favourite song from this band. Still have the original album. A classic song.
Definitely. Glad to see someone else has this as there favorite Lizzy song.
This and 'Emerald'. Both are stunning songs.
Der Genialste Songschreiber seiner Zeit für mich Forever.
i hope Phil can see how his music is still dancing in the moonlight. He left Way toooooooo soon. I wish my kids could see him, I wish more of this world could have seen his brilliance.
Twin leed guitars of Scott Gorham and Snowy White. Superb.
Excellent drum solo!!!! Have always loved thin Lizzy!!
listen to the gary moore and scott goram version on the tribute night fantastic
+Mike Athersmith Yes it was very good
I Agree... the Guitar-duel are magic.. only the banjo-duel from the movie Deliverance is better ;)
best celtic rock of all time !
I love when Scott plays the solo. Hilarious!!!!
Thank you!Great to hear 3 guitar together, and the Celtic myths :)
That's why they had a drum solo...no one can play the last section like Gary Moore
Greatest Rock Band Ever ! Love the Black Rose
Lots of people on here saying how bad this version is and how bad there were
Well I bet any one of you would love to have been at a thin lizzy concert to be in the presence of this great band and all the musicians in it
I was fortunate enough to have done this through all there line ups and it was always a very special experience
Even at the near end , the middle and at the very beginning
Thin lizzy
One of the greatest rock songs of all times...
Unreachable, phil lynotts voice having All time catching a Cold, unique. Snowy White and scott gorham on guitar, brian downey on drums. Tremendous, i find no words, what a sound with irish Traditional elements. Greetings from county dithmarsha, germany.
Pure rock n roll, R.I.P Phil, rock legend
BRIAN DOWNEY IS A GOD!!!
If u go back and listen to anything from Black Rose you can see how effective he at working amazing fills in to the beat as well as not undermine the awesomeness of Scott Gorman and Gary Moore guitars on the album
Absolutely!
thanks for uploading these videos! i love Thin Lizzy!
Amazing drum-solo. It is not often your hear that good!
The greatest of all time! Phil was god for the lizzy fans
Boy, they are really missing Gary on this performance.
Agree.....he was the master of this song and his work on the "one night in dublin" tribute show with Scott Gorham showed how great he was.
Probably the best band ever... What a song!
This is the best version ever
by far they best piece of music from lizzy
Whatever you say, I don't hear the audience complaining.
Snowy White did a fantastic job, Chinatown and Renegade feature some of the finest harmonies, solos and riffs among the entire Lizzy discography catalog. Too bad he came into the picture once Lynott & Gorham were into heroin. Absolutely underrated guitarist, who needs Moore or Robertson, I insist!
You're either trolling or utterly delusional! Bell, Robbo, Moore and Sykes all smoked Snowy White, in every category of guitar playing. White only got the gig because Phil & Scott were totally fucked up on heroin. White is a blues guitarist, at best. That style normally translates over very well to rock and metal, but White just didn't fit. I liked the songs Renegade, Chinatown and Killer on the Loose. The albums though were weak as piss, overall. Black spots on an otherwise excellent discography. Live in concert, White was dull as ditch-water. Boring solos and no movement, no interaction with the audience. Just nothing. It nearly killed Thin Lizzy
I agree with you Snowy doesn't fit thin Lizzy, however he's absolutely amazing at what he does in his music! He's such a melodic player and has some really soulful music and such a sweet tone!
Cantan estupendamente bien ,hay partes donde salen en evidencia cada miembro de la tropa ,batería guitarras ...son buenísimos,los amo. Q pena q ya ni están...GRANDES MÚSICOS,unos CRACKS!
Best rockband ever 🖤🤘🏾+
Absolutely perfect
They play this so non chalently....almost effortless....love it!!
Its out of tune...
@@rougeirishman0118 How exactly? Tell me.
Makes me cry every time.
omg, that drum solo!
Simply the best Irish themes rock song.
Awesome! Brian Downey killed it!
LOVE IT THANKS
RIP PHIL
maybe my favorite lizzy song!!!!!!!
The song of my youth :)
was democracy and the views of teh people and this is what the peoples of this island voted for in ireland.. so thats the way it is and i believe in that..thank you
Hell yeay!!!! Thank you so much for posting this
Phil Lynott the Black Irish Rose . Thin Lizzy cannot be Topped
TRUE HEROES........XX
Phil looking handsome as ever....Sigh, Scot looks cool....Got my ticket for Hammersmith in Jan 2011. Can't belive he's been gone for 25 years. Phil had so much more to do.....poet, songwriter and the best front man ever. Eternally Out Here!!!!! Wish it was Gary Moore alongside Scot as you know it makes sense....
1-01-2021... the realm of the black rose has returned,
That one mother fucking intense drum solo
A good filler as they were all too fucking high
Love a good 80s drum solo 👍
Beautiful beautiful... those were the days
¡Fantastico!
