Yes. SCR has an arcade-like approach, so people who are in wanting of a noice gaming experience they can go SCR. Roblox simulation players like me prefer realism, BR then.
@@ARandom_Toad Well, just like I said, its the reason why most U13 people play SCR. They just want fun driving trains here and there and not wanna drive such a realistic train with very sensitive controls. I am in both discords, and I know how the SCR Discord is compared to BR's. Its not that SCR isnt realistic at all, it has stations, all the rolling stock, signal system and much more entirely based on real life, but as a game it needs to have a differentiator which it has in its arcade style and livery system.
I’m quite happy with SCR’s physics and controls, nice and simple, I don’t want to have to manage all these buttons and the separate brake ect. I just want to drive a train
I rlly like SCR, it feels like a game but it’s also somewhat real, definitely not as realistic as other train games out there, but it’s just a good representation of a train simulation game at its finest.
You can’t really compare the rolling stock and number of stations between SCR and BR. SCR is over 5 years old and BR have just started at the beginning of 2023.
Well, SCR is better in terms of sheer size of trains and stations, but BR is unbeatable on realism and the sounds produced by trains on points, to me They are both Beautiful, but BR has and small qualities that surpass SCR.
Maybe one. Either way, doesn't really matter unless they add more electrification (be it 3rd rail or overhead wires, some trains including a good chunk of the electrostars can do both)
Well. BR does having a Main Line full of Overhead Wires. Class 387 Electrostars would fit nicely as a Regional train. And when it is 8-12 coaches, we can use them as Semi-Fast Commuters.
@realfrowz Atleast BR Has Working Pantagraphs NPC Passengers Free guarding Tilting railways Interactive cockpit More liveries Weather dynamics Day and night cycle Working Wipers Realistic train sounds Railroad crossing sounds The buffer will stop your train if you're to fast Bird and sea sounds at longbow Beach Realistic graphics More coins in each drive BR Has Actual UK Time Actual train names BR Has Realistic liveries that Is similar to real life BR Has cars Some trains have smoke Menu is clean Guards earn more coins Realistic Braking and acceleration and declaration sounds Hardworking and productive developers That's what they have.
The door in Br in my opinios more realistic and better, likez in scr the train just beep beep and close the door with no sounds while close the door, look at BR class 220 is very realistic
I think nowadays SCR has far better detail on its trains, it’s just generally the playerlag, train movement physics, camera, and sounds that dissappoint
I hate both, TSW 3 is better. Graphics, realism, selection of trains, has more maps than that one bullshit copy of Britain… Only downside is that DLCs are a bit expensive
In my personal experience, I find SCR easier for beginners and a better option for lower-end devices (maybe) As for the realism, with the new brakes in v2.0 it definitely is turning slightly more realistic. I myself struggle with BR, which lags me out completely, and the controls also are hard to master. However I definitely agree with some people that BR *may* surpass SCR with its high-graphic and realistic trains.
I think SCR overall is slightly better than BR (FOR NOW) Once BR has a Respactable amount of rolling stock, more roles like DS and SG, and more lines to drive it will definitely overtake SCR and any other Roblox train game simply due to how realistic and detailed it is
Not really a fair comparison stations wise. BR has not been out as long as SCR and will expand over time, just like SCR did. Therefore I would not make that a thing during this video as I don’t see it to be a completely fair comparison. I do agree with all the others tho so well done with that.
Well, I know, but that is one of the most important categories. However, there is always a difference in opinion. Some say quality of stations also mater in number of stations so do the quantity. Well, I took the quality one in too, so in that case, SCR wins. BR did have more stations than SCR on its release, 19.
@Railwaystar_Roblox you can't compare them BR is focused on a hyperrealistic aspect and it's unfair to compare it to an arcade game. A fairer comparison would be SCR Vs GCR WCR Vs SCR SCR (BEFORE NEXT GEN) Vs MTG
BR is a really detailed game, but everytime I play it I get bored so fast, and I don't know why. On the other hand, when I play SCR, I could be playing for a lot more without getting bored. DOn't get me wrong, I like br but I just find SCR more fun (imo)
Actually I wanna play GCR and experience it again (I forgot it all) but the game doesnt load, which is holding me back from playing and making an edit.
