The list is long...the singing legends from south India starting from Ghantasala, PB Srinivas, Yesudas, SP Balasubramanyam, Jayachandran all fall short of words when they describe who Rafi saab is to them. Jayachandran sir said " Kaanon me amrit ka dhaara"
@@parthamp4751PB Srinivas admired Ghantasala much more than Rafi. Yesudas also admired and respected Ghantasala a lot. Music maestro Ilayaraja is a great admirer of Ghantasala, more than any other singer. SPB not only was a great admirer and lover of Ghantasala, but also conducted a very popular and successful TV programme, ' Paadutha teeyagaa ' ( title of a popular song of Ghantasala ) for years. Once Rafi himself praised Ghantasala and said, of course, out of his clean heart, that he could not sing at Ghantasala's level. Sadly, the first Padmasree awardee for a filmy singer, Ghantasala was not known to many because of his being regional. Mannaday might not have listened to him with attention. Of course, many fellow singers praise their peers ' great skill. But, blind fans didn't mention about how Rafi praised his fellow singers, out of fear that it would downgrade Rafi's greatness.
As a Mohd Rafi fan we all love Manna da n Mahendra kapoor ji because they always had immense respect for rafi sahab inspite of them both being so gifted themselves
मन्ना दा की विनम्रता को नमन करता हूं। रफ़ी साहब ने ख़ुद एक बार कहा था कि दुनिया उनको सुनती है लेकिन वो मन्ना दा को सुनते हैं। दूसरी तरफ मन्ना दा रही साहब को सर्वश्रेष्ठ बता रहे हैं। ये है महानता।
But idiots nowadays don't mention this due to fear that it would lessen the level of Rafi. Indeed, Rafi used to praise other singers and once, had greatly admired Ghantasala's singing, saying that it would be hard for him to sing that level.
@@muhammadhamzaashraf2011: Don't talk Stupid Idiotic Rubbish Nonsense like this❤😂 Rafi Sahab has said in an Interview "People always listen to my Songs! But I listen mostly to Manna Dey Sahab Songs." This is an absolute Truth, whether you accept it or not❤❤🎉😂 But one thing, he will never give answer to the question "Who is your favourite Singer???" if ever anybody ask him that question, because, he never wanted to hurt anybody❤🎉😂😂🎉❤
The Greatest legendary blockbuster versatile veteran evergreen Play back singers, Mohammad Rafi ji, Kishore Kumar ji, Lata Mangeshkar ji, Asha Bhosle ji, Manna Dey ji, Mukesh ji, Hemant Kumar ji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭🥰
Rafi sahab ko mera Salam Namashkar Sat Sat Naman Allah Hafiz hai Rafi sahab aap ne kitna sunder gaya hai Aap ne ji Salam Aadab Namashkar ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Manna Dey is too gentle and too large hearted as was RAFI SAHAB. What he is not conscious of is that he himself is the legend of legends in Indian film music and one of the finest and greatest singers of all ages.
I am also a good singer and I can understand the level of singing. In my opinion I firmly believe that Manna Dey sir is the second best singer of the history of Indian cinema after the greatest Rafi sahab.
@@NeilB803True. But, if i am compelled to say about only one with most supremacy of all fields of filmy music, i pick only Ghantasala, not any other Indian singer. Our forefathers were not partial in selecting and awarding him Padmasree, the first of such kind given to any movie singer when Rafi, Mukesh, Manna etc were already became famous. Of course, he and Rafi were great admirers of each other.
Manna Dey Sahab was better classical Singer than Rafi Sahab , how much humble person was Manna Dey Sahab. I have not seen Classical trained Singer praising like that. And what we can Say for Rafi Sahab, he is like God to every Singer. Lots of respect to both the Legends. I loved the Innocence of Sonu Nigam also.
The Greatest legendary Blockbuster versatile veteran evergreen super play back singers , Mohammad Rafi ji , Kishore Kumar ji , Mukesh ji , Lata Mangeshkar ji , Asha bhosle, Manna Dey ji 🥰🥰😘😘🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭
Both were great , both used to appreciate each other . / Once manna Dey ji was singing on stage , He saw that Rafi sahab is sitting in front as listner , manna dey ji inveted Rafi sahab on stage . Then Rafi spoke on mike "dear music lovers , you listen my songs while i listen manna dey ji ' s songs . !"