Alan, you're absolutely correct. I just listened to the version you mentioned. No comparison.
Legend.
Desgraciadamente en esa época phil y scot ya tenían problemas con la heroína y se les notaba .Maldito veneno. Rip por phil siempre te estaré agradecido por tu musica
Oh to have a time machine!
Fantastic job from Downey here. He got the lads out of jail on this one.
John Nesbitt agreed Downey carried the band at that time Phil and Scott were whacked out of their minds and and Snowy probably would have been doing his laundry than be there
Thin Lizzy Baby !! Drumming is Aces !!
This song was written mostly by Gary Moore and no other guitar player ever came close to playing it as it was written. Add that to the fact that Lynott and Gorham were off their faces and Snowy White would have preferred to be off window cleaning and you've pretty much got it. And as for the ridiculous keyboards loitering in the background! Thank Christ for Brian Downey.
agreed 100%
Totally. Agreed with all replies to this comment. Moore had a different technique to the others, resulting in a failure to reproduce his work while off your tits, lol.
There's a great version of Gary with Scott on a reunion gig. Brian Robertson also comes out and makes a tit of himself. Dressed like he was when he was 20 and playing like he was when he was on heroin!
@@Pattbonn47 Agree, The reunion version is the best version I have heard, only Gary Moore can play it with the feel and speed required, I liked Robbo at his best too but the
reunion tribute gig wasnt his best effort, looked like he was in 2nd gear. Downey never fails to impress, just played better with age....
@@markwilliams-ny6tr He was on some gear for sure, lol. 😂😂
droomszzaahh!! 🙌!!! legend!!!
Doesn’t get any better than this
No way !
tell me the legend of long ago, when thin lizzy ruled the world!!!
Who's listening St. Patrick's Day 2021? ☘
2024 💚☘️
one off the best
You can sense the fear as the BIG solo approaches hhhheeeellllllp
lol!
Indeed and they completely lose it. A horrible period in Lizzy history for sure.
@@twilightatireland scott was able to do it but a string breaked
Well, I feel the vibe!
meme les plus grand musicien se trompent . nous sommes des etres humains . bravo a thin lyzzi
WHAT AN ANTHEM
Mr Brian Downey. That it is all you need to know. Still going strong.
The drummer is back there just working the fuck out of that kit, whilst the boys are back rocking.
Happy birthday Brian downey,
Legend!
It really does sound like Scott breaks a string at the really fast part ....and there really is no other way to do it without that open g string ...Snowy has a clean sound , but sounds like he is nailing the fast harmony bit ....Gary Moore guitar parts are a tall order .
Gary Moore stated in at least one interview that Gorham never managed to learn that section. It was certainly far faster than anything else he did play.
The great song!
💚🧡
wow...simply the fuckin best at this shit!!!!
great song the album.
Brian Downey really held this shit together!
Claramente a Scott se le rompe una cuerda... Amo Thin Lizzy!!
Even Brian Downey couldn't save this rendition of Black Rose
RIP Phil
Esta cancion la tiene en uno de sus tatuajes Axl Rose . Es mi favorita de esta gran banda irlandesa
haha scott switched guitars at the end when he came out pretending he had a broken string or something what a band!:)
Hahahahah well spotted ..😂
What a song
I kinda like Snoweys playing now that I listen too it again. Too the point, no frills. Kind of reminds me of bagpipes, some of it. Very cool.
Cristoooo santooo l'ho trovataaaa!!!!Siiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii:D
Brian Downey oh yeah! Good drummer is alway cure for drunk guitarist :D
I had the same... forgot how to play my songs, and needed minuts, not seconds to recover my memory ... It sucks, but we arent bots. Scott is imho one of the most influential rock guitarist .
What happened during the solo? Gorham lost it.
Tell me the legend of young Cuchulainn how his eyes were dark his expression sullen.
great folk hard rock.
RIP Gary Moore. Say Hi To Phil For Us All.
@wattsta07 That is the ever awesome Brian Downey,drummer from the lean days, and the best double bass drummer since the dawn of rock time....well, him and Ian Paice.... I met Brian...he sent my once small son ( now big boy! ) custom signed sticks. Bri is ma darlin'! Thin Lizzy is still timeless!
Jeanette, ich hab' dir das nich gesagt, jetzt schreib' ich's hierhin: Ich liebe Dich. Schon immer. Ich finde dich nicht mehr, paarmal versucht, na auch egal, ich wünsche und ich hoffe, das es dir sehr gut geht, wie mir. Ich liebe dich, kein Zweifel, so siehts aus. Danke! Für alles, danke.
Did Scott lose a string during the solo? The solo's faster part starts well but in 4:30 it goes wrong and he is not able to play the solo properly after that point.
this is a way better than the album version!x-)
Fkn amazing...