I would say for realism BR but I can’t play it on mobile or Xbox, which is why I always play stepford. If stepford actually had AI passengers it would be so much better.
I know Iike both Stepford County Railway & British Railway, but to be honest, British Railway is a bit better because of it's realism, graphics, speed & it's controls.
Part-2: th-cam.com/users/shortszZtBc3RV7Ag?feature=share Edit: Please stop fighting whether SCR is better or BR. We all have our own opinions and everyone would have a different one. So in the end both the games are the best for that kind of audience.
Personally, i would prefer SCR becouse of the variety of trains, better routes, announcements and companies. Becouse they all have different routes and onboard Announcements unlike BR, but I have been playing BR more becouse of the realistic style and Simply becouse SCR doesn’t update that much now.
i disagree, BR has way better graphics, attention to detail and physics, br has a smaller team aswell as a huge focus on detail. scr has completely destroyed its map eith turning the best stations into shit, leighton city and coxly were incredible a long time ago, but now they are dead as hell, i remember spawning at coxly depot and then using the track eith a huge turn and small scenery to get onto there, truly peak, butvscr has destroyed that, the BR team are working hard to supply us with new content.
@@DelinquentRevengeBR has like a lot of skill issue and a smaller map, Plus SCR has even updated more mesh trains to take away BR players so beat that :)
@@Owen_trains2010 BR has a significantly more detailed map, more attention to detail, more realistic models, more livery variety, speed limit warnings, clean door animations, almost perfect train physics, despite having a smaller map it has way more detail and WAY more skill requirements than SCR, also no pointless training that is super overhhped and strict. beat that :).
I personally like SCR liveries more, they just look really good
Agreed.
The detail Br devs put into the trains I love but I love Scr since it has more content than br rn
@@xboxgamerNorris yep true till this day.
Agree
They’re fictional, as much as i love them i prefer the realistic ones
it depends if you want to have a Semi-reallistic experience or a Super-realistic experience
Yes. SCR has an arcade-like approach, so people who are in wanting of a noice gaming experience they can go SCR.
Roblox simulation players like me prefer realism, BR then.
By looking how people behave in both SCR and BR discord server, you’ll know why
SCR is not realistic at all 💀
@@ARandom_Toad Well, just like I said, its the reason why most U13 people play SCR. They just want fun driving trains here and there and not wanna drive such a realistic train with very sensitive controls.
I am in both discords, and I know how the SCR Discord is compared to BR's.
Its not that SCR isnt realistic at all, it has stations, all the rolling stock, signal system and much more entirely based on real life, but as a game it needs to have a differentiator which it has in its arcade style and livery system.
if u want realism, go play TS Classic
I sometimes imagine a collaboration between BR and SCR.
Me too!
well the devs do have connections with the br devs i know a sound developer at scr actually works with some devs at BR
I’m quite happy with SCR’s physics and controls, nice and simple, I don’t want to have to manage all these buttons and the separate brake ect. I just want to drive a train
you have an option if you want simple or advanced controls
The brakes are too slow@@polaarj
Yep
the brakes are being separated
Just keep in mind that driving a train irl isn't as simple as SCR or BR but I see where you're coming from
In my opinion, Grand Continental Railways is the most realisitc british railway game and is HIGHLY underrated
I never really got to play GCR myself..
@@Railwaystar_Roblox try it out, it is more realistic than BR
@@melissagreentree4787 maybe becuase it doesnt run on shit roblox servers
then again TSW is overpriced and the addons are kinda mid tbh mostly@@melissagreentree4787
@@melissagreentree4787yea and how much does it cost lmao DLC sim world
Atleast BR has working pantograph unlike SCR
Yeah i gotta agree on that one.
BR has harder working Devs
walrus pantograph exists
scr is adding them actually
@@realfrowzscr devs dont „work“
I like both games really much and would never be able to choose between them so i play a lot of both British Railway and Stepford County Railway.
I rlly like SCR, it feels like a game but it’s also somewhat real, definitely not as realistic as other train games out there, but it’s just a good representation of a train simulation game at its finest.
They’re both good in their own ways, but I like BR more due to how easy it is to navigate
This is a fire edit ngl!
Thanks.. need your support for more videos like this 😊
@@Railwaystar_RobloxNo joke the Edit Fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
You can’t really compare the rolling stock and number of stations between SCR and BR. SCR is over 5 years old and BR have just started at the beginning of 2023.