Manna Dey sahab ,one of the best and most talented singers of India deserve all the praise yourself too for sharing with us anecdotes of Rafi sahab ,kudos to you too Sir !
Greatness of Manna Dey Daheb- the legendary king of Indian Classical music- who has made impartial assessment of another legendary king of melody late Rafi Saheb's performance and unique contribution in playback singing. Manna Dey ji were truly dedicated to attain perfection in classical songs. None can surpass him. His utter politeness and simplicity will always be remembered.
I beg to differ with you politely saying that Mannadey was of course a classical master, but Hindi is not the only recognised language of India to make him the greatest of Indian filmy classical songs. Ghantasala of Thelugu film industry stands first to get that credit. He was a great music director too, who composed music for 112 movies and many private songs including Bhagavathgeetha. Pl listen to this great song which must have highly impressed Sankar Jaikishan to compose similar tune for Mannadey for song, " jhanak jhanak tore baaje... ", some 7-8 years later. th-cam.com/video/RRZxCNNr-RQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Y3RCr49tejgHFcai
Respect Sonu Nigam ... Because he is the living legend which we have ...I am 21 years old ..and I know In future , there will be a time when Sonu Nigam will be not there with us.
Aaj ke daur me log ek dusre ki burai karke thak te nhi..waqai me pehle ke nek dil the..woh ache kalakar ke saath ek ache insan bhi the..love u manna Dey sahab❤❤
Ek sher hi doosre sher ko pehchaan sakta hai!! Varna aise bahut se choohey mil jayenge jo khud ko sher samajh lete hain! Baaki aap log khud samajhdaar ho
Manna Dey ke video aya to sab unke fan ban gya but kabhi inka yaad Hume nahi ata, kabhi India ke top 10 singers me Inka nam nahi ata hein , kisike video me, Lata Mangeshkar ji ne ek sahi baat boli thi unke nidhan ke bad, Lata ji ne boli ki , Manna Dey ko Jo sanman milna chaiye tha wo une nahi mila, yehi sacchai hein
Dey ki talent ko toh filmy jagath ne poori our achhi tarah se upyog nahi kiya. Khas karke jab unn ka awaz bahut behtareen thha 1950-60 me, bahut kum chances miley unko.
Not exceptional. That adjective shd be applied to KL Sigal first, as far as Hindi movie singers are concerned. For the whole India, it was Ghantasala who gets that credit, may not be first but, more than any other filmy singers. As far as Hindi songs are concerned, i love and admire Mukesh more than any other. For the whole Indian filmy songs, it would be Ghantasala, more than any other for me.
Yahi to antar hi warna kon kahta old is gold aakh num ho gai manna daa jo virasat aap chod gaye ab use taar taar kiya ja raha hi gujarish hi kuda se in sabhi logo ko ek baar bharat ko gulistan banane ke liye is jamin pr bhej de
I really can't understand these things.I love Manna dey's songs immensely and don't like Rafi. But still the world and Manna dey consider Rafi as great.
People may enjoy other singers more or even like them more but anyone who says he or she doesn’t like Rafi has no sense of music. Manna Da has shown the mirror to such people
Abe chutiye how can Kishore Kumar, Manna Dey and SPB be on rank 2nd ? 😂 Kuch bhi matlab. You're knowledge of music is next to 0. 1:- Rafi & Kishore 2:- Lata,Asha & Mukesh 3:- Manna Dey, Arijit Singh, Sonu Nigam, SPB. 4:- Abhijeet, Kumar Sanu,
@@kanishkgulwadi9245 Bhai...Rafi sahab ne kaha tha..sab log mujhko sunthe hai.lekin Mai manna da ko suntha hu🙏tho.rafi ,mukhesh,mannadey,kishor da ,Lata ji,asha ji will be at first row.they are legends .
Manna de was a useless person and average singer . He was very jealous of kishore kumar incredible voice plus his true success. That's why always he praised rafi not kishore .