Yes. I very well know that.
But SCR, in its starting, had more rolling stock compared to BR.
@@Railwaystar_Roblox they are low quality and paper trains at the beginning anyway
@@ARandom_Toad if you look in description it started in july 2022
@@Railwaystar_Roblox umm I’m not sure that class 700 is a lot of rolling stock
@@typlays48 and it released in 2023
Well, SCR is better in terms of sheer size of trains and stations, but BR is unbeatable on realism and the sounds produced by trains on points, to me They are both Beautiful, but BR has and small qualities that surpass SCR.
You set off my epilepsy at the beginning of
Dude this edit is actually so good b ro
this is facts, there equally both great games with there owne great points , i love them
Honestly BR have the best graphic and details but i prefer SCR
Edit : Also i dont like when its over detailed on roblox (Except for gore :P)
Should they add in all Electrostars in BR yes or no
Yea for sure.
Maybe one.
Either way, doesn't really matter unless they add more electrification (be it 3rd rail or overhead wires, some trains including a good chunk of the electrostars can do both)
@@Danse_Macabre_125 class 357 should be the first option because it's compatible for both electrification
@@Electrostarboi207 and it'd save the devs time with modelling as it's the only electrostar to be roughly based on the turbostar bodyshell
Well. BR does having a Main Line full of Overhead Wires. Class 387 Electrostars would fit nicely as a Regional train. And when it is 8-12 coaches, we can use them as Semi-Fast Commuters.
BR is gonna take over SCR when they update more.. I pefer BR cuz its more fun and relax for me
I pray they don't
@@realfrowzThey will, BR has a lot more potential.
@@realfrowz Well guess what? They did. As of me writing this, BR has more active players than SCR.
@@beholdfocus4479 so? As of this time there's a 100 player gap which is lousy for a game that had a more recent update
@realfrowz Atleast BR Has
Working Pantagraphs
NPC Passengers
Free guarding
Tilting railways
Interactive cockpit
More liveries
Weather dynamics
Day and night cycle
Working Wipers
Realistic train sounds
Railroad crossing sounds
The buffer will stop your train if you're to fast
Bird and sea sounds at longbow Beach
Realistic graphics
More coins in each drive
BR Has Actual UK Time
Actual train names
BR Has Realistic liveries that Is similar to real life
BR Has cars
Some trains have smoke
Menu is clean
Guards earn more coins
Realistic Braking and acceleration and declaration sounds
Hardworking and productive developers
That's what they have.
Team SCR here
It is also good for development of up but also many darkside view .
The door in Br in my opinios more realistic and better, likez in scr the train just beep beep and close the door with no sounds while close the door, look at BR class 220 is very realistic
The two games are different = the two games are fun
I like being able to walk around in the trains in BR
I never tried BR, I'm gonna compare them as well!
I like SCR SO MUCH ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Its definitely a game to be liked 👍
Agree.
i play BR more often than SCR because of the more accurate liveries despite SCR having the HST
(91 is my favourite train and none got it)
But SCR has diesel locomotives and Fourth Rail's BR has electric ones
Scr being more realistic every month like better detail of breaking is same as BR before the scr had little fast brakes 😊
BR is more fun to play but i like the look of scr more, BR is also rlly good if ur a guard
I think nowadays SCR has far better detail on its trains, it’s just generally the playerlag, train movement physics, camera, and sounds that dissappoint
I love both!
Sigma Opinion 🗿
I hate both, TSW 3 is better. Graphics, realism, selection of trains, has more maps than that one bullshit copy of Britain… Only downside is that DLCs are a bit expensive
@@Abandoned23345 TSW3 sucks because Bad graphics = physics
@@OliverXAlice_fpetsw3 doesn’t have bad graphics or physics
@@rowanmsfsso trains going into buffers at 2 mph getting yeeted is not bad physics😂
In my personal experience, I find SCR easier for beginners and a better option for lower-end devices (maybe)
As for the realism, with the new brakes in v2.0 it definitely is turning slightly more realistic.
I myself struggle with BR, which lags me out completely, and the controls also are hard to master.
However I definitely agree with some people that BR *may* surpass SCR with its high-graphic and realistic trains.
Scr is giving what we expect for roblox. British railway should be a separate game with the detail
Never giving up on SCR.