The Greatest legendary Blockbuster versatile veteran evergreen super play back singers , Mohammad Rafi ji , Kishore Kumar ji , Mukesh ji , Lata Mangeshkar ji , Asha bhosle, Manna Dey ji 🥰🥰😘😘🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭
Ek mahan kalakar hi dusre mahan kalakar ki itni izzat kar sakta hai..manna dey hats of to you...
Ye asha bhosle ko samjhna chaiye
The list is long...the singing legends from south India starting from Ghantasala, PB Srinivas, Yesudas, SP Balasubramanyam, Jayachandran all fall short of words when they describe who Rafi saab is to them. Jayachandran sir said " Kaanon me amrit ka dhaara"
Right
*Right*
@@parthamp4751PB Srinivas admired Ghantasala much more than Rafi. Yesudas also admired and respected Ghantasala a lot. Music maestro Ilayaraja is a great admirer of Ghantasala, more than any other singer. SPB not only was a great admirer and lover of Ghantasala, but also conducted a very popular and successful TV programme, ' Paadutha teeyagaa ' ( title of a popular song of Ghantasala ) for years. Once Rafi himself praised Ghantasala and said, of course, out of his clean heart, that he could not sing at Ghantasala's level. Sadly, the first Padmasree awardee for a filmy singer, Ghantasala was not known to many because of his being regional. Mannaday might not have listened to him with attention. Of course, many fellow singers praise their peers ' great skill. But, blind fans didn't mention about how Rafi praised his fellow singers, out of fear that it would downgrade Rafi's greatness.
As a Mohd Rafi fan we all love Manna da n Mahendra kapoor ji because they always had immense respect for rafi sahab inspite of them both being so gifted themselves
I'm of yours too, What an energy level you've got while singing famous in Starmaker👌👌👏👏@iffypatel
Rafi Sahab❤️🙏🏻Manna Da❤️🙏🏻
Sign of a TRUE AND GREAT ARTISTE. One ĹEGEND talking about another LEGEND. Hat's off to both the GEMS OF OUR MUSIC INDUSTRY.
Yes
THANK YIU SANJEEV DIXITJI🙂
मन्ना दा की विनम्रता को नमन करता हूं। रफ़ी साहब ने ख़ुद एक बार कहा था कि दुनिया उनको सुनती है लेकिन वो मन्ना दा को सुनते हैं। दूसरी तरफ मन्ना दा रही साहब को सर्वश्रेष्ठ बता रहे हैं। ये है महानता।
But idiots nowadays don't mention this due to fear that it would lessen the level of Rafi. Indeed, Rafi used to praise other singers and once, had greatly admired Ghantasala's singing, saying that it would be hard for him to sing that level.
Rafi sahab once said in an interview "people listen to my songs but I listen to manna da songs"
He never said that
@@muhammadhamzaashraf2011Yes, he just used to receive others ' praises but never praised any other. Right ?
Rafi sahab said that, i have seen one interview
@@muhammadhamzaashraf2011: Don't talk Stupid Idiotic Rubbish Nonsense like this❤😂 Rafi Sahab has said in an Interview "People always listen to my Songs! But I listen mostly to Manna Dey Sahab Songs." This is an absolute Truth, whether you accept it or not❤❤🎉😂 But one thing, he will never give answer to the question "Who is your favourite Singer???" if ever anybody ask him that question, because, he never wanted to hurt anybody❤🎉😂😂🎉❤
100% Correct
One legend speaking about another legend to another legend....What a legendary moment....
Manna was a real deal !
He was the king of classical music.
The Greatest legendary blockbuster versatile veteran evergreen Play back singers, Mohammad Rafi ji, Kishore Kumar ji, Lata Mangeshkar ji, Asha Bhosle ji, Manna Dey ji, Mukesh ji, Hemant Kumar ji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭🥰
ये मन्ना दा की महानता ही है कैसे बच्चों की तरह रफी साब की तारीफ कर रहे। मेरे तो आँसू ही नही रुक रहे। कितने प्यारे लोग थे ये लोग !