Honestly I feel like the SCR physics are more realistic as of 2.0
I think SCR overall is slightly better than BR (FOR NOW) Once BR has a Respactable amount of rolling stock, more roles like DS and SG, and more lines to drive it will definitely overtake SCR and any other Roblox train game simply due to how realistic and detailed it is
Yes. This is very true.
This changed
BR is way funner and way better in my opinion
British Railways is good but nothing can surpass the classics
Team British Railway, who's with me?
Также RZDsimulator со 100% физикой поездов 🗿🚬
I personally find SCR too simple and I like the slight challenge of timing when to brake in BR but SCR is still pretty solid, I just prefer BR.
Honestly, even tho GR is growing more than SCR, i still like SCR more even if GR has better graphics because it just feels more OG and its fun
SCR should add superelevation on curves.
Scr would have won if popularity was a option
I think SCR should take the better physics, because br trains sometimes just glitch out uncontrollably.
SCR No doubt because of the controls
Not really a fair comparison stations wise. BR has not been out as long as SCR and will expand over time, just like SCR did. Therefore I would not make that a thing during this video as I don’t see it to be a completely fair comparison. I do agree with all the others tho so well done with that.
Well, I know, but that is one of the most important categories. However, there is always a difference in opinion. Some say quality of stations also mater in number of stations so do the quantity.
Well, I took the quality one in too, so in that case, SCR wins. BR did have more stations than SCR on its release, 19.
@Railwaystar_Roblox you can't compare them BR is focused on a hyperrealistic aspect and it's unfair to compare it to an arcade game. A fairer comparison would be SCR Vs GCR WCR Vs SCR SCR (BEFORE NEXT GEN) Vs MTG
As of 2023 December 31th SCR has a average of 29,250 players while BR has a average of 16,423 players so more people like SCR
scr has been around for longer
@@masonsmainlineroblox I was talking about daily visists
@@masonsmainlineroblox so it doesn't matter
Visit isn't the whole story
@@SouthKoreanSantabut 2023 was the same year BR was released
SCR is still the largest rail network in Roblox, Remember that now!!!
Yes.
BR will pass that probly
Because br is still very new
@@Chrisking1912Well just because the BR network map gets bigger does not mean the population will rise
@@Owen_trains2010it will, just you see
BR is a really detailed game, but everytime I play it I get bored so fast, and I don't know why.
On the other hand, when I play SCR, I could be playing for a lot more without getting bored.
DOn't get me wrong, I like br but I just find SCR more fun (imo)
I love SCR, its the best, like this music
dude
what's this version of After Dark? I wanna know
its cool alr
terminal railways : 🗿🍷
I agree it's a tie
Also AFTER DARK EDIT YES
Also just to say can you do a battle with GCR my personal fav game and Ro scail another good game
Actually I wanna play GCR and experience it again (I forgot it all) but the game doesnt load, which is holding me back from playing and making an edit.
SCR is the best and no one will ever change my mind
I would say for realism BR but I can’t play it on mobile or Xbox, which is why I always play stepford. If stepford actually had AI passengers it would be so much better.
SCR Is better because it’s more fun because it is easier to drive trains
Ikr, I struggle to drive trains in BR
@@Owen_trains2010 yeah
@Brthegoat scr the goat
@Brthegoat **scr
@Brthegoat it’s scr
I personally think SCR has better graphics
💀
you're actually mental
Scr for the trains as in theyve got more however BR for scenery,graphics,sounds,phsics and liverys on the realistic side
SCR: Quantity
British Railway: Quality
yes
I choose quantity
@Brthegoat ok
Quantity
GCR: both
I know Iike both Stepford County Railway & British Railway, but to be honest, British Railway is a bit better because of it's realism, graphics, speed & it's controls.
also will SCR mesh the class 158 already
Do more questions and then one of them with you don't need the whole chat to go crazy
SCR is a memory from the past
BR is the future
Except on SCR you start with a decent Class 357 instead of the PACER that you get on BR
and they have npcs unlike scr
SCR will always be a legend
"unbiased"
also this man adding the "ranking system" category
SCR : this is great
BR : But I like this one
IMO, Scr is just slightly better, but it’s very close.
Think thats because SCR has more stations compared to BR.
@DevMart53 yeah and it’s less laggy on a lower end device but if you have a device that can run them both extremely well, then honestly, idk
SCR and BR are the best train games on Roblox in my opinion
SCR Team
👇
It's like a race betweeb SCR & BR
Smaller games like Dovedale Railway are just underrated
Both its just on br I am always late
SCR is overall better since even users with a potato laptop can play unlike in BR
Skill issue
@@Via_SCV-42 that has nothing to do with skill its about the computer
@@FoxyPirate39 I play on my phone o get around 40-60 fps
@@Via_SCV-42 then your phone has the things it needs to run smoothly not everyone can afford things like that
@@FoxyPirate39 oh well
Okay okay, no need for the dramatic effects lol 😂 but I really like BR better
U SUCK
Part-2: th-cam.com/users/shortszZtBc3RV7Ag?feature=share
Edit: Please stop fighting whether SCR is better or BR. We all have our own opinions and everyone would have a different one. So in the end both the games are the best for that kind of audience.
Which Editor You Used
Bro Roblox train games' communities having more beef then all of Roblox
Train games unite!
I feel like br is a more serious and realistic version of scr, which makes it far less fun and enjoyable
maybe if you don't care about realism it's less fun
@@Rowan66109 nah but also british railway has way less to offer, in scr you cna be a dispatcher, guard, signaller etc.
Personally, i would prefer SCR becouse of the variety of trains, better routes, announcements and companies. Becouse they all have different routes and onboard Announcements unlike BR, but I have been playing BR more becouse of the realistic style and Simply becouse SCR doesn’t update that much now.
British railway
I'll complete the sentence for you, British Railway Sucks
You forgot the word “sucks” poojayadav-ni6vx.
@@PreHistoricMic it’s there opinion
@@soundwavethedecepticon-z3qHave u ever learned ur homophones at school bruh it’s their not there lol
SCR made a comeback For a Tie lol
imo, Ro-scale Northeast Corridor clears both😊
SCR is the best, been playing since 2/2/21
its not about the stations man its about detail tbh quality over quantity
YESSSS AFTER DARKKK
The song is just 🔥
ranking system is just a free point to scr...
Now scr train physics are a little better
Song ?
Mr.Kitty-After Dark
Thank you
SCR
SCR 👊
Both are good❤
i disagree, BR has way better graphics, attention to detail and physics, br has a smaller team aswell as a huge focus on detail. scr has completely destroyed its map eith turning the best stations into shit, leighton city and coxly were incredible a long time ago, but now they are dead as hell, i remember spawning at coxly depot and then using the track eith a huge turn and small scenery to get onto there, truly peak, butvscr has destroyed that, the BR team are working hard to supply us with new content.
@@DelinquentRevengeBR has like a lot of skill issue and a smaller map, Plus SCR has even updated more mesh trains to take away BR players so beat that :)
@@Owen_trains2010 BR has a significantly more detailed map, more attention to detail, more realistic models, more livery variety, speed limit warnings, clean door animations, almost perfect train physics, despite having a smaller map it has way more detail and WAY more skill requirements than SCR, also no pointless training that is super overhhped and strict. beat that :).
Br should have and scr 4 because br for me is soooooooooooo laggy
the hsts approaching in terminals scr is pretty unrealistic
Wait, when did HSTs start approaching terminals??
Lol
Scr haves good graphics and ranked system
SCR is better than br but BR has better 3rd person cam
But scr could lead to the best train game on Roblox
You gave SCR a better rating for rolling stock than BR?
1. SCR trains are paper and barely mesh
2. SCR trains are nowhere near as detailed
Fr
Half of the trains doesnr even look like real trains
U two officially didn’t know the rest of the trains would be meshed and upgraded in V2.0, So u won’t be really crying about it for long 😂
SCR is better than BR ❤I love SCR❤
Yes
Or they are both equally good in their own reasons and fan-boys need to stop hating on perfectly good game.
@BrthegoatIf not for Stepford County Railway That and British Railway
@Niewiem471kid, I know you can’t realise right now but nothing is better than classics. Br just copied off scr.
@K0rp0lity U most likely to be introuble by the police
BR is mental. Way better than SCR
its like a kyiv star review
;]
SCR IS JUST BETTER😊
it's more easy to control train in SCR and BR is laggy
What is BR (what is it called
British railways