Swar Samrat ko Shat Shat Naman Duniya ki Sabse khoobsurat Awaz Suro ke Shenshah Awaz ke Jadugar Voice of God Jai Jai Mohammed Rafi Sahab
Rafi sahab ko mera Salam Namashkar Sat Sat Naman Allah Hafiz hai Rafi sahab aap ne kitna sunder gaya hai Aap ne ji Salam Aadab Namashkar ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Manna Dey is too gentle and too large hearted as was RAFI SAHAB. What he is not conscious of is that he himself is the legend of legends in Indian film music and one of the finest and greatest singers of all ages.
I am also a good singer and I can understand the level of singing. In my opinion I firmly believe that Manna Dey sir is the second best singer of the history of Indian cinema after the greatest Rafi sahab.
@@faiyazkhan1113 singers can't be ranked 1st or 2nd like that. Manna Dey sahab was a unique singer. He's extremely versatile and was second to none.
@@NeilB803True. But, if i am compelled to say about only one with most supremacy of all fields of filmy music, i pick only Ghantasala, not any other Indian singer. Our forefathers were not partial in selecting and awarding him Padmasree, the first of such kind given to any movie singer when Rafi, Mukesh, Manna etc were already became famous. Of course, he and Rafi were great admirers of each other.
Rafi Sahab was a divine personality..❤❤❤❤❤
Manna Dey Sahab was better classical Singer than Rafi Sahab , how much humble person was Manna Dey Sahab. I have not seen Classical trained Singer praising like that.
And what we can Say for Rafi Sahab, he is like God to every Singer.
Lots of respect to both the Legends.
I loved the Innocence of Sonu Nigam also.
Nobody's better than Rafi.
@@100AurangzebTrue that. Rafi is and will stay no.1.
@@100Aurangzeb तु कटुआ है।रफ़ी साहब भी मुस्लमान थे।तुझे कैसे ये बात हज़म हो सकती है अगर कोई बोल दें मन्ना दा रफ़ी साहब से बेहतर क्लासिकल सिंगर थे 😂
Listen to manna dey's laga chunari mein daag@@100Aurangzeb
@@100Aurangzeb he said, in classical. Even Rafi sahab would agree. I hope you know about Manna dey's background.
Jai Rafi sahab
Great manna da u r very honest person.
Manna Dey ji is soft heart personality.
We lost all the old Gems only their memory remains.
Jai Rafi Sahab
बडे दिल व खुले दिमाग वाले मन्ना डे साहब का मैं फैन हूं।
Nahi. Main hamesha Rafi saahab ko saamne rakhkar gaati hun. Jitna mujhse bane. Zyada seekhi nahi hun, but RafivSaahab is my God of music ❤️
مناجی ہم آپکو سلام کرتے ہیں آپ ایک مہمان کلاکار ہیں
Manna da salut hai apko rafi sab apko duwa de ap ke Jai sa koi nahi dost aur naushad sab
The Greatest legendary Blockbuster versatile veteran evergreen super play back singers , Mohammad Rafi ji , Kishore Kumar ji , Mukesh ji , Lata Mangeshkar ji , Asha bhosle, Manna Dey ji 🥰🥰😘😘🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭
And Ghantasala stands first among them all, with his classical mastery.
th-cam.com/video/RRZxCNNr-RQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Y3RCr49tejgHFcai
Rafi da 🌹🙏❤️ Maata Saraswati ji ka manas putra 🎉❤
Manna Dey legend
Both were great , both used to appreciate each other . / Once manna Dey ji was singing on stage , He saw that Rafi sahab is sitting in front as listner , manna dey ji inveted Rafi sahab on stage . Then Rafi spoke on mike "dear music lovers , you listen my songs while i listen manna dey ji ' s songs . !"
Manna Dey sahab ,one of the best and most talented singers of India deserve all the praise yourself too for sharing with us anecdotes of Rafi sahab ,kudos to you too Sir !
Rafi Sahab ❤️
Legends🙏❤️
Bhai her jagah aap 😂
@@shreyash3127 sonu ji is the reason🤭
The legend of sonu nigam ji❤
Two legends....
😘😘😘👏👏
Very nice Manna Da
Mana dey ji says jo meharbani Rafi sahab pe thi Allah ki woh hum pe nahi hai.... This is not badapan but the truth. Rafi sahab was only of his kind.
Greatness of Manna Dey Daheb- the legendary king of Indian Classical music- who has made impartial assessment of another legendary king of melody late Rafi Saheb's performance and unique contribution in playback singing. Manna Dey ji were truly dedicated to attain perfection in classical songs. None can surpass him. His utter politeness and simplicity will always be remembered.
I beg to differ with you politely saying that Mannadey was of course a classical master, but Hindi is not the only recognised language of India to make him the greatest of Indian filmy classical songs. Ghantasala of Thelugu film industry stands first to get that credit. He was a great music director too, who composed music for 112 movies and many private songs including Bhagavathgeetha. Pl listen to this great song which must have highly impressed Sankar Jaikishan to compose similar tune for Mannadey for song, " jhanak jhanak tore baaje... ", some 7-8 years later.
th-cam.com/video/RRZxCNNr-RQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Y3RCr49tejgHFcai
Sach mein Rafi Sab par uss uparwale Ka Karam tha.
Respect Sonu Nigam ... Because he is the living legend which we have ...I am 21 years old ..and I know In future , there will be a time when Sonu Nigam will be not there with us.
That’s a stupid comment
Wah dada manna day sahab acche Singer acche singer ki taarif karte miss u Rafi sahab ese omda Singer miss u Rafi sahab
Mannade is great wo Rafi saheb ki kader jante hai
मन्ना डे भी देश के महान कलाकारो मे से है लेकिन कितने विनम्र, एक महान कलाकार ही दुसरे महान कलाकार की सही तारीफ कर सकता है
These were great people who spoke what they felt...
I always have tears looking such the most humble pesonality. I wish I would be surronded with such people!!
Manna Dey himself is a legend, so humble man
Aaj ke daur me log ek dusre ki burai karke thak te nhi..waqai me pehle ke nek dil the..woh ache kalakar ke saath ek ache insan bhi the..love u manna Dey sahab❤❤
MD Saheb aap par humko naaz hai.
This logo of zee tv bring tear in my eyes
दोनों बडें महान बडें दिलवालें।
कितना बड़पन्न है
ज़िन्दाबाद मन्ना डे जी🎉 😌🙏
we feel so proud to hear that one legend praises another legend of our country
Very good work and legend talk about Muhammad Rafi and manna dey
Kya baat hai rafi sahb ki.
Rafi sahab mahan the aur unki badai karne Wale Manna Dey jee bhi bahut mahan hain aur sada rahenge.
Ek sher hi doosre sher ko pehchaan sakta hai!! Varna aise bahut se choohey mil jayenge jo khud ko sher samajh lete hain! Baaki aap log khud samajhdaar ho
Manna dey ❤❤❤❤ Rafi sahab ❤❤❤
Classical me mannada koi jawab nahi aur versatility me rafi sahab ka jawab nahi
Job log Rafi sahab ko kishore kumar se compare karte hain unhe yeh video jarur dekhni chahiye
Great singers both ..
Great respects for Manna Da for his so candid appreciations of another great rather greatest singing legend…
Super Tribute For Legend By Legend
So was you manna da 🎉
Rafi Sahab the legend🎉❤
2nd Rafi Sahab - Sonu Nigam ❤
Female male singarme rafi hi sabse sundar the. Female me arati mukharji masta.
🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌 to legends
NYC ♥️
Mana day great singer
❤
❤🙏🏻❤
What a guy!
Aurat log lata mangeshkar ko saamne rakhkar gaate hain....aur mard log Rafi sb ko saamne rakh kar gaate hain....this is a 100% fact
Manna Dey ke video aya to sab unke fan ban gya but kabhi inka yaad Hume nahi ata, kabhi India ke top 10 singers me Inka nam nahi ata hein , kisike video me, Lata Mangeshkar ji ne ek sahi baat boli thi unke nidhan ke bad, Lata ji ne boli ki , Manna Dey ko Jo sanman milna chaiye tha wo une nahi mila, yehi sacchai hein
Dey ki talent ko toh filmy jagath ne poori our achhi tarah se upyog nahi kiya. Khas karke jab unn ka awaz bahut behtareen thha 1950-60 me, bahut kum chances miley unko.
@@ckamalakanth9532 sahi baat hein, or unke awaj me kuch alagi mithas tha, khas karke classical music me wo magic tha awaj mein
All Time No.1 Kishore kumar
Kya maast joke maara hai , koun sa sata naasha karta hai.
Mukesh was a much better playback singer than Manna Dey. Manna Dey was a exceptional classical singer with a ordinary voice.
Not exceptional. That adjective shd be applied to KL Sigal first, as far as Hindi movie singers are concerned. For the whole India, it was Ghantasala who gets that credit, may not be first but, more than any other filmy singers. As far as Hindi songs are concerned, i love and admire Mukesh more than any other. For the whole Indian filmy songs, it would be Ghantasala, more than any other for me.
Yahi to antar hi warna kon kahta old is gold aakh num ho gai manna daa jo virasat aap chod gaye ab use taar taar kiya ja raha hi gujarish hi kuda se in sabhi logo ko ek baar bharat ko gulistan banane ke liye is jamin pr bhej de
Pahle ke logon me ghamad nahi hota tha doosre ki ijjat karte the
I really can't understand these things.I love Manna dey's songs immensely and don't like Rafi.
But still the world and Manna dey consider Rafi as great.
You do not like rafi saheb?
Are Bhai simple h comparison nhi ho sakta both r great and given immense to us
People may enjoy other singers more or even like them more but anyone who says he or she doesn’t like Rafi has no sense of music. Manna Da has shown the mirror to such people
@@amitabhmaheshwari My don't like list is long:some names:
Latha.M.
Alka Yagnik
Kishor Kumar
Arijit
Chayya Chayya singer
Etc.
The worst among the above list is Alka Yagnik.I really wonder how she could get so much of work in Bollywood (which is always very selective)
sonu nigam
Singing wise Ranking as per me.
Rank 1 : Mohd Rafi
Rank 2 : Kishore/Manna/Lata/SPB/Sukhwinder
Rank 3 : Sonu/Hariharan/Suresh/Arijit/Javed Ali/Kailash Kher/Richa/Kavita/
Rank 4 : Udit/Kumar Sanu/Shreya/Alka/Sunidhi/Mohd Aziz/Mahendra/Mohit/
Rank 5 : Asha/Mukesh/Neha Kakkar/Abhijeet/KK /Shaan/Chitra
Rank 6 : Arman/Mika/AR Rehman/Himesh/
Sorry in advance if i hurt anyone
Asha ji and Chithra ji is rank 5 with neha kakkar 😒😒😒
Sorry sir..so many people won't accept.but ok this is your opinion
Neha kakkar with great chitra mam, asha ji in rank 5?
Go and consult a psychologist bro
Abe chutiye how can Kishore Kumar, Manna Dey and SPB be on rank 2nd ? 😂 Kuch bhi matlab.
You're knowledge of music is next to 0.
1:- Rafi & Kishore
2:- Lata,Asha & Mukesh
3:- Manna Dey, Arijit Singh, Sonu Nigam, SPB.
4:- Abhijeet, Kumar Sanu,
@@kanishkgulwadi9245 Bhai...Rafi sahab ne kaha tha..sab log mujhko sunthe hai.lekin Mai manna da ko suntha hu🙏tho.rafi ,mukhesh,mannadey,kishor da ,Lata ji,asha ji will be at first row.they are legends .
Kishoreda se badhakar koi ho hi nahi sakta he..
dada mt bol Sonu Nigam
Manna de was a useless person and average singer . He was very jealous of kishore kumar incredible voice plus his true success. That's why always he praised rafi not kishore .
You don't know music ...
2WereGreatSingersOfB.WoodW-ithRafiSahibNr.1*
The Greatest legendary Blockbuster versatile veteran evergreen super play back singers , Mohammad Rafi ji , Kishore Kumar ji , Mukesh ji , Lata Mangeshkar ji , Asha bhosle, Manna Dey ji 🥰🥰😘😘🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭
❤